Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T21:57:04.544Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Fashions in Monastic Endowment: the Foundations of the Clare Family, 1066–1314

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 March 2011

J. C. Ward
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The great expansion in monasticism in Normandy and England in the eleventh and twelfth centuries is a commonplace of medieval history, as is the marked diminution in monastic grants after c. 1200. Far more attention, however, has been paid to the religious houses than to their founders, and it is only by looking at a baronial family over a long period that one can discern the fashions which undoubtedly existed in monastic benefaction and the changes in attitude of successive generations. The Clare family were both long-lasting and prolific, and, because of the numerous changes in the landed position of various members of the family, it is possible to see how closely in the eleventh and twelfth centuries the acquisition of new territories and the endowment of monasteries went together. Moreover, we are able to trace the changing preferences for different monastic orders and, to some extent, the reasons for this, and, in addition, to see this in the context not only of Normandy and England, but of Wales and Ireland as well. Whereas in the eleventh and early twelfth century, the Clares' gifts passed to Benedictine houses, many of them Norman or with Norman connections, they became more interested later in the new orders of the Augustinian canons and Cistercians which were spreading rapidly over Europe. At the same time they made grants to the military orders of the Hospitallers and Templars which, by giving knights the opportunity to combine fighting with a monastic life, fused two ideals of the twelfth-century world. In contrast to the variety and amount of these monastic benefactions, the Clares were content in the thirteenth century to make only the occasional grant, but they were insistent on maintaining their rights of patronage. In addition, their interest turned to the new orders of friars. There is, however, no indication here of continuous family interest from one generation to the next as would have been the case in the early twelfth century.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 32 , Issue 4 , October 1981 , pp. 427 - 451
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Sancti Anselmi Cantuariensis Archiepiscopi Opera Omnia, ed. Schmitt, F. S., Edinburgh iii. 220–1Google Scholar, ep. 94.

2 Knowles, D., The Monastic Order in England, Cambridge 1950, 596Google Scholar. This point is illustrated in the cartulary of the priory of Stoke by Clare; B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi. fo. 28a.

3 Constable, G., Monastic Tithes from their Origins to the Twelfth Century, Cambridge 1964, 95Google Scholar.

4 Vita Herluini, in Robinson, J. Armitage, Gilbert Crispin, Abbot of Westminster, Cambridge 1911, 89–91Google Scholar.

5 Ibid., 94.

6 Recueil des actes des dues de Normandie de 911 à 1066, ed. Fauroux, M. (Mémoires de la Societe des Antiquaires de Normandie, xxxvi. 1961Google Scholar), no. 98. Poree, E., Historic de l'abbaye du Bee, Evreux 1901, i. 43, 326–7Google Scholar.

7 Ibid., i. 141–2, 329. Recueil des actes de Henri II, ed. Delisle, L. V. and Berger, E. (Charles et Diplomes relatifs a l'histoire de France, 1916–1927), ii. 376Google Scholar.

8 Actes des dues de Normandie, no. 179.

9 Ibid. no. 192. Cacheux, M.-J. le, Histoire de l'abbaye de Saint-Amand de Rouen des origines a laJin du seizieme siécle, Caen 1937Google Scholar, 2.1, 178.

10 Actes des dues de Normandie, nos. 220, 231. Les Actes de Cuillaume le Conquèrant et de la reine Mathilde pour les abbayes caennaises, ed. Musset, L. (Memoires de la societe des antiquaires de Normandie, xxxvii, 1967Google Scholar), no. 2. Chartes de l'abbaye de Jumieges, ed. Vernier, J.-J., Rouen 1916, i. 88–9Google Scholar, 102–3; ii. 25.

11 Sancti Anselmi Opera Omnia, iii. 220–1, ep. 94, refers to Richard as parvulus monachus Round, J. H., Feudal England, London 1895, 478–9Google Scholar. Richard became abbot of Ely in 1100.

