Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dzt6s Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T19:53:45.734Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Counting Religion in England and Wales: The Long Eighteenth Century, c. 1680–c. 1840

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 September 2012

CLIVE D. FIELD
CLIVE D. FIELD
Affiliation:
35 Elvetham Road, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2LZ; e-mail: [email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The statistical analysis of religion in England and Wales usually commences with the mid-nineteenth century. This article synthesises relevant primary and secondary sources to produce initial quantitative estimates of the religious composition of the population in 1680, 1720, 1760, 1800 and 1840. The Church of England is shown to have lost almost one-fifth of its affiliation market share during this period, with an ever increasing number of nominal Anglicans also ceasing to practise. Nonconformity more than quadrupled, mainly from 1760 and especially after 1800. Roman Catholicism kept pace with demographic growth, but, even reinforced by Irish immigration, remained a limited force in 1840. Judaism and overt irreligion were both negligible.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 63 , Issue 4 , October 2012 , pp. 693 - 720
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 2 Samuel xxiv.1–25; 1 Chronicles xxi.1–30.

2 Field, Clive, Religious statistics in Great Britain, Manchester 2010Google Scholar, http://www.brin.ac.uk/commentary/documents/CDField–History–Religious–Statistics–BRIN001.pdf.

3 Spufford, Margaret, ‘Can we count the “godly” and the “conformable” in the seventeenth century?’, this Journal xxxvi (1985), 428–38Google Scholar.

4 Currie, Robert, Gilbert, Alan and Horsley, Lee, Churches and churchgoers, Oxford 1977Google Scholar.

5 Bruce, Steve, ‘The truth about religion in Britain’, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion xxxiv (1995), 417–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar at p. 420; ‘Religion in Britain at the close of the 20th century’, Journal of Contemporary Religion xi (1996), 261–75Google Scholar at p. 264; and Choice and religion, Oxford 1999, 65, 209–10Google Scholar.

6 Rupp, Gordon, Religion in England, 1688–1791, Oxford 1986Google Scholar.

7 Jacob, William, Lay people and religion, Cambridge 1996, 52Google Scholar.

8 For example, Davies, E. T., Religion in the industrial revolution in south Wales, Cardiff 1965Google Scholar; Warne, Arthur, Church and society in eighteenth-century Devon, Newton Abbot 1969Google Scholar; Obelkevich, James, Religion and rural society, Oxford 1976Google Scholar; Urdank, Albion, Religion and society in a Cotswold vale, Berkeley 1990Google Scholar; Barrie-Curien, Viviane, Clergé et pastorale en Angleterre, Paris 1992Google Scholar; Smith, Mark, Religion in industrial society, Oxford 1994Google Scholar; Jago, Judith, Aspects of the Georgian Church, Madison 1997Google Scholar; Ambler, Rodney, Churches, chapels and the parish communities of Lincolnshire, Lincoln 2000Google Scholar; Gregory, Jeremy, Restoration, reformation and reform, Oxford 2000Google Scholar; Spaeth, Donald, The Church in an age of danger, Cambridge 2000CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gregory, Jeremy and Chamberlain, Jeffrey (eds), The national Church in local perspective, Woodbridge 2003Google Scholar; Snape, Michael, The Church of England in industrialising society, Woodbridge 2003Google Scholar; and Marshall, William, Church life in Hereford and Oxford, Lancaster 2009Google Scholar.

9 Gilbert, Alan, Religion and society in industrial England, London 1976, 33–6, 218–19Google Scholar; cf. references at http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2612.

10 Field, Clive, ‘A shilling for Queen Elizabeth’, Journal of Church and State l (2008), 213–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Knight, Frances, The nineteenth-century Church, Cambridge 1995, 24–36Google Scholar; ‘From diversity to sectarianism’, in Robert Swanson (ed.), Unity and diversity in the Church (Studies in Church History xxxii, 1996), 377–86; and ‘Conversion in 19th century Britain’, in Ulf Görman (ed.), Towards a new understanding of conversion, Lund 1999, 116–24; Lloyd, Gareth, ‘“Croakers and busybodies”’, Methodist History xlii (2003–4), 20–32Google Scholar; Royle, Edward, ‘When did Methodists stop attending their parish churches?’, Proceedings of the Wesley Historical Society lvi (2007–8), 275–96Google Scholar.

12 Original records of early Nonconformity, ed. George Lyon Turner, London 1911–14, iii. 105–39; David Wykes, ‘The 1669 return of Nonconformist conventicles’, in Kathryn Thompson (ed.), Short guides to records, second series, London 1997, 50–4 at pp. 52–3. Wykes is preparing an edition of the returns for the Church of England Record Society.

