Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-dsjbd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-30T17:44:40.938Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Lay Catholicism and Religious Policy in Cromwellian Ireland

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 September 2013

JOHN CUNNINGHAM
JOHN CUNNINGHAM*
Affiliation:
Department of History, Trinity College, Dublin 2, Ireland; e-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The conquest of Ireland between 1649 and 1653 created almost as many problems as it solved for the English government of the country. Not least of these was how, if at all, the majority Catholic population was to be won over to Protestantism. This article reassesses Cromwellian religious policy towards the Catholic laity and traces its evolution up to the end of the decade, taking account also of Catholic responses to official measures. It argues that the supposed leniency of government policy has been overstated and that Catholics who refused to conform to Protestantism in fact risked heavy penalties.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 64 , Issue 4 , October 2013 , pp. 769 - 786
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Moran, Patrick Francis, Historical sketch of the persecutions suffered by the Catholics of Ireland under the rule of Cromwell and the Puritans, Dublin 1862, 18–85, 235–67Google Scholar; Forbes-Leith, William, Memoirs of Scottish Catholics during the XVIIth and XVIIIth centuries, London 1909, ii. 55–6, 58–67Google Scholar; Brownlow, William, A short history of the Catholic Church in England, London 1895, 441.Google Scholar

2 Acts and ordinances of the English interregnum, 1642–1660, ed. C. H. Firth and R. S. Rait, London 1911, i. 254–60; ii. 1170–80.

3 Moran, Historical sketch, 273, 342–51; Forbes-Leith, Memoirs of Scottish Catholics, ii. 63–4, 68–9; Brownlow, Catholic Church in England, 441–2; Stone, Jean, The Church in English history: a manual for Catholic schools, Edinburgh–London 1907, 256–7.Google Scholar

4 Moran, Historical sketch, 273.

5 Macinnes, Allan, ‘Catholic recusancy and the penal laws, 1603–1707’, Records of the Scottish Church History Society xxiii (1987), 27–63Google Scholar at p. 54; Anion, Peter, Underground Catholicism in Scotland, Montrose 1970, 52–66.Google Scholar

6 R. Scott Spurlock, ‘Cromwell and Catholics: towards a reassessment of lay Catholic experience in interregnum Ireland’, in S. Forrest and M. Williams (eds), Constructing the past: writing Irish history, 1600–1800, Woodbridge 2010, 157–79 at p. 170.

7 Zagorin, Perez, How the idea of religious toleration came to the west, Princeton–Oxford 2003, 238–9Google Scholar; Coffey, John, Persecution and toleration in early modern England, 1558–1689, Harlow 2000, 157–8Google Scholar; Loomie, Albert, ‘Oliver Cromwell's policy towards the English Catholics: the appraisal by diplomats, 1654–1658’, Catholic Historical Review xc (2004), 29–44 at pp. 30–2Google Scholar; Smith, Terence, ‘The persecution of Staffordshire Roman Catholic recusants, 1625–1660’, this Journal xxx (1979), 327–51Google Scholar at p. 348.

8 Firth, C. H., The last years of the protectorate, Oxford 1909, ii. 148Google Scholar.

9 Moran, Historical sketch, 342–51; Barnard, Toby, ‘Planters and policies in Cromwellian Ireland’, Past & Present lxi (1973), 31–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar at pp. 43–4; Patrick Corish, ‘The Cromwellian regime’, in T. W. Moody, F. X. Martin and F. J. Byrne (eds), A new history of Ireland, III: Early modern Ireland, 1534–1691, Oxford 1976, 353–86 at pp 355, 384; Foster, R. F., Modern Ireland, 1600–1972, London 1988, 105Google Scholar; Gillespie, Raymond, Seventeenth-century Ireland, Dublin 2006, 205Google Scholar; Lenihan, Padraig, Consolidating conquest: Ireland, 1603–1727, Harlow 2008, 144–6Google Scholar; Connolly, S. J., Divided kingdom: Ireland, 1630–1800, Oxford 2008, 116Google Scholar. For more detailed treatments see Barnard, Toby, Cromwellian Ireland: English government and reform in Ireland, 1649–1660, Oxford 1975, 172–4Google Scholar, 180–1, 187, 293; Dickson, David, Old world colony: Cork and south Munster, 1630–1830, Cork 2005, 44–5Google Scholar; Corish, Patrick, The Catholic community in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Dublin 1981, 47–8Google Scholar.

