Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-r5fsc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-27T20:54:09.517Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Love, convenience, or respectability? Understanding the alliances of the Five Star Movement in the European Parliament

Part of: IPSR-RISP 5-Star Collection

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 April 2018

Edoardo Bressanelli  and
Margherita de Candia
Edoardo Bressanelli*
Affiliation:
Department of European and International Studies, King’s College London, 22 Kingsway, London, UK
Margherita de Candia
Affiliation:
Department of European and International Studies, King’s College London, 22 Kingsway, London, UK
*
*E-mail: [email protected]
Get access

Abstract

The Five Star Movement (M5S) formed the Eurosceptic Europe of Freedom and Direct Democracy Group when it first elected its members in the European Parliament (EP) in 2014. Two and a half years later, the M5S sought, without success, to leave the Eurosceptics and join the Liberal group. This attempted a change of transnational affiliation is puzzling: why has the M5S tried to leave the Eurosceptic group to ally with the most Europhile group in the EP? How could this U-turn be explained? Relying on several different data – the EUANDI party data set, official EP data, and original interviews with members of the EP – this article provides a systematic answer to these questions. We test three general hypotheses on group membership in the EP, using the M5S as a case study. We show that neither policy congruence nor the pursuit of office fully explains the M5S’s observed or attempted alliances. We suggest, instead, that ‘domestic politics’ is the key driver of the M5S’s behaviour in the EP. Political group membership is functional to the Movement’s strategic objectives at home. This article shows that national-level explanations of transnational affiliation need to be given more consideration, and highlights the ‘second-order’ importance of the EU arena with respect to ‘first-order’ national strategic objectives.