13 The Compton census, ed. Anne Whiteman, London 1986, pp. xxix, xxxvii–xli, lxxvi–lxxix, cxxiii–cxxiv, 7; Clive Field, ‘Non-recurrent Christian data’, in Religion (Reviews of United Kingdom Statistical Sources xx), Oxford 1987, 189–504 at pp. 229–31; Snell, Keith and Ell, Paul, Rival Jerusalems, Cambridge 2000, 241CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For other references see http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2530.

14 Cornish, Joseph, A brief history of Nonconformity, London 1797, 128Google Scholar.

15 Bebb, Douglas, Nonconformity and social and economic life, London 1935, 35, 45Google Scholar.

16 DWL, ms 38.4 and references at http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2532.

17 Watts, Michael, The Dissenters, Oxford 1978–95, i. 269–70, 272–6Google Scholar; ii. 23, 29; cf. James Bradley, ‘Whigs and Nonconformists’, unpubl. PhD diss. Southern California 1978, i. 127–8, 131, 133, 136, 138, 141–2; ii. 588–602.

18 Rees, Thomas, History of Protestant Nonconformity in Wales, 2nd edn,London 1883, 265–6Google Scholar.

19 Fryer, C. E., ‘The numerical decline of Dissent’, American Journal of Theology xvii (1913), 232–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar at p. 236.

20 Bebb, Nonconformity, 38, 45.

21 Davies, Horton, The English Free Churches, London 1952, 175Google Scholar.

22 Holmes, Geoffrey, The trial of Doctor Sacheverell, London 1973, 37Google Scholar; Religion and party in late Stuart England, London 1975, 14Google Scholar; ‘The Sacheverell riots’, Past & Present lxxii (1976), 55–85Google Scholar at p. 63; and Politics, religion and society in England, London 1986, 193–4, 225–6.Google Scholar

23 Bradley, ‘Whigs’, i. 124.

24 Gilbert, Alan, ‘Methodism, Dissent and political stability’, Journal of Religious History x (1978–9), 381–99Google Scholar at p. 394.

25 DWL, ms 38.6; ‘A view of English Nonconformity in 1773’, Transactions of the Congregational Historical Society v (1911–12), 205–22, 261–77, 372–85Google Scholar.

26 Bradley, ‘Whigs’, i. 127–8, 131, 133, 136, 138, 141–2; ii. 588–602.

27 Watts, Dissenters, ii. 23.

28 Bealey, Joseph, Observations upon … Mr Owen's sermon, Warrington 1790, 31–2Google Scholar.

29 Wendeborn, Frederick, A view of England, London 1791, ii. 350Google Scholar.

30 Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 394.

31 Gilbert, Joseph, Memoir of … Edward Williams, London 1825, 351Google Scholar.

32 Spinks, Alfred, Allen, E. L. and Parkes, James, Religion in Britain, London 1952, 15–16Google Scholar.

33 Williams, Thomas, A dictionary of all religions, London 1815, 302Google Scholar.

34 Watts, Dissenters, ii. 375.

35 Jones, William, A dictionary of religious opinions, London 1815, 188Google Scholar.

36 Belsham, Thomas, The present state of religious parties, 2nd edn,London 1818, 8Google Scholar.

37 Committees for repeal of the Test and Corporation Acts, ed. Thomas Davis (London Record Society Publications xiv, 1978), 90–1.

38 Hulbert, Charles, The religions of Britain, Shrewsbury 1826, 464Google Scholar.

39 See references at http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2537.

40 Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 25Google Scholar.

41 Dearden's Miscellany ii (1839), 701.

42 Monthly Repository n.s. viii (1834), 69.

43 Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine xxxix (1836), 602.

44 McCulloch, John, A statistical account of the British Empire, London 1837, ii. 416Google Scholar.

45 Conder, Josiah, An analytical … view of all religions, London 1838, 418, 421Google Scholar.

46 Matheson, James, Our country, London 1839, 55–6Google Scholar.

47 The Record, 26 Sept. 1839.

48 Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 25Google Scholar; Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 394.

49 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii.

50 For methodological issues raised by the 1851 census see Church and chapel in early Victorian Shropshire, ed. Clive Field (Shropshire Record Series viii, 2004), pp. xiii–xxv.

51 [Gaskin, John], A just defence … of gospel ministers, London 1660 (Wing G.290)Google Scholar, sig. ARV; Original records, iii. 120; Braithwaite, William, The second period of Quakerism, 2nd edn,Cambridge 1961, 457Google Scholar; Reay, Barry, The Quakers and the English revolution, London 1985, 26–7Google Scholar.

52 Rowntree, John, Quakerism, past and present, London 1859, 59, 68–73Google Scholar; Turner, Frederick, The Quakers, London 1889, 236–7Google Scholar; Braithwaite, Second period, 459.

53 Watts, Dissenters, i. 269–70, 505–6, 509–10; ii. 23, 29, 81.

54 von Archenholz, Johann, A picture of England, London 1789, i. 174Google Scholar; Wendeborn, View of England, ii. 428.

