Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T03:26:30.411Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Policing Soviet Society: The Evolution of State Control

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Louise I. Shelley
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Soviet militsiia (regular police) has evolved in the past 70 years from a feeble body seeking to ensure the survival of Soviet rule to a massive bureaucracy corrupted by nearly absolute power. As the Soviet militia has developed the focus of its activities, its ethos, professionalism, and its relationship to both the Party and KGB have changed in all periods, the militia has had political, economic, and social responsibilities, but the balance among the three has shifted depending on the conditions of the state.

The militia, like the Soviet state, is currently in crisis. It remains an instrument of the party that is losing its legitimacy among the population. Perestroika's objective of making institutions subordinate to the law is a sharp deviation from existing practice. But even if the militsiia responds to these new expectations, because of the demands of a centrally planned socialist state the regular police will remain we intrusive into the lives of the citizenry than are police in Western democratic societies.

Type
Symposium: Perestroika in Soviet Legal Institutions
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 15 , Issue 3 , Summer 1990 , pp. 479 - 520
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 1990 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 “Figures for Crime Against Militia Disclosed,” FBIS Daily Report, 16 March 1990, at 84.Google Scholar

2 Miller, Wilbur R., Cops and Bobbies: Police Authority in New York and London, 1830–1970 21 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1977) (“Miller, Cops”).Google Scholar

3 See Stead, Philip John. The Police of France 43 (New York: Macmillan, 1983) (“Stead, Police of France”), as well as discussion in Otwin Marenin, “Police Performance and State Rule,” Comparative Politics, October 1985, at 106–7.Google Scholar

4 Marenin, Comparative Politics, at 106.Google Scholar

5 Stead, Police of France 161–62.Google Scholar

6 Bilenko, S. V., Sovetskaia Militsiia Rossi (1917–20) 52 (Moscow: Akademiia MVD SSSR, 1976) (“Bilenko, Sovetskaia Militsiia Rossii”).Google Scholar

7 Charney, Marc, “Gorbachev and Peter the Great,” N.Y. Times Book Review, 25 Feb. 1990, at 13.Google Scholar

8 . Miller, , Cops 23.Google Scholar

9 Cohen, S. F., Rabinowitch, A., & Sharlet, R., The Soviet Union Since Stalin, 11–110 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1980).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10 “Depoliticization of Lithuanian Militia Viewed,” FBIS Daily Report, 1 March 1990, at 92–93; Francis Clines, “Victorious Insurgents Act to Make Moscow a Free-Market Showcase,” N.Y. Times, 22 March 1990, at A16.Google Scholar

11 Wade, Rex A., Guards, Red and Workers' Militias in the Russian Revolution 40–41 (Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press, 1984) (“Wade, Red Guards”).Google Scholar

12 Eropkin, M. N., Razvitie organov militsii v sovetskom gosudarstve 12 (Moscow: Vysshaia Shkola MOOP, 1967) (“Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii”).Google Scholar

13 See Weissman, Neil, “Policing the New Order: The Soviet Militsiia, 1917–1928,” 19 (presented at AAASS, New York, 1984) (“Weissman, ‘Policing the New Order’”).Google Scholar

14 . Id, and Weissman, Neil, “Regular Police in Tsarist Russia, 1900–1914,” 44 Russian Review 45–68 (1985).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii 15–16.Google Scholar

16 Id at 11–12.Google Scholar

17 Id at 111–13.Google Scholar

18 Wade, Red Guards at 308.Google Scholar

19 Id at 8.Google Scholar

20 Id.Google Scholar

21 In Moscow 35% of the militsiia was drawn from the working class whereas in Siberia the figure was only 10%, the remainder being those of peasant background. In Saratov 30% of militsiia personnel were demobilized soldiers. Bilenko, Sovetskaia Militsiia Rossii at 45 (cited in note 6).Google Scholar

22 Id.Google Scholar

23 Id at 46.Google Scholar

24 Id at 47–48.Google Scholar

25 . For example, see Polubinskii, V., “Shit i mech pravoporiadka,” Agitator No. 20, 1987, at 23–25, which discussed the transfer of the first head of the criminal investigative unit (UR) to the Cheka.Google Scholar

26 Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii at 40 (cited in note 12).Google Scholar

27 . Weissman, Neil, “Prohibition and Alcohol Control in the USSR: The 1920s Campaign Against Illegal Spirits,” 38 Soviet Studies No. 8, 1986, at 361.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

