Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T15:41:54.641Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Development advisors in a time of cold war and decolonization: the United Nations Technical Assistance Administration, 1950–59*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 June 2011

David Webster
David Webster
Affiliation:
International Studies Program, University of Regina, Regina SK, S4S 0A2, Canada E-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The United Nations Technical Assistance Administration (TAA) was the world organization’s main body for development advice throughout the 1950s. In technical assistance, the UN found a global mission at a time when its peace and security functions seemed ineffective. Technical assistance experts preached the need for less developed countries to plan and modernize. This process has been studied with regard to American modernization theory, but the important role of the UN as an autonomous diplomatic actor has been less visible. The UN was a relatively acceptable source of technical assistance for many governments. Among them was Indonesia, which welcomed UN help for its State Planning Bureau. TAA aid to the Planning Bureau advanced the interests of both organizations but both failed to institutionalize themselves enough to survive the decade. Both, however, left important legacies: the TAA for UN development thinking, and the Planning Bureau for the Indonesian developmentalist state.

Keywords

aiddevelopment advisorsIndonesiatechnical assistanceUnited Nations
Type
Articles
Information
Journal of Global History , Volume 6 , Issue 2 , July 2011 , pp. 249 - 272
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 United Nations Archives (henceforth UNA), S-0441-1416-01, John Fried to Hugh Keenleyside, 15 January 1952.

2 Saing, Soe, United Nations technical aid in Burma: a short survey, Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1990, p. 11Google Scholar.

3 Sunil Amrith and Glenda Sluga, ‘New histories of the United Nations’, Journal of World History, 19, 3, 2008, pp. 251–74.

4 Rist, Gilbert, The history of development: from Western origins to global faith, 2nd edition, London: Zed Books, 2002Google Scholar; Jürgen Osterhammel, ‘“Technical co-operation” between the League of Nations and China’, Modern Asian Studies, 13, 4, 1979, pp. 661–80; Margherita Zanasi, ‘Exporting development: the League of Nations and Republican China’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 49, 1, 2007, pp. 143–69.

5 Cowen, M. P. and Shenton, R. W., Doctrines of development, London: Routledge, 1996CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 H. L. Keenleyside, ‘Administrative problems of the United Nations Technical Assistance Administration’, Public Administration, 33, 3, 1955, p. 244.

7 Indonesian ambassador to UK Subandrio, speech to Scottish Provisional Committee for War on Want, Glasgow, 21 November 1953; US Secretary of Agriculture Charles F. Brannan, cited in Wolf, Charles Jr., Foreign aid: theory and practice in southern Asia, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1960, p. 63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Generation: portrait of the United Nations Development Programme, New York: UNDP, 1985, pp. 17–18Google Scholar.

9 Benjamin Higgins with Jean Downing Higgins, ‘The reluctant planner: an overview of planning in developing countries’, TIMS Studies in the Management Sciences, 17, 1981, p. 15; Higgins, Benjamin, Nationalism and colonialism, Cambridge, MA: MIT Center for International Studies, 1955Google Scholar.

10 Keenleyside, Hugh, International aid: a summary, with special reference to the programmes of the United Nations, Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1966, p. 121Google Scholar; Rist, History of development, pp. 71–2; Sachs, Wolfgang, ed., The development dictionary, London: Zed Books, 2010Google Scholar.

11 Ekbladh, David. The great American mission: modernization and the construction of an American world order, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2010, p. 109CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

12 Westad, Odd Arne, The global cold war: Third World interventions and the making of our times, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006Google Scholar; Michael Latham, ‘Introduction: modernization, international history, and the cold war world’, in Engerman, David C. et al., eds., Staging growth: modernization, development, and the global cold war, Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, 2003, p. 9Google Scholar.

13 The Colombo Plan for co-operative economic development in South and South-East Asia: report by the Commonwealth Consultative Committee, London: His Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1950, p. 1Google Scholar.

14 Library and Archives Canada (henceforth LAC), RG25/7337/11038–40[21.2], St Laurent speech in Victoria BC, 4 May 1957.

15 Summary records cited in Bhouraskar, Digambar, United Nations development aid: a study in history and politics, New Delhi: Academic Foundation, 2007, p. 26Google Scholar.

16 Economic and Social Council, Official Records (henceforth ESCOR), second session, seventh meeting, 4 June 1946; resolution 200, in Yearbook of the United Nations (henceforth YUN), 1948–9, p. 437.

17 Lie, Trygve, In the cause of peace: seven years with the United Nations, New York: Macmillan, 1954, p. 146Google Scholar.

