Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-v2bm5 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-02T21:35:34.190Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Re-Examination of the Evidence for Agricultural Origins in the Nile Valley

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 September 2014

J. Desmond Clark
J. Desmond Clark
Affiliation:
University of California, Berkeley
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Current belief ascribes the origins of agriculture in the Nile to diffusion in the fifth millennium B.C. from southwest Asia of plants and animals the domestication of which had first begun there in the eighth millennium or earlier. A growing body of evidence is now becoming available which shows the cultural pattern in the Nile Valley at the termination of the Pleistocene to have been appreciably more complex than was previously thought and necessitates a re-examination of the evidence on which the belief for the late appearance of domestication in Egypt is based. This pre-agricultural complexity, when examined in the light of the abundant historical and ethnographic evidence for distinctive man/animal, if not also man/plant relationships in north and northeast Africa, suggests that a process of pre-adaption using the local animal and plant resources is most likely to have preceded the introduction of the Asian domesticates. Many of the indigenous practices relating to local animals and plants persisted as late as Middle Kingdom times (2052–1786 B.C.). The appearance of the Asian food plants and animals in the fifth millennium may reflect, therefore, not the beginnings of domestication in Egypt, but the replacement of genetically less suitable local species by more satisfactory, exotic forms, a situation made possible by the beginnings of regular communication between the Nile and the Levant from that time onwards.

Type
Research Article
Information
Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society , Volume 37 , Issue 2 , December 1971 , pp. 34 - 79
Copyright
Copyright © The Prehistoric Society 1971

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aldred, C., 1965. Egypt to the end of the Old Kingdom. London.Google Scholar
Anderson, J. E., 1968. ‘Late Palaeolithic skeletal remains from Nubia’, in Wendorf, F., The Prehistory of Nubia, II, 996–1040, Dallas.Google Scholar
Arkell, A. J., 1949. Early Khartoum. London.Google Scholar
Arkell, A. J., 1953. Shaheinab. London.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arkell, A. J. and Ucko, P. J., 1965. ‘Review of Predynastic Development in the Nile valley’, Current Anthropology, 6 (2), 145–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Armelagos, G. J. et al. , 1965. ‘Report of the Physical Anthropology Section, University of Colorado Nubian Expedition’, Kush, 13, 24–7.Google Scholar
Bailloud, G., 1969. ‘L'Evolution des styles céramiques en Ennedi (République du Tchad)’, Actes Ie colloque int. d'Archéol. africaine (1966), 31–45.Google Scholar
Bakker, E. M. van Zinderen, 1967. ‘Upper Pleistocene and Holocene stratigraphy and ecology on the basis of vegetation changes in sub-Saharan Africa, in Bishop, and Clark, , 125–47.Google Scholar
Barth, H., 1857. Travels and discoveries in north and central Africa, 1849–1855. New York.Google Scholar
Baumhof, M. A., 1963. ‘Ecological determinants of aboriginal California populations’, Univ. of Cal. Pubs. in Amer. Archaeol. and Ethnol., 49, 155–236.Google Scholar
Beck, P. and Huard, P., 1969. Tibesti: carrefour de la préhistoire saharienne. Paris.Google Scholar
Bishop, W. W. and Clark, J. D. (ed.), Background to Evolution in Africa, Chicago.Google Scholar
Brunton, G., 1937. Mostagedda. London.Google Scholar
Brunton, G. and Caton Thompson, G., 1928. The Badarian civilisation. Brit. Sch. of Arch. in Egypt. London.Google Scholar
Busson, F., 1965. Plantes alimentaires de l'ouest africain. Marseille.Google Scholar
Butzer, K. W., 1966. ‘Climatic change in the arid zones of Africa, 8000–0 B.C.’, in Sawyer, J. S. (ed.), World Climate 8000–0 B.C., 73–84, Roy. Meteor. Soc. London.Google Scholar
Butzer, K. W. and Hansen, C. L., 1967. ‘Upper Pleistocene stratigraphy in southern Egypt’, in Bishop, and Clark, , 329–54.Google Scholar
Butzer, K. W. and Hansen, C. L., 1968. Desert and River in Nubia. Madison.Google Scholar
