Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-g7gxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T01:27:09.924Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Traditional and ancient rural economy in Mediterranean Europe: plus ça change?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 October 2013

Paul Halstead
Paul Halstead
Affiliation:
University of Sheffield
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The study of recent ‘traditional’ Mediterranean rural economy has long been a predilection of ancient historians and archaeologists working in that area. Traditional practices and production norms have been used by ancient historians in the interpretation of the often enigmatic testimony of the ancient agronomic writers, while archaeologists have used the same information to fill in the many gaps in the material record supplied by the spade. Much of the relevant data on traditional rural economy are gleaned from the accounts of early travellers or of modern geographers, ethnographers and agronomists. But comparanda acquired at first-hand enhance the credibility of archaeologists and ancient historians as fieldworkers, and chance summer encounters with Cretan shepherds or Cycladic fishermen are valuable currency in competitive displays at academic conferences.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Hellenic Studies , Volume 107 , November 1987 , pp. 77 - 87
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies 1987

References

This paper was delivered at the Institute of Classical Studies, London, in January 1986 at the invitation of Dominic Rathbone. For various helpful suggestions and criticisms, I am indebted to Hamish Forbes, Peter Garnsey, Wim Jongman and Anthony Snodgrass; also to Jim Lewthwaite for a decade of obscure bibliographic clues, often illegible but sometimes invaluable; and to the library staff of the Ινστιτούτο Σιτηρών, Thessaloniki, for copies of publications of Greek rotation and fallowing experiments. Above all, thanks are due to the many farmers and shepherds in Cyprus, Greece, Spain and Italy who have, over the last fifteen years, treated my ignorant enquiries into their affairs with extraordinary patience and good humour.

1 For a critique of such uniformitarian assumptions about rural life in Greece, see Danforth, L. M., Journal of Modern Greek Studies ii (1985) 53–85Google Scholar.

2 E.g. Jarman, M. R., Bailey, G. N. and Jarman, H. N. (eds.) Early European agriculture (Cambridge 1982)Google Scholar.

3 E.g. Semple, E. C., The geography of the Mediterranean region and its relation to ancient history (London 1932)Google Scholar; Grigg, D. B., The agricultural systems of the world: an evolutionary approach (Cambridge 1974)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Barker, G., Prehistoric farming in Europe (Cambridge 1985)Google Scholar.

4 Semple (n. 3) 323.

5 Kilian, K., Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt ii (1972) 115–23Google Scholar; Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt iii (1973) 431–5Google Scholar; Barker, G., ‘Prehistoric territories and economy in central Italy’, in Higgs, E. S. (ed.) Palaeoeconomy (Cambridge 1975) 111–75Google Scholar; Jarman et al. (n. 2).

6 Higgs, E. S., Vita-Finzi, C., Harris, D. R. and Fagg, A. E., Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society xxxiii (1967) 1–29Google Scholar.

7 Semple (n. 3) 386; Finley, M. I., The ancient economy (London 1973) 108Google Scholar; Jones, R. Duncan, The economy of the Roman empire; quantitative studies2 (Cambridge 1982) 49Google Scholar; but cf. White, K. D., Roman farming (London 1970) 119–21Google Scholar.

8 Richter, W., Die Landwirtschaft im homerischen Zeitalter (Archaeologia Homerica ii. H [Göttingen 1968]) 100–1Google Scholar; van Wersch, H. J., ‘The agricultural economy’, in McDonald, W. A. and Rapp, G. R. (eds.) The Minnesota Messenia expedition (Minneapolis 1972) 183–4Google Scholar; Sherratt, A. G., World Archaeology xi (1980) 313–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wagstaff, M., Augustson, S. and Gamble, C., ‘Alternative subsistence strategies’, in Renfrew, C. and Wagstaff, M. (eds.) An island polity: the archaeology of exploitation in Melos (Cambridge 1982) 177Google Scholar; Bintliff, J. L. and Snodgrass, A. M., Journal of Field Archaeology xii (1985) 142Google Scholar.

