Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T01:30:20.512Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Independence of Supreme Courts in Latin America: A Review of the Literature*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 February 2009

Joel G. Verner
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

A survey of the relevant literature indicates rather graphically that little scholarly attention has been given to an assessment of the independence of supreme courts in the developing areas. A familiar theme in the scant research which has been reported is not only the relative decline of these courts, but their political weakness and general dependence in Third World countries in the first place. Although the constitutions of most developing countries provide for independent, sometimes even coequal judicial branches of government, with clearly defined and significant powers, and with constitutional guarantees to protect their independence, the evidence suggests that no more than a mere handful of national courts in these countries are truly independent: that is, few courts are free to decide cases on the basis of the established law and the ‘merits of the case’, without substantial interference from other political or governmental agents. Gamer has concluded that usually the ‘highest power rests with a Prime Minister (or President) and a small inner circle of the cabinet, whose policy decisions are seldom challenged by courts, legislatures˜’ and ‘there are few constitutional/legal traditions to restrain this central power’. Almond has written that ‘central executives and bureaucracy tend to monopolize the “rule” functions at the expense of courts and legislature’.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Latin American Studies , Volume 16 , Issue 2 , November 1984 , pp. 463 - 506
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Robert, E. Gamer, The Developing Nations: A Comparative Perspective (Boston, Allyn and Bacon, 1976), p. 16.Google Scholar

2 Gabriel, Almond, Comparative Politics: A World View (Boston, Little Brown, 1974), pp. 34–5.Google Scholar

3 Peter, H. Merkie, Modern Comparative Politics (Hinsdale, Illinois, Dryden Press, 1977), p. 194.Google Scholar

4 Raymond, Duncan, Latin American Politics (New York, Praeger, 1976), pp. 152–3.Google Scholar

5 Howard, J. Wiarda and Harvey, F. Kline (eds.) Latin American Politics and Development (Boston, Houghton Mufflin, 1979), pp. 66, 89.Google Scholar

6 Martin, C. Needler, Latin American Politics in Perspective (Princeton, New Jersey, Van Nostrand, 1963), p. 155.Google Scholar

7 Helen, Clagett, The Administration of Justice in Latin America (New York, Ocana, 1965), p. 215.Google Scholar

8 Francisco, José Moreno, ‘Justice and Law in Latin America: A Cuban Example’, Journal of Inter-A merican Studies and World Affairs, vol. 12, no. 3 (07 1970), pp. 373–8.Google Scholar

9 With the possible exception of Clagert's text, op. cit., there is no systematic study of the independence of supreme courts in particular countries; nor are there comparative studies of the courts of the region as a whole. The following are examples of Latin American constitutional legal essays of the sort to which Moreno gives reference: Antonio, Carillo Flores, ‘La Corte Suprema de Justicia Como Tribunal Federal de Ultima Instancia’, Memoria Del Colegio Nacional (Mexico), vol. 8, no. 4 (1978), pp. 75–99;Google ScholarJohn, T. Vance, The Background of Hispanic-American Law (New York, Central Books, 1943);Google ScholarPhanor, J. Eder, ‘The Impact of the Common Law in Latin America’, Miami Law Quarterly, 4, no. 4 (06 1930), pp. 436–8;Google ScholarLucio, A. Cabrera, ‘History of the Mexican Judiciary’, in David, J. Stern (ed.), Mexico: A Symposium on Law and Government (Coral Gables, University of Miami Press, 1958), pp. 23–31;Google ScholarGrant, J. A. C., ‘Judicial Control of Legislation: A Comparative Study’, The American Journal of Comparative Law, vol. 3 (1954), pp. 186–98;Google ScholarGrant, J. A. C., ‘Due Process for Ex-Dictators: A Study of Judicial Control of Legislation in Guatemala’, American Political Science Review, 41, no. 3 (06 1947), pp. 463–9;Google ScholarAngel, Ganwet, Idearium Espaáol y El Provenir de Espana (Madrid, Espana Calpe, 1962);Google ScholarMarie, R. Madden, Political Theory and Law in Medieval Spain (New York: Fordham University Press, 1930);Google ScholarFrancisco, José Moreno, ‘Latin America: The Fear Within’, The Yale Review, 55, no.2 (12 1965), pp. 27–38;Google ScholarPalmer, T. W. Jr, Guide to the Law and Legal Literature of Spain (Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing Office, 1913);Google ScholarLeopoldo, Zea, The Latin American Mind (Norman, Oklahoma, University of Oklahoma Press, 1963);Google ScholarReynaldo, Galindo Pohl, ‘Herencia Juridica y Politica Espaáa’, Journal of Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, 10, no. 2 (04 1968), pp. 213–20;Google ScholarMax, Rheinstein, ‘Common and Civil Law: An Elementary Comparison’, Revista Juridica De La Universidad De Puerto Rico, vol. 22 (1932–1933), pp. 90–107;Google ScholarPhanor, J. Eder, A Comparative Survey of Anglo-American and Latin American Law (New York, New York University Press, 1950);Google ScholarGuillermo, de Montagu, ‘Judicial Organization in Cuba’, Journal of American Judicature Society, vol. 32 (1949), pp. 337–57;Google ScholarJorge, Luna y Parra, ‘Summary of the Courts in the City of Mexico’, Journal of American Judicature Society, 27 (1943), pp. 70–3.Google Scholar