28 Weissman, “Policing the New Order” (cited in note 13).Google Scholar

29 . Timofeev, N. I., “Deiatel ‘nost’ kommunisticheskoi partii ukrainy PO obucheniiu kadrov militsii respubliki,” Trudy Kievskoi Vysshei shkoly 1975, No. 9, at 10.Google Scholar

30 Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii at 44.Google Scholar

31 Id at 37.Google Scholar

32 Id at 45.Google Scholar

33 . Id at 16, and Solomon, Peter H., “Criminalization and De-criminalization in Soviet Criminal Policy,” 16 Law & Soc'y Rev. 16–17 (198182).Google Scholar

34 Weissman, “Policing the New Order” at 16–17.Google Scholar

35 Id at 17–18; see also Bilenko, Sovetskaia Militsiia Rossii at 24–25 (cited in note 6).Google Scholar

36 Bayley, David H., Forces of Order: Police Behavior in Japan and the United States 35 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976).Google Scholar

37 Eropkin, Razvitie organove militsii at 19.Google Scholar

38 Shchelokov, N. A., Sovetskaia Militsiia 64 (Moscow: Znanie, 1971).Google Scholar

39 Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii at 20 (cited in note 12).Google Scholar

40 Conquest, Robert, The Soviet Police System 30 (New York: Praeger, 1968) (“Conquest, Soviet Police”).Google Scholar

41 Id. at 20.Google Scholar

42 Id. at 31.Google Scholar

43 Id. at 44.Google Scholar

44 Id. at 13.Google Scholar

45 Id.Google Scholar

46 Sputnik krasnogo militsionera 3 (Moscow: Zagotkhoza militsii respubliki, 1924). For a discussion of the Central Asian situation, see Mukhamedov, A. M., Slavnyi Put 33–71 (Askhabad, Turkmenistan, 1965); Dzalilov, T. A., Stranitsy istorii militsii Khorezma i Bukhary 16–70 (Tashkent, Uzbekistan, 1970); Motylev, Ia. & Lysenko, E., Soldaty Poriadka 37–40 (Dushanbe, Efron, 1967); Dzalilov, T., Vemye Otchizne 68–119 (Tashkent, Uzbekistan, 1968).Google Scholar

47 Bayley, David H., Patterns of Policing: A Comparative International Analysis 205 (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1985).Google Scholar

48 Center for Research on Criminal Justice, The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove 28–20 (Berkeley, Cal.: Center for Research on Criminal Justice, 1977); Sidney L. Harring, Policing a Class Society: The Experience of American Cities, 1865–1915 (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1983).Google Scholar

49 Miller, Cops at 11 (cited in note 2).Google Scholar

50 Dzalilov, Stranitsy istorii militsii Khorezmna i Bukhry 55–56 (cited in note 46).Google Scholar

51 Id. at 55.Google Scholar

52 Id. at 55–56.Google Scholar

53 Miller, Cops at 11.Google Scholar

54 Eropkin, Razvitie organou militsii at 28 (cited in note 12).Google Scholar

55 Id. at 30.Google Scholar

56 . Weissman, , 38 Soviet Studies at 349–68 (cited in note 27).Google Scholar

57 Id.Google Scholar

58 Dzalilov, Stranitsy istorii militsii Khorezma i Bukhary 13–14 (cited in note 46).Google Scholar

59 Nikolaev, P. F., Omskaia Militsiia v Pervye Gody Sovetskoi Vlasti (1917–1934) 42–49 (Omsk: Arkhivnyi otdel UVD Ispolkoma omskogo oblastnogo soveta deputatov trudiashchikhsiia, 1959) (“Nikolaev, Omskaia Militsiia”).Google Scholar

60 See, e.g., Nikolaev, P. F., Sibiri, Sovetskaia Militsiia (1917–1922) 228–53 (Omsk: Zapadno-sibirskoe knizhnoe izd., 1967).Google Scholar

61 Juviler, Peter, Revolutionary Law and Order 26 (New York: Free Press, 1976).Google Scholar

62 Id.Google Scholar

63 See Nikolaev, Omskaia Militsiia 66–68, for a discussion of materials from Omsk state archives.Google Scholar

64 . Markovits, Inga, “Law and Glasnost': Some Thoughts About the Future of Judicial Review Under Socialism,” 23 Law & Soc'y Rev. 403 (1989), states that this is a primary objective of socialist law.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

