Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-kw2vx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-11T23:02:26.989Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Whether to Waive Parental Permission in HIV Prevention Research Among Adolescents: Ethical and Legal Considerations

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Laurie J. Bauman ,
Claude Ann Mellins  and
Robert Klitzman
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Critical ethical questions arise concerning whether studies among adolescents of new behavioral and biomedical HIV preventive interventions such as Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) should obtain parental permission. This paper examines the relevant regulations and ethical guidance concerning waivers of parental permission, and arguments for and against such waivers. Opponents of such waivers may argue that adolescent decision-making is “too immature” and that parents always have rights to decide how to protect their children. Yet requiring parental permission may put adolescents at risk, and/or limit adolescent participation, jeopardizing study findings’ validity. This paper presents recommendations on when researchers and Institutional Review Boards (IRB) should waive parental permission, and what special protections should be adopted for adolescents who consent for themselves, e.g., assuring adolescent privacy and confidentiality, screening for capacity to consent, and identifying adolescents who are at elevated risk from study participation. We also present a series of specific areas for future research to design tools to help make these assessments, and to inform researcher and IRB decisions. These recommendations can help ensure that research is conducted that can aid adolescents at risk for HIV, while minimizing risks and protecting these individuals' rights as much as possible.

Type
Independent Articles
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 48 , Issue 1: LawSeq: Building a Sound Legal Foundation for Translating Genomics into Clinical Application , Spring 2020 , pp. 188 - 201
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2020

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, HIV Among Youth, available at <https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/group/age/youth/index.html> (last visited February 24, 2020); Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis, STD, and TB Prevention Division of HIV/AIDS Prevention, HIV Among Youth, available at <https://www.cdc.gov/nchhstp/> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020);+Centers+for+Disease+Control+and+Prevention,+National+Center+for+HIV/AIDS,+Viral+Hepatitis,+STD,+and+TB+Prevention+Division+of+HIV/AIDS+Prevention,+HIV+Among+Youth,+available+at++(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
Hosek, S.G. et al., “Safety and Feasibility of Antiretroviral Pre-exposure Prophylaxis for Adolescent Men Who Have Sex With Men Aged 15 to 17 Years in the UnitedStates,” JAMA Pediatrics 171, no. 11 (2017): 1063–1071.Google Scholar
Curtis, A.C., “Defining Adolescence,” Journal of Adolescent and Family Health 7, no. 2 (2015): 1–39.Google Scholar
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, HIV Surveillance Report: Diagnoses of HIV Infection in the United States and Dependent Areas 2017, available at <https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/library/reports/hiv-surveillance.html> (last visited February 24, 2020); See Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, supra note 1, CDC reference 2.+(last+visited+February+24,+2020);+See+Centers+for+Disease+Control+and+Prevention,+supra+note+1,+CDC+reference+2.>Google Scholar
Silver, E. and Bauman, L., “The Association of Sexual Experience with Attitudes, Beliefs, and Risk Behaviors of Inner-City Adolescents,” Journal of Research on Adolescence 16, no. 1 (2006): 29–45; Eaton, D.K. et al., Youth Risk Behavior Surveil-lance - United States, 2009, available at <https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/ss5905a1.htm> (last visited February 24, 2020); Kann, L. et al., Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance — United States, 2017, available at <https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/67/ss/ss6708a1.htm> (last visited February 24, 2020); Mosher, W.D., Chandra, A., and Jones, J., Sexual Behavior and Selected Health Measures: Men and Women 15-44 Years of Age, United States, 2002, Centers for Disease Control. Advance Data no. 362 (2005): 1–55; Côté, J., “Identity Formation and Self Development in Adolescence,” in Handbook of Adolescent Psychology Volume 1: Individual Bases of Adolescent Development, ed. Steinberg, R.L.L. (Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons, 2009), 266–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abma, J.C., Martinez, G.M., Mosher, W.D., and Dawson, B.S., “Teenagers in the United States: Sexual Activity, Contraceptive Use, and Childbearing, 2002,” Vital and Health Statistics Series 23, no. 24 (2004): 1–48.Google Scholar
See Kann et al., supra note 5.Google Scholar
See Mosher et al., supra note 5.Google Scholar
Pace, J.E., Siberry, G.K., Hazra, R., and Kapogiannis, B.G., “Pre-exposure Prophylaxis for Adolescents and Young Adults at Risk for HIV infection: Is an Ounce of Prevention Worth a Pound of Cure?” Clinical Infectious Diseases 56, no. 8 (2013): 1149–1155; Mayer, K.H. and Zanoni, B.C., “HIV Chemoprophylaxis for Adolescents: Educable Moment, Not Magic Bullet,” Clinical Infectious Diseases 56, no. 8 (2013): 1156–1158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Office of Human Research Protections, Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects (“Common Rule”), available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/common-rule/index.html> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
