Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T21:16:57.601Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Pro-Life and Feminist Mobilization in the Struggle over Abortion in Mexico: Church Networks, Elite Alliances, and Partisan Context

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 August 2021

Camilla Reuterswärd Open the ORCID record for Camilla Reuterswärd [Opens in a new window]
Camilla Reuterswärd*
Affiliation:
Camilla Reuterswärd is a research fellow at the Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, UK. [email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article comparatively analyzes the strategies and political impact of “pro-life” and feminist movements in the struggle over abortion policy in Mexico. Drawing on extensive fieldwork, it argues that anti-abortion movements are more likely to influence policymaking in contexts where they can tap into hegemonic religious institutions’ networks and alliances and indirectly provide incumbents with legitimizing moral and financial support in exchange for restrictive reforms. Partisan contexts shape incumbents’ need for such support. Feminist activists, by contrast, have neither elite connections nor access to similar mobilization resources. To make this argument, the analysis examines pro-life and feminist movements in two Mexican states: Yucatán, where Congress passed a restrictive reform; and Hidalgo, where an identical initiative failed.

Keywords

Social movementsreligious institutionsCatholic advocacyabortion
Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 63 , Special Issue 3: The Grassroots Right in Latin America , August 2021 , pp. 21 - 45
Copyright
© The Author 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the University of Miami

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Conflicts of interest: the author, Camilla Reuterswärd, declares none.

References

Interviews

Ángeles, Elsa. 2016. Activist. Pachuca, February 18.Google Scholar
Ayuda a la Mujer Embarazada (AME). 2015. Director. Mérida, September 10.Google Scholar
Derechos Cultura y Diversidad Sexual. 2015. President. Mérida, September 9.Google Scholar
Indignación. 2015. Lawyer. Mérida, October 8.Google Scholar
Interview 14. 2016. Scholar. Pachuca, March 18.Google Scholar
Interview 22. 2015. Scholar. Mérida, October 19.Google Scholar
Interview 23. 2016. Catholic Church member. Pachuca, April 11.Google Scholar
Interview 24. 2015. PAN official. Mérida, October 20.Google Scholar
Interview 28. 2015. Scholar. Mérida, October 14.Google Scholar
Interview 79. 2016. Pro-Life Activist. Pachuca, April 5.Google Scholar
Laviada Arce, Ivette. 2015. President, Pro-Yucatán Network. Mérida, October 7.Google Scholar
Letra, S. 2016. Director. Mexico City, May 10.Google Scholar
Meza Escorza, Tania. 2016. Activist. Pachuca, March 14.Google Scholar
Oasis de San Juan de Dios. 2015. Director. Mérida, October 15.Google Scholar
Ordaz Oliver, Sandra. 2016. Former PRD deputy. Pachuca, March 4.Google Scholar
Payán, Ana María. 2015. Former PAN mayor. Mérida, October 19.Google Scholar
Rincón, Carmen. 2016. Activist. Pachuca, February 23.Google Scholar
Sánchez, Otilia. 2016. Activist. Pachuca, February 26.Google Scholar
Sauri, Dulce María. 2015. Former governor of Yucatán. Mérida, September 28.Google Scholar
Servicios de Inclusión Integral y Derechos Humanos (SEIINAC). 2016. Representative. Pachuca, March 22.Google Scholar
Tellería, Yolanda. 2016. PAN deputy. Pachuca, March 31.Google Scholar
Unidad de Atención Sicológica, Sexológica y Educativa para el Crecimiento Personal (UNASSE). 2015. Lawyer. Mérida, September.Google Scholar

