Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-19T17:05:08.413Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

In Search of Ideology: The Politics of Religion and Nationalism in the New Russia (1991–1996)

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Vladimir Wozniuk
Vladimir Wozniuk*
Affiliation:
Western New England College, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Just after becoming the first-ever successful, democratically re-elected President of Russia, Boris Yel'tsin ambitiously called for creating, within the next year, a new ideology that would reflect the new state of affairs in Russia—in essence, he was calling for “re-imagining,” or reinventing, the foundations upon which Russian national community is based. With this directive, Yel'tsin was confirming something that had already become clear to many observers of Russian politics: post-Soviet Russian political life not only continued to resist democratization and pluralism, but also appeared to exhibit signs of discomfort without an officially-sanctioned ideological reference point by which the political players could set their compasses. The Kremlin's quest for a restoration of Russia's credibility as a great power included serious consideration of religion, specifically Russian Orthodoxy, playing a leading role in helping to reformulate an ideology acceptable to diverse communities within Russia in order to replace the now-defunct Marxist–Leninist ideology of the Soviet state. The old French adage “plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose” seems particularly appropriate for the new Russia in its efforts to regain credibility as a great power, along with the prestige and respect to which it had become accustomed. This article examines the dynamics of the Russian search for a new ideology in order to help restore its credibility as a great power, as suggested by Yel'tsin's call for a new “national idea.” But the search for a new ideology began well before Yel'tsin made this statement, and, therefore, the following discussion focuses on the interplay between religion and politics in this quest, covering the first five years of a reconstituted, post-Soviet Russia, that is, the time period roughly from the collapse of the Soviet Union up to the Duma (parliament) elections of December 1995 and the two-stage presidential elections of June-July 1996.

Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 25 , Issue 2 , June 1997 , pp. 195 - 210
Copyright
Copyright © 1997 Association for the Study of Nationalities of Eastern Europe 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1. ITAR-TASS, 12 July 1996. In his book Imagined Communities, Benedict Anderson reflects on the “imagined linkage” of events and ideas that constitute the identity of national communities. See Benedict Anderson, Imagined Communities (London: Verso, 1983).Google Scholar

2. Among the many sources on religious and secular messianism, see for example Nichols, Robert L. and Stavrou, Theofanis George, Russian Orthodoxy under the Old Regime (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1978); Pospielovsky, Dimitry, “The ‘Russian Orientation’ and the Orthodox Church: From the Early Slavophiles to the ‘Neo-Slavophiles’ in the USSR,” in Ramet, Pedro, ed., Religion and Nationalism in Soviet and East European Politics (Durham: Duke University Press, 1989); Tucker, Robert, Political Culture and Leadership in Soviet Russia: From Lenin to Gorbachev (New York: Norton, 1987); Hammer, Darrell, Russian Nationalism and Soviet Politics (Boulder: Westview, 1989); Kubalkova, Vendulka and Cruickshank, Albert, Marxism and International Relations (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989), especially pp. 69–97.Google Scholar

3. I have in mind here especially Ukraine, Moldova, Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania.Google Scholar

4. Pospielovsky, ibid.; also see Zernov, Nikolai, Russkoe religioznoe vozrozhdenie XX veka (Paris: YMCA Press, 1974) [The Russian Religious Renaissance of the Twentieth Century].Google Scholar

5. For a stimulating discussion of “stages” in the development of national consciousness, see Hroch, Miroslav, Social Preconditions of National Revival in Europe (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1985).Google Scholar

6. See for example the final section of his last work, Tri Razgovora o voine, progresse, i mire, s kratkoi povest'iu ob Antikhriste s prilozheniiami (St. Peterburg: Trud, 1900) [Three Conversations on War, Progress and Peace, with a Brief Tale about the Antichrist with Addenda].Google Scholar

7. See for example Vladimir Solov'ev, S., “Narodnost' s nravstvennoi tochki zreniia,” Vestnik Evropy, January 1895, pp. 354–355 (“Nationality from a Moral Point of View,” Messenger of Europe); also see Nravstvennost' i politika, 1883 (Morality and Politics).Google Scholar

8. Ibid., “Nationality …,” (my translation).Google Scholar

9. See the discussion in Oxana Antic, “Developments in Church Life,” Radio Free Europe-Radio Liberty (RFE-RL) Research Report, 3 January 1992.Google Scholar