Macapagal, K. et al., “‘I Won’t Out Myself Just to Do a Survey’: Sexual and Gender Minority Adolescents’ Perspectives on the Risks and Benefits of Sex Research,” Archives of Sexual Behavior 46, no. 5 (2017): 1393–1409; Fisher, C.B. et al., “‘Free Testing and PrEP Without Outing Myself to Parents:’ Motivation to Participate in Oral and Injectable PrEP Clinical Trials Among Adolescent Men Who Have Sex with Men,” PloS One 13, no. 7 (2018): e0200560.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Field, M.J. and Berman, R.E., eds., The Ethical Conduct of Clinical Research Involving Children (Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2004); Santelli, J.S. et al., “Guidelines for Adolescent Health Research. A Position Paper of the Society for Adolescent Medicine,” Journal of Adolescent Health 33, no. 5 (2003): 396–409.Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, The Belmont Report, available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
Office for Human Research Protection, Special Protections for Children as Research Subjects, available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/guidance/special-protections-for-children/index.html> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
See The Belmont Report, supra note 13.Google Scholar
Mustanski, B., “Ethical and Regulatory Issues with Conducting Sexuality Research with LGBT Adolescents: A Call to Action for a Scientifically Informed Approach,” Archives of Sexual Behavior 40, no. 4 (2011): 673–686.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Field and Berman, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Santelli, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Santelli, supra note 12.Google Scholar
Weithorn, L.A., “Children's Capacities to Decide About Participation in Research,” IRB 5, no. 2 (1983): 1–5; Hein, I.M. et al., “Informed Consent Instead of Assent is Appropriate in Children from the Age of Twelve: Policy Implications of New Findings on Children's Competence to Consent to Clinical Research,” BMC Medical Ethics 16, no. 1 (2015): 76; Hein, I.M. et al., “Accuracy of the MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool for Clinical Research (MacCAT-CR) for Measuring Children's Competence to Consent to Clinical Research,” JAMA Pediatrics 168, no. 12 (2014): 1147–1153.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levine, R.J., “Research Involving Adolescents as Subjects: Ethical Considerations,” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1135, no. 1 (2008): 280–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Mustanski, supra note 16.Google Scholar
See Field and Berman, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Mustanski, supra note 16.Google Scholar
Hill, B.J., “Medical Decision Making by and On Behalf of Adolescents: Reconsidering First Principles,” Journal of Health Care Law & Policy 15, no. 1 (2012): 37–73.Google Scholar
See Mustanski, supra note 16; Hill, supra note 25.Google Scholar
The National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, Research Involving Children: Report and Recommendations, available at <https://videocast.nih.gov/pdf/ohrp_research_involving_children.pdf> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
See Levine, supra note 21.Google Scholar
Stenger, R., “Exclusive or Concurrent Competence to Make Medical Decisions for Adolescents in the United States and United Kingdom,” Journal of Law and Health 14, no. 2 (1999): 209–241.Google Scholar
See National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, supra note 27.Google Scholar
Office for Human Research Protections, 45 CFR 46, Pre-2018 Requirements, available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/45cfr46/index.html> (last visited July 31, 2019); Office for Human Research Protections, 45 CFR 46, 2018 Requirements, available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-andpolicy/regulations/45cfr46/index.html> (last visited July 31, 2019).+(last+visited+July+31,+2019);+Office+for+Human+Research+Protections,+45+CFR+46,+2018+Requirements,+available+at++(last+visited+July+31,+2019).>Google Scholar
See National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, supra note 27.Google Scholar
Guttmacher Institute, An Overview of Minors’ Consent Law, available at <https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/overview-minors-consent-law> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
See Guttmacher Institute, supra note 33.Google Scholar
Culp, L. and Caucci, L., “State Adolescent Consent Laws and Implications for HIV Pre-exposure Prophylaxis,” American Journal of Preventive Medicine 44, no. 1 Suppl. 2 (2013): S119–S1124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
New York State Department of Health, Frequently Asked Questions: New York State Public Health Law Article 23 and Title 10, New York Codes, Rules and Regulations — Section 23 Guidance for Local Health Departments (LHD) and Health Care Providers, available at <https://www.health.ny.gov/diseases/communicable/std/docs/faq_billing_consent.pdf> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
