Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-t8hqh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T19:44:20.612Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Wealth in People as Wealth in Knowledge: Accumulation and Composition in Equatorial Africa*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Jane I. Guyer  and
Samuel M. Eno Belinga
Jane I. Guyer
Affiliation:
Northwestern University
Samuel M. Eno Belinga
Affiliation:
Université de Yaoundé
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The paper re-examines principles of social organization in pre-colonial Equatorial Africa, suggesting that the imagery of ‘accumulation’ of ‘wealth in people’ is not wrong, but not flexible enough to encompass the centrality of knowledge in these societies. People were singularized repositories of a differentiated and expanding repertoire of knowledge, as well as being structured kin (as in the kinship model) and generic dependents and followers (as in the wealth-in-people model). We argue that social mobilization was in part based on the mobilization of different bodies of knowledge, and leadership was the capacity to bring them together effectively, even if for a short time and specific purpose. We refer to this process as composition and distinguish it from accumulation.

The paper has three parts. The first substitutes an oral epic from southern Cameroon for an ethnography of the principles by which people pursued agendas and mobilized followings in their own political worlds. Colonial rule may have institutionalized pre-colonial political hierarchies, but it completely altered the terms for political mobilization. Hence the historical record is very limited for making inferences about how ‘wealth-in-people’ operated in action, under pre-colonial conditions. The second critiques the evolutionary assumptions about simple societies that still color the models of Equatorial societies. The third revisits the ethnography to illuminate the principles of composition. The conclusion makes inferences and suggestions with respect to aspects of pre-colonial social history.

Type
Wealth in People, Wealth in Things
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 36 , Issue 1 , March 1995 , pp. 91 - 120
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The lineage mode of production was proposed by Rey, P-P., Colonialisme, néocolonialisme et transition au capitalisme: exemple de la Comilog au Congo Brazzaville (Paris, 1971)Google Scholar, on the basis of Congo ethnography. By the late 1970s it was being used to analyze groups as different from the Punu as Southern African pastoralists, e.g. Guy, Jeff, ‘Ecological factors in the rise of Shaka and the Zulu kingdom’, in Marks, S. and Atmore, A. (eds.), Economy and Society in Pre-Industrial South Africa (London, 1980), 102–19Google Scholar. The concept of wealth-in-people (with or without hyphens) seems to have been first used by Miers, S. and Kopytoff, I. (eds.), Slavery in Africa: Historical and Anthropological Perspectives (Madison, 1977)Google Scholar. It was applied to the Kpelle by Bledsoe, C., Women and Marriage in Kpelle Society (Stanford, 1980)Google Scholar, and brought back again to Equatorial Africa in the works of Miller, J., Way of Death: Merchant Capitalism and the Angolan Slave Trade, 1730–1830 (Madison, 1988)Google Scholar, and Vansina, J., Paths in the Rainforests: Toward a History of Political Tradition in Equatorial Africa (Madison, 1990)Google Scholar. It has recently been used by Vaughan, M. and Moore, H., Cutting Down Trees: Gender, Nutrition, and Agricultural Change in the Northern Province of Zambia, 1890–1990 (Portsmouth NH, 1994), with respect to the Bemba.Google Scholar

2 Bohannan's, P. seminal article on spheres of exchange among the Tiv, ‘Some principles of exchange and investment among the Tiv’, American Anthropologist, LVII (1955) 60–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar, places women at the top of the hierarchy of value. In his definitive work on the Bene of Southern Cameroon, Laburthe-Tolra begins his chapter on the economy with an indigenous proverb: ‘If you hear wealth it means people’; Laburthe-Tolra, P., Minlaaba (Paris, 1977), 495.Google Scholar

3 Vansina, , Paths.Google Scholar

4 These thoughts are largely stimulated by Vansina's synthesis of the Equatorial history and ethnography, which both highlights the issues and also provides us – in his unification of the entire area as a single ‘tradition’ – with a rationale and excuse for using varied cases for inspiration without immediately falling into an inextricable tangle of ethnographic and historical localism. His own boldness in suggesting that there are common themes amongst the variations and innovations of Equatorial social history, of which wealth-in-people is one, gives the rest of us a window of opportunity for the kinds of speculation we pursue here.

