Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T20:44:20.208Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The term “Macedonian(s)” in Ottoman Macedonia: on the map and in the mind

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Maria Pandevska
Maria Pandevska*
Affiliation:
Institute of National History, Saints Cyril and Methodius University of Skopje, Republic of Macedonia
*
∗Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In this article I analyze the term “Macedonian(s)” based on the discourse of the Macedonian Revolutionary Organization (1893–1908) from the aspect of the internal understanding of the term as a supra-local and supra-church identity. Another matter for analysis in this article is that of the stereotypes in the interpretation of Macedonian historical processes inherited from the nineteenth century, still present in some contemporary historiographies. Hence, the article makes an attempt to bring down the stereotype about the existence of some unique Macedonian ethnic phenomenon known as the “Macedonian salad.” This article also deals with the significance of the geopolitical position of Ottoman Macedonia within the empire. More specifically, the emphasis is placed on the change of its position after the Great Eastern Crisis (1875–1881). Namely, for the first time since the Ottoman conquests in the Middle Ages, Macedonia's position within the empire changed from being a central to a peripheral Ottoman province, with all the advantages and disadvantages that this change brought about. This aspect of Macedonian historical reality is often neglected in the historiography.

Keywords

Ottoman EmpireOttoman MacedoniaMacedonian(s)supra-local identitysupra-church identitylabelingethnonym
Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 40 , Issue 5 , September 2012 , pp. 747 - 766
Copyright
Copyright © 2012 Association for the Study of Nationalities 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Adanir, Fikret. Makedonskijat văpros [The Macedonian Question]. Sofia: Amicitia, 2002. (Bulgarian translation of Die Makedonische Frage: Ihre Entstehung und Entwicklung bis 1908. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner, 1979). Print.Google Scholar
Andonov-Poljanski, Hristo, ed. Documents on the Struggle of the Macedonian People for Independence and Nation-State. Vol. I. Skopje: Univerzitet “Kiril i Metodij,” 1985. Print.Google Scholar
Barth, Fredrik. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: The Social Organization of Culture Difference. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 1969. Print.Google Scholar
Baskalov, A.N., et al. Türcç-Rusça Sözlük. Moskva/Istanbul: Izdatelstvo Ruskiij Jazik/Sosyal Yayinlar, 1977/1989. Print.Google Scholar
Berthelot, Marcellin, et al. Pour l'Arménie et Macédoine: Manifestations Franco-Anglo-Italiennes. Paris: Société nouvelle de librairie et d'édition, 1904. Print.Google Scholar
Bitovski, Krste. Makedonija i Knezevstvoto Bugarija, 1893–1903 [Macedonia and the Principality of Bulgaria, 1893–1903]. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 1977. Print.Google Scholar
Bitovski, Krste. Makedonija vo vremeto na Golemata istochna kriza, 1875–1888 [Macedonia in the Period of the Great Eastern Crisis, 1875–1888]. Skopje: Studentski zbor, 1982. Print.Google Scholar
Bogdanović, Dimitrije. Knjiga o Kosovu [A Book about Kosovo]. Beograd: Srpska akademija nauka i umetnosti, 1986. Print.Google Scholar
Bozeva-Abazi, Katrin. The Shaping of Bulgarian and Serbian National Identities, 1800–1900. Skopje: Institute of National History, 2007. Print.Google Scholar
Brailsford, Henry. Macedonia: Its Races and Its Future. London: Methuen, 1906. Print.Google Scholar
Brubaker, Rogers. Ethnicity without Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 2004. Print.Google Scholar
Delchev, Goce. Pisma i drugi materiali [Letters and Other Materials]. Sofia: Kiosev Dino, 1967. Print.Google Scholar
Delchev, Goce. Prepiska [Correspondence]. Ed. Hristo Andonov-Poljanski. Skopje: Kultura, 1972. Print.Google Scholar
Dvizenieto otsm Vardara i borbata s Vrhovistite, po spomeni na Jane Sandanski, Chernopeev, Sava Mihailov, Hr. Kuslev, Iv. Anastasov — Grcheto, Petar Iorukov i Nikola Pushkarov [The Movement from the Other Side of Vardar River and the War with the Vrhovists, from the Memoirs of Jane Sandanski, Chernopeev, Sava Mihailov, Hr. Kuslev, Iv. Anastasov –Grcheto, Petar Iorukov i Nikola Pushkarov], Materiali za istoriata na makedonskoto osvoboditelno dvizenie, Vol. VII. Sofia: 1927. Print.Google Scholar
