Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T03:53:14.006Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

An Assessment of Important Issues Concerning the Application of Benefit-Cost Analysis to Social Policy

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 January 2015

Aidan Vining  and
David L Weimer
Aidan Vining
Affiliation:
Simon Fraser University
David L Weimer
Affiliation:
La Follette School of Public Affairs
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Benefit-cost analysis (BCA) provides a framework for systematically assessing the efficiency of public policies. Increasingly, BCA is being applied to social policies, ranging from preschool interventions to prison reentry programs. These applications offer great potential for helping to identify policies that offer the best returns on public investments aimed at helping the disadvantaged or otherwise improving social life. However, applying BCA to social policies pose a number of challenges. The need for a comprehensive approach to assessing social policies generally requires making predictions based on data from multiple sources and using available shadow prices. As these predictions and shadow prices are inherently uncertain, special effort must be made to explicitly address the resulting uncertainty of predictions of net benefits. Prediction and valuation are complicated by behaviors, such as addiction, that do not clearly satisfy the assumptions of neoclassical welfare economics. As distributional goals are often an explicit motivation for social policies, BCA may be an incomplete framework for public policy purposes unless analysts can find ways to incorporate people's willingness to pay for changes in the distribution of consumption across society. If BCA is to reach its potential for contributing to good social policy, analysts must be aware of these challenges and researchers must help address them.

Keywords

social policyaddictionbenefit-cost analysis
Type
Principles and Standards
Information
Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis , Volume 1 , Issue 1 , 14 July 2010 , pp. 1 - 40
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis 2011

References

Adam, Taghreed, Evans, David B., and Koopmanschap, Marc A (2003) Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Can We Reduce Variability in Costing Methods? International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 19(2), 407–420.Google Scholar
Aghion, Philippe, Caroli, Eve, and Garcia-Penalosa, Cecilia (1999) Inequality and Economic Growth: The Perspective of the New Growth Theories. Journal of Economic Literature 37(4), 1615–1660.Google Scholar
Anderson, Michael L. (2008) Multiple Inference and Gender Differences in the Effects of Early Intervention: A Reevaluation of the Abecedarian, Perry Preschool, and Early Training Projects. Journal of the American Statistical Association 103(484), 1481–1495.Google Scholar
Anguera, Ricard (2006) The Channel Tunnel—An Ex Post Economic Evaluation. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 40(4), 291–315.Google Scholar
Aos, Steve, Lieb, Roxanne, Mayfield, Jim, Miller, Marna, and Pennucci, Annie (2004) Benefits and Costs of Prevention and Early Intervention Programs. Olympia: Washington State Institute for Public Policy.Google Scholar
Auld, M. Christopher, and Grootendorst, Paul (2004) An Empirical Analysis of Milk Addiction. Journal of Health Economics 23(6), 1117–1133.Google Scholar
Australian Productivity Commission (1999) Australia’s Gambling Industries, Inquiry Report No. 10, 26 November, available at www.pc.gov.au/inquiry/gambling/finalreport/index.html.Google Scholar
Ballard, Charles L., Shoven, John B., and Whalley, John (1985) General Equilibrium Computations of the Marginal Welfare Costs of Taxes in the United States. American Economic Review 75(1), 128–38.Google Scholar
Baron, Richard C., and Salzer, Mark S. (2002) Accounting for Unemployment among People with Mental Illness. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 20(6), 585–599.Google Scholar
Becker, Gary S., and Murphy, Kevin M. (1988) A Theory of Rational Addiction. Journal of Political Economy 96(4), 675–700.Google Scholar
Blomquist, Glenn, C., Coomes, Paul A., Jepsen, Christopher, Koford, Brandon C., and Troske, Kenneth R. (2009) Estimating the Social Value of Higher Education: Willingness to Pay for Community and Technical Colleges. IZA DP No. 4086, Bonn, Germany.Google Scholar