References

Asiaín Pereira, Carmen. 2016. Religion and Religions in the Latin American Constitutional Framework. In Law, Religion, Constitution: Freedom of Religion, Equal Treatment, and the Law, ed. Silvio Ferrari, W. Durham, Cole, Cianitto, Cristina, and Thayer, Donlu. London: Routledge. 125–50.Google Scholar
Bastian, Jean-Pierre. 1983. Metodismo y clase obrera durante el Porfiriato. Historia Mexicana 33, 1: 39–71.Google Scholar
Beer, Caroline. 2017. Making Abortion Laws in Mexico: Salience and Autonomy in the Policymaking Process. Comparative Politics 50, 1: 41–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blofield, Merike. 2006. The Politics of Moral Sin: Abortion and Divorce in Spain, Chile and Argentina. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Blofield, Merike. 2008. Women’s Choices in Comparative Perspective: Abortion Policies in Late-developing Catholic Countries. Comparative Politics 40, 4: 399–419.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blofield, Merike, and Christina, Ewig. 2017. The Left Turn and Abortion Politics in Latin America. Social Politics 24, 4: 481–510.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Camp, Roderic Ai. 1997. Crossing Swords: Politics and Religion in Mexico. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Carrasco Azcuaga, Alicia. 2015. Vifac “evita” 36 abortos cada mes. Milenio, March 13. https://sipse.com/milenio/vifac-salva-vida-mas-de-36-ninos-por-mes-141903.html Google Scholar
Ceballos Alvarado, Iris. 2015. Por segunda ocasión tiendas Chapur apoya a Vida y Familia, A.C. (Vifac), con una pasarela y desfile para recaudar fondos y seguir su labor. Diario de Yucatán, May 12.Google Scholar
Centenera, Mar. 2019. El feminismo argentino exige aborto legal y el fin de la violencia machista al próximo presidente. El País, October 15. https://elpais.com/internacional/ 2019/10/14/argentina/1571064564_727931.htmlGoogle Scholar
Congresodel Estado de Yucatán. 2009. Diario de los debates. Mérida: Congreso del Estado.Google Scholar
Delgado, Álvaro. 2016. El Yunque, la mano que mece al Frente Nacional por la Familia. Proceso, September 16. http://www.proceso.com.mx/454439/elyunque-la-mano-que-mece- al-frente-nacional-por-la-familiaGoogle Scholar
de Yucatán, Diario. 2009a. Yucatán ha dado pasos muy importantes para la familia. July 17. https://www.yucatan.com.mx Google Scholar
de Yucatán, Diario. 2009b. Beneplácito por una reciente ley. August 15.Google Scholar
Fallaw, Ben. 2013. Religion and State Formation in Post-Revolutionary Mexico. Durham: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Felitti, Karina. 2011. Estrategias de comunicación del activismo católico conservador frente al aborto y el matrimonio igualitario en la Argentina. Sociedad y Religión 21, 34–35: 92–122.Google Scholar
Flores-Macías, Gustavo. 2013. Mexico’s 2012 Elections: The Return of the PRI. Journal of Democracy 24, 1: 128–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franceschet, Susan. 2010. Explaining Domestic Violence Policy Outcomes in Chile and Argentina. Latin American Politics and Society 52, 3: 1–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franceschet, Susan, and Piscopo, Jennifer M.. 2012. Federalism, Decentralization, and Reproductive Rights in Argentina and Chile. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 43, 1: 129–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Franco, Iván. 2009. El PRI y sus obispos: el caso Berlié. Buenos Aires: Libros de la Araucaria.Google Scholar
Franco, Iván. 2013. Política y actores religiosos en Yucatán. Mexico City: Grafisma.Google Scholar
Friedman, Elisabeth Jay. 2009. Gender, Sexuality and the Latin American Left: Testing the Transformation. Third World Quarterly 30, 2: 415–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
George, Alexander L., and Bennett, Andrew. 2005. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Gerring, John, and Jason, Seawright. 2008. Case Selection Techniques in Case Study Research: A Menu of Qualitative and Quantitative Options. Political Research Quarterly 61, 2: 294–308.Google Scholar
Gill, Anthony. 1998. Rendering unto Caesar: The Catholic Church and the State in Latin America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Gill, Anthony. 2002. The Politics of Regulating Religion in Mexico: The 1992 Constitutional Reform in Historical Context. In Church-State Relations and Religious Liberty in Mexico: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives, ed. Davis, Derek. Waco: J. M. Dawson Institute of Church-State Studies, Baylor University. 79–112.Google Scholar
Gill, Anthony, and Arang, Keshavarzian. 1999. State Building and Religious Resources: An Institutional Theory of Church-State Relations in Iran and Mexico. Politics and Society 27, 3: 431–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gómez Chi, Rafael. 2012. Reconocen talento, esfuerzo y altruismo de mujeres yucatecas. Por Esto! (Mérida), November 23.Google Scholar
