Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:06:29.316Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Work and family policy: Spoilt for choice or spoilt by choice?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 February 2015

Tanya Bretherton
Tanya Bretherton*
Affiliation:
Workplace Research Centre, School of Business, University of Sydney, Sydney NSW, Australia
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Employer perspectives on work–life balance are under-developed and under-represented within the context of public debate on work and family. The current state of policy debate on work and family is grounded in the value of ‘choice’ and implicitly suggests that expanding the range of programs available will inevitably deliver a superior program for employees and employers. While diversity in program design is obviously an important priority for both parties, the current debate has not substantially increased knowledge or awareness of how best to assess program ‘fit’ nor evaluate program effectiveness for either party. This paper presents the experience of two organisations which have implemented successful work-life programs by focusing exclusively on workplace and workforce need, rather than policy rhetoric. Comparing the experience of these two organisations demonstrates that the needs of employers may be better served by a shift in the policy debate toward program ‘appropriateness’ and improved program evaluation techniques, and away from ‘choice’. Government rhetoric on ‘choice’ may actually serve to confuse rather than assist employers in the formation of an integrated and effective organisational wide work and family policy and program.

Keywords

family-friendlyworkplace case studiespart-time workwork-life policyflexibilityworking hours
Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Management & Organization , Volume 14 , Issue 3 , July 2008 , pp. 259 - 266
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press and Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andrews, K (2006) Minister's report on Work and Family: The Importance of workplace flexibility in promoting balance between work and family AGPS Canberra.Google Scholar
Appelbaum, E, Bailey, T, Berg, P and Kalleberg, A (2001) Shared Work/Valued Care: New norms for organizing market work and unpaid care work, Economic Policy Institute Washington DC.Google Scholar
Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training (ACIRRT) (2003) Agreements Database and Monitoring Report 09 University of Sydney.Google Scholar
Australian Human Relations Institute (AHRI) (2007) AHRI Awards for Excellence in Innovation: Applicant Handbook AHRI Melbourne.Google Scholar
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) (2006) Trends in the affordability of child care services 1991-2004. AIHW Bulletin 35 AIHW Canberra.Google Scholar
Barlow, K, Junor, A, and Patterson, M (1993) Banking on flexibility. Arena, 5: 43–46.Google Scholar
Bittman, M and Rice, J M (2002) The spectre of overwork: An analysis of trends between 1974 and 1997 using Australian time-use diaries, Labour and Industry, 12: 5–25.Google Scholar
Charlesworth, S (2005) Striking the Balance or Tipping the Scales?: The HREOC women, men, work and family discussion paper, Australian Journal of Labour Law 18: 313–324.Google Scholar
Comans, J (1997) Its quality that counts: quality assurance and family day care, Rattler 43: 13–15.Google Scholar
De Ceiri, H, Holmes, B, Abbott, J, and Pettit, T (2005) Achievements and challenges for work/life balance strategies in Australian organizations, International Journal of Human Resource Management, 16: 90–103.Google Scholar
Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (1998) Work and Family State of Play, DEWR Canberra.Google Scholar
Diamond, C (2002) Telework: a ‘family-friendly’ work arrangement, Labour and Industry, 13: 39–42.Google Scholar
Hakim, C (2003) Competing family models, competing social policies, Family Matters 64: 52–61.Google Scholar
Jaumotte, F (2004) Female Labour Force Participation: Ppast trends and main determinants in OECD countries, OECD Geneva.Google Scholar
Kruesmann, M, Hsu, E, Vella, K, and Jones, F (2003) Balancing parenting and work: understanding women's work orientations and working realities, and pressures of balancing parenting and work, Paper presented at Eighth AIFS Conference Steps Forward for Families: Research, Practice and Policy, Melbourne.Google Scholar
Pocock, B (2005) Work-life ‘balance’ in Australia: limited progress, dim prospects, Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 43: 198–209.Google Scholar
Pocock, B and Masterman Smith, H (2004) Workchoices and women, Journal of Australian Political Economy, 56: 126–144.Google Scholar
Power, K (2005) Parents under pressure, About the House, 25: 23–25.Google Scholar
Powlay, J (2000) Child care affordability, Paper presented to Seventh AIFS Conference Family Futures: Issues in Research and Policy, Sydney.Google Scholar
Probert, B (2006) Would you like choices with that? Women, work and family under Howard Paper presented to New Standards for New Times? The Eight Hour Day and Beyond 22 06, University of Melbourne.Google Scholar
Reader, L (2000) ‘Business versus Bath-Time’ the work and family reportPaper presented at Seventh AIFS Conference Family Futures: Issues in Research and Policy Sydney.Google Scholar
Smith, M and Ewer, P (2005) What about working women? In Sheil, C. (ed) State of the States, Evatt Foundation, Sydney.Google Scholar
Sweeney Research (2004) Mobility and Mistrust, An independent research report commissioned by Toshiba Information Systems Division.Google Scholar
Van Wanrooy, B (2005) Adapting to the lifecourse?: Evaluating men and women's working-time preferences, Australian Journal of Labour Economics, 8: 145–162.Google Scholar
Whitehouse, G (2001) Industrial agreements and work/family provisions: trends and prospects under enterprise bargaining, Labour and Industry, 12: 109–129.Google Scholar
Whitehouse, G and Zetlin, D (1999) Family friendly policies: Distribution and implementation in Australian workplaces, Economic and Labour Relations Review, 9: 221–239.Google Scholar
Whittard, J (2003) Training and career experiences of women part-time workers in a finance sector organisation: persistent remnant of the ‘Reserve Army’? Australian Journal of Labour Economics, 6: 537–557.Google Scholar