Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t7czq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T23:17:26.616Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Dynamics of Memory and Religious Nationalism in a Sino-Vietnamese Border Town

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 September 2019

TAM T. T. NGO
TAM T. T. NGO*
Affiliation:
Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity; Department of Comparative Religious Studies, Faculty of Philosophy, Theology, and Religious Studies, Radboud University Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article analyses the dynamics of official and unofficial religious nationalism in the Vietnamese border town of Lào Cai. In 1979 it was one of many Vietnamese towns that were reduced to rubble during the short but bloody war between Vietnam and China. The normalization of Sino-Vietnamese relations in 1991 allowed a booming border trade that let Lào Cai prosper, while the painful memory of this war continued to haunt the town and the daily experiences of its residents, both humans and gods. Since the Vietnamese state forbids any official remembrance of the war, Lào Cai residents have found a religious way to deal with their war memories that skilfully evades state control. By analysing narratives about the fate of the gods and goddesses that reign in the Father God Temple and the Mother Goddess Temple—two religious institutions located right next to the border—this article shows that it is in the symbolism of the supernatural that one can find memories of the war and of the changing social landscape of Lào Cai and reconstruct its history.

Type
Research Article
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 54 , Issue 3 , May 2020 , pp. 795 - 829
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

I would like to thank Ken MacLean, Peter van der Veer, Laurel Kendall, Wu Da, and Hue Tam Ho-Tai for their constructive comments, and Kenneth Dean for his insightful comments and translation of the imperial edicts.

References

1 The Đạo Mẫu, formerly known as the Four Palaces cult [Tứ Phủ] or Mother Religion, is a religious tradition that emphasizes the worship of Mother Goddess Liễu Hạnh as the highest and most important deity in the pantheon of Vietnamese indigenous spirits and deities. The Saint Trần cult started after Trần Hưng Đạo defeated the invading Mongol and Chinese armies in the thirteenth century.

2 Baud, Michiel and Schendel, Willem van, ‘Toward a comparative history of borderlands’, Journal of World History, vol. 8, no. 2, 1997, p. 211CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Nora, Pierre, Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past. Vol. 3, Symbols, Goldhammer, Arthur (trans.), Kritzman, Lawrence D. (ed.), Columbia University Press, New York, 1998Google Scholar.

4 Jing, Jun, Temple of Memories: History, Power and Morality in a Chinese Village, Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1996Google Scholar.

5 Berdahl, Daphne, Where the World Ended: Re-unification and Identity in the German Borderland, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1999, pp. 3–9Google Scholar.

6 Winichakul, Thongchai, Siam Mapped: A History of the Geo-body of a Nation, University of Hawai‘i Press, Honolulu, 1994, pp. 16–19Google Scholar; Turner, Frederic Jackson, ‘The significance of the frontier in American history’ (1894), in Selected Essays of Frederic Jackson Turner, Billington, R. A. (ed.), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1961, pp. 37–63Google Scholar.

7 Admiraal, Beth, ‘Religion and national identity in borderlands: a case study of Greek Catholics and Hungarian Reformed in Transylvania’, Occasional Papers on Religion in Eastern Europe, vol. 35, no. 3, 2015, pp. 17–42Google Scholar.

8 Ngo, Tam T. T., The New Way: Protestantism and the Hmong in Vietnam, University of Washington Press, Seattle, 2016Google Scholar.

9 See, for example, Berdahl, Where the World Ended, pp. 72–103; Yang, Mayfair, ‘Spatial struggles: state disenchantment and popular re-appropriation of space in rural southeast China’, Journal of Asian Studies, vol. 63, no. 3, 2004, pp. 719–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

10 Anderson, Benedict, ‘The goodness of nations’, in Nation and Religion: Perspectives on Europe and Asia, van der Veer, Peter and Lehmann, Harmut (eds), Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1999, pp. 197–205Google Scholar.

11 van der Veer, Peter, Religious Nationalism: Hindus and Muslims in India, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1994Google Scholar; van der Veer and Lehmann (eds), Nation and Religion; van der Veer, P., The Modern Spirit of Asia: The Spiritual and the Secular in China and India, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2014Google Scholar.

