Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T05:43:51.507Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Re-presenting Genocide: The Canadian Museum of Human Rights and Settler Colonial Power

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 March 2016

Rita Kaur Dhamoon
Rita Kaur Dhamoon*
Affiliation:
University of Victoria
*
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Rita Kaur Dhamoon, PhD, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC, Canada. E-mail: [email protected]
Get access

Abstract

In settler societies like Canada, United States, and Australia, the bourgeoning discourse that frames colonial violence against Indigenous people as genocide has been controversial, specifically because there is much debate about the meaning and applicability of genocide. Through an analysis of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights, this paper analyzes what is revealed about settler colonialism in the nexus of difficult knowledge, curatorial decisions, and political debates about the label of genocide. I specifically examine competing definitions of genocide, the primacy of the Holocaust, the regulatory role of the settler state, and the limits of a human rights framework. My argument is that genocide debates related to Indigenous experiences operationalize a range of governing techniques that extend settler colonialism, even as Indigenous peoples confront existing hegemonies. These techniques include: interpretative denial; promoting an Oppression Olympics and a politics of distancing; regulating difference through state-based recognition and interference; and depoliticizing claims that overshadow continuing practices of assimilation, extermination, criminalization, containment, and forced movement of Indigenous peoples. By pinpointing these techniques, this paper seeks to build on Indigenous critiques of colonialism, challenge settler national narratives of peaceful and lawful origins, and foster ways to build more just relations between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples.

Keywords

settler colonialismgenocideCanadian Museum for Human RightspowerknowledgenationIndigenousIndigenous and non-Indigenous relations
Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics , Volume 1 , Issue 1 , March 2016 , pp. 5 - 30
Copyright
Copyright © The Race, Ethnicity, and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association 2016 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Alfred, Taiaiake. 2001. “Deconstructing the British Columbia Treaty Process.” Balayi: Culture, Law and Colonialism 3: 37–65.Google Scholar
Altamirano-Jimenez, Isabel. 2013. Indigenous Encounters with Neo-liberalism: Place, Women, and the Environment in Canada and Mexico. Vancouver: UBC Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Andersen, Chris. 2014. Metis: Race, Recognition, and the Struggle for Indigenous Peoplehood. Vancouver: UBC Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barta, Tony. 2008. “After the Holocaust: Consciousness of Genocide in Australia.” Australian Journal of Politics and History 31 (1): 154–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Basen, Ira. 2011. “Memory becomes a Minefield at Canada's Museum for Human Rights.” Globe & Mail. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/memory-becomes-a-minefield-at-canadas-museum-for-human-rights/article555660/?page=all (Accessed August 20, 2011).Google Scholar
Benvenuto, Jeff, Woolford, Andrew, and Hinton, Alexander Laban. 2014. “Introduction.” In Colonial Genocide in Indigenous North America, eds. Woolford, Andrew, Benvenuto, Jeff, and Hinton, Alexander Laban. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 1–25.Google Scholar
Bloxham, Donald. 2008. “Organized Mass Murder: Structure, Participation, and Motivation in Comparative Perspective.” Holocaust and Genocide Studies 22 (2): 203–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bonnel, Jennifer and Roger, Simon. 2007. “Difficult Exhibitions and Intimate Encounters.” Museum and Society 5 (2): 65–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
CAC. 2010. Content Advisory Committee Final Report to the CMHR. Winnipeg: Canadian Museum for Human Rights. http://www.humanrightsmuseum.ca/ Google Scholar
