Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T21:59:17.576Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Where Is Bhutan?” The Production of Bhutan's Asymmetrical Inbetweenness in Geopolitics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 February 2021

Nitasha Kaul
Nitasha Kaul*
Affiliation:
Nitasha Kaul ([email protected]) is Associate Professor/Reader in Politics and International Relations at the Centre for the Study of Democracy, University of Westminster in London.
Get access

Abstract

In this article, I interrogate the exhaustive “inbetweenness” through which Bhutan is understood and located on a map (“inbetween India and China”). I argue that this understanding naturalizes a contemporary geopolitics with little depth about how this inbetweenness has shifted over the centuries, thereby constructing a timeless, obscure, and remote Bhutan that is “naturally” oriented southward. I trace how the construction of Bhutan's asymmetrical inbetweenness is nested in the larger story of the formation and consolidation of imperial British India and its dissolution, and the emergence of post-colonial India as a successor state. I identify and analyze the key economic dynamics of three phases marked by commercial, production, and security interests, through which this asymmetrical inbetweenness was consolidated. Bringing together sources from different disciplines and archival work, this account also challenges some of the dominant historical scholarship on Bhutan in each phase. I conclude by emphasizing that critical work at the intersection of geographical/political/historical contingencies is important to the subalternizing of geopolitics, which recognizes the myriad ways in which dominant powers have shaped both the geopolitical environment as well as knowledge-making that has constrained small states.

