Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-hvd4g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-12T23:54:42.979Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Jacobin Phrenzy: Federalism and the Menace of Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 August 2009

Marshall Smelser
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

During the first years of the American federal republic, Europe was being overrun by French revolutionary forces and ideas. Nation after nation had fallen to the revolutionaries–first weakened by propaganda and subversive organizations, then subdued by soldiery, finally converted into subordinate allies. Watching these successes, some Americans feared that the Atlantic was too narrow to keep revolutionary arms and ideology away. Indeed, the ideology seemed already to permeate the country.

American relations with the successful French nation had become tense and strained shortly after France and Britain went to war in 1793. Many people thought the country had been needlessly endangered by mismanagement of our foreign relations in such a way as to antagonize an otherwise friendly French government. Others thought the United States had been imperilled by too great a toleration of pro-French and revolutionary elements among us, who concealed diabolical designs against American security underneath their very vocal admiration for liberty, equality, and fraternity.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Review of Politics , Volume 13 , Issue 4 , October 1951 , pp. 457 - 482
Copyright
Copyright © University of Notre Dame 1951

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Bassett, J.S., The Federalist System, 1789–1801 (N. Y., 1906), 42–43. Hereafter: Bassett.Google Scholar

2 Brant, Irving, James Madison, Father of the Constitution (Indianapolis, 1950), 299. Hereafter: Brant, JMFC.Google Scholar

3 Ibid.

4 Adams, J. Q., Writings of John Quincy Adams, 7v., ed. Ford, W. C. (N. Y., 1913–1917), I, 110n. Hereafter: JQA, Writings.Google Scholar

5 Ames, Fisher to Gore, Christopher, Ames, F., The Works of Fisher Ames, 2v., ed. Ames, Seth (Boston, 1854), I, 161. Hereafter: Ames, WorksGoogle Scholar.

6 Morison, Samuel Eliot, Life and letters of Harrison Gray Otis, Federalist, 1765–1848, 2v. (Boston, 1913), I, 51. Hereafter: Morison, HGO.Google Scholar

7 Charming, Edward, History of the United States, 6v. (New York, 1932–1936), IV, 175. Hereafter: Charming.Google Scholar

8 Link, Eugene Perry, Democratic-Republican Societies, 1790–1800 (N. Y., 1942), 196. Hereafter: Link.Google Scholar

9 Channing, IV, 174n.Google Scholar

10 Quotes are from Link, 194–196.

11 Suggested by a reading of Link, 122–123.

12 Mott, Frank Luther, Jefferson and the Press (Baton Rouge, 1943), 15, quoting issue of 04 27, 1791.Google Scholar

13 Washington, George, The Writings of George Washington, 39v., ed. Fitzpatrick, J. C. (Washington, vols. XXX–XXXVII, 1939–1940), XXXII, 132–134, Washington, G. to Hamilton, A., 26 08 1792. Hereafter: GW, WritingsGoogle Scholar.

14 Washington, to Mercer, John Francis, 26 09 1792, GW, Writings, XXXII, 165.Google Scholar

15 Ames, Fisher to Gore, Christopher, 10 01 1795, Ames, , Works, I, 161–162.Google Scholar

16 Chase, Samuel to McHenry, James 4 12 1796, Steiner, B. C., The Life and Correspondence of James McHenry (Cleveland, 1907), 203. Hereafter: Steiner, McHenryGoogle Scholar.

17 In order, all from GW, , Writings, XXXV, year 1796Google Scholar: to Knox, , 4 April, p. 13Google Scholar; to Jay, , 8 May, p. 37Google Scholar; to Hamilton, , 26 June, p. 103Google Scholar; to Jefferson, , 6 July, p. 120Google Scholar; to Wolcott, , 6 July, p. 126Google Scholar; to Pickering, , 18 July, p. 144Google Scholar; to Pickering, , 10 August, p. 174.Google Scholar

18 Packard, H., Federal Republicanism, Displayed in two Discourses (Boston, 1799)Google Scholar, quoted by Link, 59.

19 Mott, , op. cit., 51–52.Google Scholar

20 Bassett, , 256–257.Google Scholar

21 Cobbett, William, Letters from William Cobbett to Edward Thornton, … 1797 to 1800, ed. Cole, G. D. H. (N. Y., 1937), 68, and xxviii.Google Scholar

22 McRee, G. J., Life and Correspondence of James Iredell, 2v. (N. Y., 1949), II, 551.Google Scholar

23 Ibid., II, 510–513.

24 JQA, Writings, I, 486.Google Scholar

25 JQA to Adams, Abigail, 9 Jan. 1798Google Scholar, ibid., II, 234.

26 Benét, S. V., “Listen to the People,” The Stephen Vincent Benét Pocketbook (N. Y., 1946), 374.Google Scholar

27 Link, 19–20, 175–186.Google Scholar

28 Link, 86–90Google Scholar; Morison, S. E. and Commager, H. S., The Growth of the American Republic, 2v., 3d ed. (N. Y., 1942), I, 376.Google Scholar

