Hostname: page-component-586b7cd67f-rdxmf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-23T21:38:41.705Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The end of Gaelic Ulster: a thematic interpretation of events between 1534 and 1610

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2016

Hiram Morgan
Hiram Morgan*
Affiliation:
St Catharine’s College, Cambridge
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The period between the Kildare rebellion and the plantation of Ulster marks the final phase of a distinct political system. During these years the English administration in Ireland made strenuous efforts to reform Gaelic society. This paper aims to show that indigenous society was not inevitably doomed to submit before a superior Renaissance state. Indeed it proved flexible in responding to the challenge and was itself in the process of ‘modernisation’. This process was most marked in Ulster which was the strongest Gaelic region and the crown’s most intractable problem. The northern province was differentiated from the other Gaelic regions of Ireland by its political and physical geography. Ulster was an homogeneous cultural zone and contained the powerful polities of Tyrone, ruled by the O’Neills, and Tirconnell, ruled by the O’Donnells. Guarding the southern approaches of the province was a barrier of rough terrain interrupted by lakes and passes.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 26 , Issue 101 , May 1988 , pp. 8 - 32
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 1988

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Earlier surveys of this period are found in LordHamilton, Ernest, Elizabethan Ulster (London, 1919)Google Scholar, and Colles, Ramsey, The history of Ulster from the earliest times to the present day (4 vols, London, 1919-20), i-ii Google Scholar. Hayes-McCoy, Gerard with his monograph Scots mercenary forces in Ireland, 1565–1603 (Dublin, 1937)Google Scholar and Canny, Nicholas with his interpretative article ‘Hugh O’Neill, earl of Tyrone, and the changing face of Gaelic Ulster’ in Studia Hibernica, x (1970), pp 7–35 Google Scholar, have been notable trail-blazers. The writer is grateful to Dr Brendan Bradshaw and the participants in the Cambridge Group for Irish Studies for their useful criticisms of an earlier version of this paper.

2 This historiographical issue is tackled by Bradshaw, in ‘The Elizabethans and the Irish: a muddled model’ in Studies, xx (1981), pp 233-44Google Scholar.

3 English and Irish strategists were well aware of Ulster’s natural strengths: see Dawtrey, ‘Clandeboye’, ?1594, (B.L., Lansd. 111/46) and ‘The memorial of O’Neill and O’Donnell to Philip III’, 1608 (Archivo General de Simancas, Estado 1297).

4 The Gaelic lordships can be described as polities, because each was a sovereign entity whose lord possessed ‘imperial jurisdiction within his room’: ‘State of Ireland’, 1515 (S.P. Hen. VIII, ii, 1).

5 It was the weakness of rights to property which led English commentators to say that the Gaelic Irish did not distinguish between Meum and Tuum, e.g. Dawtrey, ‘Discourse on Ireland’, May 1594 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/174/62, enclosure i).

6 The importance of legitimacy is emphasised in the obituary of Hugh Dubh O’Donnell, Annála Connachta, sub anno 1537.

7 See ‘The opinion of the earl of Sussex’, 1562 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1515–74, p. 339). Our knowledge of Gaelic society has been greatly extended by the scholarship of recent years, esp. Nicholls, Kenneth, Gaelic and Gaelicised Ireland in the middle ages (Dublin, 1972)Google Scholar, and his 1976 lecture, O’Donnell, Land, law and society in sixteenth-century Ireland (Dublin, 1976)Google Scholar; O’Dowd, Mary, ‘Gaelic economy and society’ in Brady, Ciarán and Gillespie, Raymond (eds), Natives and newcomers: essays on the making of Irish colonial society, 1534–1641 (Dublin, 1986), pp 120–47 Google Scholar; Simms, Katharine, From kings to warlords: the changing political structure of Gaelic Ireland in the later middle ages (Woodbridge, 1987)Google Scholar and Morgan, Hiram, ‘The outbreak of the Nine Years War: Ulster in Irish politics, 1583–1596’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, 1987)Google Scholar, chs 3–4.

