Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-l7hp2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T21:50:18.009Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ALFRED FOUILLÉE BETWEEN SCIENCE AND SPIRITUALISM

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 October 2014

LARRY S. MCGRATH
LARRY S. MCGRATH*
Affiliation:
The Humanities Center, Johns Hopkins University E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This essay examines the rapprochement between science and metaphysics that the French philosopher Alfred Fouillée staged in his writings from 1872 up until his death in 1912. Amidst the influx of new research in scientific psychology inundating France in the late nineteenth century, Fouillée's thought stands out for its creative effort to advance a new spiritualist philosophy on the basis of positive scientific advancements. Fouillée's work is significant for intellectual historians of thought in the fin de siècle because it challenges the common historiographical narrative, initially presented in H. Stuart Hughes's Consciousness and Society, which erroneously frames spiritualist thinkers, Henri Bergson chief among them, as leading a “revolt against positivism.” Fouillée throws into stark relief a new spiritualist current that incorporated research in the natural and human sciences from across Europe in order to craft an updated understanding of consciousness. This essay treats Fouillée's work as a historical window onto a distinctly new spiritualism whose proponents sought to overcome the old spiritualism of Victor Cousin's eclectic school, which shunned any naturalist underpinning of metaphysics. While Fouillée has already been widely historicized as a social and political thinker, this essay introduces original archival materials that help to resituate Fouillée as a leading figure of the new spiritualism animating French philosophy in the final quarter of the nineteenth century.

Type
Articles
Information
Modern Intellectual History , Volume 12 , Issue 2 , August 2015 , pp. 295 - 323
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Fouillée, Alfred, “La crise actuelle de la métaphysique. I—La métaphysique et la poésie de l’idéal,” Revue des deux mondes, 86 (1888), 110–40, 110Google Scholar, original emphasis. All translations from the original French are my own unless otherwise noted.

2 Hughes, H. Stuart, Consciousness and Society: The Reorientation of European Social Thought, 1890–1930 (New York, 1958), 33–66Google Scholar. Hughes uses the term “positivism” in a loose sense “to characterize the whole tendency to discuss human behavior in terms of analogies drawn from natural science.” Ibid., 37.

3 Goldstein, Jan, The Post-revolutionary Self: Politics and Psyche in France, 1750–1850 (Cambridge, MA, 2005), 6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Janet, Paul, “Une nouvelle phase de la philosophie spiritualiste,” Revue des deux mondes, 108 (1873), 383Google Scholar.

5 Fouillée, Alfred, “La philosophie des idées-forces: comme conciliation du naturalisme et de l’idéalisme,” Revue philosophique, 8 (1879), 1–32Google Scholar.

6 Lindenfeld, Davidcritiques Hughes on similar grounds, though he does not mention French spiritualism, in The Transformation of Positivism: Alexius Meinong and European Thought, 1880–1920 (Berkeley, CA, 1980), 7Google Scholar.

7 Gronin, R. C. depicts the spiritualist period as a religious revival in The Bergsonian Controversy in France, 1900–1914 (Calgary, 1988), 1–20Google Scholar.

8 Burrow, J. W., The Crisis of Reason: European Thought, 1848–191 (New Haven, 2000), 56–67Google Scholar.

9 Winders, James A., European Culture since 1848, from Modern to Postmodern and Beyond (New York, 2001), 94Google Scholar.

10 Laqueur, Thomas, “Why the Margins Matter: Occultism and the Making of Modernity,” Modern Intellectual History, 3/1 (2006), 112CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 The thinkers that Kloppenberg identifies in his configuration are Fouillée, Alfred, Dilthey, Wilhelm, Green, Thomas Hill, Sidgwick, Henry, James, William, Dewey, John. and Kloppenberg, James, Uncertain Victory: Social Democracy and Progressivism in European and American Thought, 1870–1920 (New York, 1988)Google Scholar.

12 Ibid., 26.

13 Logue, William, From Philosophy to Sociology: The Evolution of French Liberalism, 1870–1914 (Dekalb, IL, 1983), 10Google Scholar.