29 Bassett, , 105–106.Google Scholar

30 Brant, , JMFC, 415–416.Google Scholar

31 Brant, , JMFC, 417.Google Scholar

32 Brant, , JMFC, 416.Google Scholar

33 Brant, , JMFC, 417.Google Scholar

34 Brant, , JMFC, 418–419.Google Scholar

35 Brant, , JMFC, 419.Google Scholar

36 Beveridge, Albert, Life of John Marshall, 4v. (N. Y., 1916–1919), II, 515n.Google Scholar

37 Adams, John, Correspondence between the Hon. John Adams … and the late Wm. Cunningham, Esq. (Boston, 1823), 81.Google Scholar

38 Channing, IV, 65n.Google Scholar

39 Link, 175.Google Scholar

40 Link, 186–200.Google Scholar

41 Adams, Abigail to Warren, Mercy, 5 10 1799, Warren-Adams Letters, 2v. (Boson, 1917–1925), IIGoogle Scholar. (Massachusetts Hist. Soc. Coll., LXXII–LXXIII.), 341.Google Scholar

42 GW, to Rev. Snyder, G. W., 24 10 1798, GW, , Writings, XXXVI, 518–519.Google Scholar

43 JQA, Writings, I, 285–287, 331–333.Google Scholar

44 Morison, , HGO, I, 108.Google Scholar

45 Brant, , JMFC, 249.Google Scholar

46 Brant, , JMFC, 371.Google Scholar

47 Link, 125–130.

48 Adams, J. Q. to Adams, J., 2 March 1794Google Scholar, JQA, Writings, I, 180.Google Scholar

49 Suggested by a reading of Link, 133–144.

50 Link, 12n.Google Scholar

51 Moreau de St. Méry's American Journey, tr. and ed. K., and Roberts, A. M. (N. Y., 1947), 125.Google Scholar

52 Channing, IV, 220.Google Scholar

53 Brant, Irving, “Edmund Randolph, not guilty!” William and Mary Quarterly, 3d series, VII (04, 1950), 180–198.Google Scholar

54 Ames, Fisher to Dwight, Thomas, 22 09 1795, Ames, , Works, I, 176.Google Scholar

55 GW, , Writings, XXXV, 123n.–124n.Google Scholar

56 Adams, J. Q. to Adams, J., JQA, Writings, II, 157.Google Scholar

57 GW, , Writings, XXXVI, 206, 218, for examples.Google Scholar

58 Pinckney, C. C. to Pickering, T., Pickering, Timothy, Review of the Correspondence between the Hon. John Adams … and the late Wm. Cunningham, Esq. (Salem 1824) 113.Google Scholar

59 Morison, , HGO, I, 70–71.Google Scholar

60 Murray, William Vans to Adams, J. Q., JQA, Writings, II, 193n.–194n.Google Scholar

61 “Farewell Address,” GW, , Writings, XXXV, 214–238.Google Scholar

62 Channing, IV, 186n.Google Scholar

63 Channing, IV, 189.Google Scholar

64 Bailey, Thomas A., A Diplomatic History of the American People, 2d ed. (N. Y., 1942), 91–92, 92n.Google Scholar

65 Channing, IV, 189.Google Scholar

66 Beveridge, , op. cit., II, 339n.Google Scholar

67 Adams, J. Q. to Murray, W. V., 7 06 1798, JQA, Writings, II, 300.Google Scholar

68 Murray to J. Q. Adams, ibid., II, 277n.

69 Adams, Abigail to Warren, Mercy, 25 April 1797, Warren-Adams Letters, 337.Google Scholar

70 Morison, , HGO, I, 110–111.Google Scholar

71 Adams, J. Q. to Murray, W. V., 3 07 1798, JQA, Writings, II, 328, 328n., 330–331, 331n.Google Scholar

72 Dwight, Timothy, The Duty of Americans at the Present Crisis, July 4, 1798 (N. Y., 1798)Google Scholar, substantially reprinted in Thorp, W., Curti, M., Baker, C., American Issues, 2v. (Phila., 1944), I, 358–363.Google Scholar

73 Ames, Fisher to Pickering, Timothy, 4 June 1798Google Scholar, Ames, , Works, I, 226–228.Google Scholar

74 Easily available in Commager, H. S., Documents of American History, 4th ed. 2v. in 1, (N. Y., 1948), docs. no. 101 (1–2–3–4).Google Scholar

75 Suggested by a reading of Link, 44–45, 47.Google Scholar

76 Suggested by a reading of Channing, IV, 190.Google Scholar

77 Channing, IV, 235–237, 235n.Google Scholar