8 ‘Pedigree of the O’Neills’ in Moryson, Fynes, An itinerary (4 vols, Glasgow, 1907-8), ii, 175 Google Scholar.

9 For the introduction of artillery, see Hayes-McCoy, G.A., ‘The early history of guns in Ireland’ in Galway Arch., & Hist. Soc. Jn., viii (1938), pp 43–65 Google Scholar.

10 ‘Articuli, qui teneor Ego, Connatus O’Neile’, Dec. 1541 (S.P. Hen. VIII, iii, 353–5); ‘The articles of the submission of the lord O’Neill when he was created earl of Tyrone’, 1 Oct. 1542 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1515–74, pp 198–9).

11 For the Kildare ascendancy and rebellion, see Ellis, Steven G., Tudor Ireland: crown, community and the conflict of cultures, 1470–1603 (London, 1985)Google Scholar, chs 4–5. For the beginnings of reform policy, see Bradshaw, Brendan, The Irish constitutional revolution of the sixteenth century (Cambridge, 1979)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, passim.

12 Petition of Conn O’Neill, 9 Feb. 1552 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/4/9); ‘Questions to be considered against Shane O’Neill’, 1560 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1515–74, pp 304–5).

13 A.F.M., sub annis 1558 & 1559.

14 Sussex to William Cecil, 19 Aug. 1561 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/4/37).

15 This is the implication of Brady, Ciarán, ‘The killing of Shane O’Neill: some new evidence’ in Irish Sword, xv (1982), pp 115–23 Google Scholar; for confirmation that Shane was the victim of a conspiracy, see ‘Sir Henry Sidney’s memoir of his government of Ireland, 1583’ in U.J.A., 1st ser., iii (1855), p. 91.

16 Queen to Sidney, 6 July 1567 ( Laidhin, Tomás Ó (ed.), Sidney state papers (Dublin, 1962), pp 70–72 Google Scholar).

17 ’Sidney’s memoir’, p. 95.

18 Morgan, Hiram, ‘The colonial venture of Sir Thomas Smith in Ulster’ in Historical Journal, xxviii (1985), pp 261–78 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Sidney to English privy council, 25 Nov. 1575, 27 Feb. 1576, 17 Mar. 1577 ( Collins, Arthur (ed.), Letters and memorials of state (2 vols, London, 1746), i, 75–80, 89–97, 164–5)Google Scholar.

20 P.R.I. rep. D.K. 13, app., fiant no. 3021.

21 ‘Sir John Perrot’s opinion’, Dec. 1591 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/156/51).

22 Henry Bagenal to Burghley, 20 Feb. 1592 (P.R.O. S.P.63/163/29).

23 P.R.I. rep. D.K. 15, app., fiants nos 4560–61, 4809.

24 ‘Sir John O’Reilly knight his note’, Apr. 1585 (Lambeth, Carew MS 614, f. 162); ?Waterhouse ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, ff 25–6). For a full treatment of this case, see Brady, Ciarán, ‘The O’Reillys of East Breifne and the problem of “surrender and regranť” in Breifne, vi (1985), pp 233–62 Google Scholar.

25 Wilbraham to Burghley, 16 Oct. 1590 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/155/19).

26 P.R.I. rep. D.K. 16, app., fiants nos 5621–80.

27 Loftus, Gardiner and St Leger to English privy council, 16 Mar. 1594 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/173/58).

28 Fitzwilliam to Burghley, 31 July 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/58); ?Waterhouse ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, f. 21); Robert Dillon, ‘The northern circuit for sessions’, Mar. 1589 (B.L., Add. MS 5754, f. 104); Hugh O’Neill to English privy council, 4 Aug. 1592 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1588–92, pp 566–7); William Weston to Burghley, 28 Aug. 1593 (ibid., 1592-6, pp 141–2): P.R.I, rep. D.K. 16, app., fiant no. 5552.