14 Scott, John A., Republican Ideas and the Liberal Tradition in France, 1870–1914 (New York, 1966), 159–69Google Scholar.

15 Among American historians, Hayward, J. E. S. has pursued the most sustained analysis of “solidarity” in Fouillée: “Solidarity: The Social History of an Idea in Nineteenth Century France,” International Review of Social History, 4 (1959), 261–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hayward, , “‘Solidarity’ and the Reformist Sociology of Alfred Fouillée I,” American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 22/1 (January 1963), 205–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hayward, , “‘Solidarity’ and the Reformist Sociology of Alfred Fouillée II,” American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 22/2 (March 1963), 303–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar; also see Rosanvallon, Pierre, Le modèle politique français: Société civile contre la jacobinisme de 1789 à nos jours (Paris, 2004)Google Scholar; Spitz, Jean-Fabien, Le moment républicain en France (Paris, 2005)Google Scholar; Blais, Marie-Claude, La solidarité: Histoire d’une idée (Paris, 2007)Google Scholar.

16 Fedi, Laurent, “Entre organicisme et individualisme, la concurrence des philosophes sociales, en France, vers 1900,” Frédéric Worms, ed., in Le moment 1900 en philosophie (Lille, 2004), 370Google Scholar.

17 Fouillée to Ferdinand Brunetière, 22 Aug. 1902, Fonds Brunetière, Bibliothèque nationale de France, NAF 25038.

18 My biography draws from Guyau, Augustin, La philosophie et la sociologie d’Alfred Fouillée (Paris, 1913)Google Scholar.

19 Fouillée, Alfred, La philosophie de Platon: Exposition, histoire et critique de la théorie des idées (Paris, 1869), 728Google Scholar.

20 La République française, 26 Dec. 1872, article not signed.

21 Guyau, La philosophie et la sociologie d’Alfred Fouillée, xii.

22 Ibid., xiii.

23 See most recently Onfray, Michel, La construction du surhomme: Jean-Marie Guyau, Friedrich Nietzsche (Paris, 2011)Google Scholar.

24 Michon, John A., Pouthas, Viviane, and Jackson, Janet L., Guyau and the Idea of Time (Amsterdam and New York, 1988), 19–22Google Scholar.

25 Ozouf, Jacques and Ozouf, Mona, “Le tour de la France par deux enfants,” in Pierre Nora and David P. Jordan, eds., Les lieux de mémoire, vol. 1 (Paris, 1997), 290Google Scholar.

26 Ribot, Thédolue, “Philosophy in France,” Mind, 2/7 (1877), 372, 369Google Scholar.

27 See Nietzsche's copy, Zweistimmigkeit–Einstimmigkeit: Friedrich Nietzsche und Jean-Marie Guyau, ed. Hans Erich Lampl (Cuxhaven, 1990).

28 Quoted in Guyau, La philosophie et la sociologie d’Alfred Fouillée, xv.

29 Ibid.

30 Tarde, Gabriel, “Compte rendu de A. Fouillée, La morale, l’art et la religion d’àpres M. Guyau,” Revue philosophique, 28 (1889), 183Google Scholar.

31 Petrovici, Jean, “Le centenaire d’Alfred Fouillée,” Revue de métaphysique et de morale, 46/4 (1939), 662Google Scholar.

32 See Fouillée, Alfred, Esquisse psychologique des peuples européens (Paris, 1903)Google Scholar.

33 Azouvi, François and Bourel, Dominique, “Avant Propos,” in François Azouvi and Dominique Bourel, eds., De Königsberg à Paris: La reception de Kant en France (1788–1804) (Paris, 1991), 10–11Google Scholar.