Keywords

European UnionItalymulti-level governancepolitical parties
Type
Research Article
Information
Italian Political Science Review / Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica , Volume 49 , Issue 1 , March 2019 , pp. 25 - 48
Copyright
© Società Italiana di Scienza Politica 2018 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ANSA (2014), ‘Di Maio, Farage mossa tattica per M5S’, 30 May. Retrieved 11 November 2017 from http://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/politica/2014/05/30/di-maio-farage-mossa-tattica-per-m5s_f1024238-18dd-4826-aa93-7ec1f2bae8b4.html.Google Scholar
Banks, M. (2017), ‘Verhofstadt admits dalliance with 5 Star movement was a mistake’. The Parliament Magazine, 11 January. Retrieved 7 November 2017 from https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/articles/news/verhofstadt-admits-dalliance-5-star-movement-was-mistake.Google Scholar
Benedetto, G. (2015), ‘The proportionality of office distribution in the European Parliament, 1994-2012: Who gets the mega-seats?’. Paper Presented at the 45th UACES Conference, Bilbao, 7–9 September.Google Scholar
Borz, G. and Rose, R. (2010), Mapping Parties Across Europe with EU Profiler data, Aberdeen: Centre for the Study of Public Policy, University of Aberdeen.Google Scholar
Bressanelli, E. (2012), ‘National parties and group membership in the European Parliament: ideology or pragmatism?’, Journal of European Public Policy 19(5): 737–754.Google Scholar
Bressanelli, E. (2015), ‘The European elections of May 2014: still second-order elections?’, Italian Politics 30: 83–102.Google Scholar
Carroll, R., Gary, W.C. and Pachón, M. (2006), ‘How parties create electoral democracy, chapter 2’, Legislative Studies Quarterly 31(2): 153–174.Google Scholar
Casaleggio, D. (2016), ‘In Facebook [official profile]’, 15 December. Retrieved 3 April 2017 from https://www.facebook.com/Casaleggio.Davide/posts/237583446677640.Google Scholar
Conti, N. (2017), ‘The Italian political elites and Europe: Big move, small change?’, International Political Science Review 38(5): 534–548.Google Scholar
Conti, N. and Memoli, V. (2015), ‘The emergence of a new party in the Italian party system: rise and fortunes of the Five Star Movement’, West European Politics 38(3): 516–534.Google Scholar
Corbett, R., Jacobs, F. and Neville, D. (2016), The European Parliament, London: John Harper Publishing.Google Scholar
Corbetta, P. and Vignati, R. (2014), ‘Direct democracy and scapegoats: the Five Star Movement and Europe’, The International Spectator 49(1): 53–64.Google Scholar
Corriere della Sera (2017), ‘Grillo tentato di lasciare il gruppo di Farage all’Europarlamento: si vota (senza preavviso) sul futuro dell’UE’, 8 January. Retrieved 17 February 2018 from http://www.corriere.it/politica/17_gennaio_08/grillo-tentato-lasciare-gruppo-farage-all-europarlamento-si-vota-senza-preavviso-futuro-all-ue-e531e5ce-d585-11e6-9b45-ca5a29d2649d.shtml.Google Scholar
Daniel, W.T. (2013), ‘When the agent knows better than the principal: the effect of education and seniority on European Parliament Rapporteur Assignment’, Journal of Common Market Studies 51(5): 832–848.Google Scholar
Franzosi, P., Marone, F. and Salvati, E. (2015), ‘Populism and Euroscepticism in the Italian Five Star Movement’, The International Spectator 50(2): 109–124.Google Scholar
Garzia, D., Alexander, H.T. and De Sio, L. (2017), ‘Party placement in supranational elections: an introduction to the EUANDI 2014 dataset’, Party Politics 23(4): 333–341.Google Scholar
Grande, E. and Kriesi, H. (2014), ‘The restructuring of political conflict in Europe and the politicization of European integration’, in T. Risse (ed.), European Public Spheres: Politics is Back, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 190–224.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2014a), ‘Nigel Farage, la verità.’ Il blog delle stelle, 30 May. Retrieved 17 February 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/2014/05/nigel_farage_la_verita.html.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2014b), ‘Consultazione online: il gruppo politico europeo del M5S – RISULTATI.’ Il blog di Beppe Grillo, 12 June. Retrieved 23 February 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/2014/06/consultazione_o.html.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2014c), ‘La democrazia europea a rischio’. Il blog di Beppe Grillo, 8 July. Retrieved 5 March 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/2014/07/la_democrazia_a_rischio_in_europa.html.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2014d), ‘La risposta dei Verdi’. Il blog di Beppe Grillo, 5 June. Retrieved 25 April 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/2014/06/la_risposta_dei_verdi.html.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2016), ‘Il programma di governo del Movimento 5 Stelle: l’Energia’. Il blog delle stelle, 5 December. Retrieved 3 April 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/2016/12/il_programma_di_governo_del_movimento_5_stelle_lenergia.html.Google Scholar
Grillo, B. (2017), ‘Votazione online: il gruppo politico europeo del MoVimento 5 Stelle’. Il Blog delle Stelle, 8 January. Retrieved 6 April 2018 from http://www.ilblogdellestelle.it/2017/01/votazione_online_il_gruppo_politico_europeo_del_movimento_5_stelle.html.Google Scholar
Hausemer, P. (2006), ‘Participation and political competition in committee report allocation: under what conditions do MEPs represent their constituents?’, European Union Politics 7(4): 505–530.Google Scholar
Hix, S. (2005), The Political System of the European Union, London: Palgrave MacMillan.Google Scholar
Hix, S. and Lord, C. (1997), Political Parties in the European Union, New York: St. Martin’s Press.Google Scholar
Hix, S., Noury, A.G. and Roland, G. (2007), Democratic Politics in the European Parliament, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Hurka, S. and Kaeding, M. (2012), ‘Report allocation in the European Parliament after eastern enlargement’, Journal of European Public Policy 19(4): 512–529.Google Scholar
Hurka, S., Kaeding, M. and Obholzer, L. (2015), ‘Learning on the job? EU enlargement and the assignment of (shadow) rapporteurships in the European Parliament’, Journal of Common Market Studies 53(6): 1230–1247.Google Scholar