18 LAC, Hugh L. Keenleyside papers (henceforth HLKP), MG31 E102/8/1, Report of the UN mission to Bolivia, 1951.

19 US draft resolution, 25 Feb. 1949, UN document E/1191; Mahyar Nashat, ‘The United Nations expanded program of technical assistance: a legal analysis of its origins, structures and procedures’, Doctor of Law thesis, University of Geneva, 1978, pp. 13–16, 33–4.

20 Economic and Social Council resolution 222, YUN, 1958–9, pp. 443–6; ‘Economic development of under-developed countries: plan for an expanded co-operative programme of technical assistance for economic development through the United Nations and its specialised agencies’, E/1327/Add.1 (Grey Book).

21 ESCOR, eight session, 251st meeting, 25 February 1949, pp. 306–9.

22 UNA, S-0441-1416-04, note on TAA meeting with US Economic Cooperation Administration officials, 14 December 1950, and David Owen to resident representatives and liaison officers, 30 April 1952; UNA, S-0441-1416-05, US government airgram to selected embassies, April 1952.

23 Trygve Lie, address at University of Quito, Ecuador, 28 February 1951; opening statement at First UN Technical Assistance Conference, 12 June 1950; ‘Memorandum of points for consideration in the development of a twenty-year program for achieving peace through the United Nations’, 6 June 1950, all in Public papers of the Secretaries-General of the United Nations, vol. I: Trygve Lie, 1946–1953, New York: Columbia University Press, 1969, pp. 383–4, 310–11, 301Google Scholar.

24 Lie, In the cause of peace, p. 156; Saskatchewan Archives Board (henceforth SAB), R-757/2, George Cadbury to J. Brockelbank, Saskatchewan minister of resources, 28 January 1952.

25 HKLP 30/32, Peter Stursberg broadcast for CBC News, 9 September 1950; LAC, Peter Stursberg papers, MG 31 D78/35, Keenleyside interview, 28 August 1980; Gerald Hodge, ‘The rise and demise of the UN Technical Assistance Administration’, Canadian Public Administration, 10, 1, March 1967, p. 24.

26 UNA, S-0441-1416-01, G. Palthey, ‘Technical assistance’, 22 March 1949.

27 Keenleyside, International aid, p. 163.

28 Walter O’Hearn, ‘Keenleyside favored for major post at United Nations’, Montreal Daily Star, 14 July 1950.

29 HLKP 30/32, Lester Pearson to Keenleyside, 21 July 1950, and John D. Hickerson to Keenleyside, 29 August 1950.

30 Keenleyside, Hugh, Memoirs, vol. 2: on the bridge of time, Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1982, p. 390Google Scholar; idem, International aid, p. 230; idem, ‘Administrative problems of the United Nations Technical Assistance Administration’, Public Administration, 33, 3, 1955, pp. 241–67; Bhouraskar, United Nations development aid, p. 99; Vas-Zoltán, Peter, United Nations technical assistance, Budapest: Akademi Kiado, 1972, pp. 57, 61, 206–7Google Scholar; Nashat, ‘United Nations expanded program’, p. 33; van Soest, Jaap, The start of international development cooperation in the United Nations 1945–1952, Assen: Van Gorcum, 1978, p. 107Google Scholar; HLKP, 25/7, Keenleyside to Lester Pearson, 15 November 1956.

31 Pierre-Yves Saunier, ‘Ulysses of Chicago: American foundations and public administration, 1900–1960’, in Gemelli, Giuliana and MacLeod, Roy, eds., American foundations in Europe, Brussels: Peter Lang, 2003Google Scholar; UNA S-0441-1416-01, Keenleyside to T.W. Cutts, Australian mission to UN, 14 March 1955.

32 UNA, S-0441-1416-01, John Fried to Keenleyside, 15 January 1952; UNA, S-0441-1449-01, ‘Suggestions for the 1955 and 1956 programmes of technical assistance in Indonesia’, [1954]; Bhouraskar, United Nations development aid, p. 152; UNA, S-0441-1416-06, draft telegram from Cadbury to Owen, 24 April 1952.

33 Majid Rahnema, ‘Participation’ in Sachs, Development dictionary; Cowen and Shenton, Doctrines of development.

34 See, for instance, George Cadbury, ‘Planning in Saskatchewan’, in LaPierre, Laurier et al., eds., Essays on the Left, Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1971Google Scholar.

