Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-g8jcs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T02:58:22.209Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Revolution or Just Another Bloody Cycle? Swatow and the 1911 Revolution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Edward Friedman
Get access

Abstract

The 1911 Revolution in China is usually considered a failure. Changing the perspective of judgement from the national level to the local level permits a reassessment. Enough information is available from Chinese memoirs, contemporary newspapers, and foreign consular reports to make the new judgement somewhat secure if attention is focused on one particular location—Swatow.

The old administration was overthrown by expeasants led by deracinated rural intellectuals. They took power in the name of modern merchants. These merchants easily pushed the young radicals out because the ideology of the radical prevented them from using force against the wealth and status of the merchants. Rural disorder of the ex-peasants and republican election victorier for the radicals forced the urban merchants to rely on foreign election victories for the radicals forced the urban merchants to rely on foreign wealth and rural power to maintain law and order needed for trade and to maintain their own urban power base. Armed peasants and the young radicals were suppressed or bought off. Power fell to rural warlords and other political allies in urban enclaves. Only a rejoining of radical intellectuals and ex-peasants could offer China a revolution instead of just another bloody cycle.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 29 , Issue 2 , February 1970 , pp. 289 - 307
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1970

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Morse, Hosea B., The Gilds of China (London, 1909), pp. 53–56.Google Scholar

2 British Foreign Office (FO) 371/1095, Jordan to Grey, no. 426.

3 Hsin-hai ko-ming (HHKM), VII (Shanghai, 1957). p. 226.Google Scholar

4 Hsin-hai ko-ming hui-i-lu (HHKMHIL), II (Peking, 1962), p. 359Google Scholar; FO, 371/1096 Jordan, to Grey, , 11 16, 1911.Google Scholar

5 Kulp, Daniel, Country Life in South China (New York, 1925), p. 3.Google Scholar

6 United States State Department Archives, 893. 00/911, Swatow, , 12 1, 1911.Google Scholar

7 HHKMHIL, II, p. 360.Google Scholar

8 Chung-kuo min-kuo k'ai-kuo wu-shih nien wen-hsien (KKWH), 2:IV Taiwan, 1962, p. 478.Google Scholar

9 HHKMHIL, II, pp. 361 and 362.Google Scholar

10 France (Archives des Affaires Etrangères, Chine, Nouvelle Serie), 32/135–138, Swatow, , 12 7, 1911Google Scholar. The French sources were made available to me through the extraordinary generosity of Professor Marianne Bastid.

11 KKWH, 2.IV, p. 488.Google Scholar

12 France, 33/138–40, Swatow, , 12 22, 1911.Google Scholar

13 Idem; 893.00/1006, Swatow, , 12 21, 1911.Google Scholar

14 893.00/1006, Swatow, , 12 21, 1911.Google Scholar

15 893.00/911, Swatow, , 12 1, 1911.Google Scholar

16 893.00/1006, Swatow, , 12 21, 1911.Google Scholar

17 KKWH, 2.IV, pp. 487–488.Google Scholar

18 Ibid., p. 478.

19 France, 33/138–40, Swatow, , 12 22, 1911.Google Scholar

20 HHKMHIL, II, p. 361Google Scholar; KKWH, 2.IV, p. 478.Google Scholar

21 KKWH, 2.IV, pp. 478 and 488Google Scholar; HHKMHIL, II, pp. 361–362.Google Scholar

22 KKWH, 2.IV, p. 488.Google Scholar

23 893.00/1102, Swatow, , 01 11, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1093, Swatow, , 01 19, 1912.Google Scholar

24 France, 36/195–198, Swatow, , 02 1, 1912.Google Scholar

25 I have no information about whether any of these men were rich absentee landlords.

26 HHKMHIL, II, p. 361Google Scholar. Sun Tan-yai and others insist, however, that Chang asked to be sent north (KKWH, 2.IV, pp. 478 and 487).Google Scholar