Boardman, Anthony E., Greenberg, David H., Vining, Aidan R., and Weimer, David L. (2006) Cost-Benefit Analysis: Concepts and Practice, 3rd Ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
Boardman, Anthony E., Mallery, Wendy L., and Vining, Aidan R. (1994) Learning form Ex Ante/Ex Post Cost-Benefit Comparisons: The Coquihalla Highway Example. Economic Planning Sciences 28(2), 69–84.Google Scholar
Butts, Jeffrey A., and Roman, John K. (2009) Juvenile Crime Interventions. In Weimer, David L. and Vining, Aidan R., eds. Investing in the Disadvantaged: Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Social Policies. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 103–126.Google Scholar
Camerer, Colin (1997) Progress in Behavioral Game Theory. Journal of Economic Perspectives 11(4), 167–188.Google Scholar
Card, David (2001) Estimating the Return to Schooling: Progress on Some Persistent Econometric Problems. Econometrica 69(5), 1127–1160.Google Scholar
Carson, Richard T. (forthcoming) Contingent Valuation: A Comprehensive Bibliography and History. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
Cartwright, William S. (1998) Cost-Benefit and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Drug Abuse Treatment Services. Evaluation Review 22(5), 609–36.Google Scholar
Cartwright, William S. (2000) Cost-Benefit Analysis of Drug Treatment Services: Review of the Literature. Journal of Mental Health Policy and Economics 3(1), 11–26.Google Scholar
Caulkins, Jonathan P. (2009) Illicit Substance Abuse and Addiction. In Weimer, David L. and Vining, Aidan R., eds., Investing in the Disadvantaged: Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Social Policies. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 83–102.Google Scholar
Caulkins, Jonathan P., Pacula, Rosalie Liccardo, Paddock, Susan, and Chiesa, James (2002) School-Based Drug Prevention: What Kind of Drug Use Does It Prevent? Santa Monica, Cal.: RAND.Google Scholar
Clarke, Harry, and Danilkina, Svetlana (2006) Talking Rationally About Rational Addiction. Unpublished manuscript, LaTrobe University.Google Scholar
Cohen, Mark A. (1988) Pain, Suffering, and Jury Awards: A Study of the Cost of Crime to Victims. Law & Society Review 22(3), 537–556.Google Scholar
Cohen, Mark A., Rust, Roland T., Steen, Sara, and Tidd, Simon T. (2004) Willingness-to-Pay for Crime Control Programs. Criminology 42(1), 89–109.Google Scholar
Copas, J. B (1997) Using Regression Models for Prediction: Shrinkage and Regression to the Mean. Statistical Methods in Medical Research 6(2), 167–183.Google Scholar
Currie, Janet (2001) Early Childhood Education Programs. Journal of Economic Perspectives 15(2), 213–238.Google Scholar
Davies, Jim (2003) Empirical Evidence on Human Capital Externalities. Economic Policy Institute Working Paper 2003-5. London, Ontario: University of Western Ontario.Google Scholar
Dee, Thomas S. (2004) Are There Civic Returns to Education? Journal of Public Economics 88(9-10), 1607–1720.Google Scholar
Dickie, Mark, and Messman, Victoria L. (2004) Parental Altruism and the Value of Avoiding Accute Illness: Are Kids Worth More than Parents? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 48(3), 1146–1174.Google Scholar
Diener, Alan, O’Brien, Bernie, and Gafni, Amiram (1998) Health Care Contingent Valuation Studies: A Review and Classification of the Literature. Health Economics 7(4), 313–326.Google Scholar
Drake, Elizabeth K., Aos, Steve, and Miller, Marna G. (2009) Evidence-Based Public Policy Options to Reduce Crime and Criminal Justice Costs: Implications in Washington State. Victims and Offenders 4(2), 179–196.Google Scholar
Drummond, F. Michael, Sculpher, Mark J., Torrance, George W., O’Brien, Bernie J., and Stoddart, Greg L. (2005) Methods for the Evaluation of Health Care Programmes, 3rd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Eckstein, Otto (1961) A Survey of the Theory of Public Expenditure Criteria. In Buchanan, James M. (ed.) Public Finances: Needs, Sources and Utilization. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 439–494.Google Scholar
Effron, Bradley, and Morris, Carl (1997) Stein’s Paradox in Statistics. Scientific American 236, 119–127.Google Scholar
Egerton, J., Fox, D., and Leshner, A. (1997) Cost-Benefit and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Issues in the Evaluation of Illicit Drug Abuse, Malden, UK: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Engle, Pär Jason, and Weimer, David L. (2005) Enhancing Criminal Sentencing Options in Wisconsin: The State and County Correctional Partnership. La Follette Policy Report 15(1), 15–18.Google Scholar
