Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-18T13:57:19.739Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Historiography of Crisis: Jordanes, Cassiodorus and Justinian in mid-sixth-century Constantinople*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 April 2017

Lieve van Hoof  and
Peter van Nuffelen
Lieve van Hoof*
Affiliation:
Ghent University
Peter van Nuffelen*
Affiliation:
Ghent University
*
[email protected]
[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article presents a new interpretation of the historiographical production of Jordanes by situating it in the political and social environment of Constantinople of the years 550–552. It argues that these years were a period of crisis in Justinian's reign and that this is reflected in the pessimistic view of Roman power and the critique of Justinian's military and religious policy we can see in Jordanes’ Romana. If this prevents us from understanding Jordanes as a mouthpiece of the court, he cannot be reduced to a mere reproducer of Cassiodorus either: while there is more evidence for a close interaction between Jordanes and Cassiodorus (in particular the use of the Historia Tripartita in the Romana) than usually adduced, this is balanced by Jordanes’ explicit attempts to keep his distance from the senator. If the latter can be explained by Jordanes’ much lower social and literary status and his Moesian rather than Italian origin, which made him only a marginal member of Cassiodorus’ circle in Constantinople, the agreement between both men is the result of a confluence of views caused by the turn of the Italian war in 540–550. Jordanes, then, appears as a unique voice in what must have been a polyphony of opinions in mid-sixth-century Constantinople.

Keywords

JordanesCassiodorusJustinianConstantinopleLate AntiquityGothshistoriographysocial networksThree Chapters controversyliterary patronage
Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Roman Studies , Volume 107 , November 2017 , pp. 275 - 300
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2017. Published by The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Research Council under the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007-2013) / ERC Grant Agreement n. 313153. We thank the journal's referees for their very helpful criticism, and Matthew O'Farrell for checking the English expression of the paper.

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Amici, A. 2005: ‘Cassiodoro a Costantinopoli: Da magister officiorum a religiosus vir’, Vetera Christianorum 42, 215–31Google Scholar
Amici, A. 2012: ‘Iordanes e la storia gotica’, Quaderni della rivista di bizantinistica 6, 179–230 Google Scholar
Amory, P. 1997: People and Identity in Ostrogothic Italy, 489–554, Cambridge CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anton, H. H. 1994: ‘Origo gentis – Volksgeschichte: zur Auseinandersetzung mit Walter Goffarts Werk “The Narrators of Barbarian History”’, in Scharer, A. and Scheibelreiter, G. (eds), Historiographie im frühen Mittelalter, Vienna, 262–307 Google Scholar
Baldini, A. 2007: ‘Tra historia augusta e storia romana di Q. Aurelio Memmio Simmaco’, in Brandt, H. and Bonamente, G. (eds), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Bambergense, Bari, 9–34 Google Scholar
Baldwin, B. 1984: ‘The purpose of the Getica’, Studies on Late Roman and Byzantine History, Literature and Language, 121–4Google Scholar
