Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T16:47:27.513Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From Scotia to ‘Operation Tabarin’: developing British policy for Antarctica

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 October 2011

John R. Dudeney  and
David W.H. Walton
John R. Dudeney
Affiliation:
10 Church Lane, Wilburton, Cambridgeshire, CB6 3RQ
David W.H. Walton
Affiliation:
British Antarctic Survey, NERC, Madingley Road, Cambridgeshire, CB3 0ET ([email protected])
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The roots of a British Antarctic policy can be traced, paradoxically, back to the establishment of a meteorological station by the Scottish Antarctic Expedition in the South Orkneys, in 1903, and the indifference of the British Government to its almost immediate transfer to the Argentine Government. It was from that modest physical presence upon Laurie Island that Argentina came increasingly to challenge British claims to the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands Dependencies (FID), first in the late 1920s and then more extensively in the second world war. This challenge shaped British policy for the next forty years, with further complications caused by overlapping territorial claims made by Chile and the possible territorial ambitions of the USA. Britain's eventual response, at the height of World War II, was to establish permanent occupation of Antarctica from the southern summer of 1943–1944. This occupation was given the military codename Operation Tabarin. However, it was never a military operation as such, although monitoring the activities of enemy surface raiders and submarines provided a convenient cover story, as did scientific research once the operation became public. Whilst successive parties, rich in professional scientists, considerably expanded the pre-war survey and research of the Discovery Investigations Committee, their physical occupancy of the Antarctic islands and Peninsula was essentially a political statement, whereby the Admiralty and Colonial Office (CO) strove to protect British territorial rights, whilst the Foreign Office (FO) endeavoured to minimise disruption to Britain's long-standing economic and cultural ties with Argentina, and most critically, the shipment of war-time meat supplies. In meeting that immediate need, Tabarin also provided the basis from which Britain's subsequent post-war leadership in Antarctic affairs developed.

Type
Research Article
Information
Polar Record , Volume 48 , Issue 4 , October 2012 , pp. 342 - 360
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

TNA refers to The National Archives in London. FO refers to the Foreign Office and CO to the Colonial Office.Google Scholar
Acheson, A.B. 1943. Internal memorandum, 19 January 1943. TNA CO 78/215/7 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies 1943).Google Scholar
Allardyce, W.L. 1905. Letter from Governor of the Falkland Islands to CO, 27 July 1905. TNA FO 83/2092 (Foreign Office, general correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
Allardyce, W.L. 1906. Letter to the Secretary of State at CO, 26 February 1906. TNA FO 371/4 (General correspondence, Argentina 1906).Google Scholar
Amery, L.S. 1953. My political life. Vol. 2. London: HutchinsonGoogle Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1896. Discussion on Antarctic exploration. London: International Geographical Congress (Report of the sixth International Geographical Congress, 1895): 163–167.Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1927a. FO telegram to Sir M. Robertson, Buenos Aires, 14 December 1927. TNA CO 78/175/1 (Argentine wireless station 1927).Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1927b. Memorandum CP 313 (27). Printed for Cabinet, December 1927. TNA FO 371/11959 (General correspondence, Argentina 1927).Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1927c. Argentine claim to Falklands, South Georgia and South Orkneys, Conclusion of Cabinet meeting held on 14 December 1927. TNA FO 371/11959 (General correspondence, Argentine 1927).Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1943. From WGF Branch of the Admiralty to Mr Bryant at the CO, 25 September 1943. TNA CO 78/215/8 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies 1943).Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1944. ‘Strategic Value of the Antarctic’, undated. TNA ADM1/16103 (Correspondence, memoranda and paper, ‘Strategic value of the Antarctic’).Google Scholar