5 Ibid. 251.

6 Ibid. 263.

7 Ibid. 257.

8 Ibid. 89, 255, emphasis added.

9 Evans-Pritchard, for example, never saw a leopard-skin chief mediation, nor major warfare, although both of these figure centrally in his path-breaking study of the Nuer political system. Of the leopard-skin chief he emphasised, ‘I repeat that I have not seen this method employed…’; Evans-Pritchard, E. E., The Nuer: A Description of the Modes of Livelihood and Political Institutions of a Nilotic People (Oxford, 1940), 164Google Scholar. His detailed descriptions of groups mobilized for warfare and feuding come entirely from oral history and not from ethnography.

10 There is always a problem in designating the ‘ethnicity’ of the groups that constitute a contiguous cluster in Southern Cameroon, Gabon and Equatorial Guinea and that speak mutually intelligible dialects of the same language. Each sub-group in a ramifying segmentation has its own marked characteristics. The famous Fang reliquaries, for example, were not made outside a particular region, and styles of performance were said to have specific origins. So, for accuracy's sake, references to groups from here onwards will refer to the relevant sub-groups. The entire cluster is part of the ‘Equatorial Tradition’ as defined by Vansina, , Paths.Google Scholar

11 See Guyer, J. I., ‘Wealth in people and self-realization in Equatorial Africa’, Man, (n.s.) XXVIII (1993), 243–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Kopytoff's, I. model of the ‘African frontier’, in Kopytoff, (ed.), The African Frontier: The Reproduction of Traditional African Societies (Bloomington, 1987)Google Scholar, is influential here but overstates the conservatism of new community formation to a fairly extreme degree. Not only do some of the papers in the collection suggest social innovation, but by holding the history of material life constant he fails to incorporate the extremely rapid growth in knowledge, of cultigens and monies in particular.

12 Fernandez, J. W., Bwiti: An Ethnography of the Religious Imagination in Africa (Princeton, 1982), 68.Google Scholar

13 Belinga, S. M. Eno, L'épopée camerounaise: mvet. Moneblum ou l'homme bleu (Yaoundé, 1978).Google Scholar

14 An accessible source on mvet oral poetics is , G. and Atangana, F. Towo, ‘Nden-Bobo, I'araignée-toilière: conte beti, en dialecte eton du Sud Cameroun’, Africa, XXXVI (1966), 37–61.Google Scholar

15 His name may also relate to the word akom, meaning the essence, the nature of something; Tsala, T., Dictionnaire Ewondo-Français (Lyon, 1956), 41.Google Scholar

16 Variations in African epic style in modern works are illustrated by Okpweho, I., The Epic in Africa: Towards a Poetics of the Oral Performance (New York, 1979)Google Scholar, and Julien, E., African Novels and the Question of Orality (Bloomington, 1992).Google Scholar

17 Bilaba is described in Laburthe-Tolra, P., Les seigneurs de la forêt (Paris, 1981), 360–1.Google Scholar

18 We have to remain aware that this is a single performance and not a total repertoire; in the larger repertoire of mvet narratives there are stories in which women play a much larger role.

19 These names refer to an abbreviated genealogy of about thirty generations. Ekan is the closest ancestor to the present population, Nna is the ancestor of the Ekan, and Mebe'e is the divinity.

20 Radcliffe-Brown, A. R. and Forde, D., African Systems of Kinship and Marriage (London, 1950).Google Scholar

21 Koch, H., Magie et chasse dans la forêt camerounaise (Paris, 1968), 17.Google Scholar

22 Definitions in Tsala, , Dictionnaire, 92Google Scholar. Eno-Belinga suggests the following as glosses of this semantic element, that has very wide meanings: to be close to, ‘we’ (the first person plural), to have, possess, break, rupture, move house, receive, put and open very wide.

23 Guyer, , ‘Wealth’.Google Scholar

24 See Lindholm, C., Charisma (Cambridge MA, 1990).Google Scholar

25 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 840.Google Scholar

26 Although for a fascinating discussion of Aristotle's transgression of his own principles here, and the implications for approaches in anthropology, see Schrempp, G., ‘Aristotle's other self: on the boundless subject of anthropological discourse’, in Stocking, George (ed.), Romantic Motives: Essays on Anthropological Sensibility (Madison, 1989), 10–43.Google Scholar

27 Sahlins, M. D., Tribesmen (Englewood Cliffs, 1968), 23, 114.Google Scholar

28 Kopytoff, (ed.), African FrontierGoogle Scholar, for example, in an enormously useful and provocative approach to the ‘African frontier’ nevertheless sees frontier societies as essentially conservative rather than innovative, closed in their conceptions while open in their geographical vistas. But one cannot succeed in new environments without a thirst for learning. It is highly unlikely that resettlement was such a ‘mechanical’ process. The mobility with which Kopytoff is concerned was taking place in the context of experimentation with new cultigens from the New World. Innovative ecological knowledge needs to be part of the paradigm.

