Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T17:04:43.889Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Transcending East—West Dichotomies: State and Culture Formation in Six Ostensibly Disparate Areas

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2008

Victor Lieberman
Victor Lieberman
Affiliation:
University of Michigan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Although the question has assumed at least two principal forms, most scholars who would compare the history of Europe and Asia have long been absorbed with a single query: Why was Asia different?

Type
Articles
Information
Modern Asian Studies , Volume 31 , Issue 3 , July 1997 , pp. 463 - 546
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1997

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See Weber, , Economy and Society (Berkeley, 1978), II, chs 10–15;Google ScholarAnderson, Perry, Lineages of the Absolutist State (London, 1974), 397–402, 462–549;Google ScholarWallerstein, , The Modern World-System, I (Orlando, FL, 1974);Google ScholarBaechler, , Hall, , and Mann, (eds), Europe and the Rise of Capitalism (Oxford, 1988);Google ScholarHall, John A., Powers and Liberties (Oxford, 1985);Google ScholarJones, , The European Miracle (Cambridge, 1987);Google ScholarChirot, , ‘The Rise of the West,’ American Sociological Review 50 (1985): 181–95;Google ScholarParker, , The Military Revolution (Cambridge, 1988);Google ScholarWittfogel, Karl, Oriental Despotism (New York, 1981), 374–89.Google Scholar

2 Coulborn, Rushton (ed.), Feudalism in History (Princeton, 1956);Google ScholarLeach, Edmund et al. (eds), Feudalism: Comparative Studies (Sydney, 1985);Google ScholarHall, John W. and Jansen, Marius B. (eds), Studies in the Institutional History of Early Modern Japan (Princeton, 1968), 3–51;Google ScholarLeupp, Gary P., Servants, Shophands and Laborers in the Cities of Tokugawa Japan (Princeton, 1992);Google ScholarTakenaka, Yasukazu, ‘Endogenous Formation and Development of Capitalism in Japan,’ The Journal of Economic History [JEH] 29, 1 (1969): 141–62 [this entire journal issue is devoted to examining the early extent of extra-European capitalism];Google ScholarWigen, Karen, ‘The Geographic Imagination in Early Modern Japanese History,’ The Journal of Asian Studies [JAS] 51, 1 (1992): 3–29;Google ScholarHowell, David L., ‘Proto Industrial Origins of Japanese Capitalism,’ JAS 51, 2 (1992): 269–86.Google Scholar

3 Rawski, Evelyn, ‘Research Themes in Ming-Qing Socioeconomic Hitory—The State of the Field,’ JAS 50, 1 (1991): 84–111;Google ScholarNaquin, Susan and Rawski, Evelyn, Chinese Society in the Eighteenth Century (New Haven, 1987);Google ScholarEastman, Lloyd E., Family, Fields, and Ancestors (New York, 1988);Google ScholarHuang, Philip C.C., The Peasant Family and Rural Development in the Yangzi Delta, 1350–1988 (Stanford, 1990);Google ScholarFeuerwerker, Albert, ‘Presidential Address: Questions about China's Early Modern Economic History that I Wish I Could Answer,’ JAS 51, 4 (1992): 757–69;Google ScholarPerlin, Frank, ‘Proto-Industrialization and Pre-Colonial South Asia,’ Past and Present [PP] 98 (1983): 30–95;Google ScholarWashbrook, D.A., ‘Progress and Problems: South Asian Economic and Social History c. 1720–1860,’ Modern Asian Studies [MAS] 22, 1 (1988): 57–96;Google ScholarSubrahmanyam, Sanjay, ‘Rural Industry and Commercial Agriculture in Late Seventeenth-Century South-Eastern India,’ PP 126 (1990): 76–114;Google Scholaridem (ed.), Merchants, Markets and the State in Early Modern India (Delhi, 1990);Google ScholarReid, Anthony, Southeast Asia in the Age of Commerce, 1450–1680, 2 vols (New Haven, 1988, 1993);Google ScholarLieberman, Victor, ‘Secular Trends in Burmese Economic Hitory, c. 1350–1830,’ MAS 25, 1 (1991): 1–31;Google ScholarCarey, Peter, ‘Waiting for the “Just King”,’ MAS 20, 1 (1986): 59–137.Google Scholar

4 The chief suspects are cultural impediments, political sins of commission (market interference), political sins of omission (failure to provide capital-friendly institutions), and demographically-based equilibrium traps. See previous notes, plus Myers, Ramon H., ‘How Did the Modern Chinese Economy Develop?’ JAS 50, 3 (1991): 604–28;Google ScholarFeuerwerker, Albert, ‘The State and the Economy in Late Imperial China,’ Theory and Society 13, 3 (1984): 297–326;Google ScholarRowe, William T. in Zunz, Olivier (ed.), Reliving the Past (Chapel Hill, NC, 1985), 236–96;Google ScholarElvin, Mark, The Pattern of the Chinese Past (Stanford, 1973);Google ScholarRaychaudhuri, Tapan in Raychaudhuri, and Habib, Irfan (eds), The Cambridge Economic History of India, I (Cambridge, 1982), 261–307, esp. 295;Google ScholarKathirithamby-Wells, Jeyamalar in Reid, Anthony (ed.), Southeast Asia in the Early Modern Era (Ithaca, NY, 1993), 123–48;Google ScholarSmith, Thomas C., Native Sources of Japanese Industrialization, 1750–1920 (Berkeley, 1988).Google Scholar

5 On the public sphere debate, Rowe, William T., ‘The Public Sphere in Modern China,’ Modern China 16, 3 (1990): 309–29;Google Scholar‘Symposium: “Public Sphere” “Civil Society” in China?’ Modern China 19, 2 (1993);Google ScholarWong, Bin, ‘Great Expectations: The “Public Sphere” and the Search for Modern Times in Chinese History,’ Chugoku shigakkai 3 (1993): 7–50;Google ScholarBayly, C.A., ‘Rethinking the Origins of the Indian Public Sphere,’ Univ. of Michigan lecture, Sept. 15, 1995.Google ScholarA similar test of European categories in Asia involves the search for a ‘17th-century crisis,’ MAS 24, 4 (1990), special issue.Google Scholar

6 Jones, , Miracle. Cf. his later argument for sustained growth in Song China and Tokugawa Japan, Growth Recurring (Oxford, 1988).Google ScholarPubMed

7 Quote from Pipes, Richard, Russia under the Old Regime (New York, 1992), 266. Pipes’ book itself offers an essentialist Cold war view.Google ScholarCf. Greenfeld, Liah, Nationalism (Cambridge, MA, 1992), ch. 3;Google ScholarPoe, Marshall, ‘Russian Despotism’ (PhD, UC Berkeley, 1993);Google ScholarKivelson, Valerie, Autocracy in the Provinces (Stanford, 1996), Intro.Google Scholar

8 See Said, Edward, Orientalism (New York, 1978);Google ScholarAnderson, , Lineages, Note B;Google ScholarAdas, Michael, Machines as the Measure of Men (Ithaca, 1989);Google ScholarChaudhuri, K.N., Asia Before Europe (Cambridge, 1990), 19–24.Google Scholar

9 Anderson, , Lineages, Note B, 462–549.Google Scholar

10 On Leur, van and Smail, , see my ‘Introduction,’ this volume, n. 2.Google Scholar

11 Hall, , ‘The New Look of Tokugawa History,’ in Hall and Jansen, Institutional History, 55, corroborating C. Vann Woodward.Google Scholar

12 On Japanese revisionism, now in fact a new orthodoxy, see supra, nn. 2, 4, plus Thomas C. Smith, The Agrarian Origins of Modern Japan (Stanford, 1959);Google ScholarNakane, Chie and Oishi, Shinzaburo (eds), Tokugawa Japan (Tokyo, 1991).Google Scholar

13 Powelson, , Centuries of Economic Endeavor (Ann Arbor, MI, 1994).Google Scholar

14 Price, , ‘Secondary State Formation: A n Explanatory Model,’ in Cohen, Ronald and Service, Elman R. (eds), Origins of the State (Philadelphia, 1978), 161–86. Conceivably parts of West Africa could be included in this schemaGoogle Scholar

15 Becker, Marvin, Civility and Society in Western Europe, 1300–1600 (Bloomington, IN, 1988);Google Scholaridem, , The Emergence of Civil Society in the Eighteenth Century (Bloomington, IN, 1994);Google ScholarBriggs, Robin, Early Modern France 1560–1715 (Oxford, 1977);Google ScholarWoloch, Isser, Eighteenth-Century Europe (New York, 1982).Google Scholar

16 See previous references to the ‘public sphere’ debate, which takes on added significance when one compares urban publishing industries in Japan and Europe: Smith, Henry D. II, ‘The History of the Book in Edo and Paris,’ in McClain, James L. et al. (eds), Edo and Paris (Ithaca, NY, 1994), 332–52, and Mary Elizabeth Berry, this volume.Google Scholar According to Karen Wigen, ‘Mapping Early Modernity: Geographic Meditations on a Comparative Concept’ (MS), the conjuncture of urbanization, wider literacy, voluntary;associations, evidential philosophy, and an emphasis on the autonomous self in the arts suggests cultural analogies between late Ming/Qing China and the early modern West.Cf. Johnson, David, ‘Communication, Class, and Consciousness in Late Imperial China,’ in Johnson, et al. (eds), Popular Culture in Late Imperial China (Berkeley, 1985), 34–7 2.Google Scholar