Anon. (Anonymous). 1946. Argentine and Chilean territorial claims in the Antarctic. Polar Record 4 (32): 412–441.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Armour, N. 1957. In: Foreign relations of the United States. (Vols. for 1940, Vol II). Washington DC, Government Printing Office: 337–338.Google Scholar
Auburn, F.M. 1982. Antarctic law and politics. London: Christopher Hurst.Google Scholar
Barnes, J., and Nicholson, D. (editors). 1980. The Leo Amery diaries. Vol. 1 1896–1929. London: Hutchinson.Google Scholar
Barton, J. 1945. Internal memorandum. 10 December 1945. TNA CO 78/217/16 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Preliminary arrangements for Survey 1945–1946).Google Scholar
Barton, J. 1947. Memorandum to Roberts-Wray and Doynton on claim to South Orkney Islands, 17 November 1947. TNA CO 537/2465 (CO Confidential commercial and confidential original correspondence).Google Scholar
Beck, P. 1983. British Antarctic policy in the early 20th century. Polar Record 21: 475–483.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beck, P. 1984. Britain and Antarctica: the historical perspective. Fram 1: 67–82.Google Scholar
Beckett, W. G. 1942. Memorandum, 16 September 1942. TNA FO 371/30313 (General correspondence, Argentina 1942).Google Scholar
Bertram, C. 1940. Letter to RA Wiseman, Dominions Office, 26 April 1940. TNA FO 371/24168 (General correspondence – Argentine claims 1940).Google Scholar
Brown, R.N.R. 1939. Antarctic history: a reply to Professor Hobbs. Scottish Geographical Magazine 55: 170–173.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruce, W.S. 1992. The log of the Scotia expedition, 1902–4. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Burgis, L.F. 1943. Notes of War Cabinet meetings. Cambridge: Churchill College Archives Centre Burgis 2/15.Google Scholar
Bush, W.M. 1982. Antarctica and international law. A collection of interstate and national documents. Dobbs Ferry: Oceana Publications.Google Scholar
Christie, E.W.H. 1951. The Antarctic problem. An historical and political study. London: Allen and Unwin.Google Scholar
Churchill, W.S. 1941. Letter to M.Subercaseaux, Embassy of Chile declining to recognise Chilean decree, 25 February 1941. TNA FO 371/25877 (FO General correspondence, Chilean claims to territory in Antarctica 1941).Google Scholar
Churchill, W.S. 1942a. Telegram to Prime Minister of Canada asking for help in protecting the Falklands, 13 January 1942. TNA PREM 3/141 (Falkland Islands 1941–1944).Google Scholar
Churchill, W.S. 1942b. Personal minute to General Ismay requiring a battalion to be found to garrison the Falklands, 1 April 1942. TNA PREM 3/141 (Falkland Islands 1941–1944).Google Scholar
Churchill, W.S. 1944. Personal minute to FO, 24 April 1944. TNA PREM 3/141 (Prime Minister's office: Falkland Islands 1941–44).Google Scholar
Comision Nacional del Antartico. 1948. Soberania Argentina en la Antartida. Buenos Aires: Ministerio de Relaciones Exteriores Y Culto.Google Scholar
Cordovez, E. 1943. Translation of report on the expedition made to the Antarctic on the Argentine transport Primero de Mayo. (From Naval attaché, Santiago, 23 August 1943). TNA CO 78/215/8 CO (Falkland Islands to 1951. Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies 1943).Google Scholar
Darnley, C. 1928. File memorandum on investments in Argentina, 6 February 1928 . TNA CO 78/178/9 (CO Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine Wireless Station 1928).Google Scholar
Dodds, K. 1997. Geopolitics in Antarctica: views from the Southern Oceanic rim. Chichester: John Wiley.Google Scholar
Dodds, K. 2002. Pink ice – Britain and the South Atlantic empire. London: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Dowdeswell, J. 2007. Scott Polar Research Institute. In: Riffenburgh, B. (editor). Encyclopedia of the Antarctic. New York: Routledge: 834–835.Google Scholar