12 Omer, Atalia and Springs, Jason A., Religious Nationalism: A Reference Handbook, ABC-CLIO, Santa Barbara, 2013Google Scholar.

13 Hastings, Adrian, The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1997CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14 van Schendel, Willem, The Bengal Borderland: Beyond State and Nation in South Asia, Anthem, London, 2005Google Scholar.

15 The most telling example is that none of the 65 essays included in two recent publications—Wastl-Walter, Doris (ed.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Border Studies, Ashgate, Burlington, 2011Google Scholar, and Wilson, Thomas and Donnan, Hastings (eds), A Companion to Border Studies, Blackwell Publishing, New York, 2012CrossRefGoogle Scholar—pays any attention to religion.

16 Thongchai, Siam Mapped.

17 Hansen, Thomas Blom and Stepputat, Finn (eds), Sovereign Bodies: Citizens, Migrants, and States in the Postcolonial World, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2005Google Scholar.

18 Ngo, The New Way.

19 Thongchai, Siam Mapped.

20 Duara, Prasenjit, Rescuing History from the Nation: Questioning Narratives of Modern China, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1995, p. 7CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Sahlins, Peter, Boundaries: The Making of France and Spain in the Pyrenees, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1989Google Scholar; Gellner, David, ‘Introduction’, in Borderland Lives in Northern South Asia, Gellner, D. (ed.), Duke University Press, Durham, 2013, pp. 1–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Baud and Van Schendel, ‘Comparative history of borderlands’.

22 Lao Cai People's Committee and UNICEF Viet Nam, ‘Report on situation analysis of children in Lao Cai’, United Nations, 2016, http://www.un.org.vn/en/publications/publications-by-agency/doc_details/521-report-on-situation-analysis-of-children-in-lao-cai.html, [accessed 2 August 2019].

23 Hoang, Van Dao, Viet Nam Quoc Dan Dang: A Contemporary History of a National Struggle, 1927–1954, RoseDog Books, Pittsburgh, 2008Google Scholar.

24 Heilongjiang (Hắc Long Giang in Vietnamese) is the sixth-biggest province in China, in the country's northeast. Its name means ‘Black Dragon River’.

25 When Lào Cai was re-established, its population, which resided mainly in Cam Đường district, was 10,000 people. In 2012, this had increased to 108,000 people. The Cục Thống Kê Lào Cai (Provincial Statistics Bureau) has estimated that the city's population will be 300,000 by 2030.

26 Vu, Tuong, ‘Vietnamese political studies and debates on Vietnamese nationalism’, Journal of Vietnamese Studies, vol. 2, no. 2, 2007, pp. 175–230CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Kwon, Heonik, ‘North Korea's culture of commemoration’, in Atheist Secularism and its Discontents, Ngo, Tam T. T. and Quijada, Justine B. (eds), Palgrave, London, 2015, p. 119Google Scholar; Bayly, Susan, ‘Mapping time, living space: the moral cartography of renovation in late-socialist Vietnam’, Cambridge Anthropology, vol. 31, no. 2, 2013, pp. 60–84Google Scholar

28 Wolf, Arthur P. (ed.), Gods, Ghosts, and Ancestors: Religion and Ritual in Chinese Society, Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, 1974Google Scholar; Yang, Lihui and An, Deming, with Turner, Jessica Anderson, Handbook of Chinese Mythology, Oxford University Press, New York, 2000Google Scholar.

29 Jayne S. Werner, ‘God and the Vietnamese Revolution’, in Atheist Secularism, Ngo and Quijada (eds), pp. 29–53.

30 Van Luong, Hy, ‘The restructuring of Vietnamese nationalism, 1954–2006’, Pacific Affairs, vol. 80, no. 3, 2007, pp. 439–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

31 Đổi Mới or economic rejuvenation is market-free economic reform launched by the Vietnamese government in 1986, following the similar reforms of Deng Xiao Ping in China. The economic reforms were soon followed by other political and cultural reforms in the following decades which opened up Vietnam and thoroughly transformed the country.