Keywords

BhutanBritish IndiageopoliticsimperialismIndiapostcolonialsecurity
Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 80 , Issue 2 , May 2021 , pp. 317 - 336
Check for updates
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc., 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Ardussi, John Albert. 1977. “Bhutan before the British: A Historical Study.” PhD diss., Australian National University, Canberra.Google Scholar
Aris, Michael. 1979. Bhutan: The Early History of a Himalayan Kingdom. Warminster: Aris and Philips Ltd.Google Scholar
Asian Relations Organization Report. 1948. Asian Relations: Being Report of the Proceedings and Documentation of the First Asian Relations Conference, New Delhi, March–April, 1947. New Delhi: Asian Relations Organization.Google Scholar
Avtar, R. 1986. “Bhutan—A Geopolitical Survey.” In India's Northern Security, edited by Sharma, Gautam and Nagar, K. S., 193–200. New Delhi: Reliance Publishing House.Google Scholar
Basu, Gautam Kumar. 1996. Bhutan: The Political Economy of Development. New Delhi: South Asian Publishers.Google Scholar
Bhattacharya, S. S. 1965. “Bhutan in the Early Ages.” Read in the 27th Session of the Indian History Congress held at Allahabad 29th to 31st December. Summary published in Proceedings of the Indian History Congress 27: 73.Google Scholar
Bishop, Peter. 1989. The Myth of Shangri-La: Tibet, Travel Writing, and the Western Creation of Sacred Landscape. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Black, Jeremy. 2018. Geographies of an Imperial Power: The British World, 1688–1815. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Bray, John. 2009. “Krishnakanta Basu, Rammohan Ray and Early 19th Century British Contacts with Bhutan and Tibet.” Tibet Journal 34/35 (3/2): 329–56.Google Scholar
Cammann, Schuyler V. 1951. Trade through the Himalayas: The Early British Attempts to Open Tibet. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Coelho, V. H. 1970. Sikkim and Bhutan. New Delhi: Indian Council for Cultural Relations.Google Scholar
Das, B. S. 1986. “Economic Development and Social Changes in Bhutan.” In Domestic Conflicts in South Asia: Economic and Ethnic Dimensions, Volume 2, edited by Phadnis, Urmila, Muni, Sukh Deo, and Bahadur, Kalim, 82–99. New Delhi: South Asian Publishers.Google Scholar
Das, Nirmala. 1974. The Dragon Country: The General History of Bhutan. Bombay: Orient Longman.Google Scholar
Das, Smriti. 2005. Assam-Bhutan Trade Relations 1865–1949: A Socio-Economic Study. Delhi: Anshah Publishing House.Google Scholar
Deb, Arabinda. 1973. “Cooch Behar and Bhutan in the Context of Tibetan Trade.” Kailash 1 (1): 79–88.Google Scholar
Deb, Arabinda. 1976. Bhutan and India: A Study in Frontier Political Relations (1772–1865). Calcutta: Firma KLM Private Limited.Google Scholar
Diskalkar, D. B. 1933. “Bogle's Embassy to Tibet.” Indian Historical Quarterly 9:420–38.Google Scholar
Eden, Ashley. (1865) 1972. Political Missions to Bootan/Comprising the Reports of Hon'ble Ashley Eden 1864; Capt. R.B. Pemberton, 1837, 1838, with Dr. W. Griffiths's Journal; and the Account of Baboo Kishen Kant Bose. New Delhi: Manjushri Publishing House.Google Scholar
Field, A. R. 1962. “A Note Concerning Early Anglo-Bhutanese Relations.” East and West 13:340–45.Google Scholar
Gandolfo, Romolo. 2004. “Bhutan and Tibet in European Cartography (1597–1800).” In The Spider and the Piglet: Proceedings of the First International Seminar on Bhutan Studies, edited by Ura, Karma and Kinga, Sonam, 90–136. Thimphu: Centre for Bhutan Studies.Google Scholar
Gier, Nicholas F. 2014. The Origins of Religious Violence: An Asian Perspective. London: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Gilbert, Arthur N. 1975. “Recruitment and Reform in the East India Company Army, 1760–1800.” Journal of British Studies 15 (1): 89–111.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gupta, Shantiswarup. 1974. British Relations with Bhutan. Jaipur: Panchsheel Prakashan.Google Scholar
Himalayan Collection Berkeley (HCB). 1860–69. NAI 18, “From the Secy. to Govt., Bengal” (“Minute by the Hon'ble Cecil Beadon, Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal,—Dated Darjeeling, the 22nd July 1864”), Foreign Department, Political A, July 1864, Nos. 41–42.Google Scholar
Himalayan Collection Berkeley (HCB). 1860–69. NAI 18, “From the Envoy of Bootan” (“From the Hon'ble Ashley Eden, Envoy to Bootan, to Colonel H. M. Durand, C. B., Secretary to the Government of India, Foreign Department,—Dated Darjeeling, the 20th July 1864”), Foreign Department, Political A, July 1864, Nos. 53.Google Scholar
Himalayan Collection Berkeley (HCB). 1911. NAI 38a, “Loan of the services of a Sikkim State Pioneer to the Bhutan Darbar to survey the alignment of a road from Sinchula to Paro. Decision that the expenditure on this account should be borne by the Bhutan Darbar,” Foreign Department, External B, July 1911, Nos. 227–28.Google Scholar