Il Sole 24 Ore (2016), ‘La crisi e le posizioni dei partiti’, 9 December. Retrieved 4 April 2017 from http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/notizie/2016-12-08/movimento-5-stelle-200339.shtml?uuid=ADtDuJAC.Google Scholar
Jansen, T. (2006), ‘Il Partito Popolare Europeo: origini e sviluppo’, Bruxelles: Segretariato Generale del Partito Popolare Europeo.Google Scholar
Kim, J.-O. and Mueller, C.W. (1978), Factor Analysis: Statistical Methods and Practical Issues, Vol. 14, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
Klingemann, H.-D., Volkens, A., Bara, J., Budge, I. and Macdonald, M. (2006), Mapping policy preferences II: Estimates for parties, elections and governments in Central and Eastern Europe, European Union and OECD 1990-2003, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Koop, C., Reh, C. and Bressanelli, E. (2017), ‘When politics prevails: parties, elections and loyalty in the European Parliament.’ European Journal of Political Research, https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6765.12252.Google Scholar
Maggini, N. (2014), ‘ll bacino elettorale del M5s: caratteristiche socio-politiche e atteggiamenti tra continuità e mutamento’, Centro Italiano Studi Elettorali (CISE). Retrieved 25 April 2017 from http://cise.luiss.it/cise/2014/12/12/il-bacino-elettorale-del-m5s-caratteristiche-socio-politiche-e-atteggiamenti-tra-continuita-e-mutamento/.Google Scholar
Mair, P. and Mudde, C. (1998), ‘The party family and its study’, Annual Review of Political Science 1(1): 211–229.Google Scholar
Manucci, L. and Amsler, M. (2018), ‘Where the wind blows: Five Star Movement’s populism, direct democracy and ideological flexibility’, Italian Political Science Review 48(1): 109–132.Google Scholar
Marks, G. (2007), ‘Triangulation and the square root law’, Electoral Studies 26(1): 1–10.Google Scholar
Maurer, A., Parkes, R. and Wagner, M. (2008), ‘Explaining group membership in the European Parliament: the British Conservatives and the movement for European reform’, Journal of European Public Policy 15(2): 246–262.Google Scholar
McDonnell, D. and Werner, A. (2018), ‘Respectable radicals: why some radical right parties in the European Parliament forsake policy congruence’, Journal of European Public Policy 25(5): 747–763.Google Scholar
McElroy, G. and Benoit, K. (2010), ‘Party policy and group affiliation in the European Parliament’, British Journal of Political Science 40(2): 377–398.Google Scholar
Movimento 5 Stelle (2014), ‘Codice di comportamento per i candidati del MoVimento 5 Stelle alle elezioni europee e per gli eletti al Parlamento europeo’. Retrieved 17 February 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/movimento/codice_comportamento_europee.php.Google Scholar
Movimento 5 Stelle Europa (2015), ‘Gli impresentabili al Parlamento europeo. Parte 4/6’, 30 July. Retrieved 23 February 2017 from http://www.beppegrillo.it/movimento/parlamentoeuropeo/2015/07/gli-impresentabili-a-3.html.Google Scholar
Mudde, C. (2004), ‘The populist zeitgeist’, Government and Opposition 39(4): 542–563.Google Scholar
Passarelli, G. and Tuorto, D. (2018), ‘The Five Star Movement purely a matter of protest? The rise of a new party between political discontent and reasoned voting’, Party Politics 24(2): 129–140.Google Scholar
Perrone, M. (2016), ‘La strategia dei cinque stelle che ora puntano al governo’. Il Sole 24 Ore, 5 December. Retrieved 3 April 2017 from http://stream24.ilsole24ore.com/video/notizie/la-strategia-cinque-stelle-che-ora-puntano-governo/ADJbpa7B.Google Scholar
Picardi, A. (2017), ‘Cosa farà il Movimento 5 Stelle di Grillo per andare al governo. Parla il prof. Becchi’, Formiche, 24 January. Retrieved 4 April 2017 from http://formiche.net/2017/01/24/becchi-lega-m5s-movimento-stelle-grillo-governo/.Google Scholar
Pipitone, G. (2017), ‘M5s Europa, trattative già da Settembre ma parlamentari non sapevano del voto “Finire con i Non Iscritti? Un disastro”’, Il Fatto Quotidiano, 8 January. Retrieved 17 February 2018 from https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2017/01/08/m5s-europa-trattative-gia-da-settembre-ma-parlamentari-non-sapevano-del-voto-finire-con-i-non-iscritti-un-disastro/3302261/.Google Scholar
Polk, J., Rovny, J., Bakker, R., Edwards, E., Hooghe, L., Jolly, S., Koedam, J., Kostelka, F., Marks, G., Schumacher, G., Steenbergen, M., Vachudova, M. and Zilovic, M. (2017), ‘Explaining the salience of anti-elitism and reducing political corruption for political parties in Europe with the 2014 Chapel Hill Expert Survey data’, Research & Politics 4(1): 1–9.Google Scholar
Reuscher, C. (2016), ‘Das Wort Abschiebung steht nicht für Xenophobie’, Die Welt, 8 December. Retrieved 4 April 2017 from https://www.welt.de/politik/ausland/article160085548/Das-Wort-Abschiebung-steht-nicht-fuer-Xenophobie.html.Google Scholar
Settembri, P. (2004), ‘When is a group not a political group? The dissolution of the TDI group in the European Parliament’, The Journal of Legislative Studies 10(1): 150–174.Google Scholar
Strøm, K. (1990), ‘A behavioral theory of competitive political parties’, American Journal of Political Science 34(2): 565–598.Google Scholar
VoteWatch Europe (2016), ‘Who holds the power in the European Parliament? Assessing the influence of individual MEPs’. Retrieved 25 April 2017 from http://www.votewatch.eu/blog/who-holds-the-power-in-the-european-parliament-assessing-the-influence-of-individual-meps/#comments.Google Scholar
Whitaker, R. and Lynch, P. (2014), ‘Understanding the formation and actions of Eurosceptic groups in the European Parliament: pragmatism, principles and publicity’, Government and Opposition 49(2): 232–263.Google Scholar
Yordanova, N. (2011), ‘Inter-institutional rules and division of power in the European Parliament: allocation of consultation and co-decision reports’, West European Politics 34(1): 97–121.Google Scholar
Yordanova, N. and Mühlböck, M. (2015), ‘Tracing the selection bias in roll call votes: party group cohesion in the European Parliament’, European Political Science Review 7(3): 373–399.Google Scholar
Yoshinaka, A., McElroy, G. and Bowler, S. (2010), ‘The appointment of rapporteurs in the European Parliament’, Legislative Studies Quarterly 35(4): 457–486.Google Scholar
Zanni, M. (2017), ‘Marco Zanni [Facebook]’, 8 January. Retrieved 23 February 2017 from https://www.facebook.com/www.marcozanni.eu/?fref=ts.Google Scholar