29 Dupré, G., Un ordre et sa destruction (Paris, 1982).Google Scholar

30 Simmel, G., Georg Simmel: On Individuality and Social Forms (Chicago, 1971), 225.Google Scholar

31 Moore, S., ‘Legal liability and evolutionary interpretation; some aspects of strict liability, self-help, and collective responsibility’, in her Law as Process: An Anthropological Approach (London and Boston, 1978), 82–134.Google Scholar

32 Riesman, P., ‘The person and the life cycle in African social life and thought’, African Studies Review, XXIX (1986), 113.Google Scholar

33 The classic is Radcliffe-Brown, and Forde, , KinshipGoogle Scholar, although Michael Rowlands and Victor Manfredi have both independently reminded me that Forde himself took a very different perspective, more in tune with the one presented here.

34 Richards, A., Chisungu: A Girls' Initiation Ceremony among the Bemba of Northern Rhodesia (London, 1956).Google Scholar

35 Fortes, M., Oedipus and Job in West African Religion (Cambridge, 1959).Google Scholar

36 Horton, R., ‘Social psychologies: African and western’, in Fortes, , Oedipus and Job (Cambridge, rev. ed. 1983), 60.Google Scholar

37 Tessmann, G., Die Pangwe (Berlin, 1913), 206.Google Scholar

38 Meillassoux, C., ‘Essai d'interpretation du phénomène économique dans les sociétés traditionelles d'autosubsistance’, Cah. Ét. Afr., I (1961), 38–67.Google Scholar

39 Tessmann, , PangweGoogle Scholar, section reprinted in Laburthe-Tolra, P. and Falgayrettes-Leveay, C., Fang (Paris, 1992), 199.Google Scholar

40 Evans-Pritchard, E. E., ‘A contribution to the study of Zande culture’, Africa, XXX (1960), 309–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘A further contribution to the study of Zande culture’, Africa, XXXIII (1963), 183–97Google Scholar; idem, ‘A final contribution to the study of Zande culture’, Africa, XXXV (1965), 1–7Google Scholar. Quotation from ‘A contribution’, 322.Google Scholar

41 Meillassoux, C., Maidens, Meal and Money: Capitalism and the Domestic Community (Cambridge, 1981), 45.Google Scholar

42 Meillassoux's later work, The Anthropology of Slavery: The Womb of Iron and Gold, trans. Goldschmidt, Arthur (Chicago, 1991)Google Scholar, gives more space to consider the breadth of value invested in dependents by their natal communities, since he argues that the cost of acquiring people by capture (as slaves) is very low by comparison with the cost of raising them.

43 See MacGaffey, W., ‘On the moderate usefulness of modes of production’, Can. J. Afr. Studies, XIX (1985), 51–7.Google Scholar

44 Miers, and Kopytoff, (eds.), Slavery in Africa.Google Scholar

45 Bledsoe, , Women and Marriage.Google Scholar

46 Berry, S., ‘Social institutions and access to resources’, Africa, LIX (1989), 41–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

47 Miller, , WayGoogle Scholar; Vansina, , Paths.Google Scholar

48 Sahlins, M. D., Culture and Practical Reason (Chicago, 1976), 211.Google Scholar

49 Except when a relation to capitalism is analyzed, in which case it may be used in the classic sense.

50 Dupré, , Ordre et destruction.Google Scholar

51 They are recognised as different processes in one theoretical classic. Simmel distinguishes between kinds of exchange that involve sacrifice, such as the economic exchanges of which accumulation is a sub-type, and those that ‘release an inner energy we would not otherwise know what to do with… When we communicate intellectual matters in conversation, these are not thereby diminished’. He goes on to argue that, in the latter case, ‘to be allowed to contribute is itself a gain… the response of the other (is) an unearned gift’; Individuality, 44–5Google Scholar. In other words, composition is a situational process that adds (towards completion) without depriving, whereas accumulation is a permanent structural process that adds (towards pooling) by deprivation.

