Hostname: page-component-669899f699-7tmb6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-04-25T10:18:51.276Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Less Democracy, More Courts: A Puzzle of Judicial Review in Russia

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Alexei Trochev
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article explores why, throughout the 1990s, some Russian regions created their own constitutional courts and others did not. Contrary to current theories that assert that politicians create a strong and independent judiciary to protect them from the tyranny of election-winners in the context of political uncertainty, my analysis finds that constitutional courts emerged only in those regions where governors virtually guaranteed their re-election by consolidating their political power vis-à-vis federal and local governments. The article argues that both federal and regional politicians used the process of creating subnational constitutional courts to legitimize their federalism and judicial reforms. The changes in the balance of power between those governors, who aspired to have their own judicial system, and the federal government that insisted on a single federal judicial system, determined the variation in the process of court-building across Russian regions.

Type
Constitutional Articulations
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 38 , Issue 3 , September 2004 , pp. 513 - 548
Copyright
© 2004 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

Footnotes

I thank the Centre for Russian and East European Studies and the School of Graduate Studies at the University of Toronto for their support of my research; Vera Bobrova, Larissa Chetverikova, Vladimir Kriazhkov, Mikhail Mitiukov, Robert Orttung, Tatiana Prokop'eva, Tatiana Shubert, Robert Sharlet, Peter Solomon, and justices and clerks of the Russian and the Komi Constitutional Courts for their helpful suggestions; the editors of the Law & Society Review; and the anonymous reviewers for their detailed critique of an earlier version of this article. Special thanks to Catalina Troshev for her useful comments and editorial assistance.

References

References

Akopov, Petr (2002) “Otvedennykh dlia raboty srokov bylo malovato,” Izvestiia, 10 July, 2.Google Scholar
Alekseeva, Natalia, & Politykin, Anton (2000) “Velikolepnaia semerka Ustavnogo Suda, Novosti Zakonodatel'nogo Sobraniia Sankt-Peterburga,” September 14. Available at http://www.assembly.spb.ru/news/zasedania90.shtml.Google Scholar
Bedniakov, Dmitrii (2000) “Nam nuzhno svoe pravosudie,” Argumenty i fakty-Nizhnii Novgorod, 3 April. Available at http://www.innov.ru/news/nn/042000/03-4.htm.Google Scholar
Biriukov, Nikolai (1992) “Obrecheny na vzaimodeistviie,” 15 Narodnyi deputat 19–23.Google Scholar
Bobrova, Vera (1999) “Uchastie konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii v otreshenii ot dolzhnosti vysshikh dolzhnostnykh lits,” in Volovich, V. F., ed., Problemy razvitiia i sovershenstovaniia rossiiskogo zakonodatelstva. Tomsk: Izdatel'stvo Tomskogo universiteta.Google Scholar
Bobrova, Vera (2000) “Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniia statusa Ustavnogo suda sub'ekta Rossiiskoi Federatsii.” Doctoral dissertation, Constitutional Law Department, Moscow State Legal Academy, Moscow.Google Scholar
Bobrova, Vera (2001) “Izmeneniia v zakonakh o konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudakh sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1997–2001),” 7 Digest operativnoi informatsii “Akty konstitutsionnogo pravosudiia sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii” 143–57.Google Scholar
Bobrova, Vera (2002) “Zakonodateli Sverdlovskoi oblasti pytaiutsia oslabit nezavisimost Ustavnogo suda,” 10 Rossiiskaia iustitsiia 12–13.Google Scholar
Bobrova, Vera, Krovel'shchikova, Valeriia, & Mitiukov, Mikhail (2000) Zakon ob Ustavnom sude sub'ekta Rossiiskoi Federatsii: kakim on mozhet byt'. Moscow: MONF.Google Scholar