17 McNeill, , Plagues and Peoples (Garden City, NY, 1976).Google Scholar

18 Lamb, H.H., Climate Present, Past, and Future, II (London, 1977 ), ch. 17;Google Scholaridem, The Changing Climate (London, 1966);Google ScholarWigley, T.M.L. et al. (eds), Climate and History (Cambridge, 1981);Google ScholarMikami, Takehiko, ‘The Climate Reconstruction of East Asia in the Period c. 1500–1850’ (MS);Google ScholarMikami, T. (ed.), Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Little Ice Age Climate (Tokyo, 1992).Google Scholar

19 Crosby, , The Columbian Exchange (Westport, CT, 1972);Google ScholarLee, , ‘Migration and Expansion in Chinese History,’ in McNeill, William H. and Adams, Ruth S. (eds), Human Migration: Patterns and Policies (Bloomington, IN, 1978), 20–47;Google Scholaridem, ‘Food Supply and Population Growth in Southwest China, 1250–1850,’ JAS 41, 4 (1982): 711–46.Google Scholar

20 Frank, and Gills, (eds), The World System (London, 1993);Google ScholarAbu-Lughod, , Before European Hegemony (New York, 1989);Google ScholarCurtin, Philip D., Cross-cultural Trade in World History (Cambridge, 1984);Google ScholarBentley, Jerry H., Old World Encounters (New York, 1993);Google ScholarFischer, Wolfram et al. (eds), The Emergence of a World Economy 1500–1914, I (Wiesbaden, 1986);Google ScholarRichards, John F. (ed.), Precious Metals in the Later Medieval and Early Modern Worlds (Durham, NC, 1983);Google ScholarAtwell, William, ‘Some Observations on the “Seventeenth-Century Crisis” in China and Japan,’ JAS 45, 2 (1986): 223–44.Google Scholar

21 Goldstone, , Revolution and Rebellion in the Early Modern World (Berkeley, 1991).Google ScholarCf. Mousnier, Roland, Peasant Uprisings in Seventeenth Century France, Russia, and China (New York, 1970).Google Scholar

22 Japan knew but one period of sustained breakdown, c. 1467–1590. For political/administrative overviews, see Lieberman, Victor, Burmese Administrative Cycles (Princeton, 1984);Google ScholarKoenig, William J., The Burmese Polity, 1752–1819 (Ann Arbor, MI, 1990);Google ScholarWyatt, David K., Thailand: A Short History (New Haven, 1982);Google ScholarKhoi, Le Thanh, Histoire du Vietnam (Paris, 1987);Google ScholarWoodside, Alexander, Vietnam and the Chinese Model (Cambridge, MA, 1971);Google ScholarFennell, John, The Crisis of Medieval Russia 1200–1304 (London, 1983);Google ScholarCrummey, Robert O., The Formation of Muscovy 1304–1613 (London, 1987);Google ScholarDukes, Paul, The Making of Russian Absolutism 1613–1801 (London, 1990);Google ScholarGenet, J. Ph. and Mêne, M. Le (eds), Genèse de l'etat moderne (Paris, 1987);Google ScholarDuby, Georges, France in the Middle Ages, 987–1460 (Oxford, 1991);Google ScholarPotter, David, A History of France, 1460–1560 (New York, 1995);Google ScholarLadurie, Emmanuel Le Roy, The Royal French State 1460–1610 (Oxford, 1994);Google ScholarBluche, Francois, L'Ancien Régime (Paris, 1993);Google ScholarCollins, James B., The State in Early Modem France (Cambridge, 1995);Google ScholarThe Cambridge History of Japan [CHJ], III, Yamamura, Kozo (ed.), and IV, John Whitney Hall (ed.) (Cambridge, 1990, 1991);Google ScholarTotman, Conrad, Early Modem Japan (Berkeley, 1993).Google Scholar

23 Characterized by a central ‘sun,’ ‘planets’ held by a gravitational pull whose strength varied with distance, and multiple ‘moons’ for each ‘planet.’ Cf. ‘galactic polity’ in Tambiah, S.J., World Conqueror and World Renouncer (Cambridge, 1976), chs 6–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24 Woloch, Isser, The New Regime (New York, 1994);Google ScholarChurch, Clive H., Revolution and Red Tape (Oxford, 1981), chs 1, 2. I choose post-Revolutionary France to emphasize Eurasian variety, but if 1750 had been the base year, the decentralized, personalized Southeast Asian system would have found closer French parallels.Google Scholar

25 Lieberman, , Cycles, ch. 2.Google Scholar

26 LeDonne, John P., Absolutism and Ruling Class (New York, 1991), 112–18, 305–9;Google ScholarThaden, Edward C., Russia's Western Borderlands, 1710–1870 (Princeton, 1984), pts 1–2.Google Scholar

27 Ravina, Mark, ‘State-building and Political Economy in Early-modern Japan,’ JAS 54, 4 (1995): 997–1022, analyzing the ‘compound state’;Google ScholarBerry, Mary Elizabeth, ‘Public Peace and Private Attachment,’ The Journal of Japanese Studies [JJS] 12, 2 (1986), 240, 255, 257.Google Scholar

28 For different characterizations, see Woodside, , Vietnam 38, 74–82, 106–7, and passim;Google ScholarCooke, Nola, ‘The Composition of the Nineteenth-Century Political Elite of Pre-colonial Nguyen Vietnam,’ MAS 29, 4 (1995): 741–64;Google ScholarBerry, , ‘Public Peace,’ 255. 263–71; CHJ, IV, 15.Google Scholar

29 Whitmore, John K., ‘The Development of Le Government in Fifteenth-Century Vietnam,’ (PhD, Cornell Univ. 1968);Google ScholarDewey, Horace W., ‘The Decline of the Muscovite Namestnik,’ Oxford Slavonic Papers 12 (1965): 21–39;Google ScholarMousnier, Roland, The Institutions of France under the Absolute Monarchy 1598–1789 (Chicago, 1979, 1984), I, ch. 14;Google ScholarMajor, J. Russell, Representative Government in Early Modern France (New Haven, 1980), xiv, 58–96;Google ScholarCHf, III, 201–11.Google Scholar

30 White, James W., ‘State Growth and Popular Protest in Tokugawa Japan,’ JJS 14, 1 (1988), 11.Google Scholar

31 Knecht, R.J., French Renaissance Monarchy (London, 1984), 15;Google ScholarBlack, Jeremy, A Military Revolution? (Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 1991), 6;Google ScholarTilly, Charles, Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990–1900 (Cambridge, MA, 1990), 79.Google ScholarOn a comparably dramatic expansion in Ashikaga-Tokugawa armies, Ooms, Herman, Tokugawa Ideology (Princeton, 1985), 44. Yet no serious increase in Vietnamese army size is apparent c. 1600–1800.Google Scholar

32 Kettering, , Patrons, Brokers, and Clients in Seventeenth-Century France (New York, 1986), 5.Google Scholar

33 For such views, and contrasts with earlier historiography, see Mann, Michael, The Sources of Social Power, I (Cambridge, 1986), 458–63;Google ScholarHenschall, Nicholas, The Myth of Absolutism (London, 1992);Google ScholarEmmanuelli, François-Xavier, Un mythe de l'absolutisme bourbonien (Aix-en-Provence, 1981);Google ScholarParker, David, The Making of French Absolutism (New York, 1983);Google ScholarBeik, William, Absolutism and Society in Seventeenth-Centry France (Cambridge, 1985);Google ScholarHarding, Robert, Anatomy of a Power Elite (New Haven, 1978);Google ScholarMettam, Roger, Power and Faction in Louis XIV's France (Oxford, 1988);Google ScholarKollmann, Nancy Shields, Kinship and Patronage: The Making of the Muscovite Political System 1345–1547 (Stanford, 1987);Google ScholarCrummey, Robert, Aristocrats and Servitors (Princeton, 1983); Kivelson, Autocracy.Google Scholar

34 Previous note, plus Asch, Ronald G. and Birke, Adolf M. (eds), Princes, Patronage, and The Nobility (Oxford, 1991);Google ScholarWyatt, , Thailand, chs 4–6;Google ScholarLailert, Busakorn, ‘The Ban Phlu Luang Dynasty’ (PhD, Univ. of London, 1972);Google ScholarRabibhadana, Akin, The Organization of Thai Society in the Early Bangkok Period 1782–1873 (Ithaca, NY, 1969);Google ScholarCHJ, III, chs 1–6, IV, chs 1–5;Google ScholarBerry, Mary Elizabeth, Hideyoshi (Cambridge, MA, 1982), chs 4–6.Google Scholar

