Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-j824f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-03T02:42:20.277Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Odyssey of Ebenezer Smith Platt

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 January 2009

Sheldon S. Cohen
Sheldon S. Cohen
Affiliation:
Sheldon S. Cohen is Professor of History at Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60626. He would like to thank the American Philosophical Society, the Georgia Historical Society, and the keepers of John Adams Papers at theMassachusetts Historical Society for their permission to quote from manuscript papers relating to Ebenezer Smith Platt.He would also like to thank Dr. Adele Hast for her research on his behalf in England and the staff of the Benjamin Franklin Papers at Yale University for allowing him to examine their holdings. Finally, he wishes to express his grateful appreciation to Mr. Daniel Keefe, his energetic research assistant, for his invaluable efforts in aiding the completion of this project.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On 17 February 1777 John Wilkes, the controversial politician, pamphleteer, and propagandist, rose to address the House of Commons. Wilkes, renowned for his opposition to King George III and his followers, was equally regarded by Americans as a long-standing champion of their colonial rights. And it was in both of these contexts that he marshaled his oratorical skills on this occasion. The specific target of his speech was the third reading of a bill, proposed by Lord North's government, which would suspend the habeas corpus act through the remainder of the year for persons accused of high treason for actions within the American colonies, or on the high seas, or for alleged acts of piracy. Wilkes began by declaring emphatically: “I cannot continue silent while so important a Bill is pending before this house.” He then attacked the proposed act as “tyrannical, arbitrary, ambiguous, unconstitutional,” and forecast that it would lead to expansion of the American war that had been raging for almost two years. Wilkes illustrated the oppressive, unwarrantable and alienating effects of the proposed act on Americans by citing the case of a young colonial named Ebenezer Smith Platt, then confined in London's infamous Newgate prison.

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of American Studies , Volume 18 , Issue 2 , August 1984 , pp. 255 - 274
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1984

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Parliamentary Register; or History of the Proceedings and Debates of the House of Commons During the Third Session of the Fourteenth Parliament of Great Britain (London, 1777), 239Google Scholar, Hansard, T. C., Ed., The Parliamentary History of England from the Earliest Period to the Year 1803 (London, 1814), xxix, 27–28Google Scholar; Anderson, Olive, “The Treatment of Prisoners of War in Britain during the American War of Independence,” Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research, xxviii (1955), 63–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sherrard, Owen, A Life of John Wilkes (New York, 1930), 260–77Google Scholar. (The bill itself had first been presented by Lord North on February 7, 1777. See The Annual Register…for the Year 1777 [London, 1778], xx, 231Google Scholar.)

2 Hansard, , ed., Parliamentary History, xxix, 29–33Google Scholar; The Parliamentary Register, 244–45.

3 Platt, George L., The Platt Lineage; A Genealogical Research and Record (New York, 1891), 13–16, 27, 43–45Google Scholar; Platt, Charles Jr, Platt Genealogy in America; From the Arrival of Richard Platt in New Haven, Connecticut, in 1638 (New Hope, Pa., 1963), 30–32, 73–75Google Scholar; Thompson, Benjamin F., History of Long Island From Its Discovery and Settlement to the Present Time, 3rd ed. (Port Washington, N.Y., 1962), iii, 567–568Google Scholar. (The Platt estate remained in family hands until 1903.)

4 Smith, Frederick K., The Family of Richard Smith of Smithtown, Long Island; Ten Generations (Smithtown, N.Y., 1967), 131–32Google Scholar; Records of the Town of Smithtown Long Island, New York with Other Ancient Documents of Historic Value (Huntington, N.Y., 1898), 473–78Google Scholar; Platt, G., Platt Lineage, 47–48Google Scholar; Platt, C., Platt Genealogy, 75–78, 93Google Scholar; Thompson, , History of Long Island, iii, 375–76, 568–69Google Scholar. (Ebenezer Smith Platt has sometimes been confused with cousin, Judge Ebenezer Platt [1754–1839], who was born in Huntington, Long Island; see Mather, Frederic G., The Refugess of 1776 from Long Island to Connecticut [Albany, N.Y., 1913], 510–11Google Scholar; Records of the First Church in Huntington Long Island, 1723–1789 [Huntington, N.Y., 1899], 45Google Scholar; Platt, C., Platt Genealogy, 82Google Scholar.)