27 893.00/1143, Swatow, , 01 26, 1912.Google Scholar

28 893.00/1245, Swatow, , 02 29, 1912.Google Scholar

29 893.00/1180, Swatow, , 02 5, 1912.Google Scholar

30 Chin-tai shih tzu-liao (Peking, 1958), no. 2, p. 52.Google Scholar

31 KKWH, 2.IV, pp. 478–479 and 488.Google Scholar

32 “The [Ch'ao-chou speaking] villagers look upon the Hakka somewhat as they do upon foreigners because, coming into the region later… the Hakka did not accept the local civilization and particularly did not adopt the native language.” (Kulp, , op. cit., p. 80.)Google Scholar

33 893.00/1093, Swatow, , 01 19, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/ 1180, Swatow, , 02 5, 1912.Google Scholar

34 KKWH, 2.IV, p. 479.Google Scholar

35 Ibid., pp. 488–489.

36 This theme is argued in detail in my forthparticularly coming book, The Center Cannot Hold.

37 893.00/1195, Swatow, , 02 16, 1912.Google Scholar

38 Idem.

39 Kong, HongTelegraph, 03 12, 1912, p. 1.Google Scholar

40 893.00/1272, Swatow, , 03 13, 1912.Google Scholar

41 KKWH, 2.IV, p. 478–479Google Scholar; HHKMHIL, II, p. 362.Google Scholar

42 893.00/1271, Swatow, , 03 18, 1912.Google Scholar

43 Idem.

44 893.00/1182, Swatow, , 03 16, 1912.Google Scholar

45 893.00.1271, Swatow, , 03 18, 1912.Google Scholar

46 Overland China Mail, 06 22, 1912, p. 20.Google Scholar

47 The State Department memorandum of July 1950 rationalizing the “Authority of the President to Repel the Attack in Korea” does so in part listing several score of precedents. The 52nd creatively reads, “52. China, Swatow … 1912 … To save a woman and some children and conduct them to safety.” (Department of State Bulletin, 07 31, 1950, p. 178.)Google Scholar In 1916 a Japanese Foreign Office spokesman took “the example of the American marines who were landed from the Cincinnati in Swatow” as a rationale for Japanese intervention in North China (Peking Daily News, 05 12, 1916, p. 4).Google Scholar

48 893.00/1271, Swatow, , 03 18, 1912.Google Scholar

49 The Provincial Assembly on March 18, 1912 with 130 members in attendance voted to look into Lin Chi-chen's causing the Swatow disturbances (Kong, HongTelegraph, 03 21, 1912, p. 5).Google Scholar

50 Kong, HongTelegraph, 04 3, 1912, p. 5.Google Scholar

51 South China Morning Post (SCMP), 03 18, 1912, p. 2Google Scholar; Mar. 27, 1912, p. 3; Apr. 5, 1912, p. 11.

52 893.00/1302, Swatow, , 03 26, 1912.Google Scholar

53 893.00/1324, U.S.S. Monterey in Swatow, , 04 13, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1305, Swatow, , 04 6, 1912.Google Scholar

54 SCMP, 10 30, 1912, p. 7.Google Scholar

55 893.00/1324, U.S.S. Moneterey in Swatow, , 04 13, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1331, U.S.S. Monterey in Swatow, , 04 20, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1333, Swatow, , 05 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1348, Swatow, , 05 14, 1912Google Scholar. Merchant compradore Kao Sheng-chih put up at least $60,000 to buy off Lin and the other troops. Kao soon after fell ill and died.

56 KKWH, 2.IV p. 489Google Scholar; 893.00/1380, Swatow, , 06 18, 1912.Google Scholar

57 893.00/1343, Swatow, , 05 13, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1379, Swatow, , 06 14, 1912Google Scholar; KKWH, 2.IV, pp. 479 and 489Google Scholar; HHKMHIL, II, p. 362.Google Scholar

58 HHKMHIL, II, p. 361.Google Scholar

59 Kulp, , op. cit., p. 41.Google Scholar

60 FO, 228/2452, Jamieson, to Jordan, , 02 3, 1913Google Scholar and Jordan, to Jamieson, , 02 4, 1913.Google Scholar

61 FO, 228/2453, Swatow, , 02 18, 1913.Google Scholar

62 FO, 228/2453, translation from Canton 72 Guild Daily (Ch'i-shih-erh hang-pao), 03 11, 1913.Google Scholar

63 FO, 228/2453, Swatow, , 03 28, 1913.Google Scholar

64 Min-li pao, 02 18, 1913, p. 8Google Scholar, and Feb. 19, 1913, p. 10, reports to the Kwangtung Provincial Assembly of Hu-Han-min and Ch'en Chiung-ming.