55 Rowntree, Quakerism, 74, 87; Hall, David, ‘Membership statistics of the Society of Friends’, Journal of the Friends’ Historical Society lii (1968–71), 97–100Google Scholar at p. 97.

56 Rowntree, Quakerism, 88; Hall, ‘Membership’, 97; Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 156, 159–60Google Scholar.

57 Bogue, David and Bennett, James, History of Dissenters, London 1808–12, iv. 334Google Scholar; Jones, Dictionary, 199.

58 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

59 Hulbert, Religions, 258, 463.

60 Dearden's Miscellany ii (1839), 701.

61 Wood, James, A condensed history of the General Baptists, Leicester 1847, 128Google Scholar; Original records, iii. 120; J. F. McGregor, ‘The Baptists’, in J. F. McGregor and Barry Reay (eds), Radical religion in the English revolution, Oxford 1984, 23–63 at p. 33.

62 Wood, Condensed history, 145; Bebb, Nonconformity, 32–3.

63 Watts, Dissenters, i. 269–70, 505, 509–10; ii. 23, 29, 81.

64 Ivimey, Joseph, A history of the English Baptists, London 1811–30, iii. 278–9Google Scholar; iv. 13–21; Langley, Arthur, ‘Baptist ministers in England about 1750 ad’, Transactions of the Baptist Historical Society vi (1918–19), 138–62Google Scholar; Whitley, William, A history of British Baptists, 2nd edn, London 1932, 224Google Scholar; Alan Gilbert, ‘The growth and decline of Nonconformity in England and Wales’, unpubl. DPhil diss. Oxford 1973, 45; Gilbert, Religion, 37; Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 151Google Scholar; Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 394.

65 Rees, , History of Protestant Noncomformity, 389Google Scholar; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 23.

66 Wood, Condensed history, 285–95; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 147–8; Frank Rinaldi, The tribe of Dan, Milton Keynes 2008, 96–142, 208–39.

67 Baptist Annual Register i (1790–3), 175; iii (1798–1801), 1–43; Ivimey, English Baptists, iv. 62, 74; Wood, Condensed history, 287–9; Cramp, John, Baptist history, London 1868, 542Google Scholar; Minutes of the general assembly of the General Baptist churches, ed. William Whitley, London 1909–10, i, pp. lvi–lxvi; Payne, Ernest, The Baptist Union, London 1958, 267Google Scholar; Gilbert, ‘Growth’, 45, 49, 54, and Religion, 37; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 147, 151; Bassett, T. M., The Welsh Baptists, Swansea 1977, 93Google Scholar; Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 394; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 81; Rinaldi, Tribe, 213.

68 Calculated from supplements in the CM n.s. x (1834) and Baptist Magazine xxvii (1835).

69 Wood, Condensed history, 150; Baptist Handbook (1869), 134; Gilbert, ‘Growth’, 45–7, 49, 54–61; Religion, 37; and ‘Methodism’, 394; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 148, 151; Rinaldi, Tribe, 214.

70 The Record, 26 Sept. 1839.

71 Matheson, Our country, 55–6.

72 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

73 Original records. iii. 120.

74 Watts, Dissenters, i. 269–70, 505, 509–10; ii. 23, 29.

75 Gilbert, ‘Growth’, 45, 54; Religion, 37; and ‘Methodism’, 394; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 147, 151.

76 CM n.s. x (1834), supplement.

77 Gilbert, ‘Growth’, 45–7, 54–61; Religion, 37; and ‘Methodism’, 394; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 148.

78 Certainly, the Congregational member/hearer ratio is based on fewer chapels than in the Baptist case since there is no Congregational equivalent to the Baptist Magazine listing. The overall Congregational ratio may also have been skewed by a handful of returns in 1834, for instance Liverpool where 6.3 hearers per member were claimed.

79 Matheson, Our country, 55–6.

80 Conder, Analytical … view, 421.

81 The Record, 26 Sept. 1839.

82 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

83 Original records, iii. 120.

84 Watts, Dissenters, i. 269–70, 509–10; ii. 23, 29.

85 Hill, Andrew, ‘“Corporate suicide is the next best thing that lies before them”’, TUHS xxiv (2007–10), 222–34Google Scholar at p. 222.

86 Unitarian Chronicle i (1832), 145–7, 196–9, 234–5; ii (1833), 16–17, 54, 93, 127–8, 280–1; CM n.s. ix (1833), 28; The Record, 26 Sept. 1839; Webb, Robert, ‘Views of Unitarianism’, TUHS xviii (1983–6), 180–95Google Scholar at pp. 180–2.