9 Renfrew, C., The emergence of civilisation: the Cyclades and the Aegean in the third millennium BC (London 1972)Google Scholar.

10 Grigg (n. 3) 141–4.

11 See also S. Aschenbrenner, ‘A contemporary community’, in McDonald and Rapp (n. 8) 49; Lewthwaite, J. G., ‘Acorns for the ancestors: the prehistoric exploitation of woodlands in the west Mediterranean’, in Limbrey, S. and Bell, M. (eds.) Archaeological aspects of woodland ecology (British Archaeological Reports International Series cxlvi [Oxford 1982]) 218Google Scholar.

12 Semple (n. 3) 297; Grigg (n. 3) 125.

13 Semple (n. 3) 300.

14 Grigg (n. 3) 125.

15 E.g. Campbell, J. K., Honour, family, and patronage (Oxford 1964) 10–11Google Scholar.

16 Higgs et al. (n. 6); Barker (n. 5); Jarman et al. (n. 2); Frayn, J. M., Sheep-rearing and the wool trade in Italy during the Roman period (Liverpool 1984)Google Scholar.

17 Higgs et al. (n. 6) G. Mavrommatis pers. comm.

18 Admiralty, Naval Intelligence Division, Greece, i: physical geography, history, administration and peoples (Geographical Handbook Series [Andover 1944])Google Scholar; Quezel, P., Vegetatio xiv (1967) 127–228CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Turrill, W.B., The plant-life of the Balkan peninsula (Oxford 1929)Google Scholar.

20 E.g. van Zeist, W. and Bottema, S., ‘Vegetational history of the eastern Mediterranean and the Near East during the last 20,000 years’, in Bintliff, J. L. and van Zeist, W. (eds.) Palaeoclimates, palaeoenvironments and human communities in the eastern Mediterranean region in later prehistory (British Archaeological Reports International Series cxxxiii [Oxford 1982]) 277–321Google Scholar.

21 Williamson, G. and Payne, W.J. A., An introduction to animal husbandry in the tropics2 (London 1965) 79Google Scholar; Pernet, F. and Lenclud, G., Bergeren Corse (Grenoble 1977)Google Scholar.

22 Lewthwaite, J. G., ‘Plain tails from the hills: transhumance in Mediterranean archaeology’, in Sheridan, A. and Bailey, G. (eds.) Economic archaeology: towards an integration of ecological and social approaches (British Archaeological Reports International Series xcvi [Oxford 1981]) 57–66Google Scholar.

23 Wace, A.J. B. and Thompson, M. S., Nomads of the Balkans (London 1914)Google Scholar; Campbell (n. 15); Gage, N., Eleni (London 1983)Google Scholar.

24 Campbell (n. 15) 363–4.

25 See also Lees, S. H. and Bates, D. G., American Antiquity xxxix (1974) 187–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Briant, P., État et pasteurs au moyen-orient ancien (Cambridge 1982) 235Google Scholar.

26 See e.g. the extensive pollen record from central and northern Greece: Wijmstra, T. A., Acta Botanica Neerlandica xviii (1969) 511–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar; H. E. Wright, ‘Vegetation history’, in McDonald and Rapp (n. 8); Bottema, S., Late quaternary vegetation history of northwestern Greece (Groningen 1974)Google Scholar; Palaeohistoria xxi (1979) 19–40Google Scholar; Acta Botanica Neerlandica xxix (1980) 343–9Google Scholar; Palaeohistoria xxiv (1982) 257–89Google Scholar; Greig, J. R. A. and Turner, J., Journal of Archaeological Science i (1974) 177–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Turner, J. and Greig, J., Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology xx (1975) 171–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Athanasiadhis, N., Flora clxiv (1975) 99–132CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Finley (n. 7).

28 Avramea, A. P., H βυʒαντινή θεσσαλία μέχρι του 1204 (Βιβλιοθήκη Σ.Ν. Σαριπόλου 27), (Athens 1974) 66Google Scholar.

29 The antiquity of transhumant pastoralism cannot be resolved by archaeological survey alone: the often ephemeral habitations of mobile pastoralists can be archaeologically invisible, especially in the difficult terrain of the mountains; conversely, to interpret all high mountain occupation sites as the remains of transhumant pastoralists is begging the question.

