Prosecutor v. Naser Orić: The International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia Judgment of Srebrenica's Muslim Wartime Commander

Abstract

In certain quarters of the former Yugoslavia, the ICTY judgment issued on 30 June 2006 in Prosecutor v. Naser Orić has been strongly criticized for meting out a two-year prison sentence to the Bosnian Muslim wartime commander of Srebrenica. After a short sketch of the factual background which the trial chamber considered to be the pivotal sentencing factor, this note focuses on the legal issues underlying his conviction for having failed to prevent the murder and cruel treatment of a number of Serb prisoners. In particular, the trial chamber's interpretation of the standard of ‘reason to know’ of these crimes deserves attention. The judgment also gave rise to other significant developments, such as the approach to repeated prosecutorial violations of its disclosure obligations and an important clarification regarding the scope and nature of crimes committed by subordinates of a superior.