10 Philip Benedict, ‘Religion and politics in the European struggle for stability’, in Philip Benedict and Myron P. Gutmann (eds), Early modern Europe: from crisis to stability, Cranbury 2005, 120–38.

11 Canny, Nicholas, Making Ireland British, 1580–1650, Oxford 2001, 172–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 267, 460–6; Clarke, Aidan, The Old English in Ireland, 1625–1642, London 1966, 28–59Google Scholar, 238–54.

12 Christopher Hill, ‘Seventeenth-century English radicals and Ireland’, in Patrick Corish (ed.), Radicals, rebels and establishments (Historical Studies xv, 1985), 33–49. On contemporary English attitudes towards toleration see John Coffey, ‘The toleration controversy during the English revolution’, in Christopher Durston and Judith Maltby (eds), Religion in revolutionary England, Manchester 2006, 42–68. On radical tolerationists and Catholics see Norah Carlin, ‘Toleration for Catholics in the Puritan revolution’, in Ole Peter Grell and Bob Scribner (eds), Tolerance and intolerance in the European reformation, Cambridge 1996, 216–30.

13 The letters and speeches of Oliver Cromwell with elucidations by Thomas Carlyle, ed. S. C. Lomas, London 1904, i. 493.

14 Ibid. ii. 5–23.

15 Articles of peace made and concluded with the Irish rebels and papists by James Earle of Ormond also, a letter sent by Ormond to Col. Jones, Governour of Dublin, with his answer thereunto, London 1649 (Wing A.3863), 50.

16 Blair Worden, ‘Toleration and the Cromwellian protectorate’, in W. J. Sheils (ed.), Persecution and toleration (Studies in Church History xxi, 1984), 199–233 at pp. 201–2.

17 Letters and speeches of Cromwell, ii. 17.

18 A contemporary history of Irish affairs, from 1641 to 1652, ed. Gilbert, J. T., Dublin 1879–80, iii. 64–5, 83–4Google Scholar.

19 Clarke, The Old English, 216.

20 Contemporary history of Irish affairs, iii. 83–4.

21 Ibid. iii. 87.

22 Ireland under the commonwealth: being a selection of documents relating to the government of Ireland between 1651 and 1659, ed. Dunlop, Robert, Manchester 1913, i. 203Google Scholar; Acts and ordinances, ii. 423–5.

23 Ireland under the commonwealth, i. 213.

24 Ibid. i. 200.

25 Talbot, Peter, The polititians cathechisme for his instruction in divine faith and moral honesty, Antwerp 1658 (Wing F.2181), 158–9Google Scholar. See also the contemporary appraisal offered in John Lynch, Cambrensis eversus, ed. M. Kelly, Dublin 1848–52, iii. 197–9.

26 Journals of the House of Commons, 1547–1714, London 1742, vii. 137–8Google Scholar.

27 Winkelbauer, Thomas, Ständefreiheit und Fürstenmacht: Länder und Untertanen des Hauses Habsburg im konfessionellen Zeitalter, Vienna 2003, ii. 27–8Google Scholar.

28 Spicilegium Ossoriense, ed. Patrick Francis Moran, Dublin 1874–8, ii. 109–11.

29 [MacCaffrey, J.], ‘Commonwealth records’, Archivium Hibernicum vii (1918–21), 20–66Google Scholar at p. 41; O'Ferrall, Richard and O'Connell, Robert, Commentarius Rinnuccinianus, ed. S. Kavanagh, Dublin 1932–49, v. 88–9Google Scholar.

