Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T15:08:53.548Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Janus or Sisyphus? The Southern Problem of the Sudan

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2008

Alexis Heraclides
Alexis Heraclides
Affiliation:
Research Fellow in the Department of International Relations, Mediterranean Studies Foundation, Athens.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The Sudan, Africa's largest country, not much smaller than Western Europe, is caught up once more in the convulsions of a civil war pitting the Northern against the Southern Sudanese. Inevitably the present conflict is associated with the older civil war which began in the early 1960s and dragged on for ten years, claiming the lives of around one million, and bringing about a famine and devastation little known to the outside world. There are obvious communalities, but the contemporary struggle is hardly a replay of that smouldering little war that had been fought by the Southern Sudanese with the most meagre of means and but a trifle of external aid. I shall deal in some length with what can now be called the first Sudanese civil war, in order to provide the background for an understanding of the real issues at stake today, and to place this second Sudanese civil war in perspective. More generally, the ‘Southern Problem’ provides insights into communal conflicts and their international dimensions, important though overlooked and often unacknowledged problems of today's world.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 25 , Issue 2 , June 1987 , pp. 213 - 231
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1987

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Groom, A. J. R. and Heraclides, Alexis, ‘Integration and Disintegration’, in Light, Margot and Groom, (eds.), International Relations: a handbook of current theory (London, 1985), pp. 174–93.Google Scholar

2 Interviews with Alier, Abel, ‘Nine Years an Evolving Miracle’, in Sudanow (Khartoum), 03 1981, pp. 12–14,Google Scholar and Joseph Lagu, ‘Changing Times’, in ibid. April 1981, pp. 16–20.

1 Heraclides, Alexis, ‘From Autonomy to Secession: building-down’, in Groom, A. J. R. and Taylor, Paul (eds.), Frameworks for International Cooperation (London, forthcoming).Google Scholar

2 Mayall, James, ‘African Unity and the OAU: the place of political myth in African diplomacy’, in Year Book of World Affairs (London, 1973), pp. 128–33Google Scholar, and ‘Self-Determination and the OAU’, in Lewis, I. M. (ed.), Nationalism and Self-Determination in the Horn of Africa (London, 1983), pp. 77–92.Google Scholar For a critique of the dominant African view, see in particular: Kamanu, Onyeonoro S., ‘Secession and the Right of Self-Determination: an O.A.U. dilemma’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies (Cambridge), 12, 3, 09 1974, pp. 355–76;Google Scholar and Benyamin Neuberger, ‘The African Concept of Balkanisation’, in Ibid. 14, 3, September 1976, pp. 523–9. For a more general discussion of secession and international law, see Buchheit, Lee C., Secession: the legitimacy of self-determination (New Haven, 1978).Google Scholar

3 Howell, John, ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Reading, 1978, pp. 80–2 and 256–7.Google Scholar

1 Sayed Sir El Khatim Khalifa, ‘Inaugural Address to the Round Table Conference’, Khartoum, March 1965; Shepherd, George W. Jr, ‘National Integration and the Southern Sudan’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies, 4, 2, 06 1966, p. 194;CrossRefGoogle ScholarLoiria, Angelo Lobale Lokoro, ‘Political Awakening in Southern Sudan, 1946–1955: decoloization and the problem of national integration’, Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles, 1969, pp. 1–128 and 382;Google Scholar editorial in Grass Curtain (London), 1, 1, 1970, p. 3; Muddathir, 'Abd Al-Rahim ‘Arabism, Africanism, and Self-Identification in the Sudan’ in The Journal of Modern African Studies, 8, 2, 06 1970, p. 233;Google ScholarMazrui, Ali A., ‘The Multiple Marginality of the Sudan’ in Hasan, Yusuf Fadl (ed.), Sudan in Africa (Khartoum, 1971), p. 240–55;Google ScholarBeshir, Mohamed Omer, Diversity, Regionalism and National Unity (Uppsala, 1977), p. 35;Google Scholar and Wai, Dunstan M., ‘Revolution, Rhetoric, and Reality in the Sudan’, in The Journal of Modern A frican Studies, 17, 1, 03 1979, p. 72.Google Scholar

2 Aguda, Oluwadare, ‘Arabism and Pan-Arabism in Sudanese Politics’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies, II, 2, 06 1973, p. 177.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

3 Sanderson, Lilian Passmore, ‘Education in the Southern Sudan’, in African Affairs (London), 79, 315, 04 1980, p. 161.Google Scholar

1 ‘Proceedings of the Juba Conference on the Political Development of the Southern Sudan, June 1947’, appendix in Dunstan, M. Wai (ed.), The Southern Sudan: the problem of national integration (London, 1973), p. 190.Google Scholar