Dudeney, J.R. 2007. British Antarctic Survey. In: Riffenburgh, B. (editor). Encyclopedia of the Antarctic. New York: Routledge, 188–190.Google Scholar
Eden, A. 1942a. Memorandum and draft protest note sent to British Ambassador in Buenos Aires (Hadow), 27 June 1942, TNA FO 371/30313 (General correspondence, Argentina 1942).Google Scholar
Eden, A. 1942b. Handwritten memorandum in response to minutes from J. Perowne concerning protests to Argentina. TNA FO 371/30313 (General correspondence, Argentina 1942).Google Scholar
Eden, A. 1944. Memorandum to Prime Minister PM/44/287, 27 April 1944. TNA PREM 3/141 (Prime Minister's office: Falkland Islands 1941–44).Google Scholar
Foreign Office. 1940. Falkland Islands and Dependences (in continuation of Confidential 14959), Confidential 15978. In: TNA FO 371/24168 (General correspondence, Argentine claims 1940).Google Scholar
Foreign Office. 1948. Correspondence respecting Antarctica, Part 1 January to December 1947. London; HMSO (Confidential print 17519, printed for the use of the Foreign Office).Google Scholar
Fuchs, V.E. 1982. Of ice and men. Shropshire: Anthony Nelson.Google Scholar
Grindle, G. 1927. File note setting out options to respond to Argentine Government. TNA CO 78/175/1 (Argentine wireless station 1927).Google Scholar
Gorst, E. 1906. Letter to resident Minister in Buenos Aires (F. D. Harford) on behalf of the Secretary of State at the Foreign Office, 31 March 1906. TNA FO 371/4 (General correspondence, Argentina, 1906).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1904a. Letter to Marquess of Lansdowne on Scottish National Antarctic Expedition, 5 January 1904. TNA FO 118/265 (Foreign Office. General correspondence of British Embassy, Argentina).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1904b. Letter to Marquess of Lansdowne on Scottish National Antarctic Expedition, 20 January 1904. TNA FO 83/1976 (Foreign Office. General correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1904c. Letter to the Marquess of Lansdowne, 7 July 1904. TNA FO 118/265 (to Foreign Office 1904, General correspondence of the British Embassy, Buenos Aires).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1905. Letter to Marquess of Lansdowne, 12 March 1905. TNA FO83/2092 (Foreign Office. General correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1906a. Letter to Manuel A. Montes de Oca, 23 August 1906. TNA FO 371/4 (Foreign Office. General correspondence, Argentina, 1906).Google Scholar
Haggard, W.H.D. 1906b. Letter to Foreign Secretary (Sir Edward Grey), 12 December 1906. TNA FO 371/194 (Foreign Office. General correspondence, Argentina political 1907).Google Scholar
Hanessian, J. 1965. National Interests in Antarctica. In: Hatherton, T. (editor). Antarctica. London: Methuen: 3–53.Google Scholar
Harford, F.D. 1905. Letter from the British Legation in Buenos Aires to Governor Allardyce, 2 November 1905. TNA FO83/2092. (Foreign Office. General correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
Hart, I.B. 1988. Pesca: a history of the pioneer modern whaling company in the Antarctic. Salcombe: Aiden Ellis.Google Scholar
Hayward, J.L. 1944a. Letter to R.A. Gallop at the Foreign Office, 26 April 1944. TNA FO 371/33729 (Falkland Islands and territorial claims in Antarctica 1944).Google Scholar
Hayward, J.L. 1944b. Memorandum to Mr Thornley, 21 Sept 1944, TNA CO 78/217/2 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falkland Islands 1944).Google Scholar
Headland, R.K. 2009. A chronology of Antarctic exploration. London: Quaritch.Google Scholar
Hinks, A.R. 1939. On some misrepresentations of Antarctic history. Geographical Journal 94: 309–330.Google Scholar
Hobbs, W.H. 1939. The discoveries of Antarctica within the American sector as revealed by maps and documents. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 31:1–71.Google Scholar
Hughes, C.E. 1924. Message from Secretary of State to Norwegian Minister, 2 April 1924. In: Foreign relations of the United States 1939. (Vols for 1924, Vol. II). Washington DC: Government Printing Office: 519.Google Scholar
