Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T07:28:35.011Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Recycled rhetoric: examining continuities in political rhetoric as a resilience strategy in pre-independence and post-genocide Rwanda

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 June 2021

Meghan C. Laws
Meghan C. Laws*
Affiliation:
School of International Relations, University of St Andrews, Scotland, UK
*
Email: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Seen as one of Africa's most visionary and enlightened autocrats, Paul Kagame's presidency is often contrasted with the violence and ethnocentrism of his discredited predecessors. Drawing on rarely analysed primary sources, this article disputes this simplified narrative by revealing striking continuities in the ruling elite's rhetorical repertoire in the late colonial period (1956–1959) and present-day Rwanda. Both then and now, rhetorical calls to remove ethnic labels from public discourse in the name of national unity are key resilience strategies designed to shape regime relations with domestic and international audiences in ways that reinforce power concentration by a small (largely Tutsi) elite. Changes in the distribution of power and the scale of anti-Tutsi violence (most notably in 1994) help explain why a similar rhetorical strategy failed to prevent the dismantling of the Tutsi oligarchy in 1961 while strengthening its contemporary counterpart.

Keywords

Rwandapolitical rhetoricauthoritarian resilienceethnic controlcomparative historical analysis
Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 59 , Issue 2 , June 2021 , pp. 175 - 195
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

The author is deeply indebted to Marie-Eve Desrosiers whose guidance, conversation and encouragement made this article possible. The author would also like to thank Aidan Russell, John McGarry and the two anonymous reviewers at JMAS for their constructive feedback and critique. This research was funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC).

