Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-28T02:56:35.627Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Changing Soviet Views on Mahatma Gandhi

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 March 2011

Hemen Ray
Get access

Extract

In evaluating Mahatma Gandhi, Soviet scholars have always endeavored to identify him from a class viewpoint even though they frequently disagreed on the definitions of the various classes and on the attitude to be taken toward them. Mahatma Gandhi, although he came from the bourgeois class, always considered himself a socialist and a “true servant of the peasants and of the workers.” He was firmly of the opinion that “even a King can be a socialist by becoming a servant of the people.” He once told Nehru that “even when I die, you will have to admit that Gandhi was a true socialist.” Gandhi was a religious man. He believed not only in the basic philosophy of Hinduism, but also in its social structure. He deprecated the abolition of caste while opposing untouchability. He was unmodern by Western and Communist standards and he wanted India as a confederation of small village communities economically and politically self-sufficient. In the words of Nehru:

He looked back with yearning to the days of the old autonomous and more-or-less self-contained village community where there had been an automatic balance between production, distribution and consumption; where political or economic power was spread out and not concentrated as it is today; where a kind of simple democracy prevailed; where the evils of great cities were absent and people lived in contact with the life-giving soil and breathed the pure air of the open spaces.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 29 , Issue 1 , November 1969 , pp. 85 - 106
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1969

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Tendulkar, D. G., Mahatma: Life of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, VIII, (Bombay: 1951–1954), 40–41.Google Scholar

2 Nehru, Jawaharlal, Discovery of India, (London: Meridian Books Limited, 1951), p. 381.Google Scholar

3 Fischer, Louis, The Life of Mahatma Gandhi, (London: Cape, 1951), p. 355.Google Scholar

4 Quoted in Eudin, Xenia Joukoff and North, Robert C., Soviet Russia and the East, 1920–1527. A Documentary Survey (Hereafter Xenia and North), (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1957), p. 92.Google Scholar

5 Ibid., p. 161.

6 Lenin, , Sochineniia, XXXIII, 313.Google Scholar

7 Lenin, , Sochineniia, XXX, 365.Google Scholar

8 Ibid., XXV, 352–55; also Roy, M. N.'s “Memoirs,” Amrita Bazar Patrika, February 24, and May 18, 1952.Google Scholar

9 Cf. Gevorkyan, K. and Komarov, E., Landmarks of Great Friendship—The October Revolution and the Soviet-Indian Cooperation, (Information Department of the USSR Embassy in India, 1967) p. 11Google Scholar. Soviet authors quoted Lenin saying that Gandhi by organizing and heading the mass anti-imperialist movement was playing a revolutionary role.

10 Roy, M. N.'s “Memoirs,” Amrita Bazar Patrika, May 18, 1952.Google Scholar

11 Roy, M. N., “Die revolutionaere Bewegung,” Kommunistische Internationale, No. 12, 1920, pp. 239–48.Google Scholar

12 Vtoroi Kongress Kominterna, iiul-avgust, 1920, (Moscow: 1934), pp. 496–99Google Scholar. For a more detailed discussion of Roy-Lenin debate see Haithcox, John, “The Roy-Lenin Debate on Colonial Policy; a new Interpretation,” The Journal of Asian Studies, XXIII, No. 1, (November 1963), 93–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

13 Roy, M. N.'s “Memoirs,” Amrita Bazar Patrika, April 9 and May 18, 1952Google Scholar; also Carr, Edward Hallet, The Bolshevik Revolution, 1917–1923, III, (New York: Macmillan, 1953), 254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

14 Stalin, , Sochineniia, IV, 351Google Scholar; also Zhizn natsionalnostei, 09 2, 1920, p. 2.Google Scholar

15 Xenia, and North, , p. 76.Google Scholar

16 “Die gegenwaertigen Ereignisse in Indien,” Kommumstische Internationale, No. 19, 1921, pp. 189–96Google Scholar; also Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahatma Gandhi,” Far Eastern Affairs, No. 3, 1965, pp. 87–89.Google Scholar

17 Ibid.

18 Roy, M. N. and Roy, Evelyn, One year of Non-Cooperation From Ahmedabad to Gaya, (Calcutta: Communist Party of India, 1923), p. 60.Google Scholar