35 Lieberman, Victor, ‘The Political Significance of Religious Wealth in Burmese History,’ JAS 39, 4 (1980): 753–69;Google ScholarPipes, , Russia, ch. 9;Google ScholarOstrowski, Donald, ‘Church Polemics and Monastic Land Acquisition in Sixteenth-Century Muscovy,’ Slavic and East European Review [SEER] 64, 3 (1986): 355–75;Google ScholarBushkovitch, Paul, Religion and Society in Russia (New York, 1992), chs 3–5;Google ScholarAnisimov, Eugenii V., The Reforms of Peter the Great (Armonk, NY, 1993), 203–17;Google ScholarMadariaga, Isabel de, Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great (New Haven, 1981), 111–27, 515;Google ScholarReischauer, Edwin O. and Craig, Albert M., Japan (Sydney, 1979), 77, 87;Google ScholarCHJ, IV, 359–72;Google ScholarKnecht, , Francis I, 51–65;Google ScholarMousnier, , Institutions, I, ch. 7;Google ScholarFuret, Franç, Revolutionary France 1770–1880 (Oxford, 1992), 80–5, 226–8;Google Scholar Collins, this volume. Of course, the French church remained a key political actor to 1789. On Vietnamese controls, Huy, Nguyen Ngoc & Tai, Ta Van, The Le Code, 3 vols (Athens, OH, 1987), Articles 152, 215, 288, 301.Google Scholar

36 Previous note, plus Muchembled, Robert, Popular Culture and Elite Culture in France 1400–1750 (Baton Rouge, LA, 1985), emphasizing state—church cooperation in popular regimentation c. 1600–1750;Google Scholar Collins, State, 3–4, 184–95, emphasizing the state's expanded welfare and regulatory powers from Louis XIV; Hellie, Richard, Enserfment and Military Change in Muscovy (Chicago, 1971), pts I–II;Google ScholarHittle, J. Michael, The Service City: State and Townsmen in Russia, 1600–1800 (Cambridge, MA, 1979);Google ScholarBushkovitch, Paul, The Merchants of Moscow 1580–1650 (Cambridge, 1980), ch. 9;Google ScholarCrummey, , Formation, 234–41;Google ScholarAnisimov, , Peter, 217–43;Google ScholarBerry, , Hideyoshi, ch. 5;Google ScholarTotman, , Early Modern Japan, 101–59;Google ScholarTonomura, Hitomi, ‘Punish and Discipline: Criminalizing Sexual Relations’ (MS); Lieberman, Cycles, ch. 2; Akin, Thai Society, chs 2, 4, 5; Whitmore, ‘Le Government,’ chs 4, 5;Google ScholarYu, Insun, Law and Society in Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century Vietnam (Seoul, 1990).Google Scholar

37 CHJ, IV, 15, 124;Google Scholar Berry, ‘Public Peace,’ 255; Totman, Conrad, Politics in the Tokugawa Bakufu, 1600–1843 (Berkeley, 1967), 234.Google Scholar

38 Whitmore, ‘Le Government’; Taylor, Keith, ‘The Literati Revival in Seventeenth-century Vietnam,’ Journal of Southeast Asian Studies [JSEAS] 18, 1 (1987): 275–97;Google ScholarWoodside, , Vietnam, esp. chs 1, 3;Google ScholarCooke, Nola, ‘Nineteenth-Century Vietnamese Confucianization in Historical Perspective,’ JSEAS 25, 2 (1994): 270–312.Google Scholar

39 Kivelson, Valerie, ‘ The Devil Stole His Mind,’ American Historical Review 98, 3 (1993): 733–56;Google ScholarPlavsic, Borivoj in Pintner, W.M., Rowney, D.K. (eds), Russian Officialdom (Chapel Hill, NC, 1980), 19–45.Google Scholar

40 Wyatt, , ‘The “Subtle Revolution” of King Rama I of Siam,’ in Wyatt, and Alexander, Woodside, (eds), Moral Order and the Question of Change (New Haven, 1982), 9–52.Google Scholar

41 Laclau, and Mouffe, , Hegemony and Socialist Strategy (London, 1985), chs 3, 4;Google ScholarMorris-Suzuki, , ‘The Invention and Reinvention of “Japanese Culture”,’ JAS 54, 3 (1995): 759–80.Google ScholarCf. Geertz, Clifford, The Interpretation of Cultures (New York, 1973). 482Google Scholar

42 Cf. Smith, Anthony D., The Ethnic Origins of Nations (Oxford, 1986), 76–89, opposing lateral and vertical ethnics as stable communities, rather than as evolutionary processes.Google Scholar

43 Ruch, Barbara.CHJ, III, ch. 11, esp. 501.Google Scholar Cf. Osumi Kazuo, ibid., 581–2; Bito Masahide, ibid., IV, 378; Totman, Conrad, Japan Before Perry (Berkeley, 1981), 93–117.Google Scholar

44 Hall, , CHJ, IV, 30.Google ScholarSee CHJ, IV, chs 8, 14;Google ScholarTotman, , Early Modern Japan, chs 6, 10, 16, 19;Google ScholarBerry, Mary Elizabeth, this volume; essays by Moriya, Katsuhisa, Akai, Tatsuro, and Nakane, Chie in Nakane, and Oishi, , Tokugawa;Google ScholarReischauer, and Craig, , Japan, 86, 99–107.Google Scholar

45 Bartlett, , The Making of Europe (Princeton, 1993), 201 and 197–242 passim;Google ScholarBeaune, Colette, The Birth of an Ideology (Berkeley, 1991).Google ScholarCf. Krynen, Jacques, Idéal du prince et pouvoir royal (Paris, 1981), 241–77;Google ScholarGuénée, Bernard, States and Rulers in Later Medieval Europe (Oxford, 1985), 50–65, 216–20;Google ScholarStrayer, Joseph, The Reign of Philip the Fair (Princeton, 1980), 387–92.Google Scholar

46 Bendix, Reinhard, Kings or People (Berkeley, 1978).Google ScholarSee Chevalier, Bernard and Contamine, Philippe (eds), La France de la fin du XVe siècle (Paris, 1985), 265–81, 301–11;Google ScholarBeaune, Ideology; Allmand, Christopher, The Hundred Years War (Cambridge, 1988), 136–50;Google Scholaridem (ed.), Power, Culture, and Religion in France c. 1350–c. 1550 (Woodbridge, UK, 1989);Google ScholarLewis, P.S., Later Medieval France (London, 1968), 60–77, 374–80.Google Scholar

47 Collins, , State, 5. On cultural/linguistic integration c. 1500–1830,Google ScholarBrun, A., Recherches historiques sur l'introduction du Fran¸ais dans lesprovinces du Midi (Paris, 1923), pts 1, 2, 5;Google ScholarYardeni, Myriam, La conscience nationale en France pendant les guerres de religion (Paris, 1971), esp. 13–73;Google ScholarCerteau, M.de et al. , Une politique de la langue: La revolution Francaise el les patois (Paris, 1975);Google ScholarRickard, Peter, A History of the French Language (London, 1989);Google ScholarBriggs, , Early Modern, ch. 4.Google Scholar

48 Lartichaux, Jean-Yves, ‘Linguistic Politics during the French Revolution,’ Diogenes 97 (1977): 65–84;Google ScholarFuret, François and Ozouf, Jacques, Reading and Writing: Literacy in France from Calvin to fules Ferry (Cambridge, 1982), 98–9.Google Scholar

49 On integration and divergences, Wolters, O.W., Two Essays on Dai Viet in the Fourteenth Century (New Haven, 1988);Google Scholar Whitmore, ‘Le Government’; Yu, Law and Society; Lafont, P.B. (ed.), Les frontiers du Vietnam (Paris, 1989), 11–24, 136–55;Google ScholarCooke, Nola, ‘Colonial Political Myth and the Problem of the Other’ (PhD, Australian National Univ. [ANU], 1991);Google ScholarTana, Li, “The Inner Region”: A Social and Economic History of Nguyen Vietnam in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries’ (PhD, ANU, 1992);Google ScholarKhanh, Huynh Kim, Vietnamese Communism 1925–1945 (Ithaca, 1982), 26–34;Google ScholarLam, Truong Buu, Patterns of Vietnamese Response to Foreign Intervention: 1858–1900 (New Haven, 1967);Google Scholar Woodside, Vietnam; Henley, David E.F., ‘Ethnogeographic Integration and Exclusion in Anticolonial Nationalism,’ Comparative Studies in Society and History [CSSHJ] 37, 2 (1995): 286–324.Google Scholar

50 See Lieberman, Victor, ‘Was the Seventeenth Century A Watershed in Burmese History?’ in Reid, Early Modem, 240–9, and sources.Google Scholar

51 Personal communication, June 1995.Google Scholar

52 Wyatt, , Thailand, chs 4–6;Google ScholarChutintaranond, Sunait, ‘The Image of the Burmese Enemy Through History: Thai Perspective,’ Journal of the Siam Society 80, 1 (1992): 1–32;Google ScholarWinichakul, Thongchai, Siam Mapped (Honolulu, 1994), ch. 1;Google ScholarLysa, Hong, Thailand in the Nineteenth Century (Singapore, 1984), chs 1–4;Google ScholarTerwiel, B.J., Through Travellers' Eyes (Bangkok, 1989), 224–33.Google Scholar

