Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-05T02:19:57.785Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Medical Determination (and Preservation) of Decision-Making Capacity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 April 2021

Edmund G. Howe ,
Daniel S. Gordon  and
Manuel Valentin
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A recent case report described a 62-year-old woman who had suffered a stroke and subsequently had global aphasia, hemiplegia, and could not respond consistently to yes-no questions. She remained hospitalized for four years and throughout this period was irritable, uncooperative, and often refused food. Her care providers considered it very likely that she was depressed and treated her with antidepressant medication, but these drugs did not have beneficial effect.

Her situation subsequently deteriorated. She refused food and water to a greater extent and lost 22 pounds over one month. At that time electroconvulsive therapy was instituted. Thereafter, presumably responding to electroconvulsive therapy, she became pleasant and cooperative and drank and ate heartily.

Type
Article
Information
Law, Medicine and Healthcare , Volume 19 , Issue 1-2 , Spring Summer 1991 , pp. 27 - 33
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

In this instance, the patient's absolute refusal of food and fluids was interpreted as a suicidal gesture due to depression. Herrmann, N., “Electroconvulsive Therapy for a Depressed Patient with Global Aphasia.” Psychosomatics 31: 115–116, 1990.Google Scholar
Mulley, G.P., “Differential Diagnosis of Dementia.” British Medical Journal 292: 1416–1419, 1986.Google Scholar
Overman, W. Jr. Stoudemire, A., “Guidelines for Legal and Financial Counseling of Alzheimer's Disease Patients and Their Families.” Am J Psychiatry 145: 1495–1500, 1988.Google Scholar
Kim, K.Y. Hershey, L.A., “Diagnosis and Treatment of Depression in the Elderly.” Int'l J Psychiatry in Medicine 18: 211–221, 1988.Google Scholar
See Colenda, supra note 6.Google Scholar
Ibid.Google Scholar
See Mulley, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
See Colenda, supra note 6.Google Scholar
Ibid.Google Scholar
Ibid.Google Scholar
See Mulley, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
Two cases in which patients who showed pathological crying following right inferior frontal brain damage had concomitant “severe endogenous depression” are described in Ross, E.D. & Steward, R.S., “Pathological Display of Affect in Patients with Depression and Right Frontal Brain Damage.” The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders 175: 165–172, 1985.Google Scholar
Robinson, R.G. Lipsey, J.R. Rao, K. Price, T.R., “Two-Year Longitudinal Study of Post-Stroke Mood Disorders: Comparison of Acute-Onset with Delayed-Onset Depression.” Am J Psychiatry 143: 1238–1244, 1986.Google Scholar
See Colenda, supra note 6.Google Scholar
Ibid.Google Scholar
E.g., in one study of 37 patients who were artificially ventilated between 1968 and 1984, of the 21 patients still alive, 18 said they would wish to be temporarily ventilated again. Gardner, B.P. Theocleous, F. Watt, J.W.H., & Krishman, K.R., “Ventilation or Dignified Death for Patients with High Tetraplegia.” British Medical Journal 291: 1620–1621, 1985. But see, Maynard, F.M. & Muth, A.S., “The Choice to End Life as a Ventilator-Dependent Quadriplegic.” Arch Phys Med Rehabil 68: 862–864, 1987, and Wolff, K.R., “Determining Patient Competency in Treatment Refusal Cases.” Georgia Law Review 24: 733–757, 1990, for examples of patients believing otherwise.Google Scholar
House, A., “Depression after stroke.” British Medical Journal 294: 76–78, 1987.Google ScholarPubMed
Williams, G.O., “Management of Depression in the Elderly.” Primary Care 16: 451–475, 1989.Google Scholar
Factors precipitating depression in the elderly include physical illness, loss of an important relationship, institutional living, loss of autonomy, loss of financial resources, loss of occupational identity, coexisting psychiatric disorders, drugs, alcohol, physical and emotional illness and genetic-biologic vulnerability to depression. Simon, R.I., “Silent Suicide in the Elderly.” Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 17: 83–95, 1989.Google Scholar
In addition, patients with dementia are much more likely to have defects in naming, writing, calculating and motor praxis, but these differences are usually seen only in the later stages of dementia. See Stoudemire, supra note 6.Google Scholar
See Mulley, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
Brown, J.H. Henteleff, P. Barakat, S., “Is It Normal for Terminally Ill Patients to Desire Death?” Am J Psychiatry 143: 208–211, 1986.Google Scholar
Simon, , supra, note 22 at 86.Google Scholar
Gutheil, & Bursztajn, , note 2 supra.Google Scholar
Howe, E.G., “Forensic Issues in Critical Care Medicine.” Problems in Critical Care 2: 171–187, 1988. Few courts explicitly document the factors leading to a competency evaluation. Wolff, supra, note 18 at 734 n.10.Google Scholar
An illustrative case is reported in Jackson, D. & Younger, S., “Patient Autonomy in Health Care Decisions.” New England Journal of Medicine 301: 404–408, 1979 (At 406). In this case, a 52-year-old man who had progressive physical disability due to multiple sclerosis had previously adapted successfully to his handicaps. He then became “morose and withdrawn” and expressed a “strong belief” in patients’ and his own right to die with dignity. His withdrawal and depression coincided with the diagnosis of probable cancer in his mother-in-law. When the mother-in-law's diagnosis was made, his wife spent more and more time satisfying her mother's needs. The patient had “too much pride” to complain to his wife about feeling abandoned. After he acknowledged his needs in discussion with his care providers and family, he withdrew his request that he not receive supportive medical efforts.Google Scholar
Roth, N.H. Meisel, A. Lidz, C.W., “Tests of Competency to Consent to Treatment.” Am J Psychiatry 134: 270–284, 1977; Drane, J.F., “The Many Faces of Competency.” Hastings Center Report 15: 17–21, 1985; Schwartz, H.I. Blank, K., “Shifting Competency during Hospitalization: A Model for Informed Consent Decisions.” Hospital and Community Psychiatry 37: 1256–1260, 1986; Applebaum, P.S. Roth, L.H., “Clinical Issues in the Assessment of Competency.” American Journal of Psychiatry 138: 1462–1467, 1981; Hoffman, B.F., “Assessing Competence to Consent to Treatment.” Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 25: 354–355, 1980.Google Scholar
Peterson, L.M., “Refusing Medical Treatment.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 31: 454–460, 1988; Kaye, M. Bourgouin, P. Low, G., “Physicians’ Non-Compliance with Patients’ Refusal of Life-Sustaining Treatment.” Am J Nephrol 7:304-312, 1987; Howe, E.G., “Final Choices—Autonomy in Health Care Decisions.” The Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy 6: 449-482, 1990.Google ScholarPubMed
See, e.g., In re: Petition of the Department of Veteran's Affairs Medical Center, No. M45 (U.S. District for Southern District of New York, 16 and 17 August 1990). In this case, a 78-year-old man who had diabetes developed wet gangrene in one foot. His wife, acting on her husband's behalf, stated that she believed he would rather die than lose his foot, that she was uncertain that her husband had wet gangrene and that she believed that her husband's doctor had an unfounded desire to “cut.” The court rejected this patient's wife as surrogate decision-maker because she was not sufficiently objective and appointed a guardian who would consent to her husband's amputation over the patient's wife's objection.Google Scholar