Ettner, Susan L., Huang, David, Evans, Elizabeth, Ash, Danielle Rose, Hardy, Mary, Jourabchi, Michael, and Hser, Yih-Ing (2006) Benefit-Cost in the California Treatment Outcome Project: Does Substance Abuse Treatment ‘Pay for Itself’? Health Services Research 41(1), 192–213.Google Scholar
Farrell, Lisa, Morgenroth, Edgar, and Walker, Ian (1999) A Time Series Analysis of U.K. Lottery Sales: Long and Short Run Price Elasticities. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 61(4), 513–26.Google Scholar
Feldstein, Martin (1997) How Big Should Government Be? National Tax Journal 50(2), 197–213.Google Scholar
Feldstein, Martin (1999) Tax Avoidance and the Deadweight Loss of the Income Tax. Review of Economics and Statistics 81(4), 674–680.Google Scholar
Fenwick, Elisabeth, Claxton, Karl, and Sculpher, Mark (2001) Representing Uncertainty: The Role of Cost-Effectiveness Acceptability Curves. Health Economics 10(8), 779–787.Google Scholar
Freeman, Richard B. (1997) Working for Nothing: The Supply of Volunteer Labor. Journal of Labor Economics 15(1), S140–S166.Google Scholar
French, Michael T., Salome, Helena J., Sindelar, Jody L., and Thomas McLellan, A. (2002) Benefit-Cost Analysis of Addiction Treatment: Methodological Guidelines and Empirical Application Using the DATCAP and ASI. Health Services Research 37(2), 433–455.Google Scholar
Frohlich, Norman, Oppenheimer, Joe A., and Eavey, Cheryl L. (1987) Choices of Principles of Distributive Justice in Experimental Groups. American Journal of Political Science 31(3), 606–636.Google Scholar
Gold, Marthe R., Siegel, Joanna E., Russell, Louise B., and Weinstein, Milton C. (1996) Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Goldman, David, Oroszi, Gabor, and Ducci, Francesca (2005) The Genetics of Addictions: Uncovering the Genes. Nature Reviews. Genetics 6, 521–532.Google Scholar
Grant, Jon E., Rani, Desai, and Potenza, Marc (2009). Relationship of Nicotine Dependence, Subsyndromal and Pathological Gambling, and Other Psychiatric Disorders: Data from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 70(3), 334–43.Google Scholar
Greenberg, David, and Knight, Genevieve (2007) Review of the DWP Cost Benefit Framework and How It Has Been Applied. Her Majesty’s Stationary Office, Leeds: Department of Work and Pensions.Google Scholar
Greenberg, David H., and Davis, Abigail (2007) Evaluation of the New Deal for Disabled People: The Cost and Cost-Benefit Analyses. Research Report No. 431. Leeds, United Kingdom: Department of Work and Pensions.Google Scholar
Greenberg, David H., and Robbins, Philip (2008) Incorporating Nonmarket Time into Benefit-Cost Analyses of Social Programs: An Application to the Self-Sufficiency Project. Journal of Public Economics 92(3-4), 766–794.Google Scholar
Grogger, Jeffrey, Karoly, Lynn A., and Klerman, Jacob Alex (2002) Consequences of Welfare Reform: A Research Synthesis. Santa Monica, CA: Rand.Google Scholar
Grossman, Michael (2006) Education and Nonmarket Outcomes. In Hanushek, Erik and Welch, F. (eds.) Handbook of the Economics of Education, Volume 1. Amsterdam: North-Holland, Elsevier.Google Scholar
Gruber, Jonathan (2002/2003) Smoking’s Internalities. Regulation 25(4), 52–57.Google Scholar
Gruber, Jonathan, and Koszegi, Botond (2001) Is Addiction ‘Rational’? Theory and Evidence. Quarterly Journal of Economics 116(4), 1261–1303.Google Scholar
Gruber, Jonathan, and Saez, Emmanuel (2002) The Elasticity of Taxable Income: Evidence and Implications. Journal of Public Economics, 84 (1), 1–32.Google Scholar
Guryan, Jonathan, and Kearney, Melissa Schettini (2009) Is Lottery Gambling Addictive? NBER Working Paper Series, No. 14742.Google Scholar
Hammett, Theodore M., Harmon, Mary Patricia and Rhodes, William (2002) The Burden of Infectious Disease Among Inmates of and Releasees from US Correctional Facilities, 1997. American Journal of Public Health 92(11), 1789–1794.Google Scholar
Hanushek, Erik A., and Woessmann, Ludger (2008) The Role of Cognitive Skills in Economic Development. Journal of Economic Literature 46(3), 607–668.Google Scholar
Harberger, Arnold C. (1978) On the Use of Distributional Weights in Social Cost-Benefit Analysis. Journal of Political Economy 86(2), S87–S120.Google Scholar
Harmon, Colm, Oosterbeek, Hessel, and Walker, Ian (2003) Returns to Education: Microeconomics. Journal of Economic Surveys 11(1), 115–155.Google Scholar