19 Tivel, A., “Puti i perspektivy indiiskoi revoliutsii,” Novy Vostok, No. 1, 1922, pp. 104–18.Google Scholar

20 Nehru, Jawaharlal, An Autobiography, with Musings on Recent Events in India, (London: The Bodley Head, 1958), p. 82.Google Scholar

21 A Bunch of Old Letters: Written mostly to Jawaharlal Nehru and Some Written by Him, (London: Asia Publishing House, 1960), p. 24.Google Scholar

22 Nehru, Jawaharlal, An Autobiography, p. 84.Google Scholar

23 Nehru on Gandhi: A Selection, arranged in the order of events, from the Writings and Speeches of Jawaharlal Nehru, (New York: The John Day Company, 1948), pp. 10–11.Google Scholar

24 Fourth Congress of the Communist International, abriged Report of Meeting held at Petrograd and Moscow, 11 7 and December 3, 1922Google Scholar, (Published for the Communist International by the Communist Party of Great Britain, 1922), p. 26.

25 Ibid., p. 224.

26 Novy Vostok, No. 9, 1922Google Scholar, in Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahatma Gandhi,” loc. cit., p. 90.Google Scholar

27 Roy, M. N., India in Transition, (Geneva: J. B. Parget, 1922), p. 236.Google Scholar

28 Times, 01 1, 1923.Google Scholar

29 Kommunistischeskaia Revoliutsiia, No. 13–14, 1923, pp. 23–28.Google Scholar

30 young India, May 4, 1921.Google Scholar

31 Ibid., December 11, 1924.

32 It is interesting to note that Maxim Gorky played the primary role in persuading the Bolshevik leaders to commission Romain Rolland to write the biography of Gandhi. At the beginning of 1920's when Gandhi emerged as the leader of the Indian independence movement, Gorky held the view that Russian people should know about Gandhi. At the beginning of 1923 he wrote Rolland to write a biography of Gandhi because “we here know about Gandhi only from newspapers and it would be good for the Russian people to familiarize themselves with some of his views from primary sources.” Rolland quickly complied with Gorky's request.

33 Stalin, , Sochineniia, VI, 98.Google Scholar

34 Young India, December 1, 1924.Google Scholar

35 Kommunisticheskii International, No. 1, 1925, p. 133.Google Scholar

36 Mirinov, L., “Gandhi Centenary: A Russian Tribute,” Amrita Bazar Patrika, October 6, 1968.Google Scholar

37 Roy, M. N., “Klassovaia differentsiia v revoliutsionnom dvizhenii Indii,” Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, No. 5, 1925, pp. 149–68Google Scholar. Also see Voitinsky, G. N., “Kolonialnyi vopros na rasshirennom plenume IKKI,” Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, No. 4, 1925, pp. 64–66.Google Scholar

38 Stalin, , Socheneniia, VII, 147Google Scholar; also Degras, Jane, ed., Soviet Documents on Foreign Policy, 1925–32, II (Oxford: 1952), 48.Google Scholar

39 XV sezd vsesoiuznoi kommunisticheskoi partii (B), Stenograficheskii otchet, (Moscow: 1928), pp. 606–09.Google Scholar

40 Degras, Jane, ed., The Communist International, 1919–1943, II (Oxford: 1960), pp. 519 and 544–45.Google Scholar

41 Young India, 11 15, 1928.Google Scholar

42 Litman, A. D., “Gandhiji loved Russians and loved by them,” Amrita Bazar Patrika, October 1, 1967.Google Scholar

43 Harijan, March 31, 1946.Google Scholar

44 Bolshaia sovetskaia entsiklopediia, (1st ed., Moscow: 1929), XIV, 514–17.Google Scholar

45 Quoted in Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahauna Gandhi,” loc. cit., pp. 95–97.Google Scholar

46 Kuusinen, Otto, “The Indian Revolution and Gandhi's Maneuver,” International Prest Carrespondence, March 20, 1930, pp. 241–42.Google Scholar

47 International Press Correspondence, July 31, 1930, p. 666.Google Scholar

48 [I. M.] Reisner, , “Gandhi, Der Prophet der indischen Bourgeoisie,” Kommunistische Internationale, No. 20, 1930, pp. 1130–38Google Scholar; in Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahatma Gandhi,” loc. cit., pp. 99–100.Google Scholar