52 Vansina, , Paths.Google Scholar

53 Dupré, , Ordre et destruction, 107.Google Scholar

54 Koch, , Magie, 16, 19, 38, 255.Google Scholar

55 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 57.Google Scholar

56 Guyer, J. I., ‘Indigenous currencies and the history of marriage payments; a case study from Cameroon’, Cah. Ét. Afr., XXVI (1986), 577–610.Google Scholar

57 Dupré, G., Les naissances d'une société: espace et historicité chez les Beembe du Congo (Paris, 1985), 121–5Google Scholar. Certain of these characteristics may apply to Africa more generally. Riesman, , ‘Person’Google Scholar, notes how consistently medical and spiritual knowledge is thought to originate in or be animated by personal inspiration, and Sandra Barnes develops the concept of ‘outside knowledge’ as a general social phenomenon on the basis of Yoruba history: ‘Ritual, power and outside knowledge’, Journal of Religion in Africa, XX (1990), 248–67Google Scholar. But the creation and acquisition of knowledge, from within and from outside, is particularly highly developed and exuberant in the Equatorial region, negating any general theory of closed systems, even before one includes the history of trade in material goods.

58 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 563.Google Scholar

59 Guyer, J. I., ‘The iron currencies of southern Cameroon’, Symbols (12 1985), 2–5, 15–16.Google Scholar

60 Dupré, , Naissances.Google Scholar

61 Vansina, J., ‘The dictionary and the historian’, History in Africa, I (1974), 149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

62 Wrigley, C., ‘Review article: The longue durée in the heart of darkness’ J. Afr. Hist., XXXIII (1992), 129–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

63 MacGaffey, W., Art and Healing of the Bakongo, Commented by Themselves (Bloomington, 1991), 33.Google Scholar

64 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1189.Google Scholar

65 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1194.Google Scholar

66 MacGaffey, , Art, 33.Google Scholar

67 Tessmann, , Pangwe, ii, 164–5.Google Scholar

68 Tessmann, , Pangwe, ii, 164–5Google Scholar, quoted in Laburthe-Tolra, Minlaaba, 1234.Google Scholar

69 MacGaffey, , Art, 33.Google Scholar

70 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1185, 1219Google Scholar, insert and emphasis added.

71 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1185.Google Scholar

72 Tessmann, , Pangwe, 3.Google Scholar

73 MacGaffey, W., ‘Complexity, astonishment and power: the visual vocabulary of Kongo Minkisi’, J. Southern Afr. Studies, XIV (1988), 188–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

74 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1189.Google Scholar

75 Laburthe-Tolra, , Minlaaba, 1188.Google Scholar

76 Vansina, J., The Tio Kingdom of the Middle Congo, 1880–1892 (Oxford, 1973)Google Scholar; Schrag, N., ‘Changing perceptions of wealth among the Bamboma (Lower Zaire)’ (Ms edited by Phyllis Martin, Bloomington, 1990).Google Scholar

77 Janzen, J., Lemba: A Drum of Affliction in Africa and the New World, 1650–1930 (New York, 1982).Google Scholar

78 A particular named nkisi is described in MacGaffey, W., ‘Lulendo: the recovery of a Kongo Nkisi’, Ethnos, LII (1987), 339–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

79 MacGaffey, W., ‘The eyes of understanding: Kongo minkisi’, in National Museum of African Art, Astonishment and Power (Washington DC, 1993), 21.Google Scholar

80 Fernandez, J. W. and Fernandez, R. L., ‘Fang reliquary art: its quantities and qualities’, Cah. Ét. Afr., XV (1975), 744.Google Scholar

81 MacGaffey, , Art, 33.Google Scholar

82 MacGaffey, , ‘Eyes’, 95–6.Google Scholar

83 Wrigley, , ‘Review’, 132.Google Scholar

84 Schildkrout, E. and Keim, C. A., African Reflections: Art from Northeastern Zaire (New York, 1990), 147.Google Scholar

85 MacGaffey, , ‘Eyes’, 87.Google Scholar

86 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 49, 562, 565.Google Scholar

87 e. g. MacGaffey, , ‘Complexity’.Google Scholar

88 Schoonheyt, J. A., ‘Les croisettes du Katanga’, Revue Belge de Numismatique, CXXXVII (1991), 141–57Google Scholar. ‘While the evolution of dimension is linear, the evolution of weight follows a different rule, for which we do not understand the criteria…, entering into a weight system’ (p. 157).