González Rivero, José. 2009. Debate por una iniciativa. Diario de Yucatán, July 14.Google Scholar
Gutiérrez, Irma E. 1990. Hidalgo: sociedad, economía, política, cultura. Mexico City: Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.Google Scholar
Haas, Liesl. 2010. Feminist Policymaking in Chile. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
Hagopian, Frances. 2008. Latin American Catholicism in an Age of Religious and Political Pluralism: A Framework for Analysis. Comparative Politics 40, 2: 149–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, Christopher. 2018. Religious Institutions and Collective Action: The Catholic Church and Political Activism in Indigenous Chiapas and Yucatán. Politics and Religion 11: 27–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hale, Christopher. 2019. Catholic Church Advocacy in Latin America. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. 1–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Heumann, Silke. 2007. Abortion and Politics in Nicaragua: The Women’s Movement in the Debate on the Abortion Law Reform 1999–2002. Culture, Health and Sexuality 9: 217–31.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Htun, Mala. 2003. Sex and the State: Abortion, Divorce, and the Family Under Latin American Dictatorships and Democracies. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI). 2010. Panorama de las religiones en México 2010. Mexico City: Secretaría de Gobernación. http://internet.contenidos.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/productos//prod_serv/contenidos/espanol/bvinegi/productos/censos/poblacion/2010/panora_religion/religiones_2010.pdf.Google Scholar
Kampwirth, Karen. 2008. Abortion, Antifeminism, and the Return of Daniel Ortega: In Nicaragua, Leftist Politics? Latin American Perspectives 35: 122–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kane, Gillian. 2008. Abortion Law Reform in Latin America: Lessons for Advocacy. Gender and Development 16, 2: 361–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keck, Margaret, and Kathryn, Sikkink. 1998. Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Klaiber, Jeffrey. 2009. The Catholic Church, Moral Education and Citizenship in Latin America. Journal of Moral Education 38, 4: 407–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Klesner, Joseph L. 2005. Electoral Competition and the New Party System in Mexico. Latin American Politics and Society 47, 2: 103–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koesel, Karrie. 2014. Religion and Authoritarianism: Cooperation, Conflict, and the Consequences. New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lawson, Chappell. 2000. Mexico’s Unfinished Transition: Democratization and Authoritarian Enclaves in Mexico. Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos 16, 2: 267–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levine, Daniel H. 2014. Religion and Politics in Latin America. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Loaeza, Soledad. 2013. La restauración de la iglesia católica en la transición mexicana. Mexico City: El Colegio de México.Google Scholar
López, Víctor. 2018. Brasil sigue los pasos del pañuelo verde argentino en busca de la despenalización del aborto. El Diario, September 16. https://www.eldiario.es/internacional/Brasil-panuelo-argentino-despenalizacion-aborto_0_814368773.htmlGoogle Scholar
Lopreite, Debora. 2014. Explaining Policy Outcomes in Federal Contexts: The Politics of Reproductive Rights in Argentina and Mexico. Bulletin of Latin American Research 33, 4: 389–404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loza, Nicolás, and Irma, Méndez, coords. 2014. Encuesta a expertos en política estatal en México (EEPEMEX), 2001–2012. Mexico City: FLACSO/PNUD/CONACYT.Google Scholar
de Yucatán, Mérida. 2010. Album de familia empresas yucatecas importantes en el pasado. September 7. http://www.meridadeyucatan.com/album-de-familia-empresasyucatecas- importantes-en-el-pasadoGoogle Scholar
Mis, Cobal, Rafael. 2008. Van por cambio radical. Por Esto! November 14.Google Scholar
Montalvo, Enrique O. 1996. México en una transición conservadora: el caso Yucatán. La Jornada Ediciones. Mexico City: Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia.Google Scholar
Morán, Faundes, José, Manuel. 2018. The Development of “Pro-Life” NGOs in Argentina: Three Strategic Movements. Religion and Gender 8, 1: 650–79.Google Scholar
Morgan, Lynn, and Elizabeth, Roberts. 2012. Reproductive Governance in Latin America. Anthropology and Medicine 19, 2: 241–54.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Murillo, M. Victoria, and Schrank, Andrew. 2005. With a Little Help from My Friends: Partisan Politics, Transnational Alliances, and Labor Rights in Latin America. Comparative Political Studies 38, 8: 971–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Olvera, Alberto J. 2010. The Elusive Democracy: Political Parties, Democratic Institutions, and Civil Society in Mexico. Latin American Research Review 45: 79–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Organization of American States (OAS). 1994. Inter-American Convention on the Prevention, Punishment, and Eradication of Violence Against Women (Convention of Belém do Pará). https://www.oas.org/en/MESECVI/convention.asp Google Scholar