10 Christensen, A. N., ‘Strong Governments and Weak Courts’, in The Evolution of Latin American Government (New York, Holt, 1969), p. 469.Google Scholar

11 Martin, C. Needler (ed.), ‘Chile’, in Political system of Latin America (Princeton, Van Nostrand, 1964), p. 373.Google Scholar

12 Arpad, Von Lazar, Latin American Politics (Boston, Allyn and Bacon, 1971), p. 41.Google Scholar

13 Jacques, Lambert, Latin America: Social Structures and Political Institutions (Berkeley, University of California Press, 1967), pp. 294–5;Google ScholarKenneth, F. Johnson, ‘Scholarly Images of Latin American Political Democracy in 1975’, Latin American Research Review, 11, no. 2 (Spring 1976), pp. 129–40.Google Scholar

14 Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 66.Google Scholar

15 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 153.Google Scholar

16 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, pp. 152–5.Google Scholar

17 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 152.Google Scholar

18 Lambert, , Latin America: Social Structures and Political Institutions, p. 287.Google Scholar

19 Moreno, , ‘Justice and Law in Latin America: A Cuban Example’, p. 377.Google Scholar

20 Alexander, T. Edelmann, ‘Courts and Law: The Last Word, Fact or Fiction’, Latin American Governments and Politics (Homewood, Illinois, Dorsey Press, 1969), p. 480;Google ScholarHelen, Clagett, ‘Latin American Judicial Systems’, in Peter, G. Snow (ed.), Government and Politics and Latin America (New York, Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1967), p. 215.Google Scholar

21 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, p. 185.Google Scholar

22 Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, pp., 66, 86.Google Scholar

23 Victor, Alba, The Latin Americans (New York, Praeger Publications, 1969), p. 346.Google Scholar

24 Robert, J. Alexander, An Introduction to Argentine (New York, Praeger, 1969), p. 90; idem, The Tragedy of Chile (Westport, Conn., Greenwood Press, 1978), p. 349;Google ScholarMoreno, , ‘Justice and Law in Latin America: A Cuban Example’, p. 367;Google ScholarRobert, M. Schneider, The Political Systems of Braril (New York, Columbia University Press, 1971), p. 27;Google ScholarMario, Rosenthal, Guatemala (New York, Twayne, 1962), p. 247;Google ScholarJoseph, R. Barager, ‘Argentina: a Divided Country’, in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, pp. 421–2, 431;Google ScholarAlberto, Ciria, Parties and Power in Modern Argentina (Albany, State University of New York, 1974), pp. 287–8.Google Scholar

25 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, pp. 152–3.Google Scholar

26 Wiarda, and Kline, , (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, pp. 152–3.Google Scholar

27 Ibid. p. 63.

28 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, pp. 133-??.Google Scholar

29 Clagett, , ‘Latin American Judicial Systems’, pp. 215–16; Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 153.Google Scholar

30 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, pp. 154.Google Scholar

31 Alba, , The Latin Americans, pp. 345–6.Google Scholar

32 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 152.Google Scholar

33 Von, Lazar, Latin American Politics, p. 40.Google Scholar

34 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, p. 155.Google Scholar

35 Clagett, , The Administration of Justice in Latin America, pp. 11–40; idem, ‘Latin American Judicial Systems’, pp. 215–16; Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 152; Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, p. 155.Google Scholar