Makedonec, Edin, [P. Bošnakov]. “Blgarskata propaganda v Makedonia” [Bulgarian Propaganda in Macedonia]. Kustendil: Izgrev, 25 Nov. 1901. Print.Google Scholar
Hanioglu, Sukru M. A Brief History of the Late Ottoman Empire. Princeton: Princeton UP, 2007. Print.Google Scholar
Hroch, Miroslav. Social Preconditions of the National Revival in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of the Social Composition of the Patriotic Group among the Smaller European Nations. translated by Ben Fowkes. New York: Columbia UP, 2000. Print.Google Scholar
Jordanovski, Nikola. “Some Considerations about the 19th Century National Revival in Macedonia.” Miejsce Macedonii na Balkanach, Historia - Polityka - Kultura - Nauka. Ed. Stawowy-Kawki, Ireny. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, 2005. 199–208. Print.Google Scholar
Kiosev, Dino G. Istorija na makedonskoto nacionalno revolucionno dvizenie [History of the Macedonian National Revolutionary Movement]. Sofia: Izdatelstvo na Nacionalnija săvet na Otechestvenija front, 1954. Print.Google Scholar
Lange-Akhund, Nadine. The Macedonian Question, 1893–1908, from Western Sources. Boulder, CO: East European Monographs, 1998. Print.Google Scholar
“Macedonia.” Encyclopaedia Britannica. London: William Benton, 1967. Print.Google Scholar
Makedonski pregled [Macedonian Review], Sofia: 25 May 1905. Print.Google Scholar
Marinov, Tchavdar. “‘We, the Macedonians': The Paths of Macedonian Supra-nationalism, 1878–1912.” We, the People: Politics of National Peculiarity in Southeastern Europe. Ed. Mishkova, Diana. Budapest: CEU, 2009. 107–39. Print.Google Scholar
Michalidis, Iakov D. “The War of Statistics: Traditional Recipes for the Preparation of the Macedonian Salad.” East European Quarterly 31.1 (1998): 9–12.Google Scholar
Minoski, Mihailo. “Prilog kon prashanjeto na imeto na Makedonskata revolucionerna organizacija vo pochetniot period na nejzinoto dejstvuvanje, 1893–1896” [A Contribution to the Question Concerning the Name of the Macedonian Revolutionary Organization at the Beginning of its Activity, 1893–1896]. Prilozi na Makedonska akademija na naukite i umetnostite 26.2 (1995): 62–71. Print.Google Scholar
Nikolić, Vidosava. “Arhivski prilozi za izučavanja etničkih, socijalnih i ekonomskih prilika u Prokuplju, 1877–78” [Archives Contributions for Research of the Ethnic, Social and Economic Conditions in Prokuplje, 1877–78]. Arhivski almanah 4 (1962): 57–84. Print.Google Scholar
Okrăžno do revolucionnite organizacii v Maleševsko, Džumaisko i Petričko, Taen Centralen Makedono — Odrinski Revolucion. Komitet, Juni 1902 godina [Circular to the Revolutionary Organizations in Maleshevo, Dzumaja and Petrich Regions, Secret Central Macedono-Adrianople Revolutionary Committee, June 1902]. Sofia: Cyril and Methodius National Library, Bulgarian Historical Archives, fund. 224, a.e. 49. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria. “Na patot kon Ilinden: Ustavot na TMORO i negovoto datiranje” [On the Way to Ilinden: The Constitution of SMORO and Its Dating]. 100 godini Ilinden 1903–2003. Ed. Todorovski, Gane. Skopje: Makedonska akademija na naukite i umetnostite, 2005. 141–54. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria. “Periodizacija velikogo vostočnogo krizisa, 1875–1881” [Periodization of the Great Eastern Crisis, 1875–1881]. Balkanot i Rusija: Opštoto i specifičnoto vo istoriskiot i kulturniot razvitok (prilozi od zaedničkiot proekt pomegju Institutot za nacionalna istorija i Institutot za slavistika pri RAN). Ed. Todor Cepreganov and Elena Guskova. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 2010. 23–34. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria. Prisilni migracii vo Makedonija vo godinite na Golemata istochna kriza, 1875–1881 [Forced Migrations in Macedonia in the Years of the Great Eastern Crisis, 1875–1881]. Skopje: Knigoizdatelstvo Misla i Institut za nacionalna istorija, 1993. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria. Strumichki revolucioneren okrug, 1893–1903 [Strumica Revolutionary District, 1893–1903]. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 2002. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria. “Tranziciite vo makedonskoto nacionalnoosloboditelno dvizenje, 1893 —1908: niz teorijata na Miroslav Hroch” [Transitions in the Macedonian National Liberation Movement, 1893–1908: Trough the Theory of Miroslav Hroch]. Tranziciite vo istorijata i kulturata. Ed. Cepreganov, Todor. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 2008. 171–86. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevska, Maria, and Mitrova, Makedonka. “Misinterpreting the Concept of Ottoman Millet in Dictionaries.” Workshop: Macedonia. Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity, Gottingen, 21 Nov. 2010.Google Scholar