29 Morgan, ‘Outbreak of the Nine Years War’, chs 3–4.

30 Quinn, D.B., ‘“Irish” Ireland and “English” Ireland’ in Cosgrove, Art (ed.), New hist., Ire., ii (Oxford, 1986), p. 622 Google Scholar; Henry Bagenal to Burghley, 3 June 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/1); ‘Declaration of Ever O’Neill’, 1 June 1593 (ibid., enclosure i); ‘Declaration of Tadhg O’Nolan’, 17 May 1593 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1592–6, pp 99–100); ‘Petition of Ever MacRory O’Neill and Colla MacFerdorcha of Killetra’, 21 June 1593 (ibid., pp 107–9).

31 ‘Declaration of Shane’s ordinary forces’, early 1560s (Bodl., Carte MS 55, f. 591); ?Waterhouse ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, ff 50–52); O’Donnell to lord deputy, 1579 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/66/50, enclosure ii); Canny, ‘Hugh O’Neill’, pp 13–15.

32 Morgan, ‘Outbreak of the Nine Years War’, pp 176–7.

33 ‘John Smyth’s advice for Ireland’, placed in the calendar under Apr. 1569 but internal evidence points to 1573 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/28/10).

34 Dawtrey, ‘Knockfergus’, 29 June 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/21).

35 Obligations by Lachlan MacLean of Duart, 27 Aug. 1579, 25 Mar. 1580 (H.M.C. rep. 6, p. 630).

36 Hill, George, An historical account of the MacDonnells of Antrim (Belfast, 1873), pp 35–51 Google Scholar.

37 ?Waterhouse, ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, ff 45–7).

38 Annaála Connachta, sub annis 1534 & 1537.

39 Conn O’Neill to queen, June 1558 (P.R.O., S.P. 62/2/56); Queen to Sussex, July 1558 (ibid., 58).

40 Sir Thomas Cusack’s ‘book’, 8 May 1553 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/4/43); ?Waterhouse ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, ff 45–7).

41 Hill, MacDonnells of Antrim, pp 37, 125–6.

42 For a wider discussion of these issues, see Dawson, Jane, ‘Two kingdoms or three?: Ireland in Anglo-Scottish relations in the middle of the sixteenth century’ in Mason, Roger (ed.), Scotland and England, 1286–1815 (Edinburgh, 1987), pp 113–38 Google Scholar.

43 Hill, MacDonnells of Antrim, pp 46–51, 129 fn., 156.

44 Ibid., pp 125–30.

45 Queen to Sidney, 6 July 1567, 6 June 1569 (Ó Laidhin (ed.), Sidney state papers, pp 70–72, 108).

46 Hill, MacDonnells of Antrim, pp 183–5.

47 Morgan, ‘Outbreak of the Nine Years War’, pp 34–5.

48 Hill, MacDonalds of Antrim, pp 132–40; ‘Sidney’s memoir’ in U.J.A., 1st ser., v (1857), p. 310; Sidney to queen, 15 Sept. 1577 (H.M.C., D’isle and Dudley MSS, ii, 66).

49 ‘Observations of Dioness Campbell Mr, deane of Limerick, on the West Isles of Scotland’ in Miscellany of the Maitland Club (Edinburgh, 1847), iv, no. 1, p. 53.

50 Loftus and Wallop to Walsingham, 9 May 1583 (B.L., Cott. MS Titus FV, f. 26).

51 Simms, From kings to warlords, p. 139.

52 A.F.M., sub annis 1522, 1524 & 1528.

53 Ibid., sub anno 1555; Cusack and Aylmer to English privy council, 22 Dec. 1552 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/4/69).

54 ‘Treaty between Argyll and O’Donnell’ in MacPhail, J.R.N. (ed.), Highland papers (4 vols, Edinburgh, 1914-34), iv, 212-16Google Scholar.

55 Hill, MacDonnells of Antrim, pp 122 fn., 131 fn.

56 Hayes-McCoy, Scots mercenary forces, pp 149–52; Irish council to queen, 31 Oct. 1564 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/11/97).

57 ’Answers by Thomas Phetyplace’, 19 May 1567 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/20/92).

58 Hayes-McCoy, Scots mercenary forces, p. 106.

59 ‘John Smyth’s advice for Ireland’, ?1573 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/28/10); Malby to Burghley, 9 May 1580 (ibid., 73/8).