36 Von, Lazar, Latin American Politics, pp. 40–1.Google Scholar

37 James, L. Busey, Latin America: Political Institutions and Processes (New York, Random House, 1964), pp. 78–9.Google Scholar

38 Vincent, Padgett, The Mexican Political System (Boston, Houghton Mifflin, 1976), pp. 201–3;Google ScholarRobert, Scott, Mexican Government in Transition (Urbana, University of illinois Press, 1964), pp. 268–70;Google ScholarMiguel, Lanz Duret, Derecho Constitacional Mexicana (Mexico, Impr. L.D., 1945);Google ScholarClagett, , ‘Law and Court Systems’, in Harold, E. Davis (ed.), Government and Politics in Latin America (New York: Ronald Press, 1958), pp. 345–7;Google ScholarIgnacio, Burgoa, El Juicio De Amparo (Mexico, Porrua, 1951);Google ScholarAlberto, Bremauntz, Por Una Justicia al Servicio del Pueblo (Mexico, Casa De Michoacan, 1955).Google Scholar

39 Scott, , Mexican Government in Transition, p. 269.Google Scholar

40 Clagett, , ‘Latin American Judicial Systems’, pp. 215–16.Google Scholar

41 Padgett, , The Mexican Political System, pp. 201–5.Google Scholar

42 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 152.Google Scholar

43 William, W. Pierson and Federico, G. Gil, Governments of Latin American (New York, McGraw-Hill, 1957) pp. 292–3.Google Scholar

44 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 153.Google Scholar

45 Clagett, , The Administration of Justice in Latin America, pp. 11–40.Google Scholar

46 Alba, , The Latin Americans, pp. 346–7.Google Scholar

47 Ibid. p. 346/.

48 Von, Lazar, Latin American Politics, p. 43.Google Scholar

49 Clagett, , ‘Latin American Judicial Systems’, pp. 355–8.Google Scholar

50 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, p. 154.Google Scholar

51 Von, Lazar, Latin American Politics, PP. 41–2.Google Scholar

52 Arthur, S. Banks and William, Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1980 (New York, McGraw-Hill, 1980).Google Scholar

53 Paul, Lewis, Paraguay Under Stroessner (Chapel Hill, University of North Carolina Press, 1980), pp. 110–11;Google ScholarLeo, B. Lott, Venezuela and Paraguay: Political Modernity and Tradition in Conflict (New York, Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1972), p. 330.Google Scholar

54 Peter, G. Snow, ‘Argentina: Politics in a Conflict Society’, in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 123.Google Scholar

55 Jesús, de Galindez, The Era of Trujillo (Tucson, University of Arizona Press, 1973), p. 116.Google Scholar

56 Howard, J. Wiarda, Development and Dictatorship (Gainesville, University of Florida Press, 1968), p. 64.Google Scholar

57 John, D. Martz, ‘Guatemala’, in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 47; also see Rosenthal, , Guatemala, p. 247.Google Scholar

58 Needler, , Latin American Politics in Perspective, p. 155.Google ScholarRobert, Wesson has bluntly written that ‘strong regimes, of course, restaff the judiciary as they desire’ in his Democracy in Latin America (New York, Praeger, 1982), p. 118.Google Scholar

59 William, Stokes, Honduras: An Area Study of Government (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1950), p. 138.Google Scholar

60 Ogelsby, J. R. M., ‘Haiti’, in Ben, G. Burnett and Kenneth, F. Johnson (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America (Belmont, California, Wadsworth, 1970), p. 205.Google Scholar

