Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T08:14:08.490Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Recent Afrikaner Historiography

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 April 2010

F. A. van Jaarsveld
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In 1961, when the Union of South Africa became a republic, I wrote in ‘Interpretations and Trends in South African Historical Writing’: ‘The Afrikaner had won the constitutional struggle against the Briton but at the very moment that he was about to reap the rewards of his victory in a new Republic, he stood confronted with the challenge of a non-white majority, threatening to deprive him of his gains […] A national myth has already become established - that South Africa is an innocent nation and the victim of attack in an evil world, and that attempts to solve the racial problem by territorial divisions or separate development are “misunderstood”.’

Type
Historiography
Information
Itinerario , Volume 16 , Issue 1 , March 1992 , pp. 93 - 106
Copyright
Copyright © Research Institute for History, Leiden University 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Jaarsveld, F. A. van, The Afrikaner's Interpretation of South African History (Cape Town 1964) 148–149Google Scholar.

2 Ibidem, 136–137, 146, 148, 154, 156.

3 Smith, Iain, ‘The Revolution in South African Historiography’, History Today (02 1988) 10Google Scholar.

4 Smith, Ken, The Changing Past. Trends in South African Historical Writing (Johannesburg 1988) 57Google Scholar.

5 Merwe, P. J. van der, Die noordwaartse beweging van die Boere voor die. Groot Trek, 1770–1842 (The Hague 1937),Google ScholarDie trekboer in die geskiedenis van die Kaapkolonie (Cape Town 1938), andGoogle ScholarTrek (Cape Town 1945). Van der Merwe was called the F. J. Turner of South African frontier history and an early ‘Annalist’ historian in the French tradition. He holds a unique position in Afrikaner historiography.Google ScholarSpies, F. J. du Toit, Hamelberg en die Oranje-Vrystaat (Amsterdam 1941), andGoogle ScholarJaarsveld, F. A. van, Afrikaner geskiedsktywing, Verle, Hede, en Toekoms (Johannesburg 1992) 77–90Google Scholar.

6 Krüger, D. W., The Making of a Nation (Johannesburg 1969) prefaceGoogle Scholar.

7 Scholtz, G. D., Die Oorsake van die Tweede Vryheidsoorlog, 1899–1902 (2 vols.; Johannesburg 1948)Google Scholar; Suid-Afrika en die Weyeldpolitiek, 1652–1952 (Johannesburg 1962)Google Scholar; Hoe die Wereldpolitiek gevoer word (Johannesburg 1952) andGoogle ScholarDie stryd om die wêreld (Johannesburg 1962)Google Scholar.

8 Marks, Shula, ‘African and Afrikaner History’ Journal of African History 11, 3 (1970) 435–447CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 Wright, H. M., The Burden of the Present. Liberal-Radical Controversy over Southern African History (Cape Town 1977) 101–102Google Scholar.

10 Ray, D. I., Shinnie, P. and Williams, D. eds., Into the 80's, the Proceedings of the 11th Annual Conference of the Canadian Association of African Studies (Vancouver 1981) 233–235Google Scholar.

11 Ibidem, 239.

12 Ibidem, 233.

13 Jaarsveld, F. A. van, Omstrede Suid-Afrikaanse Verlede (Johannesburg 1984) 170–176Google Scholar.

14 Ibidem, 110.

15 Liebenberg, B. J., Andries Pretorius in Natal (Cape Town 1977)Google Scholar; Ferreira, O. J. O., Stormvoël van die Noorde, Stephanus Schoeman in Transvaal (Pretoria 1978); andGoogle ScholarJongh, P. S. de, Sarel Celliers (Johannesburg 1987)Google Scholar; Barnard, C. J., Gent. ljnds Botha op die Natalse Front, 1899–1900 (Cape Town 1970)Google Scholar; Scholtz, W. L. von R., Generaal Christiaan de Wet as Veldheer (Leiden 1978)Google Scholar.

