Hostname: page-component-77c89778f8-swr86 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-07-21T18:47:18.010Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Through the Back Door: Applying Theories of Legal Compliance to Illegal Immigration During the Chinese Exclusion Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Emily Ryo
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article applies theories of legal compliance to analyze the making of this country's first “illegal immigrants”—Chinese laborers who crossed the U.S.-Canadian and U.S.-Mexican borders in defiance of the Chinese exclusion laws (1882–1943). Drawing upon a variety of sources, including unpublished government records, I explore the ways in which Chinese laborers gained surreptitious entry into the United States during this period and ask, what explains their mass noncompliance? I suggest that while an instrumental perspective is useful for understanding these border crossings, it overlooks other important determinants of noncompliance: normative values and opportunity structures. Specifically, the exclusion laws were widely perceived by the Chinese as lacking social and moral legitimacy, and thus not worthy of obedience. In addition, the existence of smuggling networks and liberal immigration policies in Canada and Mexico played a critical role in facilitating noncompliance. The article concludes with a discussion about the benefits and challenges of using this theoretical framework to analyze noncompliance in immigration law.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 31 , Issue 1 , Winter 2006 , pp. 109 - 146
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2006 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bachman, Ronet, Paternoster, Raymond, and Ward., Sally 1992. The Rationality of Sexual Offending: Testing a Deterrence/Rational Choice Conception of Sexual Assault. Law and Society Review 26: 343–72.Google Scholar
Bangarth, Stephanie D. 2003. “We Are Not Asking You to Open Wide the Gates for Chinese Immigration”: The Committee for the Repeal of the Chinese Immigration Act and Early Human Rights Activism in Canada. Canadian Historical Review 84: 395–422.Google Scholar
Baureiss, Gunter. 1987. Chinese Immigration, Chinese Stereotypes, and Chinese Labour. Canadian Ethnic Studies 19: 15–34.Google Scholar
Becker, Gary S. 1968. Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy 76: 169–217.Google Scholar
Calavita, Kitty. 2000. The Paradoxes of Race, Class, Identity, and “Passing”: Enforcing the Chinese Exclusion Acts, 1882–1910. Law and Social Inquiry 25: 1–40.Google Scholar
Chan, Anthony B. 1982. Chinese Bachelor Workers in Nineteenth-Century Canada. Ethnic and Racial Studies 5: 513–34.Google Scholar
Chavez, Leo. 1998. Shadowed Lives: Undocumented Immigrants in American Society. Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace College Publishers. Google Scholar
Chen, Helen. 1980. Chinese Immigration into the United States: An Analysis of Changes in Immigration Policies. Ph.D. diss. Advanced Studies in Social Welfare, Brandeis University, Waltham, MA.Google Scholar
Chen, Yong. 2000. Chinese San Francisco, 1850–1943. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Google Scholar
Chin, Ko-lin. 1999. Smuggled Chinese: Clandestine Immigration to the United States. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Google Scholar
Chinn, Thomas W., Lai, H. Mark, and Choy, Philip P., eds. 1969. A History of the Chinese in California: A Syllabus. San Francisco: Chinese Historical Society of America. Google Scholar
Chiswick, Barry R. 1988. Illegal Aliens: Their Employment and Employers. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.Google Scholar
Cloward, Richard A. and Ohlin., Lloyd E. 1960. Delinquency and Opportunity: A Theory of Delinquent Gangs. New York: Free Press. Google Scholar
Coleman, James William. 1987. Toward an Integrated Theory of White-Collar Crime. American Journal of Sociology 93: 406–39.Google Scholar
Con, Harry, Con, Ronald J., Johnson, Graham, Wickberg, Edgar, and Willmott., William E. 1982. From China to Canada: A History of the Chinese Communities in Canada. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.Google Scholar
Corcoran, Mary P. 1993. Irish Illegals: Transients between Two Societies. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. Google Scholar
Cott, Kennett. 1987. Mexican Diplomacy and the Chinese Issue, 1876–1910. Hispanic American Historical Review 67: 63–85.Google Scholar
