Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-2brh9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-05T02:12:14.309Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Gungunyane the Negotiator: A Study in African Diplomacy*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Douglas L. Wheeler
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Gungunyane, paramount chief of the Shangana of Gazaland, 1884–95, was a very shrewd diplomat. A study of his diplomacy with Europeans suggests that his major goal was Shangana independence of action. From the beginning of his reign, Gungunyane was pressured to give concessions in both economic and political spheres. His capital was on the edge of the Rhodesian plateau until mid-1889, when the chief moved a large portion of his people as well as his capital southward to the Limpopo valley, Mozambique. This significant dislocation influenced later negotiations with Portugal. Although the chief was a strong personality, he was subject to pressures from his immediate—and in this case, warlike—African advisors. In negotiations with the British South Africa Company, the Mozambique Company and the Portuguese government, the African leader enjoyed the benefits of a fearful military reputation, a wide-reaching espionage system, and conflicts between British and Portuguese concession-seekers. A master of playing both ends against the middle to maintain his freedom of movement, Gungunyane found, nevertheless, that his diplomatic programme was undermined by Portuguese superiority in the use of firearms, disunity among the Shangana and their tributaries, and growing social disintegration caused by alcoholism, emigration, and European encroachment. His final military defeat by Portuguese forces in 1895 was not a true index of his talent as an African diplomat.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 9 , Issue 4 , October 1968 , pp. 585 - 602
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1968

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The traditional Portuguese rendering, ‘Gungunhana’, has been replaced by the Shangana or Shangaans pronunciation. The writer visited the Gaza area both in Mozambique and in Rhodesia in 1967 and heard the word pronounced as ‘Gungunyane’.

2 Gann, L. H., A History of Southern Rhodesia: Early Days to 1934 (London, 1965), 98: Gungunhana ‘lacked the ability of his father Umzila; he was a confirmed drunkard’.Google Scholar

3 Toscano, A. and Quintinha, J., A Derrocada do Império Vátua (Lisbon, 1930), 53–63, 75–6.Google Scholar

4 Trindade, Coelho (ed.), Dezoito Annos em Africa. Notas E Documentos Para A Biographia Do Conseiheiro José D'Almeida (Lisbon, 1898), 64–8, 231–2, 285.Google Scholar

5 Mathers, E. P., Zambesia (London, 1891), 400–12.Google Scholar

6 Coelho, , op. cit. 231–2.Google Scholar

7 Philip, Warhurst, Anglo-Portuguese Relations in South-Central Africa, 1890–1900 (London, 1962), 20.Google Scholar

8 James, Duffy, Portuguese Africa (Cambridge, 1959), 220, 231;Google Scholar‘J. C. Paiva de Andrada’, Grande Enciclopedia Portuguêsa e Brasileira (Lisbon and Rio de Janeiro), xx, 25–6.Google Scholar

9 Coelho, , op. cit. 377.Google Scholar

10 Ibid. 31, 106.

11 Rocha, Martins, Histdria dos Colonias Portuguesas (Lisbon, 1933), 294.Google Scholar

12 Coelho, , op. cit. 207–9, 283;Google ScholarGastāo de Almeida de Eça, F., História das Guerras no Zambeze (Lisbon, 1953–1954), II, 467–70;Google ScholarXavier, A. A. Caldas, ‘Districto de Inhambane’, Boletim do Sociedade de Geographia de Lisboa, series 7 (1887), 153–210.Google Scholar

13 Coelho, , op. cit. 207–9, 283.Google Scholar

14 Warhurst, P. R., ‘The scramble and African politics in Gazaland’, in Stokes, E. and Brown, R., The Zambesian Past (Manchester, 1966), 53–4.Google Scholar

15 Oral information gathered by the writer at Manjacaze, Mozambique in February, 1967.

16 Residente to Secretary General, 16 06 1889, no. 96, Codice a. 1411, in Arquivo Historica de Moçambique, hereafter A.H.M. (Lourenço Marques).Google Scholar

17 Paiva de Andrada, J. to Neves, Ferreira, 5 12 1889,Google Scholar in ‘Cartas de Paiva de Andrada’, Moçambique: Documentário Trimesfral (Lourenço Marques, 1941), 100–4.Google Scholar

18 Toscano, and Quintinha, , op. cit. 82;Google ScholarAntonio, Enes, A Guerra D'Africa em 1895 (Lisbon, 1945 ed.).Google Scholar

19 Caetano, Montez, Mouzinho (Lisbon, 1956), 83.Google Scholar

20 Mousinho de Albuquerque, J., Relatorio Apresentado Ao Conseiheiro…Governador Geral Interino da Provincia De Moçambique (Lisbon, 1896), 41 note;Google ScholarAmadeu, Cunha, Mousibho. A Sua Obra E A San Epoca (Lisbon, 220–1.Google Scholar

21 Coelho, , op. cit. 83.Google Scholar

22 Tennant, and Erasmus, to Cecil Rhodes, 28 02, 1894, file CT 1/7/9;Google ScholarLivingstone, J. to Rhodes, , 13 09, 1892,Google ScholarColquhoun, F. to Company, 24 03, 1892, file HC 3/5/17/5, National Archives (Salisbury, Rhodesia).Google Scholar

23 Residente at Mossurise to Secretary General, 6 February 1888, Codice 2.1411, A.H.M.

24 Coelho, , op. cit. 373.Google Scholar

25 Ibid. 274.

26 Ibid. 373.

27 Smith de la Cour to Currey, 23 06 1891, CT 1/7/12, N.A.Google Scholar

28 Coelho, , op. cit. 276.Google Scholar

29 Coiquhoun, F. to Harris, R., 24 01 1891, CT 1/7/2, N.A.Google Scholar

30 Smith, de la Cour to Harris, R., 24 01 1891, CT 1/7/11, N.A.Google Scholar

31 Smith de la Cour to Harris, 21, 30, 3103 1891,Google Scholar CT 1/7/12, N.A. Harris to Smith de la Cour, telegram, a 02 1891, CT 1/7/11.Google Scholar

32 Schulz, to Secretary, 31 12 1890, CT 1/7/9, N.A.Google Scholar

33 Harris, R. to Schulz, , 29 05 1890, CT 1/7/9, N.A.Google Scholar

34 Dennis, Doyle, ‘With King Gungunhana’, Fortnightly Review (London, 07 1891), 115–17.Google Scholar

35 Warhurst, , ‘The scramble and African politics’, op. cit. 53–4.Google Scholar

36 Lockhart, J. G. and Woodhouse, C. M., Cecil Rhodes (New York, 1963), 220–1.Google Scholar

37 Warhurst, , Anglo-Portuguese Relations, 80–106Google Scholar. For the text of the Schulz concession see F.O.C., 6495 (1891), Correspondence Relating to Great Britain and Portugal in East Africa, no. 1, inclosure in no. 191, pp. 218–19.Google Scholar

38 Duffy, , op. cit. 219–21;Google ScholarWarhurst, , Anglo-Portuguese Relations, 91, 104–5.Google Scholar

39 Gann, L., op. cit. 99.Google Scholar

40 Loch, to Gungunhana, , 14 08 1891, HC 3/5/33/10, N.A.Google Scholar

41 ‘History given to Holohulu’ (1891 ?), CT 5/7/4, N.A.

42 Doyle, D. and Longden, W. to Secretary of B.S.A. Company, 10 11 1891. CT ‘1/7/4, N.A.Google Scholar

43 Residente to Secretary General, 9 October 1891, Caixa 4.159, maço 63, A.H.M.

44 Coelho, , op. cit. 287–90.Google Scholar

45 Enes, , Moçambique (1893) Relatório (Lisbon, 1896), 174–8.Google Scholar

46 Coelho, , op. cit. 364–5.Google Scholar

47 Ibid; for text of modus vivendi, see 374−6.

48 Ibid. 378–9.

49 Ibid. 377.

50 Ibid. 381.

51 Ibid. 406–17.

52 Ibid. 470–80.

53 Ibid. 413–14.

54 Gungunhana, to B.S.A. Company, 23 06 1894 (copy), HC 3/5/17/5.Google Scholar

55 Cf. note 54 (National Archives), pencilled in left corner of document ‘The signature of Prime Minister “Magijahn” not attached—Document therefore invalid’. The 1894 document was signed by witnesses Dr Georges Louis Liengme, Aleida Gerber (Swiss missionaries) and P. Shumugan and four indunas.

