Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T07:34:35.960Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Revelry and riot in Archaic Megara: democratic disorder or ritual reversal?*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 February 2012

Sara Forsdyke
Sara Forsdyke
Affiliation:
University of Michigan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Plutarch (probably following Aristotle's lost Constitution of the Megarians) associates several episodes of riotous behaviour with the existence of a radical democracy in Archaic Megara (Moralia 295c-d, 304e-f). Modern historians, in turn, have accepted that Megara was ruled by a democracy in the mid sixth century BC. I suggest that this conclusion is unjustified because the connection between riotous behaviour and democracy in Plutarch is based on fourth-century anti-democratic political thought. I propose instead that anecdotes describing the insolent behaviour of the poor towards the rich are better interpreted in terms of customary rituals of social inversion and transgression. Drawing on comparative examples from the ancient world and early modern Europe, I show that popular revelry involving role reversal and transgression of social norms was an important locus for the negotiation of relations between élites and masses. I argue that such rituals provided temporary release from the constraints of the social hierarchy, and served to articulate symbolically the obligation of the powerful to protect the weak. The comparative examples show that such rituals were usually non-revolutionary, but could turn violent in times of rapid social and economic change. I argue that the violent episodes reported by Plutarch reflect the escalation of ritual revelry into real protest and riot in response to the breakdown of traditional relations of reciprocity between rich and poor in Archaic Megara. I suggest that élites in Archaic Megara successfully warded off more far-reaching rebellion and political reform by enacting new measures for the economic relief of the poor (e.g. the return of interest legislation). In conclusion, I address the broader historical question of why subordinate groups use ritual forms to express discontent.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Hellenic Studies , Volume 125 , November 2005 , pp. 73 - 92
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Abrahams, R.D. and Bauman, R. (1972) ‘Ranges of festival behavior’, in Babcock, B.A. (ed.), The Reversible World. Symbolic Inversion in Art and Society (Ithaca) 193–208Google Scholar
Balot, R.K. (2001) Greed and Injustice in Classical Athens (Princeton)Google Scholar
Beard, M., North, J. and Price, S. (1998) Religions of Rome 2: A Sourcebook (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Bowie, E.L. (1997) ‘The Theognidea: a step towards a collection of fragments?’, in Most, G.W. (ed.), Collecting Fragments/Fragmente sammeln (Göttingen) 53–66Google Scholar
Bradtke, E. (2000) Truculent Rustics. Molly Dancing in East Anglia before 1940 (London)Google Scholar
Brock, R. and Hodkinson, S. (eds) (2000) Alternatives to Athens. Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece (Oxford)Google Scholar
Burke, P. (1978) Popular Culture in Early Modern Europe (New York)Google Scholar
Burkert, W. (1985) Greek Religion (Cambridge, MA)Google Scholar
Cobb-Stevens, V., Figueira, T.J. and Nagy, G. (1985) ‘Introduction’, in T.J. Figueira and G. Nagy (eds) (1985) 1–8Google Scholar
Cole, S.G. (1993) ‘Procession and celebration at the Dionysia’, in Scodel (1993) 25–38Google Scholar
Connor, W.R. (1987) ‘Tribes, festivals and processions in Archaic Greece’, JHS 107, 40–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Coulton, G.G. (1925) The Medieval Village (Cambridge)Google Scholar
Darnton, R. (1984) The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes in French Cultural History (New York)Google Scholar