5 Harrison, Richard A., Princetonians, 1769–1775 (Princeton, 1980), 334–35Google Scholar; Gottesman, Rita S., “The Arts and Crafts in New York,” New-York Historical Society, Collections, lxix (1938), 159Google Scholar; Rivington's New-York Gazeteer, Feb. 24, 1774; Elizabeth Wright to Benjamin Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers, American Philosophical Society (APS), Philadelphia (hereafter referred to as Franklin Papers); Platt, G., Platt Lineage, 48Google Scholar.

6 The Case of Mr. Ebenezer Smith Platt, Merchant of Georgia; Now confined in Irons in Newgate on a Charge of High Treason (London, 1777), 1Google Scholar; New York Gazette & Weekly Mercury, Jan. 22, 1776; Jensen, Merrill, The Founding of a Nation; A History of the American Revolution, 1763–1776 (New York, 1968), 530–31Google Scholar; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers.

7 Coleman, Kenneth, Colonial Georgia; A History (New York, 1976), 266–68Google Scholar; Jones, Charles C. Jr, History of Savannah Georgia from its Settlement to the Close of the Eighteenth Century (Syracuse, N.Y., 1890), 210–12Google Scholar; Harden, William, A History of Savannah and South Georgia (Chicago, 1913), i, 167–78Google Scholar; Jones, Charles C. Jr, The History of Georgia (Boston, 1883), ii, 160–76Google Scholar; Georgia Gazette (Savannah), June 7, 1775.

8 Ebenezer S. Platt to the Commissioners of the United States at Paris, 21 Apr. 1778, John Adams, Correspondence reel 349, Massachusetts Historical Society, Boston; Marcus, Jacob R., ed., America Jewry: Documents, Eighteenth Century (Cincinnatti, 1958), 232–33Google Scholar; Jones, , History of Georgia, ii, 177–78Google Scholar; Jones, , History of Savannah, 212Google Scholar; Harden, , History of Savannah, i, 178–79Google Scholar.

9 “Information of Richard Maitland and Others, 21 Sept. 1775,” Davies, K. G., Documents of the American Revolution 1770–1783 (Colonial Office Series, Transcripts, 1775, 07–12 [Dublin, 1976]), xi, 125Google Scholar, hereafter cited as Docs. of the Amer. Rev.; Stevens, William B., History of Georgia (Philadelphia, 1859), ii, 103–05Google Scholar; Jones, , History of Savannaha, 213–15Google Scholar; Harden, , History of Savannah, 180–83Google Scholar.

10 Moultrie, William, Memoirs of the American Revolution (New York, 1802), i, 81–82Google Scholar; Governor Sir James Wright to Lord Dartmouth, 20 June, 8 July, 1775 in “Letters from Sir James Wright,” Georgia Historical Society, Collections, iii (Savannah, 1873), 189–92Google Scholar; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; Jones, , History of Georgia, ii, 180–81Google Scholar; Stevens, , History of Georgia, ii, 102–03Google Scholar; Docs. of the Amer. Rev., xi, 128.

11 Depositions of Richard Scriven and Samuel Burnett, 10 Jan. 1777, Old Bailey S.P./1777/4a, 4b, Sessions Papers of the Sessions Gaol of Delivery at Newgate (Middlesex Prisoners) Held at the Old Bailey, 1755–1796, Greater London Record Office; Docs. of the Amer. Rev., vii, 145; viii, 154; xi, 125–26; Jones, , History of Georgia, ii, 181Google Scholar. (In addition to citing its tonnage and place of construction, Lloyd's Register of Shipping, 1776, notes that Philippa was owned by Boudrieu & Co., a London firm.)

12 Sir James Wright to Lord Dartmouth, 8 July 1775, Georgia Hist. Soc. Colls, iii, 194; Depositions of Richard Scriben and Samuel Burnett; Docs. of the Amer. Rev., xi, 44, 126–27. (One early Georgia historian cites the total amount of gunpowder removed at 13,000 pounds. See McCall, Hugh, The History of Georgia Containing Brief Sketches of the Most Remarkable Events up to the Present Day [Savannah, 1816], i, 49Google Scholar.)

13 Copy of Letter of William Chamberlayne, 18 Dec. 1776, M. H. and D. B. Floyd Papers, Coll. 1308, nos. 7–12, Georgia Hist. Soc. (Savannah), hereafter cited as Floyd Papers; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 12 Apr. 1778; Depositions of Richard Scriven and Samuel Burnett; Docs. of the Amer. Rev., xi, 127.

14 Docs. of the Amer. Rev., x, 88, 91; xi, 127–28, 131; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb 13, 1777; Depositions of Richard Scriven and Samuel Burnett; Jones, , History of Savannah, 215–17Google Scholar; Coleman, , Colonial Georgia, 275–76Google Scholar; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 2.