Barnish, S. J. B. 1984: ‘The genesis and completion of Cassiodorus’ Gothic History’, Latomus 43, 336–61Google Scholar
Barnish, S. J. B. 1988: ‘Transformation and survival in the western senatorial aristocracy, c. AD 400–700’, Papers of the British School at Rome 56, 120–55Google Scholar
Barnish, S. J. B. 1989: ‘The work of Cassiodorus after his conversion’, Latomus 48, 157–87Google Scholar
Barnish, S. J. B. 1990: ‘Maximian, Cassiodorus, Boethius, Theodahad: literature, philosophy and politics in Ostrogothic Italy’, Nottingham Medieval Studies 34, 16–32 Google Scholar
Barnish, S. J. B. 1992: Cassiodorus, Magnus Aurelius: Selected Variae of Magnus Aurelius Cassiodorus Senator, Liverpool CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beatrice, P. F. 2001: ‘De Rufin à Cassiodore. La réception des histoires ecclésiastiques grecques dans l'Occident latin’, in Pouderon, B. and Duval, Y.-M. (eds), L'Historiographie de l’Église des premiers siècles, Paris, 237–57Google Scholar
Bell, P. N. 2013: Social Conflict in the Age of Justinian: Its Nature, Management, and Mediation, Oxford CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bidez, J. 1908: La Tradition manuscrite de Sozomène et la Tripartite de Théodore le Lecteur, Leipzig Google Scholar
Bjornlie, M. S. 2013: Politics and Tradition between Rome, Ravenna and Constantinople: A Study of Cassiodorus and the Variae 527–554, Cambridge/New York Google Scholar
Blaudeau, P. 2010: ‘Libératus de Carthage ou l'historiographie comme service diaconal’, Augustinianum 50, 543–65Google Scholar
Blaudeau, P. 2013: ‘Un point de contact entre collectio Avellana et collectio Thessalonicensis? Autour du cas d'Abundantius de Démétrias’, Millennium 10, 1–12 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bradley, D. 1993: ‘“In altum laxare vela compulsus”: the Getica of Jordanes’, Hermes 121, 211–36Google Scholar
Brown, T. S. 1984: Gentlemen and Officers: Imperial Administration and Aristocratic Power in Byzantine Italy, A.D. 554–800, London Google Scholar
Buonomo, L. M. 1997: ‘Introduzione alla lettura delle opere di Giordano’, in Silvestre, M. L. and Squillante, M. (eds), Mutatio rerum: Letterature, filosofia, scienza tra tardo antico e altomedioevo, Naples, 115–69Google Scholar
Burns, T. S. 1984: A History of the Ostro-Goths, Bloomington Google Scholar
Callu, J.-P., Desbordes, O., and Bertrand, C. 1984–1985: ‘L'Histoire auguste et l'historiographie médiévale’, Revue d'histoire des textes 14–15, 97–130 Google Scholar
Cameron, Alan 2012: ‘Anician myths’, Journal of Roman Studies 102, 133–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cameron, Averil 1981: ‘Cassiodorus deflated’, Journal of Roman Studies 71, 183–6Google Scholar
Cameron, Averil 1985: Procopius and the Sixth Century, London Google Scholar
Carcione, F. 1989: Liberato: Breve storia della controversia nestoriana ed eutichiana, Anagni Google Scholar
Chazelle, C. 2007: ‘The Three Chapters controversy and the biblical diagrams of Cassiodorus's Codex Grandior and Institutions’, in Chazelle, C. and Cubitt, C. (eds), The Crisis of the Oikoumene: The Three Chapters and the Failed Quest for Unity in the Sixth-Century Mediterranean, Turnhout, 161–205 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Christensen, A. S. 2002: Cassiodorus, Jordanes and the History of the Goths: Studies in a Migration Myth, Copenhagen Google Scholar