87 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

88 Conder, Analytical … view, 421.

89 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

90 Hill, Christopher, Reay, Barry and Lamont, William, The world of the Muggletonians, London 1983, 56Google Scholar; Lamont, William, Last witnesses, Aldershot 2006, 3, 161Google Scholar.

91 McCulloch, Statistical account, ii. 413.

92 Rogal, Samuel, ‘Counting the congregation’, Methodist History xxx (1991–2), 3–9Google Scholar.

93 Walsh, John, ‘Elie Halévy and the birth of Methodism’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 5th ser. xxv (1975), 1–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar at pp. 11–12.

94 Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 394; Podmore, Colin, The Moravian Church in England, 1728–1760, Oxford 1998, 120CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

95 Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 139–41Google Scholar.

96 Olivers, Thomas, A defence of Methodism, Leeds 1818, 18Google Scholar; Annual Register (1824), chronicle, 180; William Townsend, ‘English life and society’, in William Townsend, Herbert Workman and George Eayrs (eds), A new history of Methodism, London 1909, i. 333–78 at p. 369; Lenton, John, John Wesley's preachers, Milton Keynes 2009, 6Google Scholar.

97 Bradburn, Samuel, God shining forth, Bolton 1805, 64Google Scholar; Jones, Dictionary, 140; Williams, Dictionary, 176; CM n.s. v (1829), 690; x (1834), supplement; Cocking, Thomas, The history of Wesleyan Methodism in Grantham, London 1836, 130Google Scholar; Conder, Analytical … view, 421, 450; Matheson, Our country, 55–6; The Record, 26 Sept. 1839; Dearden's Miscellany i (1839), 56; Wesleyan-Methodist Kalendar (1850), 51; HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. lxxviii; Memorial of … Robert Wood, London 1854, 75–6; Memoir of the Rev Joseph Entwisle, 6th edn, London 1861, 160; Smith, George, History of Wesleyan Methodism, 5th edn, London 1866, i. 680–1Google Scholar; Johnston, James, The ecclesiastical and religious statistics of Scotland, Glasgow 1874, 11Google Scholar; The early correspondence of Jabez Bunting, ed. W. R. Ward (Camden 4th ser. xi, 1972), 182; Gilbert, ‘Methodism’, 393–4, and ‘Religion and political stability’, in Patrick O'Brien and Roland Quinault (eds), The industrial revolution and British society, Cambridge 1993, 79–99 at pp. 93–4; Field, Clive, ‘The social composition of English Methodism to 1830’, Bulletin of the John Rylands University Library of Manchester lxxvi (1994), 153–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar at pp. 153–4; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28; Rack, Henry, Reasonable enthusiast, 3rd edn, London 2002, 437–8Google Scholar.

98 Wendeborn, View of England, ii. 326.

99 Matheson, Our country, 55–6; McCulloch, Statistical account, ii. 413.

100 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

101 Salt, William, A memorial of the Methodist New Connexion, Nottingham 1827, 174Google Scholar; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 139–41.

102 The Record, 26 Sept. 1839.

103 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

104 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. lxxxii; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 140–1.

105 CM n.s. x (1834), supplement.

106 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

107 CM n.s. v (1829), 690.

108 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

109 Lander, John, Itinerant temples, Carlisle 2003, 157–61Google Scholar.

110 Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 140–1.

111 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

112 CM n.s. ser. v (1829), 690.

113 Vickers, John (ed.), A dictionary of Methodism, Peterborough 2000, 283Google Scholar.

114 Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 141. The membership figure of 26,500, given in The Record, 26 Sept. 1839, is wrong.

115 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

116 Parkes, William, The Arminian Methodists, Cannock 1995, 29–44Google Scholar; Vickers, Dictionary, 10.

117 Dallimore, Arnold, George Whitefield, London1970–80Google Scholar, i. 295–6; ii. 522–3.

118 Two Calvinistic Methodist chapels, ed. Edwin Welch (London Record Society xi, 1975), 16–17; Podmore, Moravian Church, 120.

119 Olivers, Defence, 17; Haweis, Thomas, An impartial … history of the … Church of Christ, London 1800, iii. 260–1Google Scholar.

120 Haweis, Impartial … history, iii. 254.

121 Alan Harding, ‘The Countess of Huntingdon and her connexion’, unpubl. DPhil diss. Oxford 1992, 168–70, 174, 363–4, and The Countess of Huntingdon's connexion, Oxford 2003, 152–6, 372.

122 Kirby, Gilbert, The elect lady, East Grinstead 1972, 54Google Scholar.

123 Bogue, and Bennett, , History of Dissenters, iv. 337Google Scholar; Jones, Dictionary, 55.

124 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

125 This was made up of 420 societies with 20 or 25 members each on average: Eryn White, ‘Revival and renewal amongst the eighteenth-century Welsh Methodists’, in Dyfed Wyn Roberts (ed.), Revival, renewal and the Holy Spirit, Milton Keynes 2009, 1–12 at p. 1; Eryn White, personal communication, 26 Mar. 2010.