15 Clark, William B., ed., Naval Documents of the American Revolution (Washington, D.C., 1964), i 920–21; 931–32Google Scholar; Force, Peter, American Archives, 4th serv., iii (Washington, D.C., 1840), 28, 36, 219, 683Google Scholar; Fitzpatrick, John C., ed., The Writings of George Washington from the Original Manuscript Sources, 1745–1799 (Washington, D.C., 1931), iii, 394–95, 401Google Scholar; Davis, Burke, George Washington and the American Revolution (New York, 1975), 46–47Google Scholar; Moultrie, , Memoirs of the American Rev., i, 81–82Google Scholar; Stevens, , History of Georgia, ii, 104Google Scholar; Jones, , History of Georgia, ii, 181Google Scholar.

16 Coulter, E. Merton, Georgia, A Short History, 3rd ed. (Chapel Hill, N.C., 1960), 128Google Scholar; Marcus, , American Jewry, ii, 232–35Google Scholar; Georgia Gazette (Savannah), Nov. 15, 1775; “Letters of Sir James Wright,” Georgia Hist. Soc. Colls, iii, 206–29.

17 “Journal of the Council of Safety for the Province of South Carolina,” South Carolina Historical Society, Collections, iii (Charleston, 1859), 111–13Google Scholar; “Papers of the Second Council of Safety of the Revolutionary Party in South Carolina, November 1775–March 1776,” The South Carolina Historical and Genealogical Magazine, iv (1903), 3–4Google Scholar; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 2.

18 Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 2–3.

19 Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 2.

20 Letter of Richard Maitland, Jan. 7, 1777, Admiral Clark Gayton to the Admiralty, 30 Mar. 1776, Floyd Papers, 1308, nos. 48, 55; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 3.

21 Basil Keith to Clark Gayton, 10 Apr. 1776, Thomas Harrison to Basil Keith, 10 Apr. 1776, Clark Gayton to the Admiralty, 30 Mar. 1776 (Floyd Papers, 1308, nos. 52–55); E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 3; Platt to U.S. Commissioners 21 April. 1778.

22 Thomas Harrison to Basil Keith, 10 Apr. 1776; Floyd Papers, 1308, nos. 53–54; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 3; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778.

23 Calendar of Historical Manuscripts Relating to the Revolution in the Office of the Secretary of State of New York (Albany, N.Y., 1868), i, Pt. i, 286Google Scholar; Clark Gayton to Philip Stephens, Admiralty Office, 28 July 1776; Edward Thurlow to the Earl of Suffolk, 10 Dec. 1776, Floyd Papers, 51, 56; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 3.

24 Unsigned, St. James's Palace to Mr. Attorney and Mr. Solicitor General, Dec. 10, 1776, SP 37 (State Papers Dom. Geo. iii), ii, 298; Mr. [Anthony] Chamier to William Chamberlayne, 13 Dec. 1776; Edward Thurlow to Earl of Suffolk, 10 Dec. 1776; Thomas Binsteed Letter, 19 Dec. 1776, Ebenezer Platt Case n.d., nos. 34, 45, 56, 58, Floyd Papers; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 3–4.

25 William Chamberlayne to Thomas Binsteed, 18 Dec. 1776, Philip Stephens to Sir. H. Porten, 26 Dec. 1776, William Cornwallis to Philip Stephens, 25 Dec. 1776, Thomas Binsteed note 19 Dec., 1776, Ebenezer Platt's Case n.d. (nos. 7–16, 24, 25, 31, 34 Floyd Papers); The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 4.

26 Statement of Richard Maitland, Jan. 5, 1777; William Cornwallis to Philip Stephens, Dec. 25, 1776, Thomas Binsteed letter, Jan. 13, 1777, Stanier Porten to William Chamberlayne, Dec. 29, 1776, Richard Maitland letter, Jan. 6, 1777, Thomas Binsteed note, Jan. 7, 1777 (Floyd Papers, nos. 20, 25, 37, 42, 48–50, 56); The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 4.

27 Depositions of Samuel Burnett and Richard Scriven. (Copies of these depositions are also included with the Floyd Papers, nos. 29–30 and 59–60.) Warrants of William Addington, Jan. 23, 1777, Letter of William Chamberlayne, n.d. “Ebenezer Platt Case” n.d. (Floyd Papers, nos. 1, 18, 32–34, 47); The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 4. E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers; (Sir John Fielding, 1721–1780, was the half brother of Henry Fielding. Dictionary of National Biography, s.v. “Fielding, John.”)