Cipolla, C. 1893: ‘Ricerche intorno all'anonymus Valesianus II’, Bolletino dell'istituto storico italiano 13, 7–98 Google Scholar
Coumert, M. 2007: Origines des peuples. Les récits du Haut Moyen Age occidental (550–850), Paris Google Scholar
Cracco Ruggini, L. 1981: ‘Nobilità romana e potere nell'età di Boezio’, in Congresso internazionale di studi boeziani Pavia 5–8 ottobre 1980, Rome, 73–96 Google Scholar
Croke, B. 1983: ‘476: the manufacturing of a turning point’, Chiron 13, 81–119 Google Scholar
Croke, B. 1987: ‘Cassiodorus and the Getica of Jordane’, Classical Philology 82, 117–34Google Scholar
Croke, B. 2001: Count Marcellinus and his Chronicle, Oxford/New York Google Scholar
Croke, B. 2005a: ‘Jordanes and the immediate past’, Historia 54, 473–94Google Scholar
Croke, B. 2005b: ‘Procopius’ Secret History: rethinking the date’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 45, 405–31Google Scholar
Croke, B. 2005c: ‘Justinian's Constantinople’, in Maas, M. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to the Age of Justinian, Cambridge, 60–86 Google Scholar
dell'Osso, C. 2010: Cristo e Logos: Il calcedonismo del VI secolo in oriente, Rome Google Scholar
Doležal, S. 2014: ‘Who was Jordanes?’, Byzantion 84, 145–67Google Scholar
Ensslin, W. 1949: Des Symmachus Historia Romana als Quelle für Jordanes, Munich Google Scholar
Ensslin, W. 1956: ‘“Beweise der Romverbandheit in Theodorichs des Grosen Aussen- und Innenpolitik’, in I Goti in Occidente: Problemi. 29 marzo–5 aprile 1955, Spoleto, 509–36Google Scholar
Evans, J. A. S. 1996: ‘The dates of Procopius’ works: a recapitulation of the evidence’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 37, 301–13Google Scholar
Festy, M. 2003: ‘De l'epitome de Caesaribus à la chronique de Marcellin: l'histoire romaine de Symmaque le Jeune’, Historia 52, 251–5Google Scholar
Festy, M. 2014: ‘Autour de l’Historia romana de Symmaque le Jeune’, in Bertrand, C. and Chausson, F. (eds), Historiae Augustae Colloquium Nanceiense, Bari, 243–64Google Scholar
Galdi, G. 2013: Syntaktische Untersuchungen zu Jordanes: Beiträge zu den Romana , Hildesheim Google Scholar
Galonnier, A. 1996: ‘Anecdoton Holderi ou Ordo generis Cassiodororum: introduction, édition, traduction et commentaire’, Antiquité tardive 4, 299–312 Google Scholar
Giordano, O. 1973: Jordanes e la storiografia del VI secolo, Bari Google Scholar
Girotti, B. 2004: ‘Considerazioni a margine di Jordanes, Romana, 310–314’, Rivista di storia antica 34, 323–41Google Scholar
Giunta, F. 1952: Jordanes e la cultura dell'alto medioevo: Contributo allo studio del problema gotico, Milan Google Scholar
Giunta, F., and Grillone, A. 1991: Iordanis De origine actibusque Getarum, Rome Google Scholar
Goffart, W. 1988: The Narrators of Barbarian History (A.D. 550–800): Jordanes, Gregory of Tours, Bede and Paul the Deacon, Princeton Google Scholar
Greatrex, G. 1994: ‘The dates of Procopius’ works’, Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies 18, 101–14Google Scholar
Greatrex, G. 2003: ‘Recent work on Procopius and the composition of Wars VIII’, Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies 27, 45–67 Google Scholar
Greatrex, G. 2014: ‘Perceptions of Procopius in recent scholarship’, Histos 8, 76–121 Google Scholar
Greatrex, G., and Lieu, S. N. C. (eds) 2002: The Roman Eastern Frontier and the Persian Wars. Part 2: AD 363–630: A Narrative Sourcebook, London Google Scholar