12 The exception was Goldcliff, Monmouthshire, founded in 1113 by Robert of Chandos.

13 Salter, H. E., ‘Two deeds about the Abbey of Bee’, EHR, xl (1925), 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar. AcCes de Henri. i 564.

14 Ibid., i. 563. Knowles, D. and Hadcock, R. N., Medieval Religious Houses: England Wales, London 1971, 63Google Scholar.

15 Select Documents of the English Lands of the Abbey of Bee, ed. Chibnall, M. (Camden3rd ser., lxxiii, 1951), nos. 40Google Scholar, 41. Salter, ‘Two deeds’, 75–6. Morgan, M., The English Lands of the Abbey of Bee, Oxford 1946, 149Google Scholar. Domesday Book, ed. Farley, A. and Ellis, H. (Record Commission, 1783–1816Google Scholar), i. 34b.

16 Lennard, R., ‘Peasant tithe-collectors in Norman England’, EHR, lxix (1954), 593CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Ibid., 592. Salcer, ‘Two deeds’, 76. Morgan, English Lands of Bee, 147. Select Documents of Bee, no. 39.

18 Salter, ‘Two deeds’, 76. Morgan, English Lands of Bee, 147–8. Select Documents of Bee, no.

19 Liber Eliensis, ed. Blake, E. O. (Camden Society, 3rd ser., xcii, 1962), 103–4Google Scholar, 188–9.

20 Ibid., 104. Poree, Histoire de l'abbaye du Bee, i. 161–3. Gorham, G. C., The History and Antiquities of Eynesbury and St Neot's, London 1824, i. 61–3Google Scholar. Knowles and Hadcock, Medieval Religious Houses, 75. Chibnall, M., ‘The relations of St Anselm with the English dependencies of the Abbey of Bec, 1079–93, Spicilegium Beccense, Paris 1959, i. 523–4Google Scholar.

21 Sancti Anselmi Opera Omnia, iii. 220–1, ep. 94.

22 Gorham, Eynesbury and St Neot's, i. 66–7. Chibnall, ‘The relations of St Anselm’, 522, 525.

23 Sancti Anselmi Opera Omnia, v. 421/2, ep. 473. The Rolls and Register of Bishop Oliver Sutton, 1280–99, ed. Hill, R. M. T. (Lincoln Record Society, ix. 1965) v. 79–80Google Scholar.

24 Cf. Galbraith, V. H., ‘Monastic foundation charters of the eleventh and twelfth centuries’, Cambridge Historicalfnl., iv (1932–1934), 214Google Scholar.

25 Domesday Book, i. 207a, 216a.

26 Monasticon Anglicanum, ed. Caley, J., Ellis, H. and Bandinel, B., London 1817–1830Google Scholar (hereafter cited as MA), iii. 473. Regesta Regum Anglo-Normannorum, 1100–35, ed. Johnson, C. and Cronne, H. A., Oxford 1956Google Scholar, no. 1015a. B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fo. 45b.

27 MA, v. 269. The Domesday Monachorum of Christ Church Canterbury, ed. Douglas, D. C., London 1944, 40Google Scholar.

28 B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fos. 78a, 79b.

29 MA, iii. 474. B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fo. 77b. The church of Barton Bendish was granted to Stoke by Gilbert of Tonbridge; B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fo. 64b.

30 B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fos. 46a, 73a.

31 Ibid., fos. 78a-80a. The Letters and Charters of Gilbert Foliot, ed. Morey, A. and Brooke, C. N. L., Cambridge 1967Google Scholar, no. 449.

32 B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fo. 37a. MA, iii. 476.

33 Ibid., iii. 476. Richard was a Clare honorial baron, holding land in Essex and Norfolk.

34 Morgan, English Lands of Bec, 19, 21, 29. St Neots paid the yearly sum of £1. 105., and Stoke £1., as tokens of their subjection to Bee.