Camps, G., 1969. Amekni: Néolithique ancien du Hoggar. Mem. 10, CRAPE. Paris.Google Scholar
Camps, G., Delibrias, G. and Thommeret, J., 1968. ‘Chronologie absolue et succession des civilisations préhistoriques dans le nord de l'Afrique’, Libyca, 16, 9–28.Google Scholar
Camps-Fabrer, H., 1966. Matière et art mobilier dans la préhistoire nord-africaine et saharienne. Mem. 5, CRAPE. Paris.Google Scholar
Carter, P. L. and Clark, J. D.Adrar Bous and African cattle. In press.Google Scholar
Caton Thompson, G. and Gardner, E. W., 1934. The Desert Fayum. Roy. Anthrop. Inst. London.Google Scholar
Chamla, M. C., 1968. Les populations anciennes du Sahara et des régions limitrophes. Mem. 9, CRAPE. Paris.Google Scholar
Chapelle, J., 1957. Nomades noirs du Sahara. Paris.Google Scholar
Chaplin, R. E., 1969. ‘The use of non-morphological criteria in the study of animal domestication from bones found in archaeological sites’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 231–45.Google Scholar
Clark, J. D. ‘Summary of the results of an archaeological survey of northern Aïr and Ténéré’, in Hall, D. N. (ed.), Science in the Sahara: British Expedition to the Aïr Mountains, 9–12.Google Scholar
Dalziel, J. M., 1937. The useful plants of west tropical Africa. London.Google Scholar
Dixon, D. M., 1969. ‘A note on cereals in ancient Egypt’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 131–42.Google Scholar
Drew, I. M., Perkins, D. Jr., and Daly, P., 1971. ‘Prehistoric domestication of animals: Effects on bone structure’, Science, 171, 280–2.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ducos, P., 1969. ‘Methodology and results of the study of the earliest domestic animals in the Near East’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 265–94.Google Scholar
Emberger, et al. , 1963. Bioclimatic map of the Mediterranean basin. Arid Zone Research. UNESCO. FAO.Google Scholar
Emery, W. B., 1961. Archaic Egypt. London.Google Scholar
Evans-Pritchard, E. E., 1940. The Nuer. Oxford.Google Scholar
Faure, H., 1969. ‘Lacs quaternaires du Sahara’, Mitt. Internat. Verein. Limno., 17, 131–46.Google Scholar
Faure, H., Manguin, E. and Nydal, R., 1963. ‘Formations lacustres du Quaternaire supérieur du Niger oriental: Diatomites et âges absolus’, Bull. Bur. Rech. Géol. Minières (Dakar), 3, 41–63.Google Scholar
Flannery, K. V., 1969. ‘Origins and ecological effects of early domestication in Iran and the Near East’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 73–100.Google Scholar
Gast, M., 1968. Alimentation des populations de l'Ahaggar. Mem. 8, CRAPE. Paris.Google Scholar
Gautier, A., 1968. ‘Mammalian remains of the northern Sudan and southern Egypt“, in Wendorf, , 80–99.Google Scholar
Gilot, E., 1970. ‘Louvain natural radiocarbon measurements, 8’, Radiocarbon, 12 (1), 156–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gould, R. A., 1970. ‘Journey to Pulykara’, Natural History, LXXIX (10), 56–67.Google Scholar
Grigson, C., 1969. ‘The uses and limitations of differences in absolute size in the distinction between the bones of aurochs (Bos primigenius) and domestic cattle (Bos taurus)’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 277–94.Google Scholar
Gulliver, P. H., 1965. ‘The Jie of Uganda’, in Gibbs, J. L. (ed.), The peoples of Africa, 157–96, New York.Google Scholar
Halwagy, R., 1961. ‘The vegetation of the semi-desert northeast of Khartoum, Sudan’, Oikos, 12 (1), 87–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halwagy, R., 1963. ‘Studies on the succession of vegetation on some islands and sand banks in the Nile near Khartoum, Sudan’, Vegetatio, 9 (4), 217–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harlan, J. R., 1967. ‘A wild wheat harvest in Turkey’, Archaeology (20) (3), 197–201.Google Scholar
Harlan, J. R. and Zohary, D., 1966. ‘Distribution of wild wheats and barley’, Science, 153, 1074–80.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
de Heinzelin, J., 1968. ‘Geological history of the Nile valley in Nubia“, in Wendorf, I, 19–55.Google Scholar
Herodotus, (trans. de Selincourt, A.), 1954. The Histories. London.Google Scholar
Higgs, E. S., 1967. ‘Environment and chronology—the evidence from Mammalian fauna’, in McBurney, .Google Scholar
Higgs, E. S., 1967. ‘Domestic animals’, in McBurney, , 313–19.Google Scholar