Himalayan Collection Berkeley (HCB). 1912. NAI 60, “Maharaja of Bhutan's Appeal to the Chinese Amban in Tibet for the restoration of certain lands belonging to the To-lung Tsur-po monastery, Chinese interference with Bhutan,” Foreign Department, Secret E, February 1912, Nos. 410–16.Google Scholar
Hutt, Michael. 2003. Unbecoming citizens: Culture, Nationhood, and the Flight of Refugees from Bhutan. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Inlow, E. Burke. 1978. “Report from Bhutan.” Asian Affairs 9 (3): 295–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaul, Nitasha. 2008. “Power to the People.” CSD Bulletin 15 (2): 1–2, 20.Google Scholar
Kharat, Rajesh. 1999. Bhutan in SAARC: Role of a Small State in a Regional Alliance. New Delhi: South Asian Publishers.Google Scholar
Kohli, Manorama. 1982. India and Bhutan: A Study in Interrelations, 1772–1910. New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal.Google Scholar
Lenman, Bruce. 1968. “The Weapons of War in 18th Century-India.” Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research 46 (185): 33–43.Google Scholar
Lewis, Martin W., and Wigen, Kären E.. 1997. The Myth of Continents: A Critique of Metageography. Berkeley: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mann, Michael. 2002. “From Ledger to Budget: British Fiscal Imperialism, 1750–1800.” Internationales Asienforum 33 (3/4): 247–70.Google Scholar
Markham, Clements R., ed. (1881) 2010. Narratives of the Mission of George Bogle to Tibet: And of the Journey of Thomas Manning to Lhasa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Mathou, Thierry. 2005. “Tibet and Its Neighbours: Moving toward a New Chinese Strategy in the Himalayan Region.” Asian Survey 45 (4): 503–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mazumdar, Arijit. 2005. “Bhutan's Military Action against Indian Insurgents.” Asian Survey 45 (4): 566–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Misra, Sanghamitra. 2005. “Changing Frontiers and Spaces: The Colonial State in Nineteenth-Century Goalpara.” Studies in History 21 (2): 215–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mosca, Matthew W. 2013. From Frontier Policy to Foreign Policy: The Question of India and the Transformation of Geopolitics in Qing China. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
NAI (National Archives of India). 1960. 18(14)EAD/60, “Supply of Dolomite by Bhutan—Concessions in Railway Freight.”Google Scholar
Pandit, Tooshar. 1964. “Behind Bhutan's Throne.” Eastern World 18 (November): 7–9.Google Scholar
Penjore, Dorji. 2004. “Security of Bhutan: Walking between the Giants.” Journal of Bhutan Studies 10:108–31.Google Scholar
Petech, Luciano. 1950. “The Missions of Bogle and Turner according to the Tibetan Texts.” T'oung Pao, 2s, 39:330–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phuntsho, Karma. 2013. The History of Bhutan. Noida: Random House India.Google Scholar
Rahul, Ram. 1997. Royal Bhutan: A Political History. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House.Google Scholar
Rattan, Kamaljeet. 1989. “Bhutan: Between Two Worlds.” India Today, September 15.Google Scholar
Rennell, Rodd. 1930. “Major James Rennell. Born 3 December 1742. Died 20 March 1830.” Geographical Journal 75 (4): 289–99.Google Scholar
Rennie, D. F. 1866. Bhotan and the Story of the Dooar War. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Saran, Hari. 1986. “Bhutan—Historical Survey.” In India's Northern Security, edited by Sharma, Gautam and Nagar, K. S., 201–11. New Delhi: Reliance Publishing House.Google Scholar
Sarkar, Susobhan Chandra. 1931. “Some Notes on the Intercourse of Bengal with the Northern Countries in the Second Half of the Eighteenth Century.” Bengal Past and Present: Journal of the Calcutta Historical Society 41:120–28.Google Scholar
Sinha, R. P., and Dandekar, Surya, eds. 1998. Asian Government and Politics: Studies in People, Power and Political Development. Vol. 2, South Asia: Political Resurgence and Identity. New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers.Google Scholar
Ura, Karma. 2002. “Perceptions of Security.” In South Asian Security: Futures, edited by Bannerjee, Dipankar, 59–79. Colombo: Regional Centre for Strategic Studies.Google Scholar
Vohra, Dewan C. 1980. India's Aid Diplomacy in the Third World. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House.Google Scholar
White, John Claude. (1909) 1996. Sikhim & Bhutan: Twenty-One Years on the North-East Frontier 1887–1908. London: Edward Arnold; repr., New Delhi: Asian Educational Services.Google Scholar
Younghusband, Francis. (1910) 2005. India and Tibet: A History of the Relations which have Subsisted between the two countries from the time of Warren Hastings to 1910; with a particular account of the mission to Lhasa of 1904. New Delhi: Asian Educational Services.Google Scholar
Luo, Zha and Jian, Ao. 2017. “Three Modes of Traditional Trade between China's Tibet and Bhutan.” China's Borderland History and Geography Studies 27 (4): 1–20.Google Scholar