61 Duncan, , Latin American Politics, p. 153.Google Scholar

62 George, Maier, ‘Presidential Succession in Ecuador, 1930–1970’, Journalof Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, vol. 13, nos. 3–4 (07–10 1971), pp. 475–509;Google ScholarRoderic, Al Camp, ‘Mexican Governors Since Cardenas: Education and Career Contacts’, Journal of Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, 16, no. 4 (11 1974), pp. 454–81;Google ScholarDavid, V. Fleischer, ‘As Bases Socio-Economias do Recrutamento Partidario, 1945–1965 ’and ‘A Transição Para o Bipartidarismo no Legislativo, 1966–1979’, Papers presented to the Simposio os Partidos Politicos no Brasil, Associação Nacional de Pesquisas e Postgradução em Ciencias Sociais,Google ScholarRio, De Janeiro (8–30 03 1979);Google ScholarRonald Scheman, L., ‘The Brazilian Law Student: Background, Habits, Attitudes’, Journal oflnter-American Studies and World Affairs, 5, no. 3 (07 1963), pp. 333–56;Google ScholarJoel, G. Verner, ‘Los Abogados en La Camara de Diputados de Brasil’, Foro International, vol. 17, no. 2 (10 1976), pp. 275–311; ‘El Congreso Nacional Guatemalteco de 1966–1970: Analisis de Un Elite’, Foro Internacional, vol. 13, no. 4 (04 1971), pp. 569–87; ‘Los Sistemas de Seleccion de Presidentes en America Latina: 1930–1970’, Foro Internacional, vol. 13, no. 4 (04 1973), pp. 490–512;Google Scholar‘Guatemalan National Congress’, in Weston, H. Agor (ed.), Latin American Legislatures: Their Role and Influence (New York, Praeger, 1971), pp. 293–323;Google Scholar‘The Structure of the Public Careers of Brazilian Legislators, 1963–1970’, International Journal of Comparative Sociology, vol. 16, nos. 1–2 (03 1975), pp. 64–80.Google Scholar

63 Kenneth, F. Johnson, ‘Scholarly Images of Latin American Political Democracy in 1973’, pp. 129–40;Google Scholar‘Measuring the Scholarly Image of Latin American Democracy’, in James, W. Wilkie (ed.), Statistical Abstract of Latin America, vol. 1 (Los Angeles, UCLA Latin American Center), pp. 347–66.Google Scholar Also see Russell, H. Fitzgibbon and Kenneth, F. Johnson. ‘Measurement of Latin American Political Change’, American Political Science Review, vol. 55, no. 2 (09 1961), pp. 11–23.Google Scholar

64 Charles, D. Ameringer, Democracy in Costa Rica (New York, Praeger) pp. 52–3.Google Scholar

65 Busey, , Latin America: Political Institutions and Processes, pp. 78–9; ‘Costa Rica’, in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 122;Google ScholarJohn, Bill Patrick, in his Crisis in Costa Rica: The 1948 Revolution (Austin, University of Texas Press, 1971), p. 73, mentions that the supreme court declared several decrees of President Calderón Guardía unconstitutional in the mid-1940s and that these decisions were respected by all governmental authorities.Google Scholar

66 Charles, Denton, ‘Costa Rica: A Democratic Revolution’, in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 385.Google Scholar

67 Johnson, , ‘Scholarly Images of Latin American Political Democracy’, pp. 129–40.Google Scholar

68 James, L. Busey, Notes on Costa Rican Democracy (Boulder, University of Colorado Press, 1962).Google Scholar

69 Busey, , ‘Costa Rica’, p. 122.Google Scholar

70 Jean, Blondel, ‘Rule Adjudication and the Role of Judges in Government’, in Introduction to Comparative Government (New York, Praeger, 1969), p. 431.Google Scholar

71 Thomas, E. Skidmore and Peter, H. Smith, ‘Chile: Democracy, Socialism, and Repression’, Modern Latin America (New York, Oxford University Press, 1984), pp. 113–44;Google ScholarArthur, S. Banks and William, Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1982–1983 (New York, McGraw-Hill, 1983), pp. 535–7;Google ScholarRonald, H. MacDonald, ‘The Rise of Military Politics in Uruguay’, Journal of Inter American Economic Affairs, vol. 28, no. 4 (Spring 1975), pp. 25–44.Google Scholar

72 Russell, H. Fitzgibbon, Uruguay: Portrait of a Democracy (New Brunswick, N.J., Rutgers University Press, 1954), p. 164;Google ScholarHarry, Kantor, in his ‘Efforts Made by Various Latin American Countries to Limit the Power of the President’, in Thomas, V. DiBacco (ed), Presidential Power in Latin American Politics (New York, Praeger, 1977), p. 24, stated that up to the early twentieth century, ‘the Uruguayan president dominated the legislature and the supreme court during his term of office’.Google Scholar

73 George, Pendle, Uruguay (New York, Oxford University Press, 1975);Google ScholarPhilip, B. Taylor, Government and Politics of Uruguay (New Orleans, Tulane University Press, 1960);Google ScholarLuis, Carlos Benvenuto, Breve Historia Del Uruguay (Montevideo, ARCA, 1967);Google ScholarDonald, W.Bray, ‘Uruguay’, in Burnett, and Johnson, (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America, pp. 535–56.Google Scholar