30 Barnard, Cromwellian Ireland, 171–80.

31 Perkins, William and Daniel, Godfrey, The Christian doctrine, or, The foundation of Christian religion gathered into six principles necessarie for every man to learn translated into Irish by Godfrey Daniel; and also brief and plain rules for the reading of the Irish tongue, Dublin 1652Google Scholar (Wing P.1561), sig Aiir.

32 Cunningham, John, Conquest and land in Ireland: the transplantation to Connacht, 1649–1680, Woodbridge 2011Google Scholar, and ‘The Gookin-Lawrence pamphlet debate and transplantation in Cromwellian Ireland’, in Anthony McElligott, Liam Chambers, Ciara Breatnach and Catherine Lawless (eds), Power in history: from the medieval to the post-modern world (Historical Studies xxvii, 2011), 63–80.

33 A collection of the state papers of John Thurloe, ed. Birch, Thomas, London 1742, vii. 632Google Scholar.

34 Ibid.

35 Journals of the House of Commons, vii. 480, 577; Acts and ordinances, ii. 1162–70.

36 Moran, Historical sketch, 273.

37 R. D. Edwards, ‘The Cromwellian persecution’, in The League of Prayer for the Canonisation of Blessed Oliver Plunket (ed.), Blessed Oliver Plunket studies, Dublin 1937, 68–74 at p. 72.

38 Corish, , ‘The Cromwellian regime’, 375–85, and The Irish Catholic experience, Dublin 1985, 112Google Scholar; Gillespie, Seventeenth century Ireland, 205.

39 Tudor and Stuart proclamations, 1485–1714, ed. Steele, R., London 1910, ii, no. 589Google Scholar.

40 Acts and ordinances, ii. 1162–70.

41 Conry, Maurice, Threnodia Hiberno-Catholica, sive planctus universalis totius cleri et populi regni Hiberniae, Innsbruck 1659, 34Google Scholar.

42 O'Ferrall, and O'Connell, , Commentarius Rinnuccinianus, v. 367–89Google Scholar.

43 Thurloe state papers, vii. 632.

44 Acts and ordinances, ii. 1170–80.

45 Johann Sommerville, ‘Papalist political thought and the controversy over the Jacobean oath of allegiance’, in Ethan Shagan (ed.), Catholics and the Protestant nation: religious politics and identity in early modern England, Manchester 2005, 162–78; Ronald G. Asch, ‘Die Krise des Königtums und die Resakralisierung monarchiser Herrschaft in England und Frankreich an der Wender vom 16: zum 17. Jahrhundert’, in Václav Bůžek (ed.), Ein Bruderzwist im Hause Habsburg, 1608–1611 (Opera Historica xiv, 2010), 11–34.

46 Loomie, ‘Oliver Cromwell's policy’, 30–2; Smith, ‘Persecution of Staffordshire Roman Catholic recusants’, 327–51.

47 Acts and ordinances, ii. 1170–80.

48 The diary of Thomas Burton, ed. Rutt, J. T., London 1826, ii. 140–55Google Scholar.

49 The correspondence of Henry Cromwell, 1655–1659, ed. Peter Gaunt (Camden 5th ser. xxxi, 2008), nos 318, 342; Thurloe state papers, vi. 527, 539.

50 Firth, The protectorate, ii. 148.

51 Spurlock, ‘Cromwell and Catholics’, 175.

52 Canny, Making Ireland British, 294; Ireland under the commonwealth, ii. 283.

53 Thurloe state papers, vii. 632.

54 Moran, Historical sketch, 342–51.

55 BL, ms Add. 72,877, fo. 123.

56 BL, ms Lansdowne 1,228, fos 7v–8.

57 Thurloe state papers, vi. 454–5, 515, 527.

58 Ibid. vi. 509.

59 Ibid. i. 479, 595, 619–20.

60 Correspondence of Henry Cromwell, no. 342.

61 TNA, SP 25/78, fo. 572.

62 National Library of Ireland, ms Bellew of Mountbellew 31,946.

63 Terry Clavin, ‘Talbot, Peter (1618/20–1680)’, ODNB [http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/26937, accessed 1 May 2011]; Spicilegium Ossoriense, ii. 133–5.