30 Garnsey, P., ‘Mountain economies in southern Europe or: thoughts on the early history, continuity and individuality of Mediterranean upland pastoralism’ in Mattmüller, M. (ed.), ‘Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft von Berggebieten’, Itinera v/vi (Basel 1986), 7–29Google Scholar.

31 Semple (n. 3) 386; White (n. 7) 113, 118.

32 Semple (n. 3) 411; White (n. 7) 129.

33 E.g. Christodoulou, D., The evolution of the rural land use pattern in Cyprus (World Land Use Survey Regional Monograph ii [Bude 1959]) 28–33Google Scholar.

34 James, H. M. and Frangopoulos, A., Cyprus Agricultural Journal xxxiv (1939) 5–19Google Scholar; Littlejohn, L., Empire Journal of Experimental Agriculture xiv (1946) 123–33Google Scholar; Loizides, P. A., Empire Journal of Experimental Agriculture xxvi (1958) 25–33Google Scholar.

35 B. Φ. Κοκόλιος Γεωπονικά 110–111 (1963) 1–15; Σ.Ε. Σωτηριάδης, Γεωργική Ερευνα ί (1977) 125–36.

36 Williams, M., The making of the south Australian landscape (New York 1974)Google Scholar; Chatterton, B. A. and Chatterton, L., Libyan Studies xv (1984) 157–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 E.g. Loizides, P. A., ‘The cereal-fallow rotation in Cyprus’, Proceedings of the first Commonwealth conference on tropical and subtropical soils (Commonwealth Bureau of Soil Science, Technical Communication xlvi [Harpenden 1948)] 210Google Scholar.

38 Also, in the recent, heavily deforested landscape, farmers have sometimes needed to use available dung as fuel—e.g. de Vooys, A. C., Tijdschrift van het Koninklijk Nederlandsch Aardrijkskundig Genootschap lxxvi (1959) 31–54Google Scholar.

39 Dovring, F., Land and labor in Europe 1900–1950 (The Hague 1960) 404CrossRefGoogle Scholar; M. Wagstaff and C. Gamble, ‘Island resources and their limitations’, in Renfrew and Wagstaff (n. 8) 103.

40 Dovring (n. 39) 15, 26–7; Christodoulou (n. 33); Chisholm, M., Rural settlement and land use2 (London 1968)Google Scholar; Silverman, S. F., American Anthropologist ixx (1968) 1–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Forbes, H. A., Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences cclxviii (1976) 236–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar; M. Wagstaff and S. Augustson, ‘Traditional land use’, in Renfrew and Wagstaff (n. 8) 108.

41 E.g. Wagstaff and Augustson (n. 40) 119.

42 E.g. Forbes, H. A., Expedition xix. i (1976) 5–11Google Scholar.

43 E.g. Halstead, P., ‘Counting sheep in Neolithic and Bronze Age Greece’, in Hodder, I., Isaac, G. and Hammond, N. (eds.), Pattern of the past: studies in honour of David Clarke (Cambridge 1981) 307–39Google Scholar

44 Garnsey, P. D. A., Proceedings of Cambridge Philological Society ccv (1979) 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Keller, D. R. and Rupp, D. W. (eds.), Archaeological survey in the Mediterranean area (British Archaeological Reports International Series clv [Oxford 1983])Google Scholar.

45 Osborne, R., ABSA lxxx (1985) 119–28Google Scholar.

46 T.W. Gallant, ‘The Ionian Islands paleo-economy research project’, in Keller and Rupp (n. 44); Bintliff and Snodgrass (n. 8).

47 Snodgrass, A. M., Annates (É.S.C.) v–vi (1982) 800–12Google Scholar; see also Wilkinson, T. J., Journal of Field Archaeology ix (1982) 323–33Google Scholar; Crowther, D., Scottish Archaeological Review ii (1983) 31–44Google Scholar; Williamson, T. M., Britannia xv (1984) 225–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48 E.g. Christodoulou (n. 33) 182–3.

