Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-fscjk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T03:14:04.821Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Creating and Recreating Iraq: Legacies of the Mandate System in Contemporary Understandings of Third World Sovereignty

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 November 2011

USHA NATARAJAN
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores the League of Nations' role in state formation in Third World or peripheral states and its legacy for contemporary understandings of Third World sovereignty. It examines Iraq under British Mandate, and UN and Coalition of the Willing interventions. This research was prompted by the international-law community's outrage when the Coalition invaded Iraq in March 2003. While the invasion was seen by many as an affront to international law, there was also something faintly familiar about the Coalition's reasoning for the invasion. This feeling of déjà vu escalated once regime change was followed by lengthy nation-building. The idea of recreating Iraq was not a new one. The British were tasked with something similar under the League of Nations Mandate System. UN interventions into failed states also attempt comparable transformations. Indeed, the more one contemplates international law's interventions in Iraq, the less shocking the Coalition's invasion becomes. It starts seeming foreseeable and even inevitable.

Keywords

failed stateIraqLeague of NationssovereigntyTWAIL
Type
ARTICLES
Information
Leiden Journal of International Law , Volume 24 , Issue 4 , December 2011 , pp. 799 - 822
Copyright
Copyright © Foundation of the Leiden Journal of International Law 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See, e.g., (2003) 97 AJIL, a special issue focused on future implications of the Iraq conflict, and (2003) 14 EJIL, focused on the war on terrorism including the Iraq invasion. See also public letters that international lawyers wrote to their governments: ‘Letter: War Would Be Illegal’, The Guardian, 7 March 2003, 29; ‘Howard Must Not Involve Us in an Illegal War’, The Age, 26 February 2003; H. Michael, Canadian Law Professors Declare US-Led War Illegal, World Socialist Website, 22 March 2003, www.wsws.org/articles/2003/mar2003/lawy-m22.shtml; M. Howard, ‘The Bush Doctrine: It's a Brutal World So Act Brutally’, Sunday Times, 23 March 2003, 21.

2 US President George W. Bush, ‘Remarks by the President after Visit with Employees at Nebraska Avenue Homeland Security Complex’, 19 September 2002.

3 See Anghie, A., ‘Colonialism and the Birth of International Institutions: Sovereignty, Economy and the Mandate System of the League of Nations', (2002) 34 NYUJILP 513Google Scholar.

4 US Letter to President of the Security Council, UN Doc. S/2003/351 (2003); Australian Letter to President of the Security Council, UN Doc. S/2003/352 (2003); UK Letter to President of the Security Council, UN Doc. S/2003/350 (2003).

5 See, e.g., Lowe, V., ‘The Iraq Crisis: What Next?’, (2003) 52 ICLQ 859CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Franck, T., ‘What Happens Now? The UN after Iraq’, (2003) 97 AJIL 607CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Falk, R., ‘What Future for the UN Charter System of War Prevention?’, (2003) 97 AJIL 590CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Ayoob, M., ‘The War against Iraq: Normative and Strategic Implications’, in Weiss, T. et al. (eds.), Wars on Terrorism and Iraq (2004), 155, at 159Google Scholar.

7 D. Philpott, Revolutions in Sovereignty (2001), 254.

8 S. Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (1999), 227; M. Fowler and J. Bunck, Law, Power, and the Sovereign State: The Evolution and Application of the Concept of Sovereignty (1995), 93, 124–5.

9 1933 Convention on Rights and Duties of States, 165 LNTS 19, Art. 1.

10 Weber, M., Essays in Sociology (translated and edited by Gerth, H. and Mills, C. Wright) (1946), 77–8Google Scholar.

11 Krasner, supra note 8.

12 Gross, L., ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’, (1948) 42 AJIL 20CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 21–4.

13 Philpott, supra note 7.

14 Charter of the United Nations, Art. 2(1).

15 M. Bedjaoui, Towards a New International Economic Order (1979), 45.

16 See, e.g., A. Anghie, Imperialism, Sovereignty and the Making of International Law (2005); Nesiah, V., ‘Placing International Law: White Spaces on a Map’, (2003) 16 LJIL 1CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gathii, J., ‘Neoliberalism, Colonialism and International Governance: Decentering the International Law of Government Legitimacy’, (2000) 98 Mich. LR 1996CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O. Okafor, Redefining Legitimate Statehood: International Law and State Fragmentation in Africa (2000); E. Quashigah and O. Okafor (eds.), Legitimate Governance in Africa: International and Domestic Legal Perspectives (1999); S. Grovogui, Sovereigns, Quasi-Sovereigns and Africans: Race and Self-Determination in International Law (1996); Mutua, M., ‘Why Redraw the Map of Africa? A Moral and Legal Inquiry’, (1995) 16 Mich. JIL 113Google Scholar.