Interdepartmental Committee on Research and Development in the Dependencies of the Falkland Islands. 1920. Report . British Parliamentary Papers. Cmd 657. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Kelly, D, 1943. Telegram to Foreign Office from Buenos Aires, 1 September 1943. TNA CO 78/215/8 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies 1943).Google Scholar
Kelly, D. 1952. The ruling few or the human background to diplomacy. London: Hollis and Carter.Google Scholar
Kitson, E.W. 1943. Letter of Proceedings. TNA CO 78/215/8 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies).Google Scholar
Landsdowne, Marquess of. 1904. Letter from Foreign Secretary to W.H.D. Haggard, 25 April 1904. TNA FO 118/264 (General correspondence of British embassy, Argentina).Google Scholar
Lothian, Lord. 1939a. Letter to the Foreign Secretary (Lord Halifax), 11 July 1939. FO 371/23992 (Foreign Office General correspondence, Antarctic expeditions 1939).Google Scholar
Lothian, Lord, 1939b. Letter to the Foreign Secretary (Lord Halifax). 18 July 1939. FO 371/23992 (Foreign Office General correspondence Antarctic expeditions 1939).Google Scholar
Lothian, Lord, 1939c. Message to Secretary of State, 17 November 1939. In: Foreign relations of the United States, 1956. (Vols. for 1939, Vol. II.) Washington DC: Government Printing Office: 10.Google Scholar
Lucas, C.P. 1904. Letter from the CO to Undersecretary of State at the Foreign Office, 16 April 1904. TNA FO 118/264 (Foreign Office. General correspondence of British Embassy, Argentina).Google Scholar
Lucas, C.P. 1905. Letter from CO to the Undersecretary of State at the Foreign Office, 3 August 1905. TNA FO 83/2092 (Foreign Office. General correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
MacGregor, E. 1904. Letter from the Admiralty to Undersecretary of State at the Foreign Office, 26 March 1904. TNA FO 118/264 (Foreign Office. General correspondence of British Embassy, Argentina).Google Scholar
Mackintosh, N.A. 1950. The work of the Discovery Committee. Proceedings of the Royal Society Series A, 202: 1–16.Google Scholar
Moneta, J.M. 1939. Cuatro anos en las Orcadas del Sur. Buenos Aires: Peuser.Google Scholar
Morrison, H.N. 1942, Letter to Trafford Smith at the CO, 26 November 1942. TNA ADM 116/4670 (Records of the Navy Board and the Board of the Admiralty, FID 1942–43).Google Scholar
Mossop, J. C. 1942a. Memorandum untitled, 22 April 1942. TNA ADM 116/4662 (Records of the Navy Board and the Board of the Admiralty, Deception Island 1939–1942).Google Scholar
Mossop, J.C. 1942b. Internal memorandum on behalf of the Head of Military Branch, TNA, ADM 116/4670 (Records of Navy Board and the Board of Admiralty, Falkland Islands Dependencies 1942–1943).Google Scholar
Mossop, J.C. 1942c, Memorandum untitled, 31 October 1942. TNA ADM 116/4670 (Records of the Navy Board and the Board of the Admiralty, FID 1942–43).Google Scholar
Mossop, J.C. 1943. Internal memorandum, 20 July 1943. TNA ADM 116/4931 (Records of the Navy Board and the Board of Admiralty, Falkland Islands Dependencies 1943–1944).Google Scholar
Officer, K. 1937, Letter to R.A. Wiseman, Dominions Office, from Department of External Affairs, Australia on 8 February 1937 providing draft reply to French suggestions on the limits of Adélie Land. TNA, CO 78/205/2 (Falkland Islands to 1951 – British territorial claims in the Antarctic 1937).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V. 1942a. Minute on British claim to South Orkneys, 13 February 1942. TNA FO 371/30311 (General correspondence – Argentina File 1942).Google Scholar
Perowne, JV. 1942b. Letter relaying Mr A. Eden's views to the Under Secretary of State at the CO, 23 October 1943. TNA FO 371/30323 (General correspondence – Argentina File 1942).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V. 1942c. Memorandum entitled Anglo-Argentine Relations, 15 December 1942. TNA CO78/215/7 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine Claim to the Falkland Island Dependencies 1943).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V. 1943a. Minute with respect to interdepartmental meeting on FID held on 12 January 1943. TNA 371/33525 (General correspondence – Argentina 1943).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V. 1943b. Letter to C.H.M. Waldock, 26 January 1943. TNA 371/33525 (General correspondence, Argentina 1943).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V.. 1944. Minute on Operation Tabarin activities and mail, 4 March 1944. TNA FO 371/37729, (General correspondence, Falkland Islands and territorial claims in Antarctica 1944).Google Scholar
