Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-08T07:51:20.141Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Reducing That Barbarous Country: Center, Periphery, and Highland Policy in Restoration Britain

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 July 2013

Allan Douglas Kennedy
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Despite a recent expansion of interest in the history of Restoration Scotland, historiographical engagement with the place of the Highlands in the Restoration state continues to be relatively limited. Building upon recent research into the political culture of the later seventeenth century, this article offers a new conceptualization of the relationship between the center and the Highland periphery. It argues that the region was heavily integrated into wider political circumstances, while recognizing that contemporary statesmen remained concerned about its perceived wildness. From this basis, the article moves on to consider the nature of Highland policy, suggesting that tactical shifts spoke of deeper strategic uncertainty as to whether the Highlands were best controlled through the direct imposition of government power or by close cooperation with local elites.

Keywords

ScotlandBritainRestorationHighlandsGaelicgovernmentperipherymilitary
Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 3 , July 2013 , pp. 597 - 614
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The most detailed discussion of Stuart militarism in Scotland is to be found in Ronald Arthur Lee, “Government and Politics in Scotland, 1661–1681” (PhD diss., University of Glasgow, 1995).

2 Macinnes, Allan I., Clanship, Commerse and the House of Stuart, 1603–1788 (East Linton, 1996), 130–32Google Scholar.

3 Jackson, Clare, Restoration Scotland, 1660–1690: Royalist Politics, Religion and Ideas (Woodbridge, 2003), 132–38Google Scholar.

4 Mackenzie, W. C., The Highlands and Isles of Scotland: A Historical Survey (Edinburgh and London, 1937)Google Scholar.

5 Hopkins, Paul, Glencoe and the End of the Highland War (Edinburgh, 1998);Google Scholar Macinnes, Clanship, 122–58.

6 Donaldson, Gordon, “Scotland's Conservative North in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, Fifth Series 16 (May 1965): 74Google Scholar.

7 Goodare, Julian, State and Society in Early Modern Scotland (Oxford, 1999), 264CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Grant, I. F. and Cheape, Hugh, Periods in Highland History (London, 1997), 140–43Google Scholar; Hunter, James, Last of the Free: A Milennial History of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1999), 176, 264Google Scholar; Wormald, Jenny, Court, Kirk and Community: Scotland, 1470–1625 (Edinburgh, 1991), 164Google Scholar; Stevenson, David, Highland Warrior: Alasdair MacColla and the Civil Wars (Edinburgh, 1980), 17Google Scholar.

9 Hechter, M., Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development, 1536–1966 (London, 1975), 30–34Google Scholar, 58, 81–87.

10 Withers, Charles W. J., Gaelic Scotland: The Transformation of a Culture Region (London, 1988), 72–78Google Scholar, 112, 255–56.

11 Lenman, Bruce, The Jacobite Clans of the Great Glen, 1650–1784 (Dalkeith, 1995), 43Google Scholar.

12 Macinnes, Clanship, 143–48; Shaw, Frances J., The Northern and Western Isles of Scotland: Their Economy and Society in the Seventeenth Century (Edinburgh, 1990), 45, 51Google Scholar; Watt, D., “‘The laberinth of thir difficulties’: The Influence of Debt on the Highland elite, c. 1500–1700,” Scottish Historical Review 85, no. 219 (April 2006): 28–51Google Scholar.

13 Dodgshon, Robert A., From Chiefs to Landlords: Social and Economic Change in the Western Highlands and Islands, c. 1493–1820 (Edinburgh, 1998), 102–15Google Scholar.

14 Brown, K. M. et al. , eds., The Records of the Parliaments of Scotland to 1707 (St. Andrews, 2007)Google Scholar, www.rps.ac.uk (RPS); Brown, P. H. et al. , eds., The Register of the Privy Council of Scotland, Third Series, 1661–91 (RPCS), 16 vols. (Edinburgh, 1908–70)Google Scholar.

15 For some examples of the stereotypes in contemporary literature, see Sibbald, Robert, An Account of the Scottish Atlas; or, The Description of Scotland Ancient & Modern (Edinburgh, 1683), 5Google Scholar; Childrey, Joshua, Britannia Baconica; or, The Natural Rarities of England, Scotland & Wales (London, 1662), 177–79Google Scholar; Taylor, John, Treasaurarium Mathematicae; or, The Treasury of Mathematicks (London, 1687), 142Google Scholar; Borlase, Edmund, The History of the Execrable Irish Rebellion Trac'd From Many Preceding Acts of the Grand Erruuption the 23 October, 1641, and Thence Persued to the Act of Settlement (London, 1690), 19Google Scholar; Sinclair, George, Satan's Invisible World Discovered; or, A Choice Collection of Modern Relations Proving Evidently Against the Saduceed and Athiests of This Present Age, That There Are Devils, Spirits, Witches, and Apparitions (Edinburgh, 1685), 214Google Scholar; L'Estrange, Roger, The State and Interest of the Nation, With Respect to His Royl Highness the Duke of York Discours'd at Large, in a Letter to a Member of the Honourable House of Commons (London, 1680), 14Google Scholar; Alexander, William, Medulla Historiae Scoticae (London, 1685), 212Google Scholar.

