In this article we perform a quantitative analysis of verbs of
quotation in a cohesive speech community. The incoming form be
like overshadows all other quotative verbs among speakers under 30.
This telescoped rate of change provides an opportunity to investigate the
actuation problem as well as to probe the underlying mechanism of change
in the contrasting variable grammars across generations. Multivariate
analyses of factors conditioning be like (content of the quote,
grammatical person, sex) reveal stability in the significance of
constraints, however the rankings and relative strengths reveal subtle
ongoing changes in the system. Interpreting these in sociocultural
context, we suggest that be like is an innovation that arose out
of a preexisting niche in the grammar. It accelerated during the 1980s due
to its preppy associations, later specializing as a marker of narrative
present. In accounting for these findings, we are led to contrast
generational and communal change and to question what it means to
‘participate’ in linguistic change.The first author gratefully acknowledges the support of the
Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC) for
grant #410-2003-0005 “Linguistic changes in Canada entering the
21st century” and the Research Opportunities Program at the
University of Toronto (ROP). Special thanks are owed to the research
assistants on these projects who have been instrumental in transcribing,
and in some cases extracting, the data: Stephanie Cali, Jonille Clemente,
Derek Denis, Louis Filipe, Kevin Galloway, Marion Hau, Matthew King, Megan
Lyon, Marion Macdonald, Sonja Molfenter, Jenny Seppänen, Karina von
Stedingk, Muhammad Velji, Jessica Wertman, Lina Yang, and Stacy Yeh. An
earlier version of this article was presented at NWAVE 33 (Ann Arbor,
October 2004), where feedback from our audience was instrumental. We are
also grateful to Nathalie Dion and Shana Poplack for their discerning
comments on an earlier written version.