32 Ngo, Tam T. T., ‘The Uncle Ho religion in Vietnam’, in The Secular in South, East and Southeast Asia, van der Veer, Peter and Dean, Kenneth (eds), Palgrave MacMillan, New York, 2019Google Scholar; Marouda, Marina, ‘The unending death of an immortal: the state commemoration of Ho Chi Minh in contemporary Vietnam’, South East Asia Research, vol. 21, no. 2, 2013, pp. 303–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33 ‘Vietnam to send Buddhist monks to Spratly Islands’, BBC, 12 March 2012, http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-17343596, [accessed 2 August 2019].

34 ‘Vietnam dispatches monks to occupy Spratly Islands’, American Interest, 13 April 2012, http://www.the-american-interest.com/2012/04/13/vietnam-dispatches-monks-to-occupy-spratly-islands/, [accessed 2 August 2019].

35 Khổng Chiêm, ‘Dự thảo Quy hoạch tượng đài Bác Hồ đến 2030: 14 địa phương được ưu tiên xây dựng’, Vinanet, 5 August 2015, http://vinanet.vn/vi-mo/du-thao-quy-hoach-tuong-dai-bac-ho-den-2030-14-dia-phuong-duoc-uu-tien-xay-dung-621692.html, [accessed 2 August 2019].

36 ‘Đức thánh tràn trong xã hội Việt Nam đưong đại—tăng quyèn và xung đột sự đa nghĩa của một hiện tượng văn hoá’, 8 January 2017, http://consonkiepbac.org.vn/t165/duc-thanh-tran-trong-xa-hoi-viet-nam-duong-dai-t-ng-quyen-va-xung-dot-su-da-nghia-cua-mot-hien-tuong-v-n-hoa, [accessed 2 August 2019].

37 The information in this footnote is omitted to ensure the author's anonymity

38 Sở Văn Hóa Thể Thao và Du Lịch Lào Cai, ‘Di tích lịch sử văn hóa Đền Mẫu’, 6 April 2011, http://www.laocai.gov.vn/svhttdl/1233/27665/42259/138753/Di-tich-cap-quoc-gia/Di-tich-lich-su-van-hoa-Den-Mau.aspx, [accessed 2 August 2019].

39 Taylor, Philip, Goddess on the Rise: Pilgrimage and Popular Religion in Vietnam, University of Hawai‘i Press, Honolulu, 2004Google Scholar.

40 Tuyên Giáo, ‘Chương trình du lich Về Cội Nguồn sẽ diễn ra vào tối 31.1.2009’, 11 November 2008, http://www.tuyengiao.vn/van-hoa/nghien-cuu-trao-doi/chuong-trinh-du-lich-ve-coi-nguon-2009-se-dien-ra-vao-toi-3112009-4530, [accessed 14 August 2019].

41 A retired propaganda officer confided to me that when the town of Lào Cai was re-established, there were proposals to build a war martyr cemetery close to its centre, next to the Red River, but central and provincial authorities turned them down as inconducive to the general spirit of ‘Putting aside the past, striking toward the future’ (a state propaganda slogan).

42 Tam T. T. Ngo, ‘Bones of Contention: Placing the Deaths of the 1979 Sino-Vietnamese Border War’, paper presented at the international workshop ‘Death and the Afterlife’, Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity, Goettingen, Germany, 16 June 2016.

43 Wah, Chan Yuk, ‘Language power: relational rhetoric and historical taciturnity—a study of Vietnam-China relationship’, in Connecting and Distancing: Southeast Asia and China, Leong, Ho Khai (ed.), Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore, 2009, pp. 230–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar, discusses the intentional silence surrounding the 1979 Border War in Vietnamese public announcements after 1991 as a strategy for reviving good relations with China and ignoring the need to fully address areas of past contention.

44 Tai, Hue-Tam Ho, The Country of Memory: Remaking the Past in Late Socialist Vietnam, University of California Press, Berkeley, 2001Google Scholar.