60 Waterhouse to Walsingham, 23 July 1581 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/84/44).

61 Nicholas Bagenal to Walsingham, 25 Apr. 1581 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/82/52).

62 Cusack to Warwick, 27 Sept. 1551 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/3/52).

63 Stat. Ire., i, 274.

64 Essex, ‘My opinion for the government and reformation of Ulster’, Oct. 1574 (B.L., Add. MS 48015, f. 314); Monies issued by Fitton on privy seals, 1572–8 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/62/29, f. 102).

65 Brady, ‘The O’Reillys’, pp 244–6.

66 Perrot, ‘A discourse’, July 1581 (Northampton R.O., Fitzwilliam papers, Ireland, no. 66); English privy council memorandum, Mar. 1584 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/108/79); ‘Perrot’s plot for the government of Ulster’, 20 Oct. 1584 (ibid., 112/23).

67 Dawtrey’s account of his services, July 1597 (B.L., Cott. MS Titus BXII, ff 284–5); see also Morgan, Outbreak of the Nine Years War’, pp 23–31.

68 ‘A true discourse of the late rebellion of the Burkes’, 16 Nov. 1586 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1586–8, pp 198–204); Bingham to Burghley, 30 Sept. 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/183/65).

69 Thornton to Bagenal, 16 Aug. 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/182/43, enclosure i).

70 Hayes-McCoy, Scots mercenary forces, chs 6–10.

71 ‘Observations of Mr Dioness Campbell’, p. 56; ‘Report by Sir Ralph Lane’, 9 Mar. 1599 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1599–1600, p. 73).

72 Báille, M. Ó ‘The Buannadha: Irish professional soldiery of the sixteenth century’ in Galway Arch. & Hist. Soc. Jn., xxii (1946), pp 49–94 Google Scholar.

73 O’Donovan, John (ed.), ‘Military proclamation in the Irish language issued by Hugh O’Neill in 1601’ in U.J.A., 1st ser., vi (1858), pp 57–65 Google Scholar.

74 Richard Weston, ‘A note of the earl his forces’, 22 June 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/180/48, enclosure i); Shane MacDonald Gorm, ‘List of the captains that attend Tyrone’, Aug. 1601 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1601–3, pp 13–14).

75 A.F.M., sub anno 1555.

76 ‘Answers by Thomas Phetyplace’, 19 May 1567 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/20/92); Cullen to Nicholas Bagenal, 14 Nov. 1579 ( Hogan, James and O’Farrell, Mc.N. Nicholas (eds), The Walsingham letter-book (Dublin, 1959), p. 224 Google Scholar).

77 ‘Powers of certain Irishmen’, 1562 (Bodl., Carte MS 55, f. 530); Richard Weston, ‘A note of the earl his forces’, 22 June 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/180/48, enclosure i).

78 Dawtrey, ‘Clandeboye’, ?1594 (B.L., Lansd. MS 111/46).

79 Maguire to Sussex, 20 Oct. 1562 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/7/34, enclosure i).

80 Hayes-McCoy, G.A., Irish battles (London, 1969), chs 7–8Google Scholar.

81 Drury to English privy council, 6 Jan. 1579 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/65/4); Cawell ‘Advertisements’, 24 June 1596 (ibid., 190/42, enclosure i).

82 Fenton to Burghley, 26 Aug. 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/182/63).

83 Irish council to English privy council, 4 June 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/180/5).

84 White, ‘Discourse touching Ireland’, с 1569 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/31/32, ff 81, 93); for edited version, see Canny, Nicholas, ‘Select documents: XXXIV’ in I.H.S., xx, no. 80 (Sept. 1977), pp 439–63 Google Scholar.

85 Nicholls, Land, law and society, pp 9–13; Canny, ‘Hugh O’Neill’, pp 25–32.

86 Colles, , History of Ulster, i, 182 Google Scholar.

87 Cusack to Warwick, 27 Sept. 1551 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/3/52); O’Donnelly to William Cecil, 25 May 1564 (ibid., 10/69); Fleming to William Cecil, 28 Feb. 1565 (ibid., 12/48).