34 See Cousin, Victor, “Souvenirs d’Allemagne,” Revue des deux mondes, 64 (1866), 594–620Google Scholar.

35 Victor Cousin, Elements of Psychology, trans. C. S. Henry (Hartford, CT, 1834), 406.

36 Lachelier, Jules, Sur le fondement de l’induction, 2nd edn (Paris, 1896)Google Scholar.

37 Frank, Adolphe, Dictionnaire des sciences philosophiques, 2nd edn (Paris, 1875), 1071Google Scholar.

38 Ibid., 422.

39 Fouillée, Alfred, La liberté et le déterminisme (Paris, 1884), 232Google Scholar.

40 Cousin, Victor, Cours de philosophie sur le fondement des idées absolue du vrai, du beau et du bien, ed. Garnier, Adolphe (Paris, 1836), 12Google Scholar.

41 Fouillée, Alfred, “Le néo-Kantisme en France: I—le moral criticiste,” Revue philosophique, 11 (1881), 3Google Scholar.

42 See Logue, William, Charles Renouvier, Philosopher of Liberty (Baton Rouge, LA, 1992)Google Scholar.

43 Darlu, Alphonse, “La liberté et le déterminisme selon M. Fouillée,” Revue philosophique, 23 (1887), 563Google Scholar.

44 Fouillée, La liberté et le déterminisme, 245.

45 Ibid.

46 See Revill, Joel, “Emile Boutroux, Redefining Science and Faith in the Third Republic,” Modern Intellectual History, 6 (2009), 485–512CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47 Fouillée to Renouvier, 4 June 1888, in Corpus: Revue de philosophie, 53, ed. Jean Lawruszenko and Jordi Riba (2008), 261, original emphasis.

48 Fouillée, Alfred, Le mouvement idéaliste et la réaction contre la science positive, 2nd edn (Paris, 1896), xviiGoogle Scholar.

49 Burrow, The Crisis of Reason, 54.

50 Simon, W. M. argues that Comtian positivism had found few adherents in France by the 1880s in European Positivism in the Nineteenth Century (Ithaca, NY, 1963)Google Scholar.

51 Egger, Victor, “La psychologie physiologique,” Revue philosophique, 5 (1878), 233Google Scholar.

52 Ibid.

53 Richet, Charles, “Sur la méthode de la psychologie physiologique,” Revue philosophique, 5 (1878), 33Google Scholar.

54 Fouillée to Ernest Havet, 8 March 1883, Fonds Havet, Bibliothèque nationale de France, NAF 24474, original emphasis.

55 Dominique Janicaud, Une genealogie du spiritualisme français. Aux sources du bergsonisme: Ravaisson et la métaphysique (Le Haye, 1969); later re-edited and published as Ravaisson et la métaphysique: Une généalogie du spiritualisme français (Paris, 1998).

56 See Antliff, Mark, Inventing Bergson: Cultural Politics and the Parisian Avant-Garde (Princeton, NY, 1993)Google Scholar; Gillies, Mary Ann, Henri Bergson and British Modernism (Montreal, 1996)Google Scholar; Gontarski, S. E., Ardoin, Paul, and Marrison, Laci, eds., Understanding Bergson, Understanding Modernism (New York, 2012)Google Scholar.

57 Seigel, Jerrold, The Idea of the Self: Thought and Experience in Western Europe since the Seventeenth Century (Cambridge, 2005), 251CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Henri Gouhier originally used the term “spiritualist positivism” to characterize French spiritualism in the last quarter of the nineteenth century. See the “Introduction” to Oeuvres choisies de Maine de Biran (Paris, 1942), 22.

58 Fouillée, Alfred, La pensée et les nouvelles écoles anti-intellectualistes (Paris, 1911), 347Google Scholar.

59 Vacherot, Étienne, Le nouveau spiritualisme (Paris, 1884), i, original emphasisGoogle Scholar.

60 For a discussion of France's exception from European interest in Darwin see Cannon, H. Graham, The Evolution of Living Things (Manchester, 1958), 17–20Google Scholar.

61 Spencer, Herbert, Principles of Psychology (London, 1855), 517CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 Ibid., 620.