53 Keenan, Edward L.,‘ On Certain Mythical Beliefs and Russian Behaviors,’ in Starr, S. Frederick (ed.), The Legacy of History in Russia and the New States of Eurasia (Armonk, NY, 1994), 19–40;Google ScholarPelenski, Jaroslaw, ‘The Origins of the Official Muscovite Claims to the “Kievan Inheritance”,’ Harvard Ukrainian Studies[HUS] 1 (1977): 29–52; and Kivelson, this volume.Google Scholar

54 Ethnic figures from Werth, Paul, personal communication, October 1995.Google ScholarSee Fennell, J.L., The Emergence of Moscow 1304–1359 (London, 1968);Google ScholarBushkovitch, , Religion, 34, 74–89, 111–18;Google Scholaressays by idem and Cracraft, James, HUS, 10, 3/4 (1986), 355–76, 524–41;Google ScholarCherniavsky, Michael, Tsar and People (New Haven, 1961);Google ScholarHellie, Richard, Slavery in Russia 1450–1725 (Chicago, 1982), 390–4;Google ScholarMadariaga, , Catherine, chs 20, 32;Google ScholarGreenfeld, , Nationalism, ch. 3;Google ScholarThaden, , Western Borderlands, pts 1, 2;Google ScholarKohut, Zenon E., Russian Centralism and Ukrainian Autonomy (Cambridge, MA, 1988);Google ScholarKhodarkovsky, Michael, Where Two Worlds Met (Ithaca, NY, 1992).Google Scholar

55 Cf. Chartier's, Roger notion of cultural ‘appropriation,’ The Cultural Uses of Print in Early Modern France (Princeton, 1987), esp. 6–9;Google ScholarDavis, Natalie Zemon, Society and Culture in Early Modern France (Stanford, 1965), ch. 7;Google Scholarand Rafael's, Vincente L. notion of (mis)translation, Contracting Colonialism (Ithaca, 1988).Google ScholarCohen, A.P., The Symbolic Construction of Community (London, 1985) argues that symbolism owes its versatility precisely to the fact that it carries no inherent meaning.Google Scholar

56 Yardeni, , Conscience nationale, pt II.Google Scholar

57 See Bushkovitch, Religion and Society, 70–167 passim; Cherniavsky, Michael, ‘The Old Believers and the New Religion,’ Slavic Review 25 (1966): 1–39;Google ScholarLieberman, , Cycles, 178–9, 238, 262;Google ScholarMaha-dama-thin-gyan, , Tha-thana-lin-ga-ya sa-dan (Rangoon, 1897), 185ff.Google Scholar

58 For different versions of this claim, Bendix, Kings or People; Chatterjee, Partha, The Nation and Its Fragments (Princeton, 1993), 138;Google ScholarDuara, Prasenjit, ‘Deconstructing the Chinese Nation,’ The Australian fournal of Chinese Affairs 30 (1993): 5–6;Google ScholarRanum, Orest, ‘Counter-Identities of Western European Nations in the Early Modern Period: Definitions and Points of Departure,’ in Boerner, Peter (ed.), Concepts of National Identity (Baden-Baden, 1986), 63–78.Google Scholar

59 Cf. Barth, Fredrik (ed.), Ethnic Groups and Boundaries (Boston, 1969), esp. 86–100;Google ScholarRawski, Evelyn, ‘Research Themes,’ 95, citing S.T. Leong;Google ScholarBayly, C.A., ‘The Pre-history of Communalism?’ MAS 19, 2 (1985): 177–203;Google ScholarCohen, , Symbolic Construction, 16, 69, 109, 115.Google Scholar

60 Duara, , ‘Chinese Nation,’ 20–5;Google Scholaridem, ‘Historicizing National Identity, or Who Imagines What and When,’ in Eley, Geoff and Suny, Ronald Grigor (eds), Becoming National (Oxford, 1996), 151–78.Google Scholar

61 See previous case studies, plus CHJ IV, 412, 616–20, 639–42. On national tutelary deities (of decreasing importance in France and Russia after c. 1700), Beaune, Ideology, pt I; Bushkovitch, Religion, ch. 4; Khanh, Vietnamese Communism, 31–2;Google ScholarMaspero, H., ‘Etudes d'histoire d'Annam,’ Bulletin de I'Ecole Frangaise d'Extreme Orient 16 (1916), 17;Google ScholarSpiro, Melford E., Burmese Supernaturalism (Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1967), pt III;Google ScholarShorto, H.L., ‘The dewatau sotapan,’ Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 30, 1 (1967): 127–41;Google ScholarCHJ, III, 140, 147, 455ff.Google Scholar

62 E.g., Sahlins, Peter, Boundaries (Berkeley, 1989), 115–27;Google ScholarLieberman, Victor, ‘Ethnic Politics in Eighteenth Century Burma,’ MAS 12, 3 (1978): 455–82;Google ScholarChandler, David, A History of Cambodia (Boulder, CO, 1992), 125–7;Google ScholarMadariaga, , Catherine, chs 20, 32.Google Scholar

63 Gellner, , Nations and Nationalism (Ithaca, 1983);Google ScholarAnderson, , Imagined Communities, rev. edn (London, 1991).Google ScholarAlso emphasizing modern novelty are Deutsch, Karl, Nationalism and Social Communication (Cambridge, MA, 1953);Google ScholarSuny, Ronald Grigor, The Revenge of the Past (Stanford, 1993);Google ScholarHobsbawm, E.J., Nations and Nationalism Since 1870 (Cambridge, 1990);Google ScholarEley, and Suny, , Becoming National, 1–37. Cf. the emphasis on continuity in Smith, Ethnic Origins;Google Scholarand Armstrong, John A., Nations before Nationalism (Chapel Hill, NC, 1982).Google Scholar

64 Lieberman, , ‘Ethnic Politics.’Google Scholar

65 Yet no more than in Burma did such distinctions preclude inter-ethnic alliance. Platonov, S.F., The Time of Troubles (Lawrence, KA, 1985);Google ScholarDmytryshyn, Basil (ed.), Medieval Russia: A Source Book, 850–1700 (Ft Worth, TX, 1991), 359–72;Google ScholarZenkovsky, Serge A., Medieval Russia's Epics, Chronicles, and Tales (New York, 1963), 379–87.Google Scholar

66 Whitmore, John, ‘A New View of the World’ (MS);Google ScholarChandler, , Cambodia, 123–32.Google Scholar

67 Beaune, Ideology, esp. pt I, and 323, focusing on the pre–1450 era, but arguing that the French royal religion maintained its peasant hold through 1789; Ladurie, French State, 276–83.Google ScholarSimilar arguments appear in Krynen, , Idéal du prince, 269–77;Google ScholarYardeni, , Conscience nationale, 43–56.Google Scholar

68 See Hobsbawm, , Nations and Nationalism, 18–21, 87–8.Google Scholar

69 Greenfeld, Nationalism, ch. 2. On conceptualization of political space, Paul, Alliès, L'invention du territoire (Grenoble, 1980).Google Scholar

70 See Inscriptions 848–1076 in Chas. Duroiselle, , A List of Inscriptions Found in Burma, I (Rangoon, 1921); Lieberman, Cycles, chs 2, 5.Google Scholar

71 Cf. CHJ, IV, 89–95, 596–659; Ooms, Tokugawa Ideology.Google Scholar

72 Margadant, Ted W., ‘French Rural Society in the Nineteenth Century,’ Agricultural History 53 (1979): 644–51;Google ScholarWeber, , Peasants into Frenchmen (Stanford, 1976);Google ScholarLehning, James R., Peasant and French (Cambridge, 1995).Google Scholar

73 Woodside, , Vietnam, 121.Google Scholar

74 CHJ, IV, 412, 616–20, 639–42;Google ScholarTotman, , Early Modem Japan, 366–77;Google ScholarHarootunian, H.D., Things Seen and Unseen (Chicago, 1987).Google Scholar

75 Beaune, Ideology, ch. 6, p. 313;Google ScholarKrynen, , Idéal du prince, 207–39;Google ScholarCollins, , State, 101–2, 173–4.Google Scholar

76 Phrases from Anderson, , Imagined Communities, 11.Google Scholar

77 Colley, , Britons (New Haven, 1992), ch. 1, esp. p. 18.Google Scholar

78 Moore, , Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy (Boston, 1966);Google ScholarAston, T.H. and Philpin, C.H.E. (eds), The Brenner Debate (Cambridge, 1987);Google ScholarAnderson, , Lineages;Google ScholarNorth, and Thomas, , The Rise of the Western World (Cambridge, 1973).Google Scholar