126 Jones, Dictionary, 55.

127 The Record, 26 Sept. 1839; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 148.

128 Conder, Analytical … view, 421.

129 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

130 Podmore, Moravian Church, 120.

131 Holmes, John, History of the … United Brethren, London 1825–30, ii. 354–5Google Scholar.

132 Hamilton, Taylor, A history of the … Moravian Church, Bethlehem 1900, 356Google Scholar; Hutton, Joseph, A history of the Moravian Church, 2nd edn,London 1909, 455Google Scholar; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 156; Geoffrey, and Stead, Margaret, The exotic plant, Peterborough 2003, 100Google Scholar.

133 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

134 Bryer, Percy, ‘Benjamin Ingham and Cumbria’, Cumbria Religious History Society Bulletin xi (1985), [10–12]Google Scholar at p. [10].

135 Pickles, H. M., Benjamin Ingham, Coventry 1995, 131Google Scholar; Oates, Paul, My ancestors were Inghamites, London 2003, 6–25, 125–6Google Scholar.

136 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxx.

137 Ibid. p. clxxxii.

138 Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 156. There were between forty and forty-five societies during these years: Duckworth, Dennis, A branching tree, London 1998, 109, 133Google Scholar.

139 Goyder, David, A concise history of the New Jerusalem Church, London 1827, 104–5Google Scholar.

140 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

141 P. J. Tobin, ‘The Southcottians in England’, unpubl. MA diss. Manchester 1978, 120–1; Harrison, John, The Second Coming, London 1979, 109, 248Google Scholar; Hopkins, James, A woman to deliver her people, Austin 1982, 76, 83–5, 244Google Scholar; Brown, Frances, Joanna Southcott, Cambridge 2002, 218Google Scholar.

142 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxx.

143 Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 156; Thompson, David, Let sects and parties fall, Birmingham 1980, 202Google Scholar.

144 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28; Grass, Tim, Gathering to his name, Milton Keynes 2006, 61, 115–16Google Scholar.

145 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

146 Evans, Richard, A century of ‘Mormonism’ in Great Britain, Salt Lake City 1937, 244–5Google Scholar; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 156; Bloxham, Ben, Moss, James and Porter, Larry (eds), Truth will prevail, Solihull 1987, 442Google Scholar.

147 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

148 Gwynn, Robin, ‘The arrival of Huguenot refugees in England’, Huguenot Society Proceedings xxi (1965–70), 366–73Google Scholar; ‘The number of Huguenot immigrants in England’, Journal of Historical Geography ix (1983), 384–95Google Scholar; Huguenot heritage, London 1985, 24, 32–3Google Scholar, 35, 153, 165–6; and ‘Conformity, non-conformity and Huguenot settlement in England’, in Anne Dunan–Page (ed.), The religious culture of the Huguenots, Aldershot 2006, 23–42 at pp. 35, 40; Cottret, Bernard, The Huguenots in England, Cambridge 1991, 3, 15, 188Google Scholar.

149 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii.

150 Schwartz, Hillel, The French Prophets, Berkeley 1980, 317Google Scholar.

151 Jones, Dictionary, 132; HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii.

152 The population base has been calculated as follows. For England in 1680, 1720 and 1760 the mean has been taken of the recent estimates made by back-projection and generalised inverse projection by the Cambridge Group for the History of Population and Social Structure: Wrigley, Anthony and Schofield, Roger, The population history of England, London 1981Google Scholar, and Wrigley, Anthony, Davies, R. S., Oeppen, Jim and Schofield, Roger, English population history from family reconstitution, Cambridge 1997CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For Wales in these years the older estimates reproduced in Williams, John, Digest of Welsh historical statistics, Cardiff 1985Google Scholar, have been used. Estimates for 1800 and 1840 are census-derived: Mitchell, B. R., British historical statistics, Cambridge 1988Google Scholar.

153 Sunday scholars are estimated from Laqueur, Thomas, Religion and respectability, New Haven 1976, 44–53Google Scholar.

154 Magee, Brian, The English recusants, London 1938, 111Google Scholar.

155 Wykes, David, ‘A reappraisal of the reliability of the 1676 “Compton census”’, Leicestershire Archaeological and Historical Society Transactions lv (1979–80), 72–7Google Scholar at p. 75.

156 Miller, John, Popery and politics in England, Cambridge 1973, 9–11Google Scholar; Bossy, John, The English Catholic community, London 1975, 188–9Google Scholar; Compton census, pp. lxxvii, cxxiii–cxxiv; Bishop Leyburn's confirmation register, ed. J. A. Hilton, Allan Mitchinson, Barbara Murray and Peggy Wells, Wigan 1997.