17 T. Lawrence, The Principles of International Law (1895), 85: Lawrence conceived European states as belonging to the family of nations ‘since time immemorial’.

18 Anghie, A., ‘Finding the Peripheries: Sovereignty and Colonialism in Nineteenth Century International Law’, (1999) 40 Harv. ILJ 1Google Scholar, at 69.

19 Anghie, supra note 16.

20 US President George W. Bush, ‘State of the Union Address’, 29 January 2002.

21 UK Prime Minister Tony Blair, ‘Atlantic Summit Press Conference’, 16 March 2003.

22 See, e.g., Kennedy, D., ‘The Move to Institutions’, (1987) 8 Cardozo Law Review 841Google Scholar; Berman, N., ‘A Perilous Ambivalence: Nationalist Desire, Legal Autonomy, and the Limits of the Interwar Framework’, (1992) 33 HILJ 353Google Scholar, ‘“But the Alternative Is Despair”: European Nationalism and the Modernist Renewal of International Law’, (1993) 106 HLR 1792, ‘“The Appeals of the Orient”: Colonized Desire and the War of the Riff’, in K. Knop (ed.), Gender and Human Rights (2004), 195; M. Koskenniemi, The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International Law 1870–1960 (2002); Anghie, supra note 16.

23 E. Said, Afterword to Orientalism (1995), 331–2.

24 See especially P. Sluglett, Britain in Iraq: Contriving King and Country (2007).

25 R. Khalidi, Resurrecting Empire (2004), 37.

26 Ibid., at 32.

27 Covenant of the League of Nations, Art. 22.

28 Britain already had considerable influence in the region cultivated through trade agreements with local leaders, in some cases leading to Britain being the dominant or only trading partner. British companies established special concessions over strategic routes in the Tigris and Euphrates and infrastructure agreements including parts of the Iraqi postal and telegraph services. Ottoman officials accused the British of extending spheres of influence through illegal spread of weapons and money in the region and attempting to destabilize Ottoman authority: Çetinsaya, G., ‘The Ottoman View of British Presence in Iraq and the Gulf: The Era of Abdulhamid II’, (2003) 39 Middle Eastern Studies 194CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

29 Anghie, supra note 3, at 513.

30 Anghie, supra note 18.

31 R. Jackson, Quasi-States: Sovereignty, International Relations, and the Third World (1996), 72.

32 Abi-Saab, G., ‘International Law and the International Community: The Long Road to Universality’, in MacDonald, R. (ed.), Essays in Honor of Wang Tieya (1994), 38Google Scholar.

33 Covenant of the League of Nations, Art. 22.

34 T. Dodge, Inventing Iraq (2003), 9–41.

35 Supra note 33.

36 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 22.

37 Dodge, supra note 34, at 24.

38 CO 730/34, Note prepared by the Middle East Department, Colonial Office, printed for the Cabinet, December 1922, Secret IRQ 3, 783.

39 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 99.

40 CO 730/4, CO 41616/21, Telegram from Secretary of State for Colonies to High Commissioner, 20 August 1921, 260–2.

41 Cox, P., ‘Historical Summaries’, in Bell, G., The Letters of Gertrude Bell, Vol. 2 (1939), 522–3Google Scholar.

42 Bonar Law quoted in M. Yapp, The Near East since the First World War: A History to 1995 (1996), 380.

43 Bonar Law quoted in The Times, 21 February 1923.

44 CO 739/53, CO 6851 7 Feb 23, Cabinet Committee on Iraq; P. Sluglett, Britain in Iraq: 1914–1932 (1976), 80; E. Main, Iraq from Mandate to Independence (1935), 84.

45 E. Burgoyne (ed.), Gertrude Bell: From Her Personal Papers, Volume 2, 1914–1926 (1961), 104.

46 Sluglett, supra note 24, at 156.

47 General Instructions as to the Manner the High Commissioner of Iraq Discharges His Duties, Iraq Confidential B, from Devonshire, the Secretary of State for Colonies, to Sir Henry Dobbs, the High Commissioner for Iraq, Downing Street, 20 September 1923, Sudan Collection, University of Durham Library, Box 472/13/141, 1–14.

48 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 99.

49 Tachau, F. (ed.), Political Parties of the Middle East and North Africa (1994), 175Google Scholar.

50 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 21–2, 98–9; see also Anghie, supra note 3, at 612.

51 CO 730/169/7, 1931, No. 88379/I, Part I, Conditions Governing Termination of Mandatory Control, League of Nations, CPM 1210 (I), Geneva, 26 June 1931, Permanent Mandates Commission, Twentieth Session, 2.