Chernobrovkina, Elena (1998) “Na tormozakh. Zachem Tatarstanu Konstitutsionnyi sud?,” 167 Vecherniaia Kazan, 14 October, 2.Google Scholar
Davudov, Sabir, & Shapieva, Olga (1997) “Problemy stanovleniia u razvitiia organov konstitutsionnogo kontrolia v sub'ektakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” 3 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 34–39.Google Scholar
Dolgasheva, Valentina (2000) “Deiatelnost Konstitutsionnogo Suda Respubliki Sakha (Iakutiia) i vopros o sozdanii organov konstitutsionnogo kontrolia v sub'ektakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” in Mitiukov, M., Kabyshev, S., Bobrova, V., & Zaslavskii, S., eds., Problemy obrazovaniia i deiatelnosti konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Dunlop, John B. (1997) “Russia: In Search of an Identity?,” in Bremmer, I. & Taras, R., eds., New States, New Politics: Building the Post-Soviet Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Dupre, Catherine (2003) Importing the Law in Post-Communist Transitions. Portland, OR: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
Ekspert (2003) Raspredelenie rossiiskikh regionov po reitingu investitsionnogo klimata v 2002-2003 gg.,” Ekspert, November 17. Available at http://www.expert.ru.Google Scholar
Epstein, Lee, & Knight, Jack (2003) “Constitutional Borrowing and Nonborrowing,” 1 I. CON International Journal of Constitutional Law 196–223.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eremkin, Pavel (1994) “‘Kultivatsiia’ pravovogo polia. V chih rukakh sudba Konstitutsionnogo suda?” Sovetskaia Mordoviia, 10 February.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fondahl, Gail (1997) “Siberia: Assimilation and Its Discontents,” in Bremmer, I. & Taras, R., eds., New States, New Politics: Building the Post-Soviet Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Frank, Allen, & Wixman, Ronald (1997) “The Middle Volga: Exploring the Limits of Sovereignty,” in Bremmer, I. & Taras, R., eds., New States, New Politics: Building the Post-Soviet Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Gadzhiev, Gadis, & Kriazhkov, Vladimir (1993) “Konstitutsionnaia iustitsiia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii: stanovleniie i problemy,” 7 Gosudarstvo i pravo 3–11.Google Scholar
Ganev, Venelin (2002) “The Rise of Constitutional Adjudication in Bulgaria,” in Sadurski, W., ed., Constitutional Justice, East and West. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.Google Scholar
Gavriusov, Yuri (1992) “O realizatsii printsipa razdeleniia vlastei v suverennoi respublike,” in Kataev, N. A. & Samigullin, V. K., eds., Problemy konstitutsionnogo razvitiia suverennoi respubliki. Ufa, Russia: Izdanie Verkh. Soveta i Soveta Ministrov Respubliki Bashkortostan.Google Scholar
Gavriusov, Yuri (2000) “Ob opyte raboty Konstitutsionnogo Suda Respubliki Komi,” in Mitiukov, M., Kabyshev, S., Bobrova, V., & Zaslavskii, S., eds., Problemy obrazovaniia i deiatelnosti konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Gel'man, Vladimir (2000) “Uspekhi i provaly perekhodov k democratii: politicheskie rezhimy rossiiskikh regionov v sravnitelnoi perspective,” in Rossiiskii konstitutsionalizm: politicheskii rezhim v regional'nom kontekste. Moscow: MONF.Google Scholar
Gel'man, Vladimir, Ryzhenkov, Sergei, & Brie, Michael (2003) Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions: The Comparative Politics of Russia's Regions. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
Geliakhov, Abdullakh (2001) “Pozitsii Konstitutsionnogo Suda Kabardino-Balkarskoi Respubliki po sovershenstvovaniiu zakonodatelstva v sfere konstitutsionnoi iustitsii,” in Mitiukov, M., Kabyshev, S., Bobrova, V., & Zaslavskii, S., eds., Problemy ispolneniia federalnymi organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti i organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii reshenii Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii i konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Ginsburg, Thomas B. (2003) Judicial Review in New Democracies: Constitutional Courts in Asian Cases. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goskomstat, RF (2003) Osnovnye itogi Vserossiiskoi perepisi naseleniia 2002 goda. Moscow: Goskomstat RF.Google Scholar
