Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T08:32:14.573Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Rule by Man” and “Rule by Law” in Early Republican China: Contributions to a Theoretical Debate

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 March 2010

Leigh K. Jenco
Get access

Abstract

“Rule by man” and “rule by law” are frequently invoked categories in Chinese political discourse past and present, but their theoretical scope and possible interpretation remain highly controversial. Seeking to gain analytical traction on these categories, the author revisits an early Republican debate over whether virtuous men or well-designed institutions were more essential to securing political stability and social transformation in the aftermath of China's 1911 Republican Revolution. Focusing on the work of Liang Qichao, Zhang Shizhao, and their interlocutors, the author shows how “man” and “law” not only play roles in legitimizing one or another form of rule, but also help formulate questions about the interaction between individual effort and institutional influence. Viewed from this theoretical rather than historical angle, the debates become important not only for understanding wider issues in early Republican political discourse, but also for critically interrogating their contemporary variants from Chinese—rather than Western liberal-democratic—perspectives.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of Asian Studies , Volume 69 , Issue 1 , February 2010 , pp. 181 - 203
Copyright
Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

List of References

Chow, Tse-tsung. 1967. The May Fourth Movement: Intellectual Revolution in Modern China. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Communist Party of China, Central Committee. 2006. Communique of the Sixth Plenum of the 16th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. Beijing: Communist Party of China.Google Scholar
Communist Party of China, International Department Central Committee. 2003. On the Three Represents. Beijing: Communist Party of China.Google Scholar
Yaquan, Du. 2003. “Geren zhi gaige” [Reforming the individual]. In Du Yaquan wencun [Collected works of Du Yaquan], ed. Xu, J. and Tian, J.. Shanghai: Shanghai jiaoyu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Like, Gao. 1998. Tiaoshi de zhihui: Du Yaquan sixiang yanjiu [The wisdom of accommodation: Research on Du Yaquan's thought]. Zhejiang: Zhejiang Renmin chuban she.Google Scholar
Hobhouse, Leonard T. 1911. Liberalism. New York: Henry Holt.Google Scholar
Shi, Hu. 1985. “Wushinian lai Zhongguo zhi wenxue” [Chinese literature of the past fifty years]. In Hu Shi wencun [Collected works of Hu Shi], vol. 3, 180–261. Luoyang: Luoyang tushu gongsi.Google Scholar
Zemin, Jiang. 2006. “Zai zhongyang sixiang zhengzhi gongzuo huiyi shang de jianghua” [Speech to the central ideological political work conference]. In Jiang Zemin wenxuan [Selected works of Jiang Zemin], 74–100. Beijing: Renmin chu ban she.Google Scholar
Keith, Ronald C. 1994. China's Struggle for the Rule of Law. New York: St. Martin's Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Changchun, Li. 2007. “Tuidong xuexi Jiang Zemin wenxuan he xuexi guanche ‘san ge daibiao’ zhongyao sixiang jixu xiang shendu he guangdu fazhan” [On promoting the study of The selected works of Jiang Zemin and the study of how a thoroughgoing “Three Represents” can continue to develop in both depth and breadth]. Qiu shi, March 16. http://mail.shaoshan.gov.cn/zxzxx/ShowArticle.asp?ArticleID=5784 [accessed October 9, 2009].Google Scholar
Dazhao, Li. 1959. “Minyi yu zhengzhi” [Popular custom and politics]. In Li Dazhao xuan ji [Selected works of Li Dazhao], 36–57. Beijing: Renmin shuju.Google Scholar
Qichao, Liang. 1915a. “Zhengzhi zhi jichu yu yanlunjia zhi zhizhen” [The foundations of government, with a directive for public opinion leaders]. In Da Zhonghua Zazhi [Great China magazine], ed. Qichao, Liang. Taipei: Wenhua chubanshe, 1978.Google Scholar
Qichao, Liang. ed. 1915b. Da Zhonghua zazhi [Great China magazine]. Vols. 541–55, Jindai Zhongguo shiliao congkan xubian. Taibei: Wenhua chubanshe, 1978.Google Scholar
Qichao, Liang. 1922. “Xian Qin zhengzhi sixiang shi” [The history of pre-Qin political thought]. In Liang Qichao Quanji [Collected works of Liang Qichao], vol. 6, 3603–3711. Beijing: Beijing chuban she.Google Scholar
Lin, Yusheng. 1979. The Crisis of Chinese Consciousness: Radical Antitraditionalism in the May Fourth Era. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Liu, Lydia H. 1995. Translingual Practice: Literature, National Culture, and Translated Modernity—China, 1900–1937. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luo, Guojie. 2001. “Rule by Law and Rule by Virtue Supplement Each Other.” Renmin ribao, February 22.Google Scholar
