Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:11:50.888Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Evidence for Middle-Wisconsin Peopling of Beringia: An Evaluation1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 January 2017

R. Dale Guthrie
R. Dale Guthrie*
Affiliation:
Institute of Arctic Biology, University of Alaska, Fairbanks, Alaska 99701
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Broken large mammal fossil bones in eastern Beringia have been used to argue for a middle-Wisconsin, or earlier, time of human entry into North America, It has been inferred that these controversial Pleistocene bones are artifacts because (1) they are similar to those found in archaeological sites and (2) they can be reproduced in the laboratory by replication. However, fractured, flaked, polished, faceted, cut, and scratched bones similar to the purportedly human artifacts described from Beringia are known to be produced by natural processes. New experimental data demonstrate that identifications of Pleistocene bone artifacts on the basis of differential staining and fresh breakage are suspect. Physical processes, such as the violent forces of river ice breakups in the north, and bone crushing by mammalian scavengers produce similar pseudo-artifacts. Additionally, the middle-Wisconsin dates associated with some of the finished tools, and human and dog bones from Beringia are open to question. The lack of credible dates on these artifacts raises doubt about the model of human colonization of Beringia, developed in the 1960s, which proposed an interstadial colonization of the New World.

Type
Research Article
Information
Quaternary Research , Volume 22 , Issue 2 , September 1984 , pp. 231 - 241
Copyright
University of Washington

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1

Presented at the symposium “Taphonomic Analysis and Interpretation in North American Pleistocene Archaeology” held in Fairbanks, Alaska, April 1982.