Gosudarstvennaia, Duma (1999) Postanovlenie no. 4599-II GD, January 24. Act of the lower house of the Russian parliament. Unpublished document.Google Scholar
Gosudarstvennaia, Duma (2000) Postanovlenie no. 824-III GD “O federalnykh administrativnykh sudakh v Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” November 22 (published in the legal database “SPS Konsultant Plius: Zakonoproekty”).Google Scholar
Gray, Cheryl W., & Hendley, Kathryn (1997) “Developing Commercial Law in Transition Economies: Examples from Hungary and Russia,” in Sachs, J. & Pistor, K., eds., The Rule of Law and Economic Reform in Russia. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Hendley, Kathryn (1999) “Rewriting the Rules of the Game in Russia: The Neglected Issue of the Demand for Law,” 4 East European Constitutional Rev 89–95.Google Scholar
Hirschl, Ran (2000) “The Struggle for Hegemony: Understanding Judicial Empowerment Through Constitutionalization in Culturally Divided Polities,” 36 Stanford J. of International Law 73–118.Google Scholar
Hirschl, Ran (2004) Towards Juristocracy: The Origins and Consequences of the New Constitutionalism. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Huntington, Samuel (1991) The Third Wave. Norman: Univ. of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
Kahn, Jeffrey (2002) Federalism, Democratization, and the Rule of Law in Russia. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalinin, Vitalii (2000) “Konstitutsionnyi sud' Peterburga,” 154 Sankt-Peterburgskie Vedomosti, 22 August, 3.Google Scholar
Komitet po zakonodatel'stvu (2000) Novosti Zakonodatel'nogo Sobraniia Sankt-Peterburga, September 12. Available at http://www.assembly.spb.ru/news/zasedania90.shtml.Google Scholar
Kriazhkov, Vladimir (1995) “Organy konstitutsionnogo kontrolia sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii: problemy organizatsii i deiatelnosti,” 4 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 34–45.Google Scholar
Kriazhkov, Vladimir (1998) “Problemy kompetentsii konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” 9 Gosudarstvo i Pravo 110–14.Google Scholar
Kriazhkov, Vladimir (1999) Konstitutsionnoe pravosudie v sub'ektakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Kriazhkov, Vladimir (2000) “Vzaimodeistvie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii i konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii v obespechenii edinstva konstitutsionnogo prostranstva v Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” 6 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 50–57.Google Scholar
Kriazhkov, Vladimir ed. (2002) Konstitutsionnoe pravo sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: OOO “Gorodets-izdat.”Google Scholar
Lane, Jan-Erik, & Svante, Ersson (2000) The New Institutional Politics: Performance and Outcomes. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapidus, Gail W., & Edward, Walker (1995) “Nationalism, Regionalism, and Federalism: Center-Periphery Relations in Post-Communist Russia,” in Lapidus, G. W., ed., The New Russia: Troubled Transformation. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Ludwikowski, Rett R. (1998) “Mixed Constitutions” —Product of an East-Central European Melting Pot,” 16 Boston University J. of International Law 64.Google Scholar
Lutz, Donald S. (1980) Popular Consent and Popular Control: Whig Political Theory in the Early State Constitutions. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Magalhães, Pedro C. (1999) “The Politics of Judicial Reform in Eastern Europe,” 32 Comparative Politics 43–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mandelstam, Balzer, Marjorie, (1994) “From Ethnicity to Nationalism: Turmoil in the Russian Mini-Empire,” in Millar, J. R. & Wolchik, S. L., eds., The Social Legacy of Communism. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