49 Ibid.

50 Quoted in Times, May 15, 1930.Google Scholar

51 Pravda, May 19, 1930.Google Scholar

52 Ibid., January 6, 1932.

53 Degras, Jane, ed., Soviet Documents on Foreign Policy, 1925–32, II, 443.Google Scholar

54 International Press Correspondence, March 19, 1931, pp. 294–95.Google Scholar

55 Ibid., also Ibid., March 6, 1931, p. 557.

56 Nehru, Jawaharlal, An Autobiography, p. 127.Google Scholar

57 G. S., “The Next Tasks of the Revolutionary Movement in India,” International Press Correspondence, February 26, 1931, p. 182.Google Scholar

58 Valiia, , “Konstitutsiia poraboshcheniia indiiskogo naroda i politika indiiskoi burzhuazii,” Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, June 10, 1933, pp. 56–62.Google Scholar

59 The reason of this ambivalent attitude was that Gandhi't attitude toward Communism was never influenced by an obssession with the Communist ideology. He opposed only the violent nature of Communism. He often called himself a nonviolent Communist. Apart from it, he was influenced by Nehru's report after his visit to Moscow to attend the 10th anniversary of the Bolshevik revolution. In December 1927, Nehru returned home with full of praises for new Russia. Addressing the All-Bengal students' conference in September 1928, Nehru said: “And Russia what of her? An outcaste like us from nations and much slandered and often erring. But in spite of her many mistakes, she stands today as the greatest opponent of imperialism and her record with the nations of the East is just and generous … Russia goes to the East as equal, not as a conqueror or a race proud superior. Is it wonder that she is welcomed. …”; Nehru, Jawaharlal, Before and After Independence: A collection of the most important and soul-stirring speeches delivered by J. Nehru, 1920–1950, Bright, J., ed. (New Delhi: Indian Printing Works, 1950), pp. 65–66.Google Scholar

60 Young India, July 2, 1931.Google Scholar

61 Nehru, Jawaharlal, Some Random Sketches and Impressions, (Bombay: Chetna, 1929), p. 131.Google Scholar

62 National Front, April 30, 1939, p. 189.Google Scholar

63 Melman, S., “Indiia v borbe za svoiu natsionalnuiu nezavisimost,” Mirovoe khoziastvo i mirovaia politika, No. 9, 1939, pp. 92–104Google Scholar; Bashuevich, V., “Natsionalno-osvoboditelnoe dvizhnie v Indii i borba rabochego klass,”Google ScholarIbid., No. 11, 1939, pp. 133–53.

64 “O. nekotorikh voprosakh roboty kompartii v usloviiakh voiny,” Kommunistcheskii Internatsional, No. 6, 1940, pp. 108–14.Google Scholar

65 Kochariants, G., “Voina i natsionalno-osvobodi-telnoe dvizhenie indiiskogo naroda,” Bolshevik, July 1940, pp. 56–76.Google Scholar

66 Harijan, 09 30, 1939.Google Scholar

67 A Bunch of Old Litters, pp. 424–25.Google Scholar

68 Lemin, I., “Rol Britanskoi imperil v sovremenoi voine,” Bolshevik, No. 9, 1941, pp. 27–37.Google Scholar

69 Melman, S., “Polozhenie v Indii,” Mirovoe khoziastvo i mirovaia politika, No. 11–12, 1942, pp. 46–57Google Scholar; also Lemin, L., “Anglo-indiiskie otnosheniia i voina,”Google ScholarIbid., No. 5–6, 1942, pp. 76–84.

70 Britanskaia Imperiia, (Moscow: 1943), p. 227.Google Scholar

71 Zhukov, E., “Velikaia oktiabrskaia sotsialisticheskaia revoliutsiia i kolonialnyi vostok,” Bolshevik, October 1946, p. 43.Google Scholar

72 Zhukov, , “K polozheniiu v Indii,” Mirovoe khoziastvo i mirovaia politika, No. 7, 1947, pp. 3–14.Google Scholar

73 Dyakov, A. M., Natsionalnyi vopros i angliiskii imperializm v Indii, (Moscow: 1948), p. 33.Google Scholar

74 Dyakov, , “Crisis of the Colonial System,” (Bombay: People's Publishing House, 1951), p. 32.Google Scholar

75 Communist III, 01 1950, p. 23.Google Scholar

76 Dyakov, A. M., Indiia i Pakistan, (Moscow: 1950), p. 15.Google Scholar

77 Dyakov, , Indiia vo uremia i posle vtoroi mirovoi voiny, 1939–1949, (Moscow: 1952), p. 162.Google Scholar

78 Bolshaiia sovetskia entsiklopediia, Vol. X, (2nd. ed., 1952), pp. 203–04Google Scholar

79 Ibid.

80 The Hindu, October 13, 1954Google Scholar, in Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahatma Ganhdi,” loc cit., p. 109.Google Scholar