35 MA, iii. 464.

36 B. L. Cotton MS Domitian A xi, fos. 115b–116a. Cf. Hill, R. M. T., ‘Bishop Sutton and the institution of heads of religious houses in the diocese of Lincoln’, EHR, lviii (1943), 204CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

37 B.L. Cotton MS Faustina A iv, fo. 27b. Gorham, Eynesbury and St Neot's, ii. cxli-iii.

38 B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fo. 162a.

39 A. Saltman, Theobald Archbishop of Canterbury, London 1956, 477–90Google Scholar. MA, vi. part 3, 1659–61. B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fos. 64a-70a.

40 B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fo. 87b.

41 Ibid., fo. 67b.

42 Ibid., fo. 64b. Gilbert's Norfolk manors were at Barton Bendish, Beechamwell, Crimplesham and Wereham.

43 Ibid., fos. 64b, 6ga-b.

44 Ibid., fos. 25a, 65a.

45 Ibid., fos. 19a, 19b-20a.

46 Ibid., fos. 20a-b, 21b, 22a, 22b, 23a-24b.

47 Ibid., fo. 21a.

48 Ibid., fo. 22b.

49 Ibid., fa. 24b.

50 Ibid., fo. 26a, 26b.

51 Ibid., fos. 28b, 31a-b.

52 Ibid., fos. 29a-b, 31a.

53 Ibid., fo. 30a-b.

54 Ibid., fo. 67a.

55 E.g., ibid., fo. 68a; Ingelram of Abernon gave the church of Woking, Surrey, together with his Suffolk grants.

56 Ibid., fo. 65b.

57 Ibid., fo. 69a.

58 Ibid., fo. 28a; Herbert was bishop of Norwich between 1090 and 1119.

59 Ibid., fo. 65b.

60 E.g., ibid., fos. 68b-6ga.

61 E.g., ibid., fos. 8ib, 114b, 170a. It is probable that this was also the practice earlier, but that the charters have not survived, or that the gifts were made orally and summarised in the confirmation charters.

62 Ibid., fo. 69a.

63 Ibid.Jo. 171a.

64 Ibid., fos. 50a, 170a-b.

65 Ibid., fos. 65b, 69a, 77a.

66 Ibid., fos. 66a, 69b.

67 Ibid., fo. 63a-b.

68 Ibid., fo. saa.

69 Ibid., fo. 21a.

70 Ibid., fo. 22a.

71 Ibid., fos. 28b-29a.

72 See below, pp. 446–7.

73 Chartes de Jumièges, ii. 25. Chartes du prieuré de Longueville de l'ordre de Cluny anterieures a 1204, ed. P. le Cacheux (Société de l'Histoire de Normandie, 1934), 2.

74 J. H. Round, ‘The early charters of St John's Abbey, Colchester’, EHR, xvi (1901), 723–4.

75 The Chartulary of the Priory of St Pancras of Lewes, ed. Salzmann, L. F. (Sussex Record Society, xxxviii. 1932), 120–1Google Scholar, 130–1, 155, 156. The Surrey Portion of the Lewes Chartulary, ed. Harrison, D. (Surrey Archaeological Collections, xliii. 1935), 92Google Scholar, 96, and reprinted (Sussex Record Society, 1943), 9, 13. The Norfolk Portion of the Chartulary of the Priory of St Pancras of Lewes, ed. Bullock, J. H. (Norfolk Record Society, xii. 1939), 17Google Scholar, and reprinted (Sussex Record Society, 1943), 17.

76 MA, ii. 601, 603. Facsimiles of Early Charters from Northamptonshire Collections, ed. Stenton, F. M. (Northamptonshire Record Society, iv, 1930Google Scholar), no. 18.

77 B.L. Harley MS 3658, fo. 12a. MA, ii. 597.

78 Historia et Cartularium Monasterii Sancti Petri Gloucestriae, ed. Hart, W. H. (Rolls Series, 1863–1867), i. 106Google Scholar; ii. 73–6. Regum Anglo-Normannorum, no. 1041.