35 Agarwala, Ramgopal, Planning in developing countries: lessons of experience, Washington, DC: World Bank Staff Working Papers, 1983, p. 4Google Scholar.

36 Arturo Escobar, ‘Planning’ in Sachs, Development dictionary, p. 149.

37 National Archives of the United States (henceforth NA), RG 59, lot file 64 D 207, Colombo Plan 1957, report on annual meeting.

38 State Library of New South Wales, Eleanor M. Hinder papers (henceforth EMHP), 770/8/1, notes on Hinder meeting with Japanese officials, no date [1955]; Benjamin Higgins and Guy Pauker, ‘Economic aspects of the Asian–African conference and its aftermath’, Ekonomi dan Keuangan Indonesia, 8, 1955, p. 244.

39 EMHP, 770/8/1, Hinder reports on Indian study tour of USSR, 1955; Bhouraskar, United Nations development aid, p. 101.

40 Toye, John and Toye, Richard, The UN and global political economy: trade, finance, and development, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 2004Google Scholar; Jolly, Richard et al., UN contributions to development thinking and practice, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 2004Google Scholar.

41 Hirschman, Albert O., Essays in trespassing, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1981, p. 24Google Scholar.

42 Rist, History of development, p. 78.

43 J. Stephen Hoadley, ‘The politics of development planning agencies: the evolution of Indonesia’s Bappenas’, Asia Quarterly, 1, 1978, p. 42; Rahnema, ‘Participation’, p. 129; Agarwala, Planning, p. 8; Mehmet, Ozay, Economic planning and social justice in developing countries, London: Croon Helm, 1978, pp. 17–21Google Scholar.

44 Secretary-General’s report on technical assistance, cited in Nashat, ‘United Nations expanded program’, p. 109; UNA, S-0441-1416-02, H. J. van Mook memorandum to TAA officers, 13 June 1955 and memorandum ‘UN technical assistance in Asia and the Far East 1950–1955’.

45 UNA, S-0441-1416-02, Keenleyside to Lie, 24 August 1951.

46 Nashat, ‘United Nations expanded program’, pp. 183–4; UNA, S-0441-1416-04, notes on TAA–FAO officials meeting, 13 December 1950; EMHP, 770/8/1, Hinder to S. Habib Ahmed, 25 May 1955; UNA S-0441-1416-02, Keenleyside to Lie, 1 September 1951; E/TAC/L.19.

47 SAB, R-757/2, Cadbury to Brockelbank, 28 January 1952; Lie, In the cause of peace, p. 148.

48 EMHP, 770/7, typescript of Goldschmidt speech, no date.

49 UNA, S-0441-1483-03, Keenleyside, welcome letter to experts, 26 March 1952.

50 Grey Book, pp. 31, 73; YUN, 1953, p. 313; UNA, S-0441-1416-01, ‘Relations and division of work between TAA and the Departments of Economic and Social Affairs’.

51 UNA, S-0441-1438-01, 1956 country targets; UNA, S-0441-1449-02, Cadbury to Willem Brand, 29 May 1951 and Ahmed’s notes on visit to Indonesia, 26 February 1955.

52 UNA, S-0441-1448-04, Goldschmidt to Reid, 27 January 1953; UNA, S-0175-0631-02, Manorama Sud to Stuart Rison, 2 January 1959.

53 LAC, RG 25/6613/11129-40[3.1], Pearson’s inaugural instructions to Canadian ambassador in Indonesia, 19 August 1953.

54 Feith, Herbert, The decline of constitutional democracy in Indonesia, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1962Google Scholar.

55 Robison, Richard, Indonesia: the rise of capital, Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1986Google Scholar; Paauw, Douglas, ‘From colonial to guided economy’, in McVey, Ruth T., ed., Indonesia, New Haven, CT: Yale University Southeast Asian Studies, 1963Google Scholar.

56 Mrázek, Rudolf, Engineers of happy land: technology and nationalism in a colony, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2002Google Scholar.

57 Sutter, John O., Indonesianisasi: politics in a changing economy, 1940–1955, Ithaca, NY: Cornell Southeast Asia Project, 1959, vol. 2, p. 496Google Scholar.

58 Library of Congress, Jeanne Mintz papers (henceforth JMP), box 46, UN delegation 1950[1], R. H. D. Liem, ‘Five-year plan for higher training of Indonesian youth’, 17 August 1950.

59 Sjahrir, Sutan, Our struggle, Ithaca, NY: Cornell Modern Indonesia Project, 1968, p. 24Google Scholar; Dick, Howard et al., The emergence of a national economy: an economic history of Indonesia, 1800–2000, Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 2002, p. 171Google Scholar.