CBC. 2014. Shoal Lake 40 ‘Human Rights Violation Museum Highlights water problems. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/shoal-lake-40-human-rights-violations-museum-highlights-water-problems-1.2769067 Google Scholar
Charny, Israel W. 2001. “The Psychological Satisfaction of Denials of the Holocaust or Other Genocides by Non-Extremists or Bigots.” Idea: A Journal of Social Issues 6 (1).Google Scholar
Chrisjohn, Roland, and Young, Sherri. 1997. The Circle Game: Shadows and Substance in the Indian Residential School Experience in Canada. Penticton: B.C. Theytus Books.Google Scholar
Churchill, Ward. 1997. A Little Matter of Genocide: Holocaust and Denial in the Americas, 1942 to the Present. San Francisco: City Lights Books.Google Scholar
Clearsky, Chief Murray. 2013. “Canada Sanitizing First Nations Genocide.” Censored News. http://bsnorrell.blogspot.ca/2013/08/chief-clearsky-canada-sanitizing-first.html (Accessed August 1, 2013).Google Scholar
CMHR. 2012. “Annual Report 2011–12.” Canadian Museum for Human Rights. http://humanrights.ca/about-museum/corporate-governance/corporate-reports/annual-and-quarterly-financial-reports#.U8HDzOhX79A Google Scholar
CMHR. 2014a. “Mandate and Museum Experience.” Canadian Museum for Human Rights. http://humanrights.ca/about-museum/mandate-andmuseumexperience#.U7737uhX79A Google Scholar
CMHR. 2014b. “Indigenous Galleries.” Canadian Museum for Human Rights. https://humanrights.ca/exhibit/indigenous-perspectives Google Scholar
CMHR Annual Public Meeting. 2011, 2012. “Annual Public Meetings.” Canadian Museum for Human Rights. http://humanrights.ca/about-museum/corporate-governance/corporate-reports/annual-public-meetings Google Scholar
Corrado, R. R. 2014. “Policy Issues Regarding the Overrepresentation of Incarcerated Aboriginal Young Offenders in a Canadian Context.” Youth Justice 14 (1): 40–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crosby, Andrew, and Jeffrey, Monaghan. 2012. “Settler Governmentality in Canada and the Algonquin.” Security Dialogue 43 (5): 421–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coulthard, Glen. 2014. Red Skins, White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition. Minneapolis, MI: University of Minnesota Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fontaine, Phil, Dan, Michael, and Farber, Bernie M.. 2013. “A Canadian Genocide in Search of a Name.” Toronto Star. http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2013/07/19/a_canadian_genocide_in_search_of_a_name.html# Google Scholar
Foucault, Michel. 1980. Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1979, Edited by Gordon, Colin. New York and London: Random House.Google Scholar
Friends of the CMHR. 2014. “Our Donors,” http://friendsofcmhr.com/category/our-donors/ Google Scholar
Hankivsky, Olena, and Dhamoon, Rita Kaur. 2013. “Which Genocide Matters the Most? An Intersectionality Analysis of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 46 (4): 899–920.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hinton, Alexander. 2012. “Critical Genocide Studies.” Genocide Studies & Prevention 7 (1): 4–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hinton, Alexander Laban, and Thomas, La Pointe, and Douglas, Irvin-Erickson, eds. 2013. Hidden Genocides: Power, Knowledge, Memory. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Hubbard, Tasha. 2014. “Buffalo Genocide in 19th Century North America: ‘Kill, Skin, Sell’.” In Colonial Genocide in Indigenous North America, eds. Woolford, Andrew, Benvenuto, Jeff, and Hinton, Alexander Laban. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 292–305.Google Scholar
Huttenbach, H. R. 1988. “Locating the Holocaust on the Genocide Spectrum: Towards a Methodology of Definition and Categorization.” Holocaust and Genocide Studies 3 (3): 389–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacobs, Beverley, and Williams, A.. 2008. “Legacy of Residential Schools: Missing & Murdered Aboriginal Women.” In From Truth to Reconciliation: Transforming the Legacy of Residential Schools, eds. Castellano, Marlene. B., Archibald, Linda and DeGagne, Mike. Ottawa: Aboriginal Healing Foundation, 119–40.Google Scholar
