Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T13:09:56.045Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Defining Nation and Religious Minorities in Russia and Turkey: A Comparative Analysis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 April 2010

Laman Tasch
Laman Tasch*
Affiliation:
Columbia College
*
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Laman Tasch, Department of Humanities, History, and Social Science, Columbia College, 624 S. Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL 60605. E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many countries today face the challenges posed by their ethnic and religious diversity. This article comparatively analyzes how defining nation in Russia and Turkey affects what groups constitute religious minorities and what their prospects of integration into the Russian and Turkish societies are. It conceptualizes religious minorities as those religious groups that are excluded from the prevailing and institutionalized definitions of nation. This article studies what role religion, comprising Orthodox Christianity, and Sunni Islam, respectively, has played historically and until nowadays in Russia and Turkey in the definitions of their national identities and what kind of religious minorities each of these definitions created. It argues that a position of religious minorities depends not only on the informal association of national identity of the majority with certain religion, but also on the institutionalized support for the dominant religion by the ruling political forces.

Type
Articles
Information
Politics and Religion , Volume 3 , Special Issue 2: Post-communist Eastern Europe and the Caucasus , August 2010 , pp. 327 - 351
Copyright
Copyright © Religion and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Ahmad, Feroz. 1988. “Islamic Reassertion in Turkey.” Third World Quarterly 10:750–769.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ahmad, Feroz. 1977. The Turkish Experiment in Democracy. London, UK: S. Hurst.Google Scholar
Akdoğan, Y. 2006. “The Meaning of Conservative Democratic Political Identity.” In The Emergence of a New Turkey. Democracy and the AK Party, ed. Yavuz, M. H.. Salt Lake City, UT: The University of Utah Press.Google Scholar
Akşin, Sina. 2007. Turkey. From Empire to Revolutionary Republic. The Emergence of Turkish Nation from 1789 to Present. New York, NY: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Allensworth, Wayne. 1998. The Russian Question. Nationalism, Modernization, and Post-Communist Russia. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
Anderson, John. 1994. Religion, State, and Politics in the Soviet Union and Successor States. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Antipova, N. 2007. “Prezident Fonda Istoricheskoy Perspectivy Nataliya Narochnitskaya: Zapad the Oslablyayet Usliyi Zakrepit Polupodchinennoye Polozheniye Rossiyi (President of the Foundation of the Historical Perspective Nataliya Narochnitskaya: West does not Diminish its Efforts to Reinforce Semi-Submissive Position of Russia).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/politclub/article3103235 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Arel, D. 2001. “Fixing Ethnicity in Identity Documents: The Rise and Fall of Passport Nationality in Russia.” In Report for the National Council for Eurasian and East European Research. http://www.ucis.pitt.edu/nceeer/2001-815-01g-2-Arel.pdf (Accessed March 13, 2010).Google Scholar
Ayata, S. 1996. “Patronage, Party and the State: The Politicization of Islam in Turkey.” Middle East Journal 50:40–56.Google Scholar
Beissinger, Mark R. 2002. Nationalist Mobilization and the Collapse of the Soviet State. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bekmakhanova, N. E. 2003. “Gosudarstvennoye Zakonodatelstvo I Narody Rossiyi (The State Legislature and Narody of Russia).” In Rossiysskaya Mnogonatsionalnaya Tsivilizatsiya: Yedinstvo i Protivorechiya (Russian Multinational Civilization: Unity and Contradictions), ed. Trepavlov, V. V.. Moscow, Russia: Nauka.Google Scholar
Bendix, J., Ollman, B., Bartholomew, H., Sparrow, Mitchell, and Timothy, P.. 1992. “Going Beyond the State?” The American Political Science Review 86(4):1007–1021.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bozkurt, G. 1996. Alman-Ingiliz Belgelerinin ve Siyasî Gelişmelerin Işığı Altında Gayrimüslim Vatandaşlarının Hukukî Durumu (1839–1914) (Legal Position of the Non-Muslim Citizens in the Light of the German-English Documents and Political Developments (1839–1914)). Ankara: Atatürk Kültür Dil ve Tarih Yüksek Kurumu, Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları.Google Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. 1994. “Rethinking Nationhood: Nation as Institutionalized Form, Practical Category, Contingent Event.” Contention 4(1):3–14.Google Scholar