65 . “By 1931 the Militia in the USSR were organised in Chief Administrations under the Councils of People's Commissars of the Union Republics, with local militia organs still in dual subordination. Conquest, Soviet Police 31.Google Scholar

66 Conquest, Soviet Police at 16 (cited in note 40).Google Scholar

67 Fainsod, Merle, How Russia Is Ruled 452–53 (rev. ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1970) (“Fainsod, How Russia Is Ruled”).Google Scholar

68 Conquest, Soviet Police at 18.Google Scholar

69 Fainsod, How Russia h Ruled at 73.Google Scholar

70 Id.Google Scholar

71 Shelud'ko, G. P., Sovetskaia Militsiia na Strzhe Obshchestvennogo Poriadka 23 (Kiev: Vishcha Shkola, 1982) (“Shelud'ko, Sovetskaia Militsiia”).Google Scholar

72 Hingley, Ronald, The Russian Secret Police 188 (London: Hutchinson, 1970) (“Hingley, Russian & net Police”).Google Scholar

73 Id. at 202.Google Scholar

74 Id. at 212.Google Scholar

75 Archives, Smolensk, WPK 90 and 351.Google Scholar

76 Many historical studies of the militsiia in the 1930s discuss the large numbers of fatalities that resulted from suppressing bandits and other politically motivated offenders.Google Scholar

77 Emsley, Clive, Policing and Its Context, 1750–1870 113 (New York: Schocken Books, 1983).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

78 Id. at 114.Google Scholar

79 Conquest, Robert, The Harvest of Sorrow (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986).Google Scholar

80 Bogomolov, G. A., Gold'man, V. S., Zdir, Ia. A., & Tunik, P. I., Vekhi Trudnykh Budnei 53 (Saratov: Privolzhskoe knizhnoe izd., 1963).Google Scholar

81 Id. at 52.Google Scholar

82 Archives, Smolensk, microfilm, WPK 93, provides this information from the notes of a NKVD meeting.Google Scholar

83 . Conquest, Soviet Police 55.Google Scholar

84 Fainsod, Merle, Smolensk Under Soviet Rule 195–209 (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1958).Google Scholar

85 Eropkin, Razvitie organov militsii 67–68 (cited in note 12).Google Scholar

86 Hingley, Russian Secret Police 184–86 (cited in note 72).Google Scholar

87 . Logivenenko, I. M., “Uchastie rabotnikov militsii v velikoi otechestvennoi voine,” Truy Kievskoi Vysshei Shkoly No. 9, at 18–19 (1975).Google Scholar

88 The criticism of the militsiia has been verbal throughout the USSR and in certain areas it has also been physial.Google Scholar

89 . Logivenenko, Trudy Kievskoi Vysshei Shkoly No. 9, at 19.Google Scholar

90 Id.Google Scholar

91 Id. at 15. For a fuller discussion of the war effort in Leningrad, See Skiliagin, D., V. Lesov, lu. Pimenov, & I. Savchenko, Dela i Liudi Leningradskoi Militsii 181 (Leningrad: Lenizdat, 1967).Google Scholar

92 . Hingley, , Russian Secret Police 204.Google Scholar

93 Reiner, Robert, “The Politicization of the Police in Britain,” in Maurice Punch, ed., Control in the Police Organization 143 (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1983).Google Scholar

94 Chapman, Brian, The Police State 114 (New York: Praeger, 1970).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

95 Id. at 115.Google Scholar

96 Kelling, George L. & Moore, Mark H., “The Evolving Strategy of Policing,” Perspectives on Policing No. 4, at 5 (Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Justice, 1988).Google Scholar

97 Reuss-Ianni, Elizabeth & Ianni, Francis A. J., “Street Cops and Management Cops: The Two Cultures of Policing,” in Punch, Control (cited in note 93).Google Scholar

98 Conquest, Robert, Power and Policy in the USSR: The Struggle for Stalin's Succession, 1945–1960, at 442–48 (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1967).Google Scholar

99 Id. at 212–17.Google Scholar

100 “Lavrentiy Beria's Crimes, Arrest Recounted,” FBIS Daily Report, 3 March 1988, at 60.Google Scholar