28 The Universal Magazine of Knowledge and Pleasure…, 02 1777 [London] lx, 106Google Scholar; The Scots Magazine, 05–08 1777 [Edinburgh], xxxix, 268–69, 435Google Scholar; The Gentleman's Magazine, 02, 03, 1777 [London], xlvii, 93, 147, 193Google Scholar; The London Chronicle, May 10–13, 1777; The Public Advertiser [London], 02 22, 27, 1777Google Scholar.

29 Edward Bancroft to Silas Deane, Feb. 7, 1777, The Deane Papers (New York Historical Society, Collections, xix–xxiii [New York, 1887–1891]); i, 486Google Scholar; Letter J. [John] Colton, Jan. 25, 1777, Floyd Papers, no. 23.

30 Sainsbury, John, “The Pro-Americans of London, 1769 to 1782,” William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd Ser., xxxv (1978), 423–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar; The Case of Ebenezer Smith Platt, 1–4.

31 Sellers, Charles C., Patience Wright; American Artist and Spy in George III's London (Middletown, Conn., 1976), 1–105Google Scholar; Perrine, Howard D., The Wright Family of Oyster Bay Long Island… (New York, 1923), 89–92Google Scholar; Dictionary of American Biography, s.v. “Wright, Patience.”

32 Sellers, , Patience Wright, 105–06Google Scholar; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers.

33 Patience Wright to Benjamin Franklin, Mar. 7, and after March 7, 1777, Franklin Papers.

34 Ebenezer Platt to Patience Wright, Mar. 5, 1777; E. Wright to Benjamin Franklin, Mar. 10, 1777, Franklin Papers.

35 Clark, William B., “John the Painter,” The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, lxiii (1939), 1–23Google Scholar; Ebenezer Platt to Benjamin Franklin, May 6, Patience Wright to Benjamin Franklin, May 7, 1777, Franklin Papers; Brief, “The King Against Platt,” Ebenezer Smith Platt Case, 1777, nos. 2–3, 5–6, 33 Floyd Papers.

36 Ford, Worthington C., Ed., Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789, viii (Washington, 1907), 676Google Scholar; Prelinger, Catherine M., “Benjamin Franklin and the American Prisoners of War in England during the American Revolution,” William and Mary Quarterly, 3rd Ser. xxxii (1975), 262–71Google Scholar; Ebenezer S. Platt to John Wilkes, 23 July 1777, John Wilkes Correspondence, vi, 1776–1785, British Library, London, Add. MS. 30,872, folio 84; John Wilkes to Mary Wilkes, Jan. 3, 1778, Add. MS. 30,879, folio 245.

37 Patience Wright to Franklin, Nov. 10, 1777, E. Wright to Franklin, Dec. 17, 1777, Platt to Franklin, Dec. 27, Franklin Papers.

38 Mackesy, Piers, The War for America, 1775–1783 (Cambridge, 1965), 147–59Google Scholar; Lucas, Reginald, Lord North… 1732–1792 (London, 1913), ii, 55–63Google Scholar; Prelinger, “Franklin and the American Prisoners,” 264.

39 Mackesy, 159–61; Prelinger, 271–72.

40 Ebenezer Platt to the Earl of Suffolk, Jan. 8, 1778, Letter to William Chamberlayne, Jan. 17 [1778], nos. 39–41, Floyd Papers; Public Advertiser, Mar. 16, 1778; Patience Wright to Franklin, Mar. 29, 1778, Franklin Papers; London Chronicle, Mar. 14–17, 1778. (The Earl of Suffolk had been a prime force behind Platt's internment the previous year.)

41 Butterfield, Lyman H. et al. , eds., Diary and Autobiography of John Adams (Cambridge, Mass., 1961), ii, 302, iv, 62Google Scholar; Ebenezer S. Platt to Congress, Memorials Addressed to Congress, Mar. 6, 1780 (M 247), r 51, i 41, v 8, p. 100. Papers of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789, National Archives; Platt to U.S. Commissioners, 21 Apr. 1778; Matthew Ridley to Franklin, Apr. 3, 1778, F. Bayard to Franklin, May 2, 1778, Franklin Papers.

42 Cutter, William R., ed., “A Yankee Privateersman in Prison in England, 1777–1779,” New England Historical and Genealogical Register, xxxi (1877), 285Google Scholar; Docs. of the Amer. Rev., xiii, 321; Jnls. Cont. Cong., xii, 1214.