16 Brits, J. P., Tielman Roos, Sy rol in die Suid-Afrikaanse poliliek, 1907–1935 (Pretoria 1979) andGoogle ScholarBasson, J. I., J. G. Strijdom, Sy polilieke loopbaan van 1929 tot 1948 (Pretoria 1980)Google Scholar; Geyser, O., Marais, A. H., Roux, J. H. le, Coetzer, P. W. et al., Die Nasionale Party, 1914–1948 (5 vols.; Bloemfontein 1975–1992)Google Scholar.

17 Böeseken, A.. Jan van Riebeeck en sy Gesin (Cape Town 1964),Google ScholarSimon van derStelen sy Hinders (Cape Town 1964) andGoogle ScholarSlaves and Free Blacks at the Cape 1658–1700 (Cape Town 1977)Google Scholar; Muller, C. F. J., Oorsprong van die Groot Trek (Cape Town 1974)Google Scholar.

18 Kotze, D. J., Nasionalismeas historiesefaktor (3 vols.; Cape Town 1960–1970) andGoogle ScholarDie Kommunisme I (Cape Town 1965)Google Scholar.

19 Kapp, P. H., VerrykingofFrustrasie? Gedagtes oor die studievan die algemene geskiedenis (inaugural lecture, Rand Afrikaans University 1980 (A 199)) 4Google Scholar.

20 Plessis, J. S. du, ‘Oor historiese waarheid’, Koers 31, 10 (04 1964) 543Google Scholar; Scholtz, G. D., Die taak van die historikus. Rand Afrikaans University publication A 27 (1970)Google Scholar; Hattingh, J. L., Historiese Navorsing, in Soeke na die Waarheid. Publications of the University of the Western Cape, Series A (34) (Bellville 1979)Google Scholar; Liebenberg, B. J., Waarom bestudeer ons die verlede? University of South Africa, Pretoria, Miscellanea (31) (1981)Google Scholar.

21 Archives Year Book for South African History (1981) I, Preface (my translation).

22 Ploeger, J., Die Lotgevalle van burgerlike bevolking gedurende die Anglo-Boereoortog 1899-1902 (Pretoria 1990)Google Scholar.

23 Fourie, J. J. and Stols, E. L. P., Afrikaners in die Goudstad, 1886–1961 (Pretoria 1978 and 1986)Google Scholar.

24 Geyser, O., Adv. B.J. Vorster I, 1953–1974. Geredigeerde Toesprake (Cape Town 1976)Google Scholar; Roux, J. H. le, Coetzeretal, P. W., Gent. J. B. M. Hertzog-Systreween stryd (Bloemfontein 1986)Google Scholar.

25 Preliminary Report of a Committee of the South African Historical Association (1990) on historical research (Prof. J.S. Bergh, chairman) 4.

26 Ibidem, 8–9.

27 Cf. Muller, C. F. J., Sonop in die Snide (Cape Town 1990) 526–558Google Scholar.

28 Jaarsveld, Van, Afrikaner geskiedsktyzuing, 193–207Google Scholar.

29 Butler, J., Elphic, R. and Welsh, D. eds., Democratic Liberalism in South Africa (Cape Town 1987) 35Google Scholar.

30 Heese, Hans, Croep Sonder Grmse (Bellville 1984)Google Scholar.

31 Boeyens, Jan, ‘“Zwart Ivoor”: Inboekelingen in Zoutpansberg, 1848–1869’, South African Historical Journal 24 (1991) 31–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

32 Cf. footnote 15.

33 Fonri, J. J., Die koms van die Bantoe na die Rand en hulle posisie aldaar, 1886–1899. Achives Year Book (1979) IGoogle Scholar; Nöthling, F. J., Die Vestiging van gekleurdes in en om Pretoria, 1900–1914. Archives Year Book (1982) IGoogle Scholar; Mostert, J. P. C., ‘Die politieke, maatskaplike en ekonomiese implikasiesvan swart verstedeliking in Suid-Afrika, 1939–1948’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of the Orange Free State, 1985)Google Scholar; Odendaal, A., Vukani Bantu! The Beginnings of Black Political Protest Politics in South Africa to 1912 (Cape Town 1984)Google Scholar; Grundlingh, Albert, Fighting their Chun War, South African Blacks and the First World War (Johannesburg 1987); andGoogle ScholarGebhard, Wolfgang, Shades of Reality: Black Perceptions of South African History (Essen 1991)Google Scholar.

