Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T08:07:24.092Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ANTI-SEMITISM AND PROGRESSIVE ERA SOCIAL SCIENCE: THE CASE OF JOHN R. COMMONS

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 February 2016

Luca Fiorito  and
Cosma Orsi
Luca Fiorito*
Affiliation:
University of Palermo.
Cosma Orsi
Affiliation:
Catholic University of Milan.
*
1Correspondence may be addressed to Luca Fiorito at [email protected].
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper explores John Commons’s views toward Jews in order to assess whether his published writings contain assertions that today would be stigmatized as anti-Semitic. The evidence we provide shows that Commons’s racial characterization of Jews was framed within a broad and indiscriminate xenophobic framework. With other leading Progressive Era social scientists, in fact, Commons shared the idea that the new immigration from eastern and southern Europe would increase competition in the labor market, drive down wages, and lead Anglo-Saxon men and women to have fewer children, since they would not want them to compete with those who survive on less. Within this general xenophobic context, Commons developed assertions regarding immigrant Jews that show traces of explicit anti-Semitic accusations.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of the History of Economic Thought , Volume 38 , Issue 1 , March 2016 , pp. 55 - 80
Copyright
Copyright © The History of Economics Society 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Asso, Pier Francesco, and Fiorito, Luca. 2004. “Human Nature and Economic Institutions: Instinct Psychology, Behaviorism, and the Development of American Institutionalism.” Journal of the History of Economic Thought 26 (4): 445–477.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bateman, Bradley W. 2003. “Race, Intellectual History, and American Economics: A Prolegomenon to the Past.” History of Political Economy 35 (4): 713–730.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boas, Franz. 1912. “Changes in the Bodily Form of Descendants of Immigrants.” American Anthropologist 14 (3): 530–562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, Linda J. 2004. The Literature of Immigration and Racial Formation: Becoming White, Becoming Other, Becoming American in the Late Progressive Era. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carlebach, Julius. 1978. Karl Marx and the Radical Critique of Judaism. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Cherry, Robert D. 1976. “Racial Thought and the Early Economics Profession.” Review of Social Economy 34 (2): 147–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cherry, Robert D. 1989. Discrimination: Its Economic Impact on Blacks, Women, and Jews. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Claghorn, Kate H. 1909. “Review of Races and Immigrants in America by John R. Commons.” Political Science Quarterly 24 (1): 135–137.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Commons, John R. 1901. “Immigration and Its Economic Effects.” In Reports of the U.S. Industrial Commission. Volume 15. Washington: Government Printing Office, pp. 293–743.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1903–1904. “Racial Composition of the American People.” A series of nine articles in the Chautauquan: “Race and Democracy,” 38(1): 33–42; “Colonial Race Elements,” 38 (2): 118–125; “The Negro,” 38 (3): 223–234; “Immigration during the Nineteenth Century,” 38 (4): 333–340; “Immigration during the Nineteenth Century (Continued),” 38 (5): 433–443; “Industry,” 38 (6): 533–543; “Social and Industrial Problems,” 39 (1): 13–22; “City Life, Crime and Poverty,” 39 (2): 115–124; “Amalgamation and Assimilation,” 39 (3): 217–227.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1907a. Races and Immigrants in America. New York: The Chautauqua Press.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1907b. “Review of Immigration and Its Effect Upon the United States by Prescott F. Hall.” Charities and the Commons 17: 504.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1919. “Review of Instincts in Industry: A Study of Working class Psychology by Ordway Tead and Creative Impulse in Industry by Helen Marot.” American Economic Review 9 (2): 312–316.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1924. Legal Foundations of Capitalism. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1934a. Myself. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1934b. Institutional Economics; Its Place in Political Economy. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Commons, John R. 1950. The Economics of Collective Action. New York: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Commons, John R., and Leiserson, William L.. 1914. “Wage-Earners of Pittsburgh.” In Kellogg, Paul U., ed., Wage-Earning Pittsburgh. New York: Survey Associates, pp. 113–188.Google Scholar
