Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-7cvxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:10:35.842Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reimagining the “Lost Men” of the Gilded Age: Perspectives on the Late Nineteenth Century Presidents

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 November 2010

Charles W. Calhoun
Charles W. Calhoun
Affiliation:
East Carolina University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

For much of the twentieth century, scholars treated the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era as starkly contrasting phases in the unfolding of the American story: the post-Civil War dark ages followed by the bright light of the early twentieth century. More recently, historians have recognized the oversimplification if not downright wrongheadedness of that dichotomy. The past few decades have witnessed an explosion of studies on a variety of topics with coverage dates roughly from the 1870s to the 1920s. Most of these newer works underscore the continuities between the two periods and the relatively seamless evolution of forces and institutions.

Type
Essays
Information
The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era , Volume 1 , Issue 3 , July 2002 , pp. 225 - 257
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 See, for example, LaFeber, Walter, The New Empire: An Interpretation of American Expansion 1860–1898 (Ithaca, 1963)Google Scholar; Campbell, Charles S., The Transformation of American Foreign Relations, 1865–1900 (New York, 1976)Google Scholar; Beisner, Robert L., From the Old Diplomacy to the New, 1865–1900 (Arlington Heights, IL, 1986).Google Scholar

2 Wilson, Woodrow, Congressional Government: A Study in American Politics (1885, reprint, Gloucester, MA, 1973), 62Google Scholar, 69, 167–68, 170, 187.

3 Bryce, James, The American Commonwealth, 2 vols. (New York and London, 1889), 1:50, 63Google Scholar, 177, 219, 224, 288, 295.

4 Hofstadter, Richard, The American Political Tradition and the Men Who Made It (1948; reprint, New York, 1973), 170Google Scholar; Keller, Morton, Affairs of State: Public Life in Late Nineteenth Century America (Cambridge, MA, 1977), 297CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 544; Cherny, Robert W., American Politics in the Gilded Age, 1868–1900 (Wheeling, IL, 1997), 50.Google Scholar

5 Morgan, H. Wayne, William McKinley and His America (Syracuse, 1963)Google Scholar and From Hayes to McKinley: National Party Politics, 1877–1896 (Syracuse, 1969; Sievers, Harry J., Benjamin Harrison, Hoosier President: The White House and After (Indianapolis, 1968)Google Scholar; Peskin, Allan, Garfield: A Biography (Kent, OH, 1978)Google Scholar; Reeves, Thomas C., Gentleman Boss: The Life of Chester Alan Arthur (New York, 1975).Google Scholar

6 Scaturro, Frank J., President Grant Reconsidered (Lanham, MD, 1998)Google Scholar; Smith, Jean Edward, Grant (New York, 2001)Google Scholar; McFeely, William S., Grant: A Biography (New York, 1981).Google Scholar Smith's bibliography is much more extensive than Scaturro's and includes numerous manuscript collections and other primary sources, but his footnotes suggest considerable reliance on secondary works. Perret, Geoffrey, Ulysses S. Grant: Soldier and President (New York, 1997)Google Scholar, is weak on Grant's presidential years. See also Joan Waugh, “‘A Great General Can Be a Baby President’: U.S. Grant's Presidential Legacy Reconsidered,” Paper presented at the American Historical Association Annual Meeting, San Francisco, January 4,2002, copy in my possession.

7 Jeffers, H. Paul, An Honest President: The Life and Presidencies of Grover Cleveland (New York, 2000)Google Scholar; Brodsky, Alyn, Grover Cleveland: A Study in Character (New York, 2000)Google Scholar; Nevins, Allan, Grover Cleveland: A Study in Courage (New York, 1932).Google Scholar

8 Hoogenboom, Ari, Rutherford B. Hayes: Warrior and President (Lawrence, KS, 1995).Google Scholar

9 Hoogenboom, Ari, The Presidency of Rutherford B. Hayes (Lawrence, KS, 1988)Google Scholar; Doenecke, Justus, The Presidencies of James A. Garfield and Chester A. Arthur (Lawrence, KS, 1981)Google Scholar; Welch, Richard E. Jr., The Presidencies of Grover Cleveland (Lawrence, KS, 1988)Google Scholar; Socolofsky, Homer E. and Spetter, Allan B., The Presidency of Benjamin Harrison (Lawrence, KS, 1987)Google Scholar; Gould, Lewis L., The Presidency of William McKinley (Lawrence, KS, 1980).Google Scholar