2 Shepherd, loc. cit. pp. 196–8; Beshir, Mohamed Omer, The Southern Sudan: background to conflict (London, 1968), pp. 67–71;Google ScholarAlbino, Oliver, The Sudan: a southern viewpoint (London, 1970), pp. 9–77Google Scholar, and Arnold Toynbee, ‘Forward’, in Ibid. pp. vii–ix; Gray, Richard, ‘The Southern Sudan’, in Journal of Contemporary History (London), 6, 1, 1971, pp. 108–19;CrossRefGoogle ScholarReinton, Per Olav, ‘Imperialism and the Southern Sudan’, in Journal of Peace Research (Oslo), 8, 1971, pp. 239–46;Google ScholarRussell, Peter and McCall, Storrs, ‘Can Secession be Justified? The Case of the Southern Sudan’, in Wai, (ed.), op. cit. pp. 163–8 and 175,Google Scholar and appendix in Ibid. pp. 175–83; Howell, John, ‘Politics in the Southern Sudan’, in African Affairs, 72, 287, 04 1973, pp. 163–9,CrossRefGoogle Scholar and ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 32 and 183–4; Ladouceur, Paul, ‘The Southern Sudan: a forgotten war and a forgotten peace’, in International Journal (Toronto), 30, Summer 1975, pp. 407–8;Google ScholarBadal, R. K., ‘The Rise and Fall of Separatism in Southern Sudan’, in African Affairs, 75, 301, 1976, pp. 463–73;CrossRefGoogle ScholarCollins, Robert O., Shadows in the Grass: Britain in the Southern Sudan, 1918–1956 (New Haven, 1983);Google Scholar and McClintock, D. W., ‘The Southern Sudan Problem’, in The Middle East Journal (Washington, D.C.), 24, Autumn 1970, p. 476.Google Scholar

3 See Hechter, Michael, Internal Colonialism (London, 1975), especially pp. 9 and 39–43 for an explanation of the relevant concept.Google Scholar

1 ‘Report of the Commission of Inquiry. Southern Sudan Disturbances, 4 August 1955’, quoted by Wai, op. cit. p. 58.

2 Abd Al-Rahim, loc. cit. p. 243.

3 Aguda, loc. cit. p. 188.

4 Wai, ‘Revolution, Rhetoric, and Reality in the Sudan’, pp. 73–4.

5 Gray, loc. cit. p. 117.

6 Peter Woodward, ‘Analysing Sudan's Nationalist Movements’, Institute of Commonwealth Studies, London, Seminar paper AP/80/3, 1980–1981, p. 2.

1 See, for example, Morrison, Godfrey, Eritrea and the Southern Sudan (London, 1976),Google Scholar Minority Rights Group Report, No. 5, pp. 16–17; Wai, Dunstan M., The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan (New York, 1981), passim,Google Scholar and ‘Political Trends in the Sudan and the Future of the South’, in Wai, (ed.), op. cit. pp. 147–8;Google Scholar and Wol, Lawrence Wol, ‘Réflexions sur la conscience nationale au sud-Soudan’, Ph.D. dissertation, Université de Bordeaux III, 1971, pt. 2.Google Scholar

2 I wish to thank Peter Kilner for insights into the Sudan's first civil war.

1 Letter from Deng, William to Thant, U., in Sudan Daily (Khartoum), 24 12 1962;Google Scholar ‘SACDNU Petition to the UN’, 1963, pp. 1 and 25; Oduho, Joseph and Deng, William, The Problem of the Southern Sudan (London, 1963), p. 59;Google Scholar S.A.N.U. statement, in Observer Foreign News Service (London), 12 11 1963;Google ScholarVoice of Southern Sudan (London), 1, 1, 1963 to 1, 4, 1964;Google Scholar S.A.L.F., ‘Memorandum to the 3rd Summit Conference of the OAU’, Accra, 21 October 1965; ‘SF Memorandum to OAU on Afro-Arab Conflict in the Sudan’, Accra 1965; Kwanai, in Observer Foreign News Service, 6 July 1965; Oduho, in The Vigilant (Juba?), 5 July 1965; Mayen, Muortat, in Financial Times (London), 17 06 1969;Google ScholarAfrica Research Bulletin (Exeter), July 1969, p. 1473B, and August 1969, p. 1501B; Uganda Argus (Kampala), 25 09 1969 and 10 04 1970;Google ScholarVoice of the Nïle Republic (London), various issues; Arab Report and Record (London), 16–30 11 1970, p. 643;Google ScholarGrass Curtain, various issues; and ‘The Anya-Nya Struggle: background and objectives’, c. 1971.