64 The Nicholas papers, ed. Warner, G. F., London 1886–1920, iii. 217Google Scholar; Calendar of the Clarendon state papers, ed. Ogle, O. and others, Oxford 1869–1970, iv. 254.Google Scholar; Krugler, J. D., English and Catholic: the Lords Baltimore in the seventeenth century, Baltimore–London 2004, 193–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On Talbot's activities in London see Cunningham, John ‘Oliver Cromwell and the “Cromwellian” settlement of Ireland’, HJ liii (2010), 919–37Google Scholar.

65 ms Bellew of Mountbellew 31,946.

66 Ibid.

67 Talbot, The polititians cathechisme, 155–62.

68 Allison, A. F., ‘An English Gallican: Henry Holden, 1596/7–1662’, Recusant History xxii (1995), 319–49Google Scholar; Collins, J. R., ‘Thomas Hobbes and the Blackloist Conspiracy of 1649’, HJ xlv (2002), 305–31Google Scholar at p. 314.

69 Mullett, M. A., Catholics in Britain and Ireland, 1558–1829, Basingstoke 1998, 75–6Google Scholar.

70 Desiderata curiosa, ed. Peck, F., London 1732–5, ii/9, 10–11Google Scholar.

71 [Austin, John], The Christian moderator: the second part, or, persecvtion for religion condemned, London 1652Google Scholar (Wing A.4246), 3–6.

72 Terry Clavin, ‘Talbot, Sir William (d. 1634)’, in James Maguire and James Quinn (eds), Dictionary of Irish biography, Cambridge 2009, ix. 260–1.

73 Clarke, The Old English, 84–5.

74 ms Lansdowne 1,228, fo. 8.

75 Cunningham, ‘Cromwell and the “Cromwellian” settlement’, 919–37, and Ireland under the commonwealth, ii. 414.

76 Loomie, ‘Oliver Cromwell's policy’, 37–9.

77 SP 25/78, fos 569, 571.

78 Charles Fleetwood to Edward Montagu, 6 Apr. 1655, Bodleian Library, Oxford, ms Carte 74, fo. 41.

79 Thurloe state papers, ii. 343.

80 McNeill, Charles, ‘Report on the Rawlinson collection of manuscripts’, Analecta Hibernica i (1930), 12–117Google Scholar at p. 27.

81 Acts and ordinances, ii. 1170–80.

82 Ireland under the commonwealth, i, p. x.

83 Correspondence of Henry Cromwell, no. 342.

84 Moran, Historical sketch, 350–1; Dickson, Old world colony, 44–5.

85 National Archives of Ireland, Dublin, ms Ferguson 10, fos 4, 14; King's Inns Library, Dublin, ms Prendergast 2, fo. 945.

86 Irish Record Commissioners, Sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth reports, London 1820, 147Google Scholar.

87 [MacCaffrey], ‘Commonwealth records’, 29.

88 Comerford, M., Collections relating to the diocese of Kildare and Leighlin, Dublin 1883, 320–2Google Scholar.

89 Ibid.

90 The Herbert correspondence, ed. Smith, W. J., Cardiff–Dublin 1963, 145–7, 152–4Google Scholar; Trinity College Dublin, ms 828, fo. 202r–v.

91 Barnard, Cromwellian Ireland, 289–91.

92 HMC, Report on the manuscripts of the marquess of Ormonde, London 1895–9, ii. 114–76Google Scholar; ms Prendergast 2, fo. 943.

93 ms Prendergast 2, fos 941–2; ms Ferguson 10, fos 20, 28.

94 Ancient Ireland, ed. M. A. Brennan, Dublin 1855, 90–1.

95 Thurloe state papers, vii. 632.

96 Trinity College, Dublin, ms 808, fo. 162; Clarke, Aidan, Prelude to restoration in Ireland, Cambridge 1999, 37Google Scholar.

97 Creighton, Anne, ‘The remonstrance of December 1661 and Catholic politics in Restoration Ireland’, Irish Historical Studies xxxiv (2004), 16–41Google Scholar.