Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T18:23:35.228Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Liturgy and Liberty: The Controversy over the Book of Common Prayer, 1660–16631

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2012

Christopher Haigh
Christopher Haigh*
Affiliation:
[email protected]
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a formal liturgy as against extemporized worship? After the restoration of the English monarchy in 1660, it was clear that some form of national ‘Church of England’ would be reconstructed – but would it have a set liturgy, and if so what would it be like? This paper considers over a hundred books published in the following three years, debating whether the Book of Common Prayer should be imposed, reformed or abandoned, with arguments based on biblical precepts, the practice of the early Church and reformed Churches, the duties of ministers and the needs of congregations. The debate shows how the views of both conformists and nonconformists had developed in response to the religious free-for-all of the 1640s and 1650s, though it had little influence on political decisions.

Keywords

ceremoniesChurch of EnglandCommon PrayerliturgynonconformityRestorationworship
Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Anglican Studies , Volume 11 , Issue 1 , May 2013 , pp. 32 - 64
Copyright
Copyright © The Journal of Anglican Studies Trust 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

1.

This is a revised version of a paper read at the ‘British World’ conference at the University of Southern Queensland in July 2012. I am grateful to Marcus Harmes and the other convenors for the invitation, to the Harmes family for many kindnesses, and to Alison Wall for her comments.

2.

Christopher Haigh retired in 2009 as Student (i.e. Fellow) of Christ Church, Oxford and head of the History Faculty at the University of Oxford.

References

3. The controversies before 1660 are discussed in Christopher Durston, ‘By the Book or with the Spirit: The Debate over Liturgical Prayer in the English Revolution’, Historical Research, 79 (2006), pp. 50–73. [Joseph Hall], An humble remonstrance to the high court of Parliament by a dutifull sonne of the church. (London, 1640); [Joseph Hall], A defence of the humble remonstrance, against the frivolous and false exceptions of Smectymnuus wherein the right of leiturgie and episcopacie is clearly vindicated from the vaine cavils, and challenges of the answerers (London, 1641); [Joseph Hall], A short answer to the tedious Vindication of Smectymnuus (London, 1641); [Joseph Hall], A modest confutation of a slanderous and scurrilous libell (London, 1642); [Henry Hammond], A View of the New Directorie and a Vindication of the Ancient Liturgie of the Church of England (Oxford, 1645); [Jeremy Taylor], A Discourse concerning Prayer Ex Tempore or by Pretence of the Spirit. In Justification of Authorized and Set Formes of Liturgie (London 1646).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4. [Nye, Philip], Beames of former light (London, 1660), pp. 16–17, 198–99.Google Scholar

5. Prideaux, John, Euchologia or, the doctrine of practical praying. By the Right Reverend Father in God, John Prideaux, late Bishop of Worcester (London, 1660), pp. 211–212.Google Scholar

6. Calfine, Giles, The Book of Common Prayer Confirmed (London, 1660), pp. 1–2.Google Scholar

7. Pierce, Edmund, The English Episcopacy and Liturgy Asserted (London, 1660), p. 21.Google Scholar

8. A Modest Discourse concerning the ceremonies heretofore used in the Church of England (London, 1660), pp. 2, 22, 36.Google Scholar

9. [Burges, Cornelius], Reasons showing the Necessity of Reformation (London, 1660), pp. 22–24, 28, 30–31, 36, 39, 63; H[enry] S[avage], Reasons shewing that there is no need of such a Reformation (London, 1660), pp. 3, 16.Google Scholar

10. Clark, Robert, The Lying-Wonders, or rather the wonderful-lyes (London, 1660), Sig. A2.Google Scholar

11. An Anti-Brekekekex-Coax-Coax (London, 1660), p. 4 (vere p. 8).Google Scholar

12. The Common Prayer Book Unmasked (n.p., 1660), pp. 12, 30, 68.Google Scholar

13. Hicks, Thomas, A Sharp Rebuke, or a Rod for the Enemies of Common Prayer (London, 1660), p. 2.Google Scholar

14. Elis, Edmund, Admonition to Dr Burges (London, 1661), p. 6.Google Scholar

15. Penington, Isaac, The Consideration of a Position Concerning the Book of Common Prayer (London, 1660), p. 6.Google Scholar

16. Wotton, Samuel, A View of the Face Unmasked (London, 1661), pp. 11, 32, 36.Google Scholar

17. [Bagshaw, Edward], The Great Question concerning things indifferent in religious worship (London 1660), Sig. A2; [Edward Bagshaw], The Second Part of the Great Question (London, 1661), p. 8.Google Scholar

18. Smectymnuus Redivivus (London, 1660), pp. 9, 11.Google Scholar

19. Powell, Vavasor, Common Prayer Book No Divine Service (London, 1660), pp. 4, 8.Google Scholar

20. Gauden, John, Considerations Touching the Liturgy of the Church of England (London, 1660), pp. 6, 9–12.Google Scholar