McAuley, Mary (1997) Russia's Politics of Uncertainty. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Mitiukov, Mikhail (1999) Konstitutsionnye sudy na postsovetskom prostranstve. Sravnitelnoe issledovanie zakonodatelstva i sudebnoi praktiki. Moscow: MONF.Google Scholar
Mitiukov, Mikhail, & Barnashov, Aleksandr (1999) Ocherki konstitutsionnogo pravosudiia (sravnitelno-pravovoe issledovaniie zakonodatelstva i sudebnoi praktiki). Tomsk: Izd-vo Tomskogo universiteta.Google Scholar
Mitiukov, Mikhail, Kabyshev, Sergei, Bobrova, Vera, & Andreev, Sergei, eds. (2001) Problemy ispolneniia federalnymi organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti i organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii reshenii Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii i konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Mitiukov, Mikhail, Kabyshev, Sergei, Bobrova, Vera, & Zaslavskii, Sergei eds. (2000) Problemy obrazovaniia i deiatelnosti konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Moustafa, Tamir (2002) “Law Versus the State: The Expansion and Contraction of Constitutional Power in Egypt, 1991–2000. Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, August 29–September 1, Boston, MA.Google Scholar
Muzayev, Timur (1993) “Dudayev Goes for Broke,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 8 June, 3. Translated in (1993) 45 Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press 23.Google Scholar
Nazarenko, Aleksandr (1997) “V popravkakh nuzhdaiutsia mnogie stat'i,” Birobidzhanskaia zvezda, 24 June.Google Scholar
Nevinskii, Valerii (1999) “Predely abstraktnogo kontrolia konstitutsionnogo (ustavnogo) suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” 4 Rossiiskii Iuridicheskii Zhurnal 6.Google Scholar
North, Douglass C., & Weingast, Barry R (1996) “Constitutions and Commitment: The Evolution of Institutions Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth-Century England,” in Alston, L. J., Eggertsson, T., & North, D. C., eds., Empirical Studies in Institutional Change. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
NTA (2001) “V 2001 godu Oblastnomu Zakonodatelnomu Sobraniiu Nizhegorodskoi oblasti predstoit rassmotret okolo 600 voprosov,” Nizhegorodskoe telegrafnoe agentstvo, January 3. Available at http://www.med2000.ru/news/110101.htm#3.Google Scholar
Oblastnaia, Duma (1998a) “Ob izbranii sudei Ustavnogo Suda Sverdlovskoi oblasti,” 33-e zasedanie Oblastnoi Dumy, February 24. Available at http://quake.midural.ru/press/1998/dum24fev.htm.Google Scholar
Oblastnaia, Duma (1998b) “O proekte oblastnogo zakona ‘O vnesenii dopolnenii v Oblastnoi zakon <<O Reestre gosudarstvennykh dolzhnostei gosudarstvennoi sluzhby Sverdlovskoi oblasti>>’,” Oblastnaia Duma, July 14. Available at http://www.duma.midural.ru/press/1998/dum14jul.htm.>’,”+Oblastnaia+Duma,+July+14.+Available+at+http://www.duma.midural.ru/press/1998/dum14jul.htm.>Google Scholar
Oblastnaia, Gazeta (1998) “Komissiia otberet, Duma izberet,” Oblastnaia gazeta, 5 February.Google Scholar
Obshchestvo, Ru (19981999) “Konflikty vokrug vlasti,” Internet-media “Obshchestvo.Ru,” July–February. Available at http://socarchive.narod.ru/bibl/polros/Moskva/politecsit-mo.htm.Google Scholar
Ochinian, Valeriia (1994) “Utverzhdeny osnovnye polozheniia Ustava Sverdlovskoi oblasti,” Kommersant'-Daily, 29 June, 1.Google Scholar
Olcott, Martha B. (1997) “Kazakstan: Nursultan Nazarbaev as Strong President,” in Taras, R., ed., Postcommunist Presidents. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Olcott, Martha B. (2002) Kazakhstan: Unfulfilled Promise. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.Google Scholar
Oorzhak, Aleksandr (1992) “O razdelenii vlastei v gosudarstvenno-pravovykh strukturakh Tuvinskoi Respubliki,” in Kataev, N. A. & Samigullin, V. K., eds., Problemy konstitutsionnogo razvitiia suverennoi respubliki. Ufa, Russia: Izdanie Verkh. Soveta i Soveta Ministrov Respubliki Bashkortostan.Google Scholar