Burguiere, Andre and Grew, Raymond. eds. 2004. The Construction of Minorities: Cases for Comparison across Time and Around the World. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Cagaptay, Soner. 2006a. “Passage to Turkishness: Immigration and Religion in Modern Turkey.” In Citizenship and Ethnic Conflict. Challenging the Nation-State, ed. Gülalp, H.. London, UK: Routledge.Google Scholar
Cagaptay, Soner. 2006b. Islam, Secularism and Nationalism in Modern Turkey: Who Is a Turk? London, UK: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Capotorti, F. 1991. Study on the Rights of Persons Belonging to Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities. New York, NY: United Nations Publications.Google Scholar
Cizre, Ümit. 2008. Secular and Islamic Politics in Turkey: The Making of the Justice and Development Party. London, UK: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Copeaux, E. 1998. Turk Tarih Tezinden Turk Islam Sentezine 1931–1993 (From the Turkish History Thesis to the Turkish Islamic Synthesis 1931–1993). Istanbul, Turkey: Tarih Vakfi Yurt Yayinlari.Google Scholar
Coskun, B. 2003. “The Triumph of an Islamic Party in Turkey: Effects of the Democratization Process on the Rise of the Justice and Development Party (AKP).” The Interdisciplinary Journal of International Studies 1(1):59–73.Google Scholar
Denli, O. 2007. “Freedom of Religion: Secularist Politics and Islamic Challenges.” In Human Rights in Turkey, eds. Kabasakal, Arat, and Zehra, T.. Philadelphia, PAUniversity of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Duman, D. 1999. Demokrasi Surecinde Turkiye'de Islamcilik (Islam in Turkey During the Process of Democratization). Izmir, Turkey: Dokuz Eylul Yayinlari.Google Scholar
Dumont, P. 1989. “La Periode des Tanzimat (1839–1878) (Period of Tanzimat (1839–1878)).” In Histoire de l”Empire Ottoman [History of Ottoman Empire], ed. Mantran, R.. Paris, France: Fayard.Google Scholar
Dunlop, John B. 1983. The Faces of Contemporary Russian Nationalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Erguder, U. 1991. “The Motherland Party, 1982–1989.” In The Political Parties and Democracy in Turkey, eds. Heper, M. and Landau, Jacob M.. London, UK: Tauris & Co Ltd.Google Scholar
Filatov, S. 2008. “Orthodoxy in Russia: Post-Atheist Faith.” Studies in World Christianity 14(3):187–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, J. 2000. “The Effects of Religious Discrimination on Ethno-Religious Protest and Rebellion.” The Journal of Conflict Studies 20(2):16–43.Google Scholar
Frolov, K. A. 2008. “Pravoslavnoye Soobshchestvo Epokhi Dmitriya Medvedeva (Orthodox Community of the Epoch of the Dmitriy Medvedev).” http://www.rus-proekt.ru/people/3565.html (Accessed March 13, 2008).Google Scholar
Gorenburg, D. P. 2003. Minority Ethnic Mobilization in the Russian Federation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gottlieb, Gideon. 1993. Nation against State. New York, NY: Council of Foreign Relations.Google Scholar
Grigoriadis, Ioannis N. 2007. “Tűrk or Tűrkiyeli? The Reform of Turkey's Minority Legislation and the Rediscovery of Ottomanism.” Middle Eastern Studies 43(3):423–438.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gurr, Ted R. 1993. Minorities at Risk. Washington, DC: United States Institution of Peace.Google Scholar
Gülalp, H. 2005. Kimlikler Siyaseti: Türkiye'de Siyasal Islamın Temelleri (The Politics of Identity: Foundations of Political Islam in Turkey). Istanbul, Turkey: Metis.Google Scholar
Hale, W. 2006. “Christian Democracy and the JDP. Parallels and Contrasts.” In The Emergence of a New Turkey. Democracy and the AK Party, ed. Yavuz, M. H.. Salt Lake City, UT: The University of Utah Press.Google Scholar
Hughes, J., and Sasse, G.. 2003. “Minotoring the Monitors: EU Enlargement Conditionality and Minority Protection in the CEECs.” JEMIE Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe 1(1):1–36.Google Scholar
Ignurov, V. ed. 2005. Antologiya Samizdata (Antology of Samizdat). Moscow, Russia: Mezhdunarodny Institut Gumanitarno-Politicheskikh Issledovaniy.Google Scholar