21. Bolde, Thomas, Rhetorick Restrained (London, 1660), pp. 2, 6–7, 10–11, 14–15, 29.Google Scholar

22. G[iles] F[irmin], The Liturgical Considerator Considered (London, 1661), pp. 5–6.Google Scholar

23. H.D., A Sober and Temperate Discourse concerning the interest of words in prayer (London, 1661), pp. 28, 71–73, 87.Google Scholar

24. Freeman, Ireneus, Logike latreia: The Reasonablenesse of Divine Service (London, 1661), p. 31.Google Scholar

25. Henry, Hammond, A Vindication of the Ancient Liturgie (London, 1660), pp. 12–20; Henry Jeanes, Uniformity in humane doctrinall ceremonies ungrounded on 1.Cor.14.40 (Oxford, 1660), pp. 5–6, 85.Google Scholar

26. Bernard, Nicholas, Clavi Trabales, or Nailes Fastened by some Great Masters of Assemblies (London, 1661), Sig. I2.Google Scholar

27. [Fox, George], Something in answer to the old Common-Prayer-Book (London, 1660), p. 30.Google Scholar

28. W[illiam] T[omlinson], A Word of information to them that need it (London, 1660), p. 35.Google Scholar

29. A Winding Sheet for the Anabaptists and Quakers (London, ?1660), p. 2.Google Scholar

30. Bogan, Zachary, A Help to Prayer, both extempore and by a set forme (Oxford, 1660), Sigg. B-B2, B4-5, C2.Google Scholar

31. Duncon, Eleazar, Of worshiping God towards the altar (London, 1661), pp. 12–13), 29, 37.Google Scholar

32. Crofton, Z., Altar-Worship or Bowing to the Communion Table considered (London, 1661), pp. 6–7.Google Scholar

33. Cawdrey, D, Bowing towards the Altar upon religious reasons (London, 1661), p. 14.Google Scholar

34. Baxter, Richard, Reliquiae Baxterianae (London, 1696), p. 379.Google Scholar

35. L'Estrange, Roger, The relaps'd apostate (London, 1661), Sig. A2.Google Scholar

36. [J.C.], A Short Treatise of the epidemical diseases of these times (London, ?1662), pp. 9–10.Google Scholar

37. L'Estrange, Roger, State-Divinity (London, 1661), p. 55.Google Scholar

38. Semper eadem, or a reference of the debate at the Savoy 1661 to the conference at Hampton Court 1603/4 (London, 1662), Sig. A2, p. 24.Google Scholar

39. [Womock, Laurence], Pulpit-Conceptions, Popular-Deceptions (London, 1662], Sig. B.Google Scholar

40. [Morley, George], The Bishop of Worcester's Letter to a Friend (London, 1662), pp. 4–5.Google Scholar

41. Baxter, Reliquiae Baxterianae, p. 378.Google Scholar

42. [John Owen], A Discourse concerning Liturgies and their imposition (n.p., 1662), pp. 5, 16, 66.Google Scholar

43. G[iles] F[irmin], Presbyterial Ordination Vindicated (London, 1660), p. 35.Google Scholar

44. [Crofton, Zachary], ‘A position disputing the lawfulness of ministers receiving an imposed liturgy’, in R.S., Jerubbaal Justified (London, 1663), pp. 4–5.Google Scholar

45. Zach. Crofton, ‘An epistle to the reader by way of apology for ministers not receiving the Common Prayer Book’, in F[irmin], Liturgical Considerator Considered, Sig. b2.Google Scholar

46. Prynne, William, A Short, Sober, Pacific Examination of some Exuberances and Ceremonial Appurtenances to the Common Prayer (London, 1661), p. 7.Google Scholar

47. F[irmin], Liturgical Considerator Considered, p. 22.Google Scholar

48. E.M., The Covenant Acknowledged by an English Covenanter (London, 1660), pp. 9, 14.Google Scholar

49. Leslie, Henry, A Discourse of Praying with the Spirit and with the Understanding (London, 1660), p. 34.Google Scholar

50. Barbon, John, Leitourgia theiotera ergia, or, Liturgie a most divine service (London, 1663), p. 82.Google Scholar

51. Masterson, George, The Spiritual House, in its Foundation, Materials, Officers and Discipline Described (London, 1661), p. 151.Google Scholar

52. Sparrow, Anthony, A Rationale upon the Book of Common Prayer of the Church of England (London, 1661), pp. 64, 75.Google Scholar

53. Cade, Anthony, Conscience, its nature and corruption (London, 1661).Google Scholar

54. Gunton, Simon, A Brief Discourse concerning bodily worship, proving it to be God's due (London, 1661).Google Scholar

55. Green, Ian, Print and Protestantism in Early Modern England (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), pp. 351, 353, 594.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

56. For contrasting views of the ecclesiastical politics of 1660–63, see R.S. Bosher, The Making of the Restoration Settlement: The Influence of the Laudians, 1649–1662 (London: Dacre Press, 1951) and Green, Ian, The Re-establishment of the Church of England, 1660–1663 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978). For a broader context, see John Spurr, The Restoration Church of England, 1646–1689 (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1991).Google Scholar