Daniels, Roger. 2004. Guarding the Golden Door: American Immigration Policy and Immigrants Since 1882. New York: Hill and Wang.Google Scholar
Dinnerstein, Leonard. 1994. Anti-Semitism in America. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Durand, Dana E. 1901. “General Statistics of Immigration and Foreign-Born Population.” In Reports of the U.S. Industrial Commission. Volume 15. Washington: Government Printing Office, pp. 257–292.Google Scholar
Ellwood, Charles A. 1908. “Review of Races and Immigrants in America by John R. Commons.” American Journal of Sociology 13 (4): 561–562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fein, Helen. 1987. “Dimensions of Antisemitism: Attitudes, Collective Accusations, and Actions.” In Fein, Helen, ed., The Persisting Question: Sociological Perspectives and Social Contexts of Modern Anti-Semitism. New York: De Gruyter, pp. 67–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fink, Leon. 1991a. “Intellectuals Versus ‘Workers’: Academic Requirements and the Creation of Labor History.” American Historical Review 96 (2): 395–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fink, Leon. 1991b. “A Memoir of Selig Perlman and His Life at the University of Wisconsin: Based on an Interview of Mark Perlman.” Labor History 32 (3): 503–525.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fiorito, Luca. 2010. “John R. Commons, Wesley N. Hohfeld and the Origins of Transactional Economics.” History of Political Economy 42 (2): 267–295.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forbath, William E. 2013. “Jews, Law and Identity Politics.” Mimeo. Austin: University of Texas.Google Scholar
Frankel, Noralee, and Dye, Nancy S., eds. 1991. Gender, Class, Race, and Reform in the Progressive Era. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky.Google Scholar
Goldenweiser, Emanuel A. 1911. “Immigrants in Cities.” The Survey 25 (1): 596–602. Reprinted in Philip Davis and Bertha Schwartz, eds. 1920. Immigration and Americanization: Selected Readings. New York: Ginn and Co., pp. 216–223.Google Scholar
Goldenweiser, Emanuel A. 1912a. “Review of Die Zukunft der Juden by Werner Sombart.” American Economic Review 2 (3): 678–679.Google Scholar
Goldenweiser, Emanuel A. 1912b. “Walker’s Theory of Immigration.” American Journal of Sociology 18 (3): 342–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldstein, Eric L. 2001. “The Unstable Other: Locating the Jew in Progressive-Era American Racial Discourse.” American Jewish History 89 (4): 383–409.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gonce, Richard A. 2002. “John R. Commons’s ‘Five Big Years’: 1899–1904.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology 61 (4): 755–777.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Prescott F. 1906. Immigration and its Effects Upon the United States. New York: Holt.Google Scholar
Hall, Prescott F. 1912. “Review of The Immigration Problem by Jeremiah W. Jenks and W. Jett Lauck.” American Economic Review 2 (3): 675–677.Google Scholar
Harter, Lafayette G. 1962. John R. Commons: His Assault on Laissez Faire. Corvallis: Oregon State University Press.Google Scholar
Higham, John. 1969. Strangers in the Land: Patterns of American Nativism 1860–1925. New York: Atheneum.Google Scholar
Hourwich, Isaac A. 1911. “The Economic Aspects of Immigration.” Political Science Quarterly 26 (4): 615–642.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hourwich, Isaac A. 1912. Immigration and Labor: The Economic Aspects of European Immigration to the United States. New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons.Google Scholar
Hove, Arthur. 1991. The University of Wisconsin: A Pictorial History. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Jenks, Jeremiah W., and Jett Lauck, W.. 1912. The Immigration Problem. New York: Funk and Wagnalls.Google Scholar
Joseph, Samuel K. 1914. Jewish Immigration to the United States, from 1881 to 1910. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Julius, Anthony. 2010. Trials of the Diaspora: A History of Anti-Semitism in England. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Kohler, Max J. 1912. “Restriction of Immigration—Discussion.” American Economic Review 2 (1): 72–78.Google Scholar
Kohler, Max J. 1914. “Some Aspects of the Immigration Problem.” American Economic Review 4 (1): 93–108.Google Scholar
Leonard, Thomas C. 2003. “More Merciful and Not Less Effective: Eugenics and Progressive-Era American Economics.” History of Political Economy 35 (4): 709–734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leonard, Thomas C. 2005. “Mistaking Eugenics for Social Darwinism: Why Eugenics Is Missing from the History of American Economics.” History of Political Economy 37 (Supplement): 200–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leonard, Thomas C. 2009. “American Economic Reform in the Progressive Era: Its Foundational Beliefs and Their Relationship to Eugenics.” History of Political Economy 41 (1): 109–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leroy-Beaulieu, Anatole. 1895. Israel Among the Nations: A Study of the Jews and Antisemitism. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons.Google Scholar