Ormrod, Jane (1997) “The North Caucasus: Confederation in Conflict,” in Bremmer, I. & Taras, R., eds., New States, New Politics: Building the Post-Soviet Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Osiatynski, Wiktor (2003) “Paradoxes of Constitutional Borrowing,” 1 I. CON International J. of Constitutional Law 244–68.Google Scholar
Ovsepian, Zhanna (2001) Stanovlenie konstitutsionnykh i ustavnykh sudov v sub'ektakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1990–2000 gg). Moscow: IKTs “MarT.”Google Scholar
Pachegina, Natalya (1993) “Khasbulatov Deprived of His Historical Homeland,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 4 June, 1–3. Translated in (1993) 45 Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press 22.Google Scholar
Paksimadi, L. (2001) “Problemy obrazovaniia Konstitutsionnogo Suda v Respublike Khakassiia,” 1 Digest operativnoi informatsii “Akty konstitutsionnogo pravosudiia sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii” 89–96.Google Scholar
Panshina, Natalia (2003) “Russian Chief Justice Envisages Greater Role for Regional Courts,” ITAR-TASS, 16 June. Translated in World News Connection, FBIS-SOV-2003-0616.Google Scholar
Petrov, Nikolai (2002) “Po rezultatam issledovanii Permskaia oblast okazalas demokratichnee Moskvy i Sankt-Peterburga,” Regions.Ru, October 16. Available at http://www.regions.ru/article/documents/id/878649.html.Google Scholar
Polozhenie, (1998) “O Konsultativnom sovete predsedatelei organov konstitutsionnogo (ustavnogo) kontrolia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” 4 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 74–76.Google Scholar
Problemy ukrepleniia konstitutsionnoi zakonnosti v respublikakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1998) Ufa: RIO BAGSU.Google Scholar
Prochazka, Radoslav (2002) Mission Accomplished. Budapest: Central European Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Przeworski, Adam, & Teune, Henry (1970) The Logic of Social Inquiry. New York: John Wiley.Google Scholar
Putin, Vladimir (2000) Speech at the meeting with the presidential authorized representatives in federal districts, December 25. Available at http://www.maindir.gov.ru/events/132.html.Google Scholar
Radchenko, Vladimir (2001) “Kompetentsiia administrativnykh sudov nam poniatna,” 6 Rossiiskaia Iustitsiia 9–11.Google Scholar
Ramseyer, Mark (1994) “The Puzzling (In)dependence of Courts: A Comparative Approach,” 23 J. of Legal Studies 721–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reshetnikova, Irina (1996) “Rynok stuchitsia v dver suda,” 22 Iuridicheskii vestnik 4.Google Scholar
Rosbalt, (2001) “Moskovskaia gorodskaia Duma priniala v pervom chtenii proekt zakona ob Ustavnom sude,” IA Rosbalt, November 28. Available at http://www.rosbalt.ru/index.php?sect=news&ct=0&cn=26877.Google Scholar
Rossel', Eduard (2001) Speech at the meeting of the Consultative Council of the Chairmen of Constitutional Courts, January 18, Ekaterinburg. Unpublished document.Google Scholar
Rossiiskaia, Gazeta (1996) “Dogovor o razgranichenii predmetov vedeniia i polnomochii mezhdu organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti Rossiiskoi Federatsii i Sverdlovskoi Oblasti,” Rossiiskaia Gazeta, 1 February, 5.Google Scholar
Rossiiskie, Vesti (1995) “Sokhranit edinoe konstitutsionnoe pole,” Rossiiskie Vesti, 16 February, 3.Google Scholar
Rossiiskie, Vesti (1996a) “Dogovor o razgranichenii predmetov vedeniia i polnomochii mezhdu organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Irkutskoi Oblasti i Ust-Ordynskim AO,” Rossiiskie Vesti, 25 July, 4–5.Google Scholar
Rossiiskie, Vesti (1996b) “Dogovor o razgranichenii predmetov vedeniia i polnomochii mezhdu organami gosudarstvennoi vlasti Rossiiskoi Federatsii, Permskoi Oblasti i Komi-Permiatskim AO,” Rossiiskie Vesti, 25 July, 4–5.Google Scholar