63 Fouillée, Alfred, L’evolutionnisme des idées-forces (Paris, 1890), xxxiiGoogle Scholar.

64 Ibid., original emphasis.

65 Ibid., xliv.

66 Ibid., xi, original emphasis.

67 Ibid., liv, original emphasis.

68 Ibid., 196.

69 Contini, Annamaria, “L’intelligence créatrice: Puissance et volonté de conscience dans la philosophie d’Alfred Fouillée,” Corpus, 53 (2008), 43Google Scholar.

70 See Solms, Mark and Turnbull, Oliver, The Brain and the Inner World: An Introduction to the Neuroscience of Subjective Experience (New York, 2002), 116Google Scholar.

71 Young, Robert, Mind, Brain, and Adaptation in the Nineteenth Century (New York, 1990), 93Google Scholar.

72 Fouillée, L’evolutionnisme des idées-forces, xliv, original emphasis. The standard translation of pâtir is “to suffer from,” but I have translated it as “being passive” in order to better capture the obverse active and passive modalities of the will.

73 Becquemont, Daniel and Mucchielli, Laurent, Le cas Spencer (Paris, 1998), 273Google Scholar.

74 Bergson, Henri, Time and Free Will: An Essay on the Immediate Data of Consciousness, trans. Pogson, F. L. (New York, 2001), 128, original emphasisGoogle Scholar.

75 Bergson, Henri, La pensée et le mouvant (Paris, 1934), 8Google Scholar.

76 Bergson, Time and Free Will, 196.

77 Fouillée, L’evolutionnisme des idées-forces, liv.

78 Worms, Frédéric, La philosophie en France au XXe siècle (Paris, 2011), 37, original emphasisGoogle Scholar.

79 Ibid., 39, original emphasis.

80 Fouillée, L’evolutionnisme des idées-forces, lix, original emphasis.

81 Ibid., original emphasis.

82 Ibid.

83 Guyau, La philosophie et la sociologie d’Alfred Fouillée, 88.

84 Ibid.

85 Nicolas, Serge and Charvillat, Agnès, “Introducing Psychology as an Academic Discipline in France: Théodule Ribot and the Collège de France (1888–1901),” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 37/2 (2001), 151CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 Roth, Michael S., “Remembering Forgetting: Maladies de la Mémoire in Nineteenth-Century France,” Representations, 26 (1989), 50CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

87 Ribot, Théodule, Les maladies de la mémoire (Paris, 1880), 1Google Scholar.

88 Ibid., 83.

89 Fouillée, Alfred, “Introduction,” in Guyau, Jean Marie, La genèse de l’idée du temps (Paris, 1890), xxxiiGoogle Scholar.

90 Kant, Immanuel, Critique of Pure Reason, trans. Norman Kemp Smith (Basingstoke, 1933), 77Google Scholar.

91 Fouillée, Alfred, “La mémoire et la reconnaissance des idées,” Revue des deux mondes, 70 (1885), 146Google Scholar.

92 Ribot, Les maladies de la mémoire, 36.

93 Ibid., 39.

94 Fouillée, “La mémoire et la reconnaissance des idées,” 146.

95 Fouillée, Alfred, “La survivance et la sélection des idées dans la mémoire,” Revue des deux mondes, 69 (1885), 367Google Scholar.

96 Ibid., 362–3.

97 Fouillée, “La mémoire et la reconnaissance des idées,” 147; Ribot, Les maladies de la mémoire, 41.

98 Guyau, La genèse de l’idée du temps, 50.

99 Ibid., 50.

100 Ibid., 117.

101 Fouillée, “La mémoire et la reconnaissance des idées,” 148.

102 Ibid., 160

103 Bergson, Henri, “Analyse de l’ouvrage de Guyau: La genèse de l’idée de temps avec un introduction par Albert [sic] Fouillée,” Revue philosophique, 31 (1891), 187Google Scholar.

104 Bergson, Henri, Matter and Memory, trans. Margaret Paul and W. Scott Palmer (London, 1911), 112, original emphasisGoogle Scholar.

105 Guyau, La philosophie et la sociologie d’Alfred Fouillée, 88.