Grillmeier, A., and Hainthaler, T. 1995: Christ in Christian Tradition. Volume 2: From the Council of Chalcedon (451) to Gregory the Great (590–604); Part 2: The Church of Constantinople in the Sixth Century, London Google Scholar
Gusso, M. 1995: ‘Contributi allo studio della composizione e delle fonti del Chronicon di Marcellinus Comes’, Studia et Documenta Historiae et Iuris 61, 557–622 Google Scholar
Hanslik, R. 1970: ‘Epiphanius Scholasticus oder Cassiodor? Zur historia ecclesiastica tripartita ’, Philologus 114, 107–13Google Scholar
Heather, P. 1991: Goths and Romans, 332–489, Oxford/New York Google Scholar
Jacob, W., and Hansli, R. 1952: Cassiodori-Epiphanii Historia ecclesiastica tripartita, Vienna Google Scholar
Jakobi, R. 2011: ‘Marcellinus Comes über das Ende im Westen des römischen Reiches: eine quellenkritische Petitesse’, Philologus 155, 394–6Google Scholar
Janson, T. 1964: Latin Prose Prefaces: Studies in Literary Conventions, Stockholm Google Scholar
Jones, A. H. M. 1964: The Later Roman Empire, 284–602: A Social Economic and Administrative Survey, Oxford Google Scholar
Kaldellis, A. 2004a: Procopius of Caesarea: Tyranny, History, and Philosophy at the End of Antiquity, Philadelphia Google Scholar
Kaldellis, A. 2004b: ‘Identifying dissent circles in sixth-century Byzantium: the friendship of Prokopios and Ioannes Lydos’, Florilegium 21, 1–17 Google Scholar
Kaldellis, A. 2009: ‘The date and structure of Prokopios’ Secret History and his projected work on Church history’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 49, 585–616 Google Scholar
Kelly, C. 2004: Ruling the Later Roman Empire, Cambridge, Mass. Google Scholar
Knaepen, A. 2001: ‘L'image du roi vandale Gélimer chez Procope de Césarée’, Byzantion 71, 383–403 Google Scholar
Krautschik, S. 1986: ‘Zwei Aspekte des Jahres 476’, Historia 35, 344–71Google Scholar
Kulikowski, M. 2007: Rome's Gothic Wars: From the Third Century to Alaric, New York Google Scholar
Lake, J. 2013: Prologues to Ancient and Medieval History: A Reader, Toronto Google Scholar
Leppin, H. 2011: Justinian: Das Christliche Experiment, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Liebeschuetz, J. H. W. G. 2011a: ‘Making a Gothic history: does the Getica of Jordanes preserve genuinely Gothic traditions?’, Journal of Late Antiquity 4, 185–216 Google Scholar
Liebeschuetz, J. H. W. G. 2011b: ‘Why did Jordanes write the Getica?’, Antiquité Tardive 19, 295–302 Google Scholar
Lorenzo Lorenzo, J. 1976: El valor de los preverbios en Jordanes, Salamanca Google Scholar
Luiselli, B. 1976: ‘Sul De summa temporum di Iordanes’, Romanobarbarica 1, 83–134 Google Scholar
Maas, M. 1992: John Lydus and the Roman Past: Antiquarianism and Politics in the Age of Justinian, London/New York Google Scholar
Mazza, M. 1986: ‘La historia tripartita di Flavio Magno Aurelio Cassiodoro Senatore: metodi e scopo’, in Leanza, S. (ed.), Flavio Magno Aurelio Cassiodoro, Catanzaro, 210–44Google Scholar
Meier, M. 2003: Das andere Zeitalter Justinians: Kontingenzerfahrung und Kontingenzbewältigung im 6. Jahrhundert n. Chr., Göttingen Google Scholar
Meier, M. 2010: ‘Das Breviarium des Liberatus von Karthago: einige Hypothesen zu seiner Intention’, Zeitschrift für antikes Christentum 14, 130–48Google Scholar
Merrills, A. H. 2005: History and Geography in Late Antiquity, Cambridge/New York Google Scholar