2 Pirouet, M. Louise, ‘The Achievement of Peace in Sudan’, in Journal of Eastern African Research and Development (Nairobi), 6, 1, 1976, pp. 119–20;Google Scholar and Howell, John, ‘Horn of Africa: lessons from the Sudan conflict’, in International Affairs (London), LIV, 3, 07 1978, p. 429.Google Scholar

1 Voice of Southern Sudan, I, 1, 1963 to II, 4, 1964;Google ScholarKyle, Keith, ‘The Southern Problem in the Sudan’, in World Today (London), 12 1966, pp. 512–15;Google ScholarCollins, Robert O., The Southern Sudan in Historical Perspective (Tel Aviv, 1975);Google ScholarBell, J. Bowyer, ‘The Conciliation of Insurgency: the Sudanese experience’, in Military Affairs (Kansas), 39, 3, 1975, pp. 106–7;Google ScholarO'Ballance, Edgar, The Secret War in the Sudan, 1955–1972 (London, 1977), passim;Google Scholar and Howell, ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 188–90.

2 Various issues of Grass Curtain and the news-sheet Anya-Nya; ‘The Anya-Nya Struggle, background and objectives’; Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 119–20; Howell, ‘Horn of Africa’, pp. 426–30; Toronto Daily Star, 4 January 1971; New York Times, 5 January 1971; O'Ballance, op. cit. pp. 132–41; and Woodward, op. cit. p. 3.

3 Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 115–45; and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, pp. 142–66.

4 Howell, John and Hamid, M. Beshir, ‘Sudan and the Outside World, 1964–1969’, in African Affairs, 68, 273, 1969, p. 302;Google Scholar Shepherd, loc. cit. p. 208; Howell, ‘Horn of Africa’, p. 429, and ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, p. 290, fn. 3; Wanji, in Africa Research Bulletin, February 1970, pp. 1677c–1678A, and in Uganda Argus, 20 April 1970; and Martin, David, General Amin (London, 1974), pp. 24 and 43–5.Google Scholar

1 See Albino, op. cit. pp. 6–8. For more details about the propaganda of each period and for the Southern Sudan case in general, see Heraclides, Alexis, ‘The International Dimension of Secessionist Movements’, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Kent, Canterbury, 1985, ch. v, pp. 433–516.Google Scholar

1 Kilner, Peter, ‘Better Outlook for Sudan’, in World Today, April 1970, p. 186Google Scholar; Robison, Davis, ‘Sudan: Russia's small Vietnam’, in The Jerusalem Post Magazine, 2 April 1971, p. 5Google Scholar; Wol Wol, op. cit. pp. 335–6; Ryan, Selwyn D., ‘Civil Conflict and External Involvement in Eastern Africa’, in International Journal, 28, 1972–1973, pp. 467–70 and 489–90;Google ScholarEprile, Cecil, Sudan: the long war (London, 1972), Conflict Studies Report No. 21, p. 17,Google Scholar and War and Peace in the Sudan, 1955–1972 (London, 1974);Google Scholar Martin, op. cit. pp. 44 and 158–9; Beshir, Mohamed Omer, Israel and Africa (Khartoum, 1974), pp. 31–4;Google Scholar Ladouceur, loc. cit. p. 40; Bell, loc. cit. p. 108; Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 140–1; Howell, ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 265 and 288–91, and ‘Horn of Africa’, pp. 428–31; Smith, George Ivan, Ghosts of Kampala (London, 1980), p. 68;Google Scholar and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, p. 139.

1 Lagu's letter in Drum (Nigerian edn.), March 1971).

2 Oduho, , in The Observer (London), 16 12 1962;Google Scholar Morrison, op. cit. p. 25; Martin, op. cit. pp. 25, 43–4 and 159; Eprile, War and Peace in the Sudan, p. 142; Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 140–1; Robison, loc. cit. p. 5; Steiner, Rolf, The Last Adventurer (Boston, 1978), pp. 179–80;Google Scholar Howell, ‘Horn of Africa’, pp. 432–4, and ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 243, 265, and 432–4; Smith, op. cit. pp. 78–9; and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, pp. 131–2.

3 Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 139–41; O'Ballance, op. cit. pp. 127–8; and Howell, ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 292–3.

1 Hamilton, David, ‘Ethiopia–Sudan Border Issues’, in Africa Research Bulletin, February 1968, pp. 975–7; Howell and Hamid, loc. cit. pp. 303–4 and 309–10;Google ScholarAbir, Mordechai, ‘Red Sea Politics’, in I.I.S.S. Adelphi Papers (London), 93, 12 1972, p. 32;Google Scholar Christopher Clapham, ‘Ethiopia and Somalia’, in Ibid. pp. 11–12; Morrison, op. cit. pp. 25–6; Bell, J. Bowyer, The Horn of Africa (New York, 1973), p. 45;Google Scholar Ladouceur, loc. cit. p. 410; Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 134–7; Ayele, Negussay, ‘The Foreign Policy of Ethiopia’, in Aluko, Olajide (ed.), The Foreign Policies of African States (London, 1977), pp. 50–1, 61, and 63;Google Scholar Howell, ‘Political Leadership and Organization in the Southern Sudan’, pp. 289–92, and ‘Horn of Africa’, pp. 431–3; and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, pp. 132–3.