16 “The Present State of the Highlands,” 1678, Papers of the Campbell Family, Dukes of Argyll, bundle 70, National Register of Archives for Scotland (NRAS) 1209, Inveraray Castle.

17 Mancell, Peter C., ed., Travel Narratives of the Age of Discovery: An Anthology (Oxford, 2006), 10Google Scholar.

18 Schwartz, S. B., “The Formation of Colonial Identity in Brazil,” in Colonial Identity in the Atlantic World, 1500–1800, ed. Canny, Nicholas P. and Pagden, Anthony (Guildford, 1987), 26Google Scholar; Hemming, John, Red Gold: The Conquest of the Brazilian Indians (repr. London, 2004), 34, 83–84Google Scholar, 351–83.

19 Canny, Nicholas, “The Ideology of English Colonization: From Ireland to America,” William and Mary Quarterly 30, no. 4 (October 1973)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Connolly, S. J., “Popular Culture: Patterns of Change and Adaptation,” in Conflict, Identity and Economic Development: Ireland and Scotland, 1660–1939, ed. Houston, R. A. and Morris, R. J. (Preston, 1995), 105Google Scholar; Leerson, J., “Wildness, Wilderness, and Ireland: Medieval and Early-Modern Patterns in the Demarcation of Civility,” Journal of the History of Ideas 56, no. 1 (January 1995): 32–34Google Scholar.

20 Cleland, William, “A Mock Poem, Upon the Expedition of the Highland Host, Who Came to Destroy the Western Shires, in Winter 1678,” in A Collection of Several Poems and Verses Composed Upon Various Occasions (1697), 13Google Scholar.

21 John Cahassay to Father Everard, 9 November 1685, Blair Letters, BL/1/90/2, Scottish Catholic Archive; Notebook of Robert Kirk, 1669–c.1674, Laing Collection, La.II.549, fol.53v, Edinburgh University Library.

22 RPS, 1661/1/112.

23 RPCS, 2:21.

24 Fraser, James, Chronicles of the Frasers: The Wardlaw Manuscript Entitled “Polichronicon Seu Policratica Temporum; or, The True Genealogy of the Frasers, 916–1674,” ed. Mackay, W. (Edinburgh, 1905), 465–66Google Scholar.

25 Records of the Presbytery of Caithness, 1654–1688, CH2/47/1, f. 70–71, 134, 139, 159, National Records of Scotland (NRS).

26 Fraser, Wardlaw, 465, 475.

27 Anonymous, “Marbhrann Thigearna na Comraich [Elegy to the Laird of Applecross],” in Gàir nan Clàrsach, ed. Baoill, Colm Ó (Edinburgh, 1994)Google Scholar; Cameron, John and Imrie, John, eds., The Justiciary Records of Argyll and the Isles, 1664–1742, 2 vols. (Edinburgh, 1949–69)Google Scholar, 1:36; D. Macdonald to Donald Macdonald of Moidart, 13 December 1684, Clanranald Collection, GD201/4/28, NRS.

28 Martin, Martin, A Description of the Western Islands of Scotland circa 1695, ed. Withers, Charles W. J. (Edinburgh, 2002)Google Scholar, 129, 150, 156, 203.

29 “Informatione For Angus Mckeane of Ardmurchan,” 28 July 1662, Mackay Papers, GD84/2/223, NRS.

30 Macleod, R. C., ed., The Book of Dunvegan, 2 vols. (Aberdeen, 1837–39)Google Scholar, 1:185, 190–99.

31 Evans, R. J. W., “The Habsburg Monarchy and Bohemia, 1526–1848,” in Conquest and Coalescence: The Shaping of the State in Early Modern Europe, ed. Greengrass, Mark (Sevenoaks, 1991), 141–46Google Scholar; Ingrao, Charles W., The Habsburg Monarchy, 1618–1815 (Cambridge, 1994), 64, 95–101Google Scholar; Van Horn Melton, J., “The Nobility in the Bohemian and Austrian Lands, 1620–1780,” in The European Nobilities in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, vol. 2, Northern, Central and Eastern Europe, ed. Scott, H. M. (Harlow, 1995), 117–25Google Scholar.