Harwood, Henrick J., Fountain, Douglas, and Livermore, Gina (1999) Economic Cost of Alcohol and Drug Abuse in 1992: A Report. Addiction 94(5), 631–647.Google Scholar
Haveman, Robert, and Wolfe, Barbara (1984) Schooling and Economic Well-Being: The Role of Nonmarket Effects. Journal of Human Resources 19(3), 377–407.Google Scholar
Haveman, Robert (1965) Water Resources Investment and the Public Interest. Nashville, Tenn.: Vanderbilt University Press.Google Scholar
Hayward, Mark D., Grady, William, and Billy, John O. (1992) The Influence of Socioeconomic Status on Adolescent Pregnancy. Social Science Quarterly 73(4), 750–772.Google Scholar
Heckman, James J. (2006) Skill Formation and the Economics of Investing in Disadvantaged Children. Science 312(5782), 1900–02.Google Scholar
Heckman, James J., Lochner, Lance J., and Todd, Petra E. (2006) Earnings Functions, Rates of Return and Treatment Effects: The Mincer Equation and Beyond. In Hanushek, Eric A. and Welch, Finis, eds., Handbook of the Economics of Education, 1. Amsterdam: Elsevier, North-Holland.Google Scholar
Her Majesty’s Treasury (2009) Green Book: Appraisal and Evaluation in Central Government. http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/data_greenbook_index.htm, Accessed June 16, 2009.Google Scholar
Hogg, R.C., and Bertrand, D. (2004) What Genes Tell Us about Nicotine Addiction. Science 306, November 5, 983–4.Google Scholar
Krutilla, Kerry (2005) Using the Kaldor-Hicks Tableau Format for Cost-Benefit Analysis and Policy Evaluation. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 24(4), 864–875.Google Scholar
Lam, David, and Duryea, Suzanne (1999) Effects of Schooling on Fertility, Labor Supply, and Investments in Children, with Evidence from Brazil. Journal of Human Resources 34(1), 160–192.Google Scholar
Laux, Fritz L. (2000) Addiction as a Market Failure: Using Rational Addiction Results to Justify Tobacco Regulation. Journal of Health Economics 19(4), 421–437.Google Scholar
Li, Chuan-Yun, Mao, Xizeng, and Wei, Liping (2008) Genes and (Common) Pathways Underlying Drug Addiction. PLoS Computational Biology 4(1): e2.Google Scholar
Ludwig, Jens, and Cook, Philip J. (2001) The Benefits of Reducing Gun Violence: Evidence from Contingent-Valuation Survey Data. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 22(3), 207–26.Google Scholar
Lynch, Allen K., and Rasmussen, David W. (2001) Measuring the Impact of Crime on House Prices. Applied Economics 33(15), 1981–89.Google Scholar
MacCoun, Robert, Reuter, Peter, and Schelling, Thomas (1996) Assessing Alternative Drug Control Regimes. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 15(3), 330–352.Google Scholar
Miller, Ted R., and Cohen, Mark (1997) Costs of Gunshot and Cut/Stab Wounds in the United States, with some Canadian Comparisons. Accident Analysis and Prevention 29(3), 329–341.Google Scholar
Miller, Ted R., Cohen, Mark A., and Wiersema, Brian (1996) Victim Costs and Consequences: A New Look. Washington, D.C.: National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
Milligan, Kevin, Moretti, Enrico, and Oreopoulos, Philip (2004) Does Education Improve Citizenship? Evidence from the United States and the United Kingdom. Journal of Public Economics 88(9-10), 1667–1695.Google Scholar
Moore, Tim (2007) Working Estimates of the Social Costs per Gram and per User for Cannabis, Cocaine, Opiates and Amphetamines. Sydney: National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, Drug Policy Modelling Program Monograph Series, No. 14.Google Scholar
Morris, Pamela (2001) How Welfare and Work Policies Affect Children: A Synthesis of Research. New York: MDRC.Google Scholar
Mukamel, Dana B., Gold, Heather Taffet, and Bennett, Nancy M. (2001) Cost Utility of Public Clinics to Increase Pneumococcal Vaccines in the Elderly. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 21(1), 29–34.Google Scholar
Narayanan, Sridhar, and Manchanda, Puneet (2008) An Empirical Analysis of Individual Level Casino Gambling. Stanford Graduate School of Business, Research Paper No. 2003.Google Scholar
Nicholson, Sean, Pauly, Mark V., Polsky, Daniel, Sharda, Claire, Szek, Helena, and Berger, Marc L. (2006) Measuring the Effects of Workloss on Productivity with Team Production. Health Economics 15(2), 111–123.Google Scholar
Nicol, Kristin L. (2001) Cost-Benefit Analysis of a Strategy to Vaccinate Healthy Working Adults against Influenza. Archives of Internal Medicine 161(5), 749–759.Google Scholar