60 Feith, Decline, p. 130.

61 Cited in Teuku Dzulkarnain Amin, ‘The process of planning: a study of the effectiveness of Indonesia’s national development planning agencies, 1952–1979’, PhD thesis, University of Pittsburgh, 1982, p. 125.

62 Dick et al., Emergence, p. 178.

63 Paauw, ‘From colonial to guided economy’, p. 217; Sumitro, , The government’s program on industries: a progress report, Jakarta: Institute for Economic and Social Research, 1954Google Scholar; Sutter, Indonesianisasi, vol. 3, pp. 774–8; Robison, Rise of capital, pp. 42–3.

64 NA, RG59, Lot 60D60, Cochran 1951–2, Samuel P. Hayes memorandum for file, 15 February 1952.

65 Translation from the German text of Dr. Hjalmar Schacht’s report on general economic conditions in Indonesia [1951], p. 27; Keenleyside, Memoirs, vol. 2, pp. 396–493; Sumitro, ‘Recollections of my career’, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 22, 3, December 1985, p. 36.

66 HLKP 30/14, Keenleyside travel diary, 3 October 1951; Alatas, Syed Hussein, The myth of the lazy native, London: Cass, 1977Google Scholar.

67 British Documents on Foreign Affairs part IV, series E, vol. 9, pp. 221–3, F. Shepherd, British consul in Batavia, to Ernest Bevin, Foreign Secretary, 31 July 1949.

68 UNA, S-0441-1468-01, L. N. Palar, Indonesian permanent observer to UN, to Lie, 15 March 1950; JMP, box 46, UN delegation 50[1], Palar statement to technical assistance conference, 13 June 1950.

69 UNA, S-0441-1468-01, Keenleyside to Ismail, 23 April 1951; Sumitro, ‘Recollections’, p. 36.

70 HLKP 30/14, Keenleyside travel diary, entries for 3 October and 1 October 1952; Keenleyside, Memoirs, vol. 2, pp. 396–8.

71 UNA, S-0441-1449-01, Cadbury draft report on 1954 Indonesia visit.

72 UNA, S-0441-1448-02, Goldschmidt to Keenleyside, 6 December 1951.

73 UNA, S-0441-1030, J. L. Mandereau, TAA Director of Missions, to C. Hall, Technical Assistance Recruitment Office, 18 September 1952.

74 Higgins, Benjamin, All the difference: a development economist’s quest, Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1992Google Scholar.

75 Benjamin Higgins, ‘Jan Boeke and the doctrine of “the Little Push”’, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 20, 3, December 1984, pp. 55–69; Sumitro, ‘Recollections’, p. 31.

76 Higgins, ‘Jan Boeke’, p. 68.

77 Burnell, Peter J., Economic nationalism in the Third World, Brighton: Wheatsheaf Books, 1986, p. 209Google Scholar.

78 National Archives of Australia, A11064, 809/1 [1], Australian High Commission in Colombo to Department of External Affairs, 26 February 1953.

79 UNA, S-0441-1438-06, Cadbury to Keenleyside, 11 May 1954.

80 UNA, S-0441-1449-01, Stuart Alpert to Hinder, 30 May 1954; UNA, S-0441-1449-02, Hinder to Ahmed, 18 November 1954.

81 UNA, S-0441-1030, Hinder to Keyfitz, 17 April 1954 and Hinder to Cadbury, 14 May 1954.

82 UNA, S-0441-1448-04, Goldschmidt to Hinder, 9 July 1953; UNA, S-0441-1449-02, ‘Planning Bureau Project – experts to be recruited’, 8 March 1955, and Ahmed to Hinder, 26 February 1955.

83 UNA, S-0441-1449-01, Balinski to Hinder, 1 June 1955.

84 Garis-garis besar Rentjana Pembangunan Lima Tahun 1956–1960 [Broad outlines of the Five-Year Development Plan 1956–1960], Jakarta: National Planning Bureau, 1956Google Scholar; MIT Center for International Studies, ‘A summary of the Indonesian Five Year Plan’, 1957; Higgins, Benjamin, Indonesia’s economic stabilization and development, New York: Institute of Pacific Relations, 1957Google Scholar; Dorodjatun Kuntjoro-Jakti, ‘The political economy of development: the case of Indonesia under the New Order government, 1966–1978’, PhD thesis, University of California at Berkeley, 1980, pp. 27–32; Robison, Rise of capital, pp. 36–7; National Planning Bureau, ‘Some explanations on Indonesia’s 1956–1960 Five-Year Development Plan’, Ekonomi dan Keuangan Indonesia, 9, 1956, pp. 661–82; Colombo Plan: report of the sixth meeting of the consultative committee on economic development in South and South-East Asia, Ottawa: Queen’s Printer, 1954, p. 69Google Scholar.