45 Ban Biên Tập, ‘Giàn khoan Trung Quốc khiến người Việt Nam gọi đúng tên một cuộc chiến…’, 28 July 2014, Trường Sa–Hoàng Sa, http://truongsahoangsa.info/gian-khoan-trung-quoc-khien-nguoi-viet-nam-goi-dung-ten-mot-cuoc-chien.html, [accessed 2 August 2019].

46 Tai, Hue-Tam Ho, ‘Remembered realms: Pierre Nora and French national memory’, American Historical Review, vol. 106, no. 3, 2001, pp. 906–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

47 Phạm Ngọc Triển, ‘Ba đường phố mới mang tên liệt sĩ chiến tranh biên giới 1979’, Dân Trí, 15 February 2014, http://dantri.com.vn/xa-hoi/ba-duong-pho-moi-mang-ten-liet-sy-chien-tranh-bien-gioi-1979-1392954717.htm, [accessed 2 August 2019].

48 Ngo, ‘Bones of Contention’.

49 Endres, Kirsten, ‘Constructing the neighbourly “other”: trade relations and mutual perceptions across the Vietnam-China border’, Sojourn, vol. 30, no. 3, 2015, pp. 710–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

50 Juan Zhang, ‘Border opened up: everyday business in a China-Vietnamese frontier’, PhD thesis, Department of Anthropology, Macquarie University, Sydney, 2011, studies the process of opening up the border from the Chinese side, from the perspective of traders from Hekou County. Puzzled by their refusal to talk about the 1979 war, Zhang concluded that ‘forgetting the war is an attempt for people in the frontier to reconcile a conflicted past, which forges a common ground upon which Chinese and Vietnamese can work together towards a future of progress and development’ (p. 116).

51 For a comprehensive history of the Liễu Hạnh cult, see Dror, Olga, Cult, Culture, and Authority: Princess Liễu Hạnh in Vietnamese History, University of Hawai‘i Press, Honolulu, 2007Google Scholar. Fjelstad, Karen and Hien, Nguyen Thi (eds), Possessed by the Spirits: Mediumship in Contemporary Vietnamese Communities, Cornell Southeast Asia Program, Ithaca, 2006Google Scholar, details developments within and beyond Vietnam over the past few decades in the Mother Goddess Cult, of which the Liễu Hạnh cult is a major component.

52 Dror, Cult, Culture, and Authority.

53 Phạm, Quỳnh Phương and Eiper, Chris, ‘Mothering and fathering the Vietnamese: religion, gender, and national identity’, Journal of Vietnamese Studies, vol. 4, no. 1, 2009, pp. 49–83Google Scholar.

54 Kelley, Liam, ‘Moral exemplar, our general, potent deity, Confucian moralizer and national hero: the transformations of Trần Hưng Đạo’, Modern Asian Studies, vol. 49, no. 6, 2015, pp. 1963–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

55 Phạm and Eiper, ‘Mothering and fathering’, p. 51.

56 Ban Tôn Giáo Chính Phủ, ‘Đền Thượng Lào Cai’, 14 December 2016, http://btgcp.gov.vn/Plus.aspx/vi/News/38/0/256/0/4359/Den_Thuong_Lao_Cai, [accessed 2 August 2019].

57 Dương Anh, ‘Lễ hội Đền Thượng’, Cục Di Sản Văn Hóa, [no date], http://dsvh.gov.vn/pages/news/preview.aspx?n=1203&c=41, [accessed 2 August 2019].

58 Feuchtwang, Stephan, The Imperial Metaphor: Popular Religion in China, Routledge, London, 1992Google Scholar.

59 Sutton, Donald S., ‘Ritual, cultural standardization, and orthopraxy in China: reconsidering James L. Watson's ideas’, Modern China, vol. 33, 2007, pp. 3–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

60 Hansen, Valerie, Changing Gods in Medieval China 1127–1276, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1990CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kelley, Liam, ‘Constructing local narratives: spirits, dreams and prophecies in the medieval Red River delta’, in China's Encounters on the South and Southwest: Reforging the Fiery Frontier over Two Millennia, Anderson, James A. and Whitmore, John K. (eds), Brill, Leiden, 2015, pp. 78–105Google Scholar.