157 HCP, 1878–9, xl, p. 240; Magee, Brian, ‘England's Catholic population in penal times’, Dublin Review cxcvii (1935), 253–68Google Scholar at p. 253, and English recusants, 112, 193; Carson, Robert, ‘Multiplication tables’, Clergy Review xxxii (1949), 21–30 at pp. 21–2Google Scholar; Watkin, Edward, Roman Catholicism in England, London 1957, 111Google Scholar; Steel, Donald and Samuel, Edgar, Sources for Roman Catholic and Jewish genealogy, Chichester 1974, 832Google Scholar; Bossy, English Catholic community, 189; Gilbert, Religion, 46; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 154; Lesourd, Jean-Alain, Sociologie du catholicisme anglais, Nancy 1981, 159Google Scholar; Anthony Williams, ‘Change or decay?’, in Eamon Duffy (ed.), Challoner and his Church, London 1981, 27–54 at p. 31; William Sheils, ‘Catholicism from the Reformation to the relief acts’, in Sheridan Gilley and William Sheils (eds), A history of religion in Britain, Oxford 1994, 234–51 at p. 248.

158 HLRO, Main Papers, 1 Mar. 1706, and references at http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2531.

159 Rowlands, Marie, ‘The progress of Catholics in Staffordshire’, University of Birmingham Historical Journal x (1966), 137–59Google Scholar at p. 139; Hugh Aveling, ‘Some aspects of Yorkshire Catholic recusant history’, in Geoffrey Cuming (ed.), The province of York (Studies in Church History iv, 1967), 98–121 at pp. 110–11; Williams, Anthony, Catholic recusancy in Wiltshire, London 1968, 258–60Google Scholar; John Bossy, ‘Catholic Lancashire’, in John Bossy and Peter Jupp (eds), Essays presented to Michael Roberts, Belfast 1976, 54–69 at pp. 54–5; Gooch, Leo, ‘Papist head-hunting in County Durham’, Durham County Local History Society Bulletin l (1993), 29–38Google Scholar.

160 Haydon, Colin, Anti-Catholicism in eighteenth-century England, Manchester 1993, 189–90Google Scholar.

161 The central record (HLRO, Main Papers, 21 Dec. 1767) has been printed in two volumes: Returns of papists, 1767, ed. Edward Worrall, London 1980–9. Some local returns have also been published/analysed, for which see http://www.brin.ac.uk/sources/2534. The principal secondary works are Lesourd, Sociologie, 21–92, 169–77, and Rowlands, Marie, (ed.), English Catholics of parish and town, London 1999, 261–356Google Scholar.

162 Bossy, English Catholic community, 184–6; Lesourd, Jean-Alain, ‘Les Catholiques dans la société anglaise’, Information Historique xxxvii (1975), 35–8Google Scholar at pp. 36–7; ‘Les Catholiques dans la société anglaise’, unpubl. DLitt diss. Strasbourg 1974, ii. 76; and Sociologie, 25, 31, 38; Haydon, Anti–Catholicism, 191.

163 Brady, Maziere, Annals of the Catholic hierarchy, London 1883, 169, 212, 263, 301Google Scholar; Whyte, John, ‘The vicars apostolics’ returns of 1773’, Recusant History ix (1967–8), 205–14Google Scholar; Holt, T. G., ‘A note on some eighteenth-century statistics’, Recusant History x (1969–70), 3–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar at pp. 3–5; Bossy, English Catholic community, 185; Lesourd, Sociologie, 41.

164 HLRO, Main Papers, 5 Mar. 1781.

165 Berington, Joseph, The state … of English Catholics, London 1780, 111Google Scholar; Burke, Edmund, A speech … at the Guildhall in Bristol, Dublin 1780, 53–4Google Scholar.

166 Lesourd, ‘Catholiques’, Information Historique, 37; unpubl. DLitt diss. ii. 321–6; and Sociologie, 31, 44–7; Williams, ‘Change or decay?’, 31; Sheils, ‘Catholicism’, 248. Currie, Gilbert and Horsley venture (without explanation) 120,000 in 1781: Churches and churchgoers, 50.

167 Lesourd, ‘Catholiques’, Information Historique, 37; unpubl. DLitt diss. ii. 327; and Sociologie, 46, 97–102, 159.

168 Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 23, 25; cf. Ward, Bernard, The eve of Catholic emancipation, London 1911–12, i. 18, 186Google Scholar; Carson, ‘Multiplication’, 21–3.

169 Williams, Dictionary, 302; Morris, John, ‘Catholic England in modern times’, The Month lxxiv (1892), 356–74Google Scholar at p. 374; Ward, Eve of Catholic emancipation, i. 186; ii. 53; Watkin, Roman Catholicism, 158; Steel and Samuel, Sources, 837; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 25.