79 Skocpol, , States and Social Revolutions (Cambridge, 1979);Google ScholarFiner in Tilly, Charles (ed.), The Formation of National States in Western Europe (Princeton, 1975), 84–163;Google Scholar Tilly in ibid., 3–83; idem, Coercion; Downing, , The Military Revolution and Political Change (Princeton, 1992).Google Scholar

80 This typology I have developed from Kuznets, , Modern Economic Growth (New Haven, 1966), esp. 490–509; Feuerwerker, ‘Address,’ 760–62;Google ScholarMokyr, Joel, The Lever of Riches (New York, 1990), 3–16;Google ScholarHuang, Philip C.C., ‘A Reply to Ramon Myers,’ JAS 50, 3 (1991): 629–33; idem, Peasant Family, esp. 11–18; Subrahmanyam, Merchants, 2–7; Frank and Gills, World System, 81–114, 149–51. On protoindustrialization, see Wigen, ‘Geographic Imagination,’ 13–15.Google Scholar

81 Price, Roger, An Economic History of Modern France 1730–1914 (London, 1975);Google ScholarLéon, Pierre et al. , Historie économique et sociale de la France, III (Paris, 1976);Google ScholarKemp, Tom, Economic Forces in French History (London, 1971), chs 5, 6.Google Scholar

82 Reid, Age of Commerce, II, ch. 5; Rieber, Alfred J., Merchants and Entrepreneurs in Imperial Russia (Chapel Hill, NC, 1982).Google Scholar

83 Abu-Lughod, Hegemony, ch. 11. Arguments for European precocity appear in Chaunu, Pierre, L'expansion européenne du XIIIe au XVe siècle (Paris, 1969), 335–39 (cf. Adas, Machines, 21); Mann, Sources, I, 373–413, 504 (esp. 377–9), which sees a superior European economic dynamic by 1000. Cf. Elvin, Pattern, pts 2, 3.Google Scholar See too O'Brien's, Patrick modest quantification of the impact of overseas trade, ‘European Economic Development: The Contribution of the Periphery,’ The Economic History Review 35, 1 (1982): 1–18.Google Scholar

84 Bray, , The Rice Economies (Berkeley, 1986), esp. 1–7, 198–217.Google Scholar

85 Jones, , Miracle, 226–7 and passim.Google Scholar

86 Ibid., 15–21, 226–7.

87 Brenner in Aston and Philpin, Brenner Debate; Root, , Peasants and King in Burgundy(Berkeley, 1987); Jones, Miracle; Pipes, Old Regime; Hall, Powers and Liberties; Mann, Sources; North and Thomas, Western World. Not all a re explicitly comparative within Europe, much less Eurasia.Google Scholar

88 Yamamura, in Hall, John W. et al. (eds), Japan Before Tokugawa (Princeton, 1981), 327–72.Google ScholarCf. Masahide, Bito in CHJ, IV, 373–8.Google Scholar

89 See references to Asian dynamism, supra and infra.Google Scholar

90 Feuerwerker, ‘State and t he Economy.’ Without attempting East-West comparisons, Hoffman, Philip T., Growth in a Traditional Society: The French Countryside 1450–1815 (Princeton, 1996), also sees expansion resulting more from favorable political and trade openings than from peculiar cultural features or property rights.Google Scholar

91 Rozman, , Urban Networks in Russia, 1750–1800, and Premodern Periodization (Princeton, 1976), esp. 33–40, 84.Google ScholarCf. Ladurie, Emmanuel Le Roy (ed.), Histoire de la France urbaine, III (Paris, 1981), esp. 287–389;Google ScholarJurgen Schneider in Fischer, et al. , World Economy, 15–36. On commercial vigor and specialization in our six areas, see previous notes, plus Lieberman, ‘Secular Trends’ Hong Lysa, Thailand;Google ScholarThanh-Nha, Nguyen, Tableau économique du Vietnam aux XVII et XVIII siècles (Paris, 1970);Google ScholarChaunu, Pierre and Gascon, Richard, Histoire économique et social de la France, I, 1 (Paris, 1977);Google ScholarHickey, Daniel, ‘Innovation and Obstacles to Growth in the Agriculture of Early Modern France,’ French Historical Studies 15, 2 (1987): 208–40;Google ScholarVries, Jan de, The Economy of Europe in an Age of Crisis, 1600–1750 (Cambridge, 1976);Google ScholarKahan, Arcadius, The Plow, the Hammer, and the Knout (Chicago, 1985);Google ScholarBlum, Jerome, Lord and Peasant in Russia (Princeton, 1961); Totman, Early Modem Japan, chs 5, 8, 12–13, 20–1;Google ScholarMorris-Suzuki, Tessa, The Technological Transformation of Japan (Cambridge, 1994).Google Scholar

92 Brenner, in Aston and Philpin, Brenner Debate, 21.Google Scholar

93 For theoretical discussions of the relation between demographic growth and economic change, and for divergent case studies, see Simon, Julian L., The Economics of Population Growth (Princeton, 1977), ch. 2;Google ScholarBoserup, Ester, Population and Technological Change (Chicago, 1981), 3–9, 76–7, 94–7;Google ScholarPostan, M.M., Hatcher, John, Ladurie, Emmanuel Le Roy, and Bois, Guy in Aston and Philpin, Brenner Debate; Mokyr, Lever, 4–6;Google ScholarSkinner, G. William, ‘Marketing and Social Structure in Rural China,’JAS 24, 1 (1964): 3–43 and 24, 2 (1965): 195–228;Google ScholarLadurie, Emmanuel Le Roy, The French Peasantry 1450–1660 (Berkeley, 1987), chs 1–4; and Japanese data in previous notes.Google Scholar

94 Figures from Hallam, Elizabeth, Capetian France, 987–1328 (London, 1980), 286–8; Ladurie, Peasantry, 8–10, 23, 101, 402–6;Google ScholarBraudel, Fernand, The Identity of France, II (New York, 1990), 156–80;Google ScholarCollins, , State, 181;Google ScholarHellie, , Enserfment, 304–5 (I extrapolate from Miliukov); Blum, Lord, 17, 120, 278; Totman, Before Perry, 128; idem, Early Modern Japan, 140, 251, 467; Lieberman, ‘Secular Trends,’ 11–12; Reid, Age of Commerce, I, 14;Google ScholarSternstein, Larry, ‘The Growth of the Population of the World's Pre-eminent “Primate City”,’ JSEAS 15, 1 (1984): 45; Li Tana, ‘Inner Region’; Woodside, Vietnam, 158–9;Google ScholarMcEvedy, Colin and Jones, Richard, Atlas of World Population History (London, 1978).Google Scholar

95 See supra, n. 18, esp. Lamb, Changing Climate, 219–20, on Russia; plus Reid, Age of Commerce, II, 2 9 1–8.Google Scholar

96 Skinner, G. William, ‘Presidential Address: The Structure of Chinese History,’ JAS 44, 2 (1985): 271–92; Eastman, Family, Fields, 4;Google ScholarGottfried, Robert S., The Black Death (New York, 1983);Google ScholarLanger, Lawrence, ‘The Black Death in Russia,’ Russian History [RH] 21, 1 (1975): 53–67;Google ScholarCipolla, Carlo M., Before the Industrial Revolution (New York, 1980), ch. 5; andGoogle Scholarsources in Lieberman, Victor, ‘Local Integration and Eurasian Analogies,’ MAS 27, 3 (1993), 498, n. 48.Google Scholar

97 Goldstone, , Revolution, 180–3, 356; Boserupt, Population, 94–5.Google Scholar

98 Previous notes, plus Nguyen, Tableau, 47–107; Ishii, Yoneo (ed.), Thailand: A Rice-Growing Society (Honolulu, 1978), chs 1–3;Google ScholarTakaya, Yoshikazu, Agricultural Development of a Tropical Delta (Honolulu, 1987), chs 1, 4;Google ScholarKeiji, Nagahara and Yamamura, Kozo, ‘Shaping the Process of Unification,’ JJS 14, 1 (1988): 77–109; Mokyr, Lever, chs 4, 5; Ladurie, La France urbaine, III, 3 4 6–8 9;Google ScholarMiskimin, Harry A., The Economy of Later Renaissance Europe 1460–1600 (Cambridge, 1977), chs 3–6;Google ScholarMoulin, Annie, Peasantry and Society in France since 1789 (Cambridge, 1991), 8–11.Google Scholar

99 Totman, , Early Modern Japan, 148; 7 3–9, 141–8.Google ScholarSee too the revisionist view of 17th century trade, Innes, Robert L.,‘The Door Ajar’ (PhD, Univ. of Michigan, 1988).Google Scholar

100 Reid, , Age of Commerce, I, II; Lieberman, ‘Local Integration.’Google Scholar

101 Collins, , State, 179–83, 219–20.Google Scholar

102 Kahan, , Plow, Hammer, ch. 4.Google Scholar

103 Barrett, Ward in Tracy, James D. (ed.), The Rise of Merchant Empires (Cambridge, 1990), 224–54, esp. Fig. 7·1 and Table 7·3;Google Scholar Frederic Mauro in ibid., 255–86; Flynn, Dennis O. and Giraldez, Arturo, ‘Born with a “Silver Spoon”: The Origin of World Trade in 1571,’ Journal of World History 6, 2 (1995): 201–21. See too Richards, Precious Metals, pt 3; Curtin, Cross-Cultural, chs 6–10.Google Scholar