74 Marvin, Alisky, Uruguay (New York, Praeger, 1969), pp. 50–63;Google ScholarFitzgibbon, , Uruguay: Portrait of a Democracy, pp. 160–70;Google Scholar‘Adoption of the Collegiate Executive in Uruguay’, The Journal of Politics, vol. 54, no. 3 (11 1952), pp. 616–42.Google Scholar

75 Johnson, , ‘Measuring the Scholarly Image of Latin American Democracy’, p. 366;Google ScholarBanks and Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1982–1983, p. 536.Google Scholar

76 Lawrence, Birns, The End of Chilean Democracy (New York, Seabury Press, 1974);Google ScholarRichard, E. Feinbery, The Triumph of Allende: Chile's Legal Revolution (New York, Mentor Books, 1972);Google ScholarIan, Roxborough, Phil, O' Brian and Jackie, Roddick, Chile: The State and Revolution (London, Macmillan, 1977).Google Scholar

77 Arturo, Valenzuela, ‘Chil’, in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 246.Google Scholar

78 Federico, Gil, ‘Chil’, in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 369.Google Scholar

79 Alexander, , The Tragedy of Chile, pp. 249, 253, 318–20.Google Scholar

80 Paul, E. Sigmund, The Overthrow of Allende and the Politics of Chile 1964–1976 (Pittsburgh, University Press, 1977), pp. 210–11.Google Scholar

81 Lawrence, J. LeBlanc, The OAS and the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights (The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff, 1977), p. 151.Google Scholar

82 Alexander, , The Tragedy of Chile, p. 349.Google Scholar

83 Banks and Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1982–1983, p. 90.Google ScholarArturo, Valenzuela, The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes: Chile (Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978).Google Scholar

84 Filipe, Tena Ramírez, Derecho Constitucional Mexicano (Mexico, Ed. Porrua, 1955);Google Scholaridem. ‘The International Expansion of the Mexican Amparo’, Inter-American Law Review, vol. I, no. I (01–06 1959), pp. 163–6;Google ScholarErnest, Gruening, Mexico and Its Heritage (New York, D. Appleton-Century, 1934), pp. 497–514.Google Scholar

85 Rafael, Chavez, La Intervención de La Corte Suprema en Materia Politica (Mexico, Ed. Porrua, 1946).Google Scholar

86 Robert, Scott, ‘Some Aspects of Mexican Federalism, 1917–1948’, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation (Madison, University of Wisconsin, 1949), chapter 5;Google ScholarCabrera, , ‘A History of the Mexican Judiciary’, pp. 23–31.Google Scholar

87 William, P. Tucker, The Mexican Government Today (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1957) ch. 8;Google ScholarJohn, T. Vance and Helen, L. Clagett, A Guide to the Law and Legal Literature of Mexico (Washington, D.C., Library of Congress, 1945).Google Scholar

88 Martin, C. Needler, Politics and Society in Mexico (Albuquerque, University of New Mexico Press, 1971), p. 42.Google Scholar

89 Martin, C. Needler, Mexican Politics (New York, Praeger, 1981), p. 88;Google ScholarKenneth, F. Johnson, in his ‘Mexico's Authoritarian Presidency’, in Dibacco, (ed.), Presidential Power in Latin America, p. 50, argues, however, that ‘the Mexican president has considerable power to influence decisions of the judiciary via appointment of judges and initiating removal proceedings in the Congress’.Google Scholar

90 Scott, , Mexican Government in Transition, p. 269.Google Scholar

91 Ibid. 269–71.

92 Ibid. pp. 272, 266.

93 Pablo, González Casanova, La Democracia en Mexico (Mexico, Ediciones ERA, 1965 ), pp. 21–4.Google Scholar

94 Padgett, , The Mexican Political system, pp. 201–2;Google Scholar see also Burgoa, , El Juicio de Amparo.Google Scholar

95 Needler, , Politics and Society in Mexico, pp. 42–3.Google Scholar

96 Charles, Cumberland, Mexico: The Struggle for Modernity (New York, Oxford University Press, 1968);Google ScholarKenneth, F. Johnson, Mexican Democracy: A Critical View (Boston, Allyn and Bacon, 1971).Google Scholar