170 Hulbert, Religions, 462; Brady, Annals, 192, 227. 276, 312; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 25.

171 McCulloch, Statistical account, ii. 416; [Wylie, Macleod], The progress of popery, London 1838, 7Google Scholar; Statistics of popery, 3rd edn, London 1839, 37Google Scholar; Catholic Directory (1840), 60; Morris, ‘Catholic England’, 374; Herbert Thurston, ‘Statistical progress of the Catholic Church’, in Catholic emancipation, London 1929, 245–64 at pp. 253–7; Carson, ‘Multiplication’, 21; Philip Hughes, ‘The English Catholics in 1850’, in George Beck (ed.), The English Catholics, London 1950, 42–85 at p. 44; Gilbert, Religion, 46; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 25, 154.

172 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

173 Connolly, Gerard, ‘“With more than ordinary devotion to God”’, North West Catholic History x (1983), 8–31Google Scholar at pp. 12–14, and ‘The transubstantiation of myth’, this Journal xxxv (1984), 78–104 at pp. 88–90.

174 Although some Muslims came as slaves and servants in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and as seamen and traders in the early nineteenth century, there was limited permanent Muslim settlement during this period: Matar, Nabil, ‘Muslims in seventeenth-century England’, Journal of Islamic Studies viii (1997), 63–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Islam in Britain, 1559–1685, Cambridge 1998Google Scholar; ‘Islam in Britain, 1689–1750’, Journal of British Studies xlvii (2008), 284–300Google Scholar; and ‘Britons and Muslims in the early modern period’, Patterns of Prejudice xliii (2009), 213–31Google Scholar, repr. in Malik, Maleiha (ed.), Anti-Muslim prejudice, London 2010, 7–25Google Scholar; Ansari, Humayun, The infidel within, London 2004, 26–40Google Scholar; Gilliat-Ray, Sophie, Muslims in Britain, Cambridge 2010, 13–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

175 Roth, Cecil, A history of the Jews in England, Oxford 1941, 173Google Scholar; Lipman, Vivian, Social history of the Jews in England, London 1954, 5Google Scholar; Perry, Thomas, Public opinion, propaganda and politics, Cambridge, Ma 1962, 6Google Scholar; Katz, David, The Jews in the history of England, Oxford 1994, 162, 185Google Scholar.

176 Tovey, D'Bloissiers, Anglia-Judaica, Oxford 1738, 302Google Scholar; Lipman, Social history, 6; Endelman, Todd, The Jews of Georgian England, Philadelphia 1979, 172Google Scholar.

177 Philo-Patriae, , Considerations on the bill to permit persons professing the Jewish religion to be naturalized, London 1753, 17Google Scholar; Hyamson, Albert, A history of the Jews in England, 2nd edn, London 1928, 221Google Scholar; Roth, History of the Jews in England, 223; Lipman, Social history, 6; Endelman, Jews of Georgian England, 172; Katz, Jews in the history of England, 250.

178 Wendeborn, View of England, ii. 468; Endelman, Jews of Georgian England, 172.

179 Colquhoun, Patrick, A treatise on the police of the metropolis, 5th edn, London 1797, 120Google Scholar; Lipman, Social history, 6; Endelman, Jews of Georgian England, 172; Jonathan Campbell, ‘The Jewish community in Britain’, in Gilley and Sheils, History, 427–48 at p. 432; Katz, Jews in the history of England, 317.

180 Samuel, Moses, An address from an Israelite, Liverpool 1827, 4Google Scholar; Pellatt, Apsley, Brief memoir of the Jews, London 1829, p. ivGoogle Scholar; Blunt, John, A history of the establishment … of the Jews, London 1830, 75Google Scholar; Goldsmid, Francis, Remarks on the civil disabilities of British Jews, London 1830, 69–71Google Scholar; Hyamson, History, 260; Roth, History of the Jews in England, 239; Lipman, Social history, 7; Endelman, Jews of Georgian England, 341.

181 Hannah Neustatter, ‘Demographic and other statistical aspects of Anglo–Jewry’, in Maurice Freedman (ed.), A minority in Britain, London 1955, 53–133, 243–62 at p. 261.

182 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Lipman, Vivian, ‘A survey of Anglo–Jewry in 1851’, Transactions of the Jewish Historical Society of England xvii (1951–2), 171–88Google Scholar.

183 Thomas, Keith, Religion and the decline of magic, Harmondsworth 1973, 198–206Google Scholar; Gerald Aylmer, ‘Unbelief in seventeenth-century England’, in Donald Pennington and Keith Thomas (eds), Puritans and revolutionaries, Oxford 1978, 1–21; Hunter, Michael, ‘The problem of “atheism” in early modern England’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 5th ser. xxxv (1985), 135–57Google Scholar; Berman, David, A history of atheism in Britain, London 1988Google Scholar; Priestman, Martin, Romantic atheism, Cambridge 1999Google Scholar.