Craib, Raymond B. III 1996. Chinese Immigrants in Porfirian Mexico: A Preliminary Study of Settlement, Economic Activity and Anti-Chinese Sentiment. Albuquerque, NM: Latin American Institute. Google Scholar
Curtis, James R. 1995. Mexicali's Chinatown. Geographical Review 85: 335–48.Google Scholar
Darley, John, Tyler, Tom R., and Bilz., Kenworthey 2003. Enacting Justice: The Interplay of Individual and Institutional Perspectives. In The Sage Handbook of Social Psychology, eds. Hogg, Michael A. and Cooper, Joel, 458–76. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Google Scholar
Daniels, Roger. 1986. Chinese and Japanese in North America: The Canadian and American Experiences Compared. Canadian Review of American Studies 17: 173–87.Google Scholar
Daniels, Roger. 2004. Guarding the Golden Door: American Immigration Policy and Immigrants since 1882. New York: Hill and Wang. Google Scholar
Delgado, Grace Peña. 2004. At Exclusion's Southern Gate: Changing Categories of Race and Class among Chinese Fronterizos, 1882–1904. In Continental Crossroads: Remapping U.S.-Mexico Borderlands History, eds. Truett, Samuel and Young, Elliott, 295–332. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. Google Scholar
De Lorme, Ronald L. 1973. The United States Bureau of Customs and Smuggling on Puget Sound, 1851–1913. Prologue. Summer, 77–88.Google Scholar
Dennis, Philip A. 1979. The Anti-Chinese Campaigns in Sonora, Mexico. Ethnohistory 26: 65–80.Google Scholar
Farrar, Nancy. 1972. The Chinese in El Paso. El Paso, TX: Texas Western Press. Google Scholar
Fong, Julia. 1999. The Fong Family History: Stories of My Father's Side of the Family. In Chinese America: History and Perspectives, 47–61. San Francisco: Chinese Historical Society of America. Google Scholar
Friedman, Lawrence M. 1975. The Legal System: A Social Science Perspective. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar
Fritz, Christian G. 1988. A Nineteenth Century “Habeas Corpus Mill”: The Chinese before the Federal Courts in California. American Journal of Legal History 32: 347–72.Google Scholar
Fuchs, Laurence H. 1990. American Kaleidoscope: Race, Ethnicity, and the Civic Culture. Hanover, NH: Wesleyan University Press. Google Scholar
Fry, C. Luther. 1928. Illegal Entry of Orientals into the United States between 1910 and 1920. Journal of the American Statistical Association 23: 173–77.Google Scholar
Gibbs, Jack P. 1986. Deterrence Theory and Research. In The Law as a Behavioral Instrument, ed. Melton, Gary B., 87–130. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. Google Scholar
Grasmick, Harold G. and Bryjak., George J. 1980. The Deterrent Effect of Perceived Severity of Punishment. Social Forces 59: 471–91.Google Scholar
Gyory, Andrew. 1998. Closing the Gate: Race, Politics, and the Chinese Exclusion Act. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. Google Scholar
Hsu, Madeline. 1997. Gold Mountain Dreams and Paper Son Schemes. In Chinese America: History and Perspective, 46–60. San Francisco: Chinese Historical Society of America. Google Scholar
Hsu, Madeline. 2000. Dreaming of Gold, Dreaming of Home: Transnationalism and Migration between the United States and South China, 1882–1943. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Google Scholar
Hu-DeHart, Evelyn. 1980. Immigrants to a Developing Society: The Chinese in Northern Mexico, 1875–1932. Journal of Arizona History 21: 49–86.Google Scholar
Hu-DeHart, Evelyn. 1982. Racism and Anti-Chinese Persecution in Sonora, Mexico, 1876–1932. Amerasia 9: 1–28.Google Scholar
Huo, Yuen J. and Tyler., Tom R. 2000. How Different Ethnic Groups React to Legal Authority. San Francisco: Public Policy Institute of California. Google Scholar
Jacques, Leo M. 1974. The Anti-Chinese Campaigns in Sonora, Mexico, 1900–1931. Ph.D. diss. Department of History, University of Arizona, Albuquerque, NM.Google Scholar
Jacques, Leo M. 1976. Have Quick More Money Than Mandarins: The Chinese in Sonora. Journal of Arizona History 17: 201–18.Google Scholar
Kim, Hyung-chan and Markov., Richard W. 1983. The Chinese Exclusion Laws and Smuggling Chinese into Whatcom County, Washington, 1890–1900. The Annals of the Chinese Historical Society of the Pacific Northwest 16–30.Google Scholar
Kiong, Wong Sin. 2002. China's Anti-American Boycott Movement in 1905. New York: Peter Lang. Google Scholar
Klepper, Steven and Nagin., Daniel 1989. The Anatomy of Tax Evasion. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 5: 1–24.Google Scholar