10 Simpson treats Grant's Reconstruction policies, as well as those of , Lincoln, Johnson, , and Hayes, , in Simpson, Brooks D., The Reconstruction Presidents (Lawrence, KS, 1998).Google Scholar

11 The best scholarly accounts of the Johnson impeachment are Benedict, Michael Les, The Impeachment and Trial of Andrew Johnson (New York, 2nd ed., 1999)Google Scholar and Trefousse, Hans L., Impeachment of a President: Andrew Johnson, the Blacks, and Reconstruction (1975; reprint, New York, 1999).Google Scholar See also Simpson, , Reconstruction Presidents, 123–27Google Scholar; Castel, Albert, The Presidency of Andrew Johnson (Lawrence, KS, 1979).Google Scholar

12 Bryce, , American Commonwealth, 1:47, 290.Google Scholar

13 Hoar, George F., Autobiography of Seventy Years, 2 vols. (New York, 1903), 1:246Google Scholar; George Bancroft to Ulysses S. Grant, March 5, 1869, Ulysses S. Grant Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

14 Richardson, James D., A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, 10 vols. (Washington, 1903), 7:6.Google Scholar

15 Hesseltine, William B., Ulysses S. Grant: Politician (New York, 1935), 145–53Google Scholar; Smith, , Grant, 479–80.Google Scholar

16 Richardson, Messages, vol. 7, passim; Spitzer, Robert J., “Veto, Regular,” in Encyclopedia of the American Presidency, 4 vols., eds., Levy, Leonard W. and Fisher, Louis (New York, 1994), 4:1553.Google Scholar

17 Richardson, , Messages, 7:242, 377Google Scholar; Damon, Allan L., “Impoundment,” American Heritage 25 (December 1973): 22–23.Google Scholar

18 McPherso, Edward, A Hand-Book of Politics for 1876 (Washington, 1876), 149–52Google Scholar; Richardson, , Messages, 7:361–66.Google Scholar

19 Richardson, , Messages, 7:109, 156–59Google Scholar; Grant, Ulysses S. to Medili, Joseph, February 1, 1872, in The Papers of Ulysses S. Grant, 24 vols. to date, ed., Simon, John Y. (Carbondale, IL, 1967 —), 23:3.Google Scholar

20 Sumner, Charles, Republicanism vs. Grantism…Speech of Hon. Charles Sumner of Massachusetts, Delivered in the Senate of the United States, May 31, 1872 (Washington, 1872)Google Scholar; Richardson, , Messages, 7:205, 255, 300–301Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, Ari, Outlawing the Spoils: A History of the Civil Service Reform Movement, 1865–1883 (Urbana, 1968), 106–34Google Scholar; Smith, , Grant, 587–90.Google Scholar

21 Marshall Jewell to Elihu Washburne, October 17, 1874, Elihu Washburne Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Dorman B. Eaton, quoted in Hoogenboom, , Outlawing the Spoils, 134.Google Scholar

22 Edward Atkinson to Hugh McCulloch, November 6,1868, Hugh McCulloch Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Richardson, , Messages, 7:6–8.Google Scholar

23 The best modern treatment of Grant's Reconstruction policies is Simpson, , Reconstruction Presidents, 1–6Google Scholar, 133–96, 231–36.

24 Richardson, , Messages, 7:308Google Scholar and passim.

25 Grant to James G. Blaine, March 9, 1871, Grant Papers; New York Times, March 24, 1871; Hoar, , Autobiography, 1:204–06Google Scholar; Richardson, , Messages, 7:127–28, 134–41Google Scholar; Kaczorowski, Robert J., The Politics of Judicial Interpretation: The Federal Courts, Department of Justice and Civil Rights, 1866–1876 (New York, 1985), 83–96Google Scholar; Simpson, , Reconstruction Presidents, 155–56.Google Scholar

26 Richardson, , Messages, 7:298–99, 308Google Scholar; Simpson, , Reconstruction Presidents, 231–32.Google Scholar

27 John Sherman to Grant, February 11, 1873, John Sherman Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

28 Richardson, , Messages, 7:6–8, 29Google Scholar; Gold Panic Investigation, House Report No. 31, 41 Cong., 2 Sess., 1870; New York Times, September 24, 25, 1869; Smith, , Grant, 482–90.Google Scholar

29 Richardson, , Messages, 7:30Google Scholar; Laws of the United States Relating to Loans, Paper Money, Banking, and Coinage, 1790–1895, Senate Report No. 831, 53 Cong., 3 Sess., 1896, 191–93.