52 Dobbs, DO No. SO 448, Secret Draft, 174–5.

53 Henry Dobbs's letter to Shuckburgh at the Colonial Office, 28 December 1929, CO730/150/12, 1929 Iraq, 4–5.

54 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 11–16.

55 G. Schwarzenberger, Power Politics: A Study of World Society (1964), 179.

56 Ibid.; Khalidi, supra note 25, at 24.

57 Anghie, supra note 3, at 578; Anghie, supra note 18, at 56–7.

58 US President George W. Bush, ‘President Bush Discusses Early Transfer of Iraqi Sovereignty’, 28 June 2004: ‘We pledged to end a dangerous regime, to free the oppressed, and to restore sovereignty. We have kept our word.’

59 Annexes to UN Doc. S/Res/1546 (2004).

60 See, e.g., J. Gathii, ‘Historical Dispossession through International Law: Iraq in a Historical and Comparative Context’, in B. Gruffydd Jones (ed.), Decolonising International Relations (2006), 131.

61 Anghie, supra note 3.

62 Dodge, supra note 34, at 63–6.

63 Ibid., at 64.

64 Ibid., at 1.

65 R. Davis, ‘Culture as a Weapon’, 255 Middle East Research and Information Project (2010); Dodge, supra note 34.

66 Khalidi, supra note 25, at 49–52; Dodge, supra note 34, at 159, 161.

67 Dodge, supra note 34, at 163–4.

68 Ibid., 157.

69 D. Chakrabarty, Habitations of Modernity: Essays in the Wake of Subaltern Studies (2002), xxii.

70 R. Guha, quoted in D. Chakrabarty, Provincialising Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference (2000), 14.

71 Chakrabarty, supra note 69, at 9.

72 F. Fukuyama, The End of History and the Last Man (1992); Reus-Smit, C., ‘The Return of History’, in Harris, S. et al. (eds.), The Day the World Changed? Terrorism and World Order (2001), 1Google Scholar, at 2.

73 Anghie, A., ‘Time Present and Time Past: Globalization, IFIs, and the Third World’, (2000) 32 NYUJILP 243Google Scholar.

74 M. Singer and A. Wildavsky, The Real World Order: Zones of Peace/Zones of Turmoil (1993); R. Cooper, The Breaking of Nations: Order and Chaos in the Twenty-First Century (2003); Goldgeier, J. and McFaul, M., ‘A Tale of Two Worlds: Core and Periphery in the Post-Cold War Era’, (1992) 46 IO 467Google Scholar.

75 Singer and Wildavsky, supra note 74; Cooper, supra note 74; Goldgeier and McFaul, supra note 74.

76 Falk, R., ‘International Law and the Future’, (2006) 27 Third World Quarterly 727CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

77 Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, The State of the World's Refugees: Human Displacement in the New Millennium (2006).

78 Pahuja, S., ‘Power and the Rule of Law in the Global Context’, (2004) 28 Melbourne University Law Review 232Google Scholar, at 241.

79 Helman, G. and Ratner, S., ‘Saving Failed States’, (1992–93) 89 FP 3Google Scholar.

80 Wilde, R., ‘The Skewed Responsibility Narrative of the “Failed States” Concept’, (2003) 9 ILSA Journal of International and Comparative Law 425Google Scholar, at 426.

81 Gordon, R., ‘Saving Failed States: Sometimes a Neo-Colonialist Notion’, (1997) 12 AUJILP 903Google Scholar; K. Musalo, J. Moore, and R. Boswell, Refugee Law and Policy (1997).

82 US President George W. Bush, ‘State of the Union Address’, 29 January 2002.

83 Simpson, G., ‘Two Liberalisms’, (2001) 12 EJIL 537, at 560–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 S. Chesterman, Just War or Just Peace? Humanitarian Intervention and International Law (2003).

85 Richardson, H., ‘“Failed States”, Self-Determination and Preventative Diplomacy: Colonialist Nostalgia and Democratic Expectations’, (1994) 10 Temple ICLJ 1Google Scholar, at 13.

86 Ibid., at 14.

87 Ibid., at 21.

88 Jackson, supra note 31, at 21.

89 A. Hamilton, ‘The Idea of the Nation State Is Fatally Flawed’, The Independent, 18 August 2004, 35.

90 Olmstead, M., ‘Are Things Falling Apart? Rethinking the Purpose and Function of International Law’, (2005) 27 Loyola LAICLR 401Google Scholar, at 404.

91 Ibid.

92 Fitzpatrick, P., ‘The Desperate Vacuum: Imperialism and Law in the Experience of Enlightenment’, in Carty, A. (ed.), Post-Modern Law: Enlightenment, Revolution and the Death of Man (1990), 105Google Scholar.