Kwong, Peter. 1997. Forbidden Workers: Illegal Chinese Immigrants and American Labor. New York: New Press. Google Scholar
Lai, David Chuenyan. 1988. Chinatowns: Towns within Cities in Canada. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press. Google Scholar
Lai, Him Mark. 2004. Becoming Chinese American: A History of Communities and Institutions. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press. Google Scholar
Lau, Estelle. 2000. Paper Families: Identity, Immigration Administration and Chinese Exclusion. Ph.D. diss. Department of Sociology, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL.Google Scholar
Lee, Erika. 2003. At America's Gates: Chinese Immigration during the Exclusion Era, 1882–1943. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. Google Scholar
Lessig, Lawrence. 1998. The New Chicago School. Journal of Legal Studies 27: 661–91.Google Scholar
Lopez, Ian F. Haney. 1996. White by Law: The Legal Construction of Race. New York: New York University Press. Google Scholar
Ma, L. Eve Armentrout. 1991. Chinatown Organizations and the Anti-Chinese Movement, 1882–1914. In Entry Denied: Exclusion and the Chinese Community in America, 1882–1943, ed. Chan, Sucheng, 147–69. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Google Scholar
Martinez, Oscar J. 1988. Troublesome Border. Tucson: The University of Arizona Press. Google Scholar
McClain, Charles. 1984. The Chinese Struggle for Civil Rights in Nineteenth Century America: The First Phase, 1850–1870. California Law Review 72: 529–68.Google Scholar
McClain, Charles. 1994. In Search of Equality: The Chinese Struggle against Discrimination in Nineteenth-Century America. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. Google Scholar
McClain, Charles J. and McClain., Laurence Wu 1991. The Chinese Contribution to the Development of American Law. In Entry Denied: Exclusion and the Chinese Community in America, 1882–1943, ed. Chan, Sucheng, 3–24. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Google Scholar
McKendall, Marie A. and Wagner., John A. 1997. Motive, Opportunity, Choice, and Corporate Illegality. Organization Science 8: 624–47.Google Scholar
Meier, Kenneth J. and Morgan., David R. 1982. Citizen Compliance with Public Policy: The National Maximum Speed Law. Western Political Quarterly 35: 258–73.Google Scholar
Nagin, Daniel S. 1998. Criminal Deterrence Research at the Outset of the Twenty-First Century. Crime and Justice 23: 1–42.Google Scholar
Ngai, Mae M. 1998. Legacies of Exclusion: Illegal Chinese Immigration during the Cold War Years. Journal of American Ethnic History 18: 3–35.Google Scholar
Ngai, Mae M. 2004. Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Google Scholar
Paternoster, Raymond, Robert Brame, Ronet Bachman, and Sherman., Lawrence W. 1997. Do Fair Procedures Matter? The Effect of Procedural Justice on Spouse Assault. Law and Society Review 31: 163–204.Google Scholar
Paulus, Ingeborg and Simpson., Carl 1981. Opportunity, Benefit, and Subjective Disposition: Determinants of Nonprofessional Smuggling. The Pacific Sociological Review 24: 299–327.Google Scholar
Perkins, Clifford Alan. 1978. Border Patrol: With the U.S. Immigration Service on the Mexican Boundary, 1910–54. El Paso, TX: Texas Western Press. Google Scholar
Posner, Richard A. 1972. Economic Analysis of Law. Boston: Little, Brown. Google Scholar
Rak, Mary Kidder. 1938. Border Patrol. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. Google Scholar
Ralph, Julian. 1891. The Chinese Leak. Harper's New Monthly Magazine 82: 515–25.Google Scholar
Robinson, Paul H. and Darley., John M. 1997. The Utility of Desert. Northwestern University Law Review 91: 453–99.Google Scholar
Roy, Patricia E. 1976. The Preservation of the Peace in Vancouver: The Aftermath of the Anti-Chinese Riot of 1887. BC Studies. Autumn, 44–59.Google Scholar
Salyer, Lucy E. 1995. Laws Harsh as Tigers: Chinese Immigrants and the Shaping of Modern Immigration Law. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. Google Scholar
Sanchez, George J. 1993. Becoming Mexican American: Ethnicity, Culture and Identity in Chicago Los Angeles, 1900–1945. New York: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Schatkin, Sidney B., Sussman, Leon N., and Yarbrough., Dorris Edward 1955. Chinese Immigration and Blood Tests. Criminal Law Review 2: 44–56.Google Scholar
Scheinberg, Ellen. 1994. Evidence of “Past Injustices”: Records Relating to the Chinese Head Tax. The Archivist 20: 26–30.Google Scholar