32 Braddick, Michael J., State Formation in Early Modern England, c.1500–1700 (Cambridge, 2000), 349–52Google Scholar; Heal, Felicity and Holmes, Clive, The Gentry in England and Wales, 1500–1700 (Basingstoke and London, 1994), 179CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Jenkins, Philip, A History of Modern Wales, 1536–1990 (London, 1992), 48–51Google Scholar, 59–64; Jenkins, Philip, “Seventeenth-Century Wales: Definition and Identity,” in British Consciousness and Identity: The Making of Britain, 1533–1707, ed. Bradshaw, Brendan and Roberts, Peter (Cambridge, 1998), 216–19Google Scholar.

33 Goldie, Mark, “The Unacknowledged Republic: Officeholding in Early Modern England,” in The Politics of the Excluded, c.1500–1850, ed. Harris, Tim (Basingstoke, 2001), 153–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Braddick, State Formation, 347.

35 Ibid., 347–55.

36 Fletcher, Anthony, Reform in the Provinces: The Government of Stuart England (New Haven and London, 1986), 357–58Google Scholar; Heal and Holmes, Gentry in England and Wales, 266–334.

37 Miller, John, After the Civil Wars: English Politics and Government in the Reign of Charles II (Harlow, 2000), 7–10Google Scholar, 23–26.

38 Brown, Keith M., Kingdom or Province? Scotland and the Regal Union, 1603–1715 (Basingstoke and London, 1992), 33–40Google ScholarPubMed.

39 RPCS, 1:187–88, 225–26, 435–38; George Sinclair, 6th earl of Caithness, to John Maitland, 2nd earl of Lauderdale, 20 March 1669, Lauderdale Papers, 1668–69, British Library Add. Mss. 23131, f. 168, BL.

40 RPCS, 1:177–78; Alexander Stewart, 5th Earl of Moray, to Lauderdale, 1662, Lauderdale Papers, 1662, Add. Mss. 23117, f. 14r, BL; Moray to Lauderdale, 15 January 1662, Add. Mss. 23117, f. 16r, BL; Memorandum to Lauderdale, 1662, Add. Mss. 23117, f. 17r, BL; Moray to Lauderdale, 13 February 1662, Add. Mss. 23117, f. 33r, BL; Moray to Lauderdale, 1662, Add. Mss. 23117, f. 46r, BL; Moray to Lauderdale, 6 March 1670, Lauderdale Papers, 1670, Add. Mss. 23133, f. 45r, BL.

41 Findlay, Johan, All Manner of People: The History of the Justices of the Peace in Scotland (Edinburgh, 2000), 50–54Google Scholar; Walker, David M., A Legal History of Scotland, vol. 4, The Seventeenth Century (Edinburgh, 1996), 194–96.Google Scholar

42 RPS, 1663/6/144; RPCS, 6:370; 7:196, 460.

43 RPCS, 1:1, 216, 526; 5:32; 8:34.

44 RPCS, 1:11; 2:594, 597; 3:37, 341, 399, 408, 490, 542; 5:235; 6:393, 466, 472, 493; 7:420. The last extant commission to the Highland Committee was in May 1682, and there is no record of it meeting thereafter.

45 Brown, Kingdom or Province?, 33; RPCS, 5:505.

46 Macinnes, Clanship, 32–46.

47 Committee of Estates to Clan Chiefs, 29 August 1660, Register and Minutes of the Committee of Estates, 1660, PA11/12, f. 10r–v, NRS. The lords to whom the committee wrote were: Kenneth Mackenzie, 3rd Earl of Seaforth; James Murray, 2nd Earl of Tullibardine; John Murray, 2nd Earl of Atholl; James Ogilvy, 1st Earl of Airlie; Charles Gordon, 1st Earl of Aboyne; John Mackay, 2nd Reay; Hugh Fraser, 8th Lovat; David Ross of Balnagown; Sir Robert Munro of Foulis; Duncan Stewart of Appin; Roderick Macleod of Dunvegan; Angus Macdonald of Glengarry; James Macdonald of Clanranald; Ewan Cameron of Lochiel; Lachlan Macintosh; James Grant of Freuchie; Robert Farquharson of Invercauld; Sir John Campbell of Glenorchy; Sir Dougal Campbell of Auchinbreck; Calum Macgregor, tutor of Macgregor; Sir John Colquhoun of Luss; Walter Macfarlane; John Buchanan; Archibald Campbell of Kilpunt; Sir Thomas Stewart of Garntullie; and David Lindsay of Edzell.

48 RPCS, 1:55–56.

49 Ibid., 1:638; 3:52–59, 490–91; 6:36–44; 7:82–83.

50 Lee, “Government and Politics,” 172–73; Jackson, Restoration Scotland, 132–38, 144–55.

51 “Informatione Concerning the heighlands,” 1677, Papers of the Maitland Family, Earls of Lauderdale, bundle 63/55, NRAS832, Thirlestane Castle.