97 George, Blanksten, Peron's Argentina (Chicago, University Press, 1953), pp. 122–32;Google ScholarSegunda, Linares Quintana, ‘Comparison of the Constitutional Bases of the United States and Argentina Political Systems’, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, vol.97 no.5 (04 1949), pp. 641–64;Google ScholarAustin, F. MacDonald, Government of the Argentine Republic (New York, Crowell, 1942), chapter 14.Google Scholar

98 Snow, ‘Argentina: Politics in a Conflict Society’, p. 123.

99 Barager, , ‘Argentina: A Divided Country’, pp. 421–2, 431.Google Scholar

100 Ciria, , Parties and Power in Modern Argentina, pp. 287–8.Google Scholar

101 Snow, , ‘Argentina: Politics in a Conflict Society’, p. 123.Google Scholar

102 Ciria, , Parties and Power in Modern Argentina, p. 287.Google Scholar

103 Alexander, , An Introduction to Argentina, p. 90.Google Scholar

104 Bradford Burns, E., A Histori of Brazil (New York, Columbia University Press, 1980), p. 451;Google Scholar see also Thomas, Flory, ‘Judicial Politics in Nineteenth Century Brazil’, Hispanic American Historical Review, vol. 55, no. 4 (11 1975), pp. 664–92.Google Scholar

105 Schneider, , The Political System of Brazil, p.275.Google Scholar

106 Busey, , Latin America: Political Institutions and Processes, p. 114.Google Scholar

107 Thomas, E. Skidmore, Politics in Brazil, 1930–1964 (New York, Oxford University Press, 1967), p. 135.Google Scholar

108 John, W. F. Dulles, Unrest in Brazil (Austin, University of Texas Press, 1970), p. 110.Google Scholar

109 John, W. F. Dulles, President Castelo Branco (College Station, Texas A. and M. Press, 1980), pp. 132–3.Google Scholar

110 Lewis, , The Governments of Argentina, Brazil, and Mexico, p. 59.Google Scholar

111 Riordan, Roett, Brazil: Politics in a Patrimonial Society (New York, Praeger, 1978), p. 138.Google Scholar

112 Skidmore, , Politics in Brazil 1930–1964, p. 313;Google Scholar also see Robert, Wesson and David, V. Fleischer, Brazil in Transition (New York, Praeger, 1983), p. 75.Google Scholar

113 Thomas, E. Skidmore, ‘Politics and Economic Policy-Making in Authoritarian Brazil, 1937–1971’, in Alfred, Stepan (ed.), Authoritarian Brazil (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1973), pp. 14–15.Google Scholar

114 For an overview of the Structure of the present Brazilian judiciary, see Wesson, and Fleischer, , Brazil in Transition, p. 84.Google Scholar

115 Grant, J. A. C., ‘“Contract Clause” Litigation in Colombia: A Comparative Study in Judicial Review’, American Political Science Review, vol. 42, no. 6 (12 1948), pp. 1103–26;Google Scholar‘Judicial Review by Executive Reference to Prior Promulgation: The Colombian Experiences’, Southern Calfornia Law Review, vol. 31, no. 2 (02 1948), pp. 154–71; ‘Judicial Control of Legislation: A Comparative Study’,Google ScholarAmerican Journal of Comparative Law, vol.3 (01 1954), pp. 186–98.Google Scholar

116 Vernon, Lee Fluharty, Dance of the Millions (Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh Press, 1957), pp. 51–3.Google Scholar

117 Ibid. p. 117.

118 Robert, H. Dix, Colombia: The Political Dimensions of Change (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1967), pp. 175–7.Google Scholar

119 Paul, Oquist, Violence, Conflict, and Politics in Colombia (New York, Academic Press, 1980), 177–80.Google Scholar

120 Dix, , Colombia: The Political Dimensions of Change, P. 175.Google Scholar

121 Ibid. pp. 193–4.

122 Ibid. pp. 174, 194.

123 Russell, H. Fitzgibbon and Julio, A. Fernandez, Latin America: Political Culture and Development (Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice-Hall, 1981), p. 166.Google Scholar

124 Banks and Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1982–1983, p. 101.Google Scholar

125 Dix, , Colombia: The Political Dimensions of Change, pp. 175–6;Google ScholarFitzgibbon, and Fernandez, , Latin America: Political Culture and Development, pp. 166–94;Google ScholarOquist, , Violence, Conflict, and Politics in Columbia, pp. 177–80.Google Scholar