88 Cullen to Nicholas Bagenal, 14 Nov. 1579 (Walsingham letter-bk, p. 225).

89 ?Waterhouse ‘A treatise of Ireland’, 1585 (N.L.I., MS 669, ff 52–3).

90 Carew, ‘A discourse for Ireland’, Apr. 1594 (Cambridge Univ. Lib., MS Kk 1 15, ff 52–6).

91 Greene, David (ed.), Duanaire Mhéig Uidhir: the poem book of Cú Chonnacht Mag Uidhir, lord of Fermanagh, 1566–89 (Dublin, 1972)Google Scholar; A.F.M., sub anno 1589.

92 Fitzwilliam to Burghley, 25 Oct. 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/172/11).

93 Cusack to Warwick, 27 Sept. 1551 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/3/52).

94 ‘Articles of petition’, 2 Feb. 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/178/36, enclosure iv).

95 Brian O’Neill to Irish council, 19 Mar. 1571 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/32/2, enclosure iv).

96 Dawtrey, ‘Knockfergus’, 29 June 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/21); William Weston to Burghley, 28 Aug. 1593 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1592–6, pp 141–2).

97 Maguire to Sussex, 20 Oct. 1562 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/7/34, enclosure i).

98 Magennis to Grey, 29 Aug. 1580 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/75/75).

99 See Canny, Nicholas, The Elizabethan conquest of Ireland: a pattern established, 1565–76 (Hassocks, 1976), ch. 1Google Scholar. The comments made by R. J. Hunter of the University of Ulster on this section are much appreciated.

100 ‘Old customs of O’Donnell’, 1620s (R.I.A., Miscellaneous O’Donovan MSS, 14/B/7); ‘An intelligence brought out of Tirconnell’, 21 July 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/181/47).

101 Dawtrey, ‘Knockfergus’, 29 June 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/21).

102 Sidney et al to queen, 12 Nov. 1566 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/19/43); ‘Sir John O’Reilly his note’, Apr. 1585 (Lambeth, Carew MS 614 f. 162); Smith, T.S., The civic history of the town of Cavan (Cavan, 1934), pp 5–7 Google Scholar: Rental of Bagenal estate, 1575 (Bodl., Univ. Coll. MS 103); Sidney’s notes on Bagenal’s plans for Newry, 21 May 1577 ( Collins, (ed.), Letters and memorials, i, 189–91)Google Scholar.

103 ’Discourse of Knockfergus’, ?1578 (B.L., Cott. MS Titus BX III, ff 58–61); M’Skimin, Samuel, The history and antiquities of Carrickfergus, ed. McCrum, E.J. (Belfast, 1909), pp 29–30 Google Scholar.

104 Canny, Elizabethan conquest, p. 6.

105 Hugh O’Neill’s suits, placed in the calendar under May 1590 though internal evidence points to May 1587 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/152/61); English privy council to Perrot, 7 May 1587 (Acts privy council, 1587–8, pp 74–5): Nott, Memorandum for Robert Cecil, July 1597 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1596–7, p. 362).

106 Perceval-Maxwell, Michael, The Scottish migration to Ulster in the reign of James I (London, 1973), pp 290-91Google Scholar.

107 ‘Description of Ireland’, 1598 (B.L., Add. MS 31878, f. 12).

108 Auchinross to Nicolson, 1 Aug. 1595 (Calendar of Scottish papers, 1593–5, p. 65).

109 Draft indenture between queen and Hugh O’Neill, 13 May 1587 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/129/79).

110 Keys to Fitzwilliam, 8 July 1593 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1592–6, p. 126); ‘Declaration of Edward Cornwall’, 19 Feb. 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/178/70, enclosure i).

111 English privy council to Fitzwilliam, 8 July 1590 (Acts privy council, 1590, pp 306–7); Egerton to Fenton, 15 July 1594 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/175/35, enclosure iii).