79 Historia … Sancti Petri Gloucestriae, ii. 75. Richard's wife Alic e added to the endowment; ibid., i. 104, 241; Actes de Henri II, i. 68.

80 Historia … Sancti Petri Gloucestriae, i. 352 ; ii. 77, 128.

81 Ibid., ii. 74, 76. Chertsey Cartularies (Surrey Record Society, xii, part 1, 1933), pp. ii, 104.

82 On the other hand, it has been suggested that the Gloucester charters were forgeries; H. E. Maiden, ‘The possession of Cardigan Priory by Chertsey Abbey (A study in some medieval forgeries)’, Trans. Royal Historical Society, 3rd ser., v (1911), 145–6, 150–3.

83 Dickinson, J. C., The Origins of the Austin Canons and their Introduction into England, London 1950, 134Google Scholar.

84 Ibid., 125–30.

85 Cooke, A. M., ‘The settlement of the Cistercians in England’, EHR, viii (1893), 643–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar. MA, v. 377–8. Annales de Waverleia, in Annales Monastici, ed. H. R. Luard (Rolls Series, 1864–9), ii. 225 Janauschek, L., Originum Cistcrciensium, Vienna 1877, i. 40–1Google Scholar.

86 The Text of the Book of Lion Dâv, ed. Evans, J. G. and Rhys, J., Oxford 1893, 37Google Scholar, 93.

87 Janauschek, Originum Cisterciensium, i. 19, 287.

88 Ibid., 16–17, 286. Knowles, Monastic Order, 707.

89 Calendar of Charter Rolls (hereafter cited as CCR), 1300–26, London 1908, 88Google Scholar, 96–7. Cowley, F. C., The Monastic Order in South Wales, 1066–1349, Cardiff 1977, 71Google Scholar, 90.

90 CCR, 1300–36, London 1908, 88Google Scholar, 96–8.

91 The chronicle is printed in MA, v. 269–70. It is reasonably accurate for the information obtained locally, but the Clare genealogy, based on the work of Robert of Torigni, is hopelessly muddled.

92 Ibid., v. 270.

93 Ibid., vi. part 1, 147. Dickinson, Origins of the Austin Canons, 109, 283. B.L. Harley MS 662, fo. 6a.

94 B.L. Harley MS 662, fos. nb-iab, confirmation by Walter fitz Robert; ibid., fos. 7a-8a, 12b, confirmations by Robert fitz Walter.

95 One charter mentions the.eldest branch of the family; Walter fitz Robert issued a charter for the repose of the soul of Earl Roger his kinsman, among others; ibid., fo. 57b.

96 Ibid., fos. 6b, 9a, 59a, 71b.

97 Ibid., fos. 6b, ga-b, 11a, 104a.

98 Ibid., fos. 6b-7a, gb-iob, 57b, 63b-64a, 65b, 68b-6ga. 80b, 82a, g4b, 123b. Letters and Charters o/C. Foliot, no. 368.

99 B.L. Harley MS 662, fos. 7a-8a, 12b-13a, 57b, 64b, 6ga-b, g4b.

100 MA, vi. part 1, 370–1. Facsimiles of Northamptonshire Collections, no. 4A.

101 MA, vi. part 1, 371.

102 Ibid. CCR, 1327–41, London 1912, 20Google Scholar, 27–8.

103 E.g., Field Dalling, Norfolk, part of the inheritance of Matilda of St Hilary, wife of Roger, Earl; Calendar of Documents preserved in France, 918–1206, ed. Round, J. H., London 1899Google Scholar, no. 803.

104 See below, pp. 449–50.

105 B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fo. 25a.

106 Cheney, C. R., ‘A papal privilege for Tonbridge Priory’, Bull. Institute of Historical Research, xxxviii (1965), 196Google Scholar.