89 Ascher, M., Ethnomathematics: A Multicultural View of Mathematical Ideas (Pacific Grove, 1991), 35.Google Scholar

90 Ascher, , Ethnomathematics, 37.Google Scholar

91 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 564.Google Scholar

92 For example, Jean-Jacques Aba Ebanga, Mvele virtuoso performer and intellectual, referred to in Guyer, , ‘Iron currencies’Google Scholar, who was given wives by admirers even though he was a severe paralytic.

93 Darish, P., ‘Dressing for the next life: raffia production and use among the Kuba of Zaire’, in Weiner, Annette B. and Schneider, Jane (eds.), Cloth and Human Experience (Washington DC, 1989), 125, 127, 135.Google Scholar

94 Koch, , Magie, 19Google Scholar, describes a wife's capacity to bring luck, and Tessmann, , HRAF II, 22Google Scholar, retells a story in which one new and beautiful wife releases the helpful souls that have enabled her husband to acquire 79 wives and a prosperous village, resulting in complete disaster.

95 Vincent, J.-F., Traditions et transition: entretiens avec des femmes beti du sud Cameroun (Paris, 1976).Google Scholar

96 It may even be worth rethinking the ‘natalism’ that J. Iliffe and others see in African patterns of fertility in light of an emphasis on the value of personal knowledge. ‘Review article: The origins of African demographic growth’, J. Afr. Hist., XXX (1989), 165–9Google Scholar. It is not ‘more children’ in the simple numerical sense that is at issue, but more and different powers. Cultivating the value of difference may place historically changing restrictions on the natalist logic, depending on the kind of knowledge at stake and the coexistence of incentives to accumulation, in the narrowly quantitative sense.

97 Guyer, , ‘Indigenous currencies’.Google Scholar

98 The quotation is from Rutkow, E. M., Surgery: An Illustrated History (St. Louis, 1993)Google Scholar. It appears in the review of the book by Nuland, S., ‘The inside story: a chronicle of surgery, its origins and its astonishing development through the ages’, New York Times Book Review (13 03 1994), 3.Google Scholar

99 MacGaffey, W., ‘Epistemological ethnocentrism in African studies’, in Jewsiewicki, B. and Newbury, D. (eds.), African Historiographies: What History For Which Africa? (Beverley Hills, 1986), 48.Google Scholar

100 Vansina, , Paths, 239.Google Scholar

101 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 70.Google Scholar

102 See Balandier, G., Sociologie actuelle de l'Afrique Noire: dynamique sociale en Afrique centrale (Paris, 1955)Google Scholar; Dupré, M-C., ‘Une catastrophe démographique au Moyen Congo: la guerre de l'impôt chez les Teke Tsayi, 1913–1920’, History in Africa, XVII (1990), 59–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Lyons, M., The Colonial Disease: Sleeping Sickness in the Early Colonial Belgian Congo (Cambridge, 1993).Google Scholar

103 For a general discussion of alienation in non-capitalist economies, see Gregory, C. A., Gifts and Commodities (New York, 1982).Google Scholar

104 Wrigley, , ‘Review’, 133.Google Scholar

105 Dupré, M-C., ‘Raphia monies among the Teke: their origin and control’, in Guyer, J. I. (ed.), Money Matters: Instability, Values and Social Payments in the Modern History of West African Communities (Portsmouth NH), 39–52.Google Scholar

106 Fernandez, , Bwiti, 69Google Scholar, emphasis added.

107 The changing nature and meaning of these patrimonies become key issues, if we follow Vansina's argument that they run through the entire social history of Equatorial Africa. See Guyer, J. I., Review of Vansina, Paths, Ethnohistory, XXIX (1992), 510–12.Google Scholar

108 Dupré, G., ‘The history and adventures of a monetary object of the Kwele of the Congo: mezong, mondjos and mandjong’, in Guyer (ed.), Money Matters, 77–96.Google Scholar