Perowne, J.V. 1945, Letter to S.E.V. Luke, 29 March1945. TNA CO 78/217/6 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine and Chilean claim 1945).Google Scholar
Pirie, J.H.H. 1935. The first Antarctic post. South African Philatelist 1: 54–56.Google Scholar
Pirie, J.H.H. 1949. Antarctic posts and stamps. London: Stamp Collecting Ltd.Google Scholar
Roberts, B.B. 1940–1943. Diary of some aspects of work on cold climate equipment and clothing carried out for Service Departments at the Scott Polar Research Institute May 1940–June 1943. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 188BJ/82.Google Scholar
Roberts, B.B. 1943–1961. Correspondence and committee papers of ‘Operation Tabarin’ and the FID Survey 1943–61. Cambridge: Scott Polar Research Institute MS 1308/22/1Google Scholar
Roberts, B.B. 1944a. Minute to Mr Gallop on questions raised about Operation Tabarin, 8 August 1944. TNA FO 371/37730 (Foreign Office, General correspondence Falkland Islands and territorial claims in Antarctica 1944).Google Scholar
Roberts, B.B. 1944b. Minute to Mr Beckett, 27 September 1944. TNA FO 371/37730 (Foreign Office, General correspondence Falkland Islands and territorial claims in Antarctica 1944).Google Scholar
Roosevelt, F.D. 1939. Letter to the commanding officer of the United States Antarctic Service. In: Foreign Relations of the United States 1956 (Vols. for 1939, Vol II). Washington DC: Government Printing Office: 11Google Scholar
Snow, T.M. 1928. Letter to Under Secretary of State, Colonial Office from Under Secretary of State, Foreign Office re wireless station in South Orkneys, 22 February 1928. TNA CO 78/178/9 (Falklands Islands to 1951 - Argentine wireless station 1928).Google Scholar
Speak, P. 2003. William Speirs Bruce. Polar explorer and Scottish nationalist. Edinburgh: National Museums of Scotland.Google Scholar
Stanley, O. 1943. Letter to the Governor of the Falkland Islands, 3 November 1943. TNA CO 78/215/9 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine claim to the Falklands and Dependencies).Google Scholar
Stanley, O. 1945. Telegram to the Governor of the Falkland Islands, 17 July 1945. Cambridge: BAS Archive AD8/1/12(1) item 47.Google Scholar
Terry, J.A. 1904. Letter from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Worship, Argentine Republic, to W Haggard, 8 January 1904. TNA FO 83/1976 (Foreign Office, General correspondence before 1906).Google Scholar
Townley, W.B. 1907a. Letter to Dr Estanislao S. Zeballos, 4 January 1907. TNA FO 371/194 (Foreign Office, General correspondence, Argentina political 1907).Google Scholar
Townley, W.B. 1907b, Letter to Foreign Secretary (Sir Edward Grey), 10 January 1907. TNA FO 371/194 (Foreign Office, General orrespondence, Argentina political 1907).Google Scholar
Tower, R. 1913. Letter to Governor Allardyce, 13 June 1913. TNA, FO 371/1871 (General correspondence, Miscellaneous General/American General 1913).Google Scholar
Tower, R. 1915. Letter to Sir Edward Grey from Buenos Aires Embassy, 1 February 1915. TNA FO 371/2239/24310 (Wireless station on South Orkney Islands).Google Scholar
Waldock, C.H.M. 1942. Letter to Mr R A Gallop, 9 October 1942. TNA ADM 116/4670 (Records of the Navy Board and the Board of the Admiralty, Falkland Island Dependencies 1942–1943).Google Scholar
Waldock, C.H.M. 1948. Disputed sovereignty in the Falkland Islands Dependencies, in: The year book of international law 1948. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 214–353.Google Scholar
Wells, S. 1939. Message to the British Ambassador (Lothian), 7 December 1939. In: Foreign relations of the United States 1956 (Vols for 1939, II, 15). Washington DC: Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Wordie, J.M. 1945. Letter to S.E.V. Luke, 19 March 1945. TNA CO 78/217/6 (Falkland Islands to 1951, Argentine and Chilean claim 1945).Google Scholar
Wordie, J.M. 1947. The FID Survey 1943–46. Polar Record 4: 372–384.Google Scholar