101 Id. at 61.Google Scholar

102 Conquest, Soviet Police at 23 (cited in note 40).Google Scholar

103 Statement of A. M. lakovlev on the law of the Stalinist period in “Kakim dolzhno byt' pravovoe gosudarstvo?” Literaturnaia Gazeta, 6 June 1988, at 11.Google Scholar

104 Knight, Amy W., The KGB: Police and Politics in the Soviet Union 48 (New York: Allen & Unwin, 1988).Google Scholar

105 The 1962 statute on the militsiia was not published but was circulated to a limited audience in Sprarvochnik po zakonodatel'stvu dlia rabotnikov organov prokuratury, Suda i ministerstva vnutrennykh del vol. 2, part 1, at 304–11 (Moscow: Iuridicheskaia Literatura, 1971).Google Scholar

106 . “N. R. Mironov Reviews Reformation of Soviet Punitive Agencies: Stalin and Vyshinkskiy Blamed for Past Abuses,” Survey of the Soviet Press, No. 351, 13 March 1964, at 10.Google Scholar

107 Oblast and krai—large region ranked above oblast.Google Scholar

108 Conquest, Soviet Police 24–25 (cited in note 40). Oblast and krai Soviet executive committees oversaw the Administrations of Internal Affairs. Militia departments in towns and raions were made subordinate to the local ispolkom.Google Scholar

109 . “Brief Item Announces Abolition of Ministry of Internal Affairs USSR,” Survey of the Soviet Press, No. 142, 8 Feb. 1960, at 8.Google Scholar

110 . “Ministry of Internal Affairs Renamed Ministry for Defense of Public Order RSFSR,” Survey of the Soviet has, No. 277, 24 Sept. 1963, at 15.Google Scholar

111 Barbara Raffel Price, Police Professionalism 23–26 (Lexington, Mass.: D. C. Heath, 1977).Google Scholar

112 . “RSFSR Militia Interviewed on Drive Against Using Bread as Livestock Feed,” Survey of the Soviet Press, No. 278, 1, Oct. 1962, at 24–25; “RSFSR Ukase Stipulates 3-Year Minimum Sentence for Feeding Bread to Livestock,”Survey of the Soviet Press, No. 311, 27 May 1963, at 66–67; “RSFSR Deputy Prosecutor Calls for Legal Crackdown on All Thefts and Waste of Grain Products,”Survey of the Soviet Press, No. 334, 1 Nov. 1963, at 76–79.Google Scholar

113 Berman, Harold, justice in the USSR 291–98 (rev. ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1982). The parasite laws were also applied by the militsiia against dissenters such as the greater writer losif Brodsky.Google Scholar

114 Id. at 285–98.Google Scholar

115 . Some criminal elements masked their criminal activity to join the druzhinniki. See, e.g., “‘Crude’ Actions by Volunteer Guardsmen in Arkhangelsk Scored,” Surveys of the Soviet Press, No. 162, 27 June 1960, at 20–24.Google Scholar

116 Cain, Maureen E., Society and the Policeman's Role 4–5 (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1973), discusses police and their roles.Google Scholar

117 . Juviler, , Revolutionary Law and Order 103 (cited in note 61).Google Scholar

118 Knight, The KGB 62–63 (cited in ncte 104).Google Scholar

119 . “Polozhenie o Sovetskoi Militsii,” adopted by the USSR Council of Ministers, 8 June 1973, No. 385, published in 10 Svod Zakonov SSSR 236–47.Google Scholar

120 See note 105 for a discussion of the evolution of the militsiia codes.Google Scholar

121 . Shelud'ko, Soveukaia Militsiia na Strazhe Obshchestvennogo Poriadka 23 (cited in note 71).Google Scholar

122 . Knight, Amy, “Soviet Politics and the KGB-MVD Relationship,” 11 Soviet Union part 2 (1984).Google Scholar

123 “‘Brezhnev's Special Favour’ Protected Corrupt,” SU/0144, 6 May 1988, at B/1.Google Scholar

124 Alekseeva, Liudmilla, Istoriia inakomysliia v SSSR (Benson, Vt.: Khronika Press, 1984).Google Scholar

125 . Gusev, L. N. & Bakhitov, A. A., “O resultatakh sotsiologicheskikh issledovaniia o retsidivistov i drugikh otkloniashikh ot soltsial'nogo poleznogo truda,” Informatsionnye soobshcheniia VNIIP pri MOOP, No. 35, 1971.Google Scholar