10. See for example, Slater, Wendy, “The Russian Orthodox Church,” RFE-RL Research Report, 14 May 1993.Google Scholar

11. On the KGB at high levels of the Church, see Dunlop, John B., “KGB Subversion of Russian Orthodox Church,” RFE-RL Research Report, 20 March 1992. On the process of restoring church credibility, see Antic, Oxana, “Orthodox Church Reacts to Criticism of KGB Links,” RFE-RL Research Report, 5 June 1992.Google Scholar

12. See for example, Ageschev, Yuri, “From our Mail: Anti-orthodoxy,” Literaturnaia Rossiia, 21 August 1992, in Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press (CDPSP), Vol. 44, No. 36, 7 October 1992, p. 18.Google Scholar

13. “Fear False Prophets,” Sovetskaia Rossiia, 29 August 1992. The letter was dated 23 August 1992.Google Scholar

14. Yermolayev, M., “The Pope Destroyed the Soviet Union. Will Cardinal Glemp Destroy Russia?” Literaturnaia Rossiia, 18 August 1992, in CDPSP, Vol. 44, No. 36, 7 October 1992, p. 19.Google Scholar

15. Vdovin, Gennady, “Viewpoint: Plus the Clericalization of the Entire Country,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 12 September 1992, in CDPSP, Vol. 44, No. 20, 7 October 1992, p. 20. For a more balanced perspective on protestant missionary work in Russia, see Nezhnii, Aleksandr, “A Protestant Works to Revitalize Russia,” Izvestiia, 9 September 1992 (also in Ibid.).Google Scholar

16. According to Yel'tsin adviser, Stankevich, Sergei, in 1994 church influence in State affairs had indeed increased to alarming levels. Medvedev, A., “Orthodox Church Instead of Communist Party,” Moscow News, 24 January 1994, p. 6.Google Scholar

17. Wishnevsky, Julia, “Proposes New State Ideology,” RFE-RL Daily Report, No. 189, 5 October 1994. The interview was conducted on 4 October.Google Scholar

18. Socor, Vladimir, “Leadership Consensus on ‘Great-Power Patriotism,’” RFE-RL Daily Report, No. 219, 18 November 1994. The meeting took place on 17 November.Google Scholar

19. Arbatov was quoted by the Financial Times, 17 November 1994. See ibid.Google Scholar

20. ITAR-TASS, 4 December 1995, as reported in Paretskaya, Anna, “Candidates attend Orthodox Church Conference on Russia's Future,” Open Media Research Institute Daily Digest (OMRIDD), No. 235, Part I, 5 December 1995.Google Scholar

21. Ibid. Zhirinovsky might also have been taking a cue from Aleksandr Lukashenko, President of Belarus', who earlier had declared Russian Orthodoxy to be the official religion of that country. On Belarus', See Sayenkov, Larisa, “Which Faith Is Better?” Moscow News, 4 August 1995, p. 4.Google Scholar

22. ITAR-TASS, 6 November 1994, as reported in Socor, Vladimir, “Pan-Orthodox Forum Established,” RFE-RL Daily Report, No. 212, 8 November 1994. Representatives attended from Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova, Georgia, Armenia, Romania, Bulgaria, Serbia and Montenegro, and Greece.Google Scholar

23. Cited in Ibid.Google Scholar

24. On Greece's own problems squaring Orthodoxy with rigorous Western European requirements in terms of human rights, see Pollis, Adamantia, “Eastern Orthodoxy and Human Rights,” Human Rights Quarterly, Vol. 15, No. 2, May 1993, pp. 339–356. Russia was indeed finally admitted to the Council of Europe in January 1996, the Russian Duma ratifying membership in February.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

25. Yasmann, Victor, “Yeltsin meets with Solzhenitsyn and Aleksii II,” RFE-RL Daily Report, No. 219, 18 November 1994.Google Scholar

26. During a 13 March interview with Duma Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Vladimir Lukin on Russian TV. Cited by Belin, Laura, “Solzhenitsyn: Russia Becoming a ‘Colony’ of the West,” OMRIDD, No. 53, Part I, 15 March 1995.Google Scholar