References

Banfield, A.W.F. (1974). The Mammals of Canada National Museum of Canada Ottawa Google Scholar
Beebe, B.F. (1978). Two new Pleistocene mammal species from Beringia Abstracts of the 5th Biennial Conference of American Quaternary Assoc. Edmonton Google Scholar
Behrensmeyer, A.K. Hill, A.P. (1980). Fossils in the Making: Vertebrate Taphonomy and Paleoecology Univ. of Chicago Press Chicago Google Scholar
Binford, L.R. (1981). Bones: Ancient Men and Modern Myths Academic Press New York Google Scholar
Bonnichsen, R. (1979). Pleistocene Bone Technology in the Beringian Refugium National Museum of Man Ottawa Mercury Series: Archaeological Survey of Canada, Paper No. 89Google Scholar
Bryan, A.L. (1978). Early Man in America from a Circum-Pacific perspective Dept. of Anthropology, Univ. of Alberta, Occasional Paper No. 1 Archaeological Researches International Edmonton Google Scholar
Carter, G.F. (1980). Earlier than You Think: A Personal View of Man in America Texas A and M College Station Google Scholar
Canby, T.Y. (1979). The search for the first Americans National Geographic 156 330 363 Google Scholar
Cinq-Mars, J. (1979). Bluefish Cave I: A late Pleistocene eastern Beringian cave deposit in the northern Yukon Canadian Journal of Archaeology 3 1 32 Google Scholar
Dart, R.A. (1957). The osteodontokeratic culture of Australopithecus prometheus Pretoria, Transval Museum Memoir 10 Google Scholar
Dart, R.A. (1967). Mousterian osteodontokeratic objects from Guela Cave (Haija, Israel) Quaternaria 9 105 140 Google Scholar
Dincauze, D.F. (1981). The Meadowcroft papers Quarterly Review of Archaeology 2 3 5 Google Scholar
Dixon, E.J. (1984). Context and environment in taphonomic analysis: Examples from Alaska's Porcupine River Caves Quaternary Research 22 000 Google Scholar
Ewer, R.F. (1973). The Carnivores Cornell Univ. Press Ithaca, N.Y., Google Scholar
Goodman, J. (1981). American genesis The American Indian and the Origins of Modern Man Summit Books New York Google Scholar
Gordon, B.C. (1976). Antler pseudo-tools made by caribou Raymond, J.S. Primitive Art and Technology Univ. of Calgary Archaeological Assoc., Calgary 121 128 Google Scholar
Griffin, J.B. (1979). The origin and dispersal of the American Indians in North America Laughlin, W.S. Harper, A.B. The First Americans: Origins, Affinities, and Adaptations Gustav Fischer New York 43 55 Google Scholar
Guthrie, R.D. (1967). Differential preservation and recovery of Pleistocene large mammal remains in Alaska Journal of Paleontology 411 243 246 Google Scholar
Guthrie, R.D. (1980). The first Americans?: The elusive arctic bone culture (Review of Bonnichsen, 1979) Quarterly Review of Archaeology 1 2 Google Scholar
Hagland, B. (1966). De stora rovdjurens vintervanor Viltrevy (Stockholm) 4 81 299 Google Scholar
Harington, C.R. Bonnichsen, R. Morlan, R.E. (1975). Bones say man lived in the Yukon 27,000 years ago Canadian Geographical Journal 91 42 48 Google Scholar
Harrison, T. Medway, L. (1962). The first classification of prehistoric bone and tooth artifacts Journal of Sarawale Museum 10 335 362 Google Scholar
Hassan, A.A. Termine, J.D. Haynes, C.V. (1977). Mineralogical studies on bone apatite and their implications for radiocarbon dating Radiocarbon 19 364 374 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Haynes, G.A. (1980). Evidence of carnivore gnawing on Pleistocene and recent mammalian bones Paleobiology 6 341 351 Google Scholar
Hornocker, M.G. Hash, H.S. (1981). Ecology of the wolverine in northwestern Montana Canadian Journal of Zoology 59 1286 1301 Google Scholar
Irving, W.N. Harington, C.R. (1973). Upper Pleistocene radiocarbon-dated artifacts from the northern Yukon Science 179 335 340 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Irving, W.N. Mayhall, J.T. Melbye, F.J. Beebe, B.F. (1977). A human mandible in probable association with a Pleistocene assemblage in eastern Beringia: A preliminary report Canadian Journal of Archaeology 1 81 94 Google Scholar
Jopling, A.V. Irving, W.N. Beebe, B.F. (1981). Stratigraphic, sedimentological and faunal evidence for the occurrence of pre-Sangarnon artifacts in northern Yukon Arctic 34 4 33 Google Scholar
Krott, P. (1959). Demon of the North Alfred Knopf New York Google Scholar
Krott, P. (1982). Der Vielfrass (Gulo gulo) in Okasystem Saugetierkundliche Mitteilungen BLV Verlagsgesellschaft Munich 136 150 DeitGoogle Scholar
Kruck, H. (1972). The Spotted Hyena Univ. of Chicago Press Chicago Google Scholar
Larsen, H. (1968). Trail Creek: Final report on the excavation of two caves on Seward Peninsula, Alaska Acta Arctica Fasc. XV CopenhagenGoogle Scholar
Morlan, R.E. (1978). Early man in northern Yukon Territory: perspectives as of 1977 Bryan, A.L. Early Man in American from a circum-Pacific perspective. Occasional Paper No. 1. Dept. of Anthropology, Univ. of Alberta Edmonton 78 95 Google Scholar
Morlan, R.E. (1980). Taphonomy and Archaeology in the Upper Pleistocene of Northern Yukon Territory: A Glimpse of the Peopling of the New World National Museum of Man Ottawa Mercury Series: Archaeological Survey of Canada, Paper No. 94Google Scholar
Morlan, R.E. (1984). Toward the definition of criteria for recognition of artificial bone alterations Quaternary Research 22 000 Google Scholar
Morlan, R.E. Cinq-Mars, J. (1983). Ancient Beringians: Human occupations in the late Pleistocene of Alaska and the Yukon Territory Hopkins, D.M. Matthews, J.V. Schweger, C.E. Young, S.B. The Palcoecology of Beringia Academic Press New York 353 382 Google Scholar
Morlan, R.E. Matthews, J.V. (1978). New dates for early man GEOS 2 5 winterGoogle Scholar
Müller-Beck, H.J. (1966). Paleohunters in America: Origins and diffusion Science 152 1191 1210 Google Scholar
Müller-Beck, H.J. (1981). Review of Morlan (1980) Science 213 1241 1242 Google Scholar
Myers, T. Voorhies, M.R. Corner, R.G. (1980). Spiral fractures and bare pseudotools at paleontological sites Antiquity 45 483 490 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ognev, S.I. (1962). Mammals of the U.S.S.R. and adjacent countries Vol. III Israel Program for Scientific Translations Jerusalem CarnivoraGoogle Scholar
Olsen, S.J. (1960). Post-cranial Skeletal Characters of Bison and Bos Vol. 35 Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology No. 4Google Scholar
Pullianinen, E. (1968). Breeding biology of the wolverine (Gulo gulo L.) in Finland Zoologica Fennica 5 338 344 Google Scholar
Rausch, R.A. Pearson, A.M. (1972). Notes on the wolverine in Alaska and the Yukon Territory Journal of Wildlife Management 36 249 268 Google Scholar
Stanford, D. Bonnichsen, R. Morlan, R.E. (1981). The Ginsberg experiment: Modern and prehistoric evidence of a bone flaking technology Science 212 438 440 Google Scholar
Sutcliffe, A.J. (1970). Spotted hyena: Crusher, gnawer, digestor and collector of bones Nature (London) 227 1110 1113 Google Scholar
Sutchliffe, A.J. (1973). Similarity of bones and antlers gnawed by deer to human artifacts Nature (London) 246 428 430 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sutcliffe, A.J. (1977). Further notes on bones and antlers chewed by deer and other ungulates Deer 4 73 82 Google Scholar
Thorsen, R.M. Guthrie, R.D. (1984). River ice as a taphonomic agent: An alternative hypothesis for bone “artifacts.” Quaternary Research 22 000 Google Scholar
Tseitlin, S.M. (1979). Geologiya paleolita severnoi Azii Geology of the Paleolithic of Northern Moscow Nauka Leningrad Google Scholar
Vereshchagin, N.K. (1977). Berelekh “cemetery” of mammoths Skarlato, O.A. Mammoth Fauna of the Russian Plain on Eastern Siberia Nauka Leningrad 5 50 Google Scholar