30 William A. Richardson to Grant, September 19, 1873 (telegram), Richardson to Thomas Hillhouse, September 19, 1873 (telegram), Grant Papers; Annual Report of the Secretary of the Treasury on the State of the Finances for the Year 1873 (Washington, 1873), xv.

31 Richardson, , Messages, 7:244, 268–71Google Scholar; Joseph Medili to Elihu Washburne, May 1, 1874, Washbume papers; John A. Logan to Mrs. Logan, May 7, 1874, John A. Logan Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. ; James A. Garfield, diary entries for April 22, 23, 1874, in The Diary of James A. Garfield, 4 vols., eds., Harry James Brown and Frederick D. Williams (East Lansing, MI, 1967–1981), 2:315–16.

32 Smith, , Grant, 581Google Scholar; New York Tribune, June 6, 1874; New York Times, June 12, 1874; Richardson, , Messages, 7:314–16.Google Scholar

33 Richardson, , Messages, 7:400–401Google Scholar; New York Tribune, March 3, 1877.

34 McPherson, , Hand-Book of Politics for 1876, 212Google Scholar; Richardson, , Messages, 7:444, 450–51Google Scholar; Rutherford B. Hayes, diary entry for February 14, 1879, in Hayes: The Diary of a President, 1875–1881, ed., T. Harry Williams (New York, 1964), 187.

35 John Sherman to James Pollock, September 20, 1878, Sherman Papers; Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 127–51.Google Scholar

36 Richardson, , Messages, 7:561–66Google Scholar; 1880. Proceedings of the Republican National Convention, Held at Chicago, Illinois (Chicago, 1881), 19.

37 The literature on the election of 1876–1877 and Hayes” southern policy is voluminous. The best brief account is Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, chs. 1–3.Google Scholar

38 McPherson, , Hand-Book of Politics for 1876, 213Google Scholar; Rutherford B. Hayes, diary entry for February 18, 1877, in Diary and Letters of Rutherford Birchard Hayes, 5 vols., ed., Charles Richard Williams (Columbus, OH, 1924), 3:417.

39 Hayes, diary entries for March 20, 23, 1877, in Williams, , Diary and Letters, 3:428, 429Google Scholar; New York Times, April 4, 17, 1877; McPherson, Edward, A Hand-Book of Politics for 1878 (Washington, 1878), 69, 81.Google Scholar

40 Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 52, 63Google Scholar; Santis, Vincent P. De, Republicans Face the Southern Question — The New Departure Years, 1877–1897 (Baltimore, 1959), 69Google Scholar, 74–78, 91–93; Williams, Charles Richard, The Life of Rutherford Birchard Hayes, 2 vols. (Columbus, OH, 1928), 2:241–98Google Scholar; Tulis, Jeffrey K., The Rhetorical Presidency (Princeton, 1987), 64.Google Scholar

41 New York Tribune, May 22, 1878; Philadelphia Times, May 31, 1878, quoted in Williams, Life of Hayes, 2:155n; McPherson, , Hand-Book of Politics for 1878, 192–94Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 71–72Google Scholar, 73–74. In the end the investigation backfired against the Democrats when evidence surfaced linking Tilden's nephew with attempts to bribe southern election officials.

42 Hayes, diary entry for March 18, 1879, in Williams, , Diary and Letters, 3:529Google Scholar; Richardson, , Messages, 7:530–31Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 75–78Google Scholar, 195–97.