27. Ibid. Solzhenitsyn mentioned by name the scientific and cultural grants sponsored by multi-millionaire philanthropist George Soros. See also Price, Thomas, “Foreign Missionaries Should be Banned from Russia!” Moscow News, 4 February 1994, p. 6, which outlines earlier similar criticisms.Google Scholar

28. Shusharin, Dmitri, “Appointment: Render Under Caeser,” Segodnya, 28 July 1995, in CDPSP, Vol. 47, No. 31, 30 August 1995, p. 19.Google Scholar

29. Cited in Ibid.Google Scholar

30. Ibid. Krasikov's reference was specifically to Vitalii Savitsky's and Vladimir Zhirinovsky's attempts to grant Orthodoxy an “official” standing in the State.Google Scholar

31. Cited in Ibid.Google Scholar

32. On its mediating role, see for example Slater, Wendy, “The Church's Attempts to Mediate in the Russian Crisis,” RFE-RL Research Report, 29 October 1993.Google Scholar

33. Rodin, Ivan, “Russian Federation Supreme Soviet Solves Problems of Proselytism,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 15 July 1993, in CDPSP, 11 August 1993, p. 26.Google Scholar

34. Cited in Morvant, Peggy, “Yakovlev on Communist Repression of Religion,” OMRIDD, No. 230, Part I, 28 November 1995.Google Scholar

35. Ibid.Google Scholar

36. Wozniuk, Vladimir, “The Propaganda Campaign for a New Orthodoxy in Soviet Social Science,” Political Communication, Vol. 6, No. 3, 1989, pp. 249–268.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

37. Izvestiia, 24 October 1995, p. 2.Google Scholar

38. Cited in Orttung, Robert, “Muslim Party Denounces Western Influences,” OMRI Special Report: Russian Election Survey, 5 December 1995.Google Scholar

39. Ibid.Google Scholar

40. Korolyov, Aleksandr, “Lord of Hosts Have Mercy on Us,” Trud, 6 December 1994, in CDPSP, 11 January 1995, Vol. 46, No. 50, p. 24.Google Scholar

41. Feofanov, Yuri, “The Patriarch's Message to Draftees,” source>Izvestiia, 12 October 1995, p. 1. See also, ITAR-TASS, 10 October 1995, as cited by Dmitriev, Constantine, “Patriarch Urges Russian Youth to Join the Service,” OMRIDD, No. 198, Part I, 11 October 1995.Google Scholar

42. Izvestiia, ibid.Google Scholar

43. Sokolov, Maksim, “The Barbarization of Eastern Orthodoxy,” Kommersant Daily, 9 September 1995, in CDPSP, Vol. 47, No. 36, 4 October 1995, p. 22. For an account illustrating this point, see the story about the christening of a submarine, in Ptichkin, Sergei, “How a Submarine was Christened,” Rossiiskaia gazeta, 5 September 1995, in Ibid.Google Scholar

44. Ibid, Sokolov.Google Scholar

45. Livshits, Aleksandr, economic adviser to Yeltsin. See Freeland, Christina, “Church of Christ the Savior is Becoming a Symbol of Russian Capitalism,” Finansovaia izvestiia, 29 August 1995, in CDPSP, 4 October 1995, pp. 22–23. Meanwhile, the Russian Capital City Savings Bank had donated many kilograms of Gold for the guilding of the church's domes. See “Gold from Bank for Domes,” Rossiskie vesti, 19 August 1995, in ibid.Google Scholar

46. Savitskii was speaking on a radio call-in program on 16 November 1995. See Belin, Laura, “Savitskiii Warns of Dangers of ‘Immoral’ Parliament,” OMRIDD, No. 222, Part I, 14 November 1995.Google Scholar

47. Ibid. This situation began to be substantively addressed in early 1996.Google Scholar

48. Ibid.Google Scholar

49. ITAR-TASS, as cited by Constantine Dmitriev, “Federation Council Turns Down Changes to Conscription Law,” OMRIDD, No. 246, Part I, 29 December 1995. The key point concerned including exemptions to any draftee with a single parent over 52 years of age.Google Scholar

50. Rodin, Ivan, “Russian Federation Supreme Soviet Solves Problem of Proselytism,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 15 July 1993, in CDPSP, Vol. 45, 11 August 1993, p. 26.Google Scholar