Pandevski, Manol. “Makedonskata revolucionerna organizacija megju, 1893–1918: formiranje i razvitok” [Macedonian Revolutionary Organization, 1893–1918: Creation and Development]. Sto godini od osnovanjeto na VMRO i 90 godini od Ilindenskoto vostanie. Ed. Bogoev, Ksente. Skopje: Makedonska akademija na naukite i umetnostite, 1994. 21–44. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevski, Manol. Makedonskoto osloboditelno delo vo XIX i XX vek. Nacionalnoto prashanje vo makedonskoto osloboditelno dvizenje, 1893–1903 [Macedonian Liberation Movement in the 19th and 20th Century. The National Question in the Macedonian Liberation Movement, 1893–1903]. Skopje: Knigoizdatelstvo Misla, 1987. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevski, Manol, ed. Makedonofilskoto dvizenje vo Zapadna Evropa vo 1903 godina — dokumenti. Le Mouvement Macedonophile en Europe Occidentale en 1903 — Documens [The Macedonofhile Movement in Western Europe in 1903 - Documents]. Skopje: Arhiv na Makedonija i Knigoizdatelstvo Matica Makedonska, 1995. Print.Google Scholar
Pandevski, Manol. Programski i statutarni dokumenti na Vnateshnata makedonska revolucionerna organizacija (1904–1908) [Program and Statutory Documents of the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization (1904–1908)]. Skopje: Makedonska akademija na naukite i umetnostite, 1998. Print.Google Scholar
Perry, Duncan M. The Politics of Terror: The Macedonian Liberation Movements, 1893–1903. Durham, NC: Duke UP, 1988. Print.Google Scholar
Petrov, Gjorche. “Makedonskoto osvoboditelno delo na blgarska pochva” [Macedonian Liberation Movement on Bulgarian Soil]. Sofia: Pravo, 23 Sep. 1902. Print.Google Scholar
Petrov-Rusinski, Nikola. Spomeni [Memoirs]. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 1997. Print.Google Scholar
Politicheska svoboda. Organ na makedonskite socialisti-revolucioneri [Political Freedom. Newspaper of the Macedonian Socialist and Revolutionaries]. Sofia: 6 Fev 1898. Print.Google Scholar
Pop Trajkov, Lazar. Lokvata i Vinjari. Skopje: Publishing House Matica Makedonska, 1993. Print.Google Scholar
Poutignat, Philippe, and Streiff-Frenart, Jocelyne. Theories de l'Ethnicité. Paris: P.U.F., 1995. Print.Google Scholar
Razdolov, Atanas. Sloboda ili smrt, buntovni pesni [Freedom or Death: Poems of Revolt]. Izbor, prepev i predgovor Gane Todorovski. Skopje: Knigoizdatelstvo Matica Makedonska, 1992. Print.Google Scholar
Redhouse, James W. A Turkish and English Lexicon. Constantinopole: Printed for the American Mission by A.H. Boyajian, 1890. Print.Google Scholar
Rossos, Andrew. Macedonia and the Macedonians: A History. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution P, Stanford U, 2008. Print.Google Scholar
Said, Edward W. Orientalism. New York: Penguin Books 2003. Print.Google Scholar
Smith, Anthony D. National Identity. London: Penguin, 1991. Print.Google Scholar
Spomeni na Gjorche Petrov [Memoirs of Gjorche Petrov]. Matrijali za makedonskata nacional — revolucija. Skopje: Naučen institut za nacionalna istorija na makedonskiot narod, 1950. Print.Google Scholar
Spomeni — S. Arsov, P. Kljašev, L. Džerov, G. P. Hristov, A. Andreev, G. Popanchev, L. Dimitrov [Memoirs — S. Arsov, P. Kljašev, L. Džerov, G. P. Hristov, A. Andreev, G. Popanchev, L. Dimitrov]. Skopje: Kultura, 1997. Print.Google Scholar
Svedoštva za makedonskiot identitet, XVIII — XX vek [Testimonies for the Macedonian Identity, 18th–20th Centuries]. Skopje: Institut za nacionalna istorija, 2010. Print.Google Scholar
Tomoski, Tomo, ed. Dokumenti od Vienskata arhiva za Makedonija od 1879–1903 [Documents from the Vienna archives for Macedonia 1879–1903]. Skopje: INI, 1955. Print.Google Scholar
Tully, James. Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity, 1988. Print.Google Scholar
Vardarski [P. Pop Arsov]. Stambolovshtinata v Makedonia i neizinite pretstaviteli [Stambolovism in Macedonia and Its Representatives], Viena, 1894. Print.Google Scholar
White, George W. Nationalism and Territory: Constructing Group Identity in Southeastern Europe. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield, 2000. Print.Google Scholar
Wilkinson, R.H. Maps and Politics: A review of Ethnographic Cartography of Macedonia. Liverpool, UK: University, 1951. Print.Google Scholar
Zenker, Theodor J. Türkisch - Arabisch - Persiisches Handwörterbuch. Leipzig: Wilhelm Engelmann, 1876. Print.Google Scholar
Zundhausen, Holm. Istorija Srbije od 19. do 20. veka. Beograd: Clio, 2009. Print.Google Scholar