126 . Knight, , 11 Soviet Union at 157–81, suggests that Brezhnev felt that granting leadership of the law enforcement apparatuses to his cronies enhanced his personal power.Google Scholar

127 Miller, Cops IS (cited in note 2).Google Scholar

128 Walker, Samuel, Popular Justice: A History of American Criminal justice 61 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980).Google Scholar

129 Id. at 63.Google Scholar

130 . Popov, Nikolai, “Krizis doveriia—krizis vlasti,” Ogonek No. 7, at 2–4 (1990).Google Scholar

131 . Kruzhin, Peter, “Political Organs Created in the MVD,” Radio Liberty Research 5/84, 30 Dec. 1983.Google Scholar

132 . “The Police and Openness,” 39 Current Digest of the Soviet Press No. 52, at 25 (1988).Google Scholar

133 “Vlasov Writes on Perestroyka, Crime Rate,” Moscow Tass in English, FBIS Daily Report, 15 April 1988, at 48.Google Scholar

134 Pravda, 11 Dec. 1982.Google Scholar

135 . Kruzhin, , Radio Liberty Research 5/84, 30 Dec. 1983.Google Scholar

136 RL92/83, 21 Feb. 1983, at 9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

137 . Knight, , The KGB 89 (cited in note 104).Google Scholar

138 Pravda, 26 Jan. 1983.Google Scholar

139 . Kruzhin, , Radio Liberty Research 5/84, 30 Dec. 1983, at 3.Google Scholar

140 Id. at 6–7.Google Scholar

141 . Vlasov, A., “Na strazhe pravoporiadka,” Kommunist No. 5, at 47 (1988).Google Scholar

142 . Teague, Elizabeth, “Andropov Cleans up the Militia,” RL 424/83. 9 Nov. 1983, at 3.Google Scholar

143 . Kruzhin, , Radio Liberty Research 5/84. 30 Dec. 1983.Google Scholar

144 Id.Google Scholar

145 . Knight, , 11 Soviet Union at 157–81 (cited in note 122).Google Scholar

146 RL6/85, 9 Jan. 1985.Google Scholar

147 Pravda 9 Nov. 1984.Google Scholar

148 “Interior Minister Interviewed by Yugoslav Journal,” FBIS Political Affairs Report, 1 July 1988, at 1.Google Scholar

149 “Strict Reckoning,” Literaturnaia Gazeta, 29 Aug. 1984, at 10.Google Scholar

150 Fedorchuk, V. V., “Militia Day Address,” Soviet television, 10 Nov. 1983, in SU/7491/B/1.Google Scholar

151 “Fedorchuk Assigned to Soviet Army Inspectorate,” FBIS Daily Report, 11 March 1986, at S1.Google Scholar

152 “Interior Minister Interviewed by Yugoslav Journal,” FBIS Political Affairs Report, 1 July 1988, at 1. He has been a Central Committee member since 1981.Google Scholar

153 Vlasov began his career as Party First Secretary of Irkutsk Oblast at age 29 and moved on to be an inspector of the CPSU Central Committee. After a stint on the staff of the party's Central Committee, he then became first secretary of the Rostov Oblast, the fifth largest in the USSR.Google Scholar

154 “MVD Official Discusses New Structural Measures,” FBIS Daily Report, 7 April 1988. at 44.Google Scholar

155 “12 Nov Session Recapped; Gorbachev Cited,” FBIS Daily Report, 14 Nov. 1989, at 64.Google Scholar

156 . See Savitsky, Valery, “Demokratizatsiia i Zakonnost,” Pravda 4 March 1988, at 4, and Vlasov, A., “Na Strazhe pravoporiadka. Kommunist No. 5, at 48 (1988).Google Scholar

157 . “‘Vzgylad’ Shows Attack on Liberal Writers,” RFE/RL Daily Report No. 20, 29 Jan. 1990.Google Scholar

158 Utitsin, O., “Prestizh milirseiskikh pogon,” Leninskoe znamia 8 Sept. 1988.Google Scholar

159 . “Leningrad Militiamen Put Forward Demands,” Moscow News No. 17, at 2 (1989); Braum, Zhanna & Kaplun, II'ia, “Chrezvychanoe proisshestvie na Dzortsovoi ploshadi,” Literaturnaia Gazeta, 10 May 1989, at 13.Google Scholar

160 Monkkonen, Eric H., Police in Urban America, 1860–1920 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981).CrossRefGoogle Scholar