104 Nagahara and Yamamura, ‘Process of Unification,’ 81–2. Cf. Yamamura and Tetsuo Kamiki in Richards, Precious Metals, 329–62.Google Scholar

105 French, in Brater, James H. and French, (eds), Studies in Russian Historical Geography, I (London, 1983), 79, 19;Google ScholarSmith, R.E., Peasant Farming in Muscovy (Cambridge, 1977). 27–33. 109–25, 203–26.Google Scholar

106 Crosby, , Columbian Exchange, ch. 5; Totman, Early Modern Japan, 313; Lee, ‘Food Supply,’ building on Ping-Ti Ho;Google ScholarPerkins, Dwight H., Agricultural Development in China 1368–1968 (Chicago, 1969), ch. 3.Google Scholar

107 ‘Food Supply,’ esp. 738–43.Google Scholar

108 Barrett in Tracy, Merchant Empires, 246; Eastman, Family, Fields, 125–30 suggest that prior to 1700 at most 1/3 of China's imported silver derived from Europe or the New World. Japan was the chief external source to 1640, and large-scale inflows from Britain to China began only c. 1760. But none of these calculations allow for substantial, though ill quantified, domestic silver production or overland imports from mines in Burma and Vietnam. Cf. Goldstone, Revolution, 372–4. MainlandSoutheast Asia's reliance on European/New World silver may have been similar to that of China, but Tokugawa Japan obviously was far less dependent.Google Scholar

109 Vries, De, Economy, 128–46 passim.Google Scholar

110 Cf. the typology at Wigen, ‘Geographic Imagination,’ 12–13.Google Scholar

111 Yamamura, Kozo, ‘From Coins to Rice,’ JJS 14, 2 (1988): 341–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

112 On the monetization of Muscovite government, Zlotnik, Marc, ‘Muscovite Fiscal Policy, 1462–1584,’ Russian History 6 (1979): 243–58; Blum, Lord, 131, 142–3, 228–9; Hellie, Enserfinent, 24–5, 36–8, 158–9; Plavsic in Pintner and Rowney, Officialdom, 23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

113 Wyatt, , Thailand, 88ff., 131–2; Ishii, Thailand, ch. 2; Akin, Thai Society, esp. ch. 7; Hong Lysa, Nineteenth Century, chs 1–4; Terwiel, Travellers’ Eyes, 113, 138, 150, 169, 228, 242–3, 253.Google Scholar

114 Nguyen, , Tableau, 28, 32–5, 150–1;Google ScholarSmith, R.B., ‘Politics and Society in Viet-Nam during the Early Nguyen Period (1802–62), ’ Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, 1974: 164–5; Woodside, Vietnam, 79–80, 139–40.Google Scholar

115 Beik, , Absolutism and Society; Kettering, Patrons.Google Scholar

116 Hellie, , Enserfment, esp. pts 1, 2; Kivelson, Autocracy, also emphasizing local orientations; Hittle, Service City; Lieberman, Cycles, chs 2, 5.Google Scholar

117 Brown, , Central Authority & Local Autonomy in the Formation of Early Modern Japan (Stanford, 1993).Google Scholar

118 Muchembled, , Popular Culture.Google Scholar

119 Briggs, Robin, Communities of Belief (Oxford, 1989), 53–7, 384–402;Google ScholarRevel, Jacques in Kaplan, Steven L. (ed.), Understanding Popular Culture (Berlin, 1984).Google Scholar

120 Quote is from Dewald, Jonathan, Pont-St-Pierre 1398–1789 (Berkeley, 1987), 284, discussing the erosion of Norman lordships.Google Scholar

121 Collins, , State, 43, 156, 184.Google Scholar

122 Harding, , Power Elite, esp. ch. 12, focusing on c. 1560–1650.Google Scholar

123 Moriya in Nakane and Oishi, Tokugawa, 97–123, quote 122; Berry, this volume; Totman, Before Perry, 188–99.Google Scholar

124 Cf. Stevens, , Soldiers on the Steppe (De Kalb, IL, 1995); Kahan, Plow, Hammer, chs 1, 2, 5; Blum, Lord, 247–68, 330–2;Google ScholarAvrich, Paul, Russian Rebels 1600–1800 (New York, 1972); Nguyen, Tableau, 111–82; Li Tana, ‘Inner Region,’ ch. 1; Lieberman, ‘Local Integration,’ 504–11; Ishii, Thailand, chs 1–3.Google Scholar

125 Berry, , this volume. One is reminded of the emphasis in Anderson, Imagined Communities, on print-capitalism as an agent of standardized national languages and identities.Google Scholar

126 So too in Russia, although literacy was less common, by 1700 everyday Russian had begun to assert itself in literature at the expense of archaic Slavonicized forms, while the 18th century saw the first Russian dictionaries and the beginning of modern literary culture. On literary/linguistic developments, see Thu-ta, Maung, Sa-hso-daw-mya at-htok-pat-ti (Rangoon, 1971);Google ScholarTin, Pe Maung, Myan-ma sa-pei thamaing(Rangoon, 1955);Google ScholarAeusrivongse, Nidhi, ‘The Early Bangkok Period: Literary Change and Its Social Causes,’ Asian Studies Review 18, 1 (1994): 69–76;Google ScholarWenk, Klaus, Thai Literature: An Introduction (Bangkok, 1995), 6–67;Google ScholarDurand, Maurice M. and Huan, Nguyen Tran, An Introduction to Vietnamese Literature (New York, 1985), chs 1, 5–9;Google ScholarThong, Huynh Sanh, The Heritage of Vietnamese Poetry (New Haven, 1979), xxvii–xxxi;Google ScholarRuch, Barbara in Hall, John W. and Takeshi, Toyoda (eds), Japan in the Muromachi Age (Berkeley, 1977), 279–309;Google ScholarShively, Donald H. in CHJ, IV, 706–69; Reischauer and Craig, Japan, 35–8, 99–107;Google ScholarMiller, Roy Andrew, The Japanese Language (Chicago, 1967), ch. 3 (note that kana arose in the gth century); Rickard, French Language, chs 5, 6;Google ScholarHowarth, W.D., Life and Letters in France in the 17th Century (New York, 1965); Chartier, Cultural Uses, chs 5–7;Google ScholarRiasanovsky, Nicholas, A History of Russia (New York, 1984), 285–99, 349–60;Google ScholarMarker, Gary, Publishing, Printing and the Origins of Intellectual Life in Russia, 1700–1800 (Princeton, 1985), chs 5–7.Google Scholar

127 On mainland SE Asian literacy, Lieberman, ‘Local Integration,’ 508–10; idem in Reid, Early Modern, 245–6; Terwiel, Travellers' Eyes, 59, 157–8, 179, 251–2, claiming ‘a very high proportion’ of male literacy in central Siam; Alexander Woodside, ‘Political Theory and Economic Growth in Late Traditional Vietnam’ (MS).Google Scholar

128 Smith, ‘History of the Book,’ 335–6. On French and Japanese publishing, cf. Chartier, Cultural Uses; Furet and Ozouf, Reading and Writing; Briggs, Communities; Nakane and Oishi, Tokugawa, 61–2, 118–21; Totman, Early Modern Japan, 27, 195–211, 354, 401–36.Google Scholar

129 See previous references to the French Wars of Religions, the Robe-Wrapping dispute of Burma, and the Schism in Russia.Google Scholar

130 Wales, H.G. Quaritch, Ancient Siamese Government and Administration (New York, 1965); Wyatt, Thailand, 70–86 passim.Google Scholar

131 L.H., John Keep, Soldiers of the Tsar (Oxford, 1985), ch. 1; Hellie, Enserfment, chs 2, 9;Google ScholarAlef, Gustav, ‘Muscovite Military Reforms in the Second Half of the Fifteenth Century,’ Forschungen zur osteuropaischen Geschichte [FOG] 18 (1973): 73–108.Google Scholar

132 Tax and military reforms were adumbrated in the 1360s, but solidified c. 1435–1445. Henneman, John Bell, Royal Taxation in Fourteenth-Century France (Philadelphia, 1976), esp. 274–311; Lewis, Later Medieval France, 47ff, 101–10; Collins, this volume.Google Scholar

133 Vietnam, c. 1600–1778 is an exception in so far as imported guns helped the southern Nguyen regime to hold off the northern Trinh. On the other hand, the Nguyen advanced the Vietnamese ecumene in its broadest sense, and after 1801 guns and French-style citadels bolstered Nguyen efforts at centralization.Google Scholar

134 Roberts, , ‘The Military Revolution, 1560–1660,’ ch. 7 in Essays in Swedish History (London, 1953);Google Scholar plus Hale, J.R., War and Society in Renaissance Europe, 1450–1620 (New York, 1985);Google ScholarMcNeill, William H., The Pursuit of Power (Chicago, 1982); Parker, Military Revolution; Tilly, Coercion; Samuel Finer in Tilly, National States; Marshall Poe, ‘The Consequences of the Military Revolution in Muscovy in Comparative Perspective’(MS).Google Scholar

