Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T16:50:35.055Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Simon and Eden at the Foreign Office, 1931–1935

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 October 2009

David Dutton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

This is according to Protocol. More briefly ‘Dear Anthony meet me at Geneva. Yrs. Cleopatra’

Very few of the figures who held responsibility for the making and direction of British foreign policy in the 1930s did so with much benefit to their subsequent historical reputations. Three of the four men who occupied the post of Foreign Secretary after the General Election of 1931 appeared in the cast list of the ‘Guilty Men’, vilified by the triumvirate of left-wing journalists who wrote under the pseudonym of ‘Cato’ in the dramatic summer of 1940. That vilification has been only partially redeemed by the efforts of later revisionist biographers. Certainly, Sir John Simon, Sir Samuel Hoare and Lord Halifax all left the Foreign Office with their political reputations lower in the public mind than at the time of taking office. The exception to this experience was, of course, the case of Anthony Eden who, at the time of his resignation in February 1938 after more than six years as a member of the National Government, stood, in Churchill's famous words, as the ‘one strong young figure standing up against long, dismal, drawling tides of drift and surrender’. The making of his reputation had begun in the early 1930s when Eden occupied only subordinate office within the administration. Yet an examination of the making of British foreign policy in the years 1931–5 will show that popular perceptions of Eden's position and of an apparently serious rift between him and his departmental superior were somewhat misleading.

Type
Research Article
Information
Review of International Studies , Volume 20 , Issue 1 , January 1994 , pp. 35 - 52
Copyright
Copyright © British International Studies Association 1994

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Extracts from the Simon papers at the Bodleian Library, Oxford, appear by kind permission of Viscount Simon; extracts from the Avon papers at the University of Birmingham appear by kind permission of the Avon trustees.

2 ‘Cato’, Guilty Men (London, 1940), p. 6Google Scholar.

3 Churchill, W. S., The Gathering Storm (London, 1948), p. 201Google Scholar.

4 See, for example, Rose, N., ‘The Resignation of Anthony Eden’, Historical Journal, 25, 4 (1982)CrossRefGoogle Scholar and Rothwell, V. H., Anthony Eden: A Political Biography 1931–57 (Manchester, 1992), pp. 40–6Google Scholar.

5 Colville, J., The Churchillians (London, 1981), pp. 160–71Google Scholar; Seldon, A., Churchill's Indian Summer (London, 1981), pp. 38–54Google Scholar.

6 Howard, A., RAB: The Life of R. A. Butler (London, 1987), pp. 107–8Google Scholar.

7 Cosgrave, P., R. A. Butler: An English Life (London, 1981), p. 12Google Scholar.

8 At the time of the Conservative leadership crisis in 1963, Eden wrote: ‘I would only set down that I wish Butler were a man I could respect’. James, R. R., Anthony Eden (London, 1986), p. 610Google Scholar.

9 Home, A., Macmillan 1894–1956 (London, 1988), p. 376Google Scholar.

10 James, Eden, p. 585.

11 Board, L., Sir Anthony Eden (London, 1955), p. 53Google Scholar.

12 Two Labour MPs claimed the parentage of this phrase. Foot, M., Aneurin Bevan (London, 1973), II, p. 213Google Scholar. Mr Foot has recently (Evening Standard, 14 May 1992) concluded that the verdict is a little harsh-on Ethelred the Unready.

13 Young, K. (ed.), The Diaries of Sir Robert Bruce Lockhart (London, 1980), II, p. 527Google Scholar. Yet Eden once conceded that Simon was ‘much to be preferred to [Samuel] Hoare’. Undated diary entry (1948) AP 20/1/26.

14 Simon, Viscount, Retrospect (London, 1952), p. 177Google Scholar.

15 Earl of Avon, Facing the Dictators (London, 1962), p. 23Google Scholar.

16 Avon, Dictators, pp. 219–20.

17 Naylor, J. F., A Man and an Institution (Cambridge, 1984), pp. 294–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Hall, H. H., ‘The Foreign Policy-Making Process in Britain, 1934–1935, and the Origins of the Anglo-German Naval Agreement’, Historical Journal, 19, 2 (1976), p. 481CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Rose, N., Vansiltart: Study of a Diplomat (London, 1978), p. 104Google Scholar.