Jacobs, Margaret D. 2014. “The Habit of Elimination: Indigenous Child Removal in Settler Colonial Nations.” In Colonial Genocide in Indigenous North America, eds. Woolford, Andrew, Benvenuto, Jeff, and Hinton, Alexander Laban. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 189–207.Google Scholar
Joseph, Robert Andrew. 2008. “A Jade Door: Reconciliatory Justice as a Way Forward Citing New Zealand Experience.” In From Truth to Reconciliation: Transforming the Legacy of Residential Schools, eds. Castellano, M. B., Archibald, Linda, and DeGagne, Mike. Ottawa: Aboriginal Healing Foundation, 205–31.Google Scholar
Krebbs, Mike. 2013. Roundtable on “Rioting the Right: Examining the Mobilizations of White Settler Colonialisms.” Critical Ethnic Studies Conference, Illinois, 19 September.Google Scholar
Kulchyski, Peter. 2013. Aboriginal Rights are not Human Rights: In Defence of Indigenous Struggles. Manitoba: ARP Books.Google Scholar
Lawrence, Bonita. 2002. “Rewriting Histories of the Land: Colonization and Indigenous Resistance in Eastern Canada.” In Race, Space, and the Law: Unmapping a White Settler Society, eds. Razack, Sherene. Toronto: Between the Lines, 21–46.Google Scholar
Lehrer, Erica, and Milton, Cynthia E.. 2011. “Introduction: Witnesses to Witnessing.” In Curating Difficult Knowledge: Violent Pasts in Public Places, eds. Lehrer, Erica, Milton, Cynthia E., and Patterson, Monica Eileen. Houndmills, UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lehrer, Erica, Milton, Cynthia E., and Patterson, Monica Eileen. 2011. Curating Difficult Knowledge: Violent Pasts in Public Places. Houndmills, UK Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacDonald, David. B. 2003. “Daring to Compare: The Debate about a Maori ‘Holocaust’ in New Zealand.” Journal of Genocide Research 5 (3): 383–403.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacDonald, David B., and Graham, Hudson. 2013. “The Genocide Question and Indian Residential Schools in Canada.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 45 (2): 427–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mako, Shamiran. 2012. “Cultural Genocide and Key International Instruments: Framing the Indigenous Experience.” International Journal of Minority & Group Rights 19: 175–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meister, Robert. 2010. After Evil: A Politics of Human Rights. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Miller, J. R. 1996. Shingwauk's Vision: A History of Native Residential Schools. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
Moses, A. Dirk (ed). 2004. Genocide and Settler Society: Frontier and Stolen Indigenous Children in Australian History. New York: Berghahn Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moses, A. Dirk. 2011. “Revisiting a Founding Assumption of Genocide Studies.” Genocide Studies and Prevention 6 (3): 287–300.Google Scholar
Moses, A. Dirk. 2012. “The Canadian Museum for Human Rights: the ‘Uniqueness of the Holocaust’ and the Question of Genocide.” Journal of Genocide Research 14 (2): 215–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moses, A. Dirk. 2013a. “Does the Holocaust Reveal or Conceal Other Genocides?: The Canadian Museum for Human Rights and Grievable Suffering.” In Hidden Genocides: Power, Knowledge, Memory, eds. Hinton, Alexander Laban, La Pointe, Thomas, and Irvin-Erickson, Douglas. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 21–51.Google Scholar
Moses, A. Dirk. 2013b. “Genocide.” Australian Humanities Review 55: 23–44.Google Scholar
Moshman, David. 2007. “Us and Them: Identity and Genocide.” Identity: An International Journal of Theory and Research 7 (2): 115–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murdocca, Carmela. 2010. “There is Something in that Water: Race, Nationalism, and Legal Violence.” Law & Social Inquiry 35 (2): 369–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murray, Stuart. 2013. “Use of ‘Genocide’ in Relation to Treatment of Indigenous Peoples in Canada.” CMHR. http://museumforhumanrights.ca/about-museum/news/statement-president-and-ceo-use-genocide-relation-treatment-indigenous-peoples#.U8GryehX79B (Accessed July 26, 2013)Google Scholar