43 Richardson, , Messages, 7:514–20Google Scholar; Gyory, Andrew, Closing the Gate: Race, Politics, and the Chinese Exclusion Act (Chapel Hill, 1998), 165–67.Google Scholar

44 Richardson, , Messages, 7:461, 486–88Google Scholar, 558–59, 614–17; McPherson, , Hand-Book of Politics for 1878, 128Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 92–98Google Scholar; Hayes, diary entry for April 14, 1878, in Williams, , Diary and Letters, 3:479.Google Scholar

45 Richardson, , Messages, 7:532Google Scholar; Hoogenboom, , Presidency of Hayes, 224Google Scholar, 226.

46 Garfield, diary entry for March 14,1881, in Brown and Williams, , Diary ofGarfield, 4:558.Google Scholar For a convenient compendium of Garfield's speeches and other writings, see The Works of James Abram Garfield, 2 vois., ed., Burke A. Hinsdale (Boston, 1883).

47 Garfield, diary entry for February 28, 1878, in Brown, and Williams, , Diary of Garfield, 4:30Google Scholar; Garfield to Harmon Austin, March 3, 1878, James A. Garfield Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Garfield to Hinsdale, Burke A., July 25, 1880, in Garfield-Hinsdale Letters: Correspondence between James Abram Garfield and Burke Aaron Hinsdale, ed., Hinsdale, Mary L. (Ann Arbor, MI, 1949), 454–55.Google Scholar

48 Garfield to Hinsdale, April 4, 1881, in Hinsdale, , Garfield-Hinsdale Letters, 489Google Scholar; Doenecke, , Presidencies of Garfield and Arthur, 42–45.Google Scholar

49 Garfield to Chamberlain, D. H., January 15, 1881, in New York Times, October 7, 1883Google Scholar; Garfield to Hinsdale, December 30,1880, in Hinsdale, , Garfield-Hinsdale Letters, 469–70Google Scholar; Hinsdale, , Worb of Garfield, 2:783, 791–92.Google Scholar

50 Hinsdale, , Works of Garfield, 2:784, 792–93Google Scholar; Garfield, diary entries for March 19, 26, 29, 30, 31, April 4, 5, 8, 12, 26, May 13, 23, 1881, in Brown, and Williams, , Diary of Garfield, 4:561, 564Google Scholar, 566, 567, 569, 572, 574, 582, 590, 598–99; Annual Report of the Secretary of the Treasury on the State of the Finances for the Year 1881 (Washington, 1881), xxiv-xxvi; Doenecke, Presidencies of Garfield and Arthur, 45.

51 Reeves, , Gentleman Boss, 317–18Google Scholar, 422–23; Doenecke, , Presidencies of Garfield and Arthur, 80Google Scholar; Tulis, , Rhetorical Presidency, 64Google Scholar, 65, 85; McPherson, Edward, A Hand-Book of Politics for 1882 (Washington, 1882), 115–16Google Scholar, and A Hand-Book of Politics for 1884 (Washington, 1884), 129.

52 Arthur's messages are in Richardson, Messages, vol. 8.

53 Richardson, , Messages, 8:144–45Google Scholar, 185–86, 188, 253; Supplement to the Revised Statutes of the United States, 1874–1891 (Washington, 1891), 529–33, 947.

54 Richardson, , Messages, 8:60–63Google Scholar, 145–47; Supplement to the Revised Statutes of the United States, 1874–1891, 392–96.

55 Richardson, , Messages, 8:51–52, 140Google Scholar, 179, 181–82, 247, 248; Doenecke, , Presidencies of Garfield and Arthur, 147–53.Google Scholar

56 Richardson, , Messages, 8:49, 135–36Google Scholar; Doenecke, , Presidencies of Garfleld and Arthur, 167–71Google Scholar; Reeves, , Gentleman Boss, 328–34.Google Scholar

57 Doenecke, , Presidencies of Garfield and Arthur, 171–79.Google Scholar

58 Charles E. Coon to William E. Chandler, June 24, 1886, William E. Chandler Papers, New Hampshire Historical Society, Concord, NH; Richardson, , Messages, 8:112–22Google Scholar, 138–39,187, 253; Supplements the Revised Statutes of the United States, 1874–1891, 363–69; Gyory, , Closing the Gate, 244Google Scholar, 250–53.