Davis, N.Z. (1975) Society and Culture in Early Modern France (Stanford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Angelis, F. (1994) ‘The foundation of Selinous: overpopulation or opportunities?’, in Tsetskhladze, G.R. and de Angelis, F. (eds), The Archaeology of Greek Colonization. Essays Dedicated to Sir John Boardman (Oxford) 87–110Google Scholar
Edwards, A.T. (1993) ‘Historicizing the popular grotesque: Bakhtin's Rabelais and Attic Old Comedy’, in Scodel (1993) 89–117Google Scholar
Figueira, T.J. and Nagy, G. (eds) (1985) Theognis of Megara. Poetry and the Polis (Baltimore)Google Scholar
Fisher, N. and van Wees, H. (eds) (1998) Archaic Greece. New Approaches and New Evidence (Wales)Google Scholar
Fluck, H. (1931) Skurrile Riten in griechischen Kulten (Endingen)Google Scholar
Foley, H.P. (ed.) (1994) The Homeric Hymn to Demeter. Translation, Commentary, and Interpretive Essays (Princeton)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forsdyke, S. (2001) ‘Athenian democratic ideology and Herodotus' Histories’, AJP 122, 333–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Forsdyke, S. (in press) Exile, Ostracism and Democracy. The Politics of Expulsion in Ancient Greece (Princeton)Google Scholar
Forsdyke, S. (forthcoming) ‘Land, labor and economy in Solonian Athens: breaking the impasse between history and archaeology’, in Blok, J. and Lardinois, A. (eds), Solon. New Historical and Philological Perspectives (Leiden)Google Scholar
Foxhall, L. (1997) ‘A view from the top. Evaluating the Solonian property classes’, in Mitchell, L.G. and Rhodes, P.J. (eds), The Development of the Polis in Archaic Greece (London) 113–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frier, B.W. (2000) ‘More is worse: some observations on the population of the Roman Empire’, in Scheidel, W. (ed.), Debating Roman Demography (Leiden) 139–59Google Scholar
Gluckman, M. (1956) Custom and Conflict in Africa (Oxford)Google Scholar
Gluckman, M. (1963) Order and Rebellion in Tribal Africa (London)Google Scholar
Graham, A.J. (1982) ‘The colonial expansion of Greece’, in Boardman, J. and Hammond, N.G.L. (eds), The Cambridge Ancient History III.3 (2nd edn, Cambridge) 83–162CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Halliwell, S. (2000) ‘Le rire rituel et la nature de l'Ancienne Comédie attique’, in Desclos, M.-L. (ed.), Le rire des Grecs (Grenoble)Google Scholar
Hansen, M.H. (1990) ‘Solonian democracy in fourth-century Athens’, in Connor, W.R.et al. (eds), Aspects of Athenian Democracy (Copenhagen) 71–99Google Scholar
Hobsbawm, E. (1959) Primitive Rebels. Studies in Archaic Forms of Social Movement in the 19th and 20th Centuries (Manchester)Google Scholar
Hopkins, K. (1991) ‘From violence to blessing: symbols and rituals in ancient Rome’, in Molho, A., Raaflaub, K. and Emlen, Julia (eds), City-States in Classical Antiquity and Medieval Italy (Ann Arbor) 479–98Google Scholar
Hornblower, S. (1996) A Commentary on Thucydides 2: Books IV–V.24 (Oxford)Google Scholar
Johnston, A.W. and Jones, R.E. (1978) ‘The “SOS” Amphora’, ABSA 73, 103–41Google Scholar
Kertzer, D.I. (1988) Ritual, Politics and Power (New Haven)Google Scholar
Lane, Fox R. (2000) ‘Theognis: an alternative to democracy’, in Brock and Hodkinson (2000) 35–51Google Scholar
Le Goff, J. and Schmitt, J.-C. (eds) (1981) Le Charivari. Actes de la table ronde organisée à Paris (25–27 avril 1977) par l'École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales et le Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (Paris)Google Scholar
Legon, R.P. (1981) Megara. The Political History of a Greek City-State to 336 B.C. (Ithaca)Google Scholar
Le Roy, Ladurie E. (1974) The Peasants of Languedoc (Illinois)Google Scholar
Lincoln, B. (ed.) (1985) Religion, Rebellion, Revolution. An Interdisciplinary and Cross-cultural Collection of Essays (London)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morris, I. (2002) ‘Hard surfaces’, in Cartledge, Paulet al. (eds), Money, Labour and Land. Approaches to the Economies of Ancient Greece (London and New York) 8–43Google Scholar
Nissenbaum, S. (1996) The Battle for Christmas (New York)Google Scholar