61 MacLean, Ken, ‘In search of Kilometer Zero: digital archives, technological revisionism, and the Sino-Vietnamese border’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, vol. 50, no. 4, 2008, pp. 862–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

62 Southern China, or Nanfang, is a contested zone roughly encompassing China's territory south of the Yangtze River and most of northern Vietnam. For information on the Chinese historiography of this region, see Schafer, Edward, The Vermilion Bird: T'ang Images of the South, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1967Google Scholar; Owen, Stephen, ‘Jiangnan from the ninth century on: the routinization of desire’, in Southern Identity and Southern Estrangement in Chinese Medieval Poetry, Wang, Ping and Williams, Nicholas Morrow (eds), Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong, 2015, pp. 189–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For the history of Vietnam as part of the Nanfang sphere of influence, see Taylor, Keith, The Birth of Vietnam, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1983Google Scholar; Kelly, Liam, Beyond the Bronze Pillars: Envoy Poetry and the Sino-Vietnamese Relationship, University of Hawai‘i Press, Honolulu, 2005Google Scholar; Womack, Brantley, China and Vietnam: A Politics of Asymmetry, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On the development of the Sino-Vietnam border, see Anderson, James A., ‘Creating a border between China and Vietnam’, in Eurasian Corridors of Interconnection: From the South China to the Caspian Sea, Walcott, Susan M. and Johnson, Corey (eds), Routledge, New York, 2014, pp. 15–32Google Scholar.

63 Woodside, Alexander B., Vietnam and the Chinese Model: A Comparative Study of Vietnamese and Chinese Government in the First Half of Nineteenth Century, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, and London, 1988Google Scholar; Taylor, Keith, ‘Surface orientations in Vietnam: beyond histories of nation and region’, Journal of Asian Studies, vol. 57, no. 4, 1998, pp. 949–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

64 Taylor, Goddess on the Rise; Salemink, Oscar, ‘Embodying the nation: mediumship, ritual, and the national imagination’, Journal of Vietnamese Studies, vol. 3, no. 3, 2008, pp. 261–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

65 I have described in detail elsewhere some examples of spirit possessions in which ethnic minority figures were included to serve mainly Kinh's devotees and the spirit medium's own perception of their ethnic group's cultural domination and spiritual and moral superiority vis-à-vis other ethnic groups. For more information, see Tam T. T. Ngo, ‘Performing Sacred Geography and Spiritual Warfare in Contemporary Vietnam’, paper presented at the international conference ‘The Geobody of Vietnam’, 21–22 May 2015, Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity, Goettingen, Germany.

66 Duara, Prasenjit, ‘Superscribing symbols: the myth of Guandi, Chinese god of war’, Journal of Asian Studies, vol. 47, no. 4, 1988, pp. 778–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

67 Phạm and Eiper, ‘Mothering and fathering’.

68 For a detailed history of Liu and the Black Flag Army in Vietnam, see McAleavy, Henry, Black Flags in Vietnam: The Story of a Chinese Intervention, MacMillan, New York, 1968Google Scholar.

69 Madam Sường served as the first incense mistress of the Temple after it was rebuilt in the 1991 until her death in 1996. She was my former neighbour in Pho Lu, a town 40km south of Lao Cai where most Lao Cai residents resettled in the decade after the war. In 1968, both of her sons died while fighting as North Vietnam soldiers in the south. After this tragedy, she sought comfort in the Mother Goddess to sooth her personal pain, despite other political and social trouble this worship brought her. She was one of the devotees who hid and protected the status and icons of the Mother Goddess Temple when anti-superstition campaign offices sought to destroy them. Several of the statuses were later displayed in a secret shrine in her house in Pho Lu where secret spirit possessions, with her as the main medium, took place. Madam Sường was instrumental to my early knowledge of Mother Goddess religion, just as she was to the survival of the community of the temple devotees.

70 MacLean, Ken, The Government of Mistrust: Illegibility and Bureaucratic Power in Socialist Vietnam, University of Madison Press, Madison, 2013Google Scholar.