112 Inquisitionum in officio rotulorum cancellariae Hiberniae asservatarum repertorum (2 vols, Dublin, 1826–9), ii, p. xxiii; ‘The petitions and offers of Philip O’Reilly’, Mar. 1596 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/188/4, enclosure i).

113 ’Articles of the submission of the lord O’Neill when he was created earl of Tyrone’, 1 Oct. 1542 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1515–74, pp 198–9); ‘Articles agreed unto by the earl of Tyrone’, 6 June 1590 (Cambridge Univ. Lib., MS Kk 1 15, ff 15–16).

114 White ‘Discourse of Ireland’, c. 1569 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/31/32, ff 95–6).

115 Jackson, K.H., A Celtic miscellany (Harmondsworth, 1971), pp 218–19 Google Scholar.

116 Derricke, John, The image of Ireland, ed. Quinn, D.B. (Belfast, 1985)Google Scholar, plate xii.

117 Perrott, James, The chronicle of Ireland, 1584–1608, ed. Wood, Herbert (Dublin, 1933), p. 41 Google Scholar.

118 St Leger to king, 29 Aug. 1541 (S.P. Hen. VIII, iii, 318–21).

119 ’Declaration of Charles Egerton’, 25 Sept. 1579 (Walsingham letter-bk, p. 189); Henry Bagenal, ‘Description and present state of Ulster’, 20 Dec. 1586 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/127/35).

120 Cléirigh, Lughaidh Ó, The life of Aodh Ruadh Ó Domhnaill, ed. Walsh, Paul (2 pts, Dublin, 1948-57)Google Scholar; ‘Examination of Dermond McMoris’, 29 Apr. 1601 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1600–1, p. 298).

121 Perrott, Chron. Ire., pp 67, 73.

122 Cawell, ‘Advertisements’, 24 June 1596 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/190/42, enclosure i).

123 Maguire to Sussex, 25 Nov. 1562 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/7/48).

124 Alexander, A.L.O’D. (ed.), ‘O’Kane papers’ in Anal. Hib., no. 12 (1943), pp 101-4Google Scholar.

125 Adams, G.B., ‘Aspects of monoglottism in Ulster’ in Ulster Folklife, xxii (1976), pp 84–5 Google Scholar.

126 See Marron, Lawrence (ed.), ‘Documents from the state papers concerning Miler Magrath’ in Anal. Hib., no. 21 (1958), pp 75–189 Google Scholar.

127 Park, Thomas (ed.), Nugae antiquae (2 vols, London, 1804), i, 247-50Google Scholar.

128 John Smyth to Burghley, 18 July 1573 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/41/86); Loftus and Wallop to English privy council, 23 Aug. 1583 (ibid., 104/28); ‘Petitions and offers of Philip O’Reilly’, Mar. 1596 (ibid., 188/4, enclosure i).

129 King to Irish council, 5 Mar. 1543 (S.P. Hen. VIII, iii, 442); Petition of Conn O’Neill, 9 Feb. 1552 (P.R.O., S.P. 61/4/9).

130 Hogan, James, ‘Shane O’Neill comes to the court of Elizabeth’ in Pender, Seamus (ed.), Essays and studies presented to Professor Tadhg Ua Donnchadha (Cork, 1947), p. 167 Google Scholar; English privy council to Fitzwilliam, 12 July 1589 (Acts privy council, 1588–9, p. 382).

131 Fenton to Burghley, 26 June 1595 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/180/48); ‘Advertisements delivered by Capt. James Fitzgarret’, 12 Aug. 1596 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1596–7, pp 74–6): Slane to Russell, 12 Dec. 1594 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/60, enclosure i).

132 Loftus and Wallop to English privy council, 23 Aug. 1583 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/104/28).

133 Robert Fleming to Cecil, 29 Nov. 1563 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/9/67); Hogan, ‘Shane O’Neill’, p. 167.

134 Hovenden to Hugh O’Neill, 20 Mar. 1596 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1589–1600, pp 171–2).

135 Cal. pat. rolls Ire., Eliz., p. 373; ‘Names of servitors and natives...Dungannon’, 1611 (Cal. Carew MSS, 1603–24, p. 237).