52 John Campbell of Glenorchy to Elizabeth Murray, duchess of Lauderdale, 20 February 1677, Lauderdale Papers, 1676–78, f. 29r, Add. Mss. 23138, BL.

53 Simms, J. G., “The Restoration, 1660–85,” in A New History of Ireland, vol. 3, Early Modern Ireland, 1534–1691, ed. Moody, T. W., Martin, F. X., and Byrne, F. J. (Oxford, 1976), 440–41Google Scholar; Connolly, S. J., Divided Kingdom: Ireland, 1630–1800 (Oxford, 2008), 165CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

54 Fletcher, Reform in the Provinces, 324, 333–48; Miller, After the Civil Wars, 28–31; Norrey, P. J., “The Restoration Regime in Action: The Relationship between Central and Local Government in Dorset, Somerset and Wiltshire, 1660–1678,” Historical Journal 31, no. 4 (December 1988): 789–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Miller, John, “The Militia and the Army in the Reign of James II,” Historical Journal 16, no. 4 (December 1973): 661–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

55 Lee, “Government and Politics,” 152–87.

56 Airy, Osmond, ed., The Lauderdale Papers, 3 vols. (London, 1884–85)Google Scholar, 1:194, 243; RPCS, 5:251.

57 RPS, M1661/1/36.

58 Provisions for the Garrison at Inverlochy, 1678, Army Establishments, E99/25/1–3, NRS.

59 RPCS, 2:324–29; 3:87–90; 4:135–37; 5:92–93, 243–46, 496–97; 6:1–2.

60 Airy, Lauderdale Papers, 2:136–37.

61 RPCS, 2:324–29.

62 Advertisement, Anent Stollen Goods in the Hie-Lands (Edinburgh, 1673)Google Scholar; RPCS, 3:136; Advertisement, Anent Stollen Goods in the Hie-Lands (Edinburgh, 1676)Google Scholar; RPCS, 5:244.

63 RPCS, 2:224; 4:154; Audited Treasury Accounts, 1667–71, E26/11/1, f. 46–47, NRS; Audited Treasury Accounts, 1671–76, E26/11/2, f. 131–36, 146, NRS; Audited Treasury Accounts, 1676–79, E26/11/3, f. 226–31, NRS; Artillery and Military Stores, 1667–1708, E96/12/1–2, NRS.

64 “Proposalles for Taking Order with Broken Men and Suppressing Thift in the Highlands,” 1678, Yester Papers, Miscellaneous Papers, MS. 7003, f. 144, National Library of Scotland (NLS).

65 Archibald Campbell, 9th earl of Argyll, to Lauderdale, 11 March 1668, Lauderdale Papers, 1668, Add. Mss. 23129, f. 25v, BL; RPCS, 2:422; 5:246–48.

66 Argyll to Lauderdale, 1666, Lauderdale Papers, 1666, Add. Mss. 23125, f. 102r–103r, BL.

67 Advertisement (1673). A similar declaration was made during Major Grant's period in office.

68 “Proposalles for Taking Order with Broken Men and Suppressing Thift in the Highlands,” 1678, Yester Papers, Miscellaneous Papers, MS 7003, f. 144v, NLS.

69 RPCS, 6:393–98.

70 Ibid., 7:507–15.

71 Ibid., 7:511.

72 Ibid., 7:559.

73 Register of the Commissioners for Pacifying the Highlands, 1682–86, PC8/7, f. 7r–v, 14v–16v, 19v–21v, 25v, NRS; Proclamation to be Read at Balquhiddar, 27 August 1688, Atholl Estates, box 42I(1), item 35, NRAS234, Blair Castle.

74 PC8/7, f. 4v–5r, 6v, 25r, 92r, NRS; RPCS, 8:60.

75 Macinnes, Clanship, 139; Hopkins, Glencoe, 92; Harris, Tim, Restoration: Charles II and His Kingdoms, 1660–1685 (London, 2005), 358Google Scholar.

76 Instructions from Privy Council to Highland Commission, 9 August 1682, Atholl Estates, box 29I(12), item 33, NRAS234.

77 Torcastle to Moray, 25 February 1684, Papers of the Stewart Family, Earls of Moray, box 6, item 465, NRAS217, Darnaway Castle; William Drummond, 1st viscount of Strathallan, to Ensign Walter Sharp, 12 January 1687, Sharp of Houston papers, GD30/2077, NRS.

78 PC8/7, f. 22v–23r, 23v–24r, 25r, NRS.

79 Ibid., f. 6r, 7v–9r, 10r, 110v–47r; RPCS, 8:58–60, 196–97.