Ortega, Enrique, and Iván, Fajardo. 1997. Yucatán: sociedad, economía, política, cultura. Mexico City: Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.Google Scholar
Pecheny, Mario, Jones, Daniel, and Ariza, Lucía. 2016. Sexual Politics and Religious Actors in Argentina. Religion and Gender 2, 6: 205–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peniche Quintal, Sandra. 2009. El congreso pretende negar nuestros derechos. Por Esto! July 15.Google Scholar
Pew Research Center. 2014. Religion in Latin America: Widespread Change in a Historically Catholic Region. Washington, DC: https://www.pewforum.org/2014/11/13/religion-in-latin-america Google Scholar
Population Council Mexico. 2009. ¿Qué piensan quienes habitan el Distrito Federal sobre la ley que permite a las mujeres obtener la interrupción legal del embarazo hasta las primeras doce semanas de gestación? Comparación de hallazgos clave de encuestas de opinión llevadas a cabo en el DF en los años 2007, 2008, y 2009.Google Scholar
Quezada, Sergio. 2001. Breve historia de Yucatán. Mexico City: El Colegio de México/ Fideicomiso Historia de las Americas/Fondo de Cultura Económica.Google Scholar
Ramírez, Gabriela A., and Morgan, Lynn. 2017. The Reproductive Rights Counteroffensive in Mexico and Central America. Feminist Studies 43, 2: 423–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reuterswärd, Camilla. 2019. Party Competition, the Catholic Church, and Moral Gender Policy in Mexico. Ph.D. diss., University of Wisconsin-Madison.Google Scholar
Reuterswärd, Camilla. 2020. ¡Malas Madres, Malas Mujeres, Malas Todas! The Incarceration of Women for Abortion-Related Crimes in Mexico. In Gender, Global Health, and Violence: Feminist Perspectives on Peace and Disease, ed. Confortini, Catia and Vaittinen, Tiina. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield. 139–58.Google Scholar
Sabido Méndez, Arcadio. 1995. Los hombres del poder. Monopolis, oligarquía y riqueza en Yucatán: 1880–1990. Mérida: Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán.Google Scholar
Secretaría, de Gobernación (SEGOB). 2018. Directorio de organizaciones de la sociedad civil. http://www.organizacionessociales.segob.gob.mx/en/Organizaciones_Sociales/Directorio_de_OSC Google Scholar
Snyder, Richard. 2001. Scaling Down: The Subnational Comparative Method. Studies in Comparative International Development 36, 1: 93–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
El Sol del Hidalgo. 2008. Otra causal legal del aborto. March 13.Google Scholar
El Sol del Hidalgo. 2011. Impulsarán panistas incluir en la constitución el derecho a la vida. October 26.Google Scholar
Sutton, Barbara, and Elizabeth, Borland. 2013. Framing Abortion Rights in Argentina’s Encuentros Nacionales de Mujeres. Feminist Studies 39: 194–234.Google Scholar
Trejo, Guillermo. 2009. Religious Competition and Ethnic Mobilization in Latin America: Why the Catholic Church Promotes Indigenous Movements in Mexico. American Political Science Review 103: 323–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vaggione, Juan Marco. 2014. Sexuality, Religion and Politics in Latin America. Sexuality and Politics: Regional Dialogues from the Global South, vol. 1. http://www.sxpolitics.org/sex-uality-and-politics/pdfs/volume1/5.pdf Google Scholar
Vaggione, Juan Marco. 2018. Sexuality, Law, and Religion in Latin America: Frameworks in Tension. Religion and Gender 8, 1: 14–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vargas, Jaime. 2009a. Consuman atentado contra diversidad sexual. Por Esto! July 16.Google Scholar
Vargas, Jaime. 2009b. Debe evitarse “legislar al vapor,” senalan diputados. Por Esto! July 23.Google Scholar
Vargas Aguilar, Hansel. 2008. Demandan bodas de homosexuales. Diario de Yucatán, November 14.Google Scholar
Vargas González, Pablo. 2003. Hidalgo: elecciones y reforma política 1979–2000. Mexico City: Cámara de Disputados LVIII Legislatora/Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Hidalgo.Google Scholar
Vergara Hernández, Arturo. 2011. Los masones y la revolución mexicana en el estado de Hidalgo. Revista de Investigación en Ciencias Sociales y Humanidades 13: 1–17.Google Scholar
Viterna, Jocelyn. 2012. The Left and “Life” in El Salvador. Politics and Gender 8, 2: 248–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yashar, Deborah J. 2005. Contesting Citizenship in Latin America: The Rise of Indigenous Movements and the Postliberal Challenge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ahora, Yucatán. 2010. Recibe Alicia García Gamboa medalla Héctor Victoria. October 1. http://mx00.yucatanahora.com/noticias/recibe-alicia-garcia-gamboa-medalla-hector-victoria-899 Google Scholar