136 Alexander (ed.), ‘O’Kane papers’, pp 101–4.

137 Lambert to Perrot, 23 Oct. 1584 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/112/33).

138 Jope, E.M., ‘Scottish influence in the north of Ireland: castles with Scottish features, 1580–1640’ in U.J.A., 3rd ser., xiv (1952), pp 31–47 Google Scholar.

139 Hayes-McCoy, Scots mercenary forces, p. 151; ‘John Smyth’s advice for Ireland’, ?1573 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/28/10).

140 Jope, ‘Scottish influence’.

141 Ford, Alan, The protestant reformation in Ireland (Frankfurt-am-Main, 1985), ch. 8Google Scholar.

142 Gwynn, Aubrey, The medieval province of Armagh (Dundalk, 1946), pt IVGoogle Scholar; Bradshaw, Brendan, The dissolution of the religious orders in Ireland under Henry VIII (Cambridge, 1974), pp 8–14 Google Scholar, 210–16.

143 Ellis, Tudor Ire., pp 228–38.

144 Conaghan, Charles, ‘Intrepid Donegal ecclesiastic of the sixteenth century: the Most Reverend Donald McGonagle, D.D., bishop of Raphoe, 1562–1589’ in Capuchin Annual (1976), p. 180 Google Scholar; Jones, F.M., ‘The Counter-Reformation’ in Corish, P.J. (ed.), A history of Irish Catholicism, iii (Dublin, 1967)Google Scholar, fasc. 3, pp 8–13; Wolfe, ’s ‘Account of the affairs of Ireland’, ?1573 (Cal. S.P. Rome, 1558–71, p. 482)Google Scholar.

145 Magrath, ’s ‘Proposal for the establishment of the holy inquisition in Ireland’, ?1567 (Cal. S.P. Rome, 1558–71, pp 266-7)Google Scholar.

146 Jackson, R.W., Archbishop Magrath, the scroundrel of Cashel (Dublin, 1974), pp 1–21 Google Scholar.

147 Magrath, ‘Information’, 17 Dec. 1590 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/156/12); Magrath, ‘Monasteries’, Aug. 1594 (ibid., 175/81), Magrath ‘Articles’, Aug. 1594 (ibid., 82).

148 Hayes-McCoy, Irish battles, p. 86; Wolfe, ’s ‘Account of the affairs of Ireland’, ?1573 (Cal. S.P. Rome, 1558–71, p. 482)Google Scholar; Magrath, ‘Information’, 17 Dec. 1590 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/156/12).

149 ?Magrath, ‘A catalogue of the bishops of Raphoe’, 1600 (B.L., Add MS 4797, ff 39–40).

150 Jones, ‘Counter-Reformation’, p. 39; Magrath ‘Information’, 17 Dec. 1590 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/156/12).

151 Letter of ordination, 1590 (B.L., Add. MS 4783, f. 39).

152 Conaghan, ‘McGonagle’, p. 181; ‘Relation of Ensign Alonso Cobos’, 16 May 1596 (Archivo General de Simancas, Estado 839, ff 104–5).

153 Magrath, ‘Monasteries’, Aug. 1594 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/175/81).

154 Mooney, Donagh, ’De provincia Hiberniae S. Francisci’, ed. Jennings, Brendan, in Anal. Hib., no. 6 (1934), pp 36, 48, 150, 161Google Scholar; Inquisitionum, ii, xxxiv.

155 Cullen to Nicholas Bagenal, 14 Nov. 1579 (Walsingham letter-bk, pp 224–6); ‘Examination of Turlough O’Kenny’, 3 Jan. 1592 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1588–92, p. 452); ‘Examination of Piers O’Cullan’, 29 Sept. 1595 (ibid., 7592–6, p. 409).

156 Loftus and Wallop, 26 Mar. 1584 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/108/56).

157 Magrath, ‘Information’, 17 Dec. 1590 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/156/12).

158 Conaghan, ‘McGonagle’, p. 181.

159 Byrne, M.J., The Irish war of defence, 1598–1600: extracts from De Hibernia insula commentarius of Peter Lombard, archbishop of Armagh (Cork, 1934), pp 34–7 Google Scholar.