Russell, Peter H. (2004) “Adjudication and Enforcement of Laws in a Federal System,” in Solomon, P., ed., The Dynamics of Real Federalism: Law, Economic Development, and Indigenous Communities in Russia and Canada. Toronto: CREES University of Toronto.Google Scholar
Sadurski, Wojciech (2002) Constitutional Justice, East and West. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.Google Scholar
Sbornik, Materialov (1998) Mezhdunarodnaia nauchno-prakticheskaia konferentsiia Konstitutsionnykh Sudov Rossii, Germanii i Slovenii. Petrozavodsk: KS RK.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Herman (2000) The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Sharafutdinova, Gul'naz (2003) “The Dynamics of the Post-Communist Transformation: Varieties of Authoritarian Regimes and Paradoxes of Crony Capitalism in Russia's Regions.” Presented at the National Convention of the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies, November 23, Toronto.Google Scholar
Sharlet, Robert (1993) “Russian Constitutional Crisis: Law and Politics under Yel'tsin,” 9 Post-Soviet Affairs 314–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smirnov, Viktor, & Perechneva, Irina (1994) “Novaia initsiativa Eduarda Rosselia. U ural'skikh politikov vnov' razygralsia appetit na suverenitet,” Kommersant'-Daily, 10 November, 3.Google Scholar
Solomon, Peter H. (2002) “Putin's Judicial Reform,” 1-2 East European Constitutional Rev. 117–24.Google Scholar
Solomon, Peter H., & Foglesong, Todd (2000) Courts and Transition in Russia: The Challenge of Judicial Reform. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Sovet, Federatsii (1999) “Postanovlenie no. 476-SF,” December 22. Unpublished document.Google Scholar
Stenogramma, (2001) “Zasedanie Konsul'tativnogo soveta predsedatelei konstitutsionnykh ustavnykh sudov,” Ekaterinburg, January 18, 2001. Unpublished document.Google Scholar
Stone, Alec (1992) The Birth of Judicial Politics in France. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Tarr, Alan G. (1998) Understanding State Constitutions. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
The 3rd All-Russian Congress of Judges (1994) “Resolution of March 25, 1994,” 7 Rossiiskaia Iustitsiia 3–4.Google Scholar
Travinskii, Ian (2000) “Tramplin dlia vernopodannogo dekana?,” Fontanka.Ru, 25 September.Google Scholar
Trochev, Alexei (2001a) “Constitutional Courts of the Russian Regions as Policy-Makers.” Presented at the National Convention of the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies, November 16, Crystal City, VA.Google Scholar
Trochev, Alexei (2001b) “The Constitutional Courts of Russia's Regions: An Overview,” 6 EWI Russian Regional Report No. 44, December 12, 7–11.Google Scholar
Trochev, Alexei (2003) “Competing for the Judge-Made Law: Politics of Intra-judicial Conflicts in Russia and the Czech Republic.” Presented at the National Convention of the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies, November 21, Toronto.Google Scholar
Trochev, Alexei, & Solomon, Peter H. Jr. (forthcoming) “Courts and Federalism in Putin's Russia,” in Reddaway, P. & Orttung, R. W., eds., The Dynamics of Russian Politics: Volume 2. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
Trofimova, Zhanna (1993) “Vasily Guslyannikov Dismissed with Severance Pay,” Segodnia, 24 August, 3. Translated in (1993) 45 Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press 34.Google Scholar
Tsebelis, George (2002) Veto Players: How Political Institutions Work. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ulitskii, Semen (1997) “Evgenii Nazdratenko ne nameren proigryvat',” Vladivostok, 20 June. United Nations Development Programme (2002) Doklad o razvitii chelovecheskogo potentsiala v Rossiiskoi Federatsii za 2001 god. Moscow: InterDialect+.Google Scholar
United Nations Development Programme (2002) Doklad o razviti chelovecheskogo potentsiala v Rossiiskoi Federatsii za 2001 god. Moscow: Inter Dialect+.Google Scholar