126 Robert, J. Alexander, The Venezuelan Democratic Revolution (New Brunswick Rutgers University Press, 1964);Google ScholarDavid, Eugene Blank, Politics in Venezuela (Boston, Little Brown, 1973);Google ScholarJohn, D. Martz and David, Meyers (eds.), Venezuela: The Democratic Experience (New York, Praeger, 1977).Google Scholar

127 Lynn Kelley, R., ‘Venezuelan Constitutional Forms and Realities’, in Martz, and Meyers, (eds.), Venezuela: The Democratic Experience, pp. 42–3.Google Scholar

128 Lott, , Venezuela and Paraguay: Political Modernitj and Tradition in Conflict, p. 326.Google Scholar

129 Ibid. p. 325.

130 Kelley, , ‘Venezuelan Constitutional Forms and Realities’, p. 42.Google Scholar

131 Russell, H. Fitzgibbon, Latin America (New York, Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1971), p. 355.Google Scholar

132 Lott, , Venezuela and Paraguy: Political Modernitj and Tradition in Conflict, pp. 327, 330–1.Google Scholar

133 Ibid. p. 330.

134 Donald, Herman, Christian Democray in Venezuela (Chapel Hill, University of North Carolina Press, 1980), p. 92.Google Scholar

135 Kelley, , ‘Venezuelan Constitutional Forms and Realities’, pp.43–4.Google Scholar

136 Edelmann, , ‘Courts and Law: The Last Word, Fact or Fiction’, p. 480.Google Scholar

137 Robert, J. Alexander, The Bolivian National Revolution (New Brunswick, Rutgers University Press, 1958), p. 69.Google Scholar

138 Robert, J. Alexander, ‘Bolivia’, in Needler, (ed), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 343.Google Scholar

139 Thomas, M. Millington, ‘Bolivia’, in Burnett, and Johnson, (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America, p. 429.Google Scholar

140 Fitzgibbon, , Latin America, pp. 434, 394.Google Scholar

141 Owens, R. J., Peru (New York, Oxford University Press, 1963), p. 69.Google Scholar

142 Fitzgibbon, , Latin America, p. 415.Google Scholar

143 Gary, W. Wynia, ‘The Military Authoritarian Game’, in The Politics of Latin American Development (New York, Cambridge University Press, 1978), pp. 217–18.Google Scholar

144 David, P. Werlich, Peru: A Short Histori (Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press, 1978), p. 41.Google Scholar

145 Banks and Overstreet, Political Handbook of the World, 1982–1983, pp. 382–3.Google Scholar

146 George, Blanksten, ‘Ecuador’, in Needler, (ed), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 367.Google Scholar

147 Jack, B. Galbert, ‘Ecuador’, in Burnett, and Johnson, (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America, p. 367.Google Scholar

148 John, D. Martz, ‘Ecuador: Authoritarianism, Personalism, and Dependency’, in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, pp. 87–8.Google Scholar

149 New York Times, 09 1961, 1:4.Google Scholar

150 Martz, , ‘Ecuador: Authoritarianism, Personalism, and Dependency,’ p. 88.Google Scholar

151 New York Times, 23 06 1970, 14:1.Google Scholar

152 Martz, , ‘Ecuador: Authoritarianism, Personalism, and Dependency,’ p. 89.Google Scholar

153 Ibid. pp. 87, 310.

154 John, Biesanz and Mavis, Biesanz, ‘Panamanian Politics,’ Journal of Politics, vol. 14 (08 1952), pp. 386–402;Google ScholarThe People of Panama (New York, Columbian University Press, 1955), p. 141;Google Scholar see also Larry, L. Pippin, The Remon Era (Stanford, University Press, 1964).Google Scholar

155 Harry, Kantor, ‘Efforts Made by Various Latin American Countries to Limit the Power of the President,’ p. 28.Google Scholar

156 Fitzgibbon, , Latin America, p. 113.Google Scholar

157 Charles, W. Anderson, ‘Honduras,’ in Needler, (ed.), Political. ystems of Latin America, p. 85Google Scholar see also Stokes, , Honduras: An Area Study of Government, pp. 138–9.Google Scholar

158 James, A. Morris, The Honduran Plan Politico Unidad Nacional 1971: Its Origin and Demise (El Paso, University of Texas at El Paso, Center for InterAmerican Studies, 1975).Google Scholar