Ober, J. (1998) Political Dissent in Democratic Athens. Intellectual Critics of Popular Rule (Princeton)Google Scholar
O'Higgins, D.M. (2001) ‘Women's cultic joking and mockery. Some perspectives’, in Lardinois, A. and McClure, L. (eds), Making Silence Speak. Women's Voices in Greek Literature and Society (Princeton) 137–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Okin, L.A. (1985) ‘Theognis and the sources for the history of Archaic Megara’, in Figueira and Nagy (1985) 9–21Google Scholar
Oost, S.I. (1973) ‘The Megara of Theagenes and Theognis’, CP 68, 186–96Google Scholar
Osborne, R. (1996) ‘Pots, trade and the Archaic Greek economy’, Antiquity 77, 31–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Osborne, R. (1998) ‘Early Greek colonization? The nature of Greek settlement in the west’, in Fisher and van Wees (1998) 251–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parke, H.W. (1977) Festivals of the Athenians (Ithaca)Google Scholar
Parker, R. (1996) Athenian Religion. A History (Oxford)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Passow, A. (1860) Popularia carmina graeciae recentioris (Leipzig)Google Scholar
Piccirilli, L. (1975) Megarika. Testimonianze e frammenti (Pisa)Google Scholar
Raaflaub, K.A. (1979) ‘Polis tyrannos: Zur Entstehung einer politischen Metaphor’, in Bowersock, G.W., Burkert, W. and Putnam, M.C.J. (eds), Arktouros. Hellenic Studies Presented to Bernard M. W. Knox on the Occasion of his 65th Birthday (Berlin)Google Scholar
Raaflaub, K.A. (1996) ‘Solone, la nuova Atene e l'emergere della politica’, in Settis, S. (ed.), I Greci. Storia, Cultura, Arte, Società II.I (Turin) 1035–81Google Scholar
Rhodes, P. (1981) A Commentary on the Aristotelian Athenaion Politela (Oxford; reprinted with addenda and corrigenda, 1993)Google Scholar
Robinson, E.W. (1997) The First Democracies. Early Popular Government Outside Athens (Stuttgart)Google Scholar
Sale, K. (1995) Rebels against the Future. The Luddites and their War on the Industrial Revolution. Lessons for the Computer Age (Reading, MA)Google Scholar
Scheidel, W. (2003) ‘The Greek demographic expansion: models and comparisons’, JHS 123, 120–40CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Scodel, R. (ed.) (1993) Theater and Society in the Classical World (Ann Arbor)Google Scholar
Smyth, H.W. (1906) Greek Melic Poets (New York)Google Scholar
Stallybrass, P. and White, A. (1986) The Politics and Poetics of Transgression (Ithaca)Google Scholar
Thomas, K. (1964) ‘Work and leisure’, Past and Present 29, 50–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, E.P. (1975) Whigs and Hunters. The Origins of the Black Act (London)Google Scholar
Thompson, E.P. (1993) Customs in Common (London)Google Scholar
Trypanis, C.A. (1971) The Penguin Book of Greek Verse (Harmondsworth)Google Scholar
Turner, V. (1969) The Ritual Process (London)Google Scholar
Underdown, D. (1985) Revel, Riot, and Rebellion. Popular Politics and Culture in England 1603–1660 (Oxford)Google Scholar
van Wees, H. (1999) ‘The Mafia of early Greece. Violent exploitation in the seventh and sixth centuries BC’, in Hopwood, K. (ed.), Organized Crime in Antiquity (London) 1–51Google Scholar
van Wees, H. (2000) ‘Megara's Mafiosi: timocracy and violence in Theognis’, in Brock and Hodkinson (2000) 52–67Google Scholar
Versnel, H.S. (1993) Inconsistencies in Greek and Roman Religion 2: Transition and Reversal in Myth and Ritual (Leiden)Google Scholar
Wallace, R.W. (1997) ‘Solonian democracy’, in Morris, I. and Raaflaub, K. (eds), Democracy 2500? Questions and Challenges, AIA Colloquium and Conference Papers 2 (Dubuque, Iowa) 11–29Google Scholar
Warmington, E.H. (ed.) (1961) Remains of Old Latin 1 (Cambridge, MA)Google Scholar
Winkler, J.J. (1990) ‘The laughter of the oppressed: Demeter and the Gardens of Adonis’, in Winkler, J.J., The Constraints of Desire. The Anthropology of Sex and Gender in Ancient Greece (London)Google Scholar
Zeitlin, F.I. (1996) Playing the Other. Gender and Society in Classical Greek Literature (Chicago)Google Scholar