Shaw, Clifford R. and McKay., Henry D. 1942. Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Google Scholar
Shone, Huie Yuk. 1989. Life Is Like Dream: Confessions of an Illegal Alien. In Chinese America: History and Perspectives, 87–110. San Francisco: Chinese Historical Society of America. Google Scholar
Smith, Kent W. 1992. Reciprocity and Fairness: Positive Incentives for Tax Compliance. In Why People Pay Taxes, ed. Slemrod, Joel, 223–50. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Google Scholar
Smith, Kent W. and Kinsey, Karyl A. 1987. Understanding Taxpaying Behavior: A Conceptual Framework with Implications for Research. Law and Society Review 21: 639–63.Google Scholar
Smith, Marian L. 2000. The Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) at the U.S.-Canadian Border, 1893–1993: An Overview of Issues and Topics. Michigan History Review 26: 127–47.Google Scholar
Stigler, George J. 1970. The Optimum Enforcement of Laws. Journal of Political Economy 78: 526–36.Google Scholar
Suchman, Mark C. 1997. Rational, Normative and Cognitive Perspectives in the Social Scientific Study of Law. Wisconsin Law Review 1997: 475–501.Google Scholar
Sung, Betty Lee. 1967. Mountain of Gold: The Story of the Chinese in America. New York: The Macmillan Company. Google Scholar
Tittle, Charles R. 1969. Crime Rates and Legal Sanctions. Social Problems 16: 409–23.Google Scholar
Tsai, Shih-shan Henry. 1970. Reaction to Exclusion: Ch'ing Attitudes toward Overseas Chinese in the United States, 1848–1906. Ph.D. diss., Department of History, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR.Google Scholar
Tsai, Shih-shan Henry. 1986. The Chinese Experience in America. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 1990. Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2000. Multiculturalism and the Willingness of Citizens to Defer to Law and to Legal Authorities. Law and Social Inquiry 25: 983–1019.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. 2003. Procedural Justice, Legitimacy, and the Effective Rule of Law. Crime and Justice 30: 283–357.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R., Boeckmann, Robert J., Smith, Heather J., and Huo., Yuen J. 1997. Social Justice in a Diverse Society. Denver, CO: Westview. Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. and Darley, John M. 2000. Building a Law-Abiding Society: Taking Public Views about Morality and the Legitimacy of Legal Authorities into Account when Formulating Substantive Law. Hofstra Law Review 28: 707–39.Google Scholar
Tyler, Tom R. and Huo., Yuen J. 2002. Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and Courts. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Commerce and Labor. 1906. Facts Concerning the Enforcement of the Chinese-Exclusion Laws. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Labor. 1916, 1918. Annual Report of the Commissioner General of Immigration. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Google Scholar
Vargas, Jorge A. 2001. U.S. Border Patrol Abuses, Undocumented Mexican Workers, and International Human Rights. San Diego International Law Journal 2: 1–92.Google Scholar
Wai-man, Lee. 1984. Portraits of a Challenge: An Illustrated History of the Chinese Canadians. Toronto: Council of Chinese Canadians in Ontario. Google Scholar
Wang, Guanhua. 2001. In Search of Justice: The 1905–1906 Chinese Anti-American Boycott. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center. Google Scholar
Wong, K. Scott. 1998. Cultural Defenders and Brokers: Chinese Response to the Anti-Chinese Movement. In Claiming America: Constructing Chinese American Identities during the Exclusion Era, eds. Wong, K. Scott and Chan, Sucheng, 3–40. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Google Scholar
Wong, Charles Choy and Klein., Kenneth 1994. False Papers, Lost Lives. In Origins and Destinations: Essays on Chinese America, 355–74. Los Angeles: Chinese Historical Society of Southern California. Google Scholar
Yung, Judy. 1995. Unbound Feet: A Social History of Chinese Women in San Francisco. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. Google Scholar
Yung, Judy. 1998. The Fake and the True: Researching Chinese Women's Immigration History. In Chinese America: History and Perspective, 25–56. San Francisco: Chinese Historical Society of America. Google Scholar
Zo, Kil Young. 1978. Chinese Emigration into the United States, 1850–1880. New York: Arno Press. Google Scholar