159 Chester, Lloyd Jones, Guatemala (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1940), p. 101.Google Scholar

160 Rosenthal, , Guatemala, p. 247.Google Scholar

161 John, D. Martz, ‘Guatemala,’ in Needler, (ed.), Political systems of Latin America, p. 47.Google Scholar

162 Nathan, Whetten, Guatemala: The Land and the People (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1961), p. 326.Google Scholar

163 Fitzgibbon, , Latin America, p. 104.Google Scholar

164 Ogelsby, , ‘Haiti,’ p. 205.Google Scholar

165 Fitzgibbon, , Latin America, p. 161.Google Scholar

166 Bernard, Dieterich and Al, Burt, Papa Doc (New York, McGraw-Hill, 1969), pp. 279–80.Google Scholar

167 Wiarda, , Development and Dictatorship, p. 65.Google Scholar

168 Ibid. pp. 64–5.

169 Galindez, , The Era of Trujillo, p. 116;Google Scholar see also Howard, J. Wiarda, ‘The Dominican Republic,’ in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 368.Google Scholar

170 Howard, J. Wiarda, Dominican Republic (New York, Praeger, 1977), p. 164.Google Scholar

171 Ian, Bell, The Dominican Republic (Boulder, Westview Press, 1981), p. 204.Google Scholar

172 Ibid. pp. 204–6.

173 Thomas, W. Walker, ‘Nicaragua: The Somoza Family Regime,’ in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development, p. 330.Google Scholar

174 Kenneth, F. Johnson and Phillip, Paris, ‘Nicaragua,’ in Burnett, and Johnson, (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America, p. 129.Google Scholar

175 Charles, W. Anderson, ‘Nicaragua,’ in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, p. 105.Google Scholar

176 John, A. Booth, The End and the Beginning: The Nicaraguan Revolution (Boulder, Westview, Pess, 1982), pp. 188–9;Google Scholar see also Max, Axicri, ‘A Cuban Perspective on the Nicaraguan Revolution,’ in Thomas, W. Walker (ed.), Nicaragua in Revolution (New York, Praeger, 1982), pp. 355–7.Google Scholar

177 Booth, , The End and the Beginning: The Nicaraguan Revolution, p. 189;Google Scholar see also Tomas, Borge Martínez, ‘Tomas Borge Speaks on Human Rights in Nicaragua,’ InterContinental Press, 16 03 1981, p. 250.Google Scholar

178 Fitzgibbon, and Fernández, , Latin America: Political Culture and Development, p. 326.Google Scholar

179 Leo, B. Lott, ‘Paraguay,’ in Needler, (ed.), Political Systems of Latin America, pp. 393–523;Google Scholar also see Lott, , Venezuela and Paraguay: Political Modernity and Tradition in Conflict, p. 140;Google Scholar see also Riordan, Roett and Amparo, Mendenez-Carrion, ‘Authoritarian Paraguay: The Personalist Tradition,’ in Wiarda, and Kline, (eds.), Latin American Politics and Development.Google Scholar

180 Paul, H. Lewis, Paraguay Under Stroessner (Chapel Hill, University of North Carolina Press, 1980), pp. 110–11.Google Scholar

181 Carlton, Beals, The Crime of Cuba (Philadephia, Lippincott, 1933), p. 254.Google Scholar

182 MacCaffey, R. and Burnett, C. R., Cuba (New Haven, HRAF Press, 1962), p. 114.Google Scholar

183 Jaime, Suchlicki, Cuba: From Columbus to Castro (New York, Scribner's, 1974), p. 149.Google Scholar

184 Andres, Suárez, Cuba: Castroism and Communism, 1959–1966 (Cambridge, M.I.T. Press, 1967), pp. 29–32.Google Scholar

185 Howard, J. Wiarda, ‘Cuba’, in Burnett, and Johnson, (eds.), Political Forces in Latin America, pp. 257–8.Google Scholar

186 Harry, Kantor, ‘Cuba: The Revolution Betrayed,’ Patterns of Politics and Political Systems in Latin America (Chicago, Rand McNally, 1969), p. 281.Google Scholar

187 Merle, Kling, ‘The State of Research on Latin America: Political Science’, in Charles, W. Wagley (ed.), Social Science Research on Latin America (New York, Columbia University Pess, 1964). pp. 168–207.Google Scholar