20 Naylor, Man and Institution, p. 235.

21 Simon to Eden, 28 June 1934, PRO, FO 800/289.

22 Manchester Guardian, 6 Nov. 1931.

23 Dutton, D. J., Simon: A Political Biography of Sir John Simon (London, 1992), pp. 117–44Google Scholar.

24 Bassett, R., Democracy and Foreign Policy, 2nd edn (London, 1968), p. 371Google Scholar.

25 Simon to MacDonald, 29 Jan. 1932, Simon MSS 70 fos. 184–9.

26 Simon to Amery, 19 March 1932, FO 800/286.

27 Simon to Runciman, 24 March 1932, Runciman MSS 254 (University of Newcastle upon Tyne).

28 Simon to Baldwin, 11 Oct. 1933, Baldwin MSS 121 fo. 86 (Cambridge University).

29 Kordt to Dirksen, 29 Aug. 1938, cited Andrews, E. M., The Writing on the Wall (London, 1987), p. 40Google Scholar.

30 Mrs. Madariaga to T. Jones, 15 April 1938, cited Jones, T., Diary with Letters 1931–50 (London, 1954), p. 403Google Scholar.

31 Ormsby-Gore to Baldwin, 8 Oct. 1933, Baldwin MSS 121 fos. 83–4.

32 Simon to MacDonald, 30 Dec. 1932, FO 800/287.

33 Cabinet, 13 Dec. 1932, PRO, CAB 23/73.

34 Cecil to Salisbury, 25 Jan. 1933, Cecil MSS Add. MS 51086 (British Library).

35 Simon to Vansittart, 24 March 1933, Avon MSS AP 14/1/241.

36 Eden diary, 30 Jan. 1932, AP 20/1/12.

37 Colville, J., Fringes of Power (London, 1986), II, p. 60Google Scholar.

38 AP 20/1/12.

39 26 July 1932, AP 20/1/12.

40 28 Oct. 1932, AP 20/1/12.

41 31 Oct. 1932, AP 20/1/12.