Morris-Reich, Amos. 2011. “Circumventions and Confrontations: Georg Simmel, Franz Boas and Arthur Ruppin and Their Responses to Antisemitism.” Patterns of Prejudice 44 (2): 195–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Page, Charles H. 1985. Fifty Years in the Sociological Enterprise: A Lucky Journey. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.Google Scholar
Perlman, Selig. 1952. “Jewish-American Unionism, Its Birth Pangs and Contribution to the General American Labor Movement.” Publications of the American Jewish Historical Society 41 (4): 297–337.Google Scholar
Perlmann, Joel. 2011. “Views of European Races among the Research Staff of the US Immigration Commission and the Census Bureau, ca. 1910.” Working Paper 648. Levy Economics Institute of Bard College.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Piott, Steven L. 2011. Daily Life in the Progressive Era. Santa Barbara: Greenwood.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pope, Jesse E. 1905. The Clothing Industry in New York. Columbia: University of Missouri.Google Scholar
Ramstad, Yngve, and Starkey, James L.. 1995. “The Racial Theories of John R. Commons.” Research in the History of Economic Thought and Methodology 13: 1–74.Google Scholar
Reder, Melvin W. 2000. “The Anti-Semitism of Some Eminent Economists.” History of Political Economy 32 (4): 833–856.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reder, Melvin W. 2002. “Reply to Hamowy’s Note on Hayek and Anti-Semitism.” History of Political Economy 34 (1): 262–272.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reich, Nathan. 1955. “The ‘Americanization’ of Jewish Unionism: A Two Way Process.” Jewish Quarterly Review 45 (4): 540–561.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ripley, William Z. 1899. The Races of Europe: A Sociological Study. New York: D. Appleton and Co.Google Scholar
Ripley, William Z. 1904. “Race Factors in Labor Union.” Atlantic Monthly 93 (March): 299–308.Google Scholar
Ross, Edward A. 1901. “The Causes of Race Superiority.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 18 (1): 67–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ross, Edward A. 1902. “Recent Tendencies in Sociology II.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 17 (1): 82–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ross, Edward A. 1913. “The Old World in the New: Economic Consequences of Migration.” Century Magazine 67 (November): 28–35.Google Scholar
Ross, Edward A. 1914. The Old World in the New: The Significance of Past and Present Immigration to the American People. New York: The Century Co.Google Scholar
Rutherford, Malcolm. 2006. “Wisconsin Institutionalism: John R. Commons and His Students.” Labor History 47 (2): 161–188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Solomon, Barbara M. 1972. Ancestors and Immigrants: A Changing New England Tradition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Soyer, Daniel. 1997. “Jewish Immigrant Associations and American Identity in New York, 1880–1939.”Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1997.Google Scholar
Spiro, Jonathan P. 2009. Defending the Master Race: Conservation, Eugenics, and the Legacy of Madison Grant. Burlington: University of Vermont Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stocking, George W. 2001. Delimiting Anthropology: Occasional Essays and Reflections. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Walker, Francis Amasa. 1891. “Immigration and Degradation.” Forum 11 (2): 634–644.Google Scholar
Webb, Beatrice. 1898a. “The Jews of East London.” In Sidney Webb and Beatrice Webb, Problems of Modern Industry. London: Longmans, Green, pp. 20–45.Google Scholar
Webb, Beatrice. 1898b. “How to Do Away with the Sweating System.” In Sidney Webb and Beatrice Webb, Problems of Modern Industry. London: Longmans, Green, pp. 156–191.Google Scholar
Webb, Sidney, and Webb, Beatrice. 1897. Industrial Democracy. Two volumes. London: Longmans, Green.Google Scholar
Weintraub, E. Roy. 2003. “Prejudice and the History of Economics: A Minisymposium.” History of Political Economy 35 (4): 685–686.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Weintraub, E. Roy. 2012. “Keynesian Historiography and the Anti-Semitism Question.” History of Political Economy 44 (1): 41–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Willcox, Walter F. 1906. “Review of Immigration and Its Effect Upon the United States by Prescott F. Hall.” American Economic Review 11 (4): 921–922.Google Scholar
Zeidel, Robert F. 2004. Immigrants, Progressives and Exclusion Politics: The Dillingham Commission 1900–1927. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press.Google Scholar