Mustanski, B. and Fisher, C.B., “HIV Rates are Increasing in Gay/Bisexual Teens: IRB Barriers to Research Must be Resolved to Bend the Curve,” American Journal of Preventive Medicine 51, no. 2 (2016): 249–252; Moore, Q.L. et al., “Legal Barriers to Adolescent Participation in Research about HIV and Other Sexually Transmitted Infections,” American Journal of Public Health 106, no. 1 (2016): 40–44; Mustanski, B., “Ethical and Regulatory Issues with Conducting Sexuality Research with LGBT Adolescents: A Call to Action for a Scientifically Informed Approach,” Archives of Sexual Behavior 40, no. 4 (2011): 673–686; Gilbert, A.L. et al., “Adolescent Self-consent for Biomedical Human Immunodeficiency Virus Prevention Research,” Adolescent Health 57, no. 1 (2015): 113–1139; Fisher, C.B. and Mustanski, B., “Reducing Health Disparities and Enhancing the Responsible Conduct of Research Involving LGBT Youth,” The Hastings Center Report 44, Suppl. 4 (2014): S28–S31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See supra note 37 for Moore et al.; Gilbert et al.; Fisher and Mustanski.Google Scholar
See Guttmacher Institute, supra note 33.Google Scholar
See Santelli, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Field and Berman, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Office for Human Research Protections, supra note 31 (for 2018 Requirements)Google Scholar
See Santelli, supra note 12.Google Scholar
See Office for Human Research Protections, supra note 31 (for both Pre and 2018 Requirements).Google Scholar
See Gilbert et al., supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Fisher and Mustanski, supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Fisher and Mustanski, supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Fisher and Mustanski, supra note 37.Google Scholar
Klitzman, R., The Ethics Police? The Struggle to Make Human Research Safe (New York: Oxford University Press, 2015).Google Scholar
Knopf, A.S. et al., “Adolescent Medicine Trials Network for HIV/AIDS Interventions. Moral Conflict and Competing Duties in the Initiation of a Biomedical HIV Prevention Trial with Minor Adolescents,” AJOB Empirical Bioethics 8, no. 3 (2017): 145–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merritt, M., “Moral Conflict in Clinical Trials,” Ethics 115, no. 2 (2005): 306–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Mustanski and Fisher, supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Mustanski and Fisher, supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Culp and Caucci, supra note 35.Google Scholar
See Mustanski and Fisher, supra note 37; Knopf et al., supra note 50.Google Scholar
See Culp and Caucci, supra note 35.Google Scholar
Arian, M. et al., “Maturation of the Adolescent Brian,” Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment 9 (2013): 449–461; Casey, B.J. and Caudle, K., “The Teenage Brain: Self Control,” Current Directions in Psychological Science 22, no. 2 (2013): 82–87; Yurgelun-Todd, D., “Emotional and Cognitive Changes During Adolescence,” Current Opinion in Neurobiology 17, no. 2 (2007): 251–257.Google Scholar
See Yurgelun-Todd, supra note 57.Google Scholar
Arnett, J.J., “Cognitive Foundations,” in: Adolescence and Emerging Adulthood: A Cultural Approach. 4th edition, ed. by the author, 58–92. (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall; 2010).Google Scholar
Steinberg, L., “A Social Neuroscience Perspective on Adolescent Risk-Taking,” Developmental Review 28, no. 1 (2008): 78–106; Grootens-Wiegers, P., Hein, I.M., van den Broek, J.M., and de Vries, M.C., “Medical Decision-Making in Children and Adolescents: Developmental and Neuroscientific Aspects,” BMC Pediatrics 17, no. 1 (2017): 120; See Casey and Caudle, supra note 57.Google Scholar
See Casey and Caudle, supra note 56.Google Scholar
United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, Convention on the Rights of the Child. Adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 44/25 of 20 November 1989. Entry into force 2 September 1990, in accordance with article 49, available at <https://www.ohchr.org/EN/ProfessionalInterest/Pages/CRC.aspx> (last visited February 24, 2020); Santelli, J.S., Haerizadeh, S., and McGovern, T., Inclusion with Protection: Conducting Ethical Research with Adolescents, Innocenti Research Brief (2017), available at <https://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/877-inclusion-with-protection-obtaining-informed-consent-when-conducting-research-with.html> (last visited February 24, 2020).+(last+visited+February+24,+2020);+Santelli,+J.S.,+Haerizadeh,+S.,+and+McGovern,+T.,+Inclusion+with+Protection:+Conducting+Ethical+Research+with+Adolescents,+Innocenti+Research+Brief+(2017),+available+at++(last+visited+February+24,+2020).>Google Scholar
See UN Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, supra note 62.Google Scholar
See UN Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, supra note 62.Google Scholar
Steinberg, L., “Does Recent Research on Adolescent Brain Development Inform the Mature Minor Doctrine?” The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 38, no. 3 (2013): 256–267.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fisher, C.B. et al., “Self-Consent for HIV Prevention. Research Involving Sexual and Gender Minority Youth: Reducing Barriers Through Evidence-based Ethics,” Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 11, no. 1 (2016): 1–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Weithorn, supra note 20.Google Scholar
See Levine, supra note 21.Google Scholar
See The Belmont Report, supra note 13.Google Scholar
See Levine, supra note 21; See Mustanski, supra note 16.Google Scholar
See Office for Human Research Protections, supra note 31 (for both the Pre and 2018 Requirements).Google Scholar
See Fisher and Mustanski, supra note 37.Google Scholar
Ybarra, M.L. et al., “Ethical Considerations in Recruiting Online and Implementing a Text Messaging-based HIV Prevention Program with Gay, Bisexual, and Queer Adolescent Males,” The Journal of Adolescent Health 59, no. 1 (2016): 44–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar