Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-19T02:39:02.309Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Food and nutrition policies of Nordic countries: how have they been developed and what evidence substantiates the development of these policies?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 December 2008

Unni Kjærnes
Unni Kjærnes*
Affiliation:
National Institute for Consumer Research, PO Box 173, N-1325, Lysaker, Norway
*
Corresponding author: Dr Unni Kjærnes, fax +47 67 53 19 48, [email protected]
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The present paper addresses the emergence and development of Nordic food and nutrition policies, with some reference to the types of nutrition policies characteristic of other North European countries. Nutrition programmes aimed at dietary change have a long history of public responsibility in several Nordic and North European countries. The extent of involvement, the orientation and (indication of) success have, however, varied considerably between countries. First, different types of policies are characterised by their choice of programmes and measures, e.g. information campaigns v. market regulation or catering and public services. Second, the distinctions are associated not only with programmes, but also with the status and validity of nutritional advice and dietary guidelines in public policy making. Third, when focusing on how and on what grounds the governments have developed nutrition policies, it is evident that while more or less the same participants and issues are involved, their roles and relationships may be different. In this case the role and involvement of nutritional expertise and scientific arguments in various countries will be discussed. Finally, nutrition policies may entail conflicts of interest, particularly when health concerns are confronted with food industry and agricultural interests. This situation is quite evident in the question of animal fat. The present paper addresses how these issues have been dealt with quite differently in various countries.

Type
International and Public Health Nutrition Group Symposium on ‘The interface between evidence, policy and practice in public health nutrition’
Information
Proceedings of the Nutrition Society , Volume 62 , Issue 2 , May 2003 , pp. 563 - 570
Copyright
Copyright © The Nutrition Society 2003

References

Aronson, N (1982) Nutrition as a social problem: A case study of entrepreneurial strategy in science. Social Problems 29, 474–487.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Becker, W (1997) Utvecklingen av livsmedelskonsumptionen i Norden 1965–1994 (The development of food consumption in the Nordic countries 1965–1994) In Utfordringer i ernoeringspolitikken (Challenges in Nutrition Policy). TemaNord 1997, p. 619 [Kjaernes, U, editor] Copenhagen, Denmark..Google Scholar
Befolkningskommissionen (1938) Betänkande i Näringsfrågan. Sveriges Offentliga Utredningar (Report on the Nutrition Issue. Swedish Public Reports) 1938:6 Stockholm, Sweden: Socialdepartementet..Google Scholar
Burnett, J (1989) Plenty and Want. A Social History of Food in England from 1815 to the Present Day. London: Routledge..Google Scholar
Eide, WB (2001) Breaking conceptual and methodological ground: promoting the human right to adequate food and nutrition. An example of activism with an academic base. Ecology of Food and Nutrition 40, 571–595.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Esping-Andersen, G (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Evang, K & Hansen, OG (1937) Norsk Kosthold i Små Hjem (The Diet Among Norwegian Poor Families). Oslo, Norway: Tiden.Google Scholar
Frandsen, J (1937) Omkring Husholdningsraadet (About the National Council for Households) In Statens Husholdningsraad Beretning for Finansaaret 1936–37 (The National Council for Households. Report for the Financial Year 1936–37), pp. 48–58 København, Denmark: Indenrigsdepartementet.Google Scholar
Fridericia, LS (1937) Internationalt Samarbejde om Ernæringsproblemet (International Cooperation on Nutritional Problems). Statens Husholdningsraad Beretning for Finansaaret 1936–37 (The National Council for Households. Report for the Financial Year 1936–37), pp. 59–68 København, Denmark: Indenrigsministeriet.Google Scholar
Gustafsson, B, Pihkala, E, Tønneson, KD (1974) Perspektiv på den offentliga sektorn under 1930-talet (Perspectives on the Public Sector in the 1930s). Nordiska Historikermötet 1974. Mötesrapport (Nordic Meeting for Historians 1974. Meeting Report) 105–153 Uppsala, Sweden: Uppsala University.Google Scholar
Haavet, IE (1996) Maten på Bordet 50 år Med Statens Ernæringsråd (Food on the Table. 50 Years with the National Nutrition Council). Oslo, Norway: Statens Ernæringsråd..Google Scholar
Hansen, RI (1990) Den Hensiktsmessige Ernæringspolitikken. Prosessen Fram til Stortingsmeldingen om Norsk Ernærings- og Matforsyningspolitikk (The Appropriate Nutrition Policy. The Process Leading up to the White Paper on Norwegian Nutrition Policy). Report no. 8 Oslo, Norway: The National Institute for Consumer Research..Google Scholar
Helenius, R (1991) Welfare society and people's health. A case study of the Finnish fat policy and its adaption to the goals of European trade integration. Politeia issue no. 4, 1–30..Google Scholar
Helsing, E (1991) Nutrition policies in Europe. Background and organization. Food Policy 16, 371–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hercberg, S (2001) Les bases de la politique nutritionnelle de santé publique en France: le constat et les recommendations du HCSP. Oleagineux Corps Gras Lipids 8, 7–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirdman, Y (1983) Magfrågan. Mat Som Mål Och Medel Stockholm 1870–1920 (The Stomach Issue. Food as Goal and Measure. Stockholm 1870–1920). Stockholm, Sweden: Rabén & Sjögren..Google Scholar
Hirdman, Y (1990) Att Lägga livet Till Rätta–Studier i Svensk Folkhemspolitik (To Arrange Daily Life–Studies in the Swedish Policy of People's Home). Stockholm, Sweden: Carlsson Bokförlag..Google Scholar
Holm, L, Bredsdorff, N & Rasmussen, FD (1993) The weaknesses of nutrition policies. In Regulating Markets – Regulating People. On Food and Nutrition Policy, pp. 47–63 [Kjærnes, U, editor]. Oslo, Norway: Novus Forlag..Google Scholar
Jensen, T (1993) Nutrition. A dilemma in the politics of food. In Regulating Markets–Regulating People. On Food and Nutrition Policy, pp. 17–36 [Kjaernes, U, editor]. Oslo: Novus Forlag..Google Scholar
Jensen, TØ (1994) The political history of Norwegian nutrition policy. In The Origins and Development of Food Policies in Europe, pp. 90–112 [Burnett, J and, Oddy, DJ, editors]. London: Leicester University Press..Google Scholar
Jensen, TØ, Kjærnes, U (1997) Political dilemmas of designing the good life – The case of nutrition and social democracy. In Constructing the New Consumer Society, pp. 218–233 [Holmwood, J, Radner, H, Schulze, G, Sulkunen, P, editors]. London and New York: Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, G (1986) Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain. London: Croom Helm..Google Scholar
Jul, M (1988) Mad, Ernæring og Politik i Norden. Rapport til det Permanente Nordiske Udvalg for Næringsmiddelspørsmål (Food, Nutrition and Politics in the Nordic Countries). Uppsala, Sweden: Statens Livsmedelsverk..Google Scholar
Kamminga, H & & Cunningham, A (1995) The Science and Culture of Nutrition, 1840–1940. Amsterdam, The Netherlands and Atlanta, GA: Editions Rodopi. Kjærnes U (1985) Spedbarns og Småbarns Ernæring. En Utredning om Behov og Muligheter for Nordisk Samarbeid (The Nutrition of Infants and Young Children. A Report on the Need and Possibilities for Nordic Collaboration ). Report 1985:2. Oslo, Norway: The Nordic Council of Ministers..Google Scholar
Kjærnes, U (1990) Velferdskrav og Landbrukspolitikk. Om Framveksten av Norsk Ernæringspolitikk (Welfare Demands and Agricultural Policy. The Emergence of Norwegian Nutrition Policy ). SIFO Report no. 7. Oslo, Norway: The National Institute for Consumer Research..Google Scholar
Kjærnes, U (1996) Political struggle over scientific definitions. Nutrition as a social problem in inter-war Norwegian nutrition policy. Food, Eating, and Nutrition as Social Problems: Constructivist Perspectives, pp. 261–278 [Maurer, D and, Sobal, J, editors]. New York: Aldine de Gruyter..Google Scholar
Kjærnes, U (editor) (1997) Framveksten av ernæringspolitikk i Norden (The emergence of nutrition policy in the Nordic countries). Utfordringer i Ernæringspolitikken (Challenges in Nutrition Policy). TemaNord 1997, pp. 73–88. Copenhagen: The Nordic Council of Ministers..Google Scholar
Landbruksdepartementet (1975) Om Norsk Matforsynings- og Ernæringspolitikk. Stortingsmelding (Norwegian Food Security and Nutrition Policy. White Paper) no.32 (1975–76) Oslo, Norway: Landbruksdepartementet..Google Scholar
Levenstein, HA (1988) Revolution at the Table. The Transformation of the American Diet. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press..Google Scholar
Lien, M (1990) The Norwegian Nutrition and Food Supply Policy. Accomplishments and Limitations of a Structural Approach. SIFO Report no. 4. Oslo, Norway: The National Institute for Consumer Research..Google Scholar
Margetts, B, Warm, D, Yngve, A, Sjöström, M (2001) Developing an evidence-based approach to Public Health Nutrition: translating evidence into policy. Public Health Nutrition 4, 1393–1397.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
McDougall, FL (1938) Food and welfare. League of Nations studies of nutrition and national economic policy. Geneva Studies 9, 9–56.Google Scholar
Milio, N (1990) Nutrition Policy of Food-rich Countries. A Strategic Analysis. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press..Google Scholar
Mills, M (1992) The Politics of Dietary Change. Aldershot: Dartmouth..Google Scholar
Murcott, A, Prättälä, R (1993) Comparing nutrition policies. A very small start. Regulating Markets, Regulating People. On Food and Nutrition Policy, pp. 37–46 [Kjærnes, U, editors]. Oslo, Norway: Novus Forlag..Google Scholar
Myrdal, G & Myrdal, A (1936) Krisen i Befolkningsspørsmålet (The Crisis in the Population Issue). Oslo, Norway: Tiden norsk Forlag..Google Scholar
Møller, IH (1994) Velfærdsstatens Udbygdning. Den Anden Socialreform 1933 (The Development of the Welfare State. The Second Social Reform 1933). Frederiksberg, Denmark: Samfundslitteratur..Google Scholar
Odin, M (1934) Sjukdomar och Sjukdomsfrekvens i Övre Norrland Särskilt med Hänsyn til Födans Sammansättning (Diseases and Disease Incidence in Upper Norrland with Particular Focus on the Dietary Composition). Lund, Sweden: Håkan Ohlssons Boktryckeri..Google Scholar
Palmblad, E & & Eriksson, BE (1995) Kropp och Politik. Hälsoupplysning som Samfunsspägel (Body and Politics. Health Education as a Mirror of Society). Stockholm, Sweden: Carlssons Bokförlag..Google Scholar
Pedersen, EH, Thullberg, P & & Tveite, S (1974) Nordens jordbruk under världskrisen 1929–1933 (Nordic Agriculture during the World Crisis 1929–1933). In Nordiska Historikermötet 1974. Mötesrapport (Nordic Meeting for Historians 1974. Meeting Point), 155–206 Uppsala, Sweden Uppsala: Universitet..Google Scholar
Riska, E (1993) The gendered character of professions in the field of nutrition. Regulating Markets, Regulating People. On Food and Nutrition Policy, pp. 171–186 [Kjærnes, U, editor]. Oslo, Norway: Novus Forlag..Google Scholar
Roos, G, Lean, M & Anderson, A (1997) Dietary interventions in Finland, Norway and Sweden: Lessons from Scotland. Part I. Trends in food consumption and diet-related disease. Health Bulletin 55, 432–443.Google Scholar
Roos, G, Lean, M & Anderson, A (2002) Dietary interventions in Finland, Norway and Sweden: nutrition policies and strategies. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 15, 99–110.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schmidt, LH & & Kristensen, JE (1986) Lys, Luft og Renlighed. Den Moderne Social-hygiejnes Fødsel (Light, Air and Cleanliness. The Birth of Modern Social Hygiene) København, Denmark: Akademisk Forlag..Google Scholar
Seip, AL (1984) Sosialhjelpstaten Blir Til. Norsk Sosialpolitikk 1740–1920 (The Emergence of the Social Service State. Norwegian Social Policy 1740–1920). Oslo, Norway: Gyldendal Norsk Forlag..Google Scholar
Sosialdepartementet (1981) Om Oppfølging av Norsk Ernæringspolitikk. Stortingsmelding nr.11 (1981–82) (The Follow-up of Norwegian Nutrition Policy. White Paper no.11 (1981–1982). Oslo, Norway: Sosialdepartementet.Google Scholar
Sosialdepartementet (1992) Utfordringer i Helsefremmende og Forebyggende Arbeid. Stortingsmelding nr.37 (1992–93) (Challenges in Health Promotion and Prevention. White Paper no. 37, 1992–93)). Oslo, Norway: Sosialdepartementet..Google Scholar
Statens, Husholdningsraad (1937) Beretning for Finansaaret 1936–37 (Report on the Financial Year 1936–37). København, Denmark: Indenrigsministeriet.Google Scholar
Steinmo, S, Thelen, K & & Longstreth, F (1992) Structuring Politics. Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press..CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zebich, ML (1979) The politics of nutrition: issue definition, agenda-setting, and policy formulation in the United States. Dissertation, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, USA..Google Scholar