No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Harriet Stowe's Filthy Story: Lord Byron Set Afloat
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 30 July 2009
Extract
In the September, 1869, issue of the Atlantic Monthly, Harriet Beecher Stowe published an article in which she claimed that Lord Byron, the poet, had committed incest with his half-sister. These charges had been made before and are generally accepted by Byron biographers today, but the publication of such a claim in a respectable literary journal in 1869 touched an exposed nerve of American consciousness. For weeks, Harriet Stowe was attacked in newspapers throughout the country as a liar and a fool who had sought money and notoriety by pandering to obscene and depraved tastes. The article was termed “startling in accusation, barren in proof, inaccurate in dates, infelicitous in style.” The author's literary reputation plummeted, and the Atlantic Monthly lost more than a third of its subscribers in a single year. The moral sensibilities of thousands of Americans had been outraged; this violation of a taboo unleashed resentments, which had apparently been smoldering since the end of the Civil War, against Stowe, the Beecher family, and the liberal causes with which both were identified.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1977
References
NOTES
1. See Quennell, Peter, Byron: The Years of Fame (Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books, 1967)Google Scholar and Marchand, Leslie, Byron: A Portrait (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1970)Google Scholar among others. The matter has not been entirely settled.
2. Independent, 08 26, 1869.Google Scholar
3. Mott, Frank L., A History of American Magazines (Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press, 1957), II, 505–506Google Scholar. See also Howe, Mark DeWolfe, The Atlantic Monthly and its Makers (Boston: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1919), pp. 49–50.Google Scholar
4. Holmes, Oliver Wendell to Stowe, Harriet Beecher, 07 4, 1869Google Scholar. Manuscript letter in the Beecher-Stowe collection of the Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe College.
5. The article was published simultaneously in England in Macmillan's Magazine (09 1869).Google Scholar
6. Also in the Beecher-Stowe collection of the Schlesinger Library.
7. The Stowe-Byron Controversy: A Complete Resume of All that has Been Written and Said upon the Subject, reprinted from “The Times,” “The Saturday Review,”… together with an Impartial Review of the Merits of the Case. By the Editor of Once a Week (London: T. Cooper & Co., 1869)Google Scholar. Also Wilson, Forrest, Crusader in Crinoline (Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Company, 1941), p. 536.Google Scholar
8. Stowe, Charles E., The Life of Harriet Beecher Stowe (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin, 1889).Google Scholar
9. Wilson, , Crusader, p. 536.Google Scholar
10. Another interesting explanation is developed in detail by Emig, Janet in “The Flower in the Cleft,” Bulletin of the Historical and Philosophical Society of Ohio (10 1963)Google Scholar, who feels that Harriet's close relationship with her brother Henry and a sense that he was under attack gave rise both to the incest theme and to the sense of rage that Harriet felt when she read the Guiccioli memoirs. As a girl, she had been much moved by Byron's poems and by his death. The recurrence of Byronic figures in her novels—Augustine St. Clair, Burr, Aaron in The Minister's WooingGoogle Scholar, and Davenport, Ellery in Oldtown FolksGoogle Scholar, finished just months before the Byron article—indicate a continuing fascination with the type. In each case, these men are depicted as charming and presented sympathetically, although they are in themselves and in their effects upon others evil men, villains. Like Byron, they possess sensitive souls that were twisted in childhood by struggles with a theology of predestined damnation, one not unlike that Harriet and Henry rebelled against. By accusing this childhood idol of an unspeakable crime that embodied her own unacknowledged suspicions or fears, Harriet was able, according to Emig, to restore her brother in her mind to his “primal innocence.” Karl Brown, in a novel based on the life of Stowe, Fred, The Cup of Trembling (New York: Duell, Sloan and Pearce, 1953)Google Scholar, carries this idea to the logical extreme of imagining a literally incestuous affair between Harriet and her brother, the guilt for which was projected into the Byron article. Still another suggestion, not widely accepted, comes from Knight, G. Wilson, The Evidence of Asterisks (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1957)Google Scholar, who thinks that the release of the pornographic “Don Leon” poems in 1865–66 may have come to the attention of Mrs. Stowe and prompted her defense.
11. “Stowe versus Byron,” “The Byrons and their Latest Biographer,” St. James Magazine, 25 (10 1869), 58–68, 133–36.Google Scholar
12. “Lord Byron and his Calumniators,” Blackwood's Magazine, 107 (01 1870), 123–38.Google Scholar
13. New York Times, 08 19, 1869Google Scholar. Lentricchia, Frank in “Harriet Beecher Stowe and the Byron Whirlwind,” Bulletin of the New York Public Library, 90 (1966), 218–28Google Scholar, notes that the New York Times published more than twenty long articles on the Stowe-Byron affair between September 1869 and February 1870.
14. Boston Morning Journal, 09 6 (?), 1869Google Scholar. Widely reprinted on September 7.
15. Chicago Times, 09 13, 1869.Google Scholar
16. Quoted in the Chicago Times, 09 3, 1869.Google Scholar
17. McCarthy, Justin, “Mrs. Stowe's Last Romance,” Independent, 08 26, 1869.Google Scholar
18. New York Herald, 09 4, 1869.Google Scholar
19. The Times [London], 08 30, 1869.Google Scholar
20. Dr. Leonard Bacon, quoted in Beecher, Lyman, Saints, Sinners and Beechers (Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Company, 1934), p. 7.Google Scholar
21. Information about the Beecher family may be found in Lyman Beecher and Forrest Wilson. See also Meredeth, Robert, The Politics of the Universe: Edward Beecher, Abolition and Orthodoxy (Nashville: Vanderbilt Univ. Press, 1968)Google Scholar and Sklar, Kathryn Kish, Catharine Beecher: A Study in American Domesticity (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1973).Google Scholar
22. Southern Literary Messenger, 27 (October 1858), 284–86.
23. Chicago Times and Chicago Tribune, 09 1869 and January 1870, passim.Google Scholar
24. Woman's Journal, 01 22, 1870.Google Scholar
25. Independent, 09 9, 1869.Google Scholar
26. The Revolution, 09 9, 1869.Google Scholar
27. Wagenknecht, Edward, Harriet Beecher Stowe: The Known and the Unknown (New York: Oxford Univ. Press, 1965), p. 86.Google Scholar
28. The Revolution, 10 14, 1869.Google Scholar
29. Baender, Paul, “Mark Twain and the Byron Scandal,” American Literature, 30 (01 1959), 467–85.Google Scholar
30. “Unburlesqueable Things,” Galaxy, 10 (07 1870), 137.Google Scholar