184 Aston, Nigel and Cragoe, Matthew (eds), Anticlericalism in Britain, Thrupp 2000Google Scholar; Jacob, William, The clerical profession in the long eighteenth century, Oxford 2007, 291–303Google Scholar.

185 Nash, David, Blasphemy in modern Britain, Aldershot 1999Google Scholar.

186 Field, Clive, ‘Churchgoing in the cradle of English Christianity’, Archaeologia Cantiana cxxviii (2008), 335–63Google Scholar at p. 346.

187 For example, in the diocese of Chester in 1804 and 1811: McLeod, Hugh, Religion and the working class in nineteenth-century Britain, London 1984, 20–1Google Scholar; Field, ‘A shilling’, 240.

188 Groth Lyon, Eileen, Politicians in the pulpit, Aldershot 1999Google Scholar.

189 Royle, Edward, Radical politics, 1790–1900, London 1971Google Scholar; Victorian infidels, Manchester 1974; The infidel tradition, London 1976; and ‘Secularists and rationalists, 1800–1940’, in Gilley and Sheils, History, 406–22.

190 For example, JSSL ii (1839–40), 374; iii (1840–1), 19; vi (1843), 21; xi (1848), 215.

191 Gentleman's Magazine xvii (1747), 326.

192 Bodleian Library, Oxford, ms Top. Cheshire b 1, p. 129; Heginbotham, Henry, Stockport, London 1882–92, 87Google Scholar.

193 Young, Arthur, General view of the agriculture of … Suffolk, 3rd edn,London 1804, 331Google Scholar.

194 Hume, Abraham, Missions at home, London 1850, 24–5, 29Google Scholar; HCP, 1851 ix, pp. 117–22; cf. JSSL ii (1839–40), 374; iii (1840–1), 19; vi (1843), 21, 255; xi (1848), 215.

195 Currie, , Gilbert, and Horsley, , Churches and churchgoers, 223Google Scholar.

196 Field, ‘A shilling’, 221–45.

197 Gilbert, Religion, 11–12, 28; Currie, Gilbert and Horsley, Churches and churchgoers, 22–3, 25–6, 85. Also to be found here, and of limited worth, are back-projections to 1800 of national totals for Anglican communicants.

198 Gill, Robin, The myth of the empty church, London 1993, 17, 169, 296–7Google Scholar, and The ‘empty’ church revisited, Aldershot 2003, 13, 124.

199 Obelkevich, Religion, 137–43; Barrie-Curien, Clergé, 312–19, 334–8, 431; Smith, Religion, 51–3, 244; Knight, Nineteenth-century Church, 80–2; Jacob, Lay people, 57–61; Spaeth, Church in an age of danger, 176–88; Gregory, Restoration, 262–70; Snape, Church of England, 16–19; Field, ‘A shilling’, 233–4; Marshall, Church life, 98–104.

200 CM n.s. x (1834), supplement; Monthly Repository n.s. viii (1834), 69.

201 Field, Clive, ‘A godly people?’, Southern History xiv (1992), 46–73 at pp. 50–3Google Scholar; ‘Counting the flock’, Norfolk Archaeology xliii (1998–2001), 317–26; ‘A shilling’, 221–45; and ‘Churchgoing’, 339–49.

202 HCP, 1818, xviii, p. 215.

203 Soloway, Richard, Prelates and people, London 1969, 306–15Google Scholar; Field, ‘Godly people’, 53–4; Gill, ‘Empty’ church, 13, 81, 220–4, 248–9.

204 HCP, 1852–3, lxxxix, p. clxxxii; Watts, Dissenters, ii. 28.

205 Dallas, Alexander, Pastoral superintendence, London 1841, 141Google Scholar. In a slum district of Liverpool, however, more than two-thirds of nominal Anglicans neglected worship: Hume, Missions, 29.

206 Mann, Horace, ‘On the statistical position of religious bodies’, JSSL xviii (1855), 141–59Google Scholar at pp. 152–3.

207 For example, Religion in Hertfordshire, 1847 to 1851, ed. Judith Burg (Hertfordshire Record Publications xi, 1995), p. xxix; Yorkshire returns of the 1851 census of religious worship, ed. John Wolffe (Borthwick Texts and Calendars xxv, 2000), p. v; Church and chapel in … Shropshire, p. xxiii.

208 Gilbert, Memoir, 351; Spinks, Allen and Parkes, Religion in Britain, 15–16.

209 This is suggested by Clark, Jonathan, English society, 1688–1832, Cambridge 1985Google Scholar, and English society, 1660–1832, Cambridge 2000Google Scholar.

210 Brown, Callum, The death of Christian Britain, 2nd edn, London 2009Google Scholar.