65 Kong, HongTelegraph, 04 9, 1912.Google Scholar

66 Such is the main message of the memoirs of those from rural areas as recorded in HHKMHIL, II.

67 This is established in Kraus, Richard A.'s brilliant doctoral dissertation, Cotton and Cotton Goods in China 1918–1936: The Impact of Modernization on the Traditional Sector, Harvard University, Department of Economics, 1968.Google Scholar

68 Kulp, , op. cit., p. 160.Google Scholar

69 Ibid., p. 105.

70 “The people pray to be free from disease so that they may have long life. The latter is the real value.” (Ibid., p. 61.)

71 Ibid., p. 26.

72 SCMP, 10 13, 1912, p. 6.Google Scholar

73 Kulp, , op. cit., pp. 3–4.Google Scholar

74 Ibid., p. 12.

75 Ibid., p. 31.

76 893.00/1331, Monterey, U.S.S., 04 20, 1913Google Scholar. The source for this particular piece of intelligence was a minister, the Reverend Dr. Fostor. Missionaries served as an informal but extensive intelligence network for the foreign legations.

77 Kuo-fu ch'uan chi, Taiwan, 1965, II, speeches, pp. 16–17Google Scholar contains a report of Sun Yat-sen's speech.

78 The non-Hakka CRA people killed may have been connected with the Restoration Society. Factional strife racked the CRA in Kwangtung at this time. (Hsin-hai ko-ming wu-shih nien chou-nien lun-wen chi, Peking, 1962, II, p. 512.)Google Scholar

79 893.00/1103, Swatow, , 09 5, 1912Google Scholar; SCMP, Sept. 14, 1912, p. 7. reports that the Chamber of Commerce bought up $20,000, not $30,000. Perhaps this 50% discrepancy in the two figures should be taken as indicative of the generally unreliable nature of the numbers offered in this essay.

80 893.51/1103, Swatow, , 09 5, 1912.Google Scholar

81 FO, 228/2451, Sassoons, to Jordan, , 11 6 and 11, 1912.Google Scholar

82 SCMP, 10 26, 1912, p. 7.Google Scholar

83 See, for example, the translation from the Canton Kuo-min pao, 12 25, 1912Google Scholar in FO, 228/2452 and FO, 228/2452, Jamieson, to Jordan, , 01 14, 1913.Google Scholar

84 FO 228/2452, Pakhoi, , 03 2, 1913Google Scholar. This is the first mention of Pakhoi in the essay. I do not feel confident enough in the sources available to me to piece together a coherent picture of Pakhoi politics in the 1911–1913 period. French sources and a trip to Paris would be necessary for that. For example, the French Courrier d'Haiphong which had frequent coverage of the neighboring Pakhoi area as it closely followed French commercial interests in southeast Kwangtung reported, “In the period of a week from November 13–18, 1911 all the imperial authorities of the city of Limchow … left their posts which then remained without any kind of government.” (FO, 228/1874, enclosure). Without many such sources my tentative sketch is of an area many of whose merchants are Canton people. The general explosion of local loyalties unleashed much anti-Canton sentiment. Canton quarters in some places were burned down. In other towns merchant self-defense corps were successful. There was the ubiquitous attempt to hold on to local taxes (HHKM, VII, p. 274.Google Scholar) and the ubiquitous outside army sent to collect them and restore order. Lung Chi-kuang's hordes arrived (Hsin-hai ko-ming tzu-liao, Peking, 1961 p. 208Google Scholar) and plundered widely in early 1912. Plunder by government troops was paralleled (non-parailed?) by banditry by peasant bands. Order and government were never quite restored except in the main administrative centers. In short, the Swatow area is not unique.