51. “Fear False Prophets,” also Bychkov, Sergei, “The Troubled Summer of 1992,” Moscow News, 8 November 1992, p. 2; also Slater, Wendy and Engelbrekt, Kjell, “Eastern Orthodoxy Defends Its Position,” RFE-RL Research Report, September 1993.Google Scholar

52. See for example, Price, Thomas, “Foreign Missionaries Should Be Banned from Russia!” Moscow News, 4 February 1994, p. 6. On the brotherhoods, see Antic, Oxana, “Revival of Orthodox Brotherhoods in Russia,” RFE-RL Research Report, 13 March 1992.Google Scholar

53. ITAR-TASS, 21 December 1995, as cited in Rutland, Peter, “Sects Infiltrating Schools,” OMRIDD, No. 249, Part I, 27 December 1995.Google Scholar

54. See the interview with Aleksii II in Romanov, Pyotr, “What Christianity Will Take into the 21st Century,” Kommersant Daily, 9 June 1995, as reported in CDPSP, Vol 47, No. 23, 5 July 1995, p. 22.Google Scholar

55. Zheludkov, Arkady, “Aum Shinrikyo Leaders Officialy Claim the Sect's Russian Branch To Be Independent of the Japanese,” Izvestiia, 23 March 1995, p. 2.Google Scholar

56. For details on the trial and sentencing of cult leaders, see Lapychak, Chrystyna “Doomsday Cult Leaders Sentenced in Ukraine,” OMRIDD, No. 30, Part II, 12 February 1996.Google Scholar

57. Reported by Ukrainian TV and Reuters, 9 February 1996, cited in ibid.Google Scholar

58. Ibid.Google Scholar

59. Solodov, Aleksandr, “Orthodox Church Houses Extremist Sects,” Moscow News, 19 May 1995, p. 13; and also Oxana Antic, “Revival of Orthodox Brotherhoods …”Google Scholar

60. Reported by AFP and RFE/RL, as cited by Scott Parrish, “Jewish Organization Protests Ban,” OMRIDD, 2 May 1996. On the conference, see Robert Orttung, “Conference Examines Role of Nationalism,” OMRIDD, 30 March 1996.Google Scholar

61. Ibid.Google Scholar

62. ITAR-TASS, 11 April 1996; and Zavtra, No. 17, May 1996. See also OMRI Presidential Election Survey, 16 May 1996.Google Scholar

63. Kommersant Daily, 14 May 1996.Google Scholar

64. Sovetskaia Rossiia, 13 June 1996, pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

65. Paretskaya, Anna, “Russian Muslims Unite,” OMRIDD, 2 May 1996. See also ITAR-TASS, 1 July 1996.Google Scholar

66. Sovetskaiia Rossiia, 29 June 1996, p. 1; Komsomolskaiia Pravda, 29 June 1996, pp. 1–2. See also Zhuganov, Gennady, “Together We Will Revive Russia,” Pravda, 1 July 1996; and Belin, Laura, “Zyuganov Promises to Halt Russia's Spiritual Decline,” in OMRI Presidential Election Survey, 2 July 1996.Google Scholar

67. Cited by Belin, in Ibid.Google Scholar

68. ITAR-TASS, 12 May 1996, as cited in ibid.Google Scholar

69. Penny Morvant “Lebed … Scorns Foreign Religious Sects,” OMRIDD, 28 June 1996; also “Japanese Preacher Expelled from Russia,” OMRIDD, 2 July 1996.Google Scholar

70. This was in response to a question I posed to the visiting group. The one exception was the representive of the Jewish faith, Shaevich, Rabbi Adolf Solomonovich, Chief Rabbi of Russia. Those supporting greater controls included Kondrusiewicz, Archbishop Tadeusz, Apostolic Administrator for Catholics of the Latin Rite in European Russia; Konovalchik, Pastor Peter B., President of the Union of Evangelical Christians-Baptist in the Russian Federation; and Archpriest Victor Petliuchenko, Deputy Chairman of the Department of External Church Relations of the Russian Orthodox Church, Moscow Patriarchate.Google Scholar

71. AFP, 1 July 1996, as cited by Peter Rutland, “Jewish Leader Denied Visa,” OMRIDD, 2 July 1996. See also Morvant, Penny, “Nazdratenko Threatens Foreign Religious Groups,” OMRIDD, 2 August 1996.Google Scholar