43 Fernow, Berthold, ed., New York State Archives; New York in the Revolution (Albany, 1887), i, 256Google Scholar; Public Papers of George Clinton… Military (New York, 1899), 1, 568Google Scholar; “Minutes of the Council of Appointment of the State of New York, 1778–1779,” New York Historical Society, Collections, lviii (New York, 1925), 70Google Scholar; Memorial of Platt to Congress, Mar. 6, 1780.

44 “Supply and City Tax Lists of the City and County of Philadelphia, 1781–1783,” Pennsylvania Archives, Ser. 3 (1898), xvi, 775Google Scholar; Sellers, , Patience Wright, 118Google Scholar; E. Wright to Franklin, Feb. 13, 1777, Franklin Papers. (The British occupation of Savannah until July 1782, and the inclusion of Platt in the Disqualifying Act passed by Georgia's loyalist legislature, precluded his return to the community during most of this period. See Candler, Allen D., The Revolutionary Records of the State of Georgia [Atlanta, 1898], i, 353Google Scholar.)

45 Jillson, Willard R., Old Kentucky Entries and Deeds, Filson Club Publications, no. 34 (Louisville, Ky., 1926), 140Google Scholar; Filson Club Publications, no. 27 (Louisville Ky., 1914), 89–90; Stone, Richard G., A Brittle Sword; The Kentucky Militia, 1776–1912 (Lexington, Ky., 1977), 12Google Scholar; Lyman C. Draper Manuscript Collection, Microfilm 309, Ser. C, xxvi, 174; Brookes-Smith, Joan E., comp., Master Index; Virginia Surveys and Grants, 1774–1791 (Frankfort, Ky., 1976), 175Google Scholar.

46 Cannon, Jouett T., “Index to Military Certificates, 1787, etc.,” Register of the Kentucky State Historical Society, no. 64, xxii (1924), 16Google Scholar; MS. Military Certificates No. 1, Kentucky State Hist. Soc. (Frankfort), 13; Virginia Calender State Papers (Richmond, Va., 1875–1884), iv, 202Google Scholar; Bodley, Temple, George Rogers Clark; His Life and Public Services (Boston, 1926), 379–404Google Scholar; Coleman, Kenneth, The American Revolution in Georgia (Athens, Ga., 1958), 261–63Google Scholar; Jnls. of the Cont. Congress, xxxii, 194–97.

47 Heineman, Charles B., First Census of Kentucky, 1790 (Washington, 1940), 76Google Scholar; The Kentucky Gazette (Lexington), 08 4, 1792Google Scholar; Minutes of the City Council of Savannah, June 21, 1791, Floyd Papers; Draper MSS, 309, Ser. C, xxxi, 129, 174.

48 Kelley, William, “Notes on American Artists,” New York Historical Society, Collections, lv (1922)Google Scholar; Gottesman, Rita S., “The Arts and Crafts in New York, 1777–1799; Advertisements and News Items from New York City Newspapers”, New York Historical Society, Collections, lxxxi (1954), 388–89Google Scholar; Sellers, 119–20, 225–26, 232–33. (During the American Revolution, Bowen had been interned in one of England's naval prisons: Sellers, 226.)

49 Documents Relating to the Colonial, Revolutionary, and Post-Revolutionary History of the State of New Jersey, 1st ser. xxxvii, “Calendar of Wills, Administrations, etc., 1791–1795” (1942), viii, 286Google Scholar; New York City Directories, N.Y. Hist. Soc. 1786–89; Shackelford, W. Rhodes, “Early Marriage Records of Madison County,” Register of the Kentucky State Historical Society, no. 123, xxxviii (1940), 151Google Scholar; Dictionary of American Biography, S. V. “Wright, Joseph”; Sellers, 129, 232.

50 Dorris, J. T., “A 1792 Offer for the Location of the Capital of Kentucky at Boonesboro,” Register of the Kentucky State Historical Society, no. 95, xxxi (1933), 175Google Scholar; Bakeless, John, Daniel Boone, Master of the Wilderness (New York, 1939), 342–43Google Scholar; Draper MSS, 309, Ser. S, vi, 216–17.

51 Biographical Dictionary of the American Congress, 1774–1971 (Washington, 1971), 1550Google Scholar; Dictionary of American Biography, s.v. “Platt, Charles A.” and “Platt, Thomas C.”

52 Bemis, Samuel F., The Diplomacy of the American Revolution (Washington, 1935)Google Scholar; Kaplan, Lawrence S., Colonies into Nation: American Diplomacy 1763–1801 (New York, 1972)Google Scholar. See also Griffiths, Arthur G. F., The Chronicles of Newgate (London, 1884), 2 volsGoogle Scholar.