85 SCMP, 02 25, 1913, p. 3.Google Scholar

86 Mar. 11, 1913, p. 6.

87 North China Herald, 04 19, 1913, p. 194.Google Scholar

88 893.51/1103, Swatow, , 09 5, 1912.Google Scholar

89 FO, 228/2452, Swatow, , 03 7 and 8, 1912.Google Scholar

90 SCMP, 11 19, 1912, p. 7.Google Scholar

91 Idem; the butcher tax problem caused even more trouble in Canton.

92 Idem.

93 SCMP, 05 17, 1913, p. 7.Google Scholar

94 SCMP, 01 22, 1913 and 04 8, 1913, p. 7.Google Scholar

95 893.00/1404, Swatow, , 06 24, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1411, Swatow, , 07 12, 1912.Google Scholar

96 KKWH, 2.IV, p. 481.Google Scholar

97 FO 228/1874, Pakhoi Intelligence Report for the Quarter Ended Dec. 20, 1912, p. 3.

98 FO, 228/1874, Pakhoi Intelligence Report for the Quarter Ended Mar. 31, 1913, pp. 7–8.

99 893.00/1411, Swatow, , 07 12, 1912, p. 2.Google Scholar

100 893.00/1490, Swatow, , 10 17, 1912.Google Scholar

101 893.00/1156, Feb. 13, 1912.

102 893.00/1490, Swatow, , 10 17, 1912.Google Scholar

103 Idem.; the Consul believed that “the course the election in Swatow, is doubtless typical.”Google Scholar

104 893.00/1490, Swatow, , 10 17, 1912.Google Scholar

105 SCMP, 10 16, 1912, p. 7.Google Scholar

106 893.00/1490, Swatow, , 10 17, 1912.Google Scholar

107 Four isues of the magazine, Chung-kuo t'ung-meng-hui Yueh chih-pu tza-chih, can be found in the archive of the Nationalist Party in Taiwan.

108 Ibid, no. 4, Aug. 11, 1912, p. 3.

109 893.03/4, Swatow, , 03 17, 1913.Google Scholar

110 FO, 228/1874, Intelligence Report for the Quarter Ended Mar. 31, 1913.

111 893.00/1490, Swatow, , 10 17, 1912.Google Scholar

112 FO, 228/1874.

113 British Colonial Office (CO) 129/403, May to Harcourt, 08 7, 1913.Google Scholar

114 Lu, Tsou, Ch'eng lu wen hsuan (Shanghai, 1948), p. 61.Google Scholar

115 Min kuo, Tokyo, 08 8, 1914, p. 16.Google Scholar

116 Yeh Hsia-sheng, (Shanghai, n.d.), p. 10.Google Scholar

117 893.00/2303, deposition of Hu Han-min in a 1915 libel suit.

118 893.00/1475, Swatow, , 09 24, 1912.Google Scholar

119 SCMP, 10 28, 1912, p. 7Google Scholar; 893.00/1514, Swatow, , 11 19, 1912Google Scholar; 893.00/1519, Swatow, , 11 27, 1912.Google Scholar

120 893.00/1514, Swatow, , 11 19, 1912.Google Scholar

121 SCMP, 01 22, 1913Google Scholar, reports from Swatow that “All but the landless [and the Triads] are quiet.”

122 893.00/1633, Swatow, , 03 27, 1913.Google Scholar

123 Hua-tzu jih-pao (Hong Kong), 04 14, 1913, p. 72Google Scholar. This source was generously made available to me by Prof. Edward J. M. Rhoads.

124 FO, 228/1874, Pakhoi, , 06 30, 1913, p. 3.Google Scholar

125 FO, 228/1981, Intelligence Reports for the Kwang-chou and Pakhoi Districts for the Quarter Ended Dec. 31, 1915, pp. 2–3. When one reads (Kong, HongTelegraph, 10 29, 1914Google Scholar) that the compradore for the Chartered Bank died “leaving a personal estate of $680,000,” one begins to get a feel for the relatively overwhelming power held by these compradores.

126 FO, 228/1874 and FO, 228/2500, Pitzipio to Alston, July 23, 1913.