160 Jones, ‘Counter-Reformation’, p. 29.

161 Cullen to Nicholas Bagenal, 14 Nov. 1579 (Walsingham letter-bk, pp 224–6).

162 Byrne, Irish war of defence, passim; Magrath ‘Certain brief notes concerning the present state of Ulster’, 10 June 1593 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/170/11); ‘Petition of John Thorn-burgh’, Nov. 1595 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1592–6, pp 435–6); ‘The supplication of the blood of the English’, c. 1599 (B.L., Add. MS 34313, ff 116–19).

163 White ‘Discourse on Ireland’, c. 1569 (P.R.O., S.P. 63/31/32, ff 96–8): Magrath, ‘Book’, 30 May 1592 (Cal. S.P. Ire., 1588–92, p. 501).

164 Urwick, William, The early history of Trinity College, Dublin, 1591–1660 (London, 1891), ch. 1Google Scholar.

165 Cal. pat. rolls Ire., Eliz., pp 250–51.

166 Alexander (ed.), ‘O’Kane papers’, pp 79–123. In 1606 the attorney-general received news of four titular bishops of the archdiocese of Armagh who had remained in Ireland after the war. Niall O’Boyle (Raphoe) was being protected by Rory O’Donnell and Cornelius O’Devany (Down and Connor) by Cormac MacBaron O’Neill; Richard Brady (Kilmore) was described as aged and living in Westmeath while James Magauran (Ardagh) had no fixed abode in Longford (Davies to Salisbury, 12 Nov. 1606, Cal. S.P. Ire., 1606–8, pp 17–18).

167 Ford, Protestant reformation, ch. 7.

168 Bradshaw, Brendan has argued that the exclusivist nature of its Calvinist doctrine prevented the Church of Ireland from adopting a programme of proselytisation: ‘Sword, word and strategy in the Reformation in Ireland’ in Historical Journal, xxi (1978), pp 475–502 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. This argument has been elaborated by Alan Ford in Protestant reformation, ch. 8. By extension, it can be argued that this doctrinal position was a convenient ideological mask, a double-think, which justified the socio-economic goals of the British careerists in the Irish church.

169 Ford, Protestant reformation, pp 76–80.

170 Silke, J.J., ‘The Irish appeal of 1593 to Spain’ in Irish Ecclesiastical Record, 5th ser., xcii (1959), pp 279-90, 362–71Google Scholar; Walsh, Micheline K., ‘The military order of St Patrick, 1593’ in Seanchas Ard Mhacha, ix (1979), pp 274-85Google Scholar.

171 Morgan, Outbreak of the Nine Years War’, ch 7.

172 Jones, F.M., Mountjoy, 1563–1606: the last Elizabethan lord deputy (Dublin, 1958)Google Scholar, chs 14–17.

173 Kiernan, V.G., State and society in Europe, 1550–1650 (Oxford, 1980), ch. 11Google Scholar.

174 F.M. Jones, Mountjoy, ch. 20.

175 The post-war period is treated by Canny, Nicholas in his three articles: ‘Hugh O’Neill, earl of Tyrone, and the changing face of Gaelic Ulster’ in Studia Hibernica, x (1970), pp 7–35 Google Scholar; ‘The treaty of Mellifont and the reorganisation of Ulster, 1603’ in lrish Sword, ix (1970), pp 249–62, ‘The flight of the earls, 1607’ in I.H.S., xvii, no. 67 (Mar. 1971), pp 380–99, and at large in his M.A. thesis ‘The government reorganisation of Ulster, 1603–7’ (University College, Galway, 1967).

176 After all, in the mid-1590s James VI had permitted the forfeited catholic earls of Huntly and Errol to return from exile to their estates in Scotland ( Dickinson, W.C., Scotland from the earliest times to 1603 (London, 1961), pp 367–8 Google Scholar).

177 Walsh, Micheline K., ’Destruction by peace’: Hugh O’Neill after Kinsale (Armagh, 1986)Google Scholar, passim.