Hole, F. and Flannery, K. V., 1967. ‘The prehistory of southwestern Iran’, PPS, 33, 147–206.Google Scholar
Hugot, H. J., 1963. Recherches préhistoriques dans l'Ahaggar nord-occidental, 1950–57. Mem. 1, CRAPE. Paris.Google Scholar
Irwin, H. T., Wheat, J. D. and Irwin, L. F., 1968. ‘University of Colorado Investigations of Palaeolithic and Epi-Palaeolithic sites in the Sudan, Africa’, Univ. of Utah Anthrop. Papers, 90, Nubian Series 3.Google Scholar
Jany, E., 1967. ‘Heinrich Barths Mitteilungen über Flora and Fauna Afrikas (1849–55)’, in Schiffers, H. (ed.), Heinrich Barth ein Forscher in Africa: Leben, Werk Leistung, 224–307, Wiesbaden.Google Scholar
Jarman, M. R., 1968. ‘The fauna and economy of early Neolithic Knossos’, Ann. Brit. School of Arch. Athens, 63, 241–76.Google Scholar
Junker, H., 1930. ‘Vorläufigen Bericht über die Grabung der Akademie auf der neolitschen Siedelung von Merimde—Benisalame (Westdelta) 1 bis 30 Marz, 1929’, Anzeigen der Akademie der Wissenschaften in Wien, Philosophisch-historische Klasse, Vol. 66, 156–249.Google Scholar
Kantor, H., 1965. ‘The relative chronology of Egypt and its foreign correlations before the Late Bronze Age’, in Ehrich, R. W. (ed.), Chronologies in Old World Archaeology, 1–46, Chicago.Google Scholar
Kendall, , 1969. ‘An ecological history of the Lake Victoria basin’, Ecological Monographs, 39, 121–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lagercrantz, S., 1950. Contributions to the ethnography of Africa, Studia Ethnog. Upsaliensia, 1. Lund.Google Scholar
Lee, R. B., 1968. ‘What hunters do for a living: or how to make out on scarce resources’, in Lee, R. B. and DeVore, I. (eds.), Man the Hunter, 30–48, Chicago.Google Scholar
Livingstone, D. A., 1967. ‘Post glacial vegetation of the Ruwenzori Mountains in Equatorial Africa,’ Ecological Monographs, 37, 25–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marks, A. E., 1968. ‘The Halfan Industry’, in Wendorf, , op. cit., I, 392–460.Google Scholar
McBurney, C. B. M., 1967. The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica). Cambridge.Google Scholar
Mori, F., 1964. ‘Some aspects of the rock art of the Acacus (Fezzan Sahara) and dating regarding it’, in Garcia, L. Pericot and Perello, E. Ripoll (eds.), Prehistoric art of the western Mediterranean and the Sahara, 247–59, New York.Google Scholar
Mori, F., 1965. Tadrart Acacus. Torino.Google Scholar
Munson, P. J., 1968. ‘Recent archaeological research in the Dhar Tichitt region of south central Mauretania’, West African Newsletter, 10, 6–13.Google Scholar
Nachtigal, G., 1881. Sahara und Sudan. Berlin.Google Scholar
Newberry, P. E., 1893. Beni Hassan. 2 vols. Arch. Survey of Egypt. London.Google Scholar
Nicolaisen, J., 1963. ‘Ecology and culture of the pastoral Tuareg’, National museets Skrifter Etno, 9. Copenhagen.Google Scholar
Paradisi, U., 1965. ‘Prehistoric art in the Gebel el-Akhdar (Cyrenaica)’, Antiquity, 39, 154, 95–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perkins, D., 1969. ‘Fauna of Catal Huyuk: Evidence of early cattle domesticates in Anatolia’, Science, 164, 177–9.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Portères, R., 1970. ‘Primary cradles of agriculture in the African continent’, in Fage, J. D. and Oliver, R. A. (eds.), Papers in African Prehistory, 43–58, Cambridge.Google Scholar
Rattray, J. M., 1960. The grass cover of Africa. FAO. Rome.Google Scholar
Reed, C. A., 1960. ‘A review of the archaeological evidence on animal domestication in the prehistoric Near East’, in Braidwood, R. J. and Howe, B., Prehistoric Investigations in Iraqi Kurdistan, 119–45. Chicago.Google Scholar
Reed, C. A., 1966a. ‘The Yale University Prehistoric Expedition to Nubia, 1962–1965‘, Discovery, 1 (2), 16–23. New Haven.Google Scholar
Reed, C. A., 1966b. Appendix in Wendt, W. E., ‘Two prehistoric archaeological sites in Egyptian Nubia’, Postilla, 102, 35–42.Google Scholar
Reed, C. A., 1969. ‘The pattern of animal domestication in the prehistoric Near East’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 361–80.Google Scholar
Richardson, J. L., 1966. ‘Changes in level of Lake Naivasha, Kenya, during post-glacial times’, Nature, 209, 290–1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rizkana, I., 1957. ‘Two new Egyptian cultures’, in Clark, J. D. (ed.), Proc. Third Pan-afr. Cong. on Prehist., Livingstone, 1955, 391–3, London.Google Scholar