93 Pfaff, W., ‘A New Colonialism? Europe Must Go Back into Africa’, (1995) 74 FA 1Google Scholar.

94 Helman and Ratner, supra note 79.

95 Scharf, M., Williams, P., and Hooper, J., ‘Resolving Sovereignty-Based Conflicts: The Emerging Approach of Earned Sovereignty’, (2003) 31 Denver JILP 349Google Scholar.

96 Charter of the United Nations, Arts. 73–91.

97 Anghie, supra note 3, at 622.

98 UN Doc. S/Res/46 (1990); UN Doc. S/Res/678 (1990).

99 UN Doc. S/Res/687 (1991).

100 UN Doc. S/Res/688 (1991).

101 UN Doc. S/Res/687 (1991).

102 G. Simpson, Great Powers and Outlaw States (2004), 293–4, 313–14; M. Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (translated by Allan Sheridan) (1977).

103 Wedgwood, R., ‘The Fall of Saddam Hussein: Security Council Mandates and Pre-Emptive Self-Defense’, (2003) 97 AJIL 576CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 579; Yoo, J., ‘International Law and the War in Iraq’, (2003) 97 AJIL 563CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 567, 570.

104 Damrosch, L. and Oxman, B., ‘Agora: Future Implications of the Iraq Conflict: Editors' Introduction’, (2003) 97 AJIL 553Google Scholar.

105 R. Chandrasekaran, Imperial Life in the Emerald City (2006).

106 Orders and Regulations of Coalition Provisional Authority.

107 US President George W. Bush, ‘President Discusses the Future of Iraq’, 26 February 2003.

108 Ibid.

109 See subsection 3.2, supra.

110 Ibid., at 8.

111 Byman, D., ‘Constructing a Democratic Iraq: Challenges and Opportunities’, (2003) 28 IS 47Google Scholar; Dawisha, A. and Dawisha, K., ‘How to Build a Democratic Iraq’, (2003) 82 FA 36Google Scholar; Makiya, K., ‘A Model for Post-Saddam Iraq’, (2003) 14 Journal of Democracy 5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

112 1949 Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Times of War, 75 UNTS 287, Arts. 47–78; 1907 Regulations Concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land, 205 ConTS 277, Art. 43.

113 UN Doc. S/Res/1483 (2003).

114 Ibid.

115 J. Gathii, supra note 60, at 131.

116 UN Doc. S/Res/1483 (2003).

117 Whyte, D., ‘The Crimes of Neo-Liberal Rule in Occupied Iraq’, (2007) 47 British Journal of Criminology 177CrossRefGoogle Scholar; D. Atkinson, ‘Selling Iraq: Reconstruction, Privatization and Empire in Denial’, (April 2007) Conflict in Focus 18; International Crisis Group, ‘Reconstructing Iraq’, in ICG Middle East Report No. 30 (Amman, Baghdad, Brussels) (2004); US Government Accountability Office, Rebuilding Iraq: US Mismanagement of Iraqi Funds (2005), 13.

118 UN Doc. S/Res/1483 (2003).

119 Gathii, supra note 60, at 142.

120 UN Doc. S/Res/1546 (2004).

121 2004 Law of Administration for the State of Iraq for the Transitional Period, Art. 26(c).

122 Constitution of the Republic of Iraq, Arts. 25, 26, 110.

123 US President George W. Bush, ‘President Says Saddam Hussein Must Leave Iraq within 48 Hours’, 17 March 2003.

124 Anghie, A. and Chimni, B., ‘Third World Approaches to International Law and Individual Responsibility in Internal Conflicts’, (2003) 2 Chinese Journal of International Law 77CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at 85.

125 Dobbs, supra note 52 and corresponding text.

126 Burke, A., ‘The Perverse Perseverance of Sovereignty’, (2002) 1 Borderlands E-Journal 2Google Scholar.

127 Foucault, supra note 102, at 170.

128 Gong, G., ‘The Standard of “Civilisation”’, (1984) 56 International Society 54Google Scholar, at 63.

129 US President George W. Bush, Address to a Joint Session of Congress and the American People, 20 September 2001.

130 US President George W Bush, Address to UN General Assembly, 10 November 2001.

131 Damrosch, L. and Oxman, B., ‘Editor's Introduction’, (2003) 97 AJIL 556Google Scholar; D. McGoldrick, From ‘9–11’ to the ‘Iraq War 2003’: International Law in an Age of Complexity (2004), 8; UK Prime Minister Tony Blair, ‘Debate on Iraq’, 18 March 2003, 410 Hansard HC 768; Editorial, ‘New World Order’, The Guardian, 11 March 2003.