Jung, C. 2006. “Race, Ethnicity, Religion.” In The Oxford Handbook of Contextual Political Analysis, eds. Goodin, Robert E., and Tilly, C.. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Karasipahi, S. 2009. “Comparing Islamic Resurgence in Turkey and Iran.” The Middle East Journal 63(1):87–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kipp, Jacob W. 1994. “The Zhirinovsky Threat.” Foreign Affairs May/June.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kirişçi, K. 2000. “Disaggregating Turkish Citizenship and Immigration Practices,” Middle Eastern Studies 36(3):1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kula, M. 2005. “Communism as Religion,” Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions 6(3):371–381.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“Kurs “Osnovy Pravoslavnoy Kultury” Polza ili Vred? (Course “The Foundations of the Orthodox Culture.” Benefit or Harm?).” Novosti Federatsiyi. http://www.regions.ru/news/2003853 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Leskov, S. 2007a. “Akademik, Ruskovoditel Noggorodskoy Arkheologicheskoy Ekpeditsiyi Valentin Yanin: “V Novgorode Demokratiyu Sozhrali Oligarkhi (Academician Valentin Yanin, a head of the Novgorod Archeological Expedition: “In Novgorod Democracy was swallowed by Oligarchs).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/obshestvo/article3107985/ (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Leskov, S. 2007b. “Aleksandr Chubaryan, direktor of the Instituta Vseobshchey Istoriyi RAN: “Gosudarstvennost – Obshchaya Cherta Vsekh rezhimov v Rossiyi (Alexander Chubaryan, a director of the Institute of the General History of the RAS: “Statehood is a Common Feature of All Regimes in Russia).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/obshestvo/article3109437 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Leskov, S. 2008a. “Academik Abdusalam Guseynov: Progres Obeshchal Ray, a Prines Smertelnuyu Ugrozu (Academician Abdusalam Guseynov: Progress Promised Paradise, but Brought a Deadly Threat).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/obshestvo/article3122433 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Leskov, S. 2008b. “Direktor Instituta Arkheologiyi I Etnographiyi, Akademik Anatolliy Derevyanko: Vlast – ne Zhenshchina. Yeye Lyubit Ne Dolzhno (Director of the Institute of the Archeology and Ethnography, Academician Anatoliy Derevyanko: ‘Power is not a Woman; It Should not be Loved).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/science/article3111936 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Margulies, R., and Yildizoglu, R.. 1988. “The Political Uses of Islam in Turkey.” Middle East Report No. 153:12–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McCarthy, Justin. 1997. The Ottoman Turks. An Introductory History to 1923. London, UK: Longman.Google Scholar
McFarland, S. 1998. “Communism as Religion” International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 8:33–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“Ministerstvo Obrazovaniya I Nauki RF Vyrazilo Solidarnost s Protestantami I Katolikamu v Voprose o Prepodavaniyi Osnov Pravoslavnoy Kultury (Ministry of Education and Science Expressed Solidarity with the Protestants and Catholics on Question of Teaching The Foundations of the Orthodox Culture).” http://www.rlinfo.ru/press/pr20063108c.html (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Mitchell, T. 1991. “The Limits of the State. Beyond Statist Approach and their Critics.” American Political Science Review 85(1):77–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Öktem, K. 2008. “Being Muslim at the Margins: Alevis and AKP.” Middle East Report 246http://www.merip.org/mer/mer246/oktem.html (Accessed November 20, 2009).Google Scholar
Okutan, M. Ç. 2004. Tek Parti Döneminde Azınlık Politikaları (Minority Policies During the Period of One-Party Rule). Istanbul, Turkey: Bilgi University Publications.Google Scholar
Onar, N. 2007. “Kemalists, Islamists, and Liberals: Shifting Patterns of Confrontation and Consensus, 2002–2006.” Turkish Studies 8(2):273–288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oran, B. 2006. Türkiye'de Azınlıklar. Kavramlar, Teori, Lozan, Iç Mevzuat, Içtihat, Uygulama (Minorities in Turkey. Concepts, Theory, Content, Opinion, Application). Istanbul, Turkey: Iletişim.Google Scholar
Ozkirimli, U. 2000. Theories of Nationalism: A Critical Overview. Basingstoke, Turkey: Mcmillan.Google Scholar
Papkova, I. 2008. “Orthodox Religiosity among Elite University Students in Russia and its Relationship to their Political Views.” Religion in Eastern Europe XXVIII(2):1–17.Google Scholar