Saad, S. I., 1967. ‘Studies of pollen and spore content of Nile Delta deposits (Berendal region)’, Pollen and Spores, 9 (3), 467–503.Google Scholar
Saxe, A. A. ‘Social dimensions of mortuary practices in a Mesolithic population from Wadi Haifa, Sudan’. Paper presented, meeting of Amer. Anthrop. Assoc., 1966.Google Scholar
Shiner, J. L., 1968. ‘The Cataract tradition’, in Wendorf, , 564–611.Google Scholar
Simoons, F. J., 1965. ‘Some questions on the economic prehistory of Ethiopia’, Journ. Afr. Hist., 6 (1), 1–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smith, H. S., 1969. ‘Animal domestication and animal cult in dynastic Egypt’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 307–16.Google Scholar
Smith, P. E. L., 1966. ‘The late Palaeolithic of northeast Africa in the light of recent research’, Amer. Anthrop., 68 (2), Special publication, Clark, J. D. and Howell, F. C. (eds.)—Recent studies in Palaeo-anthropology, 326–55.Google Scholar
Smith, P. E. L., 1967. ‘New investigations in the late Pleistocene archaeology of the Kom Ombo plain (Upper Egypt)’, Quaternaria, 9, 141–52.Google Scholar
Smith, P. E. L., 1967b. ‘A preliminary report on the recent prehistoric investigations near Kom Ombo, Upper Egypt’, in Fouilles en Nubie, 1961–1963, 195–208, Antiquities Department of Egypt.Google Scholar
Smith, P. E. L., 1968. ‘Problems and possibilities of the prehistoric rock art of northern Africa’, African Hist. Studies, 1 (1). Boston.Google Scholar
Stevenson-Hamilton, J., 1947. Wild life in South Africa. London.Google Scholar
Täckholm, V., 1951. ‘The plant of Naqada’, Ann. Serv. Antiq. d'Egypt, 51, 299–312.Google Scholar
Täckholm, V. and G., , 1941. Flora of Egypt, 1. Bull. Fac. Sci., 17. Cairo.Google Scholar
Trigger, B. G., 1968. Beyond History: the methods of Prehistory. New York.Google Scholar
Ucko, P. J. and Dimbleby, G. W., 1969. The Domestication and Exploitation of Plants and Animals. Chicago.Google Scholar
Vermeersch, P., 1969. ‘Les fouilles d'Elkab’, Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, Suppl. 1, XVII, Deutscher Orientalistentag, Teil 1, 32–6.Google Scholar
Vermeersch, P., 1970. ‘L'Elkabien’, Chronique d'Egypt, 45 (89), 45–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vignard, E., 1928. ‘Une nouvelle industrie lithique, le Sebilien’, BSPF, 25, 200–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vignard, E., 1934. ‘Le Paléolithique en Egypte’, Mém. Inst. Franç. Arch. Orientate, 66. M!elanges Maspero, 1, 165–75.Google Scholar
Wendorf, F., 1968. The Prehistory of Nubia, 2 vols. ed. Dallas, .Google Scholar
Wendorf, F., Said, R. and Schild, R., 1970. ‘Egyptian prehistory: some new concepts’, Science, 169, 1161–71.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wendt, W. E., 1966. ‘Two prehistoric archaeological sites in Egyptian Nubia’, Postilla, 102, 1–46.Google Scholar
de Wet, J. M. J. and Huckabay, J. P., 1967. ‘The origin of Sorghum bicolor, II—Distribution and domestication’, Evolution, 21 (4), 787–802.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
White, J. P., 1971. ‘New Guinea and Australian prehistory: the “Neolithic problem“,’ in Mulvaney, D. L. and Golson, J. (ed.), Aboriginal Man and Environment in Australia, 182–95. Canberra.Google Scholar
Winkler, H. A., 1938–1939. Rock drawings of southern Upper Egypt. 2 vols. London.Google Scholar
Woodburn, J., 1968. ‘An introduction to Hadza ecology’, in Lee, and DeVore, , op. cit., 49–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, H. E., 1968. ‘Natural environment of early food production north of Mesopotamia’, Science, 161, 334–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
van Zeist, W., 1969. ‘Reflections on prehistoric environments in the Near East’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 35–46.Google Scholar
van Zeist, W., 1970. ‘The Oriental Institute excavations at Mureybit, Syria: Preliminary report on the 1965 campaign. Part III, The Palaeobotany’, Journ. Near Eastern Studies, 29 (3), 167–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zohary, D., 1969. ‘The progenitors of wheat and barley in relation to domestication and agriculture dispersal in the Old World’, in Ucko, and Dimbleby, , 47–66.Google Scholar