2 Wol Wol, op. cit. p. 325.

3 Le Monde (Paris), 18–19 July 1965; New York Times, 4–17 August 1965; Shepherd, loc. cit. p. 208; Kyle, loc. cit. p. 519; Le Nouvel Observateur (Paris), 15 March 1967; Howell and Hamid, loc. cit. p. 302; Eprile, Sudan, p. 16; Ryan, loc. cit. p. 469; Sarkesian, Sam C., ‘The Southern Sudan: a reassessment’, in African Studies Review (Los Angeles), 16, 1, 04 1973, p. 13;Google Scholar O'Ballance, op. cit. pp. 79, 85 and 153; and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, pp. 136–7.

1 Reported in the Egyptian Gazette (Cairo), 1 July 1968, and the Straits Times (Kuala Lumpur), 19 September 1968.

2 East African Standard (Nairobi), 14 July 1963; Arab Report and Record (London), 1–15 April 1965, p. 81; Africa Diary (New Delhi), 25 April to 1 May 1965, p. 2838; Africa Confidential (London), 20, October 1965, p. 4; Africa Research Bulletin, August 1965, p. 239B, August 1966, p. 633BC, November 1966, p. 757C, and July 1968, p. 1117BC; New York Times, 11 August 1968; Howell and Hamid, loc. cit. pp. 304 and 309; Wol Wol, op. cit. pp. 326–7; Mahgoub, Ahmed Mohamed, Democracy on Trial (London, 1974), pp. 204–6;Google Scholar O'Ballance, op. cit. pp. 77–8; and Wai, The African-Arab Conflict in the Sudan, p. 137.

3 Pirouet, loc. cit. pp. 120–37.

1 The Black Book of the Sudan on the Expulsion of the Missionaires from Southern Sudan: an answer (Milano, 1964); Observer Foreign News Service, 6 Septembers 1965 and 28 February 1966; Bonfati, Adriano, ‘Soudan: noirs et blancs, dixième parallèle’, in Les Mois en Afrique (Paris), 01 1966, pp. 35–6;Google Scholar Morrison, op. cit. p. 17; Mahgoub, in Africa Diary, 25 April to 1 May 1966, p. 2838; and Sanderson, loc. cit. pp. 158–60.

2 For the present civil war, see the following: Meynell, Charles, ‘Sudan – North and South’, in Uganda and Sudan (London, 1984),Google Scholar Minority Rights Group Report, No. 66, pt. II, pp. 22–7; Mason, Andrew, ‘Southern Sudan: a growing conflict’, in World Today, December 1984, pp. 520–7;Google ScholarGreenfield, Richard, ‘Two Months that Shook Sudan’, in Horn of Africa, VIII, 1, 1985, pp. 5–20;Google ScholarLesch, Ann Mosely, ‘Confrontation in the Southern Sudan’, in The Middle East Journal, 40, 3, Summer 1986, pp. 410–28,Google Scholar and ‘A View from Khartoum’, in Foreign Affairs (New York), pp. 807–26.Google Scholar

1 I am particularly indebted to Leonidas Rokanas for information concerning the latest phase of the conflict. For press reports see, inter alià, the following: New African (London), August 1983, pp. 33–4, May 1984, pp. 59–61, June 1984, pp. 21–3, November 1985, pp. 14–15, September 1986, pp. 18–20 and 27–8, and April 1987, p. 25; Africa Now (London), May 1984, pp. 20–2 and July 1984, pp. 23–4; Africasia (Paris), May 1984, p. 15 June 1985, pp. 43–4, June 1986, pp. 28–9, October 1986, pp. 36–7 and April 1987, p. 27; Middle East Magazine (London), November 1983, pp. 25–6 and October 1986, pp. 10–12; and Le Monde (Paris), 23 August 1984, 22 August 1986, 10 May 1987 and 20 June 1987.

1 Garang, quoted in Lesch, loc. cit. p. 421.

1 Cudsi, Alexander S., ‘Islam and Politics in the Sudan’, in Piscatori, James P. (ed.), Islam in the Political Process (Cambridge, 1983), pp. 51–3.Google Scholar

1 For the concept of superordinate goals and their function in conflict resolution, see Sherif, Mujafer, Group Conflict and Cooperation (London, 1966), pp. 88 and 90–3.Google Scholar For the relevance of this concept at the inter-state level, see Groom, A. J. R., ‘Functionalism and World Society’, in Groom, and Taylor, Paul (eds.), Functionalism: theory and practice in international relations (London, 1975), pp. 98–9.Google Scholar