81 “Za dalneishi podem sovetskogo vostokovedeniia,” Kommunist, No. 8, 1955, pp. 78–83.Google Scholar

82 Balabushevich, V. and Dyakov, A., “Kniga o velikom indiskom narode, The Discovery of India” Kommunist, No. 9, 1955, pp. 98–106.Google Scholar

83 Pravda, 11 22, 1955.Google Scholar

84 Ibid.

85 Pravda, 11 25, 1955.Google Scholar

86 Quoted in New Times, 11 18, 1955.Google Scholar

87 Pravda, February 20, 1956.Google Scholar

88 “XX szed kommunisticheskoi partii sovetskogo soyuza i zadachi izucheniia sovremennogo vostoka.” Sovetskoe Vostokovedenie, No. 1, 1956, pp. 3–12.Google Scholar

89 Zhukov, E., “Gandhi's Role in History,” New Times, February 2, 1956, pp. 15–16.Google Scholar

90 Zhukov, E., “Raspad kolonialnoi sistemy imperializma,” Partiinia Zhizn, No. 16, 1956, p. 45.Google Scholar

91 Mezhdunarodnaia Zhizn, No. 3, 1956, pp. 61–63.Google Scholar

92 Azizian, A., “Raspad kolonialnoi sistemy imperializma i novie otnoshenia mezhdu stranami,” Voprosy Ekonomiki, No. 10, 1956, p. 9.Google Scholar

93 Alayev, L. B., “Izuchenie istorii Indii v SSSR 1917–1934 godakh,” Narody Azii i Afriki, No. 2, 1963, pp. 161–172Google Scholar; “Diskusii ob ekonomicheskikh i politicheskikh positsiiakh natsionalnoi burzhuazii v stranakh vostoka,” Sovetskoe Vostokovedenie, No. 1. 1957. p. 179.Google Scholar

94 Dyakov, A. M. and Reisner, I. M., “Rol Gandhi v natsionalno-osvoboditelnoi borbe narodov Indii,” Sovetskoe Vostokovedenie, No. 5, 1956, pp. 21–34.Google Scholar

95 Pravda, August 5, 1958.Google Scholar

96 Shifman, A., “Lev Tolstoi i Mahatma Gandhi,” Sovremenni Vostok, No. 9, 1960, pp. 16–19.Google Scholar

97 Litman, A., “Borets za nezavisimost Indii, Sovremenni Vostok, No. 2, 1958, pp. 23–25.Google Scholar

98 Pravda, 01 27, 1957.Google Scholar

99 Pravda, December 12, 1964 and 01 7, 1965.Google Scholar

100 New York Times, October 1, 1965Google Scholar; Times of India, October 2, 1965.Google Scholar

101 Pravda, July 15, 1966.Google Scholar

102 Martyshin, O. V., “K khrakteristike sotsialnykh idealov Gandizma,” Voprosy Filosofii, No. 1, 1965, pp. 95–108.Google Scholar

103 Komarov, E. N., “Ideological bond between Gandhi and Tolstoy,” Indian Express, 11 7, 1968.Google Scholar

104 Revoliutsionnyi Vostok, No. 7, 1922, p. 117Google Scholar in Tidmarsh, Kyril, “The Soviet Re-Assessment of Mahatma Gandhi,” loc. cit., pp. 95–96.Google Scholar

105 PTI dispatch from Moscow, October 4, 1968.

106 Quoted in Hindustan Timer, October 5, 1968.Google Scholar

107 Schorr, Bianca, “Mahatma Gandhi: Zum Gedenken,” Deutsche Aussenpolitik. No. 2, 1968, pp. 167–172.Google Scholar

108 New China News Agency, October 12, 1968.

109 Pravda, July 18, 1968.Google Scholar

110 Ibid., July 19, 1968.

111 India News, July 13, 1968.Google Scholar

112 Amrita Bazar Patrika, 11 2, 1968.Google Scholar

113 Times of India, 11 1, 1968.Google Scholar

114 Quoted in Amrita Bazar Patrika, 11 7, 1968.Google Scholar