Neu, Dean, and Richard, Therrien. 2003. Accounting for Genocide: Canada's Bureaucratic Assault on Aboriginal People. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.Google Scholar
Owusu-Bempah, Akwasi, Steve Kanters, Eric Druyts, Kabirraaj Toor, Katherine A. Muldoon, Farquhar, John W., and Mills, Edward. 2014. “Years of Life Lost to Incarceration: Inequities Between Aboriginal and Non-Aboriginal Canadians.” BMC Public Health 14: 585.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Paul, Alexandra. 2013. “Donations won't sway content, says CMHR: Can't buy ‘genocide’ label, chiefs told.” Winnipeg Free Press. http://www.firstperspective.ca/index.php/news/1157-donations-won-t-sway-content-cmhr-declares#!/ccomment Google Scholar
Pitt, Alice, and Britzman, Deborah. 2003. “Speculations on Qualities of Difficult Knowledge in Teaching and Learning: An Experiment in Psychoanalytic Research.” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 16 (6): 755–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Radia, Andy. 2013. “New Museum Slammed for Not Using the Term ‘Genocide’ to Describe Aboriginal Relations Exhibit.” Yahoo News. https://ca.news.yahoo.com/blogs/canada-politics/museum-slammed-not-using-term-genocide-describe-aboriginal-210802328.html Google Scholar
Razack, Sherene. 2012. “Memorializing Colonial Power: The Death of Frank Paul.” Law and Social Inquiry 37 (4): 908–32.Google Scholar
Rifkin, Mark. 2013. “Settler Common Sense.” Settler Colonial Studies 3 (3–4): 322–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Samson, Colin. 2014. “Dispossession and Canadian Land Claims.” In Colonial Genocide in Indigenous North America, eds. Woolford, Andrew, Benvenuto, Jeff, and Hinton, Alexander Laban. Durham and London: Duke University Press, 246–70.Google Scholar
Short, Damien. 2010. “Australia: A Continuing Genocide?” Journal of Genocide Research 12 (1–2): 45–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simon, Roger I. 2011. “A Shock to Thought: Curatorial Judgment and the Public Exhibition of ‘Difficult Knowledge.” Memory Studies 4 (4): 432–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stannard, D. E. 1998. “Uniqueness as Denial: the Politics of Genocide Scholarship.” In Is the Holocaust Unique? Perspectives on Comparative Genocide, eds. Rosenbaum, A. S.. Boulder, CO: Westview, 248–61.Google Scholar
Stote, Karen. 2012. “The Coercive Sterilization of Aboriginal Women in Canada.” American Indian Culture and Research Journal 36 (3): 117–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tatz, Colin. 1999. “Genocide in Australia.” Journal of Genocide Research 1 (3): 315–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
TRC. 2015. Honouring the Truth, Reconciling for the Future: Summary of the Final Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. Winnipeg: Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada.Google Scholar
UCC. 2008. “Holodomor Recognized as Genocide by Canadian Parliament.” Ukrainian Canadian Congress. http://www.holodomorsurvivors.ca/Canadian%20Recognize/Holodomor%20recognized%20as%20genocide%20by%20Canadian%20Parliament.html Google Scholar
Watson, Irene. 2011. “The 2007 Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Indigenous Survival – Where to From Here?.” Griffith Law Review 20 (3): 507–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welch, Mary Agnes. 2013. “CMHR Rejects ‘Genocide’ for Native Policies: Staff Decides Against Using Word in Exhibits.” Winnipeg Free Press. http://www.firstperspective.ca/index.php/news/1096-cmhr-rejects-genocide-for-native-policies.Google Scholar
Welch, Mary Agnes. 2014. “Tories Seek Museum Content: Want List of All Exhibits that Refer to Federal Government,” Winnipeg Free Press. http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/tories-seek-museum-content-275245431.html Google Scholar
Wolfe, Patrick. 2006. “Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native.” Journal of Genocide Research 8 (4): 387–409.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Woolford, Andrew. 2009. “Ontological Destruction: Genocide and Canadian Aboriginal Peoples.” Genocide Studies and Prevention 4 (1): 81–97.Google Scholar