Möller, L. 2012: Jordanes, Die Gotengeschichte: Übersetzt, eingeleitet und erläutert, Wiesbaden Google Scholar
Momigliano, A. 1960a: ‘Cassiodorus and Italian culture of his time’, in Momigliano, A. (ed.), Secondo contributo alla storia degli studi classici, Rome, 191–229 Google Scholar
Momigliano, A. 1960b: ‘Gli Anicii e la storiografia Latina del VI sec. d.C.’, in Momigliano, A. (ed.), Secondo contributo alla storia degli studi classici, Rome, 231–53Google Scholar
Momigliano, A. 1975: ‘L'età del trapasso fra storiografia antica e storiografia medievale (320–550 d.C.)’, in Sesto contributo alla storia degli studi classici, Rome, 49–71 Google Scholar
Mommsen, T. 1882: Iordanis Romana et Getica, Berlin Google Scholar
Mommsen, T. 1894: Chronica minora. Saec. IV.V.VI.VII, Berlin Google Scholar
Moorhead, J. 1983: ‘The last years of Theoderic’, Historia 32, 106–20Google Scholar
Moorhead, J. 1984: ‘The Decii under Theoderic’, Historia 33, 107–15Google Scholar
Moorhead, J. 2015: The Popes and the Church of Rome in Late Antiquity, London/New York Google Scholar
O'Donnell, J. J. 1979: Cassiodorus, Berkeley Google Scholar
O'Donnell, J. J. 1982: ‘The aims of Jordanes’, Historia 31, 223–40Google Scholar
Parnell, D. A. 2015: ‘The social networks of Justinian's generals’, Journal of Late Antiquity 8, 114–35Google Scholar
Pazdernik, C. F. 2005: ‘Justininiac ideology and the power of the past’, in Maas, M. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to the Age of Justinian, Cambridge, 185–212 Google Scholar
Pazdernik, C. F. 2006: ‘Xenophon, Hellenica in Procopius’ Wars: Pharnabazus and Belisarius’, Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 46, 175–206 Google Scholar
Pfeilschifter, R. 2013: Der Kaiser und Konstantinopel: Kommunikation und Konfliktaustrag in einer spätantiken Metropole, Berlin Google Scholar
Price, R. 2009: The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553: With Related Texts on the Three Chapters Controversy 2 2, Liverpool Google Scholar
Reydellet, M. 1981: La Royauté dans la littérature latine, de Sidoine Apollinaire à Isidore de Séville, Paris Google Scholar
Robinson, P. 2004: ‘Dead Boethius: sixth-century accounts of a future martyr’, Viator 35, 1–22 Google Scholar
Sarantis, A. 2009: ‘War and diplomacy in Pannonia and the Northwest Balkans during the reign of Justinian: the Gepid threat and imperial responses’, Dumbarton Oaks Papers 63, 15–40 Google Scholar
Sarantis, A. 2016: Justinian's Balkan Wars: Campaigning, Diplomacy and Development in Illyricum, Thrace and the Northern World A.D. 527–65, ARCA: Classical Medieval Texts, Papers and Monographs 53, Prenton Google Scholar
Sarris, P. 2006: Economy and Society in the Age of Justinian, Cambridge Google Scholar
Schipke, R. 2013: Das Buch in der Spätantike: Herstellung, Form, Ausstattung und Verbreitung in der westlichen Reichshälfte des Imperium Romanum, Wiesbaden Google Scholar
Schirren, C. 1858: De ratione quae inter Iordanem et Cassiodorem intercedat commentatio, Dorpat Google Scholar
Schoene, A. 1900: Die Weltchronik des Eusebius in ihrer Bearbeitung durch Hieronymus, Berlin Google Scholar
Scholten, D. 2015: ‘Cassiodorus’ Historia Tripartita before the earlier extant manuscripts’, in Gantner, C., McKitterick, R. and Meeder, S. (eds), The Resources of the Past in Early Medieval Europe, Cambridge, 34–50 Google Scholar
