Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T04:09:33.580Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Composers, Trends and the Question of Nationality in Nineteenth-Century Musical Greece

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 June 2011

Haris Xanthoudakis
Haris Xanthoudakis*
Affiliation:
Ionian University
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The question of a European-type local music was raised in modern Greece as early as during the first years of its independent life, and within the context of a rapid Occidentalizing and modernizing process. The earliest Greek professional musicians to serve this social, as well as ideological, need came from the Ionian Islands, but soon other parts of the national territory saw the birth of some important composers who added specific German, French or Russian components to the basically Italianate flavour of the Ionian musical tradition. In their respective works the main trends of nineteenth-century European music found their Greek way, although a sparse use of local folk elements was only gradually, hesitantly, and – in any case – partially accepted by a middle-class public, willing to keep its distance from its own Ottoman past. It was mainly for that reason that a Herderian-type musical nationalism, although already visible around 1850, had to wait until the end of the century before obtaining its clear and definite shape, and before occupying the central Greek musical scene during the early years of the new age.

Type
Research Article
Information
Nineteenth-Century Music Review , Volume 8 , Issue 1: Music in Nineteenth-Century Greece , 27 June 2011 , pp. 41 - 55
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Panayotakis, Nikolaos M., Frangiskos Leondaritis (Venice, 1990Google Scholar).

2 Panayotakis, Nikolaos M., ‘Martyries gia tin mousiki stin Kriti kata ti Venetokratia’ [‘Evidences about Music in Venetian-held Crete’], Thesaurismata 20 (1990): 9–169Google Scholar.

3 Kardamis, Kostas, ‘Music in the Ionian Islands’ History and Culture of the Ionian Islands (Region of the Ionian Islands, 2008): 360Google Scholar. For details about the composers mentioned in the present text, see Kostas Kardamis, ibid., as well as Leotsakos’, George ‘Greece, § III, 1: Art Music since 1770’ in The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, ed. Stanley Sadie, 2nd ed., vol. 10 (London: Macmillan Publishers Limited, 2001): 349–351Google Scholar.

4 Kostantzos, Georgios, Konstantinos Agathofron Nikolopoulos (PhD diss., Ionian University, Corfu, 2009)Google Scholar.

5 For details on Mantzaros, see Kostas Kardamis, Nikolaos Chalikiopoulos Mantzaros (Corfu, 2008).

6 Xanthoudakis, Haris, Kardamis, Kostas (eds), Nikolaos Chalikiopoulos Mantzaros (Corfu, 2003): 195–201Google Scholar.

7 Rapporto del Cav. N. Calichiopulo Manzaro, Presidente della Musica della Società Filarmonica in Corfù, relativo al dono di alcune opere di Monsigny e Grétry (Corfu, 1851).

8 Mindler, Joseph M., Hymne an die Freiheit, ed. Hans-B. Schlumm, Andreas Kertscher, Konstantinos Zervopoulos (Paderborn, 2010): 33–40Google Scholar.

9 See Samson, Jim, ‘Nations and Nationalism’ in The Cambridge History of Nineteenth-Century Music, ed. Jim Samson (Cambridge, 2002): 570–571Google Scholar.

10 Xanthoudakis, Haris, ‘O poietis tis Aria Greca’ [‘The Poet of Aria Greca’], Mousikos Logos 7 (Summer, 2006): 51Google Scholar.

11 Xepapadakou, Avra, ‘O Markos Botzaris tou Pavlou Carrer: mia “ethniki” opera’ [‘Markos Botzaris by Pavlos Carrer: a “National” Opera’], Mousikos Logos 5 (Summer 2003): 27–63Google Scholar (pp. 27–28).

12 Domeneginis in 1849; Liberalis in 1857; Tzannis-Metaxas in 1873. However, it is probable that Tzannis-Metaxas’ piece was composed quite earlier.

13 We know at least one opera with the same title composed by a foreigner; see Synadinos, Theodoros, Istoria tis Ellinikis Mousikis, 1824–1919 [History of Greek Music, 1824–1919] (Athens, 1919): 88–89Google Scholar.

14 Leotsakos, Giorgos, Pavlos Carrer, Apomnimoneuta kai Ergographia [Pavlos Carrer, Memoirs and Works] (Athens, 2003): 32Google Scholar.

15 See Kourbana, Stella, ‘The Birth of Music Criticism in Greece: The Case of the Historian Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos’, Nineteenth-Century Music Review 8/1 (this issue)Google Scholar.

16 Serouios, Georgios, Calliope (Hermoupolis, 1845): 86Google Scholar.

17 Foustanos, Ioannis, Armonia kai Melodia [Harmony and Melody] (Hermoupolis, 1887)Google Scholar: η′.

18 A fragment of this letter appears as an appendix in Foustanos, ibid.

19 In Xepapadakou, ‘O Markos Botzaris’, 42 (note 4).

20 Hermoupolis 120 (31 Dec. 1866), 122 (12 Jan. 1867), 125 (2 Feb. 1867).

21 Meaning, vaguely, the popular musical styles developed within the boundaries of the Ottoman Empire, under the influence of its ‘official’ music. See Pekka Pennanen, Risto, ‘The Nationalization of Ottoman Popular Music in Greece’, Ethnomusicology 48/1 (2004): 1–25Google Scholar.

22 Leotsakos, Pavlos Carrer, 117.

23 On Hypopsifios see Kardamis, Kostas, ‘O Hypopsifios tou Spiridonos Xynda: Mia apopira epanektimisis’ [‘Spiridonos Xynda's Hypopsifios: A Re-evaluation’], Chronika tis Aestitikis [Annals of Aesthetics] 43 (2005–06): 121–129Google Scholar.

24 Padovan, Domenico, ‘Poche Parole sopra i scritti del Cav. Nicolò C. Manzaro’, I Phoni 361 (12 Apr. 1872): 2–3Google Scholar (p. 2).

25 See his letter addressed to Ioannis Foustanos, published as an appendix, after Carrer's letter, in Foustanos, Armoniá.

26 Leotsakos, Giorgos, ‘Dimitios Lalas, O Makedonas mathitis kai ikios tou Richard Wagner (1844–1911)’ [‘Dimitrios Lalas, Richard Wagner's Macedonian Pupil and Intimate (1844–1911)’], O Wagner kai i Ellada [Wagner and Greece] (Athens, 1992): 207–45Google Scholar.

27 Kelkel, Manfred, Naturalisme, Verisme et Réalisme dans l'Opéra (Paris, 1984): 248, 365–366Google Scholar.

28 ‘Life, life always and everywhere, even in the vagueness of song’.

29 Xanthoudakis, Haris, ‘O Georgios Pachtikos kai i mousiki gia to Archaio Elliniko Drama’ [‘Georgios Pachtikos and his Music for the Ancient Greek Drama’], Parastaseis Archaiou Ellinikou Dramatos stin Evropi kata tous neoterous chronous [Performances of Ancient Greek Dramas in Europe in Modern Times] (Athens, 1999): 47–51Google Scholar.

30 Lambelet, Georgios, ‘I Ethniki Mousiki’ [‘National Music’], Ta Panathinaia 2 (1901): 82–90Google Scholar, 126–31.

31 See Kokkonis, Georges, La Question de la grécité dans la musique néohellénique (Paris 2008)Google Scholar.