References

REFERENCES

Azeda, H. 2014. ‘Kwibuka 20 – shadows of memory’, 11.4.2014 [Video File]. <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2ioiQ6brfk>, accessed 12.9.2019.,+accessed+12.9.2019.>Google Scholar
Baldwin, G. 2019. ‘Constructing identity through commemoration: Kwibuka and the rise of survivor nationalism in post-conflict Rwanda’, Journal of Modern African Studies 57, 3: 355–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, J. 2007. Why the French Don't Like Headscarves: Islam, the state and public space. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Breed, A. 2013/2014. ‘Resistance acts in post-genocide Rwanda’, Kritika Kultura 21/22: 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carney, J.J. 2014. Rwanda Before the Genocide: Catholic politics and ethnic discourse in the late colonial era. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Chrétien, J.P. 2006. The Great Lakes of Africa: two thousand years of history. Translated by Straus, S.. New York, NY: Zone Books.Google Scholar
Conroy, J. 2014. (Director and Producer). ‘Rwanda's Untold Story’. BBC Documentary. <https://vimeo.com/107867605>, accessed 5.7.2020., accessed 5.7.2020.' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Conroy,+J.+2014.+(Director+and+Producer).+‘Rwanda's+Untold+Story’.+BBC+Documentary.+,+accessed+5.7.2020.>Google Scholar
Crisafulli, P. & Redmond, A.. 2012. Rwanda Inc.: how a devastated nation became an economic model for the developing world. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Dawisha, A. 1999. ‘“Identity” and political survival in Saddam's Iraq’, Middle East Journal 53, 4: 553–67.Google Scholar
Desrosiers, M. 2014. ‘Rethinking political rhetoric and authority during Rwanda's first and second republics’, Journal of the International African Institute 84, 2: 199–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Desrosiers, M. & Thomson, S.. 2011. ‘Rhetorical legacies of leadership: projections of ‘benevolent leadership’ in pre- and post-genocide Rwanda’, Journal of Modern African Studies 49, 3: 429–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dunn, K. 2003. Imagining the Congo: the international relations of identity. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Findley, C.V. 2010. Turkey, Islam, Nationalism and Modernity. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Firro, K.M. 2012. ‘Nationalism and confessionalism: Shiʿis, Druzes and Alawis in Syria and Lebanon’, in Roald, A.S. & Longva, A.N., eds. Religious Minorities in the Middle East: domination, self-empowerment, accommodation. Leiden: Brill.Google Scholar
Fox, J. 2013. ‘Why President Kagame Runs Rwanda Like a Business.’ International Business. <https://hbr.org/2013/04/why-president-kagame-runs-rwanda> accessed 7.5.2021.+accessed+7.5.2021.>Google Scholar
Freedom House. 2019. ‘Freedom in the world: Rwanda, 2019.’ <https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/2019/rwanda>, accessed 8 July 2019.,+accessed+8+July+2019.>Google Scholar
Grant, A. 2015. ‘Quiet insecurity and quiet agency in post-genocide Rwanda’, Ethnofor, Security 24, 2: 15–36.Google Scholar
Hughes, C. 1997. Taiwan and Chinese Nationalism: national identity and status in international society. New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Jessee, E. 2017. Negotiating Genocide in Rwanda: the politics of history. London: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, W. 2012. ‘Beyond Pyongyang and Singapore: the Rwandan state, its rules and the military’, in Campioni, M. & Noack, P., eds. Rwanda Fast Forward: social, economic, military and reconciliation prospects. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Jourde, C. 2005. “The president is coming to visit!’: dramas and the hijack of democratization in the Islamic Republic of Mauritania’, Comparative Politics 37, 4: 421–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lemarchand, R. 1970. Rwanda and Burundi. New York, NY: Praeger Publishers.Google Scholar
Lemarchand, R. 1994. Burundi: ethnocide as discourse and practice. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Centre Press.Google Scholar
Lemarchand, R. 2009. The Dynamics of Violence in Central Africa. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Linden, I. & Linden, J.. 1977. Church and Revolution in Rwanda. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Longman, T. 2017. Memory and Justice in Post-Genocide Rwanda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lustick, I. 1980. Arabs in the Jewish State: Israel's control of a national minority. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Mamdani, M. 2001. When Victims become Killers: colonialism, nativism and the genocide in Rwanda. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Mann, L. & Berry, M.. 2015. ‘Understanding the political motivations that shape Rwanda's emergent developmental state’, New Political Economy 21, 1: 119–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mayersen, D. 2014. On the Path to Genocide: Armenia and Rwanda Reexamined. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
McGarry, J. 2010. ‘Ethnic domination in democracies’, in Weller, M. & Nobbs, K., eds. Political Participation of Minorities: a commentary on international standards and practice. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Mwambari, D. 2019. ‘Music and the politics of the past: Kizito Mihigo and music in the commemoration of the genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda’, Memory Studies. <https://doi.org/10.1177/1750698018823233>, accessed 10.5.2021.CrossRef,+accessed+10.5.2021.>Google Scholar
Newbury, C. 1998. ‘Ethnicity and the politics of history in Rwanda’, Africa Today 45, 1: 7–24.Google Scholar
Newbury, C. & Newbury, D.. 2000. ‘Bringing the peasants back in: agrarian themes in the construction and corrosion of statist historiography in Rwanda’, American Historical Review 105, 3: 832–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ntirenganya, E. 2021. ‘New bill proposes comprehensive reforms to Itorero.’ The New Times, 1.4.2021.Google Scholar
Nyirubugara, O. 2013. Complexities and Dangers of Remembering and Forgetting in Rwanda. Leiden: Sidestone Press.Google Scholar
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR). 2010. ‘Democratic Republic of the Congo, 1993–2003: report of the mapping exercise documenting the most serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law committed within the territory of the Democratic Republic of the Congo between March 1993 and June 2003.’ Geneva.Google Scholar
Pearson, J.L. 2017. ‘Defending empire at the United Nations: the politics of international colonial oversight in the era of decolonisation’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History 43, 3: 525–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Perraudin, A. 2003. Un évêque au Rwanda. Saint Maurice: St. Augustine.Google Scholar
Pottier, J. 2002. Re-imagining Rwanda: conflict, survival and disinformation in the late twentieth century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Prunier, G. 1995. The Rwanda Crisis: history of a genocide. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Reed, C.W. 1996. ‘Exile, reform, and the rise of the Rwandan Patriotic Front’, Journal of Modern African Studies 34, 4: 479–501.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reyntjens, F. 1985. Pouvoir et droit au Rwanda: droit public et evolution politique, 1916–1973. Tervuren: Musée Royal de L'Afrique Centrale.Google Scholar
Reyntjens, F. 2013. Political Governance in Post-genocide Rwanda. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reyntjens, F. 2015. ‘Rwanda: progress or power keg’, Journal of Democracy 26, 3: 19–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Soudan, F. 2015. Kagame: the president of Rwanda speaks. New York, NY: Enigma Books.Google Scholar
Straus, S. 2006. The Order of Genocide: race, power and war in Rwanda. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Straus, S. & Waldorf, L., eds. 2011. Remaking Rwanda: state building and human rights after mass violence. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Sundberg, M. 2016. Training for Model Citizenship: an ethnography of state-making and civic education in Rwanda. London: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thomson, S. 2013. Whispering Truth to Power: everyday resistance to reconciliation in post-genocide Rwanda. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin.Google Scholar
Vandeginste, S. & Huyse, L.. 2005. ‘Consociational democracy for Rwanda?’, in Marysse, S. & Reyntjens, F., eds. The Political Economy of the Great Lakes Region in Africa: the pitfalls of enforced democracy and globalization. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Vansina, J. 2004. Antecedents to Modern Rwanda: the Nyiginya kingdom. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin.Google Scholar
Wagoner, F.E. 1968. ‘Nation-building in Africa: a description and analysis of the development of Rwanda.’ PhD Dissertation, The American University.Google Scholar
Waldorf, L. 2006. ‘Mass justice for mass atrocity: rethinking local justice as transitional justice’, Temple Law Review, 79: 1–87.Google Scholar
Waugh, C.M. 2004. Paul Kagame and Rwanda: power, genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front. Jefferson, NC: McFarland and Co.Google Scholar
Wedeen, L. 1998. ‘Acting ‘As If’: symbolic politics and social control in Syria’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 40, 3: 503–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wedeen, L. 2015. [1999]. Ambiguities of Domination: politics, rhetoric, and symbols in contemporary Syria. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yiftachel, O. 2006. Ethnocracy: land and identity politics in Israel/Palestine. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
Zisser, E. 2006. ‘Who's afraid of Syrian nationalism? National and state identity in Syria’, Middle Eastern Studies 42, 2: 179–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zorbas, E. 2004. ‘Reconciliation in post-genocide Rwanda’, African Journal of Legal Studies 1, 1: 29–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zürcher, E.J. 2004. Turkey: a modern history. New York, NY: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar

Speeches and policy reports

Government of Rwanda (GoR). 1999. ‘The unity of Rwandans: before the colonial period and under colonial rule and under the First Republic.’ Kigali: Office of the President of the Republic.Google Scholar
Kagame, P. 6.9.2010. ‘Inauguration address.’ Kigali.Google Scholar
Kagame, P. 14.2.2011. ‘State of the nation address.’ Kigali.Google Scholar
Kagame, P. 4.7.2014. ‘Address to Kwibohoro 20 – celebration of the 20th anniversary of Rwanda's Liberation Day.’ Kigali.Google Scholar
Kagame, P. 18.8.2017. ‘Inauguration address.’ Kigali.Google Scholar
Organic Law N 47/01. 18.12.2001. ‘Instituting punishment for offences of discrimination and sectarianism.’Google Scholar
Organic Law N 18/08. 23.7.2008. ‘Relating to the punishment of the crime of genocide ideology.’Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2000. ‘Rwanda Vision 2020.’ Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2003. ‘The Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda.’ Adopted 26 May.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2008. ‘Policy on Cultural Heritage.’ Ministry of Sports and Culture.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2015. ‘Itorero’. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation. <http://www.rwandandiaspora.gov.rw/programs/itorero/>, accessed 2.2.2020.,+accessed+2.2.2020.>Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2011. ‘National Itorero Commission (Strategy).’ Ministry of Education.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2012. ‘National Decentralization Policy.’ Ministry of Local Government.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2013. ‘Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy II, 2013–2018.’ Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2013. ‘Strategic plan (2013–2017) of National Itorero Commission: final report.’ National Itorero Commission.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2015. ‘National Cultural Heritage Policy.’ Ministry of Sport and Culture.Google Scholar
Republic of Rwanda (RoR). 2018. ‘Itorero’. Rwanda Governance Board. <http://rgb.rw/home-grown-solutions/rwandas-hgs-good-practices/itorero/>, accessed 4.15.2020.,+accessed+4.15.2020.>Google Scholar

Archival sources

Conseil Supérieur du Pays. 13.08.1956. ‘Huitième session du Conseil Supérieur.’ Transcripts. Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Conseil Supérieur du Pays. 18–21.12.1956. ‘Neuvième session du Conseil Supérieur.’ Transcripts. Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Conseil Supérieur du pays. 1957. ‘Le mise au point.’ Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
‘Comité de l’étude de l'aspect social Muhutu-Mututsi.’ 31.03–3.04.1958. Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Comité de Parti Nationale UNAR. 13.09.1959. ‘Manifeste du parti politique ‘abashyirahamwe b'urwanda [Union Nationale Rwandaise–UNAR].’Google Scholar
Comité de Parti Nationale PARMEHUTU. 19.10.1959. ‘Manifeste-programme du PARMEHUTU.’Google Scholar
‘Déclaration du Mwami Mutara au pays.’ 2.9.1956. Temps Nouveaux d'Afrique.Google Scholar
‘Déclaration des chefs du Ruanda.’ 7.10.1956. Temps Nouveaux d'Afrique.Google Scholar
‘Deuxième séance de l’étude de l'aspect social muhutu-mututsi.’ 10–12.04.1958. Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Gitera, J.H., Kaibanda, G., Niyonzima, M., Ndahayo, C., Nzeyimana, I., Mulindaha, C., Sentama, G., Munyambonera, S. & J. Sibomana. 1957. ‘Note sur l'aspect social du problème racial indigène au Ruanda.’ (Bahutu Manifesto). Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Harroy, J-P. 30.5.1956. ‘Lettre au Monsieur le Conseiller du Mwami du Ruanda à Nyanza,’ 211/4822/2.326. Usumbura. Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
‘Le dernier Conseil Supérieur du Ruanda: Lamentables débats.’ 6.7.1958. Temps Nouveaux d'Afrique.Google Scholar
‘Les vingt-cinq ans de règne du Mwami du Ruanda.’ 7.7.1957. Temps Nouveaux d'Afrique.Google Scholar
Ministre des Colonies. ‘Rapport de l'administration belge au Congo et au Ruanda- Urundi 1922–1961.’ Brussels: African Archives.Google Scholar
Ndazaro, L. 13.9.1959. ‘Première réunion du Parti de l'Union Nationale Ruandaise.’ Kigali.Google Scholar
United Nations (UN). 1957. ‘Report of the United Nations visiting mission to trust territories in East Africa, 1957, on Ruanda–Urundi, T/1346.’ New York, NY: UN.Google Scholar
United Nations (UN) 13.12.1946. ‘Ruanda-Urundi: text of trusteeship agreement as approved by the General Assembly of the United Nations, TS0064.’ New York, NY: UN.Google Scholar