Vedernikov, Nikolai (1998) “Osobennosti stanovleniia konstitutsionnogo pravosudiia v Rossii,” in Problemy ukrepleniia konstitutsionnoi zakonnosti v respublikakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Ufa, Russia: RIO BAGSU.Google Scholar
Vedernikov, Nikolai (2000) “Organy konstitutsionnogo kontrolia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” in Ershov, V. V., Radutnaia, N. V., & Vedernikova, O N., eds., Sudebnaia Sistema Rossii. Moscow: Delo.Google Scholar
Vedernikov, Nikolai, & Derbenev, Evgenii (2000) “Nash opyt popytki sozdaniia Ustavnogo Suda v odnom iz sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii,” in Mitiukov, M., Kabyshev, S., Bobrova, V., & Zaslavskii, S., eds., Problemy obrazovaniia i deiatelnosti konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Verkhovnyi Sovet Komi ASSR (1990a) Tretia sessiia Verkhovnogo Soveta Komi ASSR (12 sozyv) 1 etap October 23–26. Stenograficheskii otchet. Syktyvkar.Google Scholar
Verkhovnyi Sovet Komi ASSR (1990b) Chetvertaia sessiia Verkhovnogo Soveta Komi ASSR (12 sozyv) December 20–22. Stenograficheskii otchet. Syktyvkar.Google Scholar
Verkhovnyi Sovet Respubliki Komi (1994a) Dvadtsat pervaia sessiia Verkhovnogo Soveta Respubliki Komi. 12 sozyv. Stenograficheskii otchet. October 11–13. Syktyvkar.Google Scholar
Verkhovnyi Sovet Respubliki Komi (1994b) Dvadtsat pervaia sessiia Verkhovnogo Soveta Respubliki Komi. 12 sozyv. 2 etap. Stenograficheskii otchet. December 6–7. Syktyvkar.Google Scholar
Volkov, Dmitrii (1994) “Konstitutsionnyi Sud odnorazovogo polzovaniia,” Segodnya, 17 February, 1.Google Scholar
Wilson, Gary N. (2001) “‘Matryoshka Federalism’ and the Case of the Khanty Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug,” 17 Post-Soviet Affairs 167–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yamanishi, David S. (2000) “Rule of Law, Property Rights, and Human Rights.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, September 1–4, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Zadvorianskii, Evgenii (2000) “Ustavnyi sud—khorosho, no Konstitutsionnyi—luchshe,” Rabochii put, 24 February.Google Scholar
Zrazhevskaia, Tatiana (2000) “Trudnosti stanovleniia konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov v sub'ekte Federatsii,” in Mitiukov, M., Kabyshev, S., Bobrova, V., & Zaslavskii, S., eds., Problemy obrazovaniia i deiatelnosti konstitutsionnykh (ustavnykh) sudov sub'ektov Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Moscow: Formula prava.Google Scholar
Zysmanov, Mikhail (2000) “Vlast dolzhna byt chestnoi i kompetentnoi,” Rabochii Put, 13 April.Google Scholar

Statutes Cited

Federalnyi konstitutsionnyi zakon “O Konstitutsionnom Sude RF” (1994) 13 Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, st. 1447.Google Scholar
Federalnyi konstitutsionnyi zakon “O sudebnoi sisteme RF” (1997) 1 Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, st. 1.Google Scholar
Federalnyi zakon “Ob organakh sudeiskogo soobshchestva” (2002) 11 Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, st. 1022.Google Scholar
Ustav Sverdlovskoi Oblasti (1995) 5 Vedomosti Sverdlovskoi Oblastnoi Dumy.Google Scholar
Zakon RF “O statuse sudei RF” (2001) 51 Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, st. 4834.Google Scholar
Zakon Respubliki Kareliia “O Konstitutsionnom Sude Respubliki Kareliia” (1994) Kareliia, 27 April–3 May.Google Scholar
Zakon Sverdlovskoi Oblasti “Ob Ustavnom Sude Sverdlovskoi Oblasti” (1997) Oblastnaia gazeta, 13 May.Google Scholar
Zakon Sankt-Peterburga “Ob Ustavnom Sude goroda Sankt-Peterburga” (2000) 9 Novoe v zakonodatelstve Sankt-Peterburga, 28 June.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 16.10.1997 (1997) 5 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 57–64.Google Scholar
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 11.04.2000 (2000) 4 Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii 15–26.Google Scholar
Opredelenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 6.03.2003 (2003) Rossiiskaia gazeta, 29 April, 10.Google Scholar