Schwartz, E. 1939: Drei dogmatische Schriften Justinians, Munich Google Scholar
Schwartz, E. 1940: Vigiliusbrief: Zur Kirchenpolitik Iustinians, Munich Google Scholar
Schwartz, J. 1983: ‘Jordanès et l'Histoire Auguste’, in Bonner Historia Augusta Colloquium 1979–1981, Bonn, 275–84Google Scholar
Signes Codoñer, J. 2003a: ‘Kaiserkritik in Prokops Kriegsgeschichte’, in Brodka, D. (ed.), Freedom and its Limits in the Ancient World, Cracow, 215–29Google Scholar
Signes Codoñer, J. 2003b: ‘Prokops Anekdota und Justinians Nachfolge’, Jahrbuch der Oestenreichischen Byzantinistik 53, 47–82 Google Scholar
Silvestre, M. L. 1997: ‘Cassiodoro e l'uso politico della storia’, in Silvestre, M. L. and Squillante, M. (eds), Mutatio rerum: Letterature, filosofia, scienza tra tardo antico e altomedioevo, Naples, 81–114 Google Scholar
Sotinel, C. 1992: ‘Autorité pontificale et pouvoir impérial en Italie byzantine au temps de Justinien: le pape Vigile’, Mélanges de l'Ecole française de Rome: Antiquité 104, 439–63Google Scholar
Sotinel, C. 2005: Identité civique et christianisme: Aquilée du IIIe au VIe siècle, Rome Google Scholar
Sotinel, C. 2007: ‘The Three Chapters and the transformation of Italy’, in Chazelle, C. and Cubitt, C. (eds), The Crisis of the Oikoumene: The Three Chapters and the Failed Quest for Unity in the Sixth-Century Mediterranean, Turnhout, 85–120 Google Scholar
Stein, E. 1949: Histoire du Bas-Empire. Tome II: de la disparition de l'empire d'occident à la mort de Justinien (476–565), Paris Google Scholar
Swain, B. 2010: ‘Jordanes and Vergil: a case study of intertextuality in the Getica ’, The Classical Quarterly 60.1, 243 Google Scholar
Van Nuffelen, P. 2013: ‘Olympiodorus of Thebes and eastern triumphalism’, in Kelly, C. (ed.), Theodosius II and his Age, Cambridge, 130–52Google Scholar
Várady, L. 1976: ‘Jordanes-Studien: Jordanes und das Chronicon des Marcellinus Comes: die Selbständigkeit des Jordanes’, Chiron 6, 441–87Google Scholar
Vitiello, M. 2006: ‘Cassiodoriana: gli excerpta valesiana, l’aduentus e le laudes del principe Teoderico’, Chiron 36, 113–33Google Scholar
Vitiello, M. 2015: ‘Theodoric and the Italic kingdom in Cassiodorus’ Gothic history: a hypothesis of reconstruction’, Klio 98, 645–63Google Scholar
Wagner, N. 1967: Getica: Untersuchungen zum Leben des Jordanes und zur frühen Geschichte der Goten, Berlin Google Scholar
Weissensteiner, J. 1994: ‘Cassiodor/Jordanes als Geschichtsschreiber’, in Scharer, A. and Scheibelreiter, G. (eds), Historiographie im frühen Mittelalter, Vienna/Munich, 308–25Google Scholar
Wes, M. A. 1967: Das Ende des Kaisertums im Westen des römischen Reichs, Gravenhage. Google Scholar
Wolfram, H. 1980: Geschichte der Goten: von den Anfängen bis zur Mitte des 6. Jahrhunderts: Entwurf e. histor. Ethnographie, Munich Google Scholar
Wolfram, H. 1994: ‘Origo et religio: ethnic traditions and literature in early medieval texts’, Early Medieval Europe 3, 19–38 Google Scholar
Wood, P. 2011: ‘Being Roman in Procopius’ Vandal Wars’, Byzantion 81, 424–47Google Scholar
Zecchini, G. 1985: ‘Il 476 nella storiografia tardoantica’, Aevum 59, 3–23 Google Scholar
Zecchini, G. 1993: Ricerche di storiografia latina tardoantica, Rome Google Scholar
Zecchini, G. 2009: ‘Ende und Erbe der lateinisch-heidnischen Geschichtsschreibung’, in Goltz, A., Leppin, H., and Schlange-Schöningen, H. (eds), Jenseits der Grenzen, Berlin/New York, 91–105 Google Scholar