49 White (n. 7) 336, citing an unpublished paper of K. Hopkins; cf. Delille, G., Agricohura e demografia nel regno di Napoli nei secoli xviii e xix (Naples 1977)Google Scholar, who cites maximum cultivable areas of 3·5 ha and 10 ha respectively for smallholdings without and with a pair of oxen (pp. 127–9) and a requirement of up to 10–12 ha of grazing to maintain a single ox (p. 135).

50 Forbes, H. A., Strategies and soils: technology, production and environment in the peninsula of Methana, Greece (Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania 1982) 217Google Scholar; Delille (n. 49); White (n. 7) 484 n. 5.

51 White, K. D., Agricultural implements of the Roman world (Cambridge 1967)Google Scholar.

52 E.g. Delille (n. 49) 118 fig. 39.

53 Goody, J., Production and reproduction Cambridge Studies in Social Anthropology xvii (1976)Google Scholar; see also Gilman, A., Current Anthropology xxii (1981) 1–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar; A. G. Sherratt, ‘Plough and pastoralism: aspects of the secondary products revolution’, in Hodder et al. (n. 43).

54 G. Jones and P. Halstead, ‘Traditional crop processing in Amorgos, Greece’, (in preparation).

55 E.g. Sigaut, F., L'agriculture et le feu Cahiers des Études Rurales i (Paris 1975) 220–1Google Scholar.

56 McConnell, P., The agricultural notebook (London 1883)Google Scholar.

57 Duncan-Jones (n. 7) 330.

58 Sahlins, M., Stone age economics (London 1974)Google Scholar.

59 Forbes (n. 40); (n. 50); J. O'Shea, ‘Coping with scarcity: exchange and social storage’, in Sheridan and Bailey (n. 22).

60 Hill, P., Rural Hausa: a village and a setting (Cambridge 1972)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

61 Cf. Rowley-Conwy, P. A., ‘Slash and burn in the temperate European Neolithic’, in Mercer, R. J. (ed.), Farming practice in British prehistory (Edinburgh 1981) 85–96Google Scholar.

62 E.g. Skorda, E. A., ‘Constraints to cereal production and possible solutions in Greece’, Fifth regional cereals workshop, Algiers, i (Algiers 1979) 30Google Scholar.

63 van Bath, B. H. Slicher, The agrarian history of western Europe AD 500–1850 (London 1963)Google Scholar; Duby, G., Rural economy and country life in the medieval west (London 1968)Google Scholar.

64 E.g. E.van Cauwenberghe, and van der Wee, H. (eds.) Productivity of land and agricultural innovation in the Low Countries (1250–1800) (Leuven 1978) 125–39Google Scholar.

65 Percival, J., The wheat plant (London 1921) 421–2Google Scholar; Arnon, I., Crop production in dry regions, 2: systematic treatment of the principal crops (London 1972) 48Google Scholar.

66 E.g. Hopkins, K., Conquerors and slaves (Cambridge 1978)Google Scholar; Rathbone, D. W., JRS lxxi (1981) 10–23Google Scholar.

67 Finley (n. 7) 109.

68 Finley (n. 7) 127.

69 Cf. Boulay, J. du, Portrait of a Greek mountain village (Oxford 1974) 33–7Google Scholar; Forbes (n. 50).

70 Finley (n. 7).

71 Duncan-Jones (n. 7).

72 E.g. Finley (n. 7) 102–3; Hopkins (n. 66).

73 E.g. Finley (n. 7) 169–70; Austin, M. M. and Vidal-Naquet, P., Economic and social history of ancient Greece: an introduction (London 1977) 291–4Google Scholar.

74 Duncan-Jones (n. 7) 38.

75 Duncan-Jones (n. 7) 146.

76 Cf. Duby (n. 63) 23, suggesting that Pliny is describing extensive, but Columella intensive agriculture; cf. also M. H.Jameson, CJ (1977–8) 122–45.