34 Aswegen, H. J. van, Geskiedenis van Afrika (Pretoria 1980), andGoogle ScholarHistory of South Africa to 1854 (Cape Town 1991)Google Scholar.

35 Muller, Sonop in die Suide, Pretorius, F., Kommandolewe tydens die Anglo-Boereoorlog, 1899–1902 (Cape Town 1991)Google Scholar.

36 Cf. Zyl, D. J. van, Kaapse Wyn en Brandeiuyn, 1795–1860 (Cape Town 1974)Google Scholar.

37 Jaarsveld, F. A. van, ‘Die ontmitologisering van die Afrikaner se Geskiedenisbeeld’ in: Coetzee, A. J., Hulsels van Kristal (Cape Town 1981)Google Scholar; Liebenberg, B. J., ‘Mites rondom Bloedrivier en die Gelofte’, and ‘Bloedrivier en Gods Hand’, South African Historical Journal 12 (1980) 1–12, and 20 (1988) 17–32. Re Slagtersnek seeCrossRefGoogle ScholarScholtz, G. D., Die ontwikkeling van diepolitieke denken van die Afrikaner III (Johannesburg 1970) 231–239;Google ScholarHeese, J. A., Slagtersnek en sy mense (Elsiesrivier 1973)Google Scholar.

38 Broodryk, M., ‘Die stand van eietydse geskiedenis in Suid-Afrika’, Journal of Contemporary History 15 (3) (12 1990) 110–111Google Scholar.

39 Jaarsveld, F. A. van, Geskiedkundige Verkenning (Pretoria 1974) 117–134Google Scholar.

40 Jaarsveld, F. A. van, Stedelike geskiedenis as navorsingsveld vir die Suid-Afrikaanse historikus. Rand Afrikaans University Publication Series 3 (Johannesburg 1973)Google Scholar; Jaarsveld, F. A. van, ‘Tematiek en Metodiek van die historiese industrialiseringsnavorsing’, South African Historical journal 21 (1979) 91–103.CrossRefGoogle ScholarVide, also my Moderne Geskiedskrywing (Durban 1982)Google Scholar.

41 Grundlingh, A., ‘Politics, Principles and Problems of a Profession: Afrikaner Historians and their Discipline, c. 1920 - c. 1965’, Perspectives in Education 12, 1 (1990) 1–19Google Scholar.

42 Bundy, Colin, in Radical History Review. History from South Africa 46/7 (1990) 137Google Scholar.

43 Moll, J. C. et al., Tussengroepsverhoudinge soos weerspieël in die Suid-Afrikaanse Historiografie (Pretoria 1987) 12, 17–18Google Scholar.

44 Bergh, J. S., Uitdagings vir die Afrikaner Historikus (University of Pretoria 1987) 12–13 (my translation)Google Scholar.

45 Elphick, R. and Giliomee, H. B., The Shaping of South African Society 1652–1820 (Cape Town 1989)Google Scholar.

46 Toit, A. du and Giliomee, H. B., Afrikaner Political Thought. Analysis and Documents 1780–1850 (Cape Town 1983)Google Scholar.

47 American Historical Review 88, 4 (1983) 920CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

48 Smith, Ken, The Changing Past, 98Google Scholar.

49 Bruwer, P. F., Die Derde Vrykeidsoorlog woedand Vir Volk en Vtyheid (Morgenzon 1986 and 1990)Google Scholar

50 Duvenhage, G. D. J., Die Groot Trek (Pretoria 1986–1987)Google Scholar.

51 Nipperdey, Th., Nachdenken über die deulsche Geschichte (Munich 1986) 226Google Scholar.