135 Tilly, , Coercion, 104, 76ff, 99–104; Anisimov, Peter, 160–233 passim; Collins, this volume; Harding, Power Elite, ch. 13;Google ScholarStone, Bailey, The Genesis of the French Revolution (Cambridge, 1995).Google Scholar

136 Lieberman, ‘Local Integration,’ 492–5, 511–13. Cf. Skinner, C. (tr.), The Battle for Junk Ceylon (Dordrecht, Holland, 1985).Google Scholar

137 Schaeper, Thomas in Sonnino, Paul (ed.), The Reign of Louis XIV (Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 1990), 27–43;Google ScholarBluche, François, Louis XIV (Oxford, 1990), ch. 8;Google Scholar Anisimov, Peter, 70–86; Cracraft, James (ed.), Peter the Great Transforms Russia (Lexington, MA, 1991), pt IV.Google Scholar

138 Vries, De, Economy, 242–3, and chs 7, 8. The mutual stimulation of war, economic growth, and state-building receives emphasis also at Tilly, Coercion, esp. chs 3, 4;Google Scholaridem in Skocpol, Theda (ed.), Bringing the State Back In (Cambridge, 1985), 169–91;Google ScholarAnderson, , Lineages, 32–41; Kahan, Plow, Hammer, chs 7, 8.Google Scholar

139 Lieberman, Cycles, 96–107, 250–62; idem, ‘Local Integration,’ 489–519; Koenig, Polity, 14–30, 107–18; Hong Lysa, Thailand, 38ff, 77, 84;Google ScholarWhitmore, John K., Vietnam, Ho Quy Ly, and the Ming (New Haven, 1985), 74–6;Google ScholarWyatt, , Thailand, 171–2.Google Scholar

140 Berry, this volume. A similar argument appears in Akira, Hayami, ‘A Great Transformation,’ Bonner Zeitschrift fur Japanologie 8 (1976): 3–13; and Kozo Yamamura in Hall, Before Tokugawa, 327–72.Google Scholar

141 See the comparison of military and domestic dynamics in Europe and Japan at White, ‘State Growth,’ 1–25, esp. 14.Google Scholar

142 Without invoking European comparisons, Totman, Early Modem Japan, chs 12, 13, emphasizes the growing strain on Japan's resource base after c. 1700 and the aborted expansion into Ezo.Google Scholar

143 Jansen, , China in the Tokugawa World (Cambridge, MA, 1992), 76–88. Cf. Berry, this volume; and Harootunian, Seen and Unseen, 36–56, 186–96.Google ScholarHowell, David L., ‘Ainu Ethnicity and the Boundaries of the Early Modern Japanese State,’ PP, 142 (1994): 69–93 argues that after 1600 the categories ‘Ainu’ and ‘Japanese’ became more clearly delineated, but less through warfare than the political needs of the Matsumae domain within the Tokugawa system; and the impact on Japan at large appears to have been quite limited.Google Scholar

144 CHJ, IV, 373–8.Google Scholar

145 Cf. Behrens, C.B.A., Society, Government and the Enlightenment (New York, 1985), 161–2.Google Scholar

146 Lieberman, Cycles; Wyatt, ‘Subtle Revolution.’

147 Totman, , Early Modern Japan, 168–83; Ooms, Tokugawa Ideology, analyzing what he terms Japan's first ‘fully closed ideology.’Google Scholar

148 Of course, West European and Central/East European administrative philosophies also differed, as for example, in the latter's greater cameralist emphasis. Raeff, , The Well-Ordered Police State (New Haven, 1983), pt. 3;Google Scholaridem, Understanding Imperial Russia (Columbia, 1984), esp. 24–31; Behrens, Society, esp. 116–62.Google Scholar

149 Collins, , State, 168–70, 264.Google Scholar

150 Totman, , Tokugawa Bakufu, 234. Cf. Collins, State, 145.Google Scholar

151 See supra n. 139, plus Denis J.B. Shaw in Bater and French, Historical Geography, 118–42; Chaunu, in Chaunu and Gascon, Histoire économique, I, 1: 214–24; De Vries, Economy, 200–54;Google ScholarBergeron, Louis, France under Napoleon (Princeton, 1981), ch. 7; Kahan, Plow, Hammer, chs 4–9; Yamamura in Hall, Before Tokugawa, 327–72;Google ScholarHubbard, Robert V. and Hafner, James A., The History of Inland Waterway Development in Thailand (Ann Arbor, MI, 1977); Li Tana, ‘Inner Region,’ ch. 1.Google Scholar

152 Ricklefs, M.C., ‘Some Statistical Evidence on Javanese Social, Economic, and Demographic History in the Later Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,’ MAS 20, 1 (1986): 1–32;Google ScholarOwen, Norman in Owen (ed.), Death and Disease in Southeast Asia (Singapore, 1987), 91–114.Google Scholar

153 Lieberman, ‘Local Integration,’ 506–8; essays by Hall and by Yamamura in Hall, Before Tokugawa, 211–19, 327–72; Totman, Before Perry, 195–9:Google ScholarLloyd, Howell A., The State, France, and the Sixteenth Century (London, 1983), 30–5, 111–13; Knecht, Francis I, 308–10; Dewald, Pont-St-Pierre, 127–56, 212. Cf. Root, Peasants, arguing that the 18th century French monarchy strengthened, rather than weakened, communal forms of peasant economic organization.Google Scholar

154 Tsukahira, T.G., Feudal Control in Tokugawa Japan (Cambridge, MA, 1966); Reischauer and Craig, Japan, 94. Cf. De Vries, Economy, 206–7; Koenig, Burmese Polity, 31, 59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

155 Essays by Tilly and by Rokkan in Tilly, Formation, 40–9 (citing Strayer), 77–80, 581–97.Google Scholar

156 Cherniavsky, Michael, ‘The Old Believers and the New Religion,’ Slavic Review 25, 1 (1966): 1–39; Paul Werth, ‘Apostasy, Alienation, and the Reconfiguration of Imperial and Religious Space in Russia's Eastern Provinces’ (MS).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

157 See, e.g., Tun, Than (ed.), The Royal Orders 0f Burma, 10 vols (Tokyo, 1983–1990), IV, 130–1, V, 458, 572;Google ScholarWoodside, , Vietnam, chs 3, 4; Sonnino (ed.), Louis XIV, chs 10–14; Anisimov, Peter, 217–25; Collins, State, 119–22.Google Scholar

158 Elias, , The Civilizing Process, 2 vols (New York, 1978, 1982), esp. I, ch. 1 and II, ch. 1; Ellery Schalk in Asch and Birke, Princes, Patronage, 245–63; Tsukahira, Feudal Control.Google Scholar

159 Sternstein, , ‘Primate City,’ 49; Koenig, Polity, 107–18.Google Scholar

160 McNeill, , Plagues, ch. 3; Lamb, Climate Present, II, 435–49.Google Scholar

161 Aung-Thwin, Pagan, ch. 9; Mabbett, Ian and Chandler, David, The Khmers (Oxford, 1995), ch. 15;Google ScholarCHJ, III, chs 3, 4;Google ScholarVernadsky, George, Kievan Russia (New Haven, 1976), ch. 8.Google Scholar Cf. the emphasis on peripheral growth in Yoffee, Norman and Cowgill, George L. (eds), The Collapse of Ancient States and Civilizations (Tucson, AZ, 1988), chs 1, 10. In short, we see c. 400–900 c.e. a political/economic shift from Eurasian cores to outlying areas, several of which faced challenges from their own peripheries c. 1100–1400.Google Scholar

162 On disease and climate, previous notes. On bullion and commercial contraction, clearer in Europe than East Asia, Day, John, The Medieval Market Economy (Oxford, 1987);Google ScholarMiskimin, Harry A., The Economy of Early Renaissance Europe, 1300–1460 (Cambridge, 1960), 129–34; Blum, Lord, 57–73; Richards, Previous Metals, pts 1, 2.Google Scholar

163 On inflationary causes and effects, again clearest for Europe, Morineau, Michel in Histoire économique, I, 2, 929–40;Google ScholarGoldstone, , Revolution, 89, 122, 186–7, 360–94;Google ScholarBlum, Jerome, ‘Prices in Russia in the Sixteenth Century,’ JEH 16 (1956): 182–99; Miskimin, Economy 1460–1600, 35–46; Crummey, Formation, 7–8; Mann, Sources, 433–4, 457–8; Flynn and Giraldez, ‘Silver Spoon.’Google Scholar

164 Duby, , Middle Ages, 298, echoing R.I. Moore in this volume.Google Scholar

165 See Lieberman, Cycles, 32–46, 285–6; Wyatt, Thailand, 86–98; Crummey, Formation, chs 6, 8;Google ScholarKliuchevsky, V.O., A Course in Russian History (Armonk, NY, 1994), ch. 1; Parker, Absolutism, 27–45.Google Scholar