Parla, T., and Davison, A.. 2008. “Secularism and Laicism in Turkey.” In Secularisms, ed. Jakobsen, Janet R. and Pellegrini, A.. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Parland, T. 2005. The Extreme Nationalist Threat in Russia. New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Powell, David. 1975. Antireligious Propaganda in the Soviet Union: A Study of Mass Persuasion. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Preece, J. J. 1997. “National minority rights vs. state sovereignty in Europe: changing norms in international relations?” Nations and Nationalism 3(3):345–364.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ramet, Sabrina P. 1993a. “Preface.” In Religious Policy in the Soviet Union, ed. Ramet, Sabrina P.. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Ramet, Sabrina P. 1993b. “Religious Policy in the era of Gorbachev.” In Religious policy in the Soviet Union, ed. Ramet, Sabrina P.. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Riasanovsky, Nicholas V. 1959. Nicholas I and Official Nationality in Russia, 1825–1855. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Riasanovsky, Nicholas V. 2005. Russian Identities. A Historical Survey. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Saidazimova, G. 2008. “Turkey: Religious Officials Criticizes on Stance on Women.” Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty, June 4.Google Scholar
Service, R. 2003. Russia. Experiment with a People. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Shevtsov, V. S. 1969. Grazhdanstvo v Sovetskom Soyuznom Gosudarstve (Citizenship in the Soviet Union State). Moscow, Russia: Iuridicheskaia Literatura.Google Scholar
Shevtsov, V. S. 1970. Sovetskoye Grazhdanstvo i Gosudarstvenniy Suverenitet (Soviet Citizenship and State Sovereignty). Moscow, Russia: Nauka.Google Scholar
Shchuchenko, V. 2001. “Russkaya Kultura I Kultura Rossiyi: Nesliyannost I Nerazdelnost Ikh Istoricheskogo Bytiya (Russkaya Culture and Culture of Russia: Impossible to Merge and Impossible to Separate their Historical Existence).” In Russkaya Kultura I Kultura Rossiyi (Russian Culture and Culture of Russia), ed. Scchuchenko, V.St. Petersburg, Russia: SP6 GAK.Google Scholar
Siskova, A. 2008. “Russian Orthodox Church Sets Tone on Human Rights.” Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty June 30.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony D. 2001. Nationalism: Theory, Ideology, History. Malden, MA: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Smolkin, V. 2009. “‘Svyato Mesto Pusto Ne Byvayet:’ Ateisticheskoye Vospitaniye v Sovetskom Soyuze, 1964–1968. (‘Sacred Place does not Stay Empty:’ Atheist Upbringing in the Soviet Union, 1964–1968)” Intellectual Russia 3. http://www.intelros.ru/readroom/nz/-365-2009/4010-srjato-mesto-pusto-ne-byraet.html (Accessed November 20, 2009).Google Scholar
Sotsial'noe bogoslovie. http://www.soctheol.ru (Accessed March 13, 2010).Google Scholar
Spiliopoulou Akermark, A. 1997. Justifications of Minority Protection in International Law. London, UK: Kluwer Law International.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tepe, S. 2006. “A Pro-Islamic Party? Promises and Limits of Turkey's Justice and Development Party.” In The Emergence of a New Turkey. Democracy and the AK Party, ed. Yavuz, M. H.. Salt Lake City, UT: The University of Utah Press.Google Scholar
Thoms, Oscar N. T., and Ron, J. 2007. “Do Human Rights Violations Cause Internal Conflict?” Human Rights Quarterly 29(3):674–705.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tibi, B. 2006. “Europeanizing Islam or the Islamization of Europe: Political Democracy vs. Cultural Difference.” In Religion in an Expanding Europe, ed. Byrnes, Timothy A. & Katzenstein, Peter J.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tilly, Charles. 2005. Identities, Boundaries, and Social Ties. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Boundaries.Google Scholar
Tilly, Charles, and Goodin, Robert E.. 2006. “It depends.” In The Oxford Handbook of Contextual Political Analysis, ed. Goodin, Robert E. and Tilly, C.. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Tishkov, V. 2007. “Rossiyksiy Narod I Rossiyskaya Identichnost (Russian Nation and Russian Identity).” Izvestiya. http://www.izvestia.ru/obshestvo/article3105272 (Accessed March 15, 2009).Google Scholar
Tolz, Vera. 2004. “The Search for a National Identity in the Russia of Yeltsin and Putin.” In Restructuring Post-Communist Russia, ed. Brudny, Y., Frankel, J., and Hoffman, S.. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tunaya, T. Z. 1991. Islamcılık Akımı (Movement of Islamism). Istanbul, Turkey: Simavi Yayınları.Google Scholar
Vertigans, Stephen. 2003. Islamic Roots and Resurgence in Turkey: Understanding and Explaining the Muslim Resurgence. New York, NY: Praeger.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walters, Philip. 1993. “A Survey of Soviet Religious Policy.” In Religious policy in the Soviet Union, ed. Ramet, Sabrina P.. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wright, J. 1996. “The OSCE and the Protection of Minority Rights.” Human Rights Quarterly 18(1):190–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yakley, A. J. 2009. “Turkish PM Promises Reform to Religious Minorities.” Reuters August 15.Google Scholar