42 Eden to Simon, 23 Nov. 1932, AP 14/1/120.

43 Diary, 19–20 Nov. 1931, AP 20/1/11.

44 Amery, L. S., My Political Life (London, 1955), III, p. 154Google Scholar.

45 Murray to Eden, 6 July 1934, Murray MSS 316 fo. 12 (Bodleian Library).

46 Ormsby-Gore to Baldwin, 1 Oct. 1933, Baldwin MSS 121 fos. 74–6.

47 Cabinet, 17 May 1933, CAB 23/76.

48 Simon to Baldwin, 12 May 1933, Baldwin MSS 121 fos. 33–4.

49 PRO, CP 228 (33).

50 Diary, 14 Oct. 1933, AP 20/1/13.

51 Avon, Dictators, p. 47.

52 Note by Simon, 14 Oct. 1933, Simon MSS 77 fo. 62.

53 CP 240 (33), approved by the Cabinet on 23 Oct. 1933, CAB 23/77.

54 Simon to Vansittart, 23 Dec. 1933, Baldwin MSS 121 fos. 129–35.

55 Documents on British Foreign Policy, 2nd Series, vol. 5, no. 509 and vol. 6, no. 32.

56 Chamberlain to H. Chamberlain, 3 July 1933, Chamberlain MSS AC 5/1/624 (University of Birmingham).

57 Diary, 17 Nov. 1933, AP 20/1/13.

58 Diary, 19 Nov. 1933, AP 20/1/13.

59 Diary, 8 Jan. 1934, AP 20/1/14.

60 Diary, 10 Jan. 1934, AP 20/1/14.

61 N. Chamberlain diary, Jan. 1934, Chamberlain MSS NC 2/23 A.

62 Diary, 14 Jan. 1934, AP 20/1/14.

63 Eden to Baldwin, 21 Feb. 1934, Baldwin MSS 122 fos. 31–3.

64 James, Eden, p. 135.

65 Eden to Simon, 21 Feb. 1934, cited Carlton, D., Eden (London, 1981), p. 45Google Scholar.

66 As note 61.

67 Eden to Baldwin, 24 Feb. 1934, Baldwin MSS 122 fos. 35–6.

68 Eden to MacDonald, 22 Feb. 1934, cited Carlton, Eden, p. 46.

69 Avon, Dictators, p. 70.

70 Simon to Phipps, 23 Feb. 1934, DBFP 2nd Series, vol. 6, no. 308.

71 Diary, 24 Feb. 1934, AP 20/1/14.

72 Ormsby-Gore to Baldwin, 26 Feb. 1934, Baldwin MSS 122 fo. 37.

73 Avon, Dictators, p. 84.

74 CAB 23/78.

75 Diary, 21 Dec. 1934, Simon MSS 7 fo. 11.

76 House of Commons Debates, 5th Series, vol. CCXCVI, cols. 213–14.

77 Diary, II Dec. 1934, Simon MSS 7 fo. 9.

78 Avon, Dictators, pp. 100–7.

79 Diary, 9 Dec. 1934, Simon MSS 7 fo. 8.

80 Chamberlain to H. and Ida Chamberlain, 9 Dec. 1934, Chamberlain MSS NC 18/1/898.

81 Mommsen, W. J. and Kettenacker, L. (eds.), The Fascist Challenge and the Policy of Appeasement (London, 1983), p. 298Google Scholar.

82 Cabinet, 12 Dec. 1934, CAB 23/80.

83 AP 20/1/14.

84 N. Chamberlain diary, 17 Dec. 1934, NC 2/23A.

85 Simon to Sir G. Clerk, 21 Jan. 1935, DBFP, 2nd Series, vol. 12, no. 359.

86 Diary, 28 Feb. 1935, AP 20/1/15.

87 Chamberlain to H. Chamberlain, 9 March 1935, Chamberlain MSS NC 18/1/908.

88 Diary, 4 March 1935, AP 20/1/15.

89 Beatrice Webb diary, 16 March 1935 (Harvester Microfiche).

90 Diary, 24 March 1935, AP 20/1/15.

91 Diary, 26 March 1935, AP 20/1/15.

92 Avon, Dictators, p. 142.

93 Avon, Dictators, p. 178.

94 Chamberlain diary, 8 April 1935, NC 2/23A.

95 Taylor, T., Munich: The Price of Peace (London, 1979), p. 217Google Scholar.

96 Simon to George V, 27 March 1935, FO 800/290.

97 Diary, 27 March 1935, Simon MSS 7 fos. 24–5; Simon to Dr S. Berry, 5 April 1935, Ibid 82 fos. 38–9.

98 Diary, 24 April 1935, AP 20/1/15.

99 Diary, 24 April 1935, AP 20/1/15.

100 Hall, ‘Foreign Policy-Making Process’, pp. 493–5.

101 The growing divergence between Simon and Eden in the last months of their partnership at the Foreign Office is well covered by Peters, A. R., Anthony Eden at the Foreign Office 1931–1938 (Aldershot, 1986), ch. 3Google Scholar.

102 Ormsby-Gore to Eden, nd, AP 14/1/491.

103 R. Lumley to Eden, 4 April 1935, AP 14/1/460.

104 Diary, 26 June 1933, AP 20/1/13.

105 Chamberlain to Simon, 14 March 1934, Simon MSS 78 fo. 111.

106 Diary, 23 June 1933, AP 20/1/13.

107 Eden to Hoare, 12 Oct. 1935, AP 14/1/450 G.

108 Lloyd George to Cecil, 25 April 1934, Lloyd George MSS G/4/1/17 (House of Lords Record Office).