107 Curia Regis Rolls, 1213–15, London 1935, 84–5Google Scholar. CCR, 1300–26, London 1908, 210Google Scholar. Hailstone, E., The History and Antiquities of the Parish of Bottisham and the Priory of Anglesey in Cambridgeshire, Cambridge 1873, 187–8Google Scholar.

108 Cheney ‘A papal privilege’, 196–7.

109 Wood, S., English Monasteries and their Patrons in the Thirteenth Century, Oxford 1955, 16Google Scholar, 118. CCR, 1126–57, London 1903, 148Google Scholar.

110 Records of the Templars in England in the Twelfth Century, ed. Lees, B. A. (Records of the Social and Economic History of England and Wales, ix, 1935Google Scholar), cxxxvi-vii, 63, 65, 77, 218. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, fo. 135b.

111 Records of the Templars, cxxvii, 52, 198–9, 223–4.

112 Ibid., 168–9, 171.

113 B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, fos. 124a, 124b, 235b. Letters and Charters of C. Foliot, no. 385.

114 MA, vi. part 2, 804, 806–7. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, fo. 123a-b. Rotuli Chartarum in Turn Londinensi Asservati, 7/99-/2/6, ed. T. D. Hardy (Record Commission, 1837), 16.

115 VCH, Hertfordshire, London 1914, iv. 444.

116 MA, vi. part 2, 803. 834–5. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, fo. 123a-b.

117 B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, To. i23a-b. A Kentish Cartulary of the Order of St John of Jerusalem, ccl. C. Cotton (Kent Records, xi, 1930), 70, 73–6. Rotuli Chartarum in Turn Londinensi, 16. AM, vi. part 2, 806–7. Registrum Rqffense, ed. J. Thorpe, London 1769, 665–6.

118 Rees, W., A History of the Order of St John of Jerusalem in Wales and on the Welsh Border, Cardiff 1947, 112–13Google Scholar.

119 B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vi, fos. 848–850, 4583–4600.

120 Ibid., fo. 123a-b.

121 Ibid., lbs. 328b, 329a, 383a.

122 Ibid., 10.332b.

123 Ibid., lbs. i23a-b, 205a, 210a.

124 E.g., Richard's establishment of a priory for Benedictine nuns at Usk, c. 1170; B.L. Additional Charter 5342; MA, iv. 591.

125 Historic and Municipal Documents of Ireland, 1172–1320, ed. Gilbert, J. T., London 1870, 497Google Scholar. Chartularies of St Mary's Abbey, Dublin, ed. Gilbert, J. T. (Rolls Series, 1884), ii. 223Google Scholar.

126 Registrumde Kilmainham, ed. McNeill, C. (Irish MSS Commission, 1932), p. ivGoogle Scholar.

127 Rees, Stjohn of Jerusalem in Wales, 18.

128 Some Unpublished Texts from the Black Book of Christ Church, Dublin, ed. A. Gwynn, Analecta Hibemica, no. 16, Dublin 1946, 308. A Calendar of the Liber Niger and Liber Albus Christ Church, Dublin, ed. H. J. Lawlor, Proc. Royal Irish Academy, xxvii (1907–9), section C, no. 1, p. 69. MA, vi. part 2, 1148. Orpen, G. H., Ireland under the Normans, 1169–1333, Oxford 1911–1920, i. 355Google Scholar, suggests that the second chapel was dedicated to St Mary of Alba Landa, i.e., the Cistercian monastery of Whitland in Pembrokeshire.

129 Calendar to Christ Church Deeds, Dublin, in The Twentieth Report of the Deputy Keeper of the Public Records in Ireland, 1888, 36, 103. Liber Niger and Liber Albus of Christ Church, Dublin, 29.