56 Rhodes to Soveral, Dec.? 1894, HC 3/5/17/5, N.A.; Longden, W. to ‘Charter’, telegram, 18 02 1915, A 3/18/18/4, N.A.Google Scholar

57 Kimberley to MacDonald (copy), F.O., 21 November 1894, HC 3/5/17/5, N.A.

58 Coelho, , op. cit. 232–3, 324.Google Scholar

59 Ibid. 274, 457–8.

60 Hollis, to Uhl, , 28 06 1895, Despatches from U.S. Consuls in Lourenço Marques…., Roll 2, National Archives, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar

61 Military Commandant of Limpopo to Residente, 21 March 1894, Caixa 4.159, A.H.M.

62 Mousinho, de Albuquerque, Moçambique 1896–1898 (Lisbon, 1913 ed.), 39–40.Google Scholar

63 Military Commandant, Inhampura, to Residente, 18 10 1894, Caixa 4.159, maço 23, A.H.M.Google Scholar

64 Marcello, Caetano (ed.), As Campanhas de 1895 Segundo Os Contemporáneos (Lisbon, 1945), 40–7.Google Scholar

65 Carlos, Selvagem, Portugal Militar (Lisbon, 1934), 618–19;Google ScholarCaetano, , op. cit. 39–40.Google Scholar

65 Coelho, , op. cit. 516–18.Google Scholar

67 Enes, , A Guerra, 310–11, 459.Google Scholar

68 Coelho, , op. cit. 459–60.Google Scholar

69 Ibid. 460–2.

70 Toscano, and Quintinha, , op. cit. 89.Google Scholar

71 Coelho, , op. cit. 473–5.Google Scholar

72 Enes, , A Guerra, 247–51.Google Scholar

73 Ibid.. 238–46.

74 Ibid.. 249–51; Almeida reported that Liengme had no influence with Gungunyane, but another Portuguese report contradicted this. Rosario, to Military Commandant, 17 12 1894, Caixa 4.159, maço 23, A.H.M.Google Scholar

75 Coelho, , op. cit. 504–5, for terms.Google Scholar

76 Ibid.. 516–18.

77 Enes, , A Guera, 459–60.Google Scholar

78 Warhurst, , Anglo-Portuguese Relations, 107–7;Google ScholarCoelho, , op. cit. 522–3.Google Scholar

79 Ayres, d'Ornellas, Cartas D'Africa (Lisbon, 1930), 85;Google ScholarEnes, , op. cit., 310–11.Google Scholar

80 Coelho, , op. cit. 499, 511, 523;Google ScholarCaetano, , op. cit. 158–60.Google Scholar

81 Ornellas, , op. cit. 97–8, 291–5, 305;Google ScholarToscano, and Quintinha, , op. cit. 360.Google Scholar

82 Albuquerque, , Relatório Apresentado A. Conseilheizo Correia E Lança (Lisbon, 1896), 35–45;Google ScholarAlbuqueŕque, , Livro das Campanhas (Lisbon, 1935), I. 43–7.Google Scholar

83 For the exiled years of Gungunyane, see Pedro, de Merelim, ‘Os Vátuas na Ilha Terçeira’, Atlantida (Angra do Heroisnio, Azores Islands), IV, (1960), 317–18,Google Scholar and my forthcoming chapter, ‘Gungunhana’, in Bennett, Norman R. (ed.), Leadership in Eastern Africa (Boston University Press, 1968).Google Scholar

84 Residente to Secretary General, ?November 1891, Caixa 4. 159, A.H.M.

85 Brown, R., ‘Aspects of the scramble for Matabeleland’, in Stokes, and Brown, , op. cit. p. 73.Google Scholar

86 Coelho, , op. Cit. 377.Google Scholar

87 Duffy's interpretation in Portuguese Africa (232) is an echoing of an earlier one in the Royal Naval Intelligence Division's A Manual of Portuguese East Africa (London, 1919), 499–500.Google Scholar

88 Coelho, , op. cit. 83.Google Scholar

89 Enes, , op. cit., 128.Google Scholar

90 Coelho, , op. cit. 83.Google Scholar

91 ‘Gazaland’ entry in LO 8/I/I Minute Book, p. 44, N.A. (Salisbury).Google Scholar

92 Many Europeans refused to believe that Gungunyane was defeated when the news first came out. The U.S. Consul in Mozambique was no exception. Hollis, to Uhl, , 01 1896, Despatches N.A. (Washington, D.C.)Google Scholar

93 David, Rodrigues, ‘A Ocupação de Moçambique’, Revista da Infanteria (Lisbon, 1910), 150.Google Scholar