Mill, John Stuart. [1861] 1991. On Liberty and Other Essays. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Morley, John. 1886. On Compromise. 2nd ed.London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Ocko, Jonathan K., and Gilmartin, David. 2009. “State, Sovereignty, and the People: A Comparison of the ‘Rule of Law’ in China and India.” Journal of Asian Studies 68 (1): 55–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Peerenboom, Randall. 2002. China's Long March Toward Rule of Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shen, Yuanyuan. 2000. “Conceptions and Receptions of Legality: Understanding the Complexity of Law Reform in Modern China.” In The Limits of the Rule of Law in China, edited by Turner, Karen G., Feinerman, James V., and Kent Guy, R., 20–44. Seattle: University of Washington Press.Google Scholar
Shue, Vivienne. 2009. “Sovereignty, Rule of Law, and Ideologies of the Nation.” Journal of Asian Studies 68 (1): 101–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fansen, Wang. 2003. Zhongguo jindai sixiang yu xueshu de xipu [Modern Chinese thought and genealogies of scholarship]. Taipei: Lianjing chu ban she.Google Scholar
Jiafu, Wang, et al. 1996. “Lun yi fa zhi guo” [On the theory of “depending on law to govern the country”]. In Yi fa zhi guo jianshe shehuizhuyi fazhi guojia [Using the theory of “depending on law to govern the country” to build a socialist rule of law state], ed. Liu, H., Li, B., and Li, L.. Beijing: Zhongguo fazhi.Google Scholar
Weston, Timothy B. 1998. “The Formation and Positioning of the New Culture Community, 1913–1917.” Modern China 24 (3): 255–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. 1913a. “Shehui chongbai zhi renwu” [The renwu that society most admires]. Yongyan, August 16.Google Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. 1913b. “Shehui yu renwu” [Society and renwu]. Yongyan, February 1.Google Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. 1913c. “Yulun yu renwu” [Public opinion and renwu]. Yongyan, March 1.Google Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. 1913d. “Zhengzhi yu renwu” [Government and renwu]. Yongyan, May 16.Google Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. 1913e. “Zhengzhijia zhi pingge” [The moral character of politicians]. Yongyan, September 1.Google Scholar
Wu, Guanyin. n.d. “Zhengzhi yu daode.” Da Zhonghua Zazhi [The Great China Magazine].Google Scholar
Guanyin, Wu, and Liang, Qichao, eds. 1912–14. Yongyan [The Justice]. 30 vols. Tianjin: Yong yan bao guan.Google Scholar
Yong, Xia, et al. , eds. 1981. Fa zhi yu ren zhi wen ti tao lun ji. [Collected discussions on the questions of rule by law and rule by man]. Beijing: She hui ke xue wen xian chu ban she, 2003.Google Scholar
Gongquan, Xiao. 1977. Zhongguo zheng zhi si xiang shi [History of Chinese political thought]. 6th ed.Taibei: Hua gang.Google Scholar
Zongmian, Xu. 1984. “Shibaizhe de tansuo: 1913–1915 nian jian guanyu Zhongguo ruhe shixian minzhu zhengzhi de taolun” [The losers' exploration: Debates over how China might actualize democratic government, 1913–1915]. Lishi yanjiu 4:23–44.Google Scholar
Deshan, Yang. 2006. “Yi fa zhi guo,” “yi de zhi guo” [“Relying on law to govern the nation,” “using virtue to govern the nation”]. News of the Communist Party of China, June 25. http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/64171/4527669.html [accessed October 9, 2009].Google Scholar
Young, Ernest P. 1977. The Presidency of Yuan Shih-k'ai: Liberalism and Dictatorship in Early Republican China. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Shengyang, Yue. 1989. “Yizhi xifang minzhu zhengzhi de shibai yu qimeng sixiang de fusu” [The failure to transplant Western democratic government and the recovery of enlightenment thought.] In Shidai de cuowei yu lilun de xuanze: xifang jindai sichao yu zhongguo ‘wusi’ qimeng sixiang [An era's misplaced position and its theoretical choices: Modern Western thought and Chinese “May Fourth” enlightenment thought], ed. Liu, G., 99–138. Beijing: Qinghua University Press.Google Scholar
Dongsun, Zhang. 1914. “Zhengzhi geming yu shehui geming” [Political revolution and social revolution]. Zheng Yi 1 (4): 1–6.Google Scholar
Pufan, Zhang, and Zeng, Xianyi. 1981. “Renzhi yu fazhi de lishi pouxi” [Historical analysis of rule by man and rule by law]. In Fazhi yu renzhi wenti taolun ji, ed. Xia, Y., 205–22. Beijing: Shehui kexue wenxian chu ban she.Google Scholar
Shizhao, Zhang. 2000. Zhang Shizhao quan ji [Collected works of Zhang Shizhao]. 10 vols. Shanghai: Wen hui chu ban she.Google Scholar
Xiaozhan, Zou. 2001. Zhang Shizhao she hui zheng zhi si xiang yan jiu, 1903–1927 nian [Research on Zhang Shizhao's sociopolitical thought, 1903–1927]. Changsha: Hunan jiao yu chu ban she.Google Scholar