130 ‘The book of the foundation of Walden Abbey’, translated C. H. Emson and H. Collar, Essex Review, xlv (1936), 225–7. Richardson, H. G., ‘Some Norman foundations in Ireland’, Medieval Studies presented to Aubrey Gwynn, ed. Watt, J. A., Morrall, J. B. and Martin, F. X., Dublin 1961, 30–2Google Scholar.

131 Chartularies of St Mary's Abbey, Dublin, ed. J. T. Gilbert (Rolls Series, 1884), i. 354–6; ii. 1.51–2. Gwymi, A. ‘The Origins of St Mary's Abbey, Dublin’, Jnl Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland, Ixxix (1949), 124Google Scholar.

132 Register of the Abbey of St Thomas, Dublin, ed. Gilbert, J. T. (Rolls Series, 1889), 110–15Google Scholar, 117, 367–8.

133 Ibid., 75–80, 142–4, 167, 170–2, 369.

134 ‘Crede Mihi’. The Most Ancient Register Book of the Archbishops of Dublin before the Reformation, ed. Gilbert, J. T., Dublin 1897, 49Google Scholar.

135 Chartularies of St Mary's, Dublin, i. 30–1, 67–8.

136 Annales de Morgan, in Annales Monastici (ed. Luard), i. 1–40.

137 Morgan, English Lands of Bee, 29–30, 33. Cowley, Monastic Order in S. Wales, 200–1.

138 Ibid., 196–7, 216, 225–6, 246, 248–9, 252.

139 CCR, 1300–26, London 1908, 103–4.

140 Cowley, Monastic Order in S. Wales, 197.

141 Annales de Theokesberia, in Annales Monastici (ed. Luard), i. 41–180.

142 Ibid., 137, X40, 151.

143 Ibid., 76.

144 Ibid., 124.

145 Ibid., 151.

146 Ibid., 147.

147 Ibid., 76; ibid., 132, the woodland was returned to Earl Richard in 1243.

148 Ibid., 135.

149 Ibid., 167.

150 Ibid., 83.

151 Ibid., 140, 511–16.

152 MA, vi. part 1, 333. Knowles and Hadcock, Medieval Religious Howes, 278–9.

153 Dickinson, J. C., The Shrine of Our Lady of Walsingham, Cambridge 1956, 11–19Google Scholar.

154 B.L. Cotton MS Appendix xxi, fo. 65b.

155 His son Geoffrey was referred to as a minor in the Pipe Roll of 1130; Magnum Rotulum Scaccarii, de anno31 Henrici I, ed. Hunter, J. (Record Commission, 1833), 94Google Scholar.

156 MA, vi. part 1, 73. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vii, fo. 8a-b.

157 MA, vi. part i, 74. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vii, fo. 31a.

158 B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vii, fos. 120–133.

159 Ibid., fo. 13a has two minor confirmations from Earl Richard (d. 1262) and his wife, Countess Matilda.

160 CCR, 1326–57, London 1903, 334Google Scholar.

161 B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vii, fos. 13b-15a.

162 CCR, 7226–57, London 1903, 354Google Scholar, 377.

163 Ibid., 377, 475. B.L. Cotton MS Nero E vii, fos. 14b–15a.

164 MA, iii. 106. Matthaei Parisiensis Chronica Majora, ed. R., H.Luard (Rolls Series, 1875–1884Google Scholar), v. 688.

165 MA, vi. part 3, 1599–1600.

166 B.L. Harley MS 4835.

167 Ibid., fos. 7b, 8a, 8b, ga. CCR, 1236–57, London 1903, 334Google Scholar.

168 B.L. Harley MS 4835, fo. 48b.

169 Ibid. fos. ib-6b.

170 MA, vi. part 3, 1600. Flares Historiarum, ed. Luard, H. R. (Rolls Series, 1890), iii. 142Google Scholar.

171 I wish to thank Professor R. M. T. Hill, Mr A. Tomkinson and Dr E. M. Veale who read an earlier draft of this article.