166 See sources for Table 1. China too saw an increase 1400–1600 off. 110%, Eastman, Family, Fields, 4.Google Scholar

167 Goldstone, , Revolution, 31–8, 63–169.Google Scholar

168 Ibid., 192–4, 274; Akin, Thai Society, 27–31, 172–3.

169 Collins, , State, 3, 61–124 passim.Google Scholar

170 Lieberman, Cycles, 211–24; Li Tana, ‘Inner Region,’ ch. 7; Raeff, Marc in Forster, Robert and Greene, Jack P. (eds), Preconditions of Revolution in Early Modern Europe (Baltimore, 1970), 161–203; Avrich, Rebels, ch. 4.Google Scholar

171 French victory in the American War could not erase debts occasioned by that war and by three earlier 18th century reverses. See infra n. 177. On Burma and Siam's military problems, Lieberman, Cycles, ch. 4; Wyatt, Thailand, 124–38.Google Scholar

172 262%, 1700–1800. Gabriel Ardant in Tilly, Formation, 199.Google Scholar

173 Leonard Blussé, ‘Chinese Overseas Expansion and State Formation Processes in Maritime Southeast Asia, 1550–1800’ (MS); Gungwu, Wang, China and the Chinese Overseas (Singapore, 1992), pt. 1; Eastman, Family, Fields, chs 4, 6;Google ScholarBayly, C.A., Indian Society and the Making of the British Empire (Cambridge, 1988), ch. 1.Google Scholar

174 Best documented in France, Goldstone, Revolution, 209–10. Cf. Lieberman, Cycles, 159–61.Google Scholar

175 On challenges to existing hierarchies, Goldstone, Revolution, ch. 3 and 346; Chaussinand-Nogaret, Guy, The French Nobility in the Eighteenth Century (Cambridge, 1985); Dewald, Pont-St-Pierre, esp. chs 2,4;Google ScholarSmith, Jay Michael, ‘The Culture of Meritin Old Regime France’ (PhD, Univ. of Michigan, 1990), chs 5, 6; David K. Wyatt, ‘The Eighteenth Century in Southeast Asia’ (MS); idem, Thailand, 127–32; Teruko Saito, ‘Rural Monetization and Land-Mortgage Thet-kayils in Kon-Baung Burma’ (MS); Lieberman, Cycles, 156ff, 221; Hittle, Service City, 170–1; Blum, Lord, 288–303, 361–2, 470–93;Google ScholarMelton, Edgar, ‘Proto-Industrialization, Serf Agriculture and Agrarian Social Structure,’ PP, 115 (1987): 69–106; Totman, Before Perry, 192–9, 231–2.Google Scholar

176 Doyle, William, Origins of the French Revolution (Oxford, 1980), ch. 4;Google ScholarChartier, Roger, The Cultural Origins of the French Revolution (Durham, NC, 1991);Google ScholarFuret, François, Interpreting the French Revolution (Cambridge, 1981);Google ScholarFarge, Arlette, Subversive Words (Univ. Park, PA, 1992).Google ScholarCf. Raeff, Marc, Understanding Imperial Russia (New York, 1984), 58–61, 129–35; Madariaga, Catherine, ch. 34; Marker, Publishing, chs 4–7; Totman, Early Modern Japan, ch. 19.Google Scholar

177 Skocpol, States and Revolutions. See too Behrens, Society, Government, 164–5, and Stone, Genesis of French Revolution.Google Scholar

178 Koenig, , Polity, ch. 1; Wyatt, Thailand.ch. 6; Le Thanh-Khoi, Histoire, ch. 8;Google ScholarEllis, Geoffrey, The Napoleonic Empire (London, 1991); Church, Revolution and Red Tape.Google Scholar

179 Blanning, T.C.W., The French Revolution (Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 1987), 41–9;Google ScholarPrice, Roger, A Concise History of France (Cambridge, 1993), 139–41; Chaussinand-Nogaret, French Nobility; Becker, Civil Society, esp. pt I.Google Scholar

180 See Kierstead, Thomas, The Geography of Power in Medieval Japan (Princeton, 1992), 6–7, 122–3;Google ScholarDuara, Prasenjit, Rescuing History from the Nation (Chicago, 1995).Google Scholar

181 Smail, ‘Autonomous History’; Weber, Peasants into Frenchmen; Sahlins, Boundaries.

182 On modernization theory and its critics, Downing, Military Revolution, 5–6; Hunt, Lynn, Politics, Culture and Class in the French Revolution (Berkeley, 1984), 205–12.Google Scholar

183 Elvin, Pattern, pt 2; idem in Abrams, P. and Wrigley, E.A. (eds), Towns in Societies (Cambridge, 1978), 79–89;Google ScholarHaeger, John Winthrop (ed.), Crisis and Prosperity in Sung China (Tucson, 1976).Google Scholar

184 Rowe in Zunz, Reliving, 260–83; Naquin and Rawski, Chinese Society; Huang, Peasant Family, pt 1;Google ScholarJohnson, et al. , Popular Culture; Eastman, Family, Fields;Google ScholarSkinner, G. William (ed.), The City in Late Imperial China (Stanford, 1977), 26–8;Google ScholarChu, T'ung-tsu, Local Government in China under the Ch'ing (Stanford, 1962);Google ScholarBartlett, Beatrice S., Monarchs and Ministers (Berkeley, 1991);Google ScholarVen, Hans van de, ‘Recent Studies of Modern Chinese History,’ MAS 30 (1996): 225–41.Google Scholar

185 Richards, , The Mughal Empire (Cambridge, 1993), 1–2et seq.Google ScholarCf. Singh, Chetan, ‘Centre and Periphery in the Mughal State,’ MAS 22, 2 (1988): 299–318.Google Scholar

186 Richards, Empire, esp. chs 1–4, 9; idem, ‘The Seventeenth-Century Crisis in South Asia,’ MAS 24, 4 (1990): 625–38;Google ScholarHodgson, Marshall G.S., The Gunpowder Empires and Modern Times (Chicago, 1972), ch. 2; Bayly, Society, ch. 2; and supra n. 3.Google Scholar

187 If Muscovy's domain was more vast, its population c. 1700 was barely 8% that of the Mughal realm, and was more concentrated.Google Scholar

188 Cf. Chu, Local Government, chs 1,10; Richards, Empire, ch. 4.Google Scholar

189 Bayly, ‘Communalism,’ 181ff; Richards, Empire, 3, 53, 60. See too Metcalf, Barbara, ‘Presidential Address: Too Little and Too Much: Reflections on Muslims in the History of India,’ JAS 54, 4 (1995): 951–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

190 Richards, Empire, 151ff, 175ff, 218, 284, 290; Bayly, C.A., Imperial Meridian (London, 1989), 22;Google ScholarTalbot, Cynthia, ‘Inscribing the Other, Inscribing the Self,’ CSSH 37, 4 (1995): 692–722.Google Scholar

191 Wink, , Land and Sovereignty in India (Cambridge, 1986);Google ScholarAlam, , The Crisis of Empire in Mughal North India (Delhi, 1986);Google Scholar Bayly, Society, ch. 1; idem, Rulers, Townsmen and Bazaars (Cambridge, 1983), ch. 1; Richards, Empire, ch. 12;Google ScholarCole, J.R.I., Roots of North Indian Shiism in Iran and Iraq (Berkeley, 1988);Google ScholarGordon, Stewart, The Marathas 1600–1818 (Cambridge, 1993).Google Scholar

192 Previous note, plus Burton Stein, ‘State Formation and Economy Reconsidered,’ and Perlin, Frank, ‘State Formation Reconsidered,’ MAS 19, 3 (1985): 387–413 and 415–80; Bayly, Society, 14–18.Google Scholar

193 Bayly, Society, 5, chs 1, 2; Washbrook, ‘Progress.’Google Scholar

194 Discussion of archipelagic Southeast Asia derives from Reid, Age of Commerce, I and II; Lieberman, ‘Local Integration,’ 540–82;Google Scholaridem, ‘Wallerstein's System and the International Context of Early Modern Southeast Asian History, ’Journal of Asian History 24, 1 (1990): 70–90;Google Scholaridem, ‘Mainland-Archipelagic Parallels and Contrasts, c. 1750–1850,’ forthcoming in Reid, Anthony (ed.), The Last Stand of the Autonomous States of Southeast Asia.Google Scholar

195 Ricklefs, M.C., Jogjakarta under Sultan Mangkubumi 1749–1792 (London, 1974); Carey, ‘Just King,’ 59–137.Google Scholar

196 Imagined Communities, esp. 114–15, 127–32, 176–85.Google Scholar

197 Lieberman, ‘Ethnic Politics,’ 480–2.Google Scholar

198 Henley, ‘Ethnogeographic Integration,’ 286–324 also has sought to contrast the Indonesian and Indochinese experience by analyzing differences in precolonial heritage, colonial conquest, and colonial policy; yet he generally fails to consider the degree to which the latter two sets of factors depended on the first.Google Scholar