Olsen, Jan Abel, and Richardson, Jeff (1999) Production Gains from Health Care: What Should Be Included in Cost-Effectiveness Analyses? Social Science & Medicine 49(1), 17–26.Google Scholar
Olsen, Jan Abel (1994) Production Gains: Should They Count in Health Care Evaluations? Scottish Journal of Political Economy 41(1), 69–84.Google Scholar
Oreopoulos, Philip (2006) Estimating Average and Local Average Treatment Effects of Education When Compulsory Schooling Laws Really Matter. American Economic Review 96(1), 152–175.Google Scholar
Perneger, Thomas V. (1998) What’s Wrong with Bonferroni Adjustments. British Medical Journal 316(7139), 1236–1238.Google Scholar
Potenza, Marc T., Kosten, Thomas R., and Rounsaville, Bruce J. (2001) Pathological Gambling. Journal of the American Medical Association 286(2), 141–44.Google Scholar
Rogers, Mark (2003) A Survey of Economic Growth. Economic Record 79(244), 112–135.Google Scholar
Roman, John K., and Visher, Christy (2009) Prisoner Reentry Programming. In Weimer, David L. and Vining, Aidan R., eds., Investing in the Disadvantaged: Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Social Policies. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 127–150.Google Scholar
Samuelson, Paul A. (1937) A Note on Measurement of Utility. Review of Economic Studies 4(2), 155–61.Google Scholar
Steiner, MaryAnn, Vermeulen, Lee C., Mullahy, John, and Hayney, Mary S. S. (2002) Factors Influencing Decisions Regarding Influenza Vaccination and Treatment: A Survey of Health Care Workers. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 23(10), 625–627.Google Scholar
Tapper, Andrew, McKinney, Sheri, Nashmi, Raad, Schwarz, Johannes, Deshpande, Purnima, Labarca, Cesar, Whiteaker, Paul, Marks, Michael J., Collins, Allan C., and Lester, Henry A. (2004) Nicotine Activation of a4* Receptors: Sufficient for Reward, Tolerance, and Sensitization. Science 306, November 5, 1029–32.Google Scholar
Taylor, Shelley E., and Brown, Jonathon D. (1988) Illusion and Well-Being: A Social Psychological Perspective on Mental Health. Psychological Bulletin 103, 193–210.Google Scholar
Uhl, G.R. (2004) Molecular Genetic Underpinnings of Human Substance Abuse Vulnerability: Likely Contributions to Understanding Addiction as a Mnemonic Process. Neuropharnacology 47 (Supplement 1), 140–147.Google Scholar
Weimer, David L., and Sager, Mark A. (2009) Early Identification and Treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease: Social and Fiscal Outcomes. Alzheimer’s & Dementia 5(3), 215–226.Google Scholar
Weimer, David L., and Vining, Aidan R. (2009) Investing in the Disadvantaged: Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Social Programs. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
Weimer, David L., Vining, Aidan R., and Thomas, Randall K. (2009) Cost-Benefit Analysis Involving Addictive Goods: Contingent Valuation to Estimate Willingness-to-Pay for Smoking Cessation. Health Economics 18(2), 181–202.Google Scholar
Weinstein, Milton C., Siegel, Joanna E., Garber, Alan M., Lipscomb, Joseph, Luce, Bryan R., Manning, Willard G. Jr., and Torrance, George (1997) Productivity Costs, Time Costs and Health-Related Quality of Life: A Response to the Erasmus Group. Health Economics 6(5), 505–510.Google Scholar
Weisbrod, Burton A. (1968) Income Redistribution Effects and Cost-Benefit Analysis. In Chase, S. B., ed., Problems in Public Expenditure Analysis. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution, 177–208.Google Scholar
Weisbrod, Burton A. (1981) Benefit-Cost Analysis of a Controlled Experiment: Treating the Mentally Ill. Journal of Human Resources 16(4), 523–548.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Barbara, and Tefft, Nathan (2009) Early Childhood Interventions. In Weimer, David L. and Vining, Aidan R., eds., Investing in the Disadvantaged: Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Social Policies. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 17–29.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Barbara, and Haveman, Robert (2001) Accounting for the Social and Non-Market Benefits of Education. In Helliwell, John F., ed., The Contribution of Human and Social Capital to Sustained Economic Growth and Well Being. Vancouver, B.C.: University of British Columbia Press, 221–250.Google Scholar
Zerbe, Richard O. Jr., Bauman, Yoram, and Finkle, Aaron (2006) An Aggregate Measure for Benefit-Cost Analysis. Ecological Economics 58(2), 449–461.Google Scholar