85 Kusudiarso Hadinoto, cited in Ali Budiardjo, ‘Abdi negara dan abdi bangsa [Servant of the state and servant of the nation]’, appendix to Djamin, Awaloedin, Ir. H. Djuanda: negarawan, administrator, teknokrat utama [Engineer Haji Djuanda: statesman, administrator, eminent technocrat], Jakarta: Kompas, 2002, p. 255Google Scholar.

86 Soedjatmoko, ‘Point Four and Southeast Asia’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 270, 1, 1950, p. 74.

87 LAC, RG25/8146/5495-C-2-40[1.2], Canadian ambassador George Heasman to Department of External Affairs, 27 June 1956.

88 Ekbladh, Great American mission, p. 162; NA, RG59, Lot 60D60, file Japan 1954, memorandum of conversation, 28 October 1954.

89 Amin, Process of planning, p. 35.

90 Ariel Heryanto, The development of “development”’, Indonesia, 46, 1988; Roeslan Abdulgani, speech at Univeritas Padjadjaran, 1961, cited in Yamin, Muhammad, Roeslan Abdulgani, Bandung: Universitas Padjadjaran, 1961, pp. 153–64.Google Scholar

91 Nimrod Raphaeli, ‘The planning machinery in Indonesia’, Philippine Journal of Public Administration, 18, 3, 1974, pp. 245–6; Amin, Process of planning, pp. 60–6; Kahin, Audrey and Kahin, George R., Subversion as foreign policy: the secret Eisenhower and Dulles debacle in Indonesia, Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press, 1995.Google Scholar

92 UNA, S-0441-1416-01, Owen to Keenleyside, 1 June 1955 and Keenleyside to Owen, 10 June 1955.

93 Nashat, ‘United Nations expanded program’, p. 178; Hodge, ‘Rise and demise’, p. 24; Keenleyside, International aid, pp. 230–2.

94 UNA, S-0175-0638-03, Gould to Keenleyside, 27 September 1958; ‘Report of the implementation of the programme of the Five Year Development Plan during the years 1956, 1957, and 1958’; Gould to Rison, 12 November 1958.

95 UNA, S-0136-0017-05, M. Tajima, ‘Indonesia’, September 1966; UNA, S-0136-0017-04, Adnan A. Tamini, ‘Report on visit to Indonesia, 19 June–7 July 1964’.

96 Roosa, John, Pretext for mass murder: the September 30 Movement and Suharto’s coup d’etat in Indonesia, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 2006Google Scholar.

97 Mohammad Sadli, ‘The influence of the military on economic development: an analysis drawn mainly from the Indonesian experience’, unpublished paper, MIT Center for International Studies, 1964, p. 15.

98 Most recently and comprehensively in Simpson, Bradley R., Economists with guns: authoritarian development and US–Indonesian relations, 1960–1968, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2008Google Scholar.

99 Sarbini Sumawinata, ‘Recollections of my career’, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 28, 2, 1992, p. 49.

100 UNA, S-0441-1449-01, Alpert to Hinder, 30 May 1954.

101 UNA, S-0441-1449-02, Ahmed’s notes on Indonesia visit, 26 February 1955.

102 UNA, S-0441-1449-01, Cadbury’s 1954 draft report on Indonesia visit.

103 Hoadley, ‘Politics’, pp. 56–65; Amin, Process of planning, pp. 40–3, 152; Papanek, Gustav F., ed., The Indonesian economy, New York: Praeger, 1980Google Scholar.

104 UNA, S-0136-0017-04, Owen mission report, 15 December 1966.

105 Orlando Letelier, ‘Economic “freedom’s” awful toll: the “Chicago boys” in Chile’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 8, 3, 1976, p. 45.

106 ‘Introduction to the fourteenth annual report of the Secretary-General’, 22 August 1959, in Public papers of the Secretaries-General of the United Nations, vol. IV: Dag Hammarskjöld 1958–1960, New York: Columbia University Press, 1974, p. 464Google Scholar.

107 Prashad, Vijay, The darker nations, New York: New Press, 2007Google Scholar.