59 Proceedings of the Eighth Republican National Convention…1884 (Chicago, 1884), 138–64; Reeves, , Gentleman Boss, 420Google Scholar; McCulloch, Hugh, Men and Measures of Half a Century: Sketches and Comments (New York, 1888), 484.Google Scholar

60 Richardson, , Messages, 8:375–83Google Scholar; Welch, , Presidencies of Cleveland, 53–56Google Scholar; Fisher, Louis, “Grover Cleveland Against the Senate,” Congressional Studies 7 (1979): 11–25Google Scholar; Marszalek, John F. Jr., “Grover Cleveland and the Tenure of Office Act,” Duquesne Review 15 (1970): 206–19Google Scholar; Cleveland, Grover, Presidential Problems (New York, 1904), 3–69.Google Scholar

61 Richiadson, , Messages, 8:549–58Google Scholar; Skocpol, Theda, Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy in the United States (Cambridge, MA, 1992), 102–51Google Scholar; Charles Hedges, comp., Speeches of Benjamin Harrison, Twenty-third President of the United States (New York, 1892), 71.Google Scholar

62 Richardson, , Messages, 8:394–97Google Scholar, 407–409, 580–91; Reitano, Joanne, The Tariff Question in the Gilded Age: The Great Debate of 1888 (University Park, PA, 1994).Google Scholar

63 Richardson, , Messages, 8:774–78.Google Scholar

64 “Harrison's Speeches in 1888,” undated typescript, Louis T. Michener Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Hedges, Speeches of Benjamin Harrison; Tulis, , Rhetorical Presidency, 64Google Scholar; Socolofsky, and Spetter, , Presidency of Harrison, 157–83.Google Scholar

65 Richardson, , Messages, 9:5–14Google Scholar, 32–58, 60, 70–71, 74, 76–77, 80–81; Hamson, Benjamin to Blaine, James G., July 17, 23, 1890, in The Correspondence between Benjamin Harrison and James G. Blaine, 1882–1893, ed., Volwiler, Albert T. (Philadelphia, 1940), 109Google Scholar, 112; P. C Cheney to L. T. Michener, March 23, “1893” [1896], Michener Papers. Dingley's observation is reported in the Cheney letter.

66 Supplement to the Revised Statutes of the United States, 1874–1891, 760–61, 762–64, 774–76, 794–97, 803–804, 812–69, 905–907, 947, 948–50; E. W. Halford to Edward McPherson, October 17, 22, 1890, Edward McPherson Papers, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.; Richardson, , Messages, 9:124–29Google Scholar; Socolofsky, and Spetter, , Presidency of Harrison, 70–73.Google Scholar

67 Richardson, , Messages, 9:332.Google Scholar

68 Richardson, , Messages, 9:390.Google Scholar

69 Richardson, , Messages, 9:396, 401–405Google Scholar; Welch, , Presidencies of Cleveland, 117–19Google Scholar, 122–24, 129–39.

70 Wilson, Woodrow, “Mr. Cleveland as President,” Atlantic Monthly 79 (March 1897)Google Scholar in The Papers ofWoodrow Wilson, 69 vols., ed., Arthur S. Link (Princeton, 1966–1994), 10: 104, 110, 113.

71 Blodgett, Geoffrey, “The Political Leadership of Grover Cleveland,” South Atlantic Quarterly 82 (Summer 1983): 298–99.Google Scholar

72 Cullom, Shelby M., Fifty Years of Public Service: Personal Recollections of Shelby M. Cullom, Senior U.S. Senator from Illinois (Chicago, 1911), 275Google Scholar; Gould, Lewis L., “William McKinley and the Expansion of Presidential Power,” Ohio History 87 (Winter 1978): 9–10Google Scholar; Morgan, , McKinley, 126Google Scholar, 274–75.

73 Gould, , Presidency of McKinley, 38Google Scholar, 241, and “William McKinley and the Expansion of Presidential Power,” 10–12; Ritchie, Donald A., Press Gallery: Congress and the Washington Correspondents (Cambridge, MA, 1991), 202.Google Scholar

74 McKinley, William, Speeches and Addresses of William McKinley from March 1, 1897 to May 30, 1900 (New York, 1900)Google Scholar; Tulis, , Rhetorical Presidency, 64Google Scholar, 66, 86; Gould, , Presidency of McKinley, 127–28Google Scholar, 135–37, and “William McKinley and the Expansion of Presidential Power,” 12–14; West, Henry Litchfield, “The Growing Powers of the President,” Forum 31 (March 1901): 23–24.Google Scholar

75 Bryce, , American Commonwealth, 2:696–97.Google Scholar